Townhall.com, Where Your Opinion Counts
Talk Radio:   Bill Bennett   Mike Gallagher   Dennis Prager   Michael Medved   Hugh Hewitt   
BREAKING NEWS  LeftArrow - Townhall.com : Conservative, Political, Republican   RightArrow - Townhall.com : Conservative, Political, Republican  
Columns, funnies & more in your inbox!
  • Check the boxes and send us your email address to receveive your free newsletter
  • Your daily must-read of conservative columns, cartoons and news. Coulter, Sowell, Krauthammer and more.
  • Townhall.com’s weekly inside scoop on what’s happening behind the scenes in the world of politics. When news breaks, we report.
  • Signup to receive the latest daily Townhall cartoons
Friday, November 14, 2008
Rich Tucker :: Townhall.com Columnist
More Peace Than War
by Rich Tucker
Vote on It:
Average Vote:
[+] Text [-]
 
Poll
Will the Dems' health care Christmas Present to America be an improvement or detriment to our health care system?


It’s strange how some expressions just fade away, while others seem to stick around forever.

For example, children still pepper their speech with the word “like,” as they have for generations. And the word “say” has been all but replaced by the word “go.” As in, “I go, ‘like, no way,’ and she, like, goes, ‘so, totally.’” And so forth.

Other expressions, though, have become quaint and unusual. Consider the French expression “c’est la guerre.” You don’t hear this one much anymore. And there’s a good reason for that.

Merriam-Webster’s online dictionary defines “c’est la guerre” to mean “that’s war: it cannot be helped.” And it’s worth remembering that, throughout human history, this was the common view. War was a regular part of the landscape for virtually everyone, virtually everywhere. It “couldn’t be helped.”

Not anymore, though. War is relatively rare these days.

It almost goes without saying that in prehistoric times, life was brutal and short. Humans were at war often with each other, and always with nature. Animals and the environment were endlessly dangerous and needed to be tamed if humanity would survive.

Even when humans managed to civilize our living space, we didn’t stop fighting each other. As Robert E. Lee put it at Fredericksburg, “It is well that war is so terrible, or we should get too fond of it.”

Alexander the Great supposedly wept when there were no more worlds to conquer. But who can doubt that, had he lived, he would have gone right on leading armies into new lands, killing and capturing along the way?

It didn’t matter, either, whether people lived under a strong central government (such as Rome) or under a series of weak kings (as in the Middle Ages). War never ended. Whether it was the Crusades, a series of raids on neighboring castles and kingdoms, or the 100 Years War, people kept fighting each other.

Think North America looked different? Many like to idealize Native Americans as peace-loving, back-to-nature types -- proto-1960s hippies wiped out by Columbus and his smallpox. It’s not true.

Indians existed in a constant state of tribe-against-tribe warfare. Consider the Iroquois. In their book, “Beyond the Covenant Chain,” Daniel Richter, James Merrell and Wilcomb Washburn write that, “Far from being the savage rulers of a wilderness empire, as old myth has portrayed them, the Iroquois were brought by the accumulated effects of famine, disease and war ‘within two finger-breadths of total destruction.’”

Man’s eagerness to kill and conquer other men didn’t stop in modern times, either. We just got better at it.

At the dawn of the 20th century, British poet Hillaire Belloc presaged the violence to come when he pointed out that his country’s troops would prevail in developing lands because, “Whatever happens, we have got the Gatling gun and they have not.” Of course in World War I, both sides had versions of the “Gatling gun,” and by the time the Allies prevailed, millions had been slaughtered.

Things didn’t immediately change even after a second World War. One reason the victorious allies formed NATO was to, in the words of its first Secretary General Lord Ismay, “To keep America in, to keep Russia out and to keep Germany down.” Leaders expected another war, and wanted to have their militaries prepared for it.

Even the award-winning children’s book “Stone Soup,” published in 1947, plays up the theme. The villagers are frightened when three soldiers come to town. That, again, is a reasonable fear. Throughout history, when armed men came to your village it was bad news, even if they wore the uniform of your country or king.

