Townhall.com, Where Your Opinion Counts
Talk Radio:   Bill Bennett   Mike Gallagher   Dennis Prager   Michael Medved   Hugh Hewitt   
BREAKING NEWS  LeftArrow - Townhall.com : Conservative, Political, Republican   RightArrow - Townhall.com : Conservative, Political, Republican  
Columns, funnies & more in your inbox!
  • Check the boxes and send us your email address to receveive your free newsletter
  • Your daily must-read of conservative columns, cartoons and news. Coulter, Sowell, Krauthammer and more.
  • Townhall.com’s weekly inside scoop on what’s happening behind the scenes in the world of politics. When news breaks, we report.
  • Signup to receive the latest daily Townhall cartoons
Wednesday, July 23, 2008
Paul Greenberg :: Townhall.com Columnist
Academe Then and Now
by Paul Greenberg
Vote on It:
Average Vote:
[+] Text [-]
 
Poll
Will the Dems' health care Christmas Present to America be an improvement or detriment to our health care system?


The invitation to my college reunion arrived the other day. No need to mention which one. Let's just say I got my undergraduate degree from the University of Missouri in the High Middle Ages. (The journalism school had just made the switch from stone tablets to parchment.)

The form the university's alumni association sent out had a space for Best Campus Memories, to which it had allotted a generous six lines. I couldn't have summed up my best campus memories if I'd had six pages. Besides the educational time I spent at The Green Door, where the beer was cheap and the jukebox featured Fats Domino, my fondest memories center around the remarkable history faculty that somehow coalesced at Columbia, Mo., during my student years. I'd gone there to attend journalism school but stayed to study under that rare constellation of teachers.

The history faculty seemed to consist entirely of professors who were either on their way to teach at places like Stanford or the Sorbonne, or on their way back from Oxford and Cambridge - and I'd caught them just when they were all on campus at the same time.

The remarkable thing about those teachers was not their scholarship, though theirs was indeed remarkable, but the immense care and patience - the tenderness almost - that they took with us students.

Here's one example of many: the professor who taught the freshman survey course in American history was from Virginia, which you realized as soon as he pronounced his first vowel.

I had a reading course with him. Being a Virginian, he was a devotee of Jefferson's, but he assigned me to read, among other works, Henry Adams' "History of the United States During the Administrations of Jefferson and Madison."

That would be Henry Adams, the great-grandson of John Adams, grandson of John Quincy, son of Charles Francis Adams, and naturally enough a thoroughgoing critic of everything that Mr. Jefferson, his great-grandfather's nemesis, ever thought, said or did.

Henry Adams' beautifully crafted words - his book is not only history but literature - reached across time and turned me into an Adams/Hamilton Federalist, which led to my becoming successively a Henry Clay Whig, then a Lincoln Republican, right through the whole successive conservative chain of ideas in American history to the present day.

At the time - the 1950s - conservatives were widely assumed to have no ideas at all. But only "irritable mental gestures that seek to resemble ideas," as the literary critic Lionel Trilling put it. All too accurately. For back then the right was as devoid of ideas as the left is now.

My staunchly Jeffersonian teacher - James L. Bugg - questioned me closely about the Federalist positions I defended. Nevertheless, he didn't just tolerate but encouraged other opinions. He even took me on as a graduate assistant. I wonder if such a thing would be possible now, in our ideologically driven day.

Now I realize how blessed I was to have encountered such teachers. At the time I took it as a matter of course. Talk about spoiled; I thought all graduate schools were like that.

I found out they weren't when I went on to an Ivy League school. Columbia University in the early 1960s was quite a step from the University of Missouri in the late 1950s. Quite a step down. At Columbia, ideology was already all. Even then education was rapidly giving way to indoctrination. Fail to toe the party line and you'd pay the price.

However devoted my teachers at Missouri were to their own carefully considered and deeply held ideas, their devotion to their students was greater. I still see their faces plain, and hear their voices clearly. And recall their exquisite tact even though half a century has gone by.

I pictured my old teachers again when I came across an article not long ago by a professor named Alan Kors. Its title: "On the Sadness of Higher Education." Why sad? Because the professor was remembering the breadth, the openness, the tolerance of his own professors many years ago, and contrasting it with the social agendas, political ultra-correctness, and general dumbing-down of the academy today.

The kind of professor Alan Kors so fondly remembers from his days at Princeton, and I remember so gratefully from Missouri, is now an endangered if not extinct species on American campuses. Hence the sadness of higher education today.

Share:
Vote on It:
Average Vote:
 
About The Author

 
TOWNHALL DAILY: Sign up today and receive Townhall.com daily lineup delivered each morning to your inbox.
Wow
Bravo those men. Having been shaped somewhat by my 18th Century and Restoration English Literature Professor, and considering the current climate in academe today, I'm sure that Pope, Addison & Steele, and Swift would be permanently assigned to "sensitivity training." All at the request of the Provost, of course.

What Happened?
How did our schools, most of which cost in excess of $20000/year, become indoctrination centers for socialist agendas? Did I say $20K/yr? My sister's kid just graduated from Duke @$46,000/yr. No rebate for the Lacrosse debacle. I don't want to send my kids to these cesspools, let along bankrupt my future to send them. Any suggestions?

Thanks Paul . . .
Well done. I hold a Ph.D. from a southern "Ivy" League school and a J.D. But simply cannot bring myself to submit to the will of these little Hitlers who call themselves Professors by trying to earn tenure from them. Therefore I got OUT of "academia."

