Townhall.com, Where Your Opinion Counts
Talk Radio:   Bill Bennett   Mike Gallagher   Dennis Prager   Michael Medved   Hugh Hewitt   
BREAKING NEWS  LeftArrow - Townhall.com : Conservative, Political, Republican   RightArrow - Townhall.com : Conservative, Political, Republican  
Columns, funnies & more in your inbox!
  • Check the boxes and send us your email address to receveive your free newsletter
  • Your daily must-read of conservative columns, cartoons and news. Coulter, Sowell, Krauthammer and more.
  • Townhall.com’s weekly inside scoop on what’s happening behind the scenes in the world of politics. When news breaks, we report.
  • Signup to receive the latest daily Townhall cartoons
Thursday, April 02, 2009
Paul Greenberg :: Townhall.com Columnist
The Entitled
by Paul Greenberg
Vote on It:
Average Vote:
[+] Text [-]
 
Poll
Do you feel the leaked information from a global warming alarmist organization is meaningful?



Every teaching assistant at a large state university has had the experience. At least I did as a TA in the University of Missouri's history department. Sometime during the semester you'd get a call from a junior assistant coach -- as new to the academic life as you were -- who just wanted to drop by and have a Coke.

How strange. I was mystified the first time it happened. What did he want, the pleasure of my company? Had he confused me with a football fan? Didn't he know that us intellectuals prefer baseball? Ah, the arrogance of youth. I kind of miss it.

After some puzzling small talk -- what do you think of this weather? where you from? -- my visitor got around to the point: He mentioned a student in a freshman survey course, a student whose name didn't register at once. Mainly because he just sat there without anything to say. His thoughts, if any, were clearly far away. Maybe on the football field?

It seems that said student had failed a quiz or two, not surprisingly, and he would make an awfully fine guard or tackle or whatever if only his grades were better and he stayed eligible, and could I see my way clear to ... well, even I could see where this was heading, and the conversation was closed.

The young coach had carried out his assignment, I'd done my duty, no hard feelings. That's the way it worked. Every system has its little accepted corruptions that accumulate like sludge on the gears. I don't know if that kind of visit still happens. It shouldn't.

There's been one big change since my days behind the lectern. It's no longer the coaches who appeal, wheedle, growl, grovel, or whatever it takes to raise a student's letter grade. It's the students themselves.

Naturally enough, a team of academics has written a paper about this sad trend. ("Self-Entitled College Students: Contributions of Personality, Parenting and Motivational Factors"). The syndrome now has a name (Academic Entitlement) and an abbreviation (AE) -- just like Attention Deficit/Hyperactivity Disorder (ADHD).

Doubtless there will soon be federal grants and endowed chairs to study AE and a drug to treat it. And sure enough, it'll turn out to be more widespread than anyone ever suspected.

The four scholars who did this Pioneering Study trace the origins of AE to parental pressure, material rewards for good grades, competitiveness, and "achievement anxiety and extrinsic motivation." They conclude that AE is "most strongly related to exploitive attitudes towards others and moderately related to an overall sense of entitlement and to narcissism."

At the risk of putting all that in plain English, these kids are spoiled brats with character problems. But how will they ever get over them if they're not allowed to fail -- and learn from their failures? If their mediocre performance is regularly rewarded with As and Bs, how will they learn the difference between excellent and run-of-the-mill?

The saddest aspect of these kids' condition is that they're unaware of it. They actually think they're pretty darned good, and deserve those good grades. More to be pitied than scorned, they may come out of school with no idea of what real accomplishment is, and the intrinsic satisfaction of doing something well.

They may never thrill at a formula elegantly devised, a mission truly accomplished, a sentence well written, a simple procedure done with care every time, an experiment perfected, a form that perfectly follows function....

Not for The Entitled the sense of awe that may be the first step toward God. If a teacher dropped one of these students off at the Metropolitan Museum of Art, he the might emerge a few hours later with only one question: Is this going to be on the test?

