Townhall.com, Where Your Opinion Counts
Talk Radio:   Bill Bennett   Mike Gallagher   Dennis Prager   Michael Medved   Hugh Hewitt   
BREAKING NEWS  LeftArrow - Townhall.com : Conservative, Political, Republican   RightArrow - Townhall.com : Conservative, Political, Republican  
Columns, funnies & more in your inbox!
  • Check the boxes and send us your email address to receveive your free newsletter
  • Your daily must-read of conservative columns, cartoons and news. Coulter, Sowell, Krauthammer and more.
  • Townhall.com’s weekly inside scoop on what’s happening behind the scenes in the world of politics. When news breaks, we report.
  • Signup to receive the latest daily Townhall cartoons
Tuesday, May 13, 2008
W. Thomas Smith, Jr :: Townhall.com Columnist
Bloodying Iran's Foreign Legion
by W. Thomas Smith, Jr
Vote on It:
Average Vote:
[+] Text [-]
 
Poll
Will the Dems' health care Christmas Present to America be an improvement or detriment to our health care system?


Hezbollah – Iran’s Lebanon-based terrorist legion – may have bitten off more than it can chew in its recent attacks against pro-government forces in Lebanon. They’ve certainly underestimated the tenacity of the latter as evidenced by the underreported head-to-head thrashing Hezbollah is getting in-and-around the Chouf Mountain region, southeast of Beirut. Nevertheless, Hezbollah should never have been able to get away with what it has over the past week; or for that matter, the past 25 years.

Problem is, the legitimate government of Lebanon has given Hezbollah’s dogs too much rope since the end of the Lebanese Civil War in 1990, and the legitimate Lebanese army has done virtually nothing to disarm Hezbollah despite the will of the majority of the Lebanese people. Nor has the army (which has received $millions in support from the U.S.) made any substantive attempt to crush the recent terror offensive which began last week after Hezbollah surveillance cameras were discovered at Beirut International Airport, and the government of Prime Minister Fouad Siniora called for the dismantling of Hezbollah’s extensive telecommunications network.

Hezbollah should have long been disarmed under United Nations Security Council Resolutions 1559 and 1701, which call for the disarming of all militias in Lebanon. But the Shiia terrorist group – which receives training and financing by Iran’s Islamic Revolutionary Guard Corps (approximately $ one-billion, annually, in giant bags stuffed with American cash smuggled over the unchecked Syrian-Lebanese border) and operational support from Syria – says it is not a militia, but a “resistance.” And both the commander-in-chief of the armed forces, Gen. Michel Sleiman, and his chief of intelligence, told me in one-on-one meetings last fall, “Hezbollah is a resistance against foreign aggression, and it was here before the army.”

So in the eyes of the senior commander of the legitimate army: Hezbollah has a right – and should continue to have that right – to exist as an Iranian-Syrian proxy army serving an illegitimate Shiia state – the kingdom of Hezbollah – within the sovereign territory of the legitimate state, Lebanon.

That is precisely what we have here, and because of that perceived right – which flies in the face of UN convention – Hezbollah is literally getting away with murder under the guise of “resistance” against foreign aggression.

Of course, the foreign aggression Hezbollah speaks of is the potential threat of Lebanon’s southern neighbor, Israel. But let’s not forget, Hezbollah provoked the summer 2006 war with Israel, and in the wake of the assassination of Hezbollah’s mad-bomber Imad Mughniyeh in February 2008, Hezbollah’s secretary general Hassan Nasrallah tauntingly declared “open war” with the Jewish state. Sounds a bit more like defiance than resistance.

Be that as it may, Hezbollah has now gone beyond its self-proclaimed raison d’être, as it has overtly turned its weapons on the Lebanese people. One source in Lebanon telling me that in addition to shooting people, burning property, and systematically destroying newspaper offices and television stations, Hezbollah is arresting people at will, kidnapping others, and forcing their way into the homes of Lebanese civilians without provocation.

The shame of it all is that the army and police have all but refused to confront the group’s aggression, much less challenge its illegitimate authority.

