Townhall.com, Where Your Opinion Counts
Talk Radio:   Bill Bennett   Mike Gallagher   Dennis Prager   Michael Medved   Hugh Hewitt   
BREAKING NEWS  LeftArrow - Townhall.com : Conservative, Political, Republican   RightArrow - Townhall.com : Conservative, Political, Republican  
Columns, funnies & more in your inbox!
  • Check the boxes and send us your email address to receveive your free newsletter
  • Your daily must-read of conservative columns, cartoons and news. Coulter, Sowell, Krauthammer and more.
  • Townhall.com’s weekly inside scoop on what’s happening behind the scenes in the world of politics. When news breaks, we report.
  • Signup to receive the latest daily Townhall cartoons
Sunday, March 29, 2009
Paul Jacob :: Townhall.com Columnist
The crisis hits in waves
by Paul Jacob
Vote on It:
Average Vote:
[+] Text [-]
 
 
Poll
Will the Dems' health care Christmas Present to America be an improvement or detriment to our health care system?


I get confused about the economy as much as the next guy. For days — indeed, weeks — I can go about my life without understanding what the Sam Hill is going on.

The bad news is I’m not alone.

The worse news? Our leaders are not only just as confused as you and me, but they actually manage to cause much of our mutual confusion.

Case in point: The way our leaders have been talking, they are spending our future trillions to stimulate today’s economy.

The trouble with talk of stimulus is that it turns out we are not in a liquidity crisis. The trouble is not that banks don’t have, or haven’t had, enough money to loan (hence the talk of “liquidity”). The horrible truth this time around is that banks suffer from accounts that just don’t add up. Their capital appears to have evaporated with the decline in housing prices and the mortgage bubble, leaving them unable to cover future bursts of unpayable loans.

Though our leaders from Bush and Paulson to Obama and Geithner talk about stimulus and liquidity and stuff like that, the eventual and “better” rationale for giving money to the banks was not so that they’d make loans, but that they’d have enough capital to cover future defaults.

Defaults which, alas, appear to be coming in several big waves.

There’s evidence that one of the next waves of economic crises to hit us is the collapse of a whole array of pension funds. It turns out that a lot of managed funds have taken more and more risk in the past few decades. And you know what that means.

As a fascinating article in Reason puts it, there’s been a further destabilizing element added in recent memory: So-called “moral investing.” Goody-two-shoe types have played the piper’s tune and enticed a lot of investors and fund managers to take their lemmings (I mean earnings) and sock them away in businesses that are “good” — not in the sense of profitable or secure, but in the sense of “moral,” “trendy,” or just plain “politically correct.” That makes the funds and the investments themselves less secure, as money has gone from likely winners to pipe dreams.

When pension funds collapse, things can get pretty bad.

Of course, things are looking bad on any number of fronts.

We have been reminded a lot, recently, that, since the establishment of FDIC, no one has lost money in a U.S. bank in an account insured by the FDIC. But the head of the FDIC recently upped insurance on accounts. Why? She blurted out the truth: The account insurance system may itself be insolvent.

Panic ensues. People with lots of dough (not me) have been pulling cash from banks in the hundreds of thousands, the millions.

On a bright note, the sales of safes are way up.

Somehow, I don’t think that’s the stimulus our leaders were aiming at.

Though every downturn, like every spurt of progress, is different, this downturn has more than a whiff of the stench of the Great Depression about it. What reeks? Our sense of the future.

An economy such as ours depends on a sense of stability about the future. It rests on stable policy, and the perception of same. The only thing stable about the stories coming from the White House has been the huge hunks of money being doled out. Everything else has been contradictory and at cross-purpose.

Fear itself. Roosevelt was right, that is the biggest problem. But Roosevelt was wrong moving beyond this homily: His flailing from policy to policy gave the investment sector a sense of paralyzing fear. Capital was withheld. The depression drew on and on.

