Townhall.com, Where Your Opinion Counts
Talk Radio:   Bill Bennett   Mike Gallagher   Dennis Prager   Michael Medved   Hugh Hewitt   
BREAKING NEWS  LeftArrow - Townhall.com : Conservative, Political, Republican   RightArrow - Townhall.com : Conservative, Political, Republican  
Columns, funnies & more in your inbox!
  • Check the boxes and send us your email address to receveive your free newsletter
  • Your daily must-read of conservative columns, cartoons and news. Coulter, Sowell, Krauthammer and more.
  • Townhall.com’s weekly inside scoop on what’s happening behind the scenes in the world of politics. When news breaks, we report.
  • Signup to receive the latest daily Townhall cartoons
Monday, April 23, 2007
Suzanne Fields :: Townhall.com Columnist
When Stereotypes Stalk Tragedy
by Suzanne Fields
Vote on It:
Average Vote:
[+] Text [-]
 
Poll
Will the Dems' health care Christmas Present to America be an improvement or detriment to our health care system?


Please don't let him be Jewish.

Please don't let him be black.

Please don't let him be Chinese, Japanese or Korean. (Or even Pacific Islander.)

Such were the prayers of men and women across the nation who feared a backlash from stereotypes of a killer, especially a mass murderer of such evil as the shooter at Virginia Tech. When portraits of a villain fill the television screens, it's easy for good people to look to their comfortable prejudices for explanations. Blaming race, religion, ethnicity and culture seems more reasonable than accepting the randomness of one madman.

The Asian American Journalists' Association urged editors and reporters to "avoid using racial identifiers unless there is a compelling or germane reason" (and by urging restraint in the name of Asian journalists neatly identified the killer's ethnicity). The public naturally wants to learn everything it can about someone who commits such a heinous act. Reporters look for every angle to explain motive, raising questions about race along with questions of sociology and psychology. Cho Seung-Hui, age 23, had lived in the United States since he was 8, and had spent those first eight years in his native Seoul. That's simply a fact, and Koreans here and there are particularly sensitive about it.

An editorial in the Korea Herald, a Seoul newspaper, expressed shock and sadness over the murder of 32 students and called the young man "one rotten apple," but certainly not acting on behalf of Koreans or the Korean government. No one had suggested that he did, but the newspaper, perhaps typical, worries that "the shocking incident will taint the good image that the Korean community and the Korean nation have strived to build among Americans."

South Korean President Roh Moo-hyun expressed shock and sent two messages of condolence and consolation to Virginia Tech. Official representatives of the South Korean government said they would work to prevent a backlash and " minimize the impact on the South Korea-U.S. alliance further strengthened by the conclusion of a bilateral free trade deal."

Shallow generalizations always do harm, and there was nervous anticipation in Korean neighborhoods where families expected bigotry to surface. Asian bloggers feared sociologists would use the profile of the killer to describe the "fragile egos" of Asian men. Others fretted that glib comparisons would dredge up the image of Japanese kamikaze pilots of World War II, who used themselves as flying bombs targeted at American warships. Still others were concerned about a proliferation of condescending and patronizing stories about "good" Koreans.

The "multimedia package" Cho left behind played into the stereotype. He had watched the South Korean movie "Oldboy," with violent themes of obsession and revenge. Its protagonist was shown pointing a gun to his head, as Cho did in the video he made before his rampage. But Korean moviemakers have nothing to teach American moviemakers about sordid and gratuitous violence.

Nevertheless, the Rev. Peter Chin, the pastor of Open Door Presbyterian Church in Herndon, Va., five miles from the suburban town where Cho grew up, noted that hateful comments aimed at Koreans were posted on Facebook.com, a site popular with young people. Such websites also carried warnings against prejudice and sought communal solace.

The Europeans, addicted to anti-American venom, served up most of the early stereotypes, citing Western and gangster movies as if Cho were a runaway "ride 'em, shoot 'em" cowboy, or a remorseless Clyde without Bonnie. Some of the editorialists called Charlton Heston our national hero, and naturally linked him with George Bush and John Wayne, eager for a shootout.

