Townhall.com, Where Your Opinion Counts
Talk Radio:   Bill Bennett   Mike Gallagher   Dennis Prager   Michael Medved   Hugh Hewitt   
BREAKING NEWS  LeftArrow - Townhall.com : Conservative, Political, Republican   RightArrow - Townhall.com : Conservative, Political, Republican  
Columns, funnies & more in your inbox!
  • Check the boxes and send us your email address to receveive your free newsletter
  • Your daily must-read of conservative columns, cartoons and news. Coulter, Sowell, Krauthammer and more.
  • Townhall.com’s weekly inside scoop on what’s happening behind the scenes in the world of politics. When news breaks, we report.
  • Signup to receive the latest daily Townhall cartoons
Thursday, February 14, 2008
Victor Davis Hanson :: Townhall.com Columnist
'The Candidate' - Starring Barack Obama
by Victor Davis Hanson
Vote on It:
Average Vote:
[+] Text [-]
 
Poll
Will the Dems' health care Christmas Present to America be an improvement or detriment to our health care system?


In these uncertain times, the relatively new Sen. Barack Obama has become America’s “change” candidate. But how different in real terms is the Obama candidacy?

Obama’s father was from Kenya, and he grew up for a time in Indonesia. But, otherwise, Obama was raised by his white mother and grandparents in a middle-class suburb in Hawaii — a unique upbringing in the 1970s but hardly so in today’s multiracial and itinerant America.

At private school, he was sometimes known as Barry. Perhaps had he taken the name of his maternal family who raised him — Dunham — a Sen. Barry Dunham of mixed ancestry from Illinois would now not be causing quite the same sensation.

Indeed, a Sen. Dunham may have been viewed as a minority candidate to the same limited degree that a similar staid-sounding Gov. Bill Richardson resonated as a Mexican-American.

True, many African-Americans may have voted for Obama because he’s a gifted charismatic role model and in belief that his agenda will offer welcome change. But he apparently has far less appeal to other minority groups as a grassroots alternative. Both Hispanics and Asians have voted against him in large numbers.

Take away the exotic name and Sen. Obama’s early background is not all that different from millions in an increasingly racially mixed and diverse America, in which a woman, a Latino, an Italian-American, a Mormon, a popular TV actor and a 71-year-old all ran for president this year. Three of these candidates also survived cancer.

Obama’s later Ivy-League education and political career resemble those of many elites in both parties. While Sen. and Mrs. Obama lecture, in populist fashion, about the burdens of school loans, they are really talking about paying off their two Harvard Law School tuitions, degrees that are not typical of struggling students, but instead government-guaranteed investments in the good life — as their 2006 joint income of nearly a million dollars attests.

Of course, from the little we know about his vague proposals, Obama certainly seems to offer a different choice from the current administration: quick withdrawal from Iraq, formal talks with Iran and essentially a worldwide conference with the Muslim world to iron out our differences.

At home, Obama sometimes advocates repealing the Bush tax cuts and raising some revenue through higher taxes — all to pay for vague Great Society government programs for the middle class, students and the poor. But few could list many key differences between Obama’s platform and Hillary Clinton’s views.

Where did we get the notion that Obama is the avatar of change? The answer is again not just that he is part African-American. (A Jesse Jackson or Al Sharpton, for example, would go nowhere.) Or that he has new policies or ideas. In fact, to the extent Obama has laid out any details of a program, they aren’t any more novel than those of his rivals.

Instead, he is the change candidate for two simple reasons. First, Obama is fresh, without the albatross of a long political career around his neck. We know little about him — and too much about the others. The more he sticks with generalities, the less he offends particular constituents — without having to make tough choices that day after day might keep offending 49 percent of the electorate.

Second, Obama is a stylish, inspirational speaker — a sort of elegant Adlai Stevenson of the 1950s and the hip, young Gary Hart of the 1980s all in one. He is wonderful in repartee, smart, full of good grace and without the shrillness of Clinton, or the occasional temper of McCain.

