Bill Murchison

A lot of reassurance comes from the knowledge that on our fast-spinning planet some things never change. To name two of those things: the tang of Beefeaters and Schweppes, and the mechanical response of leading polls when gasoline prices get too high for general comfort.
It's the latter experience that prompts serious contemplation of the first. I ask: Who wouldn't need a stiff drink upon hearing Ted Kennedy make all kinds of threatening noises about "price gouging" at the gasoline pump?

We know at that point what's coming: a rising chorus of commentary on the topic of oil companies and their indifference to the public weal. It's the rerun of the 1973 to 1980 Washington sideshow that featured price controls imposed by Richard Nixon, congressional fulminations about "obscene profits" and finally, the imposition, under Jimmy Carter, of a "windfall profits tax" on oil.

This is how Washington behaves at moments of energy exigency, inasmuch as behaving so gratifies a certain kind of irritable voter, at the same time, it muffles discussion of government complicity in the problem.

Nobody would pretend that gasoline prices aren't again, as after Katrina and Rita, as high as a cat's back -- though not as high as they were, temporarily, three decades ago. You'd suppose our leaders would be trying to address the problem of undersupply at a time of rising demand and international tension.

Alas -- there on TV last weekend was Kennedy, advising that President Bush "should have called the head of the oil companies into the White House and started jawboning." By which I think he means demanding the companies lower their prices. In the Kennedy worldview, prices tend to be set not by market forces but by -- to employ the senator's word -- "greed." Evidently, the companies thought they could rob us blind without Ted Kennedy's noticing. Hah!

The senator then goes on about a windfall profits tax, cheerfully oblivious to some facts you might have hoped were lodged firmly in his personal recollection. The Congressional Research Service estimated in 1990 that Carter's windfall profits tax (really an excise tax) decreased domestic oil production by 3 percent to 6 percent, while pumping up dependence on foreign oil by 8 percent to 16 percent. Thank you, Congress.

Bill Murchison

Bill Murchison is the former senior columns writer for The Dallas Morning News and author of There's More to Life Than Politics.
TOWNHALL DAILY: Be the first to read Bill Murchison's column. Sign up today and receive daily lineup delivered each morning to your inbox.
©Creators Syndicate ©Creators Syndicate