But why should they be any different from what they are? Raised in an age when self-esteem is all, they're told how great they are from K to 12 and may graduate without the faintest idea of what greatness is, or demands.

Consider this newly named syndrome another argument for universal military service. Call it Greenberg's Theorem: There's nothing wrong with these kids that six weeks of basic training at an Army base in some barren clime wouldn't cure -- if they didn't manage to have mama or papa get them out of it.

But if they stuck it out, they'd soon learn that it's results that count, not influence or manipulation. Or even effort if it's misplaced, if it amounts to nothing more than the same mistakes endlessly, energetically repeated.

To quote a deluded young senior at the University of Maryland: "I think putting in a lot of effort should merit a high grade. What else really is there than the effort that you put in?"

Well, for starters there is talent, insight, intention, humility, tolerance, an openness to criticism and a determination to learn from it. There is an appreciation for what is noble and contempt for what is base. And the love of knowledge for its own sake, not for the rewards it might bring, and . . . well, you get the point. Unless, of course, you think you're entitled.

Share:
Vote on It:
Average Vote:
 
About The Author

 
TOWNHALL DAILY: Sign up today and receive Townhall.com daily lineup delivered each morning to your inbox.
Shrinque
You're correct that I was guilty of ignoring the meat, such as it was, of the article, but only Mr. Greenberg knows what he meant when he said he did his duty.

"Every system has its little accepted corruptions that accumulate like sludge on the gears." I took that to mean he "played ball" with the athletic department; maybe I was wrong.

For the rest, I'm down with kenley.

How about a discussion of Greenberg's Theorem?

Does he really think that six weeks (months?) of boot camp could put a dent in childhood memories of the trophies for everyone mentality that has spread like herpes at a forty per cent discount dollar kissing booth?

The Madness of Students as Customers
As a college professor of over 25 years, I can tell you that another contributing factor is that students "evaluate" courses, and then these same student evaluations form the basis of Deans' assessments of "teaching quality." It has always struck me as odd to have students evaluate the quality of teaching provided by someone who has forgotten more than the student will ever know about the subject matter. This has become the norm in a world where students have become "customers" and University Presidents and School Deans pay so much attention to rankings of university quality by magazines that know little about the issues involved in education.

Academic Entitlement
I went to university during the Vietnam War when professors were loath to flunk students and expose them potentially to the draft.

But at least they had the integrity to give the goofoffs, myself included, a gentleman's C. I assume women got the same but since they weren't subject to the draft, I never bothered to check.

For all the deserved scorn
that college athletes reap for their inflated grades, at least they have experienced the true nature of competition and have, in the final analysis, flourished or failed on their own merits. Even if it wasn't in the classroom, they've "earned" something by hard work, talent, and commitment.

The same can not be said for many of the "intellectuals" who spent their college years drunk and drugged, and then "negotiated" their grades and degrees.

I agree that boot camp would help, but so would sports, starting young, and on teams where you can be benched, or dismissed, if you don't "make the grade"

I was a TA at the UM.
This was around 1979 when the program was about to take off. I had a football player who never came to class. I flunked him. My professor called me into the office with the message that "He's a football player. They work hard." We worked out a deal which called for the player to write a paper. The paper was insufficient. His citations were bogus. They were copied straight out of a chapter in the teaxt and were unrelated to what they were cited for. I gave him A C and wrote that "Football is a great game" on his paper. I thereafter lost the TA and had documented proff that a course grade was changed form B to D. Never did get the PhD. But UM did go on to have one hell of a football program.

PreMed Students are the worst
If Mr. Greenberg thought student athletes were bad, he should be grateful he wasn't a TA in the biological sciences... I never met a more grovelly bunch than pre Med students... Oh just thinking about it gives me heart burn... "Oh I can't get a B in this course... I'll never make it into Blank Medical School. Can you help me out?".... Maybe preLaw students are similar, I don't know? Never had a student that came to me in advance of a bad grade asking for help... Now that would have been refreshing.

