Townhall.com, Where Your Opinion Counts
Talk Radio:   Bill Bennett   Mike Gallagher   Dennis Prager   Michael Medved   Hugh Hewitt   
BREAKING NEWS  LeftArrow - Townhall.com : Conservative, Political, Republican   RightArrow - Townhall.com : Conservative, Political, Republican  
Columns, funnies & more in your inbox!
  • Check the boxes and send us your email address to receveive your free newsletter
  • Your daily must-read of conservative columns, cartoons and news. Coulter, Sowell, Krauthammer and more.
  • Townhall.com’s weekly inside scoop on what’s happening behind the scenes in the world of politics. When news breaks, we report.
  • Signup to receive the latest daily Townhall cartoons
Sunday, October 12, 2008
Paul Jacob :: Townhall.com Columnist
Seems like old times
by Paul Jacob
Vote on It:
Average Vote:
[+] Text [-]
 
Poll
Was the Copenhagen Global Warming Summit Walk-Out a Win for the U.S.?


In the 14th century, the Black Death hit Italian shores and quickly spread. People panicked, sought causes, tried to find someone to blame.

Today, American finance goes into crisis, and the crisis quickly spreads. People (particularly politicians) panic, seek causes, someone to blame.

In medieval Europe, they rounded up the usual suspects: First the Jews, then the heretics, then witches. Not even cats were safe (according to some accounts) since, as “everyone knew,” cats were witches’ “familiars.” Members of these groups were killed in great numbers, burned at the stake, hung, thrown into bogs. It was not pleasant.

The “usual suspects” got attention in our current crisis, too. Who’s to blame? “Wall Street greed” and “unregulated markets” and the like. Hordes of Democrats said the fault lied with Republicans. I have heard no small number of Republicans return the favor.

Then, just to show how modern we all are, there were no killings. Instead, the two parties got together and threw money at the offenders.

We’ve come a long way, baby.

Finding Causes
The Jews, of course, had nothing to do with causing the plague. I’m convinced witches were likewise completely innocent of the charges.

And the cats? Well, house cats may have provided Europeans with their only advantage, for cats killed the rats that nurtured and transported and transmitted the plague. By panicking, Europeans may have made their lot worse than it would otherwise have been.

You might think we would have grown up by now, would now know enough not to panic. Still, the rush to judgment has been swift . . . and as unerringly wrong-headed as a medieval conspiracy theorist.

First one major institution, then another, was taken over by the federal government. More are threatened by Bush’s new nationalization procedures. The old guard of political insiders, on both sides of the aisles, praised these moves. The only politicians to oppose the take-overs in significant number were first-term Republicans in Congress. (More evidence that incumbent expertise isn’t worth shoring up with unlimited terms in office.)

The awful truth of a burst bubble is the specter of bankruptcy. A lot of people just cannot stand the very idea. They’ll do anything to postpone it, if they can.

Yet there’s an awful lot of evidence that you just have to weather these periods, not “prop things up.” The post-Great War depression in Britain, and America’s own early days in the Great Depression show as much: Both regimes worked mightily to prevent a huge sector of prices from hitting their natural floors. In those cases, it was mainly wages that got propped up. The effect? Massive unemployment.

Today we fear that housing prices will hit their natural floors (so to speak), and try to prevent the downward motion of economic gravity. And we shall reap “idle resources” for the effort. It will not be pleasant.

Already, after committing about a trillion dollars to propping up the major players that so miserably failed, the stock market goes into its own special panic, indicating that the investment crowd is not exactly assured by government that piecemeal nationalization is the proper response to a crisis.

There are a number of causes of the current crisis. But to understand the response, you have to keep in mind something else: fear of widespread bankruptcies.

And it’s not just about the mortgage fiasco. Or banks. Or financial intermediaries. The current crisis reveals three previously hidden forms of bankruptcy.

A Bankruptcy of Expertise
All those experts who goaded us into buying homes we could not afford, who said that housing prices could only go up and up and up . . . they don’t look so smart now, do they?

