Townhall.com, Where Your Opinion Counts
Talk Radio:   Bill Bennett   Mike Gallagher   Dennis Prager   Michael Medved   Hugh Hewitt   
BREAKING NEWS  LeftArrow - Townhall.com : Conservative, Political, Republican   RightArrow - Townhall.com : Conservative, Political, Republican  
Columns, funnies & more in your inbox!
  • Check the boxes and send us your email address to receveive your free newsletter
  • Your daily must-read of conservative columns, cartoons and news. Coulter, Sowell, Krauthammer and more.
  • Townhall.com’s weekly inside scoop on what’s happening behind the scenes in the world of politics. When news breaks, we report.
  • Signup to receive the latest daily Townhall cartoons
Friday, December 14, 2007
Thomas Sowell :: Townhall.com Columnist
Say It Ain't So
by Thomas Sowell
Vote on It:
Average Vote:
[+] Text [-]
 
Poll
Was the Copenhagen Global Warming Summit Walk-Out a Win for the U.S.?


Shoeless Joe Jackson was the only man to bat .382 in his last season in the major leagues. After that he was banned for life for his role in the "black sox scandal," the deliberate throwing of the 1919 World Series.

It was to Jackson that a youngster was supposed to have said, "Say it ain't so, Joe."

Maybe we are too sophisticated today to react that way to the news that many major league star players have been taking steroids or other performance-enhancing drugs. But maybe we have gotten too sophisticated for our own good.

Some people are questioning whether there should now be asterisks alongside the records of Barry Bonds or other star players. That is the least of the problems -- and the least of the solutions.

Steroids are dangerous and sometimes fatal. Yet, if some players use them, others will feel the pressure to use them as well, in order to compete.

Most important of all, many young people will imitate their sports heroes -- and pay the price. Those young people are far more important than asterisks.

You might think that athletes who are making a million dollars -- not per year, but sometimes per month -- could spare some concern for the kids who look up to them.

But too many think only of themselves, and not always wisely, even for themselves.

Football star Michael Vick's downfall was dog-fighting, rather than steroids, but it was the same reckless disregard of rules, jeopardizing a career that would have earned him more in a few years than most people make in a lifetime.

Even those of us who are not Michael Vick fans have to find it painful to see a young man self-destruct this way. If anything good comes out of this, it might be that his fate may deter others.

The bottom line question for those in authority, whether in the courts or in professional sports is, "What are you going to do about it?"

The law has already spoken in the case of Michael Vick. It is too early to say what the law will do in the case of Barry Bonds and others involved in the steroid controversy.

But it is not too early to point out that what the law does or does not do is separate from what the people in charge of professional sports do.

In a court of law, the accused is presumed to be "innocent until proven guilty" beyond a reasonable doubt. But too many people mindlessly repeat that phrase for things outside of courts.

All the ballplayers accused of throwing the 1919 World Series were acquitted in a court of law -- and all were nevertheless banned from baseball for life anyway by the commissioner of baseball.

In a sense, that ban applied not only for life but beyond death. None of those players has been put in the Baseball Hall of Fame, even though Shoeless Joe Jackson hit .408 at his peak and left a lifetime batting average of .356.

That was long before we became so sophisticated that we learned to come up with excuses for those who violate rules and additional excuses for those who refuse to impose penalties.

Today there are those who lament Pete Rose's exclusion from the Baseball Hall of Fame, despite a record on the field that would certainly have put him there, except for breaking rules.

But Shoeless Joe Jackson's even more impressive record would certainly have put him in Cooperstown, if he had not broken the rules.

There is still some lingering hope of sanity in the baseball writers' refusal to vote Mark McGwire into the Baseball Hall of Fame, despite his tremendous career achievements.

Keeping known rule-breakers out of Cooperstown would be a lot more effective deterrent than putting asterisks alongside their records, to be disregarded by those who are "non-judgmental."

