Townhall.com, Where Your Opinion Counts
Talk Radio:   Bill Bennett   Mike Gallagher   Dennis Prager   Michael Medved   Hugh Hewitt   
BREAKING NEWS  LeftArrow - Townhall.com : Conservative, Political, Republican   RightArrow - Townhall.com : Conservative, Political, Republican  
Columns, funnies & more in your inbox!
  • Check the boxes and send us your email address to receveive your free newsletter
  • Your daily must-read of conservative columns, cartoons and news. Coulter, Sowell, Krauthammer and more.
  • Townhall.com’s weekly inside scoop on what’s happening behind the scenes in the world of politics. When news breaks, we report.
  • Signup to receive the latest daily Townhall cartoons
Wednesday, June 18, 2008
Thomas Sowell :: Townhall.com Columnist
Tim Russert (1950-2008)
by Thomas Sowell
Vote on It:
Average Vote:
[+] Text [-]
 
Poll
Will the Dems' health care Christmas Present to America be an improvement or detriment to our health care system?


Only with Tim Russert's sudden death at the age of 58 has his true stature as a landmark journalist become as widely recognized as it has long deserved to be.

To ask who will replace him as host of "Meet the Press" is to confront the reality that there is no one comparable on the horizon. Those of us who have followed "Meet the Press" since the long ago days of Lawrence Spivak know that Russert was the best of some very good hosts.

What made Tim Russert special was not some trademark catchword or contrived persona. What you saw was what you got-- a down to earth guy who came on the air having thoroughly researched the subject and having a keen insight into politics and politicians.

He didn't flaunt his knowledge. He was one of the few very smart people who seemed to feel no need to impress others that he was smart. But, if you knew the subject that he was talking about, you realized that he had really done his homework.

There was something else that set Tim Russert apart from many other journalists, whether print journalists or broadcast journalists: His agenda was bringing out the facts.

He didn't let the politicians he interviewed get away with slippery statements and inconsistent positions. But it was not "gotcha" journalism. It was not trying to filter or slant information to promote some political or ideological agenda.

No doubt Tim Russert had his own opinions. He had, after all, been on the staff of the late Senator Daniel Patrick Moynihan and on the staff of former New York governor Mario Cuomo.

But, whatever Tim Russert's political opinions were then or later, that was not what his program was about. He was there to serve the audience by bringing out the facts about the political world, a world where spin is the usually name of the game.

Often critics who complain about media bias argue as if what is needed is to be "fair" to "both sides." But what is far more important is to be honest with the audience-- who are seeking information and understanding about the real world, not about the ideology or the agenda of the journalist.

This is not to denigrate opinion journalists, who have a valuable role to play, just as reporters like Tim Russert do. But, with both opinion journalists and reporters, the question is whether you play it straight with the audience, instead of filtering out inconvenient facts in order to manipulate the audience in favor of some agenda.

In short, the issue is honesty rather than "fairness." The question is whether journalists put their cards on the table. Russert put his cards on the table-- and they were high cards.

A small personal note: A few months ago, an old friend said that he would like to get a videotape of my interview on "Meet the Press" back in 1981. I dug up an old videotape in my garage but, after several summers in a hot garage, it was not in very good shape.

As a long shot, I decided to write to "Meet the Press," to see if they would sell me another copy of the interview, if it was still available.

This interview took place back in the days when Bill Monroe was the program's moderator. But, since the only name I knew of at "Meet the Press" was Tim Russert, I addressed a note to him, figuring that one of his secretaries might get back to me with the information.

Instead, I received a DVD of that interview and a brief, handwritten note from Tim Russert, with a transcript of the interview thrown in.

How people treat those who cannot do them any good or any harm reveals a lot about their character. For me, Tim Russert scored high in that department as well.

Share:
Vote on It:
Average Vote:
 
About The Author
Thomas Sowell is a senior fellow at the Hoover Institute and author of The Housing Boom and Bust.
 
TOWNHALL DAILY: Sign up today and receive Thomas Sowell and Townhall.com's daily lineup delivered each morning to your inbox.
 
©Creators Syndicate
Replace Russert?
As the movers look at the availble "talent" to host MTP they realize that Tim truly was the tallest midget.

Good luck to all.

