Townhall.com, Where Your Opinion Counts
Talk Radio:   Bill Bennett   Mike Gallagher   Dennis Prager   Michael Medved   Hugh Hewitt   
BREAKING NEWS  LeftArrow - Townhall.com : Conservative, Political, Republican   RightArrow - Townhall.com : Conservative, Political, Republican  
Columns, funnies & more in your inbox!
  • Check the boxes and send us your email address to receveive your free newsletter
  • Your daily must-read of conservative columns, cartoons and news. Coulter, Sowell, Krauthammer and more.
  • Townhall.com’s weekly inside scoop on what’s happening behind the scenes in the world of politics. When news breaks, we report.
  • Signup to receive the latest daily Townhall cartoons
Wednesday, January 17, 2007
Rich Galen :: Townhall.com Columnist
Pardon Scooter Libby
by Rich Galen
Vote on It:
Average Vote:
[+] Text [-]
 
Poll
Will the Dems' health care Christmas Present to America be an improvement or detriment to our health care system?


The US Constitution gives the President the unbridled power to pardon people. Article II, Section 2: [The President] shall have power to grant reprieves and pardons for offenses against the United States, except in cases of impeachment.

Presidents, in modern times, have typically issued a list of pardons on their last day in office so there is no political outfall. Presidents need not give any reason for a pardon. They just sign a paper and it's done.

Bill Clinton understood this in his bones. On January 20, 2001 he pardoned about 7,233 people including people with names like Mark Rich and Roger Clinton.

The trial of Lewis "Scooter" Libby on five counts of obstruction of justice, making false statements and perjury began yesterday with jury selection.

President George W. Bush should use Article II, Section 2 to pardon Lewis "Scooter" Libby. He should do it today. He should sign whatever paper he has to sign and stop this foolishness.

Libby, you may remember, is the only person ever to be charged in the phony scandal regarding Joe Wilson and his wife Valerie Plame.

Plame, to briefly review the bidding, had been a covert officer in the CIA. Robert Novak revealed Ms. Plame's name in a column and wrote that two members of the Bush Administration had told him she worked at the CIA.

It is illegal to reveal the identity of a covert officer in the CIA unless that person is no longer a covert officer in the CIA and the CIA actually took steps to protect the covert officer's identity and a couple of other things.

Absolutely none of the elements which would have made revealing Valerie Plame's name a crime existed. None.

The other night on MSNBC's Hardball, Chris Matthews was so flummoxed by the whole thing that he couldn't remember whether the special prosecutor's name was Fitzgerald or Fitzpatrick.

The answer is both: His name is Patrick J. Fitzgerald.

It turns out that the first guy to mention Valerie Plame's name to columnist Bob Novak was not Scooter Libby, or Karl Rove. It was the then Deputy Secretary of State Richard Armitage.

Armitage, according to published reports, 'fessed up to the fact he was the leaker but, according to Armitage, US Attorney Gerald Fitzpatrick or Patrick Fitzgerald or whatever his name really is "asked me not to discuss this, and I honored his request."

Whoa! Check please! Fitzgerald was hired to find out who had leaked Valerie Plame's name to Bob Novak, right?

It turns out that as early as 2003, Fitzgerald knew who had leaked the name but asked the leaker not to tell anyone he was the leaker so he could indict someone in the leak case who was not the leaker?

What, one wonders, did Fitz-whatever threaten Armitage with if Armitage hadn't "honored his request?"

Judith Miller of the New York Times went to jail for refusing to divulge her source (it was Libby). Matt Cooper of Time Magazine was about to go to jail for refusing to divulge his source (it was Rove).

But neither Libby nor Rove was the original source. It was Armitage.

When the story first broke it was reported that Cooper said to Rove that Plame worked at the CIA and that Rove had responded with something like, "Yeah, I heard that, too."

In Washington, you never admit you don't know something. You say, "Yeah, I heard that too."

Fitzgerald chose not to indict Armitage because there was no crime. He tried like the devil to indict Rove but Rove convinced the grand jury that he made or took hundreds of phone calls a day and failing to remember one call with one reporter several years earlier was not a crime  it was astonishingly normal.