Unfortunately Senator George Mitchell's report on steroid use in the major leagues and its recommendations are of the let-bygones-be-bygones approach that has spread the disregard of rules throughout the whole society, from student cheaters to career criminals.

Share:
Vote on It:
Average Vote:
 
About The Author
Thomas Sowell is a senior fellow at the Hoover Institute and author of The Housing Boom and Bust.
 
TOWNHALL DAILY: Sign up today and receive Thomas Sowell and Townhall.com's daily lineup delivered each morning to your inbox.
 
©Creators Syndicate
The real inconvenient truth is
the law has become a joke. We don't enforce the rules anymore. We don't enforce propriety anymore. From our wide open southern border, to the treatment of interns in the oval office, to perjury, to cheating, there is no brake on abhorent behavior of any sort. Perhaps we should stop calling them laws, rules and norms and simply refer to them as what they are: suggestions for saps that can't afford expensive lawyers, public relations experts and spin merchants.

Please God, may the pendulum swing the other way -- and soon!

Oh, the shame of it all!
The real shame is that steroids don't really help. Steroids didn't make Barry Bonds, or ANY major leaguer, a great player, their talent is what made them great. Too bad that wasn't enough for Bonds. And too bad his example has the potential to delude young athletes into thinking steroids are their "ticket to the bigs".

Twenty years from now, Barry Bonds will be a mere memory for a few who got to see him play. When he's sitting on his porch remembering his playing days, I hope he has enough of a conscience to shed a tear or two.


tweaky
Steriods didn't help? While they indeed had talent before taking steriods and steriods will not help people without talent to suddenly become talented they did help the players that took them. Look at Bonds number before he allegedly started taking them and after. His homerun numbers soared. Look at Clemens. His number were good but after they were outstanding.

Someone please explain to me about Vick and his sentence. He admits to killing some dogs and gets villified and sent to prison for 23 months. However, a woman kills her unborn baby and she is a hero. The laws here seem really screwed up.

We need an Asterisk League
Have a regular league, and a league where it's legal to do anything to your body you can think of. From steroids to bionics, whatever.

So in the regular league, we can test un-enhanced human players against each other on the proverbial "level playing field." May the best man win.

But if you want to play as an Enhanced player and take whatever drugs might be available, then you switch to the Asterisk League. May the best pharmacist win.

Throw the rule breakers out of the Hall
That Ruth guy used prohibited alcohol to help him relax. Throw the bum out.

Another problem with Steroids
As Dr. Sowell says, the asterisk is far less important than the effect on our children.

I saw an interview with Jose Conseco and another baseball player. Jose Conseco had won some award or other, and was saying something such as he would be willing to give back the award. The runner up was also interviewed.

His point was he didn't care about the award, but the millions he lost in contracts because he played by the rules.

That's a bad lesson too, that cheating is rewarded, and a lesson that's probably not lost on a lot of kids.

I don't get too excited about...
...steroids in sports.It is against the rules,so if you take them you will be suspended.But I don't watch baseball to see players who follow the rules.I watch baseball to see home runs and double plays and no hit games,etc.I don't particularly care how they do it.I'll leave that to others who do care.Babe Ruth was a draft dodger during WWI and I don't like draft dodgers,but I would go see him play baseball if I had been alive during WWI.

I would watch Barry Bonds play also,and for the same reason.Bonds problem is with team owners,not me.I feel the same way about Vick.His problem is with the law,peta,and team owners.Not me.

I wonder what would happen if we applied the same rules in that other enterainment life,Hollywood? You get the idea.

Entertainment industry...
Professional "sports" are not true sports but rather employement in the entertainment industry (unlike the old days where they were much closer to true sports).

Were those modern day jocks (refered to in Dr Sowell's column) involved in true sports, they would (at best) be sign up for room & board (& meals) - their only big income being generated from the number of victories during the season (Dolphins would be broke). Teams employing "coke heads" would have to forfeit their victories, the "dope heads" would be suspended from the league, the prize earnings they might have received would be denied (prison sentences would include extra time for inability to pay back any "prise money" from previous seasons).