And it’s happening all over again. The policy announcements, the revisions, the regrets — they keep on coming from the White House and Capital Hill. And the swings from rationale-to-rationale can have a horrible cumulative effect, dashing all expectations of hope and confidence in policy, signaling to investors to withdraw from investing.

Yet even that isn’t the worst of it. The worst of it is our gargantuan government debt, both explicit (issued and traded and monetized) and implicit (promised in the form of “entitlements” like Social Security and Medicare). Looming over our nation’s head has been this ever-growing public debt. Debt cannot continue to grow and grow.

This is where the current administration’s blunderings, like the last one’s, are so dangerous. Both have panicked, insisting on doing “something” so as to appear to have courage and resolve and all that, while in truth showing little else but very empty hands. And heads.

Of course, if you don’t look closely, it looks like a plan. It’s money. Money, money, and more money.

But no matter how much research we do trying to make sense of our current economic predicament, and the shifting rationales of leaders’ bedrock policy — no matter whether your explanations tend to lean Post Keynesian or monetarist or Austrian or what-have-you — one truth remains abundantly evident: it’s money we don’t have, and spending it increases debt. And that hastens the final wave, the last wave. A tsunami.

Our politicians, too shortsighted to see the damage they do, continue to draw nearer that last wave of financial disaster.

It’s all these trillions spent. And owed. The Congressional Budget Office recently reported that its estimate of the national debt is $2.3 trillion more than figured by Obama’s team. And while Congress trusts the CBO rather than any administration’s BS, astute observers of debt know that both estimates are far too low.

Spend a trillion here, a trillion there, and pretty soon it adds up to . . . unreal money, as the dollar collapses, inflation goes hyper, and the real crisis begins.

Share:
Vote on It:
Average Vote:
 
About The Author
Paul Jacob is President of Citizens in Charge. His daily Common Sense commentary appears on the Web, via e-mail, and on radio stations across America.
 
TOWNHALL DAILY: Sign up today and receive Townhall.com daily lineup delivered each morning to your inbox.
Sounds
like Germany before their militeary build up. Those folks were taking wheelbarrels of money to buy a loaf of bread.

Uhh when pension funds collapse
the benefits get frozen. They don't go away - they're as insured as a bank account. The government corporation that handles that is called the Pension Benefit Guaranty Corporation (PBGC).

"and the real crisis begins"
Gee, I wonder who the left will use as a scapegoat?

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Christian

hahaha
The government cannot even cover one corporation, let alone "the pension funds" - not along ago the airlines issues set them to be drained - I guess a couple trillion printed up a couple more times 'ell cover though - at the oft reduced rate...
20 years of doubling and trpling and overspending even as the economy grew like wildfire is coming home to roost. Inflationary home pricing and building induced by libtard government was fine as it was all going up, huh, but now the extra fake trillions of "government induced hyper value" are deflating ... and the shenanigans are exposed to the public, who frankly didn't have a clue.
I guess the next fake bubble is the green economy to come - with the robber libbers to gank the funds from people who buy energy, meaning EVERYONE including the dirt poor, and funnel it to their sick, disgusting, make me wanna puke psycho libtard jacks that we'll have to listen to spewing ROHS gaia religion lies for DECADES to come.
"WE'RE DESTROYING THE EARTH" "WE'RE DESTROYING THE EARTH" "WE'RE DESTROYING THE EARTH"
Just think, we'll be hearing that for decades, and then CENTURIES...

hoodaticus
You're wrong.

If we have a small amount of pension fund insolvency the PBGC could step in and take over the funds, although the pensioners benefits may get reduced significantly in the process.

PBGC has no ability to "insure" the coming collapse. FDIC has no ability to "insure" bank deposits once bank failures hit a critical threshold.

Their only option would be to apply for their own bailout, and the gov't would respond using more money that was conjured up out of thin air.

PBGC was in trouble even before the current financial woes, and I feel confident that their position has not improved since last October.

No Plan?
They got a plan. Create economic catastrophe, use catastrophe to scare the crap out of everybody, convinced terrified population to give up the rights, put government in charge of everything.