The very system these geniuses set up, to hedge risk in the mortgage markets, turns out to have had all the ingenuity of Marxism.

The trouble with socialism was that, without a market in producers’ goods, planners couldn’t calculate the value of the goods at their disposal. Unable rationally to plan to meet consumer needs, planners were left producing too many of the wrong kinds of shoes, not enough of the kinds wanted.

Marxians ended up looking like the biggest kind of fools.

Our business experts followed suit, designing a system that split up mortgages so that risk could be managed. However, their mechanism was so complicated that it could only make sense when markets were relatively stable. (Yes, these bozos thought markets could only go up and up, forever.) It was doomed to chaos when markets spiraled out of “equilibrium” or its real-world makeshift equivalent.

The hedge market for commercial capital became similarly cumbersome, similarly opaque during a crisis.

Most experts look like fools now. Let’s remember this, as we go forward. Advice-taker, beware.

Bankruptcy of Policy Smarts
Speaking of bad advice, look to our political class.

Right away George W. Bush provided the “money” statement: He said we should solve the problem immediately, worry about its causes later.

You cannot solve a problem you do not understand.

The underlying cause? The house of cards the experts built was erected on the basis of federal policy. For decades, the federal government has been trying to “put people into houses” that they could not afford. It has been a multi-pronged effort. Hence the many prongs provoking our current pain.

That’s the nature of government activism: It is usually activated to fix previous government activism.

I am not the one to debate all the alleged “solutions.” But I know enough to be suspicious of most. Investor Jim Rogers’s statement — that America, with its multiple bailouts is already “more communist than China” — is worth thinking about.

Our leaders, of course, would sell us into socialist slavery in a blink, if it gets them re-elected. In fact, that appears to be exactly what they are doing.

The Looming Federal Bankruptcy
This is just the tip of a Titanic iceberg. The current crisis is nothing compared to the likely bankruptcy of the United States government itself.

Deficits soar. Neither major-party candidate plans to balance a budget in his first four years. The debt balloons. And now our politicians add multiple multi-billion-dollar bailouts onto this mess.

What happens when the government cannot maintain this debt? What happens when foreigners will not buy our bonds?

Meanwhile, journalists question political candidates as if the mortgage crisis and the attendant liquidity crisis were the worst thing we can imagine.

Much of the panic in Washington may (just perhaps) be based on the fear that the current market implosion will usher in the government’s own, much larger bankruptcy. And yet massive bailouts — piling debt upon debt — make the doom scenario not only more inevitable but also more imminent.

It would make more sense to kill cats.

Share:
Vote on It:
Average Vote:
 
About The Author
Paul Jacob is President of Citizens in Charge. His daily Common Sense commentary appears on the Web, via e-mail, and on radio stations across America.
 
TOWNHALL DAILY: Sign up today and receive Townhall.com daily lineup delivered each morning to your inbox.
No complaint...
--
...either in amplification or contravention.

Bravo, Mr. Jacob.




=====
"The wavelike movement affecting the economic system, the recurrence of periods of boom which are followed by periods of depression, is the unavoidable outcome of the attempts, repeated again and again, to lower the gross market rate of interest by means of credit expansion. There is no means of avoiding the final collapse of a boom brought about by credit expansion. The alternative is only whether the crisis should come sooner as the result of a voluntary abandonment of further credit expansion, or later as a final and total catastrophe of the currency system involved."

-- Ludwig von Mises

Wells Fargo
My son would love this article.

The Coming 920 Billion Dollar Bailout
has been sponsored by Obama and has already passed Biden's Foreign Relations Committee in the Senate. Immense pressure is being placed on McShame and Sarah Palin by BONO and his media influence to sign on to this Socialist taxpayer giveaway to the world.


http://www.newswithviews.com/Kincaid/cliff257.htm

We've secretly replaced the Republican
leadership with a bunch of big-government socialists. Let's see if anyone notices.

It's a real shame the Democrats are even worse, because the GOP needs a ballot box butt kicking in the worst way.