But, with pro-sports being the "entertainment industry", the jocks do not get held to the same level of accoutability that the general public would be held to - the jocks get paid regardless of victories (in many cases their contracts ensure that they will receive an income even if they do fail to last with a team). Like Hollywood employees, they tend to get off much lighter (for crimes committed) than the general public would.

So, like many people, I turn on the TV to air them only when I'm entitled to rest - when they will ensure that I sleep.

When nobody obeys the rules
you end up with Mexico, or Russia - two potentially great countries where crime and corruption prevents their rise above 3rd world status.

People look at scofflaws and wonder if they too, could get away with skirting the "rules" and succeed, in business, sports, or sneaking across our southern border.

The long, disgusting Clinton impeachment proceedings were especially uncomfortable to me personally because I had been inculcated by my Dad to always play by the rules and take responsibility for my own actions. The enemedia to this day marvels at how easily Bill and Hill can lie. Obviously their mothers never used the old classic ploy, "look at me so I can see if you're lying." Mine did and I learned at an early age that truth is always the best option and not having to remember which lie I told which person, made my life so much less complicated.

I was also offended when Newtie and his successor were shown to be immoral, and like most conservatives, welcomed their exit, as is proper. I've asked many of my liberal friends why they will tolerate behavior in their politicians that they would never stand for in their husband, brother or friends. They have no good answer other than, "it's was just about sex, a private matter."

That lying under oath to a judge and grand jury is no longer a crime to them, unless the perp is a republican, is very troubling, and one of the reasons this country is heading down the crapper.

Rules? There are no rules.
There is only what is WANTED. Rules can be blamed for any problem and sued away as the pesky oppressors that they are.

Its all one, ...
Its all one with the general refusal of our society to say -- plainly, clearly, and firmly -- that some things are simply WRONG.

When a society substitutes, "Well, ... it depends, ... ," for clear statements that certain actions are RIGHT and certain other actions are WRONG its not surprising to find people regarding all "rules" as optional. Regrettable, disgusting even, but not surprising.


MLB
Major League Baseball and other major sports businesses enjoy a special exemption from Anti-trust statutes that no other kind of business can even dream of. Why? At least part of the reason was the belief that baseball players, enjoying a certain hero status in American society, were essential to the moral upbrining of its youth. In other words, baseball and other professional sports, enjoy special treatment because they are supposed to provide a special service to society over and above that of making money. Well, since sports are now all about the money, and cultivating civic virtue be da&*ed, it's time to re-visit the status of ALL professional sports' special anti-trust exemptions.

Since the Strike in 1994
Major League Baseball lost this fan. MLB gets none of my time in person or on TV. It certainly gets none of my money.
The fans came in last in 1994 and have remained in last place since then.
If there is no punishment for flagrant violations of the rules, then let the player/druggies juice up all they want to. They think they're the only ones affected. They have no idea how they will affect our children's lives and they certainly don't care.
Again, the fans come in last.

Thanks for a good article,
Righteousness, Integrity, Honor, man why are these not praised today.

Thanks Mr. Sowell for stating how far we have fallen.

Idiototic optimism is not the cure, repentance is.

Personally, I gave up on
baseball during the player strike. The records no longer mean anything when compared to the day when I was young and watched Mickey Mantle hitting home runs. How many people remember that when Rodger Marris broke the record that Mickey Mantle was right behind him and was one of the best long ball hitters who ever lived?

As for steroids, if the league has banned them, then the people using them should be shunned the same as shoeless Joe.

Hey, if you bury them no one will come.

