Brandon Gaylord

A campaign that claimed Obama was just another politician could have used a number of scenarios to reinforce this theme. For example, Obama sat under Jeremiah Wright for 20 years. A racist as Glenn Beck claimed? No, just political ambition keeping him in the pew. Obama gets a favorable deal on his house from Tony Rezko. Corruption? No, just another political insider getting an insider deal. Obama has a coffee hosted by Bill Ayers. Palling around with terrorists? No, just a typical politician who will rub elbows with anyone willing to write a check. Obama goes back on his word to accept public campaign funding. A liar? Not so harsh. He’s just a run-of-the-mill politician who will abandon his principles for political gain.

This campaign would have been devastating The narrative would have been credible with the public and even the media while reinforcing itself consistently throughout the campaign. Despite difficulties imposed on McCain by the economic collapse and his Iraq position, voters would have been much less likely to see Obama as the agent of change.

Republicans had a similar opportunity in 2012. Mitt Romney’s early assessment that President Obama was a nice guy who was in over his head could have been a winning campaign theme. The incompetence narrative would have been a powerful one for Republicans. The waste in the stimulus? Incompetence. Solyndra? Incompetence. Sending 2,000 guns across the border without tracking them or notifying the Mexican government? Incompetence. The failed negotiations over the debt ceiling? Incompetence. By the time Benghazi came along it would have been the cherry on top of the incompetence sundae. No need to reach for conspiracy theories.

Instead of building a strong narrative from the bottom up as Rove did for the Bush campaigns in 2000 and 2004, Republicans tried to hit a home run on every pitch. I doubt most voters in hindsight can even recall the McCain and Romney arguments against Obama.

While Rove built strong narratives for his candidate and against his opponent, he was also influential in using the GOP’s Voter Vault, which was one of the first micro- targeting tools. Additionally, Rove expanded the electoral map in 2000 and 2004. Besides the usual battleground states, Bush was competitive in Oregon, Washington (2000), Minnesota, New Mexico, and Wisconsin, while keeping respectable margins in deep blue states like Delaware, New Jersey, and Hawaii. Even Vermont was only a 10-point race in 2000. McCain and Romney played very narrow fields and were left with few paths to victory late in their campaigns.

Republicans may currently have demographic and issue struggles, but they have exacerbated these problems by straying from fundamental campaigning. Weak, conspiratorial attacks and poor campaign tactics will not win elections against well- funded well-organized opponents. Rove’s strength was fundamentals. The GOP must return to these fundamentals immediately if they wish to regain power.


Brandon Gaylord

Brandon J. Gaylord- Editor, HorseRacePolitics.com, graduated from George Washington University’s Graduate School of Political Management.