Townhall.com, Where Your Opinion Counts
Talk Radio:   Bill Bennett   Mike Gallagher   Dennis Prager   Michael Medved   Hugh Hewitt   
BREAKING NEWS  LeftArrow - Townhall.com : Conservative, Political, Republican   RightArrow - Townhall.com : Conservative, Political, Republican  
Columns, funnies & more in your inbox!
  • Check the boxes and send us your email address to receveive your free newsletter
  • Your daily must-read of conservative columns, cartoons and news. Coulter, Sowell, Krauthammer and more.
  • Townhall.com’s weekly inside scoop on what’s happening behind the scenes in the world of politics. When news breaks, we report.
  • Signup to receive the latest daily Townhall cartoons
Monday, February 26, 2007
W. Thomas Smith, Jr :: Townhall.com Columnist
The New York Giant who died on Iwo Jima
by W. Thomas Smith, Jr
Vote on It:
Average Vote:
[+] Text [-]
 
Poll
Will the Dems' health care Christmas Present to America be an improvement or detriment to our health care system?


We’ve seen it countless times: The stirring photograph snapped 62-years-ago of five U.S. Marines and one Navy Corpsman raising the second (larger than the first) American flag atop Mount Suribachi on the Japanese-held island of Iwo Jima.

It is a picture of a moment captured on the fourth day of the month-long Battle for Iwo. It symbolized the American struggle in World War II, and it literally defined the modern Marine Corps.

As the flag went up, thousands of Marines and sailors across the island cheered, as did sailors witnessing the event offshore. Ships' horns blew. Whistles shrieked. From the main deck of USS Eldorado, a beaming Secretary of the Navy James Forrestal turned to Marine General Holland M. ‘Howlin’ Mad’ Smith and exclaimed, “Holland, the raising of that flag on Suribachi means a Marine Corps for the next 500 years.”

What most Americans forget, however, is that the battle was far from over. Three of the six men who raised the flag on February 23, 1945 would soon be killed in action. And from February 19 through March 17, nearly 7,000 Americans would perish as they wrested control of the island from the enemy: Most of those Americans unsung or a least unknown in general American culture.

One of those Americans was 1st Lieutenant Andrew Jackson “Jack” Lummus Jr., a Texas-born Marine officer and recipient of the Medal of Honor (MOH) who was – and is – quite literally the epitome of all that is wrapped up in what it means to be a Marine.

I remember someone once telling me that because most Marines are athletically inclined and by nature, competitive (only a competitive person would choose to join the Corps in the first place), that the Marines’ athleticism and competitiveness combined with their tenacity in combat must have resulted in a lot of unrecorded track and field records being set on Iwo Jima.

Lummus surely must have set a few. In fact he was setting records before the Marines.

A 29-year-old former defensive lineman with the New York Giants and an All-American at Baylor University who – in addition to football – had once signed a minor league baseball contract, Lummus left the Giants to become a Marine infantry officer in January 1942, a month after Pearl Harbor. Three years later, he was busy spotting enemy targets on Suribachi, as his fellow Marines ambled up the hill with the now-famous flag. Within days, he would be reassigned to E Company, 2nd Battalion, 27th Marines of the 5th Marine Division where he was given command of 3rd Platoon.

That’s when his unrecorded records began to be set.

During two days and nights of violent fighting against – according to his MOH citation – “fanatic opposition,” Lummus led his Marines forward toward the northern edge of the island. On the morning of March 8, the former New York Giant found himself spearheading E Company’s assault against a series of interconnecting enemy foxholes, spidertraps, bunkers, and caves.

At one point, Lummus was sprinting forward with his men when a grenade blast knocked him to the ground. Stunned, but without serious injury, he quickly got back on his feet and continued the attack. He then charged an enemy bunker and killed everyone inside with his submachinegun. A second grenade exploded near him, shattering his shoulder, yet according to his MOH citation, he “staunchly continued his heroic one-man assault and charged the second pillbox, annihilating all the occupants.”

Three times that morning Lummus, alternating between a submachinegun and a carbine, charged and wiped out entrenched enemy positions. And there was no respite in the fighting between the attacks as he was constantly running from one position to the next, encouraging his men, directing supporting tank fire, and killing enemy soldiers.