Breaking all rules
We also do not follow the rules in our "living document" Constitution written in disappearing ink on Silly Putty. The Supremes protect and defend the opinions of dead judges (precedents) more than they protect and defend the Constitution and have usurped the illegal legalized power to amend that document anytime that five of the nine choose to do so. Our government has degenerated from a constitutional republic into a "wonderful" de-mob-ocracy. Enjoy the bread and circuses, because our days as a great nation are over. www,poorgrandchildren.com

This is Absurd
(Excerpts from my longer blog post on this subject)

Congress needs to attend the business of Government, and forget about micro managing professional sports. They are uninformed or stupid - probably both. . . .

Barry Bonds has been charged in a trumped up process crime. They asked him if he took steroids. He said no. Others said yes. They say that may be perjury or obstruction. It may be. Ask Scooter Libby or Martha Stewart. No one has charged Bonds with illegal sterioid use or posession, no one has ever tested him positive for a banned substance. If he did use steroids, they were likely legally obtained, and used during a period that there was no rule against it in Major League Baseball. . . .

Second, if your high school age or younger kid is illegally obtaining and using anabolic sterioids you are a crappy parent, and your kid is an idiot. I doubt Congress can legislate anything effectively to alter either of those condition. . . .

When Umpires
are knowingly allowed to change the strike zone for every batter based on their feelings towards him and batters are allowed their base when they charge the mound, what difference does it make if any of the rest of the rules get followed?
The exemption form anti-trust laws is archaic and should be removed form sports. If it stays then ALL of the rules should be enforced. Union contracts do not supercede the established rules. They don't in any other industry so why let them in sports?

I don't care.
I usually hang on Dr. Sowell's words and opinions, because he has a way of nailing the bottom line. In this case, I'm not sure. Mitchell named perhaps 85 "rule breakers" primarily because a few people ratted 'em out. Maybe the "evidence" was overwhelming. Maybe it was just the word of a disgruntled individual seeking to reduce his own culpability. In any case, ignoring the innocent until proven guilty hypocrisy, you cannot convince me that all users of steroids were named. So those users who weren't named don't face any impediment to Cooperstown even though it is ridiculous to assume that nobody else broke the rules. So we punish those accused, let others skate, and hope that nobody notices. Let's all hope the nanny state doesn't decide that exercise and clean living gives a player an illegal advantage. That would affect people like Nolan Ryan. Or did Nolan pitch a no-hitter in his forties because . . . ?

Congress has no business in baseball
Why hasn't anyone else raised the question of whether Congress should even be involved in this issue?

I asked myself that, during the last round of hearings on steroid use.

Don't those clowns have anything better to do?

Democrats--have you fleeced all of the wealthy people? There's no one left for you to tax? Don't you have some Christmas displays to ban, or something?

Republicans--is the border closed yet? You have time for this?

And let's not even mention the fact that, apart from any drug laws that were broken, necessitating action by the EXECUTIVE and JUDICIAL branches, what business is it of the Federal government, to get involved in baseball's operations?

Every other conservative should be asking these questions. But this is the Age of Stupidity, and all of you conservative Boomers accept the idea that the government should "do something" about any given issue.

You know what--we'll get exactly what we deserve.

Hillary delenda est.

Oh, the dichotomy!
It is rare when I disagree with Dr. Sowell. But I’ve held a far right libertarian view of sports, drugs and caveat emptor since high school. Back then, sports figures were protected by the press and their foibles covered up. The hero figurine as societal statue was unblemished. And, we still found ways to “enhance” our performance with all manner of legal and illegal substances and strategies.

I certainly agree with all those posting here that sports leagues (professional or not) should be disallowed dispensation from anti-trust regulation.

Self destructive behavior is instructive only to those who are capable of learning from other people’s mistakes. That being the case, if an athlete crosses the finish line achieving a world record and collapses dead with their next step, bury them with the metal round their neck, then post their name along with the manner of death for the record.

Bobble heads are not worth much to many and Charles Barkley was right. He’s no hero.

Mark McGwire should be in the hall of fame.