The Third Amendment to our Constitution seems quaint these days. “No soldier shall, in time of peace be quartered in any house, without the consent of the owner, nor in time of war, but in a manner to be prescribed by law.” But foraging soldiers were clearly a concern in the 1770s, right here in our country.

Yet -- despite the wars in Iraq and Afghanistan and the civil war in Sudan -- today’s world is as peaceful as it’s ever been.

In its annual yearbook, the Stockholm International Peace Research Institute writes that, “In 2007, 14 major armed conflicts were active in 13 locations around the world.” This may sound like a lot of fighting, but it’s really not. “Over the past decade the global number of active major armed conflicts has declined overall,” the institute adds.

The numbers have been trending in the right direction for some time. “Between 1989 and 2002, about 100 state-based conflicts came to an end. More wars are now ending than beginning,” a Human Security Centre report put it in 2005. Humanity has made great progress, and that’s changing our language and our landscape.

C’est la guerre? Maybe the next generation will instead go, “War? Like, what’s that?”

Share:
Vote on It:
Average Vote:
 
About The Author

Rich Tucker is an editor in Washington D.C. and a columnist for Townhall.com.

Be the first to read Rich Tucker's column. Sign up today and receive Townhall.com delivered each morning to your inbox.< Sign up today!

WAR IS OVER
What a fantastic article!

The narrative of human history is the triumph of love over ignorance.

The behavior of war is possible only to the extent that its effects are removed from the eye -- made possible by the silence that surrounds those impacted by the trauma of dealing death for political ends.

With the creation of the ultimate weapon and the influx of powerful information technology, both within the past century, the behavior is no longer possible. We literally will never again see massed armed forces in open conflict.

What remains is the persistent bullying of the powerful over the weak - essentially crime. That remnant has a very short shelf life, and we have witnessed with the Iraq debacle it's (hopefully) final gasp.

WAR IS OVER.

When war
becomes economically unfeasible to all parties involved it still will not become obsolete. War is mans nature.

"War is mans nature."
Nope.

The law of the jungle is the friction which ignites the fire of the soul.

Love is the law. War is the aberration. And, thankfully, it's end has come.

WAR IS A PROMISE OF GOD
WAR HAVE A THREEFOLD RESOLUTION BUT SOME HOW LIBERALS TRY TO STOP IT FROM HAPPENING. WAR HAS BEEN APART OF TGHE HISTORY OF THE WORLD. AND OF OUTSIDE OF NATURAL DIASTER THERE IS NOTHING THAT HELP CONTROL POPULATION IN THE WORLD. TEMPORARY FIXES LIKE ABORTION ARE MAN ANSWER TO COVER DEFIANCE IN THE NAME OF PEACE. IT HAS ALWAYS SERVED AS A MEASURE OF CORRECTING PEACE AS SEEN THROUGH THE EYES OF ABUSIVE RULING PARTY. HOWEVER MANY GOVERNMENT LEADERS TRYING TO BE GOD IS STILL DEFIANCE. IT ALSO ALLOW PEACE TO REIGN FOR A SEASON WITH GROWTH.

Human nature is inherently dark
and the pursuit of power, the tendency toward presumption, and the desire for instant gratification governs the actions of the man who assumes the position of being his own god.

Peace is the exception rather than the rule.

Good and evil?
I think all folks are inherently selfish, and peace is the fullest extension of that selfishness.

War is only possible in a vacuum of information, in service to a cause outside the self which usurps the individual. With information comes knowledge, an accretion of which imparts wisdom. Information can no longer be blocked - it is available at a geometrically increasing rate.

Truly, altruism and peace are the fullest expression of the self-centered human being.

That war has always been means nothing about its future, imho. Slavery has always been, as well.

Where did you come up
with the mularkey that human nature is inherently dark? There is more good in people when they're young than there is good. The selfishness and hatred that causes dark natures is learned and practiced. Obama's disdain for our country's values and principles will lead us into troubled times. His leftist illuminati ideals will cause an unprecedented decay in our country's morals.