Then in a final effort to crush all resistance in the battalion’s front, he ordered a platoon assault against an enemy emplacement. As the Marines charged, Lummus stepped on a landmine. The enormous blast that followed could be heard across the entire island.

Numbed and with ears ringing, Lummus’ Marines could still make out the familiar Texas drawl of their platoon commander shouting, “Forward! Keep moving!” They could hear him, but they couldn’t see him. Not until the blast’s smoke and dust cleared. Then they saw the blackened figure of a man bent over and trying to push himself up on one of his elbows.

The Marines initially thought their lieutenant was standing in a hole. Then there was the horror of what they were looking at: Lummus was upright on two bloody stumps: His legs had been blown off, and much of his lower trunk was missing.

Several of the younger Marines, weeping like children, ran to his side. Some of the older Marines briefly considered a mercy shooting. But Lummus kept urging them forward: “Dammit, keep moving!,” he uttered. “You can't stop now!”

According to the official report. “Their tears turned to rage. They swept an incredible 300 yards over impossible ground... There was no question that the dirty, tired men, cursing and crying and fighting, had done it for Jack Lummus.”

Hours later on a stretcher bound for the operating table, an ashen-faced Lummus managed a smile for the Navy surgeon and quipped, "Well, Doc, I guess the New York Giants have lost the services of a damned good end."

Lummus died that afternoon, and was buried at the base of Mount Suribachi not far from where he had landed in the first wave, two-and-a-half weeks earlier. He was posthumously awarded the Medal of Honor.

The image of the flag-raising on Iwo Jima, which we’ve once again seen republished and rebroadcast over the past week’s 62nd anniversary of the battle (which we’ll continue to see throughout the first half of March), reminds us of our greatness as a nation: As it should. But we must also remember that without the sacrifices of “giants” like Jack Lummus, there would be no flag. No nation.

There have been many such giants in our history. And we must honor those “giants,” always tell their stories, and hope that our children will aspire to be as courageous and unselfish as they. Just as our descendents must honor and tell the stories of the American giants who are now fighting in Iraq, Afghanistan, and other corners of the world in the war on terror.

Share:
Vote on It:
Average Vote:
 
About The Author
W. Thomas Smith Jr. is a former U.S. Marine rifle-squad leader and counterterrorism instructor. He is the author of six books, and he has covered war and conflict in the Balkans, on the West Bank, in Iraq, and Lebanon. Visit him online at http://www.uswriter.com.
 
TOWNHALL DAILY: Be the first to read W. Thomas Smith's column. Sign up today and receive Townhall.com daily lineup delivered each morning to your inbox.
What a brave man!
Where do people like him come from? To be able to urge your men to gon on even after being so badly hurt shows how strong marines are-to see a modern example read the gift of valor.

The sacrafice of our Marines deserve
much better then what Hollywood has been giving them. Today Hollywood has joined with the enemy against America. And quite frankly I fantasize about a senerio were an retired marine that has become sick and tired of their treason shows up back stage of the Acadamy Awards with a full tank of Napalm and comes out and procceds to empty out his tank upon that whole bunch of glitering narcissist.

Great Article....
Last evening, instead of watching the Academy Awards and listening to a bunch of self-absorbed, anti-American, whiny, Hollywood types engage in their annual exercise of excess and self-congratulation, I watched the History Channel. They had on a marathon of their show "Dogfights". Seeing Leo Thorness wearing his Congressional Medal of Honor and hearing Robbie Reisner describe his exploits over Mig Alley made my eyes well with tears. These two and the other like them know what duty, honor and respect mean. Where does our country get such men?

Linlithgow
I was the SecNav's Battle Site guide on an Iwo visit a few years back and in doing my research, I found a quotation from an officer who stated: "There were many acts of heroism by men who deserved a medal but there was no one to witness it."

Marines, doing what they'd been trained to do, w/o being told or led, often dying in the process. They'll be forever remembered.

MarineDad
Parris Island is the great leveler. Until you've stood at attention and been a buffet for sand fleas, you ain't seen NOTHING! haha.

Also, classes on Marine history and traditions are given regularly and studying your "green monster" reinforces the lesson.

Ask your son to invite you to a "dining-in" as a guest. You'll never forget it. The REAL fun is at a Mess Night. Marines only and the grog flows freely.