It started with OJ
Feel free to comment if you believe I'm wrong, but I believe the birth of this current environment started with the OJ Simpson case. Never before had our entire country witnessed a murder case with such overwhelming evidence and non-stop media coverage....only to watch the murderer walk away. The common response was, “Yeah, he probably killed them, but one of the detectives used the ‘N’ word one time, so....”

...and then a few years later we get the famous Clinton line, “It depends on your definition of ‘is’”.

We’ve taught our current generation that “getting away with it” is actually a skill or ability that is to be respected and admired. How sad.

Drugs.
Is there really something out there that will let me hit a baseball whether it curves or comes at me at 90mph?

Is there really something that makes me feel good or better every morning I wake up?

I'm not worried about being in the Hall of Fame, I just want to feel better each day.

Just one last thing, will it help me make a 10 footer every time?



IMHO posters today seem to be....
...missing the point of the column!
--------------------------------------------------
To me, Dr. Sowell has pointed out the shift in our society from one which was responsible for its actions to one which is now an enabler of life without mores at any level (pretty extreme statement, but not off the radar). To that end we (as a society) MUST make a decision. Do we want to, by in-action, continue down this road exemplified by MLB (and most probably other professional sports -- note the pre-mature deaths among footballers and wrestlers); or, do we rise up and force, by action, the return to a lawful society (and by that I mean a society where one is held responsible for obeying ALL the rules -- whether (government) laws or league rules -- with no second chances before harsh punishment -- i.e. one strike and you are out for a few seasons).

Ultimately it is OUR choice – should we make a choice for enabling which will lead to total corruption of our law based society; or, shall we make the choice for a future?

I, for one, choose a future for my now adult children and their children! What about you?

TBC :>)

Greg
Where would you draw the line on your libertarian stance? You believe it’s all fair in love and war (and sports). If one athlete breaks the rules to beat the others, you say “good on him”. But what about in career or life matters? What if a coworker breaks the rules to get the promotion you don’t get....or an unscrupulous kid breaks the rules to get the college admission over your kid? It’s basically the same concept in sports.

JimP
"Righteousness, Integrity, Honor, man why are these not praised today."

Not only not praised, but laughed at as suitable only for fools and dupes and actively argued against as "imposing your morals on others." :-(

As though without them a society could be anything but a dysfunctional mess.

Money rules, not Cooperstown
I don't believe that keeping drugged players away from Cooperstown will be a deterrent at all. Money talks.

When Eric Gagné went to his first training camp with the Dodgers, he was driving a battered Pontiac Cutless. In the parking lot, his car was surrounded with Porshes and Mercedez. One of the Dodgers' players had just offered a Ferrari to one of his brothers.

To a guy like Gagné in the face of adversity, the choice was cruel: Either go back home selling shoes or take HGH, add 4-5 miles/h to his fastball and be the one who gets to offer Ferraris as birthday presents.

In all honnesty, which one would you choose?

A national disgrace.

If baseball does not clean up its act and hold these and other "juicers" acccountable...

... my hope is that fans STAY AWAY in droves.

I will.

Most of us have a strong sense of fair play, but if we fail to vote with our pocketbooks on this one... WE are as guilty as they are.

True home run king; Hammerin' Hank Aaron.

Record book; the decency of, at least, an asterisk.

Hall of Fame; NO juicers or cheaters allowed. Period

Nuff said.

benehogan
You, and many like you completely miss the point of "performance enhancing drugs". Yes you must first be able to hit a 90 mph fastball. But with the juice you can now hit a 90 mph fastball twice as far as you used to. The whole point of taking the drugs is to "enhance" an ability that you already have.
I personally believe that its time to yank the anti-trust rug out from under professional sports and make them play by the same union rules that all the rest of us have to.
And lets have a special corner in Cooperstown for reserved for everyone that is caught breaking the rules. Call it the Wall of Shame.