Sounds like a plan.

What's next?
I agree with TruLib. Also creating Mass Confusion and Distractions to implement "closed door" government changes. Unfortunately, the vast majority of the low income and younger population do not care, nor understand what is happening. This administration has very little "transparency"!

Is Centralized Banking the next step in BO's plan? Implement Soro's Super Currency?

Social Collapse
Yesterday my daughter brought to my attention an interesting article. It was 'Best Practices to Survive Total Social Collapse'. It's the transcript of an 1 1/2 hour speech given to the Long Now Foundation on Feb. 13 of this year by Dmitri Orlov.

Orlov says: "So that’s what we have now. The ship is on the rocks, water is rising, and the captain is shouting “Full steam ahead! We are sailing to Afghanistan!” Do you listen to Ahab up on the bridge, or do you desert your post in the engine room and go help deploy the lifeboats? If you thought that the previous episode of uncontrolled debt expansion, globalized Ponzi schemes, and economic hollowing-out was silly, then I predict that you will find this next episode of feckless grasping at macroeconomic straws even sillier. Except that it won’t be funny: what is crashing now is our life support system: all the systems and institutions that are keeping us alive. And so I don’t recommend passively standing around and watching the show – unless you happen to have a death wish."

http://cluborlov.blogspot.com/2009/02/social-collapse-best- practices.html

Of course more important than being able to read the sign of the times is knowing what to do about them. David Wilkerson, the founder of Teen Challenge and the pastor of Times Square Church has said the Holy Spirit told him to stock up 30 days supply of non-perishable food because of riots and fires in our major cities.

http://davidwilkersontoday.blogspot.com/2009/03/urgent-mess age.html

Unfortunately, 30 days supply of food isn't going to help much in case of a total social collapse. Neither are guns.

But there is one who is able to help. "The Lord is good. A stronghold in the day of trouble; And He knows those who trust in Him. Nahum 1:7-8

He was able to take care of Elijah for 3 years in the midst of a drought caused famine. 1 Kings 17-18

He can care for us if we put our trust in Him.

2 Chronicles 7:14

This is how pensions collapse
In NJ, TPAF and PERS (teacher and pub. employee) pension funds must be paid for by employee, employer, and the State.

The State, in infinite wisdom. invested in the dot.coms and when they collasped in the late 90s, the State lost money it has never been able to replace.

Mush of PERS was invested through Lehman and lost all of it when the gov't bailed out every Tom, Dick, and Harry but let Lehman fail.

Now, Jon Corzine, formally of Goldman-Saks, having already lost another $1 billion in my pension, wants to INVEST IN TOXIC ASSESTS. He thinks that's a way to double down (spent too many days in Atlantic City?) and get back all the money lost or never funded.

I worked 30 years in pub. school teaching and paid my pension dues, my school district paid their share, by the State has renigged on its responsibilities--

just as Cong. has promoted Fannie and Freddie and CRAs when you cannot give loans to people incapable of repaying them if you want a solvent financial industry.

But Cong. didn't care (see Barney Frank and Chris Dodd remarks in 2003 and 2005) because they were getting votes and great press out of their housing miracles. Now, it was all Bush' fault.

This krap started with FDR and his great exp. with Keynesian ec.'s that don't work, always create deficits and debts, and is strangling the US as I write.

reply#9
totally misses the point. When an individual makes purchases based on moral conviction (as I do by buying toyotas and hondas so I won't be supporting the Densocrats throuh union dues transfers)he is acting for himself and himself only. When a pension plan does it, it is dragging along many otherwise unwilling participants,much the same way that socialist and Densocrats do when they force other citizens to participate in their social justice ponzi schemes.

A lot of shoes are dropping
World trade is falling off a cliff as we speak, with Japan dropping 50% in Feb. If lots of pension funds go down, that will be very deflationary, and will make a lot of retirees boiling mad. Conjuring (printing) up new money to replace money that has disappeared is OK since a simple replacement is not inflationary. But at some point, money printing becomes very inflationary - and you don't know what that tipping point is until you reach it.

