Townhall.com, Where Your Opinion Counts
Talk Radio:   Bill Bennett   Mike Gallagher   Dennis Prager   Michael Medved   Hugh Hewitt   
BREAKING NEWS  LeftArrow - Townhall.com : Conservative, Political, Republican   RightArrow - Townhall.com : Conservative, Political, Republican  
Columns, funnies & more in your inbox!
  • Check the boxes and send us your email address to receveive your free newsletter
  • Your daily must-read of conservative columns, cartoons and news. Coulter, Sowell, Krauthammer and more.
  • Townhall.com’s weekly inside scoop on what’s happening behind the scenes in the world of politics. When news breaks, we report.
  • Signup to receive the latest daily Townhall cartoons
Thursday, January 29, 2009
Paul Greenberg :: Townhall.com Columnist
The More Things Change...
by Paul Greenberg
Vote on It:
Average Vote:
[+] Text [-]
 
Poll
Will the Dems' health care Christmas Present to America be an improvement or detriment to our health care system?


The country now has a new secretary of the treasury who sounds a lot like the old one. Maybe because Timothy Geithner was at Henry Paulson's right hand when that now former secretary of the treasury was doing everything he could think of (and re-think of) to save the country's and the world's financial superstructure. Which is still unsteady, Some say unsteadier.

To quote Mr. Geithner's boss over at 1600 Pennsylvania Avenue, who's also new on the job: "Tim's work and the work of the entire Treasury Department must begin at once. We cannot lose a day because every day the economic picture is darkening here and across the globe."

Some of us just hope Mr. Geithner will move faster on the country's problems than he did on his own, specifically his back taxes, which he neglected to pay for years, then paid only in part.

He'd made the same "careless mistakes" in earlier years, but Citizen Geithner was by now beyond the reach of the law for those way-past-due taxes, and he didn't pay them. Why do more than the minimal if you don't absolutely have to? So long as you're doing the legal thing, why bother about doing the right thing?

Not till he was being considered as secretary of the treasury did Tim Geithner cough up all the money he should have paid in the first place. That was surely the most troubling aspect of his nomination; it hints at calculation rather than just carelessness.

To quote The Hon. Robert Byrd, West Virginia's very senior senator, on Mr. Geithner's ethical threshold in these matters: "Had he not been nominated for treasury secretary, it's doubtful that he would have ever paid those taxes." For once Sen. Byrd, that great muddy font of endless oratorical folderol, may have said something short and to the point. No wonder a number of senators (34) refused to confirm Mr. Geithner's nomination.

But now Timothy Geithner is going to be responsible for collecting taxes from those of us who obey the law -- or at least make a stab at it, for the monstrous Internal Revenue Code is scarcely decipherable even to certified public accountants.

No, this is not a propitious start for an administration of Hope and Change, which is now just trying to do its best with what it's got -- perhaps not the most idealistic course but a realistic one.

The Age of Hamilton is definitely past, and the pickings are lean when it comes to national leaders of both genius and honor. Perfection is not to be achieved in this less than perfect world. An acceptable if not admirable choice, Mr. Geithner will have to do. Sad to say, he may be the best man, warts and all, for the job.

Secretary Geithner certainly has the requisite experience for his new assignment, and what is experience but another name for having made mistakes? The country will surely wish him the best, for as he succeeds, so may the rest of us.

For another important office, whom does our brave new president and harbinger of Hope and Change choose to head the Securities and Exchange Commission? That agency is much in need of rehabilitation after its last commissioner (Christopher Cox) pretty well destroyed its reputation for sharp-eyed regulation of the markets.

The new broom turns out to be an old one: Mary Schapiro. She was the head of the Financial Industry Regulatory Authority (FINRA for mercifully short) that pretty much ignored one warning after another from financial analysts about the now notorious Bernard Madoff. They rightly suspected he was running a Ponzi scheme that would have out-Ponzi'd Charles Ponzi himself.

But the only thing FINRA did was lecture Mr. Madoff about minor and purely technical violations. Which was a bit like issuing Enron's executives a warning ticket for double parking.

Once again the new president's need for an experienced hand in the financial markets has outweighed his rhetoric (and only rhetoric) about change. He may have low-rated experience during his presidential campaign, but now he seems to feel the need for it.

After all, what was the alternative to appointing these flawed characters?

(And who is not flawed?) Appointing someone who knew nothing about the securities market, except perhaps how to denounce it, would have been a much worse decision -- though it would certainly have pleased the nation's know-nothings on both the left and right.

Barack Obama, despite the messianic hopes he raised, turns out to be only human after all. The good news is that, by making these appointments, he seems to have recognized that he is -- and must do the best he can with the imperfect instruments he's got, to wit Tim Geithner and Mary Schapiro.