I'm with you, Black Cherokee! pt 1
We have indeed reached a point where the enabling of destructive behavior has been turned into a virtue while attempting to stop destructive behavior has been turned into the "vice" of "being judgmental".

Our kids are in the second generation of being taught to emote rather than to think and that sensitivity is more important than truth. Along with that, they are being taught self-esteem without need for accomplishment and, indeed, that actually performing at a high level is bad because it might make the less gifted or less dedicated feel bad.

Add in the petulant cynicism of academia with its continual "deconstruction" of all things heroic in their perpetually immature outrage that someone might have actually achieved things greater than they themselves could manage.

Add in the hedonistic desire to plug the ears and blind the eyes lest anyone realize the emptiness that is the long-term result of the pursuit of pleasure above all else.

And you get a society where prudence, wisdom, self-control, and obedience to legitimate authority are either so foreign to the world view as to be incomprehensible or are actively opposed because such things would spoil everyone's fun.

...

I'm with you, Black Cherokee! pt 2
...

As it happens, there is a new story today about an increase in suicide among the middle-aged. http://www.foxnews.com/story/0,2933,316809,00.html

What are the odds of anyone in the mainstream media giving an honest look at this possibility? Could these people committing suicide in middle age be those who have lived this life of no-rules hedonism and are now discovering that they:

Are diseased/physically damaged as the result of their lifestyle,
Are no longer in possession of the attractiveness of youth and thus unable to lure attractive companions,
Are alone without a family,
Are in financial trouble,
Have accomplished nothing lasting or worthwhile,
Are not having fun anymore despite having done what they were told would create happiness,
And unable to find hope because they have been taught to deny God -- the source of all hope.

:-(

Babe Ruth
A poster made a comment about throwing Ruth out because he would get drunk.He could not have been drunk while playing.It is simple to prove my point.Get drunk throw a ball in the air and try to catch it.

Icedog-JimP
IceDog - OJ and Bill Clinton, The Poster Boys for Birth Control!

JimP - You are preaching to The Choir.

Higher Education is no different
It works this way in college. I am on our school's Judicial Board, that hears cases of student misconduct that are not settled by the student at some point. We deal with cases of alleged cheating and give the professor and the student a chance to present their arguments. In our training session, we were presented with a variety of outcomes that one would like out of a case hearing. Here is the list:

1. Finding the truth
2. Providing a just result
3. Providing an educational process
4. Encouraging students' maturation and development
5. Making a safe community
6. Upholding the University's policies
7. Ensuring a fair process
8. Protecting the rights of the accused student
9. Protecting the University from liability
10. Punishing wrongdoing

So, out of these 10, we were each asked to choose the 3 that we thought were most important. (Mine were 1, 2 and 8 in case you are wondering.) The majority of people had, as their number one priority, #3: making this an educational process. Punishment and truth meant nothing -- their most important thing was to make sure the student learns from the experience so that hopefully they don't do it again. When are we as a society going to learn that people generally know what the rules are and know what is wrong, and when they choose to ignore the rules to further their own ends, they need to face appropriate punishment?

..and Greg
what of Pete?

Steroid use in Baseball
Dear Mr. Sowell:

The reaction from the media on Mitchell's steroid report has been fierce, waiting to nail every player to the wall. The fan reaction on the other hand has been ho hum, no big deal, just another day in professional sports. Most American's could care less about what professional athletes do anymore.

Personally I think they should go ahead and legalize steroids and have doctors doing the prescribing. They are still going to use steroids at least they can be used more safely if regulated by Medical professionals. Society uses drugs to cure every ailment known to man. We use drugs for sicknesses, pain, mental illness, to make us taller, to make us smarter etc., why not use drugs to make us faster and stronger as well. To most people there's not a licks worth of difference from one type of drug to another

By what stretch of the imagination
...has it become the Federal gummint's business whether professional athletes use performance-enhancing drugs?