When The Foreigners Call In The Debt
We will be working directly for Chinese, Russian, and mid-easterners as they take over our remaining industry. What is a bankrupt US? A printing press. Our politicians and appointees along with the MSM have killed US industry, money, borders, sovereignty, religion, and values. It is no longer bad to do these things, people get rewarded for doing them.

Finally a Coherent Expose
Your article is right on reality versus spin.
California was the precursor in what liberal mismanagement over many years will result in. California is bankrupt financially, economically, morally and spiritually, with a credit rating as bad as that of sinkhole Bolivia.
America (DC) is indeed well on it's way too!
Foreigners have lost confidence in our "virtual" credibility we've been riding on based on past glory.
The market isn't stupid, the recent free fall takes into account the inevitability of further socialistic policies regardless of who is elected. Should Obama get elected, you will see the largest capital flight from one country in world's history.
China, Brazil, India, Singapore and other smaller countries have taken over from the United States the production of tangible wealth. Selling hamburgers to each other may be nice but it doesn't produce wealth.
The only way out for us is to eliminate capital gains taxes and all business taxes plus 80% of the mostly frivolous regulations so we can atract industries back here to produce wealth.
We have outregulated and out taxed our businesses creating a hostile environment for thm. Why does everyone wonder why business go offshore ? They don't have a choice ! If they stay they go broke.

We Need a Witch Hunt!
A lot went into this debacle. Bush's compassionate conservatism where you bend the economic rules just a little bit to prove you really are not a bad old Republican who rigidly believes in following the rules and the Democrats' eternal surrender of commonsense to accommodate their constituency of liberal fat cats, hourly workers, minorities, and the welfare class for votes.

But guess what? We're in the process of re-electing the same people who caused this crash. Electing the same people involved in a catastrophe and expecting different results is the definition of insanity.

We should have a "witch hunt" with a symbolic burning at the stake of our so-called representatives so they might think twice before taking actions that lead a whole country over the cliff.

This is a war and the enemy is ensconced in the Capitol. Citizens need to start throwing a lot of tomatoes.




Egon
And of course, you are the perfect example of capital flight while you could still buy something with an American dollar. And Obama's solution is tax the rich and the consensus DC solution is print more money and give it away. Well, it was nice while it lasted. Only my grandchildren, and the families old farm keep me here.

Jerseyvet
Or Molotov cocktails.

Low income housing
Anyone that has owned a house for very long comes to understand why Lowes and Home Depot do very well. There are a lot more costs involved in home ownership than simply paying the mortgage. Just how anyone could encourage people to buy homes they can barely afford is way beyond my comprehension.

Pistol FL
You are right, sorry to say so. Yet we are glad we did it in the nick of time, 4 years ago.
We have managed to build some capital in the past few years and would gladly invest over here again, but only if we can at least see a light at the end of the proverbial tunnel : A friendlier business environment. I doubt that I will live to see that.
Let's hope that there will still be an election in 2012 - My vote is for Gov.Palin.

Regardless of the sense of his article
There is a lot of failure to lay blame where it is due. You can talk about mismanagment of government, you can talk about socialism, etc. However, unless you place the blame where it belongs and only where it belongs, the forcing by the Clinton administration, of mortgage bankers and lenders, to loan money to the poor and minorities, even using their ability to pay utilities and their welfare checks as evidence of ability to pay mortgages above their ability, with the consequent moving of mortgages to Freddie Mac and Fannie Mae, and the denial of problems that were clearly evident, and denied by the likes of Barney Frank and his buddies in the Democrat Party, and even when the whole thing began to unravel, these same people blamed George W. Bush for their own evil crimes, you cannot make sense of this situation. This short summary of the true facts are what caused the breakdown of the financial markets. I do not believe the United States will go bankrupt. Talk like that is panic talk. The markets will recover and prosper, just like markets always do. The free market will react and recover, just like it always does. Relax and have faith.

The reason why
you have more and more government intervention in the markets, as well as other aspects of our lives, is because we as a society have become weak and do not want to accept responsibility or consequences for our actions.

