Bill Murchison

The New York Times, for reasons it clearly thought sufficient, buried the story on page six of the business section. I call for a timely exhumation. This is a good story. It matters to our honorable profession, the newspaper business.
Rocked by internal scandal two years back -- an arrogant Times management had promoted and protected an incompetent, mendacious black reporter named Jayson Blair -- our newspaper of record took a sudden interest in its own credibility. The topic had for some time deserved consideration. A longstanding Times tendency was that of looking down long Manhattan-ish noses at the non-Manhattan-ish doings of middle America, especially those involving conservatives. Either the Times was disdainful of what it saw or it just wasn't interested. There was some good middle ground -- just not nearly enough.

 A leader of American journalism, the Times needed to do better. Then came the Jayson Blair affair. Top editors lost their jobs. The Times, for maybe the first time ever, acted penitent. It hired an ombudsman to receive reader complaints and appraise news coverage. It started a study of its internal practices. The section C, page six story mentioned above tells how it all came out.

 Before I relate what the story relates, let me speak a word of professional admiration for the New York Times, a newspaper in which I immerse myself daily.

 Any great institution infuriates as well as delights. Every Sunday, I ask myself: Do I really need to scan Frank Rich's latest attempt to demonstrate why half the troubles of the world can be blamed on George W. Bush? Wasn't Rich a good enough drama critic? Did he have to go and become an all-purpose oracle? Still, for style and intelligence, no U.S. newspaper, saving only the estimable Wall Street Journal, matches the Times.

 What does the Times now say it must do? The 16-page report has 10 more or less commandments to editors and writers. Among these: better communication with readers, through a Times blog, easier e-mail access to reporters and editors and regular columns by the paper's top three editors; better coverage of "middle America, rural areas and religion"; a system for dealing with controversies over Times reporting; software to detect plagiarism; and less use of anonymous sources.

 Every bit of this, every particular, strikes me -- journalism prof as I have become -- as sound, sensible and in tune with present needs.

Bill Murchison

Bill Murchison is the former senior columns writer for The Dallas Morning News and author of There's More to Life Than Politics.
TOWNHALL DAILY: Be the first to read Bill Murchison's column. Sign up today and receive daily lineup delivered each morning to your inbox.
©Creators Syndicate ©Creators Syndicate