Germany's Stuttgarter Zeitung described the killer as living in "a society in which weapons are idolized as emblems of freedom and manliness . . . a country where the masses cheer when aging actor Charlton Heston raises a musket in his shaky hand and bellows that nobody will ever be able to take his weapon from him unless they 'pry it from my dead, cold hands.'"

The European moralizers mostly exposed their ignorance of the real, as opposed to the celluloid, America. Virginia Tech is a gun-free campus, mandated by law. Since they brought it up, the Germans should be reminded that Hitler first deprived Germans of their arms and then of personal and civil liberties. Only later, the good ol' boys from Virginia and the West and a lot of points between, having been brought up to use and respect guns, had to ride to the rescue of Europe. Speaking of stereotypes.

Share:
Vote on It:
Average Vote:
 
About The Author

Suzanne Fields is a columnist with The Washington Times.

Be the first to read Suzanne Fields' column. Sign up today and receive Townhall.com delivered each morning to your inbox.

©Creators Syndicate
Yes
Occurrences like this afford endless opportunities for people to flout their ignorance and prejudices.


BrianR
Or flaunt them.

I would hope that any sane individual would understand that Cho was an individual, acting on his own, regardless of his ethnicity, gender, sexual preference, education, eye color, ad frickin' nauseum.

I expect to be disappointed in that hope.

I can't wait
until the first time a woman (god forbid) pulls a massacre like this. The stereotypes on Town Hall will be electrifying.

South Korean People
I've known many South Korean people and consider many of them among friends an acquaintances. They're, almost to a person, good honorable people, who I would be proud to have at my back. They should feel, no more than anyone else, a sense of shame and revulsion for this contemptible, evil, murderous, scum. Shame because we (collectively) brought up this monster and revulsion because of what the monster did.

All we can do for any South Korean who feels responsible for this is to extend the hand of friendship and understanding. If they, like a friend of mine, apologize for the actions of the monster we need to accept the apology. To not do so is to, in effect, say to them that it can't be apologized for and to leave a stain on their honor.

For once I am spouting multiculti platitudes, but this is just the way most traditional South Koreans see things.

expect nothing less
I expect nothing less than rampant indulgence in prejudices and stereotypes, especially from conservatives. Now we have all those conservatives saying that people with mental illnesses are all dangerous to society, and "somebody" should have locked Cho up, overlooking the fact no grounds for incarceration have yet been uncovered.

good article but...
... I do want to quibble with a few points.

< < and by urging restraint in the name of Asian journalists neatly identified the killer's ethnicity > >

Actually, it may have identified the killer's *racial* identity, not his ethnic identity, since the concern of Asian American journalists could have pointed to him being of Japanese, Korean, Chinese, Taiwanese, Vietnamese, Mongolian, Filipino, Singaporean, or even Indian or Pakistani descent. These are different ethnic groups but all (except for Indian and Pakistani) usually accepted as the same racial group.

< < Since they brought it up, the Germans should be reminded that Hitler first deprived Germans of their arms and then of personal and civil liberties. > >

The first part of that (about Hitler depriving Germans of their arms) is apparently not true.

http://www.straightdope.com/mailbag/mhitlergun.html

I first heard about the Hitler gun hoax on the Rush Limbaugh show a few years back, when he acknowledged he had erred in citing an apparently fictitious speech Hitler made about restricting guns.

Okay, but other than that, I liked this article. After the L.A. riots in 1991, many Korean Americans felt blindsided when their stores were looted and/or attacked, maybe even targeted, and they are worried now. But nothing like that will happen if good and reasoned arguments like this one are made clear.

I do want to point out that the South Korean president making his statement of regret was probably a wise move. After all, even though Seung Cho had lived in America most of his life, he was still a citizen of the Republic of Korea, of which President Roh is the head of state.

vocabulary
Brian R., 'flout' means 'to set aside or ignore'; 'flaunt' means 'to show off or bring attention to'.

