Townhall.com, Where Your Opinion Counts
Talk Radio:   Bill Bennett   Mike Gallagher   Dennis Prager   Michael Medved   Hugh Hewitt   
BREAKING NEWS  LeftArrow - Townhall.com : Conservative, Political, Republican   RightArrow - Townhall.com : Conservative, Political, Republican  
Columns, funnies & more in your inbox!
  • Check the boxes and send us your email address to receveive your free newsletter
  • Your daily must-read of conservative columns, cartoons and news. Coulter, Sowell, Krauthammer and more.
  • Townhall.com’s weekly inside scoop on what’s happening behind the scenes in the world of politics. When news breaks, we report.
  • Signup to receive the latest daily Townhall cartoons
Monday, April 21, 2008
Star Parker :: Townhall.com Columnist
A papal message about academic freedom
by Star Parker
Vote on It:
Average Vote:
[+] Text [-]
 
Poll
Was the Copenhagen Global Warming Summit Walk-Out a Win for the U.S.?


I became my own story last week when I got word that a large Catholic University in Minnesota, University of Saint Thomas, denied permission for me to speak there as part of my college speaking tour.

How could this be happening? A Catholic university, which has played host to talks from left wing Al Franken and a transgendered woman named Debra Davis, nixes a presentation on abortion from a conservative black woman?

Conservative blogs were soon aflame. Then stories in print. Plenty of flak started reaching the university and soon a representative was on the phone to put me back on their calendar.

I'm glad things worked out, regardless of why.

I've been speaking on university campuses for years. Over 150 of them. I know firsthand their left-leaning bent and what a conservative has to deal with walking into the belly of the liberal beast.

But this incident had a more bitter tinge than usual. This was a Catholic university and my topic was abortion.

Plus, the rejection came just as Pope Benedict XVI, who has called abortion "today's greatest injustice," was scheduled to arrive in the United States for his "teaching" visit.

How could I not feel irony when, shortly after receiving the call to reschedule my presentation, a few miles from me, at Catholic University in Washington, D.C,. the Pope was talking about the importance of Catholic universities aligning themselves with church doctrine?

Pope Benedict XVI has talked about the "dictatorship of relativism." This accurately captures what we're dealing with on our campuses.

The Randolph Foundation funded a survey a few years ago of university professors' political leanings. The work was done by professors from George Mason University, Smith College, and the University of Toronto.

Seventy two percent of American university professors identified themselves as liberals and 15 percent conservative. Fifty percent self-identified as Democrats and 11 percent Republican.

In a recent column, Michael Barone of US News & World Report, analyzing Democratic primary voting patterns, noted that Barack Obama's support has been particularly strong in university towns.

And, not surprisingly, our youth is becoming ever more firmly planted on the left. According to the Pew Research Center, 58 percent of 17-29 year olds call themselves liberals and 76 percent identify as Democrats.

Recent Gallup polling shows that in a match-up between Barack Obama and John McCain, Obama wins by 20 points among 18-29 years olds.

Young people are naturally inclined to be open, to experiment, to try anything once.

But there is a world of difference in openness in the pursuit of truth and openness in a world in which there is no truth.

The Pope, in his remarks at Catholic University, noted his appreciation for the importance of academic freedom. However, he points out that there is no inconsistency between faith and academic freedom.

Key here is his observation that "in a world without truth, freedom loses its foundation."

Too often what we now call academic freedom is in fact the politicization of our campuses. Openness with no truth becomes politics and the exercise of power. What, or who, becomes the arbiter of what is wisdom?

Not surprisingly, the Randolph Foundation study found that where truth is the most subtle professors are most consistently on the left. Eighty-one percent of humanities professors identify themselves as liberal and 75 percent of those in social sciences do.

To state the obvious, our youth is our future. There are 42 million Americans in the 18-29 age bracket. Many will move from the left as the experience of life gives them the dose of truth that they are not getting in their formal education. But how many and at what cost?

Have abortion, divorce, and sexually transmitted diseases become our primary educational tools for learning about the sanctity of life, of family, and the meaning of love?

As stated by the wise Pope who now graces us with his visit and teaching, our materialism leads us "to lose sight of our dependence on others as well as the responsibilities we bear towards them."

And that "freedom is not only a gift but also a summons to personal responsibility."