To the 3rd & 5th Marine Divisions
When my uncle joined the 1st Marine division in 1966, headed for Vietnam, I read a very lengthy account of the battle for Iwo Jima. I came to realize that volumes could be filled on just what was written on the citations, for one of the most medal awarded fights in US history.

In thinking about the heroic deeds, it makes one wonder what drives men to such selfless exploits. There was no promise of heaven attached to their deaths, nor earthly glory to be attained since you'll hardly ever hear from a veteran of his experiences.

I have since concluded that comradeship had as much to do with it as anything. These Marines fought for each other as well as and for the sons and brothers who they hoped to spare the same experience.

The 1st has been a tradition in my family going back to WWI and we who have not served are so thankful and proud of those who have.

Allow me to add that I am really disappointed in Eastman's Iwo exploitation films. I've admired much of his past work but in his mercenary pursuit of fame and fortune over recent years, he's fallen precipitately in my estimation.

Iwo Jima
Last summer, my father-in-law, Johnny, passed away. He had been a full professor, with a PhD in History and an ABD in English. He taught Shakespeare and the poetry of WWI and his dissertation had been on the art of warfare in the Dark Ages; by any stretch an amazing man.

He also had been a Marine who fought on Iwo Jima and won a Bronze Star with Valour while serving with Chesty Puller in Korea. We bought him a new set of dress blues and brand new ribbons for him to be buried in; we learned a lot about the decorations, and about the battles he saw, and we had a fresh appreciation of how lucky Johnny had been to come out of all of it alive.

Johnny told us that there were so many dead and wounded on Iwo that it was hard to not walk on someone. He occasionally talked about Iwo when we asked, but not much; it was obvious that the memories it evoked still had a profound impact on him. That a kind, sweet, selfless man still existed after seeing such carnage is a tribute to the quality of the men and women who serve. He had several close calls and was awarded two Purple Hearts and when we asked him what he won his Bronze Star w/V for, he said "for good reports" (it is always awarded for valour in battle). Such is the modest nature of those who have sacrificed to ensure our freedom and I am grateful for the time I was able to spend with my father-in-law.

So it was with some excitement that my husband and I welcomed the movie "Flags of Our Fathers", although we knew it would be bittersweet, having just lost Johnny.

After reading reviews about how "human and tragic" the Japanese seemed in "Letters from Iwo Jima", to the extent that "you wanted them to beat the Americans", and all sorts of other comments along that line, we decided to not see FoOF, as it almost seemed like an obligation Eastwood had while he made the movie that he REALLY wanted to do, which was "Letters...". I never heard such glorious and complimentary phrases uttered about FoOF as I did about Eastwood's depictions of the Japanese who fought on Iwo. It was a horrible battle for both sides, but it became obvious that one of the movies far overshadowed the other, and by extension, the story.

I don't know why I expected more from Hollywood; only they would be able to take one of the most heroic and bloody battles ever fought by Americans and manage to turn it into an affair where people were openly lamenting the fact that we won. War is brutal, and the loss of life is always tragic, but to take something that is so ingrained and important to Americans; that was such a rally point for our nation at a time of uncertainty; a battle filled with tales of heroism and sacrifice and to diminish it in any way is inexcusable. Tell the story of the Japanese too, they have a tale to tell, but not in a matter that reduces the sacrifices of people like 1st Lt. Lummus, Gy Sgt. Basilone or the thousands of others, whose names we will never know, who fought on that island, were wounded, or perished there.

And they won't be forgotten
It's why the Marines named each of the obstacles in the boot camp crucible after heros like Lummus and Basilone--to impress upon each recruit the absolute necessity of honor, courage and commitment to overcoming adversity. It worked on my son, as I'm sure it did on all of them. They leave Paris Island or San Diego profoundly changed.

Hell of a Marine
And a true Texan - 27 MOH awarded from that campaign - to paraphrase a quote "Uncommon valor was common"

Flag raising
I met the guy who took that picture at a photography show years ago in San Francisco. But the movie has not come to my town because most good movies don't come here. The college kids prefer the blockbusters, action or horror.

WAR HORSE
Don't be petty. Respect for honor, courage, and sacrifice is not limited to political orientation. Remember, we liberals worked for civil rights and many were hurt and some killed. We should all honor such exemplary men.

Great column.
Bravo Zulu! As a former Navy Corpsman, Doc Bradley, one of the flag-raisers, is my hero.