Russert v. Hillary
Tim Russert gained all the respect I can offer when he had HRC on his show. He showed her a clip of her husband admiting to having an inappropriate relationship with Monica Lewinsky and then asking something along the lines of: "Are you ready to admit there was no right wing conspiracy?"

I guess that's why Hillary refused to go on Meet The Press during the initial stages of her campaign. She knew Tim (and Fox News) was not a lackey of the DNC (like Olbermann & Matthews) and she would be called on the carpet for her hypocracy. Only when she failed at getting rid of Obama did she decide she had to face Russert. This told me everything I needed to know about Tim Russert. If you were a phony he would expose you for being a phony - no matter which political party you belonged to.

The only way NBC could replace Russert would be to hire Brit Hume. If not, then the show will just gravitate into another DNC production and lose a majority of its viewers. If they bring in the anti-American Olbermann then the show is toast.


Note that the right had no one like him.

The reason is simple -- the Dems realized that their best talent grew up poor. In Russet's case, working on the back of a garbage truck.

The left pays college kids and recent grads a living wage and they have no shortage of talent. The right expects volunteers and a "good" job with Heritage pays something like $12K. Right.

Russet was fair but he was a Dem. And the reason why our side has no one like him is that we have spent the last 40 years forcing our young people to make the tough decision to make a living rather than support our causes.

$12K to support yourself in DC? Only those with trust funds need apply....

Will, the Marxist homosexual
Ah, Will the guu who frequents professor Adams writings. Will moderates his opinions here, but take a look at some of his responses at Dr. Adams columns. Will is probably the farthest left poster you can find. He is dedicated to promoting Marxism, and he hates white people, Christians and Republicans. He also is no fan of heterosexual marriage.

With that said check out his postings on Dr. Adams writings.

Only Sowell could write a true Obit
for Tim Russert. He was real is the comment I hear from those on the left as well as the right. You knew where you stood. How many on TV could be liked by Bill Clinton AND Rush Limbaugh?

Thank you Master Sowell for telling it the way it should be.

NO FOWG, They will NEVER
Be able to find anyone to fill Tim Russert's shoes. They would be better off to retire MTP and replace it with something else.

But we know they'll never do that. They'll find someone else to host the show, but it will never be the same.

One other thing about all of the tributes to Russert by the posters here that I HOPE everyone else has noticed is that, unlike when a Conservative Commentator or Public Figures passes, ALL of the posts honoring Russert, from the Cons and the libs alike, WERE CIVIL AND RESPECTFUL.

The same CAN NOT be said of the comments made by libs when Reagan, Falwell, Buckley or even Ann Coulters father passed away.

CAN THEY LIBS??

The Cyclist
you could not have mentioned a better replacement for Tim. Brit Hume is another class act that seems to want facts, not fame! RIP Mr. Russert. You'll be missed!

THE Doctor Is Correct
Russert's fame came from being down to earth and equally tough on politicians. So why aren't there more like him? I don't know but it sure sounds like a good way to get more listeners and fans. More listeners sounds like more $$$$ for the networks and stations so why aren't they following that pattern? Perhaps they are more ground into biased politics than for the good of their club.

Enuff already...
When will the last article be written eulogizing this guy? Heartless...me...no...just way over the top reporting and coverage...

sdeakins
That comment was one that should have been kept to yourself.

The man hasn't been dead for even a week.

Tim Russert RIP
I ,for one,will miss Tim Russert. He was the best moderator on television. He was thorough and I have seen him drill Democrats as well as Republicans.

Someone before me said maybe they should retire the show altogether. That is the best idea I have heard. No one could come close to replacing him and would forever be trying to fill his shoes. It can't be done.






Somebody will succeed Tim Russert,
but nobody on the horizon at present seems to be able to replace him.

My greatest fear is that MSNBC's golden boy, Keith Olbermann will be given the post by the anti-Americam management of General Electric, NBC and MSNBC. After all, it is clear that Olberman can not compete with Bill O'Reilley in prime time, might as well give him a spot with built in high ratings.

Then he can bring MTP to the sewer of Countdown.

I saw Tim Russert in person,
giving a commencement address at D'Youville College in Buffalo, where my wife was one of the graduating class, in the summer of 1995.

Tim Russert had class that those who eulogized him (Olbermann, Matthews, Robinson, Maddow etc. etc.) could not dream of having in their wildest dreams.