Still, and as I mentioned earlier, Hezbollah may have bitten off more than it can chew:

“Hezbollah is powerful, but so are the Druze and other Lebanese sects,” says Lebanese political analyst Elie Fawaz. “This is what the ferocious fights of the Chouf have proven.”

Fawaz tells me that Hezbollah’s battlefield tactics have proven woefully inadequate against the pro-government forces in the mountains above Beirut. And, he says, those tactics have – in many quarters – backed Hezbollah into strategically difficult positions, compelling the terrorist group to hold covert, indirect talks with members of the pro-democracy March 14 coalition “to get Hezbollah out of the mess it has gotten itself into.”

So far Hezbollah has avoided the largely Christian areas of Lebanon. The group has instead concentrated its offensive operations in west Beirut (which it has now largely withdrawn from), the mountains east of the capital, the Bekaa Valley further east, and in the north in-and-around the city of Tripoli. If Hezbollah has any strategic sense remaining – which I don’t believe it has ever truly possessed – it will keep out of the Christian areas, because it is the Christian areas where the terrorist group will truly take a beating.

As I have said on multiple occasions, Lebanon is a crucial front on the war on terror. The front is now critical. The Lebanese armed forces and the national police have a real opportunity here, as does the Lebanese government and its declared Western allies like the U.S. and France. And unlike the situation on the ground in Iraq and Afghanistan – where the war on terror seems to groan on-and-on – the next several days and weeks may well bring about a dramatic turn of events in Lebanon. And those who are the most committed to their causes are the ones who will gain the upper hand.

Share:
Vote on It:
Average Vote:
 
About The Author
W. Thomas Smith Jr. is a former U.S. Marine rifle-squad leader and counterterrorism instructor. He is the author of six books, and he has covered war and conflict in the Balkans, on the West Bank, in Iraq, and Lebanon. Visit him online at http://www.uswriter.com.
 
TOWNHALL DAILY: Be the first to read W. Thomas Smith's column. Sign up today and receive Townhall.com daily lineup delivered each morning to your inbox.
Lebanon
I am very upset by the events in Lebanon and the unwillingness of free people to confront the growing threat of terrorism and oppression.
Hezbollah is a danger to the world.

MarCi
i rather thought this Smith was implying that Hezzbollah has made a mistake; I think not. I think they are well aware of their actions and pretty sure of the outcome in their favor.

KILLER
Those responding in criticism to you don't realized you bolstered your arguement by using the term "Industrial Military Complex". That explains it all, right?

Charlie in TX says
"Hezzbollah, directed by Iran and aided logistically and politically by Syria, could very well end up ruling Lebanon regardless of the beliefs of this author."

Uh, I believe that's the danger the author has suggested.

STAY IN UN
gretske:

I think we should stay in the UN. For one thing, it is a great place to find out what other countries are trying to do.

But I do think we should use our veto. Russia and China use it every time they think something will curtail their power. We never use it for fear that we are using our power to force other countries to do as we think they should. I think the veto should be used for everything that will harm the US.

Between using the veto to stop their attacks on us and using the UN as a spy center, we should keep it.

as far as the U.N.
just another, in this case international, "work-welfare" program supported by US Liberals with taxpayer dollars. It seems that waste is all our leaders, both DEMS and REPS, since WW2 know!

Lebanon
Hezzbollah, directed by Iran and aided logistically and politically by Syria, could very well end up ruling Lebanon regardless of the beliefs of this author.
One very curious, and you can bet cleverly planned and implemented, thing is that Hezzebollah has recruited "alternates" in each opposing sect creating divisions within each (the Lebanese Christians, Druze, and Sunnis who support Hezzbollah and have strong ties to Syria); there is no united front opposing them.
A free Lebanon will only be saved, and assured, by the direct intervention of Western forces, coupled with Egyptian, Turkish, Saudi, Jordanian and/or other Muslim, mainly Arab Muslim, forces with the will to destroy Hezzbollah within Lebanon's sovereign borders, and I don't think this will happen.