One more time for the dense
Capitalism is like a machine. With no govenor controlling the output it frequently oscillates out of control into destruction/depression. Since that nasty old man, FDR, we have not had a depression, until now. The govenor he put in place was financial regulation. Those regulations were removed in '99 and it took 9 years for the economy to oscillate out of control. So much for government being the problem.

If you fear a total social collapse, head for the hills. Sell your assets, but the survivalist gear, and leave. Let the sane weather the storm and prosper.

Bail out the institutions and fire the staff.


What banking regs. or stock market
or houseing regulations were removed in 1999, under Pres. Clinton?

We have nothing but regulation, everywhere all of the time. Tax law takes up two volunes about 3 feet in width each. You cannot carry them individually.

Fed. regulations now run into the tens of thousands of pages.

What happened ec. was in 1938, FDR started Freddie Mac to promote house buying when people regarded mortgages as one of the 7 deadly sins.

Johnson started Fannie Mae to promote house buying in his war on poverty. To a degree, Freddie and Fannie made sense as people with houses are better citizens, neighbors, and workers.

Then Carter invented the Community Re-investment Act in 1977 (and Clinton added to it in 1992) to promote sales and insurance in slum areas banks usually avoided. It also required penalities for practicing discrimination if 10% of a bank's portfolio were not *bad debts.* That's a presciption for BANKruptcy.

As long as we were in the Reagan boom that began in 1983 and was little affected for 25 years, those drags of the system worked. But when too many people who could not or would not pay for their loans accrued into those acts and orgs., the US credit markets froze.

That's what happened and is still happening because Freddie, Fannie, the CRA's, and the idiots who think you can tell banks to lend to crooks and deadbeats and yet have a successful ec. are still in place and the party of Keynes is in admin.

When enough houses are foreclosed and enough banks have failedm, eventually capitalism will correct itself. But in the meantime, the Big O and ilk are busy cluttering up the works with borrowed debt and insupportable budgets and programs.

The Depression
I lived through the depression and we are thare again. Paul Jacob is absolutely correct in what he says. I beleive that it took a world war to pull us out of it. Am I correct?

Where do the
old and infirm people go when there is no longer money for Medicare, social security and other critical entitlements? When the dollars sent to them are inflated past any real worth? Argentina had hyper-inflation beginning in the late 80's. Retirement accounts and pensions were destroyed. Dollar savings were replaced by dint of government fiat into rapidly inflating pesos. All suffered but worst off of all were the fixed-income retired. When one's monthly pension will buy a few hundred loaves of bread at the beginning of the inflation cycle but only a few slices at it's crest and all welfare has disappeared, where do the helpless old men and women go?
Perhaps Sen. Grassly, dem. Iowa's ad hominem advice for the AIG bonus boyos could be re-tooled for the millions of elder Americans that he and his corrupt party are fast pushing to the abyss. "Jump, you worthless bas*^&ds!"

A Case Study in Moral Investment
MediaCircus.com has documented a case study in moral investment. We're currently living through it's impact. It shows how Barack Obama and ACORN sued Citibank under CRA to force it to make bad loans.

"Posted on 03 October 2008

Do you remember how we told you that the Democrats and groups associated with them leaned on banks and even sued to get them to make bad loans under the Community Reinvestment Act which was a factor in causing the economic crisis (see HERE ) well look at what some fellow bloggers have dug up while researching Obamas legal career. Looks like a typical ACORN lawsuit to get banks to hand out bad loans.

In these lawsuits, ACORN makes a bogus claim of Redlining (denying poor people loans because of their ethnic heritage). They protest and get the local media to raise a big stink. This stinkmeans that the bank faces thousands of people closing their accounts and get local politicians to lobby to stop the bank from doing some future business, expansions and mergers. If the bank goes to court, they will win, but the damage is already done because who is going to launch a big campaign to get the banks reputation back?