Share:
Vote on It:
Average Vote:
 
About The Author

 
TOWNHALL DAILY: Sign up today and receive Townhall.com daily lineup delivered each morning to your inbox.
Paul, a word of advice
"Barack Obama, despite the messianic hopes he raised, turns out to be only human after all. The good news is that, by making these appointments, he seems to have recognized that he is -- and must do the best he can with the imperfect instruments he's got, to wit Tim Geithner and Mary Schapiro."

Retire. Seriously and affectionately, if you believed this, it really is time to pack the bags and head (even further) South.

PAUL IS SMART AND RIGHT !
YOU NEVER BAD MOUTH THE I R S !WE WISH MR TIM GEITHNER WELL!

Wonder How Mr. Sen. "Constitution"
Wonder hos Sen Byrd voted ??NO I hope. Actually it would not surprise me either way..

Gresham's Law extended
If bad currency drives good currency out of circulation, bad politicians and political appointees keep potentially good ones out of office. As long as we settle for the best officeholders that we seem likely to get, the likelihood of getting anyone better will remain low. Why should anyone with good ideas or a good reputation go to the great trouble of seeking office if the intolerable are good enough?

The choices before the Senate seemed clear:

* It shouldn't have afflicted us with a treasury secretary who has showered his cronies with hundreds of billions of dollars of taxpayers' money, but isn't a regular taxpayer himself. It shouldn't have even considered anyone who not only failed to pay taxes for years on end, but also pocketed an employer's reimbursements for those unpaid taxes.

* It shouldn't have confirmed an attorney general who participated in an auction of pardons.

* It shouldn't have approved a secretary of state with a tangled web of connections to foreign governments and interests.

Confiming a cabinet appointee isn't like voting in the usual mayoral election, in which Lousy and Worse are the only two candidates, and one must eventually win. In a confirmation vote, _Try Again_ is always on the ballot. Everyone who cast a vote in favor of these creeps should be ashamed.

But then I'm just a know-nothing.

Where's Howard Dean?
Looks like the real "culture of corruption" is rearing it's ugly head in the form of "Change we can believe in!"

To quote BHO's racist mentor, the chickens really do appear to be "coming home to roost."

Knowledge.
Paul Greenberg, you know, and understand, and accept, human nature. It is only fools who do not.

A fool and his self-righteousness are rarely parted.

It seems to me a fair share of these types respond to Greenberg essays -- to show themselves?

"Welcome back, Mr. Greenberg," was my continuing thought, as I read, "The More Things Change...."

More foolishness
An interesting position if I read it correctly: corruption and fecklessness are components of human nature that must simply be accepted, but the folly of high standards isn't. Perhaps this seems puzzling because I'm both a know-nothing and a fool. Still I maintain that those who expect little of their officials invariably get it good and hard.

Greenberg
You imply that there are no competent and honest candidates when you accept competent and dishonest ones. As noted by Paleocon, its crazy to appoint a known miscreant because it prevents the possiblility of finding an honest one. Its not like there is no other competent economist. How about Sowell or Williams or even one of the perspicatious folks who were trying to blow the whistle on Madoff.

Pistol
Just so. There must be a few competent officials who've somehow managed not to stiff the IRS, hire illegal aliens, rubber-stamp unpardonable pardons, or accept millions from foreign despots. Whether any of them would serve in Obama's cabinet is another question, one that neither party seems willing to ask.

Anyway, confirming Geithner, for example, has a direct cost -- it puts a tax-dodger in charge of the treasury. It also has an opportunity cost -- it bars a more eligible candidate from that office, at least for a while.

Paleocon
Gotta go, its a play for pay day.

ITM, happy good morning to you and OncealwayaMarine and all the other staunch folk who keep up my spirits in what can appear to be a sea of fools.

Pistol
Thanks. Have a good time.

.P and P.
Darn! I wish I had never made a mistake. Geez, however, I am not sorry I inflated some of my business expenses, on 40 years of tax returns. Paying 30% was enough, due to my own self-righteousness.

Yeah, I wish we had better. Why don't you two get into it?

Michael
Why don't you? Your obviously superior understanding of human nature would make you perfect for secretary of Health and Human Services or Compassion Czar.

I'm just a Vuhginyuh redneck and, by your utterly nonjudgmental reckoning, a fool. I'd never put myself up for high office. I'm not worthy. Fortunately, I don't have to be a master carpenter to recognize that the roof leaks.

Paleocon.
Huh?

I'm back here, deep in the Ozarks, my best friends are Bubba, and Tim the Cajun. They build stuff. I'm retired. We're all rednecks.

How'd you and I get off on the wrong foot?

Oh, that "self-righteousness" thing I mentioned, I guess. There's nothing wrong with that, up to a point.

Hey, I like Greenberg's stuff, you don't. Let's have a few beers, put a line in the water.

I won't even mention the former USMC stuff. That seems to get a lot of play, around here. That was a long time ago, Old Corps, ya know.

I must say, for where you and your friend are coming from, you do make good points.

Michael
"How'd you and I get off on the wrong foot?

"Oh, that "self-righteousness" thing I mentioned, I guess."

Good guess.