As a Virginia resident, I have beheld no outcry whatever concerning Cho's race. For that matter, no responsible reporter has even intimated that his heritage was a factor in his crimes.

As a conservative, the facts of his mentally unstable acts and writings tell me that he should not have been released from the mental health facility in the first place. Being committed to a hospital environment for your own and others' safety is somewhat different from just being 'locked up' in a prison setting. They let him go. 50+ people suffered the consequences.

annoying
It annoyed me no end that while we were learning the news of the shooting that Fox News had feeds saying Asian and Korean students were fearing a backlash. How disgusting! How insulting! We are a victim and they are calling us racists. They are removing themselves from the group, and are not focused on the news and on the dead but on themselves. They are exhibiting a maneuver learned from cold calculating manipulative CAIR where every time Americans are gunned down, blown up, burned up, run over, and killed, CAIR jumps up and down and says American Muslims are worried about backlash. This removes the attention from the real victim and focuses it on imaginary future victim hood. I wrote Fox News at the time and said the feed should read English Majors every where are worried about backlash. How about eyeglass wearers are expecting backlash? How about brunettes are expecting backlash? There may one day be a backlash but it won't be based upon racial identity, it will be based on a group being such self involved narcissists that they angered people. People don't like going to funerals and having someone get up and speak and say "it's all about me, it's all about me, it's all about me." We don't like that twisted Christian group that shows up with their agenda to disrupt young military people's funerals and funerals of children killed by pedophiles. How's this for advice: "Shut up and mourn."

Bytheocean
Agreed. I, too, was disgusted at the news reports about Korean-Americans fearing a backlash. What a load of crap. To my knowledge, there is nothing in the Korean culture which would encourage such an atrocity. Now, the Muslim culture? Another story entirely. It absolutely burns me up when newscasters and interviewers play up "straw man" stories like this, or allow people they are interviewing to make obvious misstatements or tell outright lies. IMHO, it is incumbent upon the interviewer to challenge the lies, not just sit there with a slap-happy grin on his/her face swallowing the garbage.

past informs the present
Bytheocean, given the incidents that have happened to Asians in the past, I don't think the fear of backlash is imaginary.

Who, for example, would have thought that four white police officers being acquitted for beating Rodney King would lead to dozens of Korean businesses being looted and attacked?

Mourning the loss of these thirty-two innocents (as many Korean Americans have done as groups and as individuals) and expressing concern about a potential backlash are not mutually incompatible actions.

It depends on what you mean by mass..
AudiR10,

An Illinois babysitter was indicted last week for murder. She allegedly murdered a pregnant woman, cut out and killed the unborn child. Then she allegedly drowned the woman's three children in the bathtub where she dissected their mother. Is that mass murder? Or, must it be a white guy with a gun to be eligible for such recognition.

DeWayne Wickham in "USA Today" goes through a litany of concerns / complaints by Americans of Korean decent about alleged persecution that they received at the hands of their non-Asian fellow citizens.

In the ONLY example in which he mentions race, he states that a Korean dry cleaner in a white neighborhood saw his business drop off after the VT shooting. He seems to imply that stupid white folks are reacting more to this tragedy than anyone else. A poll question should be posed. Do Koreans feel more threatened walking through a predominantly white neighborhood a week after the VT shooting vs walking through a predominantly black neighborhood just about any day of the year?

I trust that Purplestater is using irony in his LA riot example. But maybe he's just unaware of the notorious, routine animosity that many people in the Black community have for Asians. Rodney King was just a catalyst for unleashing repressed hatred.

I applaud the South Korean people for their sense of shame at the shooter's heritage, even though they bear no collective guilt. Except for a few knuckleheads, I doubt there will be any serious backlash against Koreans. I hate to say it, but most Americans are too ignorant to discern the differences between the various Asian groups in our society anyway.

