Townhall.com, Where Your Opinion Counts
Talk Radio:   Bill Bennett   Mike Gallagher   Dennis Prager   Michael Medved   Hugh Hewitt   
BREAKING NEWS  LeftArrow - Townhall.com : Conservative, Political, Republican   RightArrow - Townhall.com : Conservative, Political, Republican  
Columns, funnies & more in your inbox!
  • Check the boxes and send us your email address to receveive your free newsletter
  • Your daily must-read of conservative columns, cartoons and news. Coulter, Sowell, Krauthammer and more.
  • Townhall.com’s weekly inside scoop on what’s happening behind the scenes in the world of politics. When news breaks, we report.
  • Signup to receive the latest daily Townhall cartoons
Tuesday, October 02, 2007
Thaddeus McCotter :: Townhall.com Columnist
S-CHIP and the Politics of Principle
by Thaddeus McCotter
Vote on It:
Average Vote:
[+] Text [-]
 
Poll
Will the Dems' health care Christmas Present to America be an improvement or detriment to our health care system?


Democrats and like-witted pundits claim the S-CHIP reauthorization is a defining issue which will seal the GOP's electoral fate next fall. Unscrupulously using children as props in a soulless script replete with ironic appeals to an apparently socialist Almighty, these Denizens of Governmental Dependence gleefully assert the "politics" of S-CHIP will mask their policy's fiscal irresponsibility and trump Republicans' foundational principles.

If this were the case, the Democrats and their Left-wing smear groups wouldn't be threatening to spend millions to intimidate Republicans into abandoning our core beliefs and over-riding a promised Presidential veto. We must and will resist; and, so doing, we will triumph.

First, the S-CHIP bill (H.R. 976) must be vetoed. This politically motivated bill advances a government run health care system by arbitrarily spending $35 billion over the next five years to expand a social program originally targeted at poor children to now include children and adults in families making over $100,000 a year and people who already possess private health care insurance. In consequence, over 2 million people will be crowded out of their existing private health insurance and ensnared in this social welfare program. Moreover, despite purporting otherwise, this bill ensures many of these new enrollees will also be illegal immigrants, who need only show a valid driver's license to join. (Remember: in some states, most recently New York, one need not prove citizenship to receive a driver's license).

Compounding these problems, the bill refuses to prioritize federal spending and, instead, imposes a regressive tax disproportionately impacting the poor. Even with the new tax hike, the new S-CHIP program is unsustainable beyond 2013 and, thus, is fiscally irresponsible. This insult to the taxpayers is exacerbated when one takes into account the Democrats' Budget Resolution's promise of massive personal tax increases, many of which will be slated to fund S-CHIP or worse in future years.

At its core, then, the S-CHIP debate provides the following stark contrasts between the two parties' guiding principles:

1. Republicans believe Americans are sovereign citizens. Democrats believe Americans are hapless victims.

2. Republicans believe the federal government must serve sovereign Americans. Democrats believe Americans must serve a sovereign federal government.

3. Republicans believe in reducing people's taxes. Democrats believe in raising people's taxes.

4. Republicans believe social programs exist to make poor people self-reliant. Democrats believe social programs exist to make all people state dependents.

5. Republicans want poor people to escape the welfare state. Democrats want all people inside the welfare state.

6. Republicans believe America needs a fiscally sound social safety net that temporarily helps poor people and respects taxpayers. Democrats believe America needs a big government trampoline that permanently traps poor people and impoverishes taxpayers.

7. Republicans believe a social program's success is measured by how many people have escaped from it. Democrats believe a social program's success is measured by how many people have been added to it.

8. Republicans believe government should not use taxpayers' money to unfairly compete against taxpaying businesses. Democrats believe government should use taxpayers' money to unfairly compete against taxpaying businesses.

9. Republicans believe in free enterprise and our citizenry. Democrats believe in the welfare state and its bureaucracy.

If our Republican Party is daunted by the politics of S-CHIP and shrinks from reaffirming its defining principles, social welfare programs will never help poor Americans escape governmental dependence. Instead, the Democrats will continue their push to shackle Americans with a bureaucrat-centered health care system and other insidious forms of governmental dependence; and our Republican Party – the party of the Great Emancipator – will not only lose the next election.

It will lose its soul.