To Paranoidmystic
Sir/Mam I don't profess to know if U are paranoid, but MYSTIC???? I doubt that!
As a retired (25yrs) military vet I don't claim to be an expert on causes of turmoil/conflict but as a "Been There, Done That" participant of the "Nam thing" I was told we were there because we were signatories to SEATO..Or U aware that such a "Treaty" existed prior to the conflict?? We Military simply did as we were directed--Politicians run wars!! That much I do know..Have a Good Day

Wooow!
Some of you guys are too profoundly deed for me to night.
I’m going to have to pass on any comment.

I thought that wars came as a result of someone wanting something you had and thought that they could kick your butt and take it.

That’s why I figured that I would stay out of this one.

war and peace
War is such a strange thing. I am about as anti-violence as one can get and I could not imagine the horrors that accompany war.

I do think War should be a last resort. I am extremely opposed to the Iraq War, but I also know that if/when we leave Iraq we have to do it responsibly.

I think killing is wrong and because of my strong christian belief I could never take part in combat.

Both my grandfathers were veterans and were in wars. One of my grandfathers in particular always spoke against war. I don't think he ever forgave himself for things he did during the war.

He had scars from it his whole life.

I hate to see the injuries that some veterans have. I hate that we have lost so many lives to the Iraq War -and that includes the so called enemy and innocent civilians who have died because of this war.

I feel for all the victims of war on all sides of any conflict.

One day I hope humans can find more meaningful ways to settle disputes.

You would think with all of our resources and all of our minds we could come up with a better way.

We often get distracted with our news that we forget that the most important news should deal with war and Peace.

I wish we would hear more peace activists in our news media. I often wonder where are the voices of Peace? Of course as Amy Goodman would remind us "They are everywhere."

Is There A Just War.
OK, I just couldn’t resist.

The wisest Father in the universe said; “From whence come wars and fighting’s among you? Come they not hence, even of your lusts that war in your members?
Ye lust, and have not: ye kill, and desire to have, and can not obtain: ye fight and war, yet ye have not, because ye ask not.

Ye ask, and receive not, because ye ask amiss, that ye may consume it upon your lusts”.

Undeniable man is inherently sinful. Rather than submit to the will of God, he depends upon his own devices.

Sorry neighbor, we live in a world where every single human being lives with discontentment, always dissatisfied about something.

As long as man has a sinful bone in his body you will have wars.

The thing that you really have to ask yourself is; are you willing to let someone impose war upon you without a just cause.

You’re absolutely right that there is a time to fight, even unto the death. There’s no room for pacifism in the life of those who believe in what right.

Don’t buy into that stuff that the people of God shouldn’t fight. God expects you to stand up for what is right. If the people of God don’t know what’s right, who does.

No greater love hath a man, than to lay down his life for his brother.

Paranoidmystic, take your meds
You are not paranoid enough. Do you really think we will never see massed armed forces in open conflict? Then I guess you missed the news of Russia's recent attack on Georgia. And Russia's forces were massed. They also raped and pillaged. As for your opinion that we will only see crime instead of war, I put to you that crime is just war on a one to one basis for personal rather than national reasons. One is armed and takes something from the other, and may even take the other's life. And by the way, calling acts of terrorism a Crime does not make it so. When the nation of Islam is trying to destroy our nation, as they are every day, as is mandated by Islam, then that is not a crime, it is war. The fact that they do not used massed armies only means that Islamic nations and terrorists know that they cannot prevail against us on the battlefield, so they sneak around and try to accomplish their acts of war in other ways. Iraq is not a debacle. Saddam is dead and cannot harm anyone any more, and that is a good thing. There is freedom where once there was tyranny, and that's good thing. And only war could have achieved it. Years of useless UN resolutions and sanctions only produced the oil-for-food corruption. Sudan and Darfur are still killing people for being different, Somalia is a hellhole of constant war, a failed state. Russia is moving weapons into Venezuela. I think I've said enough. You need to read the news once in awhile, and stop pontificating from California. Sheesh.

Ayn Rand
Thank You. It is so tiring to read the words of the "Kumbayahers." Yes..,read the news.While you're at it...,peruse an atlas.