That includes the politicians.

The solution looks like the problem
You don't pour water on a drowning man, yet that is what the government is doing. Government-private partnerships have great potential to distort markets and can lead to collapses. A small example is the ethanol subsidies to ease fuel prices; food prices increased. Take away the subsidies and the ethanol industry collapses because it is not competitive.

Tax breaks and subsidies to provide housing for more Americans artificially increased demand. With increased demand and lower mortgage rates, the prices were artificially increased. A bubble like this eventually has to come to an end, and here we are. Now the government is going to "solve" this problem with more market intervention, rather than letting the markets take their natural course. And Obama has plans for even more government-private cooperation, such as alternative fuels and health care. In general, liberals don't trust free markets and feel an obligation to regulate, control, and direct them. It really doesn't work very well.

So, folks, batten down the hatches. More storms are coming.

And It Is Well Underway
Even now, the Glorious Peoples Heroic Revolutionary Commissar Of Wealth will decide which businesses can succeed and which will fail. The Commissariat Of Wealth will also be deciding how much CEOs can earn. And guess what: a similar cap on YOUR earnings comes next.

Welcome to the U.S.S.A.

It's all about the debt.
Ah, but the GOP is bailing as fast as the Democrats. That should make us all feel good. But the article, how true it is. State and Local Government debt, Federal debt, and consumer debt. It's all about debt. And yes, if it makes you feel good, you're already working for the Chinese, the Arabs, and the Japanese. After all, they have all that Federal debt. And if we expect to keep running deficits, and we do, and bailout homeowners and banks, and are, we will just have to borrow even more. It's an easy ride down on cheap money, it's a much tougher one back when you have to earn it.

lanczos, I'm just waiting for Paulson
to publish a five year plan...

Isn't that what good central planners are supposed to do?

Mis-directed Anger...
Whoever is in office should be held accountable from the start.

All the big bold talk from Republican citizens who couldn't keep their President Bush from building the largest federal government of all time. As Bush encouraged and built the trillion dollar debt, mortgaged the future, had cronies run Katrina debacle, had crony friends get awful rich on the war that was built on a lie, Iraq is a bit late. We should have been in Afghanistan from the get go after 9/11. Bush used the evangelicals to get elected and then kicked them to the side. You got clowned by your party leaders. Damn, I would be mad as hell.

INTEREST,INTEREST,INTEREST
REMENBER BEFORE GREED TOOK OVER AND INTEREST WAS MAX 7% AND LOAN SHARKS BECAME BIG BANKS.CREDI CARD INTEREST NOW CLOSE TO 30%, MANY FEES. BORROW $100 CAN DON'T PAY YOUR MONTHY PAYMENT AFTER A YEAR YOU WILL STILL OWE +++OVER $500. NOW THAT IS WHAT I CALL GREED.

It is not just the President's fault
In this case it goes all the way back to President Clinton to President Bush and Congress of both presidents.

The bears and the bulls have always existed on Wall Street. What goes up MUST come down, especially when it's overinflated to begin with.

Capitalism on the way up and socialism on the way down is only postponing the inevitable. In the long run all this money (thrown after bad) is not going to stop the flood.

When our politicians....ALL of them, not just the President.....start keeping common sense laws instead of playing in Socialism, THEN it will right itself. Until then, hang on for the ride, folks.

The present state of things.
For socialism to take over with its "new" ideas (which are very old and total failures) the "old" has to be removed. The process has been going so gradually that society, like the frog in the kettle, has not gotten wise to it until it is too late--the frog is cooked. The Utopian ideas of the socialists are a total illusion yet they are hardly concerned for the massive consequence in any society when it is implemented. Oh, such death and destruction that has resulted in every case. If it is happening here in our own beloved country then we are seeing the end of the greatest democracy that ever existed. I grieve, and fear for the future. BUT our hope must be in God who is the true foundation of any worthwhile society. Will we tell Him "No" as has happened before.

