Townhall.com, Where Your Opinion Counts
Talk Radio:   Bill Bennett   Mike Gallagher   Dennis Prager   Michael Medved   Hugh Hewitt   
BREAKING NEWS  LeftArrow - Townhall.com : Conservative, Political, Republican   RightArrow - Townhall.com : Conservative, Political, Republican  
Columns, funnies & more in your inbox!
  • Check the boxes and send us your email address to receveive your free newsletter
  • Your daily must-read of conservative columns, cartoons and news. Coulter, Sowell, Krauthammer and more.
  • Townhall.com’s weekly inside scoop on what’s happening behind the scenes in the world of politics. When news breaks, we report.
  • Signup to receive the latest daily Townhall cartoons
Sunday, March 02, 2008
Salena Zito :: Townhall.com Columnist
Born Fighting
by Salena Zito
Vote on It:
Average Vote:
[+] Text [-]
 
Poll
Will the Dems' health care Christmas Present to America be an improvement or detriment to our health care system?


What do Hillary Clinton, Mike Huckabee, John McCain and Barack Obama have in common, besides wanting to be the next commander in chief?

They are all of Scots-Irish descent, an ethnic and cultural lineage that has produced more presidents and military leaders than any other.

“Fascinating, but not surprising,” says U.S. Sen. Jim Webb, D-Va. The former naval secretary and decorated Marine should know: He catalogued the migration and cultural influence of the Scots-Irish in America in his book “Born Fighting.”

They have “always had the tradition of being in leadership positions, whether it is the military or in politics,” Webb says. In fact, 17 of America’s 43 presidents are confirmed Scots-Irish.

They also comprise the largest swing-voting bloc in the country; you cannot win a presidential election without them. In a 2004 newspaper column, Webb suggested that by ignoring Scots-Irish voters in places such as West Virginia and Tennessee, Al Gore probably lost the 2000 presidential election.

“Senator Webb, a heroic, literary figure himself, is correct,” says GOP political strategist John Weaver, who never ignores the Scots-Irish voter.

Weaver is a rarity, however; a call to more than a half-dozen academic political specialists and pollsters found none who recognized the Scots-Irish impact on elections.

That lack of knowledge is a social and political curiosity. How can there be such scant understanding of a 30 million-strong ethnic group that has produced so many leaders and swung most elections?

Perhaps because political academics and pollsters parse the Scottish half off with the WASP vote and define the Irish-Catholic half as blue-collar Democrats. They are neither.

So, who are these mystery leaders and influential voters?

Dr. Joyce Alexander, secretary of the national Scotch-Irish Society in Philadelphia, traces their roots to a mass migration from northern Ireland in the 1700s.

The “Ulster Scots,” who had been tossed to Ireland two centuries earlier, grew tired of fighting England’s battle against Irish Catholics, so they left. A group of their clans settled in New Hampshire, then spread to Maine and Vermont.

“Eventually, most of them settled south of New England,” Alexander explains, “from the center and bottom of Pennsylvania down to the tips of Alabama and Georgia,” a region better known as Appalachia.

In time, they became the dominant culture for most of the Midwest and the South.

Much of our democracy’s values emanates from the Scottish Kirk, a philosophy that embraced a bottom-up populist form of governing made up of councils of peer groups.

“Scots-Irish never accept the fact that their leaders are superior to them in any way, in terms of their human qualities,” Webb says. Instead, they measure their leaders by their own code of honor, loyalty and sometimes in-your-face leadership.

The states with the largest populations of Scots-Irish -- Alabama, Arkansas, both Carolinas, parts of California, Colorado, northern Florida, Georgia, Indiana, Illinois, Kansas, Kentucky, northern Louisiana, Mississippi, Missouri, New Hampshire, southern Ohio, Oklahoma, Pennsylvania, Tennessee, Virginia, West Virginia -- are a veritable list of what a candidate must carry in order to become president.

They also are the bulk of “red states” that Democrat Obama (Scots-Irish on his mother’s side) has carried in primaries and caucuses.

In modern politics, Republicans have done a better job of courting the Scots-Irish. With their traditional family ties, individualism, proud military service and disdain for too much government, the Scots-Irish have swung right ever since the civil-rights era.

Democrats began losing the Scots-Irish vote when they shifted to courting the black vote. That shift ended the Democrats’ hold on the South, where many Scots-Irish lived.

As a voting bloc, the Scots-Irish respond passionately to five things: the right to bear arms, the preservation of family, a love of country, a respect for life and success in war.

As leaders, they often deliver a populist message with a take-no-prisoners swagger. The best examples in presidential history are Andrew Jackson, Teddy Roosevelt, Ronald Reagan and Bill Clinton.

According to Webb, America’s “populist notion of a culture that demands strong leaders makes it a natural breeding ground” for leaders in the Scots-Irish tradition.

So it makes sense to him that all four of today’s candidates descend from “Born Fighting” clans.

Webb, a one-time Republican who switched sides in 2006 to run for the Senate, is on just about everyone’s shortlist for vice president.

