Townhall.com, Where Your Opinion Counts
Talk Radio:   Bill Bennett   Mike Gallagher   Dennis Prager   Michael Medved   Hugh Hewitt   
BREAKING NEWS  LeftArrow - Townhall.com : Conservative, Political, Republican   RightArrow - Townhall.com : Conservative, Political, Republican  
Columns, funnies & more in your inbox!
  • Check the boxes and send us your email address to receveive your free newsletter
  • Your daily must-read of conservative columns, cartoons and news. Coulter, Sowell, Krauthammer and more.
  • Townhall.com’s weekly inside scoop on what’s happening behind the scenes in the world of politics. When news breaks, we report.
  • Signup to receive the latest daily Townhall cartoons
Sunday, May 17, 2009
Paul Jacob :: Townhall.com Columnist
Ode to California
by Paul Jacob
Vote on It:
Average Vote:
[+] Text [-]
 
 
Poll
Was the Copenhagen Global Warming Summit Walk-Out a Win for the U.S.?


On Tuesday, Californians will get to do something that I love to do: Vote. The Golden State’s Assembly has placed six measures on a statewide special election ballot.

Forget for a moment that these ballot measures 1A through 1F include a giant tax increase paired with a phony spending cap, an authorization to borrow billions from future lottery receipts, and two spending shifts away from voter-approved programs.

Remember that five of the six propositions seem thankfully headed to almost certain defeat. In fact, the only ballot item that appears likely to win — and win big — is Proposition 1F, which stops pay increases for the governor, top state officials, and state legislators when the general fund is in deficit.

Legislators were offering this one sweetener. Voters seem likely to eat this sweet dessert and leave the meat and potatoes behind.

I won’t blame them for voting down the first five measures. I would, too. In fact, I envy Californians for getting the opportunity to vote these idiotic proposals down. I’d certainly like an opportunity to veto plenty of stuff passed by my legislature, and to weigh in on budget decisions.

In Virginia, decisions are made in Richmond with seldom any direct input from the people. And unlike California and 23 other states, we have no initiative and referendum process to check the legislature or to pass reforms ourselves.

It’s not that California doesn’t have problems; it does. It’s just that the problems don’t stem from too much citizen say-so.

Politicians and insiders often blame California’s voter initiative and referendum process for the state’s budgetary problems. They blame term limits, passed by initiative. They blame the two-thirds vote requirements for the California Legislature to pass a budget or raise taxes, again mandated by initiative.

Yet, they ignore the simple fact that Californians love their state’s initiative and referendum process, and the many reforms that have sprung from the process.

Me? I go with the idea that the customer is always right. And voters, not politicians or anointed experts, are the customers of government.

The Los Angeles Times recently wrote that “Propositions 1D and 1E represent ballot-box budgeting coming back to haunt the California electorate.”

Judging from the polls, voters don’t seem “haunted” at all. They’re set to defeat both D and E, ratifying their original vote to direct certain funding.

Both 1D and 1E are on the ballot because, by law, any initiative statute passed by California voters cannot be repealed by legislators. Instead, legislators must put an amendment to or a repeal of the initiative law on the ballot for voters to decide. In this case, legislators are seeking to divert some funding from mental health and childhood development programs passed through initiatives.

Kent Drum’s blog post on Mother Jones entitled, “The Scourge of the Ballot Initiative” notes that one measure concerns just $200 million dollars. Drum argues, “I’m not about to spend hours pouring over ballot arguments.”

He adds, “This is why we elect a legislature.”

Call me crazy, but I find it sorta nice to be asked, first, before officials overturn my vote.

Mr. Drum says the special election propositions are “one of the reasons I loathe the initiative process these days.”

For the record, none of these six measures are “initiatives” — that is, initiated by the people and petitioned onto the ballot. These six propositions are legislative referrals, placed on the ballot by a vote of the state legislature.

While some voter initiatives have mandated spending or otherwise affected the California budget, the actual impact is nothing like the hype, according to University of Southern California Professor John G. Matsusaka. His paper, “Have Voter Initiatives Paralyzed the California Budget?” concludes:

Virtually all of the earmarked spending was for education, and would have been appropriated by the legislature even without an initiative mandate. Initiatives placed only minimal constraints on the legislature’s ability to raise revenue. The facts suggest that voter initiatives are not a significant obstacle to balancing the budget in California.

The problem in California is the concentration of power in the legislature, resulting in misrepresentation and low public approval ratings.