If anything, Obama resembles the handsome, well-spoken Robert Redford character Bill McKay, of the 1972 movie “The Candidate,” but updated for the new millennium: brighter, more charismatic and multicultural.

In these divisive times of war and economic anxiety, a tired public apparently wants someone hip, upbeat, reassuring in talk and fresh in spirit, but not too specific in prescribing any painful remedies for our various maladies.

As it turns out, there are not all that many handsome, young natural speakers, with a hint of mystery and the promise of racial harmony — at least none who speak inspirationally, respond to criticism with humor and are genuinely nice guys.

At least in that cosmetic sense, Obama really is a rarity — a pleasant change in other words from what we’re used to seeing and hearing, past and present.

If Obama can translate all that into true leadership and effective policy, that would be real change. If not, we’ll be asking the same question posed by Robert Redford’s character Bill McKay to end “The Candidate”: “What do we do now?”

Share:
Vote on It:
Average Vote:
 
About The Author
Victor Davis Hanson is a classicist and historian at the Hoover Institution, Stanford University, and a recipient of the 2007 National Humanities Medal.

Be the first to read Victor Davis Hanson's column. Sign up today and receive Townhall.com delivered each morning to your inbox.

I thought O'Bama was Irish
Next you'll tell me "change" isn't refering to diapers.

I thought O'Bama was Irish
Next you'll tell me "change" isn't refering to diapers.

Obama the Pathetic Liar

How can Mr. Hussein unite the country when he himself is a member of a hardcore racist church that boasts about black this, black that and puts the mother continent of Africa first before the USA and boasts about how unashamedly black they are. The preacher is a known far left leaning revolutionist type. If he was not a hardcore racist himself, then he would not be a member of such an establishment.

Mr. Hussein has had NO experience whatsoever in his lifetime of creating jobs, or the knowledge on how economics works by his statements concerning raising taxes to pay for everything when this country is on the brink of bankruptcy. This guy is the smoothest talking snake oil salesman to ever be on a TV screen. It is absurd how this guy has put all of his followers into such a hypnosis over his empty rhetoric.

Link to Mr. Hussein’s “Racist” church:

Look at the focus on being "black" and "African" in Obama's and Oprah Winfrey’s church:

http://www.tucc.org/about.htm

This author is a confused person
who can throw out just any jargons to hype Barack "the Audacity of Hype" Obama.

Just read this...

"Second, Obama is a stylish, inspirational speaker — a sort of elegant Adlai Stevenson of the 1950s and the hip, young Gary Hart of the 1980s all in one. He is wonderful in repartee, smart, full of good grace and without the shrillness of Clinton, or the occasional temper of McCain."

"If anything, Obama resembles the handsome, well-spoken Robert Redford character Bill McKay, of the 1972 movie “The Candidate,” but updated for the new millennium: brighter, more charismatic and multicultural."

"At least in that cosmetic sense, Obama really is a rarity — a pleasant change in other words from what we’re used to seeing and hearing, past and present"

Given more space, this author would probbaly write: "Obama is bigger than life". Or, "Obama, the super messiah, a rarity creature, with Godly voice".

Gee, how hopeless pundits and authors have been in this Obamania festival.

The author also wrote:
"In these divisive times of war and economic anxiety, a tired public apparently wants someone hip, upbeat, reassuring in talk and fresh in spirit, but not too specific in prescribing any painful remedies for our various maladies."

Ok, it's a war time. But economic anxiety? Don't we have business cycle in which economy is sometimes ups and sometimes down? And tired public? And how the author knows that the public is tired...and tired of what? Tired of Britney Spears? Maybe.

And..fresh in spirit? But in the previous paragraph the author said that Obama's proposal is vague. Nothing fresh in spirit here. The call for unity and change is as old as the history of human race.

What's new in this whole presidential candidate business is how lazy and how bad the media have been in analyzing the Obamania objectively.





Hanson is on the mark!
Hanson may be on the mark. But I think the story line should be more the fairy tale about the King and his new wardrobe. Will the media wake up and see that there is no wardrobe, only a blank slate in BHO.