Share:
Vote on It:
Average Vote:
 
About The Author
Star Parker is the founder and president of CURE, the Coalition for Urban Renewal & Education, a 501c3 think tank which explores and promotes market based public policy to fight poverty, as well as author of White Ghetto: How Middle Class America Reflects Inner City Decay.
 
TOWNHALL DAILY: Sign up today and receive Townhall.com daily lineup delivered each morning to your inbox.
Excellent Article.
What is the sense of a catholic college, if it isn't catholic. Then again, the same can be said of our government and it's relationship to the founding documents.

Maybe the saying of "As the Church goes, so goes the world." is correct.

I'm glad things worked out too Star....
It's nice to see that freedom of speech still does exist in America.

I get so tired of the proverbial double standard.

Great article as usual--
With all the liberalism I see in the college town that we live in, where my wife and I did our graduate work, I see unabashed liberalism.

There is no way that we will ever give any money or time to this school that at one time went for quality instead of quantity. This is our opinion upon observation.. We are afraid, as your article suggests, that liberalism is in full bloom on most college campuses.

Yes, unfortunately, our taxes help fund this state university..@#$@%^&*. My feelings exactly.

The polls of Youth
Have these polls been taken periodically of youth, and follow them as they age?

I've read somewhere that, yes, many graduates of liberal universities are liberal, not surprisingly. But most of them hit the "real world" and gradually embrace conservatism.

It's like that old saw: a conservative is a liberal who's been mugged.

Just wondering if there's any studies out on that topic, vs. just polling youths.

Thanks Pope
Thanks Pope for diagnosing all our ills…

So nice of you to prescribe a good dose of muscle-relaxant so nobody can get up and fight all our ills...

Just what we all so badly needed more love is all you need big lies...

Oh but this is a special kind of love is all you need…

Wake me up when there is another Pope who expects us to whip some hides...

Maybe if they appoint a Pope younger than eighty…

Just saying…

From a distance…

chas
From a distance…

That's the most revealing part of your comments.

From a great distance indeed.

Expelled...
Along the same line, let's make Ben Stein's movied Expelled a big hit. His documentary reveals the persecution of professors who now dare express the thought that there may be something to be said for Intelligent Design, or express doubt in the Darwin Theory.

Youth
Freedom to ignore other views = liberalism. "Stupid is as stupid does," Forrest Gump.

The value of speaking out
Conservatives need to keep on top of this kind of thing and remember that, just like Russian taxi drivers and Intourist, when you stand up and snarl at them, they back down.

As for Chas, perhaps you would be happy with the Rev. Jerimiah Wright -- but I will pray that the distance will be shortened between you and God so that you will not feel so prone to substitute violence for prayer.

Behind ivy-covered walls.

Thank you, Star... again, for another expose into the absolute fraud they call academic freedom.

This should be shouted from the roof tops.

But I wonder, how many parents are listening...?


Star
You misunderstood them, they just made a scheduling mistake.After all these are libs,and they believe in free speech.That is as long as it is leftist and wierdo speech

my two cents
Ms. Parker - glad to hear the good news.

I am a practicing Catholic, I love my German Shepherd and I am proud of him and I think he told a lot of people what they NEEDED to be told, in his quiet way. There are a lot of CINO universities these days, foremost among them Notre Dame but there is hope and we will come back from this.


Has any liberal explained ...
...that if morality is relative, why we should accept theirs?

And if it is relative, what is it relative to?

Recommended reading
ANYTHING by George Weigel

Mr. Blue

one more and I'm outa here
Be Not Afraid

And in Soviet Canuckistan
Local Catholic Church (and School Boards) have bought the lefty-PC message hook, line and stinker. On a 1995 visit to Calgary, I saw that the Catholic board had decided to allow "non-religious education option" (FYI, such already was in existence--through the PUBLIC School Board).

If this was the situation in somewhat-more-conservative Alberta, i shudder to even think of the rather irrecoverable Ontario!

Evolution of liberal education
A truly liberal education shouldn't equate to liberal politics. Liberal suggesting that all views are taken into consideration. Ironically, what is being called liberal education today isn't liberal at all, but rather a limited, narrow and distorted view of the world and it's issues.

Many years ago, when I graduated from a liberal arts Catholic college we were exposed to all sides of issues and were taught the fundamentals of evaluating arguments and reaching our own conclusions. Required courses included logic, epistomology, philosophy and religion (religion classes included comparative theology of the worlds major religions).