Seems to me that this issue should be nowhere on Congress' list of things to worry about, what with us slowly being drawn into World War 3.


As usual there are some good comments...
fro the usual good-comment people.
But I could write a book on all the misinformation and misconceptions by some of you here.
Ruth was a draft dodger? How many Major League Baseball stars did you see in WW!?
Steroids doesn't make you hit a curveball better.
No, but the help someone who already has the talent to hit a baseball to hit it farther. Bonds doesn't have the highest batting average because of steroids, but he has hit the most home runs because of them.
Nolan Ryan was striking out batters with regularity long before steroids and probably before you were born. And it was well-known how well he kept himself in shape. If you knew anything about it, guys like Ryan and Koufax had tremendous back muscles that enabled them to throw so hard.
Neither Ruth, nor Ryan nor many others I could mention saw their physiques swell to such incredible porportionsat any time in the lifetimes.
Finally, it was proven that Joe Jackson never even DID any of the things he was accused of. In fact, he had the highest batting average of anyone in the Series, on either team.
So much for history and justice.

Sterioids in Baseball
Look, it's a game. Games consist of rules. You play by the rules or it's not a game.

Baseball has rules. One of the rules is you don't take any drugs. Take them, you break the rules. It's as simple as that.

They did it. They should be barred from the game.

If not, we shouldn't attend the game. What are you going to see? A bunch of cheaters beat the brains out of a bunch of real athletes.

You're going to PAY YOUR OWN MONEY for that?

HA-HA-HA-HA-HA!

Icedog, OJ, and Bonds
Icedog, you’re probably right about the origin of much of today’s attitudes towards athletes. I personally don't watch much professional sports, but I lost all interest in baseball with the strike.

Anyway, on Bonds: "If the needle didn’t penetrate, you must exonerate!"

The Truth on Steroids !
{As} A former "LEGAL "user of Steroids in MMA ..Mixed Marshal Arts at the national level .
it is and {UNQUESTIONED }advantage to use Steroids .
Case closed .
Your strength is 25-30% greater after 3-4 months
use .You grow hair in strange places .
Your 2 you know what's shrink a little .
Your muscle mass is greater and your fat count is far lower . Your Body weight goes up .
Just look at Bonds and 6 other pot. Hall of Fame stuffed shirts . We in the know can see it from a 100 yards away .
You have far more endurance and that makes for better cardio .
your down time's is shorter and your body temp and sex drive is huge .
You get anger quicker and it raises your blood pressure a lot .
That is why I quite before it killed me !
Any QUESTIONS ? I didn't think so .


Asterisk? NO, banishment
To truly punish the steroid offenders MLB should strike their entire careers from the history of MLB, and FORBID any MLB-sanctioned broadcast (tv or radio), publication, etc from ever mentioning the name of the offenders ANYWHERE, ANYTIME, under ANY CIRCUMSTANCES. That would be the ultimate "death penalty". When A-Rod approaches 714 any announcer who mentions Bonds by name, or refers to "him" by position, team, or "fake record" will be fined, same as if the Reds let Pete Rose sit in the dugout. It is not unlawful censorship if it is not the government doing the censoring.

Very Difficult Topic, Dr. Sowell
Athletes have always thrown everything they have into their sports. If steroid use is a problem, what about Cortisone? How many players continue a game after a hefty dose of cortisone on a broken or damaged limb to kill the pain? How fair or safe is that? Do we want our kids to idolize those that do?

The nature of sports is brutish. Trying to make it gentile only de-natures it, altogether.

I am more inclined to follow Mitchell's advice, both for the past and the future.

Shoeless Joe in, Rose&Bonds out
Shoeless Joe should be in the Hall, Rose & Bonds should not.

Too Late
recent polls are showing that the people don't care.
Even here at a conservative site, there is plenty of indication that there is no outrage.
So much so, that it becomes obvious that many people are now druggies themselves.
It's too late.
Thank God I am in the winter of my life. I wouldn't want to be a young man in this environment that we have created.