9PM ET
SEAN HANNITY, OF HANNITY & COLMES ~ FOX NEWS, IS GOING TO AIR A VERYIMPORTANT DOCUMENTARY ABOUT BARACK OBAMA, SUNDAY NIGHT AT 9:00 PM. HE STATED ON THE AIR THIS EVENING THAT NO ONE IN THE NEWS MEDIA WAS WILLING TO DO THIS.

HANNITY IS GOING BACK TO OBAMA'S EARLIER DAYS, SHOWING EVEN THEN HIS TIES TO RADICAL PROFESSORS, FRIENDS, SPIRITUAL ADVISERS, Etc., HE STATED THIS EVENING THAT HE WILL SHOW IN DETAIL HIS TIES TO REV. WRIGHT FOR 20+ YRS
(which we all know) HOW HE WAS PARTICIPATING WITH THIS MAN, AND NOT FOR THE REASONS HE STATES!

HE HAS UNCOVERED MORE OF OBAMA'S RADICAL LEADERS AND WE WILL SEE THINGS THAT NO ONE IN THE MEDIA IS WILLING TO PUT OUT THERE.

THIS WILL BE A NIGHT THAT YOU WILL KNOW MORE ABOUT OBAMA THAN EVER BEFORE. HANNITY IS VERY PASSIONATE ABOUT THIS PROGRAM AND ASKED THAT EVERYONE PLEASE, PLEASE WATCH~~

SUNDAY NIGHT, 9 PM.

HANNITY IS DETERMINED THIS INFORMATION BE PUT OUT THERE BECAUSE AS AMERICANS, WE STILL DO NOT KNOW ABOUT OBAMA!! WAKE UP AMERICA!!

THIS IS SERIOUS,EVERYONE. I KNOW MOST OF YOU WATCH FOX NEWS, AND YOU KNOW WHO YOU ARE VOTING FOR, BUT IF YOU CAN, PLEASE PASS THIS ON TO EVERYONE YOU KNOW.

THIS IS CRITICAL FOR OUR COUNTRY. MY PRAYER IS THAT WE, ALONG WITH SEAN HANNITY, WILL REACH SOMEONE/ANYONE BEFORE NOV. 4th.

WE MUST NOT GIVE UP!!!!!!!!!


9PM ET
SEAN HANNITY, OF HANNITY & COLMES ~ FOX NEWS, IS GOING TO AIR A VERYIMPORTANT DOCUMENTARY ABOUT BARACK OBAMA, SUNDAY NIGHT AT 9:00 PM. HE STATED ON THE AIR THIS EVENING THAT NO ONE IN THE NEWS MEDIA WAS WILLING TO DO THIS.

HANNITY IS GOING BACK TO OBAMA'S EARLIER DAYS, SHOWING EVEN THEN HIS TIES TO RADICAL PROFESSORS, FRIENDS, SPIRITUAL ADVISERS, Etc., HE STATED THIS EVENING THAT HE WILL SHOW IN DETAIL HIS TIES TO REV. WRIGHT FOR 20+ YRS
(which we all know) HOW HE WAS PARTICIPATING WITH THIS MAN, AND NOT FOR THE REASONS HE STATES!

HE HAS UNCOVERED MORE OF OBAMA'S RADICAL LEADERS AND WE WILL SEE THINGS THAT NO ONE IN THE MEDIA IS WILLING TO PUT OUT THERE.

THIS WILL BE A NIGHT THAT YOU WILL KNOW MORE ABOUT OBAMA THAN EVER BEFORE. HANNITY IS VERY PASSIONATE ABOUT THIS PROGRAM AND ASKED THAT EVERYONE PLEASE, PLEASE WATCH~~

SUNDAY NIGHT, 9 PM.

HANNITY IS DETERMINED THIS INFORMATION BE PUT OUT THERE BECAUSE AS AMERICANS, WE STILL DO NOT KNOW ABOUT OBAMA!! WAKE UP AMERICA!!