And, yes, he too is Scots-Irish.

Share:
Vote on It:
Average Vote:
 
About The Author
Salena Zito is a political analyst, reporter and columnist.
 
TOWNHALL DAILY: Sign up today and receive Townhall.com daily lineup delivered each morning to your inbox.
Praise for a traitor
James Webb WAS a Marine, and served in Reagan's cabinet.
He couldn't make it on his own, so he sold his priciples, his honor, and ethics to gain an elected office.
A mob similiar to the Cosa Nostra, the Capone mob, or the ruling party of Russia---The Democrats--put him in office.

My measure is the like husband who cheats on his wife with a misress,"If he will do it to her (cheat, betray), he will do it to you".

Yes, Webb has a title and an office. But that is all.

Trappings of power, not responsibility
"What do Hillary Clinton, Mike Huckabee, John McCain and Barack Obama have in common, besides wanting to be the next commander in chief?"

Uh, I don't think any of them really want to be commander-in-chief---the one who makes tough decisions on behalf of our nation. What I see is four people who badly want the trappings of power-but not the responsibility that goes with them.

Being Scots-Irish,
and having read his book, I used to like Jim Webb a lot. I still can't resolve myself to his inexplicably going to the other camp. It makes me wonder about his agenda.

Having said that, it's only fair to point out that (with the exception of Iraq policy) he doesn't vote in lockstep with the liberal wing of his party.

Another Myth
I have some of the Scot-Irish in me also but is a minor piece of my DNA. I was not born fighting. It is utterly amazing the weird thoughts that writers put into words. Did you ever think that one of the common strings among those four is that they have hair? Now refute, renounce, or reject that. Another common streak it that they all want to make my life better and they are the one to do it. Going to Washington - to build a better life for all Americans. Destroying it is more real. Clinton and Obama want a total give-away, the state will take care of you, it takes a village, etc. McCain wants a virtual border, one that disappears when you try to touch it or see it, and more "free" trade. Huckleberry, wants to re-born us which, I guess, is sorta like "compassionate conservatism."

Jim Webb is fine with me.
The fact Jim Webb abandoned the GOP is a mark of distinction to me.

I applaud him for it.

"Courageous" and "rational" are two terms I would use to describe him.

Having said that, the other part of the equation troubles me.

Leaving the GOP, with its infestation of big-government, compassionate conservative, neocon vermin is eminently logical....but embracing the Democrat Party is NOT.

Democrat Party has been hijacked by socialist-lite politicians.

If Ron Paul were not such a doofus, and our nation had a real independent who believed in small government that still provided for those with permanent handicaps, a strong defense, a rational foreign policy not beholden to a reckless neocon philosophy, that person could probably start a movement that would replace the wheezing, dysfunctional, in-bed-with-special-interests, democrat AND republican parties.

On Scot-Irish population, that group is not deemed to be a "victim class", and it has far too many Caucasian males to suit the sensibilities of those who decide which groups are "worthy" of admiration.

Hard work and accomplishments do not enter into those decisions.

A Hero ???
I will take nothing away from Mr. Webbs military service but myself and many others served our country in wartime as well as Mr Webb, and John Mc Cain, and War Hero is not automatically bestowed and attached to our names. I just wonder why every politician who served one day in the military becomes automatically a War Hero ???

Scots-Irish?
How politically correct. You mean Rednecks and Crackers. This country would have been better off if the Redneck riff-raff had never been allowed into the country. The Redneck-Crackers and the Irish were a nasty lot, it took a century to civilize the savages once they arrived on these shores. The South did not and does not lag behind economically and intellectually only because of slavery, but primarily because of the profound difference in cultural values that existed between the Redneck-Crackers and the English culture of New England, Tidewater Virginia, and Quaker Pennsylvania.

well said, jerebaub, as usual
The reason that independents have seen the greatest growth versus those accepting either the Republican brand or the 'Crat brand is that each side has pursued peculiar passions. Shrillary is not tanking because she is too moderate-- she simply leaves too many turned off, while Barack is a snake oil salesman.

Barack has soared al la Jimma' Carter because of the pied piper phenomenon following a rank smell in the W.H. Why did the latter happen? Because Presidente Jorge got snookered by the neoCONS into spending almost a $ trillion already to make war on the WRONG bad Islamics because a few neoCONS (Wolfy, Perle, Feith, and Libby then inside the W.H.) wanted to build bases there for Israel's protection.

Presidente Jorge also abandoned conservative principles by growing govt. (Rx Care, etc.) and fiscal irresponsibility (no vetoes), so now the economy is tanking due to a caved dollar. We cannot spend huge $ on Iraq allegedly stanching terror while welcoming ILLEGALS who will suck social service funds dry and wreck our socio-economic stability as they morph inexorably us into a third world country. Presidente Jorge is the personification of the Peter Principle and Murphy's Law... he has made Obama possible.