Richard, it would appear . . .
. . . that you are the one who is confused. Mr. Greenberg's column addresses not student athletes but all students these days who have a sense of entitlement. The example he gave at the outset was from a time long gone when only the dumb jocks had that sense. And, if you would re-read the opening paragraphs closely, you would discover that Mr. Greenberg failed the dumb jock despite the Junior Assistant Coach's visit.

"Student athletes" do exist, but not in all institutions, however. Florida State, Clemson, Davidson, and Brown apparently have none.

Reply #19.
Like katie doesn't know anyone who voted for Bush, maybe you need to broaden your circle of exposure?

hmm
'Raised in an age when self-esteem is all, they're told how great they are from K to 12 and may graduate without the faintest idea of what greatness is, or demands.'

First of all isn't greatness subjective depending on what you value? ok....and

Who are these kids being told they're doing great when they're actually not? I have rarely witnessed this, and that is after 13 years of public education plus 6 more in a public college...plenty of work experience, my own family, friends families, etc

Like ParanoidMystic said, 'Whatever the solution is, I don't know, but some people go through life with a hunger to learn and some just don't.'

so
broad brush painting never works that well...who are 'The Entitiled'??? seems to me like every single person has at some point felt a sense of entitilment about something. What the hell?? What about the phrase 'I'm entitiled to my opinion'? What if it is about a subject in which you never studied/worked to understand? Are you still entitiled, and why?

Like I said, how is this not simply a negative aspect of human nature?


ok
this article could have been written in three sentences

1.Some aspects of human nature suck.

2.Some, do not suck.

3.One of the aspects that does indeed suck is a sense of entitlement about certain 'given' things that individuals feel (some much much more than others...kinda like greed)...end...

oh one more

4.Those who feel entitled to receive anything they havent worked for should get no respect for that sense of entitlement, while those who work for what they receive should. In my opinion it is ridiculous to try to make this a right/left issue

Simple Solution
There is no free lunch, no free education and the hard but honest answer is that we have to abolish the Public School system. It is the forced breeding grounds for the voting base the Liberals need. Forced - for those of us who pay the way of the many who have no skin in the game.

It is necessary to go on the offensive and illustrate the obvious deficiencies, such as literacy, integrity and accountability. This system needs to be shut down and done immediately.

The pending implosion of housing will make it an easy sell to the massive numbers of retirees in this country who will soon come to the realization that they own nothing. They may have paid their mortgage in full, but they will likely have a difficult time meeting the financial obligation of the Cities and Counties Lease Rates. Those people will run out of their homes en masse as those property tax bills rise at a much greater rate than their social security checks. The 'publicly funded' school system will be forced to collapse - as well it should.

Problem solved - fight scare tactics with REAL NUMBERS that are REALLY SCARY!

Socialism has created
professional loosers.

As a
society we are "aspiring to mediocrocy"

Unite and fight
Find a Tea Party, on line petitions, conservative ideas, newspapers, radio, blogs and more at, http://aresay.blogspot.com/

The True Story Of The Year!!!

I just returned from picking up my son at the airport; whereupon, I met the "Forrest Gump" of AirTran. This lovely, young African-American woman served as the meeter-greeter, counter agent, peanut provider and forgotten baggage representative for AirTran. When we were forced to meet last to discuss my son's lost baggage, she asked him to name some of the identifiable contents. He replied, among other things, that his luggage included an Ipod charger and speakers. And, how did this lovely woman respond? "That's too bad, you could have sent them to Queen Elizabeth II!"

What a wonderful treasure this young woman is and could she have responded is a more pointed manner?

AMERICAN EDUCATIONAL CABAL
I have worked in it for 35 years--as a special teacher that goes from school to school.