The best solution? Much smaller districts where shoe leather can compete with money and connections. This means more state assemblymen and senators.

But like most important reforms, it will need to come through the voter initiative process. Legislators won’t want to reduce their personal slice of power.

Sure, bad policy decisions have been and can be made by voters as well as by politicians. Still, politicians retain their gigantic market share — and continually press their overwhelming advantage — in enacting disasters.

California is in trouble, no doubt about it. But the problem isn’t the voters. They’re the solution. 

Share:
Vote on It:
Average Vote:
 
About The Author
Paul Jacob is President of Citizens in Charge. His daily Common Sense commentary appears on the Web, via e-mail, and on radio stations across America.
 
TOWNHALL DAILY: Sign up today and receive Townhall.com daily lineup delivered each morning to your inbox.
California rules!
We have fired governors, overturned our Supreme Court, and removed from government the power to raise taxes by amending our own Constitution - all on ballot iniatives that almost anyone with enough determination could force the people to vote on.

I love my state!

Hoodaticus
Say that again when our beloved Ninth Circuit overturns Prop 8 -- as it almost surely will.

I HATE "my" stste! Thank God we're only here until the Navy moves us again.

The People Choice!
Though it is true that the People of California have put a number of iniatives on the ballots, it is the ones who run the state before the People took back over the budget concurns that has really hurt the state and put it in the shape that she is in at this time.

Free education, free medical, free income, free transportation, and the list goes on for those who are not willing to work or are there illedgal, and not paying any taxes. I'm not saying that they all be sent packing and sent home to where ever they came from. NO! But do require them to pay THEIR share of taxes and do be paid under the table per say. Go after the employers who are doing this, and that would have a great impact on the state budget troubles.

Who was it who said...
...(I paraphrase)"A democracy will exist only as long as it takes the people to realize they can vote themselves largess from the public treasury"? Adam Smith? Ben Franklin?

Help me out here.

TRESPASSING
If California 'fails', but is 'too big' to 'fail', are We the People, the American taxpayers, going to be mandated to 'bail' Californis out?
THAT'S TAXATION WITHOUT REPRESENTATION.
Taxpayers in every other State DID NOT vote on or for Californias politicians and legislation which have bankrupted their State and we ARE NOT responsible for their mismanagement.

If police can arrest protesters 'trespassing' at Notre Dame then it's about time the police start arresting the politicians in Washington 'trespassing' on our Constitution and our 'Rights'.

DOWN WITH THE DEMOCRATS
The corruption is responsibly laid at the Democrats' door! They push the Homosexual Agenda and spend, spend, spend.

One major earth quake driving SF into the Pacific would help the situation!

Back to basics
Every state which has fallen under Democratic Control is facing bankruptcy due mainly from their "free give-away programs". Stop funding and educating all the illegals and they would save billions. If the Liberal Elites want to save them, let them fund them with their own money. Stop Anchor Babies! They get free college while our own children are denied student loans. Stop building prisons with resort type facilities - no more internet, TV, workout rooms, etc. It doesn't work! Make the prisoners do actual hard work, chain gangs building roads or whatever the state needs (they'll learn a skill). Stop the flow of easy travel to Mexico and back, make everyone apply for a visa. This would slow down drugs, guns and killing.

Absolute Idiocy
It is absolute idiocy that California could more than pay for all its socialist spending if they just allowed for offshore drilling but do not for non-sensical "enviromental" concerns. Its absolute idiocy that a large part of their social welfare budget goes to supporting illegal aliens. Its absolute idiocy that unable to trim their budget through payroll costs due to the union stranglehold. It is absolute idiocy that we as a nation are going to follow their example and bankrupt this country.

Proved wrong
I admit it. I was wrong. I apologize to LORI. With the giving of old Abe Lincoln and Barak Obama, I was wondering if anything good could come out of Illinois. Are you sure you aren't a transplanted Southerner?
Why aren't people like you in politics? not enough money or crooked enough? Don't worry there are many out here like us. We just have to take charge and throw the bums out. Our biggest problem is trying to convince the brainwashed voters to vote like John Quincy Adams advocated. "Vote for principle and though you vote alone, you may have the sweetest reflection that your vote is not wasted".

Terminating California
You gotta hand it to Arnuld, the Terminator: He illustrates the superiority of brains over brawn by the lack of the former quality in his incompetent performance in bringing California to the brink of bankruptcy.

Then he didn't have a good script writer and director!

HEY NAM
It your question is not rhetorical, (or even if it is), I think the answer is DeToqueville. Whoever, he clearly knew whereof he spoke.