I dare say Star would have been well received and probably standing room only in the good old days of a truly liberal college.

God bless and keep Star Parker
My e-mail to Ms. Parker:

Thank you for your courage in addressing the hatred and evil awaiting you at the colleges and universities at which you speak.

As a Catholic, I am appalled at St. Thomas' first refusal to have you as a speaker.

I hope that the Pope's frank talk to Catholic university presidents will remind them that they can lose their "Catholic" designation. What a sorry state we are in when we have reached this nadir.

May your talk reach some receptive ears. God bless and keep you.

Truly a breath of fresh air...
is Star Parker. Your columns are excellent, Star. I like to think of you as a "Shining Star"!

Parents, beware of where you send your precious children for their higher education. Why would you sacrifice so much of your hard earned money to send your children to a liberal cesspool?
Wake up, parents! Wake up!!!!

A college or university is a place where one pays good money (big Money) to learn "things". Pick a place of higher learning that will teach you children a moral and valuable way of life. And I mean true, God-ly objective morality not the oxymoronic "liberal morality".

"What GOOD is it to gain the whole world but suffer the loss of your immortal soul"?

NO FREEDOM IN ACADEMIA

.....Ask David Horowitz, Ann Coulter, or any other Conservative who tries to speak on College Campi ...

.....He who controls today's schools ...controls tomorrow's Government .....COLOSSUS

I warned my daughter
when she went off to college that she would be exposed to some pretty stupid perspectives, but to keep an open mind and evaluate each "fact" and opinion before reaching her own conclusions and to put whatever she needed to on the paper to get an "A". From my point of view the professors are not instructors or teachers, they are wanna-be indoctrinators which makes them less than honest. So if my kiddo has to prevaricate somewhat on her papers, so be it.
She seems to be doing well in that area.
Plus there's the fact that I told her she couldn't come home a socialist. LOL

Franken isn't on the "left wing"
It's always amusing to read self-congratulatory posts from extremist who've taken themselves way too seriously.

They've found THE TRUTH. They've outgrown the silly l i b e r a l impulses that afflict lots of misguided young people before they ultimately wisen up with age and "real-world experience".

How wonderful to be so certain every position they take is absolutely, unquestionably right...inspired by god, probably...and any opposing position is indisputably wrong...and maybe treasonous as well.

That said, St. Thomas withdrew Star's invitation initially because it feared she would violate the university's insistence that campus discourse be civil. You know, as in "civil discourse"?

It had less than nothing to do with runaway campus liberalism as Star dishonestly implies in her column.

Ann Coulter violated St. Thomas' civility rule when she brought her flamethrower act to campus. St. Thomas folks, virulently opposed to abortion to a person, feared Parker might do the same.

It's also possible St. Thomas officials caught Star's act on Bill Maher's show recently and decided she wasn't intellectually weighty enough to merit podium time?

Maybe they figured St. Thomas' student body already knew by rote the case against abortion and Star had nothing particularly new or interesting to say.

The times I've seen Star deliver R talking points in her bubbly, sing-song, Valley girl persona, I couldn't help but wonder if that's who she really is or if she's yet another a media opportunist ala Coulter, Michelle Malkin and Dennis Miller...pandering to a lucrative right-wing target audience.

Finally, Al Franken is closer to the center of the progressive spectrum than the left wing. Much closer.










I'm not the only one!
That can make the connection between the Holy Father's visit and remarks, and Ben Stein's movie.

Silencing dissent of the Liberal agenda is still infringing upon freedom. Mine, yours, everyones.

Turning away from Catholic teaching is even worse. It is a dis-service to the Catholic communities that support the schools, and imperils the immortal souls of the students.

Ben Stein is using the vehicle of a movie on the subject of "Darwinism," and recounts all the crimes against humanity done under the "guide" of scientific research. He then compares it to Intelligent Design that makes no stand on the "whom" but acknowledges that life is infinitely more complex and interconnected.

One way "embraces life" the other "law of the jungle" and I thought we were past the point of being savages.

Of course Darwinism's influences would explain why many schools are worse than any scene from "Lord of the Flies" written BTW to combat that portion of "Darwinism" that implies NO discipline and laws ARE needed. Religion has an important place too.