It is important to understand the nature of these lawsuits and what their purpose is.ACORN filed tons of these lawsuits and ALL of them allege racism."

I know it won't have any influence on the liberals trolling these sites. They can't handle the truth. It would destroy their vision of themselves, and of the world in which they live. It's much easier to blame everything on George Bush and the Republicans. But if the truth is broadcast widely enough and boldly enough, sooner or later it will begin to have impact even if not on those whose whole self identity lies in their moral superiority to the rest of us and to the culture as a whole.

http://www.mediacircus.com/2008/10/obama-sued-citibank-unde r-cra-to-force-it-to-make-bad-loans/

2 Chronicles 7:14

Thanks for reading Reason Magazine
It's nice to see that Mr. Jacob reads Reason. the libertarian's have all the good ideas. But of course, these were the ideas of our founding fathers: limited government, free minds and free markets.

The bailouts will lead to more of the same, and either our government will hyper inflate away their obligations, or default on them. It would be better to let failing firms fail, and have it sorted out in bankruptcy court. Now we're encouraging irresponsible behaviour, and as Economics 101 tells us, when we subsidize something, we'll get more of it. And since we're punishing responsible behaviour (taxing people to pay for this) we can expect less of that. God help us.

Cause of Recessions
Bleeding Heart Liberal thinks “Capitalism is like a machine. With no govenor (sic) controlling the output it frequently oscillates out of control into destruction/depression.”

He rejects business cycle theory and fails to grasp the economic distortions these regulations cause. Economists call these “malinvestments.” To restore economic health, they need to be liquidated, the proceeds transferred to more appropriate areas, and then reinvested.

During this process, a drop in production and standard of living is inevitable. If left “untreated,” a recession should last roughly 12 to 18 months. His hero, FDR, dragged out the Depression for a decade by trying to keep businesses afloat that had to fail and trying to keep wages unrealistically high.

The point of regulation is to protect existing businesses from competition, not to prevent inevitable business cycles. Efforts to “dodge” recessions necessarily postpone and exacerbate the problem.

The twin policies of abolishing legal tender laws (which allows consumers to choose the most stable currencies) and deregulation (which allows them to go about their business unmolested) would prevent most of the economic distortions that make recessions inevitable.

Mark Read Pickens

Capitalism with a conscience
or compassionate corporatism or whatever name it is given has been practiced by corporate America for decades. I first heard the concept given a name from a politically incoherent lib friend who travels the world in her flip flops, sponging off people she barely knows, and soaking up all the anti-American opinions she hears. She thinks US companies should "pay a living wage" to their factory workers abroad. I one time did the necessarily short Socratic seminar, then realized I was wasting my time. A Marxist is a Marxist, whether they know it or not.

It cost US consumers millions in extra costs to have some corporation such as GE tout its do-gooder philanthropy in a full page ad. Why do I want GE, or worse yet, my Iroquois Power and Light Company, building a park or a playground somewhere? That is corporate self-promotion which results in higher prices. Grrrrr

David, you're right.
They're NOT as insured as a bank account. Not even close, actually. Thanks for that correction.

Not to worry ...
about silly paper money. Soon we'll all have our chip and all the budens of life will be lifted from our shoulders.
Hail to our Dark Lord Obama and his Satanic Minions!
Sign Up to Post Your CommentsSign Up to Post Your Comments
If you are already registered, click here to login. Otherwise, please take a few seconds to register with Townhall.com. Once you sign up, you’ll be able to post your comments immediately, use the action center, get podcasts, and more!
Note: Fields marked with a red asterisk (*) are required.
Salutation:
First Name:
*
Last Name:
*
Email:
*
Nickname:
*
Note: Nick name will be shown when you post comments.
Address 1:
*
Address 2:
City:
*
State:
*
Zip:
*
Phone:
      
Your daily must-read of conservative columns, cartoons and news. Coulter, Sowell, Krauthammer and more.
(Bi-Weekly) We highlight the best opportunities from our partners for surveys, action items and more.