Share:
Vote on It:
Average Vote:
 
About The Author

A life-long resident of southeast Michigan, U.S. Representative Thaddeus McCotter was first elected to Congress in 2002 to represent the citizens of Western Oakland and Western Wayne Counties.

Be the first to read Thaddeus McCotter’s column.
Sign up today and receive Townhall.com delivered each morning to your inbox.
Sign up today
Self-reliant and Self-respecting
Thaddeus McCotter has captured a classic principle of truth that Liberals are hoping to bury.

We measure the health of the body by the strength, resistance, the efficient an effective use of the attributes and resources that every cell in the body possesses. Cells may be keep alive and multiply many years beyond their usual life span, and so can some organs, where if we remove these the body dies.

The health of a family, consisting of a Mother and Father and their own children is no healthier that the some total of each family member. There is no progress without the ability to manage our own lives individually and collectively for the over all well being and of our children’s future families.

A family is where mature responsible parents nurture and prepare their children for their first steps in life. Here the loving respectful and considerate social/emotional environment of a spiritual nature helps children to be accountable to tame and train their appetites and passions, before they are able to determine responsibly their own future.

If we cannot master our own self, we will not very likely be able to serve others, to help them to master their personal self, because they are prisoners to their own appetites and passions, addicted to them.

Republican Principles promote self-reliance and inter dependence that prepare us for the future and promotes our freedom

Liberal Compromise promotes dependence and codependence a self-perpetuating state of bondage.

Socialism: ALWAYS "for the little ones!"
This SCHIP crappola is a no-lose proposition for the Democrats and their left-of-center blog pals. If vetoed, the SCHIP issue can be demagogue point as Republicans not helping our children. GASP! Of course expansion of government and increase in high paid bureaucracy is always posited as "for the children." Blot the tears and allow government power to grow. The reality is that this boost for welfare to the middle and upper middle class is unprecedented. If the Dems win this round, they institute a program that makes the middle class even more beholden to the Dems for basically all eternity. The other problem here the few have mentioned is that this action will tend to force middle and upper middle class parents to CANCEL their private insurance coverage for the little ones currently on the books. Just where the Dems want them.

As our government schools typically teach--from the time kids are just done crapping in their pants all the way to high school seniors' parents crapping at having to pay for college--the GOVERNMENT is what makes this nation great--not private initiative and private enterprise. We are to be beholden to government for safety, health, and other goodies from cradle to grave--forever.

Welcome to socialism--painfully slow legislated style.

Down below the border, and hitting below the belt in ever more fierce Marxian undertones, El Presedente for Life Hugo Chavez has now not only decided elections are not part of revolutionary socialism's needs, but that even private schools are to teach the party line of "Socialismo!"

Chavez, along with moonbat encounters like Defcon America, Media Matters, and the next Madame President, would be proud of the Democrats efforts here to mimic his compash on the kiddies. He argues on their behalf also, after all.

Socialism: ALWAYS "for the little ones!"
This SCHIP crappola is a no-lose proposition for the Democrats and their left-of-center blog pals. If vetoed, the SCHIP issue can be demagogue point as Republicans not helping our children. GASP! Of course expansion of government and increase in high paid bureaucracy is always posited as "for the children." Blot the tears and allow government power to grow. The reality is that this boost for welfare to the middle and upper middle class is unprecedented. If the Dems win this round, they institute a program that makes the middle class even more beholden to the Dems for basically all eternity. The other problem here the few have mentioned is that this action will tend to force middle and upper middle class parents to CANCEL their private insurance coverage for the little ones currently on the books. Just where the Dems want them.

As our government schools typically teach--from the time kids are just done crapping in their pants all the way to high school seniors' parents crapping at having to pay for college--the GOVERNMENT is what makes this nation great--not private initiative and private enterprise. We are to be beholden to government for safety, health, and other goodies from cradle to grave--forever.

Welcome to socialism--painfully slow legislated style.

Down below the border, and hitting below the belt in ever more fierce Marxian undertones, El Presedente for Life Hugo Chavez has now not only decided elections are not part of revolutionary socialism's needs, but that even private schools are to teach the party line of "Socialismo!"

Chavez, along with moonbat encounters like Defcon America, Media Matters, and the next Madame President, would be proud of the Democrats efforts here to mimic his compash on the kiddies. He argues on their behalf also, after all.

President Bush has hands over his ears.
Pres. Bush refuses to acknowledge that the American people demand a change from his administration. He has surrounded himself with his circle of friends so that he never hears the word "No".