It (all brands, types, sects) tends to give a frame work for an orderly society and relations between people and between the Creator and people.

We are to care for each other, and provide for the fragile, infant and aged. Not "cull the herd" or "allow only the best specimens to procreate."

Civil discourse
I have read nothing by Star Parker that has not been civil. I didn't see her on TV as cited above. Could someone cite when she has not been civil?
The leftist protesters who shout down or throw things at conservative speakers are surely not civil. Personal attacks usually substitute for valid ideas and are a dead giveaway.
Donald W. Bales

Hope all works out for you.
After reading the story and all the posts that are above this one, I was surprised to see so many that took exception to what the Catholic University did. Maybe they did not have the money to pay for your time, maybe. Maybe one or two men did not want you on their campus. You will never know the truth and that is how it is in the New World Order of things. “New World Order” was the words used by George Bush Sr. and the Arabian Gulf War and nothing in America has been the same afterwards. Look what has happened in our Collages and Universities and even our schools from 1990 – 1991 time frame till now. What are people thinking? Looks to me that people no longer care about people, just themselves. You know, it is not personal but the only ones I have to answer to is my wife and children, other than that it is just business and I will do what I want. Is it at all possible that this is how Liberals now want to be in lifa and do business, destroying what is morally right? It took the Popes way of thinking to change someone’s mind, maybe. If this is now the accepted way about everything, folks you are correct, it is just wrong thinking. You took a stand and I hope all works out for you.

Star Parker & Libs
Ms. Parker I want to thank you for another great column & wish you the best as you enter the lion's den on St. Thomas campus. Perry White, you are an absolute idiot! I don't know what planet you live on, but last time I checked Al Franken was not only far-left, but also the most unfunny comedian I've ever witnessed. Come back to earth buddy. You're REALLY out there! Libs wouldn't grasp truth if you beat them over the head with it.

Good for you, Star ...
The first I ever heard about Ms. Parker is when she made the decision to not accept Welfare. She, instead, found two other roommates with different work shifts so that one adult was always home with the children, and each of these women then worked toward goals and good jobs so they could improve their outlooks for the future, both for themselves and their children. Then Star appeared on Oprah's show where she was roundly criticized for encouraging women to get off Welfare and use their minds to further their education, etc. And, look at Star today. She made it. Proof that in America, if you become educated, work hard and prove yourself, you CAN make it. Oprah believes in giving a handout, more than a hand up, in my opinion.

Perry White writes
"Al Franken is closer to the center of the progressive spectrum than the left wing."

That is absolutely correct. The left wing is only the left wing. the Progressives are now Marxist Socialists.

Your point lacked a point
Ken writes: Perry White, you are an absolute idiot! I don't know what planet you live on, but last time I checked Al Franken was not only far-left, but also the most unfunny comedian I've ever witnessed. Come back to earth buddy. You're REALLY out there! Libs wouldn't grasp truth if you beat them over the head with it.

PW: Ken, does this pass for cogent argument on your debating team?

sedonaman
You will have trouble finding many liberals to explain why if morality is relative, what is it relative to. After all most actual liberals are not moral relativists. And the liberal straw man that one finds in conservative arguments is not in a position to answer questions.

not clear
It is not clear what Parker is actually arguing for. Sometimes she seems to be offended by the idea that some viewpoints are not getting an equal hearing. At other points she seems to be decrying the fact that her viewpoint is not getting a special pride of place in some places. So is her view that there should be an open exchange of ideas, or is it that her view should be specially advantaged at Catholic schools?

I can see the reasons for thinking that a university should stand for truth, and that therefore some arguments are too stupid to meet that standard. After all, whatever ones view of abortion it should be pretty obvious that it is not the same kind of thing as genocide. After all there is no attempt to force abortions on anyone, and no group that is in danger of being irradicated by the legality of abortion. So is her view that Universities should be able to forbid speakers who argue for such inanities or that they shouldn't. (I know she would use a different example of an inanity but that is not relevant to the principle here).

Lon
--Lon: After all there is no attempt to force abortions on anyone, and no group that is in danger of being irradicated by the legality of abortion.--

Abortion is forced on every single innocent baby whose life is prematurely snuffed out. Whatever the law may say with respect to their `personhood`, they are nevertheless irrefutably biologically human -- our most vulnerable brothers and sisters. The callous way that Lon and other pro-choicers entirely disregard this slaughter of innocents, as if there were not always the death of a biological human with every abortion, is itself, inhuman.