Air America, Washington Post and The Worst Person In The World are the best examples what journalism is not, and they are all, 180 degrees opposite of the integrity of Tim Russert.

I saw Tim Russert in person,
giving a commencement address at D'Youville College in Buffalo, where my wife was one of the graduating class, in the summer of 1995.

Tim Russert had class that those who eulogized him (Olbermann, Matthews, Robinson, Maddow etc. etc.) could not dream of having in their wildest dreams.

Air America, Washington Post and The Worst Person In The World are the best examples what journalism is not, and they are all, 180 degrees opposite of the integrity of Tim Russert.

Cyclist, good choice!
Another good choice would be the good Dr. Sowell himself. I can think of no one else that would be better at clearing the spin and keeping common sense in the dialogue. Although I never watch MTP and therefore had no first hand knowledge of Tim Russert, I have learned from the eulogies of mostly "right-wing" commentators that he was both a great moderator and a truely fine human being that the world is in far too short a supply. He will be truely missed.

Replacements
Bret Baier, Brit Hume, Thomas Sowell, Laura Ingraham, Sean Hannity, and there are many others. He can be replaced easily if the thinking is, "It is not the man, it is the message". Journalist nepotism of promoting each book written by appearing on each news show, should stop unless the networks intend to extend that promotion to all book writers that want to spread their own take on the issues. Eulogies may be heartfelt or they may just be a phony payback for helping earn book royalties.

Princess Diana...
and look how long she's been gone.

Tim Russert
I've learned far more about this man since his death than I ever knew from seeing his work, and I am convinced that he was a very good person who positively affected all those around him.

I do think and hope that MTP will move on, more likely with a differently gifted host than with a hopeful clone. If Mr. Russert had a fault, I think he was too enamored of our very flawed political and electoral processes. He may have been equally tough on Democrats as on Republicans, but he never questioned that the two together were the rightful rulers of our country. In that, he certainly wasn't alone, but maybe a successor will have the will and inclination to go even deeper.

Heart disease
I've already articulated this on another thread but I'm eternally amazed by how little modern medicine knows about heart disease. Russert could afford the best health care available (obviously socialized medicine was not necessary). Nor was Russert morbidly obese.

This condition deserves greater public attention. Unfortunately, no Lance Armstrong or Bono is touting the cause.

Thomas Sorwell's article on Tim Russert
I never met the man, but watched him on MTP as well as the Today Show every week during the primary's. To me he always came across as a truly nice man. One you would meet on the street and he would shake your hand, not look the other way or avoid you.
He was a deeply religious person and seemed to love his son, his wife, his dad and his beloved Buffalo which he always talked about. I for one of thousands will miss him terribly and I hope to meet him some day in Heaven.
Marilyn, Portland, Oregon

Cyclist's suggestion
Very astute choice! Hume, like Russert, demonstrates it is the subject matter and the guest that is the story, not the journalist/commentator. The ego or agenda is NOT the story, unlike what we see from the likes of Olbermann, Mathews, O'Reilly, et.al.
Other possibles like Ted Koppel (probably too old) and Neil Cavuto (perhaps too young) only underline just how tall Mr. Russert really stood.

I agree Tim was the greatest


I agree that Tim was one of the greatest people on TV, but what a great fuss to make of anyone who was able to leave without pain and suffering.

I think that most of the Cable noise was because at least some of them realized Tim was the best, and they could never copy him. They thought that if they said nice things about Tim, maybe, just maybe, people would associate them with excellect Tim.

What I am afraid will happen, is that Keith Stupidman will now fake his death, just in hopes he gets a minute or two on TV when someone, as stupid as it sounds, might say he was also wonderful.

All I have asked my family to do is to have my G’daughter look at the smile on my face, and holler, “Hooray, G’pa finally made it, he is now with his Sweetie for eternity.” Then buy me a half-way ticket to Catalina Island.


ALL I EVER WANT IS THE TRUTH
The reason I watched "Meet the Press" is the same reason why I read Dr. Sowells books and articles, I want the truth. Come to think of it, Lou Dobbs likes placing all the facts out on the table for all to see and coming up with a solution, maybe he would be a good candidate for "Meet the Press". Thanks for all your insight Dr. Sowell.

On the road to being a giant
Tim Russert was not around long enough to attain "giant" or icon status. His life was cut short for reasons known only to his Creator.