Fla has ballot initiatives
Fla has ballot initiatives but by our own ballot initiative we raised the bar to 60% to pass one; thereby neutering ballot initiatives!

Now the legislature has that more power and the majority that much less.

What idiots we are.

Let them gather signatures
Another weakness in the system is stealth. To raise taxes, a 2/3 majority vote by the people is required, and in 1997, Ventura Co. supervisors put a proposed tax hike on the ballot in FEBRUARY, only three months after the big election in November, and as a result, relatively few people turned out to vote. Still, it lost by a small margin. Undaunted, the supervisors put it on ANOTHER ballot only a few months later. Having forgotten all about it, even fewer voters turned out [hence the stealth nature]. Only about 4,000 people voted, and this time it passed by less than 100 votes because mostly only those who wanted it to pass bothered to vote.

Herein lies a problem with legislative referrals. The legislature desiring to put an issue on the ballot should have to gather signatures like anyone else so desiring.

Just Vote no - often and early
Screw Sacramento, these Liberal idiots created this Mess, they can pay for it now...

Joel
Good morring my friend; Please explain to me how one is able to " own " property in this country ???? If you are not able to pay the taxes on it then the state or fed. govt. takes it away. If you leave it to someone when you die then there is the inheritance tax that must be paid. AND if the state of fed. govt. decides that THEY need it then they take it. With little or no recourse for the citizen...One dose not realy own property in this country anymore we just rent it...

California, may it slide into the sea
California, the liberal idea test tube for the last 50 years, should, like the cancerous tumor that it is, simply fall into the sea.
The last act of sanity for California was voting in Reagan as governor. Every other action by this deplorable, traitorous, disgusting state and it's liberal lefty loonies, has been the test bed of the liberal ideas that sicken this land. May God take this cancerous tumor from our land.

Time to Let CA Fail
As a Californian, I've already proudly voted to defeat all but 1F--keeping politician salaries from going up until they deal with this nightmare. We want government to fix all problems and relieve all pain! We blame politicians who say "no" for doing nothing. We need a lot more of nothing. To get elected, CA politicians have been given. They could get away with that when incomes were high, but they are now left with promises they can't fulfill. Only in failure will they find the will to change the entitlement mentality that is choking our economy and chasing businesses out of our state. Fail now or fail later at an even greater cost. I say, it's time for a lot more "no" and a lot more "nothing" from government. We need a return to self-reliance and more true community where people help their neighbors and family...not go to the government for another entitlement!

SCOTUS and Liberals
Are the reason this country is in so much trouble.Arnold is a stupid rino that is led around by his nose by his leftist wife

California Is A Cancer
and I resent my tax dollars going down that cesspool. We're going to have to bail out those freaks.

please sir may i have another
As sure as Obama needs a teleprompter, the California Legislators will scapegoat the Citizens for defeating this poor excuse for failing to do your job right the first time!

Perhaps we can trade our
debt to China for California. Kind of like Napoleon in 1803-04 with the Louisiana Purchase.
So SHHHH...don't let them know it turned into a real latrine of a state.

BAD DEAL
We have made the Germans rich, the Japanese rich, the Arabs rich (hail Dubai), and now China rich.

California stumbles into poverty. Maybe those we have made rich will buy California? Probably not -- with its Democratically controld government it would be a bad deal!

DrT is right!
Put CA state bankruptcy as an option on the ballot and it would pass overwhelmingly.

The only way to undo the public employee union contracts is for the state to go belly up. The unions have so poisoned the political process in this state that they own the Dem party and spend lavishly on ads promoting their candidates and programs paid from the taxes obtained from a passive public. This is a preview of what is happening nationwide under Obama, Pelosi, Reid etal.

Unions, together with the leftest newspapers and other MSM have turned this state into the Peoples Socialist Republic of Mexico El Norte. We are bankrupt politically, socially and spiritually and it is time to acknowledge this fact!



Joel-De Oprresso Liber

"California
Most business owners would find the govt of the Peoples Republic of China less oppressive than the govt of the Peoples Republic of California."


You hit the nail on the head there!

I am voting yes
on 1D and 1E.

Yep! These issues were one giant rip off to begin with and they deserve to be ripped off and killed.

I am also growing tired of the legislature kicking the can down the road with these stupid special elections, which really amount to trickery with the wording to begin with.

I also can't help but wonder how much money is wasted on these special elections.

California
used to serve as a good example and now serves as a horrible warning!