People who know Scooter Libby (and I am not one of them) say that he is a decent guy. A smart guy. And a patriot.

In the kind of painful ironies which abound in Washington the lawyer who represented Marc Rich in his pardon plea to President Clinton was Scooter Libby.

President Bush should return the favor. Pardon Libby.

Share:
Vote on It:
Average Vote:
 
About The Author

Rich Galen has been a press secretary to Dan Quayle and Newt Gingrich. Rich Galen currently works as a journalist and writes at Mullings.com

Be the first to read Rich Galen's column. Sign up today and receive Townhall.com delivered each morning to your inbox.

Republican perverts reign in washington
Where in god's name do the republics find these perverts ,homosexuals and child molesters such as Limbaugh .Guckert , O'reilly and now Libby to further your cause . Damn this is an evil world after all! You kool aiders can justify anything.

Emelia's a moron
Look, I've never read Libby's book, nor was I even aware he had written one, let alone aware of its contents. But, just because he WROTE ABOUT incest and bestiality does not mean he SUPPORTS such indecent acts. Again, I haven't read the book, but I'll bet you Libby portrayed these activities in a negative light. Every story needs a villain, and the more heinous the villain's acts, the more interesting the story. If he had written a NON-FICTION piece, and, within that work, clearly advocated in favor of legalizing these heinous activities, then you would have a point. As it is now, the only point you have is the one on the top of your HEAD!

Think about it, Emelia! Is every author who ever wrote a murder mystery, at heart a murderer himself? Is every story that features rape proof that the author is a rapist? Both of these activities are far worse than bestiality (unless you're a totally whacked animal rights freak, who thinks a sheep's vagina is more sacred than a human's, or even the life of that human). Yet I don't see you questioning the moral fiber of every author who ever wrote such a story featuring rape or murder.

Get your head out of your azz, Emelia. If you think Libby broke some law, you're wrong, but at least it's relevant to the story.

Regards,
Trevor

By that logic
Sure, go ahead and pardon those accused of connections with violations of laws in the current administration. After all the Administration as the primary responsibility of law enforcement, so they should be able to selectively enforce those laws against their own.

In reality, I am in favor of pardoning Libby *after* a trial if he is found guilty. THis way at least we have some court record about some aspects of what really appeared to be a viscious and illegal action of revenge by our current administration. But I don't think Scooter should be a scapedog (hence pardon him).

Of course, if I were a party line Democrat, I would be saying "I would like nothing more than to have Scooter pardoned right now" because there would be nothing better for that party than to make the Bush Administration look like the worst of the Nixon and Harding administrations.

You can read, right, emelia?
I'm wondering because you accuse tbmbuzz of considering that "peddling in bestiality and paedophilia (sic) to be sexy, normal and an icon of success (money?) and feel that this is reasonable behaviour on behalf of a human being.." whereas what he actually said was "gratuitous, raunchy sex."

So I'm wondering if you can read since in my book (pardon the pun) those descriptions aren't equivalent...




BUMPER STICKER NEEDED
"PARDON SCOOTER LIBBY,
PROSECUTE JOE WILSON AND FITZGERALD"

DO I HEAR ANY OBJECTIONS????

Lynne is Right
Of course you are right, Lynne. Your problem is that you must think that the liberal conspiracy hate-Bush kooks care about things like facts. If so, you will become very frustrated.

In my post a while ago, I suggested that a pardon would only send the fever-swamp lib-kooks hyperventilating about an imperial, corrupt administration--you know, the usual rant. A pardon might even lend an air of legitimacy to prosecutor Fitzgerald's kangaroo court. That is why the trial has to go all the way to verdict, with such highlights as embarassing liberal print-media journalists about their jihad against this president (they claim objectivity and never face scrutiny). A verdict will be an acquittal, and the lib-kooks will be held to a mirror to see themselves as the biased, crazed, maniacal haters that they are. Conclusion: No pardon, please; let the wheels of justice roll on.

By the way, I read recently that the Scooter Libby defense fund is presently between 2.5 and 3 million dollars. So fortunately, he won't go bankrupt defending himself.