Islamofascism is not going away.

When you see a soldier, thank him. He is the reason you can post your "GIVE PEACE A CHANCE" baloney.

No war is just. Some wars are justifiable. We are in one!

Yes soldiers fought war..
for peace.

Ples pray tell me how many wars really had anything to do with peace? Or were not cause because of our aggression. one or two, maybe.

If people want peace they seek it dilengtly and the first strike is not the peace maker. Yet, the peacemaker must withhold for peace.

We attacked Iraq for what peace? Give me a break, terroism was to be the mission. Terrosims is and will always exist, crossing our soil has to do with our borders, not their border crossing with war machines, claiming peace.

That has been a progressives idea since ever. I remember when Republicans said, quit war mongering to stimulate the economy. Now we call it fighting for terroism or peace to be able to still spend freely without a balanced budget.

Wake up, just a progressive idea no matter how you wrap it for Americans.

War & peace
When you see a soldier thank him. When you go home at night pray for him. Pray also for victory. It is the only way to honor their sacrifices.
Defeat will only encourage those who want to kill or enslave us to greater efforts.

President Bush Quotes!
President Bush has made some interesting comments about the National ID card for Americans, although most Americans are honest law abiding citizens. He said that employees should be held accountable for hiring illegal aliens which makes them law enforcement agents in a sense without a gun. He said that employees who don't comply with the law should be fined and that a Metric tamper proof card must be implemented to keep illegals from working in our country and illegals must comply with the law. This leads me to the question, if illegals and employees must follow the law and prove U.S. citizenship then why isn't Barack Hussein Obama II who is a constitutional attorney complying with the U.S. Justices and the lawsuit filed by Philip J. Berg, Esq., as well as other lawsuits pending, and showing his U.S. Live Birth Certificate to the Justices as part of the push for Proof of U.S. Citizenship by the Justice Department and the government? Do the laws only apply to the worker bees and not to the elite who hold themselves above the law? By the way, wouldn't it be more constitutionally correct just to close the borders rather than chip honest citizens and track them like animals?

Rose in CA
Honey,
Do you ever stop to read what you write?
If you don't know the difference between employees and employers, how do you expect people to put any value on what you say?

Rose @ 11:43 AM
Rose, I think you meant to write "employers", not employees.

The employer has the hiring/firing authority and thus the responsibility for doing a "due diligence" check on prospective employees.

The employer can't be held to a law enforcement type standard, but must conduct a reasonable inquiry into the prospective employee's background. For example, if you want to hire a driver, you'd certainly want to check the man's state driving record and ask other companies that he drove for about his behavior.

There is a national data base for citizens who have commercial drivers licenses. Why aren't you up in arms about that?

When To Fight, When Not To Fight
OK folks; let’s be rational on the subject.

Wars have been going on since Cain killed Able.
Most wars have been fought over the quest for power in modern times, which was determined by leaders, and rulers, not the common man.

In undeveloped countries wars have fought for territorial rights, for the purpose of obtaining what was needed for survival, such as food and water.
Animals do the same thing.

We no longer live in the 1800’s.
What we as a nation face is the real fact that nuclear weapons have changed the ground rules for war.

In 25 minutes, or less if nukes are placed in Cuba, the US can become vaporized through no fault of its own other than some country thinking your religion is evil and they would be doing God a service to rid the world of you.

Now, it was not the USA that sought to eradicate someone over religion. I was the other way around, we must remember that.

The USA is a capitalistic nation who loves to make money and we are not in the habit of going around the world killing the golden goose, and destroying its nest.

Even the Gulf War, which many say was fought over oil, was instigated by another power. The US got involved because of national security reasons. As long as we are dependent on resources from outside the US we are going to be faced with those challenges.
So, tell your government to become energy independent NOW. We are not going to kill the planet any faster than China.

No sane person enjoys the brutality of war. No soldier enjoys taking ones life, but world peace will not come until Jesus Christ rules with a rod of iron.

We try to trust our leaders to be prudent in when to go to war and not go to war.
There a lot of factors that you are not aware of.