Heed it America, and most especially heed it GOP!

Democrats have had control of the legislature for 40 years here, due mainly to milquetoast Republicans, who are lazy and offer no differentiation between the two parties.

JAG
You Stated:
"Unions, together with the leftest newspapers and other MSM have turned this state into the Peoples Socialist Republic of Mexico El Norte. We are bankrupt politically, socially and spiritually and it is time to acknowledge this fact!"
I wish you were wrong. I pray you are wrong. But, every ounce of evidence suggests you are right.

Joel
Yup you are correct in what you say. I think that far to many people take their freedom and rights for granted. also I have been thinking upon these " Illegal " people that are here in our country and I propose that if they want to stay then a mandatory stint in the military of, oh say 6 years might sufficient...What say you on this??
And by the way sorry it took so long to get back to this as I am mowing my grass today...lol

The Right Thing?
The cruelty of our California government has set a new low for this country. Is this pre-revolutionary France?
In the midst of horrible economic conditions, the rulers are willing to sacrafice...nothing. Their relentless spending on public employees is unfair. To bestow lavish benefits onto an individual by confiscating income from those lacking in anything similar is...unfair.

There is a river of dollars flowing to millions of illegals aliens. To take from the struggling law abiding citizen and give to the illegal is criminal and is immoral.

On Tuesday we decide if a huge tax increase, only weeks following a huge tax increase, in the middle of a bad economic situation is sane.

On Tuesday we tell Sacramento who their Masters are. The Teachers Union or the Tax Payer.
On Tuesday we decide whether to give liquor to the alcoholic, or not.

Go, CA, and tell the Dems.
in Sacramento, even Arny, and the rotten public unions to go pound sound.

Arny should get some cojones and stop going along to get along with a 16% rise in CA spending since he became gov., on a platform of fiscal responsibility.

Arny's Republicanism is what has the Rep. Party in the situation it's in. It talks about lower taxes and less gov't and then gets into office and thinks it's a lib.

Maybe it will send a message to King Elect O and the ninnies in the US Cong.

Vote NO.

As a native born Californian
I am ashamed California had no native son to win the Governorship.

And elected one of the dumbest men in America to that post.

My own personal opinion of him after the past few years of watching California become a third world nation

Ballot Measures
I live in Ca. and the good thing about ballot measures is that we get to vote to do or not to do something our legislators didn't. I hope soon that the voters will realize we dont need them and will push hard for a part time legislature. Ca. use to be a great state but not anymore. Illegal immigrants, entitlements, hundreds of death row inmates sucking us dry. We have water issues but not one leader has gone after desalinization plants along our coast. The environmentalist are killing us and allowing the fish, salamanders and condors to thrive. This Liberal lunacy has to stop.

Thank you,Joel et al...
...:-)

Reconquista
A government that takes a chunk of money each month from its' people and gives it to the citizens of another country. A goverment that prints in the language of another country. A government that provides extra special services to the citizens of another country. A government going broke by spending billions on citizens of a foreign country.

Is this France after millions of Germans invaded?
Or
Is this California after millions of Mexicans invaded?

CA is finished.
Th idiots in CA that have elected these morons are getting what they deserve...a failed socialist state, run by in inept bureaucracy, that can't admit to its failures much less offer solutions.

In 15 months the state will be bankrupt with no alternatives left. Within two weeks of bankruptcy you will have chaos in the streets and the National Guard on the street corners. Glad to know our returning troops will have a new assignment closer to home.

If you have a family and any sense of when to bail, this is now the time to quietly head for the exit.

CA will become Ex. A that will be used by conservatives for the next 50 years to convince the residents of the other 49 states that liberalism run amuck is the path to ruin.

Would anyone on this thread - voluntarily move to this hell hole of a state??

es, fo & die david, jeff & loulouise
this little ole hell hole is responsible for 13% of US gdp. Number one state in agricultural output, and comparable to no.'s 3. 4.& 5 (Iowa, Kansas and Nebraska) combined.

I have a hunch that we'll elect another Republican governor (Meg Whitman) in 2010, one who'll likely do a good job and, at the very least, not be an easy target for the msm.

were it up to me, we'd be drilling for oil all up and down our 800ish mile coastline (30 miles out wouldn't be to blighty)

now it's true that "'frisco" (old school southern california colloquial meant to irritate bay area intelligentsia) is not likely to be leaning to rhe right any time soon. Same goes for Hollywood, which is just over the hill from where I live. It's a helluva tax base though, and, you know, they've got a right to their opinions.