Obama and hope
It is not "hope" but "how" if hope is to be realized. And the "how" must be of substance. Otherwise, hope becomes a "fairy tale"!

Elections are not in a Vacuum
The conservative press is blasting the 'liberal' positions of Obama. But this election will not be a choice of liberal or no liberal, or even conservative or no conservative. Each of the candidates will have an opponent - and the contrast with the opponent - not the contrast with ideology - will decide the election......
http://thefiresidepost.com/2008/02/14/vacuum-the-votes-but- not-in-a-vacuum/

Here's the Reason...
...for Obama's surge. He ain't a Baby Boomer! He's got absoulutely nothing to do with "the Sixties" and there's a large portion of this country's voters sick to death of us narcississtic geezers taking up all the press.

Mr. Hanson
The young people who support Mr. Obama believe that they can create a "WORLD" filled with "LOVE" and ran on "RESPECT".If God, could send "US" a virus, that would kill those over 65,they might have a chance.The young don't want to DIE for old FOOLS.Who can blame them?Today, we have a generation at hand, that has a new definition for "Western Civilization".The old tired enslaving concepts are wasting away,while being replaced by New ones.This is a courageous group of people, that "US" have raised and their ideas are superior, to those they inherited.The challenges of the FUTURE, belong to the young,so let them choose their own approach.Churchill said;"Important Decisions,Should be Made by Those Who Have the Most to Lose".Time is more valuable than MONEY.

Art writes,
Best description by Mark Steyn: WHEN YOU LOOK AT HIS SPOKEN WORDS WRITTEN ON A PAGE THEY TURN TO DUST.

He Is the One
A more apt analogy to the Barack Obama phenomena is that of Neo played by Keanu Reeves in The Matrix. In fact, I actually heard Oprah Winfrey say, "He is the one."

...which leads to memories of what happened to the Jonestown cult--mass suicide--and the space age cult, who killed themselves to join the mother ship hovering over the earth.

This Obama cult seems to hark back to the Sixties generation of pot-smoking flower children who just wanted "to give peace a chance." But I thought the flower children were all middle-aged now working nine to five and raising a family, with all that fantasy behind them.

Who knew that many of these secularists still believe in the Messiah?

Obama's new book
The title of his new book should be "Audacity of Arrogance". With his lack of experience it is somewhat arrogant on his part to believe he is qualified to be the president.

The beginning
I'm less interested in Obama or McCain, per se, than in what they represent. When a President's approval ratings have been mired in the 30's for years, when Congress's ratings on both sides of the aisle is south of 30, when almost 80% of the people believe the nation is on the wrong the track, when increasing numbers of people are dropping party loyalty and identifying themselves as independents, and when one party throws up Obama, and the other McCain, whose primary claim to fame is his independence, we can see that there is growing dissatisfaction with politics as usual, and with the old guard who practices those politics. Obama has simply captured the mood. McCain, to a lesser degree, has done the same thing.

Since, however, there is no concensus on what to change, nor how to do it, neither candidate will accomplish much at this point in time. However, what increasing numbers recognize is that the issues of the 21st century have little to do with those of the 20th century, and that the America of the 21st century is becoming a very different country from what it was. Economically, we can no longer command the world as we did, nor can we provide the same degree of military leadership for the West that we did as well. We are moving from a manufacturing society to one based on service, our debt is high and will inevitably grow, and our reliance on foreign banking to finance debt, and on other countries to produce our durable goods, increasingly robs us of our sovreignity. Internally, the very make-up of the society is systematically shifting, as we move increasingly away from our Western roots to a model rooted in diversity. Inevitably, we will have to recognize this and deal with it. But not now - and not in this election. This is only the beginning.

Obama's my man! :0)
I'm votin' Obama! I'd rather have an inexperienced, naive bumbler in the White House, who should be no match for the likes of M. McConnel, rather than a spiteful, inside wolf in sheeps clothing furthering the dysfunctional divide of our party. Let all those 'enlightened' folks see what a mess an empty suit can do.