Had he lived out the full number of his days, I have no doubt he would have been numbered with the all-time greats. He will be missed.

The Best
You know just how truly good Russert was when Thomas Sowell labels him "The Best...".

As far as Sowell hosting the show...you could it make it PPV and I would gladly drop $49.95 every week to watch.

Russert
I guess when I watched Big Tim I had the impression that he was a libreal who gave the left a pat on the back while demonizing the right.

Replacements
brit Hume would be great, I agree. I'd love to hear him bark at phony pols on both sides "Quickly!" as the break is coming fast. Also John Kasich has a similar style and ability that could restore lost credibility at that rag of a network. There are a few others with the ability to pierce both sides. Tammy Bruce could handle it. Paul Gigot if he cared to. It is certainly a very short list of talking heads that would keep me as interested as I have been for 25 years. If it is Gregory or Keith Overbite, I am out!

How about Karl Rove?
Just kidding. You have to spend your life working for Democrat office holders to qualify as fair and evenhanded, right. Karl would be great, but better would be a return to the original format with a moderator and three guest journalists. Is was "Meet the Press" not "Meet Tim". Remember?

rip
i am certain that tim was a decent person and i know he will be grieved and missed by his loved ones, rest in peace tim.
i watched MTP at times. tim was ok.

that said, the rending of cloth and hair by the media is beyond belief.
one would have thought god died.
this a a media feeding frenzy. i guess they see that they too are mortal and want this much attention when it's their time.

adios,
Harvey
Lancaster, Taxifornia
dial 1 for english

micheal savage
i think mike would be a good choice.
he hates democrats as much as he hates republicans.
i don't think the networks would like him any more than he, them.

ciao,
Harvey
Lancaster, Mexifornia
dial 1 for english

It is sad
that a person who is reasonably thorough and unbiased in his work as

Toucan
I agree with you about Sowell and Russert, but Lou Dobbs? Dobbs' show is a perfect of example of bias. It is not a liberal bias, but a populist bias that rants about trade and immigration. His "reports" done by Bill Tucker and others are tremendous spin.

Tim Russert
He was one of the best in his field.

Surprising.....
Surprising that Dr. Sowell thinks he could do no good or harm to Tim Russert. Any syndicated columnist could do good, or harm, to the reputation of a public figure like Tim Russert. Dr. Sowell, you underestimate your influence!

Tim Russert
Tim Russert
By Joe Hernandez

Tim Russert dead at age fifty-eight
A man that was the best of the best
As a Journalist he stood alone as great
His viewers of this they can attest

No one will be able to replace him
Meet The Press as also died
Journalism's good days now seem grim
This feeling will be felt worldwide

Tim Russert was a special breed
He was what you saw and got
A man that needed to exceed
Every week he filled his time slot

Always well prepared and ready
With a sense of journalistic know-how
His approach was smart and steady
Only facts would he allow


Free of ideological and political bias
Guardian of the truth presented as facts
Did not allow for any political pious
Or guests deviating from their tracks

He respected his audience with honesty
Never allowing others to misinform
No spin, ideology or dishonesty
Only presenting the facts was his norm

Replacement for Russert
The MSM would go balistic, the dnc would scream bias, but the most intelligent man for the job of replacing Russert would be Michael Barone.

The MSM and the dnc would never stand still for this choice because they know full well that Barone would be able to quote from their previous statements to contradict what they tried to slide through as their "always held positions".

Barone has to be one of the most intelligent and honest men in the US media.

Pirate 6/18 #34
"Forcing our young people to make the tough decision to make a living...." is supporting our causes. Kid's with cushy jobs is but the first step to becoming a lefty elitist.
Sign Up to Post Your CommentsSign Up to Post Your Comments
If you are already registered, click here to login. Otherwise, please take a few seconds to register with Townhall.com. Once you sign up, you’ll be able to post your comments immediately, use the action center, get podcasts, and more!
Note: Fields marked with a red asterisk (*) are required.
Salutation:
First Name:
*
Last Name:
*
Email:
*
Nickname:
*
Note: Nick name will be shown when you post comments.
Address 1:
*
Address 2:
City:
*
State:
*
Zip:
*
Phone:
      
Your daily must-read of conservative columns, cartoons and news. Coulter, Sowell, Krauthammer and more.
(Bi-Weekly) We highlight the best opportunities from our partners for surveys, action items and more.