Yawn
I sincerely hope that the next time something terrible event such as the massacre at VT happens (and sooner or later it most assuredly will) that the pathetic, demented perpetrator is a well-educated, white, native-born, heterosexual, Christian male ... in other words, except for the delusions and hate, a carbon copy of myself. I'm tired of listening to self-appointed moral advisers lecturing me about blaming a group for the acts of an individual or whining about how they're being persecuted for something not their fault, even though such a thought had never entered my head. Instead, I'll be treated to every talking head proclaiming how this latest tragedy is simply the latest example of the hate and violence inherent in the white patriarchal American homophobic evangelical power structure. At least it'll be got for a couple of laughs.

not irony
alopekos teumesios wonders if I was using irony or if I was aware of the Korean-Black tensions that existed at the time of the L.A. riots, including what was seen as a Korean storeowner getting a free ride for killing a Black teen named Latasha Harlins.

Yes, I was well aware, but their existence does not undermine my point at all: underlying racial tensions do exist and they sometimes don't need a big spark for things to get lit up. Nor does that spark need to be rational or linear.

There is apparently no racial component to Cho's murderous rampage, and 99.99% of Americans realize that. But it is absolutely prudent for a visible minority to concerned about the irrational racialist reaction of the remaining 0.01%.

Irrational racialist reactions like that of the killer in Arizona who murdered a Sikh after 9/11. A Sikh, who is neither Arab nor Muslim, but whose turban and beard make him look like he could be -- to the less rational. Some nineteen people were killed in the aftermath of 9/11, and it's always more dangerous for a visible minority.

http://minnesota.publicradio.org/display/web/2007/04/03/sikhfilm/

unlikelihood
< < Do Koreans feel more threatened walking through a predominantly white neighborhood a week after the VT shooting vs walking through a predominantly black neighborhood just about any day of the year? > >

Who made this about White or Black? If there is a backlash (and I think that *if* there is, it would be very few and isolated incidents, since I have faith in the vast, vast, vast majority of Americans to see past race in this situation), it could be from Whites or Blacks, both of whom were among Cho's victims.

Look, I'm not saying that there *is* or *will be* a backlash, only that it is prudent to prepare for the possibility that there *could be*. And if there isn't, then that's absolutely wonderful.

Purple
You ask, "Who made this about White or Black?"

Answer is: you did. "After the L.A. riots in 1991, many Korean Americans felt blindsided when their stores were looted and/or attacked, maybe even targeted..."

Or have you forgotten that the rioters weren't a nicely diverse, multicultural rainbow parade?

You're right. Not black and white
Purple,

I didn't make it Black and White. I was commenting on how DeWayne Wickham's only mention of race in his column (USA Today 4/24) about potential backlash against Koreans was to cite one alleged case of white folks not patronizing an Asian dry cleaner after the VT massacre. His implication was pretty clear.

My point was that DeWayne is always quick to highlight racism or racial tension in other groups than his own.

Nazi Gun Laws - Not a Hoax
Purple,

Your own link states that German Jews were not allowed to own any firearms by 1938. They were the targeted minority (along with other select groups), in case you forgot. Gun ownership was restricted to "reliable" people like Nazi Party members.

The salient point is that gun laws infringe upon a citizen's to defend against armed attack. The firearm effectively levels the field between elderly homeowner and young home invader. It levels the field between tyrant and citizen. If Jews had the capability to spill Nazi blood after Kristallnacht to the same degree they did in the Warsaw ghetto, the death toll may have been much lower.
Sign Up to Post Your CommentsSign Up to Post Your Comments
If you are already registered, click here to login. Otherwise, please take a few seconds to register with Townhall.com. Once you sign up, you’ll be able to post your comments immediately, use the action center, get podcasts, and more!
Note: Fields marked with a red asterisk (*) are required.
Salutation:
First Name:
*
Last Name:
*
Email:
*
Nickname:
*
Note: Nick name will be shown when you post comments.
Address 1:
*
Address 2:
City:
*
State:
*
Zip:
*
Phone:
      
Your daily must-read of conservative columns, cartoons and news. Coulter, Sowell, Krauthammer and more.
(Bi-Weekly) We highlight the best opportunities from our partners for surveys, action items and more.