Obamamania
Obama: Mr. SOS - The 21st century version of the Snake Oil Salesman. Style Over Substance or how about Symbolism Over Stances - This guy is a phony. Can't wait for McCain to bring up a real issue or two and the public sees thru his highly polished veneer. The DEMS will regret throwing Hitlary out.

What the mob wants
What the mob wants the mob gets. Where is it written in the Constitution that every American, and illegal immigrant, is entitled to no-cost healthcare? If Osama Obama were white he'd be as popular as Dennis Kuchinich. The Oracle, Oprah, wouldn't have given him the time of day. Once America sees past his blackness they will reject him. Then again this country goes ga ga over Paris Hilton and is enthralled with Brittany Spears. "Bread and circuses give them bread and circuses".

strange logic
There is some real strange logic going on this thread.

What Hanson is trying to say is he speaks and looks real pretty but that's all there is.

If Obama gets elected I wonder what the population will do when he can't even deliver half of his promises.

Senator Obama
Obama has a detailed presidential plan on his website. Compare those plans to the US Constitution. You decide if he should be president. WARNING: Grab your checkbook.

The Outsider...
A disturbing aspect of Obama that's little mentioned is how much of a true outsider he is to most of America, culturally, by upbringing and, yes, racially.
He has a "similar, but not quite" relationship to white Americans, but also to black Americans, and seems a charismatic Outsider to all of them.
This is troubling when we think of how other "outsider, but similar" leaders in history have treated the population. The Corsican Napoleon and the French... the Austrian Hitler and the Germans. Such leaders showed a casual willingness to sacrifice the people who'd made them feel like Outsiders in the name of their own grand schemes.

Obama the Candidate
A useful adjunct to Victor Davis Hanson's column is Daniel Henniger's "Wonderland" OpEd in todays (Feb 14) Wall Street Journal. In that column he takes Obama's "victory" speech after last weekends primary successes and strips away the rhetoric, leaving behind a Dennis Kucinech / John Edwards-like rant about two Americas, workers in two jobs and unable to afford health insurance for dying relatives, bleak economic social and racial conditions for a majority of Americans, and on and on.

Hopefully, Henniger is correct in his conclusion: this approach, once it is widely recognized, will be as unsuccessful for Obama as it was for Edwards and Kucinich.

He'll be flushed out soon enough...
The darling of the media and liberals will soon have to face McCain one-on-one in the debates. He will soon have to defend his plan to:

- raise taxes
- spend $210 billion to stimulate the economy (again)
- explain how he's going to pay for national health care (another entitlement train wreck waiting to happen)
- Explain what's going to happen in Iraq when he pulls all troops out and how he intends to deal with the ongoing threat of crazy muslims
- Explain what he's going to do to secure our borders and deal with illegal aliens

He won't be able to dodge and weave his way out of his positions in a debate. Most who are swooning over him now don't even know what his positions are since he's relying on his "star" power to propel him along. McCain is a pro and will sink Obama in the debates.

LJ7392-Lolo
Osama Obama is ALL HAT and NO CATTLE!

‘Hope’ is HOPELESS without ACTION. Stand Osama Obama and I side by side, put a coffee cup on the ground in front of both of us. I’ll urinate in my cup and he can HOPE in his. Which one do you think will fill up faster?

Shallow Rhetoric
Barack DOES have a pleasent voice - easy to listen to. BUT - take away all the catch phrases (change, turn the corner, etc) and the essence of his "message" is meaningless drivel.

Topgun got it right about Barack's religion. Google "United Church of Christ" and find out for yourself. Then, compare his core beliefs (pro Africa - anti America), his lame excuse concerning "symbols of patriotism", and refusal to honor the National Anthemn and Pledge of Allegiance.

I would trust Hillary before Obhama!