"There's nothing wrong with that, up to a point."

Speaking of points, you seem to have missed mine. I'm not saying that I'm better than Geithner, Holder, or Clinton. On the contrary, I'm saying that they're no better than I am, and that's a weak recommendation for one of the most powerful offices on the planet. I have high expectations of people in high office. I don't let my manifest inability to meet those expectations prevent me from applying them rationally. I'm not a doctor, either, but I have no qualms about holding out for a doctor who hasn't lost his license for malpractice.

"Hey, I like Greenberg's stuff, you don't."

Actually I do, most days. I'm just not overfond of this column.

"Let's have a few beers, put a line in the water."

It'll take a lot of monofilament to stretch from Chesapeake Bay to the Ozarks.

"I won't even mention the former USMC stuff."

Um. . .you just did.

"I must say, for where you and your friend are coming from, you do make good points."

That's kind of you to say. And I agree that the perfect is the enemy of the good. If we hold out for the best possible nominees, many positions will go unfilled. (On reconsideration, that may not be a bad thing.) I couldn't care less whether Geithner smoked dope in high school or had to retake calculus in college. But theft and tax-cheating seem to me directly relevant to his qualifications to run the Treasury Department.

I readily admit, however, that I'm out of the mainstream.


Paleocon.
I'll let the olive branch remain, I may even send over a dove, to cover the distance between us.

Where I suspected you might not be a serious person, was the last line in your first post: "But then I'm just a know-nothing." (By the way, weren't they around in a past century)?

Unless you were being sarcastic. I still don't know, because you have repeated that idea.

And, funny, I don't come off too foolish -- maybe a little -- in your selective, out of context quotes, from my posts. A pretty good job, by you, all in all.

Washington Corruption

This administration is less than a month old and already we see the corruption.

Paleocon, Pistol, great points!
And great retort to Michael who seems to think crooks in high office are OK as long as they are DemoncRats.

Paleocon, if your monofiliment line is coming from the Chesapeake, you must be on the Eastern Shore, Chincoteague maybe, or Newport News perhaps. It is a much shorter cast to the Potomac and you wouldn't have to teach me economics 101.

Pure Hogwash Mr. Greenburg
This type of the "lesser of two evils" thinking is all part of the scam being perpetrated upon us by you elites. The idea that only the elites in the two corrupt parties have the necessary wisdom, knowledge, and experience to govern is a lie designed to keep power in the hands of the elites.

This virtual lock on power by the two majors is the reason we are in this mess. Einstein's definition of insanity is proved right, because doing the same thing and expecting a different result is insane. Sadly, the same old thing we are getting is more evil.

We have been scammed by the elites, including you Mr. Greenburg! Our inheritance has been stolen right out from under us!

If any of you care to see how the elites have managed this theft, you need to visit my website, JOEOLIVAFORPRESIDENT.ORG. The election is over, but the site will be available for a few more weeks, so check it out.

2010 isn't far away, and "we the people" need to gather up some faith and courage. We need to reject the elites and the propaganda that spews out of the DEM/GOP/MSM political machines. Wake up America! How in the world can we keep electing these same incompetent, lying, corrupt politicians? Haven't we any sense of what is at stake: Constitutional self government, rule of law, and will of the people?

Let's get over this party loyalty garbage and do what is best for our beloved nation and the future we are passing along to our children and grandchildren. D-a-m-m-i-t, what is the matter with us? No guts to stop these crooks?
Thanks, Joe

Rich Not Wealthy.
Sure, just pile on. If you've voted Republican, most of the time, since 1960, why not?

Yeah, I got a few cooks, in all that time. Probably get a few more.

Crook
I don't wish that tax cheat well. I think he should be locked up as an ordinary mortal whth no ties to the Messiah would have been.

A Modest Proposal
How about we cut back on what Treasury is responsible for and it will matter less who is in charge. We should also abolish the SEC and make people realize they are responsible for where their money goes. Then guys like Maddoff will be looked at much more closely by people with a real interest in what he is doing. Apparently the folks at the SEC didn't really care that much. He ran that scam for so long because everybody figured the government was looking out for them.

Anyone thinking that anyone in government is doing anything but playing CYA is a fool. There are a lot of people that are going to be really disappointed in Mr. Obama.
Sign Up to Post Your CommentsSign Up to Post Your Comments
If you are already registered, click here to login. Otherwise, please take a few seconds to register with Townhall.com. Once you sign up, you’ll be able to post your comments immediately, use the action center, get podcasts, and more!
Note: Fields marked with a red asterisk (*) are required.
Salutation:
First Name:
*
Last Name:
*
Email:
*
Nickname:
*
Note: Nick name will be shown when you post comments.
Address 1:
*
Address 2:
City:
*
State:
*
Zip:
*
Phone:
      
Your daily must-read of conservative columns, cartoons and news. Coulter, Sowell, Krauthammer and more.
(Bi-Weekly) We highlight the best opportunities from our partners for surveys, action items and more.