Melonhead
The mention of the loathsome Sen. Webb, who ran as a 'moderate' and votes like the Stalinist he is, brings to mind Mark Levin's so appropriate adjective, 'Melonhead', not just because it so aptly describes the exterior of the aforementioned appendage but also the mushy, moldering socialist contents of that warped and ugly rind.
Its so nice of Ms Zito to introduce a whole new ethnic group into our national mix. Can we afford to leave one single American unsubsidized, when the criminal conspiracy that is American History has so fattened the rich and so blighted the lives of us, the little people, the victims? Thank Gaea that the Age Of The Socialist Imam Approaches!

Karoden
Hanoi John Kerry is called a war hero by some, even though he conned his way out of Vietnam in four months, made a propaganda broadcast in the Senate to aid the Viet Vong, and became an agent for the VC while still a naval reserve officer.

heros
at least Juan McCain is against the abortionists.

remember this when you vote for the menshevik candidate instead of the bolshevik candidate.

you cannot be a democratic menshevik if you are against abortion. what a sick litmus test for a pary to adhere to.

adios,
Harvey
Lancaster, Mexifornia
dial 1 for english

just because they are of
Sots-Irish descent doesn't mean we like or wish to vote for any of them.

Had you left out the references to the politicos this would have been a fairly good, although incomplete article about the Scots-Irish in America.

Augustus-McRae
Have you ever thought that those redneck crackers were part of the country before there was a country? Or that the Quakers haveing asked them to serve as a buffer between the Iroquis and their pacific selves thought that they were better off with the Iroquis?


Go, Scotch-Irish!
"Scotch-Irish" is probably is the largest and most influential culture in the US. It isn't based on ethnic or racial exclusivism, and has never been. It wasn't narrowly the culture of Ulster, but Ulster Scots were its most influential carriers to the U.S. Here, the S-I assimilated quickly, by choice, but retained their culture, while adapting it to a new setting ("old wine, new bottle").

The organizing values are belief in God, work and family, self-reliance, patriotism, and intense resistance to intrusion by government (or others) on freedom. A defining principle of American democracy -- the defining idea, perhaps -- is natural rights, the precept that people are born with rights. Governments that invade people's rights are illegitimate; thus, the animating principle of the Declaration of Independence.

Zito is incorrect that Ds began losing S-I voters over civil rights. The D party has been offending these voters for a very long time, from well before the civil rights movement, and in multiple regions. My mother explained her decision to leave the D party as follows: "The Depression ended, but the welfare kept going. The Democrats paid people not to work, that's all. It's wrong and it's bad for society." She was by no means wealthy. She did not overlook that liberals and Ds were apologists for communism in Russia, China, Cuba and anywhere else. S-I values, then, are everything fearful to the secular left, MSM, and the D party leadership. What better endorsement could one enjoy?

For further reading, David H. Fischer's work is the best known foundation of the scholarship ("Albion's Seed"). Webb is good, but is a popular treatment ("Born Fighting").

Augustus
You're kind of correct. On the frontier the Scotch-Irish were famous for squatting on other people's land and picking fights with the Indians. But I treasure my Scotch-Irish blood because it's sometimes useful to know when not to take any more ****. A history teacher friend informs me that my Scotch-Irish ancestors were the only frontier group that scalped the Indians back.

Another Book on the S-I
"The Scotch-Irish: A Social History", James G Leyburn. Chapel Hill NC: The University of North Carolina Press, 1962. I just now checked; as of Sunday night 3-2 amazon.com has 59 copies used starting at $4.10. My copy is paperback and has 377 pages and a 19-page bibliography. This is a WONDERFUL book if you want to know more about your Scotch-Irish ancestry. It gives a ton of detail about the historical background in Scotland and Ireland as well as about the transatlantic migration, settlements, migration patterns in this country, dates, importance of religion and politics, etc..

Augustus_McRae
Rednecks and crackers? Spoken like a Rockefeller Republican in a moment of honesty. I'm a little surprised you included the Tidewater Virginians, though.

You can't treat the New England, Pennsylvania Quaker and Tidewater Virginia settlers as a homogeneous English group. They're all from different areas and backgrounds in England. As Realist said, read "Albion's Seed" if you want the best information about the different British groups who settled America. Leyburn's "Scotch-Irish" was also good, as lilly mentioned.


I was a huge James Webb fan
until I saw him speak and then had lunch with him.

I've never met such a self-important arrogant know-it-all prick. I'm glad he switched side.
Sign Up to Post Your CommentsSign Up to Post Your Comments
If you are already registered, click here to login. Otherwise, please take a few seconds to register with Townhall.com. Once you sign up, you’ll be able to post your comments immediately, use the action center, get podcasts, and more!
Note: Fields marked with a red asterisk (*) are required.
Salutation:
First Name:
*
Last Name:
*
Email:
*
Nickname:
*
Note: Nick name will be shown when you post comments.
Address 1:
*
Address 2:
City:
*
State:
*
Zip:
*
Phone:
      
Your daily must-read of conservative columns, cartoons and news. Coulter, Sowell, Krauthammer and more.
(Bi-Weekly) We highlight the best opportunities from our partners for surveys, action items and more.