Killer is right
Things are changing. And change is always good, except when it's bad. And this change is VERY bad. What I'm saying is that I believe that Thomas Jefferson, James Madison, George Washington, etc., had more brains than the whole of todays Democrat party. We have changed so much that none of them would recognize the country today. All they asked of government was to stand out of the way, much different than killer and his ilk, who want government to do everything for them, a bunch of helpless whining babies. They could no more take responsibility for their own life than they could flap their arms and fly. The country is going you-know-where in a handbasket, thanks to the leeches.

Hobson's choice
If it came down to a choice between Hillary and Obama, I'd vote for Hillary. Better the Devil you know than the Devil you don't know.

Obana is a great candidate
By November everyone will know he is an inch deep and a radical liberal. Yes, we will be stuck with McCain, but that is better than either of the democrats.

Killer
I guess I'm one of those older people you're talking about. I don't want any of the empty, "Oh, Wow", "Like" "Don't really give a damn if it isn't about ME" crowd making this country different! I just want this country to stay on some kind of even keel while I'm still here. After I'm gone all those young people can mess up the world to their own selfish pleasure!

Primaries not over
For those of us whose primaries are still to come, we might be wise to go vote for Hillary.

My choice is still Newt

In the first place, I am 100% against change for the sake of change, but am all in favor of improvement.

killer
writes, "The old tired enslaving concepts are wasting away,while being replaced by New ones"

I believe you. I am starting to think your nickname might be more descriptive of you than I would like.


Barack is trumping Shrillary
I think that when they autopsy her campaign many will point to Slick Willie as the loose cannon that backfired... the race card thing was STUPID, but leave it to the Clintonista's to try any dirty trick. The tears thing could only be used once, and only a few states have a lot of Mexicans actually voting (see Mexifornia)-- SO FAR.

Barack has out-campaigned her, partly because Presidente Jorge and the rest have so stunk up Washington (what else is new?!) that is is best not to be stressing experience there. Shrillary had parlayed Slick Willie's adultery into a Senate seat (as even honest libs like Howard Fineman admit), but too many correctly do not see Slick's time in the W.H. as HER experience, though she tries to play that for all it is worth.

Barack is an empty suit so far on details, but so was Jimma' Carter in '76 when he followed another failure/bad smell in the W.H... appearance passes for reality to many. And he got lucky to have the underwhelming liberal open border RINO Amnesty Juan McQuisling as his opponent. We are sick of hearing the neoCON drivel about how we must never leave Iraq; it is the only tune the old man can play. He admits that he does not understand economics-- swell time for that "straight talk."
We had better support a lot of REAL Republicans for Congress to stop the bleeding and save the republic from the ILLEGAL invasion and the permanent welfare state, which the 'Crats will have when the ILLEGALS all actually vote, which will not even require citizenship... that's what the driver's license ploy is all about.

BARACK HUSSEIN OBAMA
someone help: doesn't barack hussein obama translate to mean "tabula rasa"?

History
We are living at a momentous time in history here. It was hardly that long ago that a black person even trying to vote, much less run for president, would have been hung to a tree and burned. Be interesting to see what the outcome will be if he does manage to get elected.

I hope we do get a welfare state. It will be much preferred to the grotesque one that we have now under the autocracy of kleptomaniacs that are now in the white house.

He is the one - The Obama
This is a very nice article about Obama. The comments are really good. Nice discussion.


===================================
Jincy
for sale by owner
http://fsbo.fastrealestate.net
Sign Up to Post Your CommentsSign Up to Post Your Comments
If you are already registered, click here to login. Otherwise, please take a few seconds to register with Townhall.com. Once you sign up, you’ll be able to post your comments immediately, use the action center, get podcasts, and more!
Note: Fields marked with a red asterisk (*) are required.
Salutation:
First Name:
*
Last Name:
*
Email:
*
Nickname:
*
Note: Nick name will be shown when you post comments.
Address 1:
*
Address 2:
City:
*
State:
*
Zip:
*
Phone:
      
Your daily must-read of conservative columns, cartoons and news. Coulter, Sowell, Krauthammer and more.
(Bi-Weekly) We highlight the best opportunities from our partners for surveys, action items and more.