It is a frightening experience to see the mediocrity:

ONLY THE SCHOOL SYSTEM COULD FAIL LIKE THIS AND STILLBE FUNDED!

self esteem
My son always railed against his grades and the standard I set. Nothing below a "c" or there would be loss of priveleges. I was told that I didn't care about his self esteem or 'feelings'. My reply was always the same: self esteem comes with getting a good grade, good job, being a part of something good, etc. After Army basic training he came home with a different attitude and told me that he saw what I was trying to do and wasn't such a know-nothing hard head after all. The feel-good, no one fails movement started in the 80's has ruined our young people in particular and our society as a whole. No one is too good to fail!!

LIBERALS LOVES TEST
LIBERALS USE TEST AS A WAY TO SHOW NEED FOR THEIR GREED. NOT I.Q. TEST, NOT DNA TEST, NOR ANY TEST THAT CAN PROVE ANYTHING, THEY USE TEST TO CLAIM PREJUDICE. TEST SHOULD BE USED TO SEPARATE THE STUDENT FROM THE ENTRY LEVEL CAREER PERSON AND THEN ENHANCE THE SKILLS TO ENABLE BETTER PEOPLE.

Hahaha...
Boy this article was a treat.

I had a very difficult time in high school and college always hearing that often-asked question: "Will this be on the test?"

Whatever the solution is, I don't know, but some people go through life with a hunger to learn and some just don't.

When i give my
math students a test, i always pass out at least 3, sometimes 5 different versions, that pretty much look alike. Its the biggest favor i can do for my students. This way, the 40 0r 50 percent who would cheat quickly realize they have to learn the work. Also, the kids who really need help are very soon exposed. They'll thank me later.

The athlete salaries should motivate
So perhaps it is the enrollment policies. Many schools love the athletic program and enroll accordingly.

TownhallPlus.com

Whiners Keep On Whining

It started with the Great Society, then The Dumbing Down Of America, and continued with parents' giving their children everything even if it bankrupted the households. Now, we have the whiners, who have never done anything, demanding even more.

Take a look at the New York Time's slime of the clownish behavior in London during the G20:

http://thelede.blogs.nytimes.com/2009/04/02/protesters-fail -to-bring-down-global-capitalism-with-costumes-puppets/

And, guess what? The whiners are coming to New York City in September for the next G20 meeting.

Richard
Only 2 or 3 out of 100,000 are qualified to play sports...for a living.

I did enjoy
I did enjoy walking in a day before the other under grads to sign up for the days and times of the courses I needed. That said, I did pull the grades and completed Grad School without any additonal help. After all Paul, it was my body that got beat up for the greater glory of the institution of higher learning! I do agree with you however!

ps
i hope it was obvious that the quote I chose could pass as an intellectual's description of a Saturday afternoon football game, perfected.

live, and let live.

Who's Confused?
"They may never thrill at a formula elegantly devised, a mission truly accomplished, a sentence well written, a simple procedure done with care every time, an experiment perfected, a form that perfectly follows function...."

Student-athletes exist, but they clearly are not the ones of which you bemoan. Dry those crocodile tears, hand out the c minuses, and accept the reality of college athletics.

Helloo........Paul.......? Athletic Scholarship. Oxymoronic, no? Kwitcherwhinin' and teach those who want an education and play ball with those who want to play ball - for a living.
Sign Up to Post Your CommentsSign Up to Post Your Comments
If you are already registered, click here to login. Otherwise, please take a few seconds to register with Townhall.com. Once you sign up, you’ll be able to post your comments immediately, use the action center, get podcasts, and more!
Note: Fields marked with a red asterisk (*) are required.
Salutation:
First Name:
*
Last Name:
*
Email:
*
Nickname:
*
Note: Nick name will be shown when you post comments.
Address 1:
*
Address 2:
City:
*
State:
*
Zip:
*
Phone:
      
Your daily must-read of conservative columns, cartoons and news. Coulter, Sowell, Krauthammer and more.
(Bi-Weekly) We highlight the best opportunities from our partners for surveys, action items and more.