Thankfully, we finally have a congress that is asking questions.

Jimmy D - why is anyone that disagrees with your political beliefs a "Traitorous Socialist Commie Pig"? You have so much hate.

Veto is a mistake
I'm a republican. I am appalled at the talk of veto [now done at this writing]. This is literally throwing the baby out with the bathwater, no pun intended. The arguments against the bill are specious and political. For a republican to say that benefiting those over 100k is a reason for not providing a benefit is a bit hard to take given our party's emphasis on the "well heeled". This is a MISTAKE. It is time we embrace the poor and disenfranchised as the party of Lincoln. That is not a "liberal" concept, it's a historical fact. Neocons have taken over from the true conservatives such as hatch and Gingrich. We're coming back and taking back the Reagan revolution. Remember Reagan, the Union president?

Keep digging your own graves, GOP!!!
Brain Dubya, who, according to that wise philosopher Psychobabe Coulter is mentally retarded, revealed himself to be another totally heartless GOP slug by vetoing any funding for S-chip. Yeah, we have all this money to waste every single day in a toilet called Iraq, but heaven forbid we should help American kids. Compassionate conservative? That is the biggest lie of all time!!!!

Keep digging your own graves, GOP! The Donkey will kick the Elephant in the tush next year big time!!!

Political Principles?
We are talking here about 7B per year to provide health insurance for poor children. Bush has recently requested a supplemental appropriation of 200B for this year to support a failed war in Iraq. Talk about hypocracy!!!

About the Quote by Alexander Tyler
This is an urban legend. It might sound good but there is no source for the comments.

Remember
Orrin Hatch, Republican from Utah, is a co-sponsor of SCHIP. Republicans can also abandon to Constitution. Both parties have abandoned the PEOPLE.

Jimmy D
Right on! And please remember that almost half of all American voters now pay no income taxes. When this number gets to about 60% the majority will be able to vote themsleves "goodies" that are aid for by the minority. When this happnes, the pace of "spend (on the majority) and tax (the minority)" will accelerate.

Of course, the minority will only put up with so much, which means that the system, by which I mean the nation, will grind to a halt.

Hypocrisy
The money being proposed to expand S-CHIP is dwarfed by the money Bush proposed for the prescription drug benefit for seniors, which was passed during his Administration with many Republicans in Congress voting FOR it.

http://tinyurl.com/2zquf6

That is costing taxpayers some TWENTY TIMES MORE than the S-CHIP expansion would.

Explain to me why the Bush prescription drug benefit for seniors was consistent with GOP principles.

And explain to me how a Republican Congressperson or Senator can vote for one and not for the other.

This guy is actually in government???
That's scary.

This tirade reads like a page from Ann Coulter.

One would hope that someone who's in the US House would have a better thought out position than "Democrats bad, Republicans good!".

Please sir, spare us your grandstanding. Don't you have anything better to defend your stance with than "Democrats are Communists"? That's so 1950's.

Bush's Unhealthy Veto
Sebastian Mallaby covered this in the WaPo yesterday

http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-dyn/content/article/2007/09/30/AR2007093001035.html

"President Bush has spent six-plus years not using his veto. In 2005, he became the first president since John Quincy Adams to complete a term in the White House without once standing up to Congress; he has since paused to interrupt this doormat act on only three occasions. But now his patience is exhausted, and he is spoiling for a fight. Congress has had the temerity to propose expanding health care for poor children.

Politically, this is crazy. The bill that Bush is poised to veto has bipartisan backing, and two-thirds of the public say they like it. But in policy terms the veto looks a little crazy, too. The bill would extend the State Children's Health Insurance Program, a successful initiative that Bush himself supports. A veto would be based on misleading statistics and an exaggerated faith in markets."

Quote by Alexander Tyler
His quote was in reference to the Fall of the Athenian Empire.

"A democracy cannot exist as a permanent form of government. It can only exist until the voters discover that they can vote themselves money from the public treasure. From that moment on the majority always votes for the candidates promising the most money from the public treasury, with the result that a democracy always collapses over loose fiscal policy followed by a dictatorship. The average age of the world's great civilizations has been two hundred years. These nations have progressed through the following sequence: from bondage to spiritual faith, from spiritual faith to great courage, from courage to liberty, from liberty to abundance, from abundance to selfishness, from selfishness to complacency from complacency to apathy, from apathy to dependency, from dependency back to bondage."