For gretske (#2)
Was further proof of Useless Numpties being a total failure even necessary?

Great article
Mr. Smith!

Question? If Hezbollah does not want to fight in the Christian areas because they would truly take a beating, do you see the Christians, Druze and Government forces willing to unite and crush this cancer in their country?

I agree with gretske's first statement, and also with MarCi.
Ratas y Ratones: Couldn't we use some more such leaders? Ones who have ACTUAL experience?

Dear Rigidf
It's actually quite simple.
Unlike the war with Israel, Hezbollah was attacking peoples lands and homes. Hezbollah calls itself a resistance. But they are actually terrorists fighting the true resistance.

Defeating Hezbollah
How is it Hezbollah (according to our media) can defeat Isreal last year, grow stronger and then get it's head handed to it by the Local Army?

Rigidflexibility

Keep your check
***Please forgive me,if I don't thank you,for your service.Your check was more than enough***

So Mr Killer,
Is that the new leftwhack justification phrase so that you can express distaste for the military but still come off as pseudo-patriotic?If so, it's lame and as unpatriotic as one of the pres candidates who expressly refuses to wear an American flag on his lapel.

MarCi
Good point.

Killer
could you re-submit the above in Klingon? I am sure you have studied that language.

Or perhaps you could just go back to debating how Khan could have recognized Chekov when he came on board the Enterprise long after Khan and his gang were exiled to Ceti Alpha Five.

Great article
Barack Obama [ who has received the endorsement of Hezbollah's sibling Jihadist group, Hamas ] should read this.

I know a leader when I see one!
W. Thomas Smith Jr. is a former U.S. Marine rifle-squad leader and counterterrorism instructor. He is the author of six books, and he has covered war and conflict in the Balkans, on the West Bank, in Iraq, and Lebanon. Visit him online at http://www.uswriter.com.

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
I will follow you, any time, any where!

gretske
There is a scene in the "Godfather",where Marlon Brando is explaining to his young son,who is orchestrating the WAR against him.Be careful ,that you don't fight the wrong ENEMY.Cutting off the "TAIL" of the SNAKE,does not "Kill" the snake.If you only knew?

Killer is suffering
From the delusion shared by many Americans, including Senators and Representatives, who think if they ignore jihadists, they will go away. Like the proverbial ostrich, they stick their head into the sand, not realizing what is prominently displayed above ground for all to see.

Killer
Hi Killer.
Well done on changing the subject.
So what is the thing going on with Iran about which we have no clue ?
Why so cryptic ?
Spit it out, man !

Colonel
The president of the United States is sworn to protect "US" from "All Enemies";Foreign and Domestic.The Military Industrial Complex would have US think, that a physical war would serve our purpose.This is a bold-faced LIE.In point of fact,they are "US" domestic enemies.Please refer to warnings from President Eisenhower.We are in an economic war and most Americans don't even know it.This last statement,includes you, most emphatically!Please forgive me,if I don't thank you,for your service.Your check was more than enough...

Killer the expert?
Methinks killer is kuh-razee.
He certainly is poorly informed.
;-)

jimash
There is something going on with Iran, that Americans have no "Clue" about.When you and others find out,it will be too late.I only want to warn you.It is never the enemy you see, that "KILLS" you."The ART of WAR",is more than a BOOK!!!

Fortunately
There are patriots in Lebanon who love their country. They are Muslim, Christian, and Druze, and they are willing to fight for the goals and aspirations of a free people.
If a men and women are willing to fight for freedom as the people are against the Hezbolla then we should support in every way possible.
A free Lebanon is a Middle East that is that much freer.
Hezbolla is being defeated. They know it and Iran knows it. We need to know and cheer the free peoples forward.
Thank you for a great article.

Killer says
For those,who do not understand,a very simple fact;Hezbollah is not a "Militia" group,but is a "Legitimate" part of the Lebanon government.Also,please stop trying to put this "Fiasco" at the feet of Iran.