I think president elect Obama is now finding that out in security briefings.

WAR AND PEACE
War is never popular for any purpose. There were many debates among our elected officials before we entered WWI, WWII, Korean War, Viet Nam War and Iraqi war. Have we fogotten that GWB took the Iraq war question to our Congress and Senate for a vote. Check the quotes of many of the Democrats who voted to invade Iraq because Sadam was a threat. When the war was not over in a year the Democrats decided this was a good reason to make Bush the warmonger. However, I am thankful to Bush and the 3500 men who died in Iraq that we have not had another attack on our soil during the past 7 years. The terrorist realized Americans would stand together and fight.

How long will it take our enemies to realize that Obama has a weak point? Putin is already pushing for us to remove the defensive missles in Poland and the Czech Republic, Hamas is making threats against Isreal again, Iran says they won't talk until their terms are met. French President Sarkosy, our great alli? is speaking against the missles in Eastern Europe,
how many terrorist cells are in this country waiting for the moment to strike. Joe Biden was right, Obama will be tested, but it may be sooner than 6 months if you listen to the foreign sabers that are rattling now.

a war is a war is a war is a war
WW1 was one of the most tragic misundertanding and mistake in history. The world was moving up, then war came and after it poverty, evil and another terrible war. The the W. allies wrote such peace treaties (Versailles, etc.) that it could not but explode. (Last the Yugoslav wars of the 90s - a direct result). The "Mid East" was created by stupid British and French bureaucrats.Iraq was INVENTED by the morons. So was Syria, Lebanon, Jordan, Sudan... They were just a lines on old maps - divided between the "Great". Look at them now. The chutzpaed Serbs were rewarded with an Empire, which they eventually would not give up without killing and maiming hundreds of thousands. Srebrenica was a direct result of the PEACE of 1919, not of the war of 1914. And the late US intervention in Bosnia and Kossova were JUSTIFIED. AS was the war to topple Saddam. What a tragedy that the US (in want of ANY other capable and willing force) cannot cope with the challenges of Sudan and Congo. Our European peacenik govts. are good for nothing: a life of a Congolese or a Darfurian is not worth annoying China. Nor a Tibetan's, nor a Burmese's. While Russia's massive crimes in the North Caucasus mean nothing. Pacifists stopped the west from acting when Germany first (1936) violating its peace terms. Had they acted swiftly, WWII, the Holocaust and the hellish Soviet regimes in Eastern Europe would not have happened. And neither would Saddam have been the dictator of Iraq, since his BAATH party was created by the Nazis in the 30s - as was Assad's one in Syria (still in power, thank you very much). And in 1936 it could have been finished almost painless.But WAR IS BAAAAAD... "The Russians love their children, too", "Let's give peace a chance" "Peace in our Times" "Bush lied - children died". Pllllleeeaaase....

Jeff
Children shouldn't have to be disciplined or raised if we are not inherently dark. "No!" and "Mine!" are always among the first words of two year olds world wide. You know , "His Majesty, the Baby" (Freud)? The id is the childish, selfish part of ourselves. Calling someone "immature" or "childish" would be a high compliment, if we were born loving, kind beings. I could go on, but I'm all mularkied out. My gramma loved the word, "mularky", BTW!

VLADWE
You made some excellent and concise points on the wars and conflicts in the last century whereas Peace often led to other wars. History has shown that only the strong military countries can maintain the peace. The Pacifist at all times never really reflect on where they would have been had our nation not had a strong military that was willing to bears arms against our enemies or quell an encroaching threat to our way of life. War is not a Saturday night football game and I don't believe any of our Presidents have sent any of our men or women into a conflict without feeling the emotion of what our costs in lives would be. Our younger society today has grown up with movies and TV which present the hard issues, but see it resolved in at least 2 hours. Real Life is never that simple. I worry about our nation's reflection to the world now with an inexperienced future president and a hot headed vice president. Ready to Lead? I wonder if Obama understands the difference between running a good campaign for a presidential election and supervising a campaign for the safety of it's citizens. He has never walked through the killing fields, only the South Side of Chicago.