BTW character assassination is a terrible thing. I hope that Mitchell can prove each and every instance with something more than heresay.

And as far as that goes, for the record, Babe Ruth was not a draft dodger. In the early days of the war he was exempt because he was married. After they changed that exemption he enlisted in the US army reserves.
It's all covered in Brandon Toropov's book, The 50 Biggest Baseball Myths

Long time fan here!
I really like the well researched, no nonsense, common sense approach you take to your writing Mr. Sowell!!!

I am really saddened over the explosive use of steroids in sports. Between Marion Jones and baseball we've seen a lot of it lately.

And it's really a terrible situation.

Pro athletes retire rich and at an EXTREMELY young age. Many of them take advantage of the education that they got in college and start second careers.

So it really saddens me when I see people like Reggie White, along with many of those pro wrestlers, suddenly dying well before their time.

What good is it to make all that money if you're not going to be around long enough to enjoy it?

Life is meant to be lived, and I would rather take things more slowly... a step at a time... even if I'm not the greatest at something. That's much better than burning brightly for a few years and then fading into eternity.

But that's the beauty of our free speech environment. Even the athletes who claim they aren't role models ARE. They're out there, in front of everybody on television in the public eye.

They're either a GOOD role model or a BAD one.

What we need to teach our children is how to tell the difference.

I Don't See A Problem Here

Idiots, Morons, and Sports Fans will gnaw this bone to bits just like my buddy Groucho does with the monkey skulls I give him when he's a good boy.

I don't know who said, "Sports doesn't build character, it reveals it," but he nailed it down pretty well.

To those among you who live and breath sports and the statistics, you will asterix no matter what anyway. To those who consider sports to be a diversion, a source of exercise and entertainment (myself included here)we will play, watch, chuckle, rant, fume, and patiently wait for the proper peckers to fall off.

If I missed anybody here, email me at getafreakinglife@tempestinateapot.huh?

Selig
Selig should be fired.

Ignorance
Some apparently unknown facts:

1. MLB had no rule prohibiting the use of steroids or HGH during the period covered in the Mitchell report. So there are no "rule breakers". Get off your high horse.

2. There is no scientific data that shows steroids or HGH help you hit home runs. Most PEDs were used to help players recover from injury rather than to improve performance. That is why half the players named are pitchers, not hitters.

3. Pete Rose was ratted out on his gambling by Paul Janszen after Janszen was charged with- you guessed it- possession and distribution of steroids. Janszen was a daily visitor to the Reds clubhouse for nearly a three-year period in the late 80s, so I guess we can pretty confidently say the PED issue goes back a lot further than Bonds and Canseco. Should we throw out every guy voted into the Hall since 1990? They share the same guilt as Clemens and Bonds, which is to say they played in the era of suspected PED use. Kirby Puckett or Dave Winfield anybody? How about Ironman Cal Ripken? Now we know how he did it, right?

What a joke. This isn't about cheating as much as its about a lot of ill-informed and self-righteous people and the lazy media that beats the drum for them.


Do steroids really help?
With all of the current and former Baltimore Orioles among the alleged users, why is this team not winning more games?
Sign Up to Post Your CommentsSign Up to Post Your Comments
If you are already registered, click here to login. Otherwise, please take a few seconds to register with Townhall.com. Once you sign up, you’ll be able to post your comments immediately, use the action center, get podcasts, and more!
Note: Fields marked with a red asterisk (*) are required.
Salutation:
First Name:
*
Last Name:
*
Email:
*
Nickname:
*
Note: Nick name will be shown when you post comments.
Address 1:
*
Address 2:
City:
*
State:
*
Zip:
*
Phone:
      
Your daily must-read of conservative columns, cartoons and news. Coulter, Sowell, Krauthammer and more.
(Bi-Weekly) We highlight the best opportunities from our partners for surveys, action items and more.