A: In my country political parties and religious institutions do not have paramilitary organizations that start wars with other countries.
B: Nasrallah admits that they serve Iran and use the Iranian national motto. "Death to America".
But that is just for show right ?

Killer says
"For those,who do not understand,a very simple fact;Hezbollah is not a "Militia" group,but is a "Legitimate" part of the Lebanon government.


And that is supposed to reassure us ?
Do the political parties in your state have militias and paramilitary organizations ?
Generally speaking this is not how things work and you know it.

RE: Great piece Smith
Best article on the subject we have yet seen out of Lebanon.
We will never get this from NYT.

Great piece Smith
Glad to read some uplifting news coming out of Lebanon. I was under the impression the things were much worse there.

Killer, is that sufficient rational for all conflicts - the price of gas? How about if we use carbon footprints to determine our foreign policy?

bob
Do you understand "Supply and Demand"?Emphasis on "Supply"...The oil amount,that we receive from Iran is irrelevant.The fact, that their "OIL" will be consigned to China is the point.No matter what China does, market forces will be changed.I could say more,but I won't!!!

killer
Gas will go up to 10 dollars a gallon? How much oil do you think we get from Iran?

Militia
For those,who do not understand,a very simple fact;Hezbollah is not a "Militia" group,but is a "Legitimate" part of the Lebanon government.Also,please stop trying to put this "Fiasco" at the feet of Iran.Go ahead and invade Iran "Stupid".Gas prices will go to $10.00 a gallon and China will get the Oil.Also,the America economy will "Collapse".DA...Dumb As a doorknob!!!

Hezbollah VS the Lebanon Army
Every since our "Cowardly Retreat" after the Barracks was destroyed the Syria thru Hezbollah has done as it wants--they are convinced that the US will just talk and talk and talk at the UN while they take over this small country.

Hezbollah
I believe it is clear that if we are to win the GWOT we must find a way get rid of Hezbollah and save the Lebanon front.


Lebanon
This writer exposed the truth about Hezbollah a long time ago - and he was right - at a time when many people did not believe him and some even chastised him for what turned out to be his courageous and spot-on reports. My question is: why did no other American reporter there get it right when Smith did? And now this mess which he predicted has come to pass. Everyone involved should be ashamed of themselves - we could have saved lives.

Lebanon
Re this statement: "Hezbollah should have long been disarmed under United Nations Security Council Resolutions 1559 and 1701, which call for the disarming of all militias in Lebanon."

Most of us know the UN will never put teeth into any resolution, and a small glance at history proves our statement.

Until Lebanon stands behind the rightful government and stands against terrorists, unrest will continue. People in the world are often prisoners of politics, and the foolish acceptance of a group like HezB keeps innocents in bondage to that group's whims and irrational actions.

As for the UN, it is a dark, propagandistic, anti-American hole for US dollars.

best, Kay B. Day

In my opinion.

Further Proof the UN is a Failed State
What more evidence do we need that the UN is a cancer on the international scene? All they do is steal money (oil for food), bungle nuclear non-proliferation (Iran), fail at human relief (Myanmar) and sexually harass employees.

The only thing the UN does is to stir up anti-US feelings around the world, thwart our efforts, and use our money to do it.

GET OUT OF THE UN, NOW!

Defeating Hezbollah
God bless you Mr. Smith
Sign Up to Post Your CommentsSign Up to Post Your Comments
If you are already registered, click here to login. Otherwise, please take a few seconds to register with Townhall.com. Once you sign up, you’ll be able to post your comments immediately, use the action center, get podcasts, and more!
Note: Fields marked with a red asterisk (*) are required.
Salutation:
First Name:
*
Last Name:
*
Email:
*
Nickname:
*
Note: Nick name will be shown when you post comments.
Address 1:
*
Address 2:
City:
*
State:
*
Zip:
*
Phone:
      
Your daily must-read of conservative columns, cartoons and news. Coulter, Sowell, Krauthammer and more.
(Bi-Weekly) We highlight the best opportunities from our partners for surveys, action items and more.