THIS IS SERIOUS,EVERYONE. I KNOW MOST OF YOU WATCH FOX NEWS, AND YOU KNOW WHO YOU ARE VOTING FOR, BUT IF YOU CAN, PLEASE PASS THIS ON TO EVERYONE YOU KNOW.

THIS IS CRITICAL FOR OUR COUNTRY. MY PRAYER IS THAT WE, ALONG WITH SEAN HANNITY, WILL REACH SOMEONE/ANYONE BEFORE NOV. 4th.

WE MUST NOT GIVE UP!!!!!!!!!


Judith Oh Judith
Be sure to listen carefully Judith. I will be. I am truly anxious to hear what the FBI and CIA investigations have revealed. I want to hear how the Patriot Act has helped to expose Barack Obama. I am also anxious to hear how many other "terrorists" and "Muslims" have infiltrated our House, Senate and government. I so want to find out how Hammity has been able to discover his proof without the FBI or CIA involvement. It used to be that the front of terrorism was in Iraq. Has it now moved to Chicago?

This time it's different
Contrasting this situation with the Great Depression of the 1930's, I see a real problem here. In the 30's, government was relatively small, and consumed a far smaller proportion of GDP. Therefore, growth of government, in the form of the WPA and other agencies that provided jobs for people, were possible.

Now, government is a monster. It is already tapped out in terms of debt. It is already the largest employer in the nation. There is no more room to grow, no more money to borrow, no more programs or agencies that could be created without adding to an already unsustainable level of debt.

Has anyone even considered that the government's own demand for credit may have been instrumental in the crash?

I don't like
the bailout anymore then anyone else. Yet I also get John Mauldin's newsletter every week. He if very much free market and hates to say it but the government had to do it. In fact in his newsletter this last week he was talking globally. It isn't just the US. It is all over the place. Credit is freezing up bad. Banks won't lend to other bands. He is afraid that LOC will be next to go. Then we will be in big trouble. All of us. Not just the US.

off the mark
What a tortured analogy. And Jacob's account reflects a misunderstanding of the problem that Congress is trying to address.

The subprime mortgage mess that got us into this problem was primarily an issue of loans made by the least regulated sources.

But the current worry is not even directly about the high number of foreclosures, it is about the effect that has had on the avialability of credit. Even solid businesses make use of short term credit. And if such credit is prohibitively expensive then companies that are not themselves the source of the problem are in danger of going under.

Jacob's account starts with an assumption that there is a natural floor to these things so that suffering is manly since it is necessary. But credit is a matter of confidence. There is no reason to believe that the suffering is necessary. And no reason to value unnecessary suffering.

But if conservatives want to campaign on the value of letting people suffer because it is natural, they should go ahead.

VOTE AGAINST ALL INCUMBENTS!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Please join my crusade, to kick ALL these sorry, slimey, corrupt, sons o' bitches out of office!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Let foreigners purchase homes
If people from other countrys could buy up our
housing inventory we wouldn't have a housing
problem. This would prop up the price of existing housing and free up builders to be
more prudent in building up future inventory.

THE FAT CATS !!! THE DEMO RATS??????
THE FAT CATS SUPPLY THE JOBS THE DEMO-RATS,SPREAD THE KIM JUNG IL,TYPE NONSENSE!WE ARE BETTER OFF WITH THE CATS!
Sign Up to Post Your CommentsSign Up to Post Your Comments
If you are already registered, click here to login. Otherwise, please take a few seconds to register with Townhall.com. Once you sign up, you’ll be able to post your comments immediately, use the action center, get podcasts, and more!
Note: Fields marked with a red asterisk (*) are required.
Salutation:
First Name:
*
Last Name:
*
Email:
*
Nickname:
*
Note: Nick name will be shown when you post comments.
Address 1:
*
Address 2:
City:
*
State:
*
Zip:
*
Phone:
      
Your daily must-read of conservative columns, cartoons and news. Coulter, Sowell, Krauthammer and more.
(Bi-Weekly) We highlight the best opportunities from our partners for surveys, action items and more.