How Soon Some Forget
It seems like just yesterday when a whole lot of alleged Conservatives got into a lather when a sitting, (or actually lying) president failed to tell the truth under oath in court. Suddenly perjury became a big issue, even big enough to engender an impeachment. Now we have a neo-con big shot up on charges for lying to a prosecutor under oath, and lying under oath is no longer a big deal. Charges should be dropped!!! Jorge Bush needs to pardon the fellow and so forth.... What is sadly hilarious is that it seems to be hard to find a juror who believes that our Illustrious Vice President can be trusted to tell the truth. This administration has done more to destroy the credibility of the Presidency and the Conservative Movement than any Democrat including Hillary.

Go Bulldog, Go!
Those of us out here in flyover country earnestly hope that Fitzgerald can help give Mr. Libby a fair trial, and gain a conviction in the process. We really hate to see The Bulldog distracted from his prime task of cleaning out the bi-partisan Augean Stables of Illinois politics. Expecting any mortal, or even a Hercules to clean up both Illinois and the Bush administration is expecting far too much.

The President Is Not Free With Pardons
Sending Border Patrol Agents to Prison for attempting to Apprehend a Drug Smuggler Sends a definite message to other Border Patrol Agents and furthers his agenda of selling the Southwest out to the Mexicans.

The only stance I could find by the president was a statement he made when Governor of Texas. He said, "There is no evidence an innocent man was ever executed in the State of Texas."

I wonder how that would stand if investigations/DNA went on after the execution. Why don't they use the DNA on some of the old cases? Afraid of what they will find?

No Pardon - Trial will Vindicate
If President Bush pardons Libby, it will imply guilt. No, let the trial go all the way to verdict. Embarass the media chimpanzees, show the liberal conspiracy kooks that there was never a case, and let Scooter Libby be vindicated by the process. There is no other way.

Justice
The only justice one can hope for is that the idiot in the White House is impeached and the neo-cons who engineered this war are rounded up and deported to Israel to which their real allegiance lies. Libby is a liar and a pornographer but he is chump change. Mr. Gollum (or whatever his name is)is wrong on the Plame case. Ms. Plame was indeed covert and working on arms issues in the Mid-East. Her husband, Joe Wilson, has more moxie in his pinky than any of the criminals in this administration. The whole affair was aimed at discrediting him over the (forged)Niger documents. Time to wake up class. No more koolaid for you.

loveitorleaveit
You have missed the point completely.

The fact that Libby and Web share the same mentality does not subtract one from the other. Rather... it shows a distinct common interest of those in high-office, and thus contempt for those that they purportedly represent.

Although these people should be free to write as they please, perhaps we should question the minds of those that feel the need to pen such prose, especially if they seek office.

Perhaps those that seek exaltation are the least deserving, or it could be just obfuscation and greed that are the motivating factors.

http://www.drudgereport.com/flashaw.htm


MOnty
Good thing that The Impeached One isn't the POTUS or those agents would have to cough up 200K to buy a POTUS pardon.

Pardon him, then arrest Fitzgerald.
Fiztgerald has openly admitted he abused his powers as special prosecutor when he statetd, for the entire world to hear, that he knew from day one that there had been no crime committed, and that his goal was a political witch hunt.

Pardon Libby, then toss Fitzgerald in Gitmo for a few years.

twits
Aren't you all the same twits who loudly shrieked "the rule of law" when the shrub received the election in 2000 via the supreme court and when clinton was impeached for lying about an affair that had no relation to white water? The rule of law is that libby lied to federal prosecutors and it does not matter what armetage did or did not do.

emelia
What do the two things have to do with each other? Your comparison is not reasonable.

To save yourself from being a hypocrite, please provide a reply denouncing Jim Webb (D), the newly elected senator from Virginia for the same reason.

This entire issue is ridiculous you must admit. Libby is being charged with a crime as a result of an inquiry where no crime was committed. Can anyone honestly remember every conversation they had in chronlogical order for the last 6 months? Libby is being "Nifonged".

tbmbuzz
Well I guess if you consider peddling in bestiality and paedophilia to be sexy, normal and an icon of success (money?) and feel that this is reasonable behaviour on behalf of a human being, and then state that when others don't adhere to these practices they are in some way hung-up and in need of help!