This is what the DEMONRATS are giving us. Vote Democrat and say GOODBYE AMERICA.

Funnyoldrepublicans & Author
To Funnyoldrepublicans: You are a Socialist and if you had any sense, which you don't, you will know the Socialism and Communism are not the utopian government that it promises. I bet you were proud of the Democratic Controlled house when they violate a vote on the floor this year and violated over 200 years of Honor and codes of ethics. The ones who are destroying America is the Socialist Demonrats who will bankrupt our economy and turn over our Sovereign rights to the U.N. and Illegals and who will weaken our Military and allow for the defeat of this Country in the future. I hope YOU get your just reward. I know your Children and Grandchildren, if you ever have any, will never know the Freedoms that our Past & Present generations have. I hope they hold you personally accountable and I really do hope you pay the price for your stupidity & Traitorous actions (voting for Democrats)and thoughts. Democrats in Office are America's Greatest threat to the U.S.A. and our Constitution & Bill of Rights.

To the Author - Stop sidestepping the issues. Call them for what they are. - Traitorous Socialist Commie Pigs who are by their own actions are destroying the foundation of America - ALL BASED UPON FACTS - not OPIONIONS.

The Real Reasons for Contributions
Funnyoldrepublican states, "Business leaders are wisely drifting away from the GOP because of the idiotic war in Iraq, the growing federal debt, and a nutty conservative social agenda."

I hate to interupt your celebration over the Democrats "guaranteed" victories in 2008, but I believe your above statement misses the most important reasons why the Democrats are taking away the lions share of contributions from business.

1. Big business likes big government and regulations -- they have the infrastructure to comply with regulations and the lobbyists to shape legislation in their favor. They like a cozy relationship between government and business.

2. Open Borders -- Big business likes an endless supply of cheap labor and they figure that Democrats are more likely than Republicans to keep the gravy train moving.

3. Picking a Winner -- Big Business is often fairly agnostic when it comes to politics and that is why they often contribute to both parties. The big money however, is likely to go the candidates they think have the best chance to win. Rightly or wrongly, business has figured that the Dems have the best chance of winning in 2008. One thing is for sure, you don't want to be a large business that hasn't "contributed" to Hillary when she takes the reigns of power -- she has been known to be rather power hungry and vindictive.

"Stark" Contrasts
Unfortunately Mr. McCotter's 9 point list is only what Republicans SHOULD believe. The reality is that way too many and especially way too many in positions of power do not believe in those principles. I believe that Republicans are basically the ones that gave birth to the whole S-Chip scheme in the first place -- should we be surprised that the Democrats want to now expand its scope and purpose? Let's also remember that there are no Republicans (at least that I know of) that are trying to ELIMINATE the whole S-Chip program and that many Republicans voted with the Democrats to expand the program.

Hey, I'm all for what Mr. McCotter is trying to convey, but let's not fool ourselves. Republicans are far from united on these issues. For Christ sake if George Bush is threatening to veto a piece of spending because it could bust the budget then you KNOW it must be something horrible. And yet way too many Republicans seem to think that expanding "free" healthcare is a great idea.

God forbid
people are allowed to live their lives free of gov't interference. Why can't folks see that this little S-Chip scheme for what it is. It has NOTHING to do with helping kids. It's got everything to do with control. Get 'em on the gov't pay roll early and you've got a better chance of keeping them there. the Repubs aren't much better when it comes to certain issues (national ID cards come to mind).

The Dems believe that they can run our lives better than we can. Be careful what you wish for.
Sign Up to Post Your CommentsSign Up to Post Your Comments
If you are already registered, click here to login. Otherwise, please take a few seconds to register with Townhall.com. Once you sign up, you’ll be able to post your comments immediately, use the action center, get podcasts, and more!
Note: Fields marked with a red asterisk (*) are required.
Salutation:
First Name:
*
Last Name:
*
Email:
*
Nickname:
*
Note: Nick name will be shown when you post comments.
Address 1:
*
Address 2:
City:
*
State:
*
Zip:
*
Phone:
      
Your daily must-read of conservative columns, cartoons and news. Coulter, Sowell, Krauthammer and more.
(Bi-Weekly) We highlight the best opportunities from our partners for surveys, action items and more.