Outnumbered conservatives here do what we can do but we need some help. Our state has been blue since '92. Not my cup of tea, but no reason to bail. If it takes David's Ex. A to do the job, I can live with it. Right here in sunny california. eat a peach.

All you haters are just jealous.
California today is still the best place to live in human history.

There are ads saying vote yes on 1A-F
which is what a RINO WOULD DO! VOTE NO, VOTE CONSERVATIVE AND SLAP BOTH PARTIES SILLY FOR THEIR INSOLENCE!

Only vote "yes" on 1F - limiting raises for these idiots in office. The others are tax increases, some of them deferred.

California is proof

California is proof Liberlism doesn't work.

You can't tax your way to prosperity.

You can only tax your way into bankruptcy.

You don't know much about California
Okay, some of you have false impressions of California and her citizens.

First, we are a center-right state -- not a leftist nanny-state. The Dems with the willing help of the Repubs created themselves safe little fiefdoms from which to run -- practically guaranteeing that all incumbents have no opposition and the Repubs will be a minority in all legislative offices. This was done by gerrymandering all legislative districts after the 2000 census. Thanks to another citizens' initiative, this will all change after the 2010 census since the legislature in Sacto won't be drawing district lines anymore.

Second, for the ignorant Navy-brat -- the 9th Circuit is federal, idiot, not Californian. Hope your next duty is some place nice, like Greenland.

Part 2
Third, California has been bailing out the other states for decades. For every dollar in taxes we send to DC, we get back 75 cents. So, we are the ones getting screwed, not you. And, if the Feds would simply PAY for the unfunded mandates they have foisted upon the state, and protected the state from an illegal foreign invasion of illegal aliens as required in the US Constitution, we wouldn't have a financial mess in the first place. We did pass a citizens' initiative outlawing illegal immigration and benefits to illegals back in 1994, but a corrupt ACLU judge on the federal 9th Circuit held up our law for 4 years until a Democrat could be elected governor. He refused to appeal the decision to the full court and just "mediated" our law out of existance. This governor was later recalled and ousted from office after agreeing to give driver's licenses to illegal aliens. Our annual deficit is around 16 billion dollars -- the exact amount it costs us to educate, medicate and incarcerate the illegal foreign invaders. This does not include the costs incurred by their faux-citizen anchor-baby offspring. Nor does it include lost tax receipts from the underground economy. Nor does it include the wage depression a bloated, foreign-dominated labor market foists on all California workers.

Most of California's problems are federally induced, for the rest, we have the citizens' initiative and we use it on a regular basis.

Part 2
Third, California has been bailing out the other states for decades. For every dollar in taxes we send to DC, we get back 75 cents. So, we are the ones getting screwed, not you. And, if the Feds would simply PAY for the unfunded mandates they have foisted upon the state, and protected the state from an illegal foreign invasion of illegal aliens as required in the US Constitution, we wouldn't have a financial mess in the first place. We did pass a citizens' initiative outlawing illegal immigration and benefits to illegals back in 1994, but a corrupt ACLU judge on the federal 9th Circuit held up our law for 4 years until a Democrat could be elected governor. He refused to appeal the decision to the full court and just "mediated" our law out of existance. This governor was later recalled and ousted from office after agreeing to give driver's licenses to illegal aliens. Our annual deficit is around 16 billion dollars -- the exact amount it costs us to educate, medicate and incarcerate the illegal foreign invaders. This does not include the costs incurred by their faux-citizen anchor-baby offspring. Nor does it include lost tax receipts from the underground economy. Nor does it include the wage depression a bloated, foreign-dominated labor market foists on all California workers.

Most of California's problems are federally induced, for the rest, we have the citizens' initiative and we use it on a regular basis.
Sign Up to Post Your CommentsSign Up to Post Your Comments
If you are already registered, click here to login. Otherwise, please take a few seconds to register with Townhall.com. Once you sign up, you’ll be able to post your comments immediately, use the action center, get podcasts, and more!
Note: Fields marked with a red asterisk (*) are required.
Salutation:
First Name:
*
Last Name:
*
Email:
*
Nickname:
*
Note: Nick name will be shown when you post comments.
Address 1:
*
Address 2:
City:
*
State:
*
Zip:
*
Phone:
      
Your daily must-read of conservative columns, cartoons and news. Coulter, Sowell, Krauthammer and more.
(Bi-Weekly) We highlight the best opportunities from our partners for surveys, action items and more.