Then I can only think that you seek to justify your own affiliations with said practices for either; monetary gain (success!)or your love of raunchy sex with children or animals....

You also do a great disservice to many talented authors.....




I beg your pardon
Sorry. It brings a smile to my ever loving jaw to see Clinto being cited as the reason for a Republican misstep.

The onus for his probable conviction is now placed on the best U.S. Attorney -- Pat Fitzgerald -- in the nstion. His appointment to his post in Illinois after nomination by conservative Senator, at the time, Peter Fitzgerald has resulted in conviction after conviction of local and state politcos of both parties.

He is moving up the political food chain, eliciting confessions along the way, The Democrat Daleys, Dem. Governor Blago's people, and the Republican combine which freezes out all conservatives can hardly wait for the President to dump him. Everybody else is holding their breath. This is the first time that the Illinois sewers have been opened and a small bit of sky opened to view.

If POTUS who is a friend of the Democrat Richie Daley forces Peter Fitz out because of a hack like Libby, Illinois and the rest of the nation lose

The Scooter tried to play the game with the big boys. Crime, without the threat of punishment, runs rampant.

Frankly, the big threat to republicans is that a conviction of the Scooter without the vow of pardon will mean that there is no way to tie in the VEEP, if that were the trail.

Convict him, and unlike the rest of these white collar easy riders send him to a maximum security prison not a Club Fed., which has all the amenities save a golf course.

emelia
It is extremely difficult in today's society to succeed (make money) as an author without gratuitous, raunchy sex. Just ask Jim Webb (D)!


Apparently you have some personal hangups. Get help.

Article wrong
Sorry but I disagree with Galen today. If Bush pardons him without the full trial, it will go down very bad in the PR world. Dems will claim that justice was not served and now we will never know the truth. They will claim abuse of power even though Clinton did the same thing 100x worse with people who were actually guilty!

The fallout would not only make the last 2 years in office that much harder for Bush, but it would also hurt the GOP in 2008 elections.

Let the courts do their thing and run the course. If we get some wako lib jury and judge then Bush can pardon him after the elections. He should also pardon any of our troops who the lawyers are going after, border patrol agents, or anyone else who the PC police have gone after for doing their dang job!

Surely not
the same Scooter Libby that wrote about:

• a scene of incest between two uncles and their niece;
• a hunter asking his companions if they should f*** a freshly killed deer while it's still warm;
• the description of a prepubescent girl's painted "mound" and pleasing lack of vaginal odor;
• a story about a girl who's kept in a cage and raped by a bear to train her to become a prostitute.

http://www.nerve.com/dispatches/libby/dirtypolitician/


Pardons

Mr.President,we know you are not a gutless
hypocrite like slick willy,so go ahead and
pardon the border patrolmen and Libby now.
Don't wait. The lefty libs are against you
no matter what you do. So do it NOW.

Amen
Agreed, Monty. He should WITHOUT DELAY pardon all three. But his opponents don't call him "shrub" without reason. Look forward to a bankrupt-Libby show trial and a long, undeserved prison sentence for two guys who were trying to keep a criminal illegal alien and his drugs out of the USA. The prosecutors should be joining Nifong in being investigated themselves. Shameful!

Yeah well
Maybe Bush should pardon those two border patrol agents first.
Sign Up to Post Your CommentsSign Up to Post Your Comments
If you are already registered, click here to login. Otherwise, please take a few seconds to register with Townhall.com. Once you sign up, you’ll be able to post your comments immediately, use the action center, get podcasts, and more!
Note: Fields marked with a red asterisk (*) are required.
Salutation:
First Name:
*
Last Name:
*
Email:
*
Nickname:
*
Note: Nick name will be shown when you post comments.
Address 1:
*
Address 2:
City:
*
State:
*
Zip:
*
Phone:
      
Your daily must-read of conservative columns, cartoons and news. Coulter, Sowell, Krauthammer and more.
(Bi-Weekly) We highlight the best opportunities from our partners for surveys, action items and more.