Not to disagree with SecNav Jimmy Forrestal, but it wasn't the flag-raising that guaranteed a Marine Corps for 500 years. It was fine young men like Jack Lummus.

HM2/USN 1966-70
Vietnam, Class of 1968.

Amazing Grace
I had to stop in the middle of the article to join in weeping for Jack Lummus. This story is one of the finest examples of manhood and bravery and self-sacrifice that I have ever read. I am deeply grateful and humbled by the service of men Like Jack, from Valley Forge to Baghdad, Iraq and know that I owe a debt that I can never replay. There is a special place in Heaven for our fallen heroes. May we never forget.

Movies were once pro-American
Like Fess Parker's "Davy Crockett" or James Stewart's "Glenn Miller Story". Gary Cooper's "Sgt York". "God Is My Co-Pilot" was about AVG flier Robert L. Scott.

Today we have no stories or film of American heroes because neither Hollywood nor the MSM has American heroes. Theirs are all foreign and anti-American.

God bless Jack Lummus
God bless the Marine Corps, and every Marine who has ever served honorably. The citizens of this country, who have not been Marines, will never know how trully fortunate thay are to have The United States Marine Corps standing guard to keep the wolf from their door!

Thousands of stories like Jack Lummus, John Basilone, and my first Company Gunny, Jimmie Howard, are the lore and legends of the Corps. In a legacy of honor, service, and sacrifice that has been passed on from those who came before to those who serve today, and to those yet to come. For the USMC "Uncommon Valor" is indeed "Common virtue" every single day!
OOORAAHH!!!
USMC '68 - '74
RVN '69 - '70

Duty, Honor and Country
I wonder where the remarks of Kimberly, Liberalgoodman and those others of like persuasion are? Oh, I forgot - the concepts of Duty, Honor and Country are unknown in their world!

A Real Hero
We seldom read about the real heroes in our midst and the sacrifices they make so that we can enjoy our freedoms-which we too often take for granted.
Back in the early 70's, I was being mustered out of the Army after service in Vietnam and was stationed at a safe mid-west Army base. A young civilian lady greeted us everyday at the main reception area where she worked and always had kind words for the men and women passing through, always wishing them well on whatever they chose to do, and gave words of encouragement to those of us who had various war wounds...
It was only later that I learned that she was a wife of a P.O.W. I never found out if her husband ever returned, but her silent witness and encouragement made her a hero in my eyes!

MV Jack Lummus
The Marines use huge ships to forward stage equiment at sea. One of these ships is the Motor Vessel Jack Lummus.

Also note
GySgt John "Manila John" Basilone, a personal hero of mine.

Wins the Medal of Honor on Guadalcanal for single-handledly repulsing a Japanese attack.

Goes BACK to the States on a War Bond drive and DID NOT have to go back to combat.

He learned that his unit was deploying to Iwo and volunteered to go back.

The legend was killed on the beach by a mortar shell as he motivated his men inland.

http://noliberalspin.townhall.com/g/a0cafe08-b0ff-494b-aea5-8047e0133b07

Great article
I'd never heard of this guy. What a real hero!

Recommended Book
Excellent article by Mr. Smith. For more on Iwo Jima, I recommend "Iwo Jima: Legacy of Valor" by Bill D. Ross.

Our heroes...
...we need to hear this story over and over. We need to see it printed everywhere.
It's disgraceful that the MSM fails to devote time and space on a regularly frequent basis to the heroes of then and now.

Wow

I had heard of Jack Lummus, having followed Baylor's football tradition, but I had no idea he was such a war hero. Thanks for sharing this. This country is indebted to the man.

Thanks
Very good article. Thanks.
Sign Up to Post Your CommentsSign Up to Post Your Comments
If you are already registered, click here to login. Otherwise, please take a few seconds to register with Townhall.com. Once you sign up, you’ll be able to post your comments immediately, use the action center, get podcasts, and more!
Note: Fields marked with a red asterisk (*) are required.
Salutation:
First Name:
*
Last Name:
*
Email:
*
Nickname:
*
Note: Nick name will be shown when you post comments.
Address 1:
*
Address 2:
City:
*
State:
*
Zip:
*
Phone:
      
Your daily must-read of conservative columns, cartoons and news. Coulter, Sowell, Krauthammer and more.
(Bi-Weekly) We highlight the best opportunities from our partners for surveys, action items and more.