WHAT IS THIS WOMAN TALKING ABOUT
I maintain a great respect for anyone who rises above a depressing circumstance...

That said, I'm really not quite sure what Ms. Star's point was. I don't recall reading about any uproar or blogs being aflame regarding her speaking engagement at Saint Thomas.

What is perhaps most apparent about the article is the tone of self importance, that sense of being piled upon, when one doesn't get there way. Further, Star grossly failed to provide any information regarding her conversation with the University and, most important, if she simply needed to just reschedule her appearance. Instead, the article spoke of being "Rejected", entering "The Belly of the Beast", "Left-Leaning Bent", all of the usual accusations without s single explanation as to what actually occurred. The article seemed more of an attempt to cry "Poor Misunderstood & Denied Conservative" than what was revealed by the scant facts provided... A Calendar Shuffle.

Conservatives are to oft greeted in uncivil terms by many, but this is not one of those times... at least evidenced by what Ms Star has provided.

Although an author, by any technical measure, Ms. Star's ability to effectively communicate is poor... Were she not a Black Woman who "Pulled herself up by her bootstraps" we wouldn't be reading this tripe... Were she Denise Smith, with three children and a past Cocaine addiction, she would be of little interest.


What I Learned This Week (http://whatilearnedthisweek.wordpress.com/)

Papal Message
Why on earth would you think the students of a Catholic University would want to hear a discussion on Abortion. And from someone that constantly tells them they are librals, non christians and more.
As a Roman Catholic, I knew very early in life about the responsiblity of bringing children into the world. I also was taught to think for myself and seek God's wisdom.
The problem with abortion foes, is that the majority of those against it practice either safe sex, have financial means to support large families or live off the government.
While most of the ones that support a womens right to abortion are White, non Catholics have small families, are socially well off and feel they need to help the poor and under priveledge.
So what else are you going to say, nothing.
Let Roe Vs Wade be and lets talk about the lack of jobs for the under educated and older workers.

Butcher
Nice name especially when talking about killing babies. In the Catholic High School I attended we were shown actual film footage of an abortion and therefor we all knew what an abortion was. "So what else are you going to say" I think I'll say "It's murder" and "Thou shalt not kill" I'm surprised that in seeking God's wisdom you didn't find it.

Abortion and genocide
Lon above stated,

"After all there is no attempt to force abortions on anyone..."

As the next poster, Bob Doyle, stated so clearly, "Abortion is forced on every single innocent baby whose life is prematurely snuffed out."

Lon goes on, "...and no group that is in danger of being irradicated by the legality of abortion."

Black women have abortions at more than twice the rate of their percentage of the population.

Do you think it is a cooincidence that the great majority of Planned Parenthood's abotion mills are located in poor inner city neighborhoods where blacks make up a large portion of the population?

Margaret Sanger was the founder of Planned Parenthood. Here's what she had to say about blacks:

"We do not want word to go out that we want to exterminate the Negro population," she said, "if it ever occurs to any of their more rebellious members." Woman's Body, Woman's Right: A Social History of Birth Control in America, by Linda Gordon"

Google "Margaret Sanger Planned Parenthood"

Please pray to God to soften the hearts of the pro-abortion people, and put an end to the scourge of abortion.




To Bigfootbob
If you have not already done so, I urge you to read George Grant's biography of Sanger the She-Snake, titled "Killer Angel." It confirms what you say about Sanger wanting to use abortion as a weapon of long-term genocide.
Sign Up to Post Your CommentsSign Up to Post Your Comments
If you are already registered, click here to login. Otherwise, please take a few seconds to register with Townhall.com. Once you sign up, you’ll be able to post your comments immediately, use the action center, get podcasts, and more!
Note: Fields marked with a red asterisk (*) are required.
Salutation:
First Name:
*
Last Name:
*
Email:
*
Nickname:
*
Note: Nick name will be shown when you post comments.
Address 1:
*
Address 2:
City:
*
State:
*
Zip:
*
Phone:
      
Your daily must-read of conservative columns, cartoons and news. Coulter, Sowell, Krauthammer and more.
(Bi-Weekly) We highlight the best opportunities from our partners for surveys, action items and more.