Subject: a war is a war is a war i
vladwe super post. You sure know your history and your perspective is right on target.

About employers and illegals
The E-Verify system has a 90+% record of identifying legal employees.

It's a simple, more than 10 years old, process by which an employer submits the SS # that has been alleged to belong to a prospective employee, and Social Security flashes back to him that the possible employee is, indeed, who he or she says he or she is, or isn't.

Incredibly, the Democrats want the program to expire! Well, not so unbelievably, I guess.

America Is At War With Itself!
America is battling for its life. America has survived peacefully for 200 years, but even during trials and tribulations, it has maintained its traditions built upon a Judeo-Christian foundation written by mainly God-fearing men who knew what would happen to a free people if they didn't write the U.S. Constitution exactly as originally intended. They wrote the laws to prevent the people from falling victim or sliding into an immoral lifestyle, materialistic goals over decency, and lies over truth, compromise over integrity, and slavery over freedom perpetrated by an evil entity who hides in dark places, meets in secret, and plots to destroy the greatest country in the world and the most free like a phantom in the night. America is the most generous, yet the most hated by many countries even though Americans have helped support the poor and even shed their blood here and abroad so all people can live free and with dignity. We are a great country and we should not let anyone eliminate or diminish the U.S. Constitution and the Bill of Rights under the guise of creating laws for our own good which violate or change the original laws of the land.

Michael of KY
I understand completely what you are saying. It is hard to reconcile war with so much carnage in the wake. You ask or hope or pray that someday man can figure out how to settle our differences without war. There is always one way and it is called surrender. We are doing battle with an enemy that will not rest until they destroy us or we can no longer influence their 5th century lifestyle. The only way to stop that is to stop modernity. These people have fought wars for centuries, millenia even, so do not look for them to negotiate any time soon. But have no fear, you can stay above the fray, there will always be someone to protect you, someone else to die for the peace you enjoy. I respect your religious views even though I do not agree with them. It's ok brother, I would not mind dying so that you can live free. How long you remain free is out of my control though. Someday you will have to stand up or be enslaved.

My time has passed. I already did my 20 years in the military. I am 55 and fighting my own war with cancer. I win some of the battles but I already know I will lose this war. I want to ensure that I instill in my children a duty to protect freedom, and not just their's but everyone's. Salvation is God's greatest gift to man, and next to that is freedom. Without it what is there? Misery and grief.

To Micheal Of Ky
There will be wars and rumers of wars , but young men such as you and I once were will be FIGHTING them . Right now the US is fighting for it's life . Our High Courts are diluting
the Constitution , Our Politions are breaking all the natural laws of MAN . The people are
basically in ( I give a S**T mode ), yet we must keep trying to Put The Constituion and the Bill of Rights above everything except my God or your God . Pray that our country wakes up
before their is nothing to wake up to .

War is Over
It was the best of times, it was the worst of times. There are peaceful, good men in this country who love their family and friends. There are men of an evil nature who seek to subjugate their fellow man to an ideal and expand their totalitarianism. As long as there is evil in this world and good men who sacrifice themselves to save the weak, there will be wars. Here's to hoping that men will still sacrfice themselves for an ideal and for the weak rather than sacrificing them for the theoretical ideal of peace that doesn't hinder those of an evil nature.
Sign Up to Post Your CommentsSign Up to Post Your Comments
If you are already registered, click here to login. Otherwise, please take a few seconds to register with Townhall.com. Once you sign up, you’ll be able to post your comments immediately, use the action center, get podcasts, and more!
Note: Fields marked with a red asterisk (*) are required.
Salutation:
First Name:
*
Last Name:
*
Email:
*
Nickname:
*
Note: Nick name will be shown when you post comments.
Address 1:
*
Address 2:
City:
*
State:
*
Zip:
*
Phone:
      
Your daily must-read of conservative columns, cartoons and news. Coulter, Sowell, Krauthammer and more.
(Bi-Weekly) We highlight the best opportunities from our partners for surveys, action items and more.