To Stunned, if your kid got out of Duke, make sure that he or she is vaccinated and eventually receives a real education. Because odds are he was scammed by the Blue Devils. The Lacross thing was an abomination. Never forget most Duke professors supported the accuser. They call that Intelligence?

I think that there are a few colleges that still believe in education. And hard sciences are often at least "okay" even in the big universities. But the rest of it is rotten, fetid, expensive indoctrination. What a crock.

Dear Stunned
There are (surprisingly) still some great schools out there - you just have to dig....deep! Hillsdale College in Michigan (I am shocked that state still allows conservatism), Patrick Henry college...there are more. Now you have State colleges (like in California) who are trying to say that anyone (especially targeted are home schoolers and private schooled kids, of religious schools) who has had "other than evolution only" in core subjects cannot qualify for their programs unless they re take those classes with an "evolution only (read: total marxists)" curriculum. The reason, I guarantee you, is because kids who have a well rounded education, with an open exchange of ideas (as in my kids learn creation studies and are very well versed in evolution and its fallacies) are too smart for these "institutions of higher learning" and are making our marxist educational system look as horrible as they are. Until parents take back their rights over their kids and stop supporting these corrupt institutions it will only get worse. Parents must stop sending their kids to these indoctrination centers where they are only allowed to parrot their professors, and not actually think! As far as not wanting to bankrupt yourself to send them...good. My parents raised all 5 of us, (we were either upper lower class or lower middle class) we all attended university - and we all paid for it. I worked 3 jobs (did very well) had a small scholarship - as did we all and a few of us had some school loans. I guarantee you one thing: since "mommy and daddy" weren't footing the bill we treasured each class and grade as we were paying for it! It's ok to help your kids with school - but parents shouldn't pay for all of it.

Re: Stunned
My experience is this:

We live in Austin. My daughter went to Austin Comm Coll for two years, then transferred to UT-Austin. I paid her tuition, but she was responsible for her living expenses (though my mom helped her.) She worked full time in the summers and half time during the regular term to pay for her apt, food, car expenses, etc.

Result: BS degree in Arch. Engr. from a top-2 program *with no debt whatsoever.*

And if they want a non-tech degree (psych, English, foreign language, etc.), then any place is as good as any other, so cheaper is better.

College Home Schooling Anyone???
It's a shame that we can't issue diplomas for the learning of facts and not feelings these days. The cruel irony is that if you stick up for capitalism and freedom your GPA is impacted. That in turn impacts your professional marketability and future earnings potential. So if you are a true capitalist you will earn less than a snivelling toady leftist!

The answer: Self-taught private business owners. Grass roots small business owners are the ticket. Let the left wing looney professors rot in their ivy covered halls!

Stunned:
If you're looking for a good liberal arts school, there's St. Thomas Aquinas College http://www.thomasaquinas.edu in Santa Paula, CA. They study the "great books".

The permanent column
The nice thing about this article is that it could have been written in Greenberg's day by septagenarians remembering how much better the professors were in the 20's, and it will be written again in the coming 40's about how much better the professors were in the 00's.

It is particularly comic since Greenberg actually experienced the ideological faculty in the '60s but is convinced, without providing any evidnece except for another grumpy old-timer complaining about today's youth, to suggest that things are worse today.

Please, Keep Your Kids Home
I seriously hope you all keep your kids out of the higher education loop. That way my kids will have less competititon on the education front when they finish their degrees.

Thus far, the three who have finished or are still enrolled have had great experiences and report no "indoctrination" that they can't identify and deal with. The fourth will enter in the fall and is the most capable of them all.


The right wing fear of and focus on higher education is not a result any real problem with such issues. The real problem is that right wingers simply don't want their kids to hear any viewpoints that diverge from the conservative line of thinking, as if the only things worth learning are the things with which you agree.

Lon, the fool
Once again, Lon misses the whole point of a column in order to maintain his dismissive tone toward a conservative.

Mr. Greenberg's cadre of accomplished professors probably compared favorably to academicians who were teaching during our country's infancy. There is no way the same could be said today of any university faculty - unless, maybe, you look to Hillsdale or some similar institution devoted to true education.

I'd Rather Be In Alaska
Clearly, you know next to nothing about the quality of faculty in higher education.

But that's part of the issue. Somehow, people who don't know anything about a topic feel comfortable pontificating about it. If you understood education or had a good one, you would no better than to make such absurd generlizations.


Jack, an unnecessary reply
Jack writes: "...you would no (sic) better than to make such absurd generlizations (sic)."

I would also "no" better than to display such ignorance on a public forum.

Jack is a perfect example of the failure of modern education.

Alaskantankerous
You, you idiot. I have very bad eyesight.

Jack, I don't think I'M the idiot...
'nuff said... good day, sir.

Of course
you don't think you are the idiot. You need someone else to help you understand that. Seriously, if you think you know something a bout a topic, but it's all wrong, you have to have someone point it out to you.

I'dRatherBeinAlaska
It is possible that the journalism school at the University of Missouri was unique in its collection of scholars, unmatched at any time in this nations history, but Greenberg does not actually give an evidence for it.

The Journalism department at Northwestern in the '90s played a large role in discovering several innocent people on death row in Illinois. That speaks well of it to me, although I gather they have been having some problems more recently. And possibly saving the lives of convicted killers on the technicality that they are innocent may count as too political for Greenberg's taste.

But somehow that great collection of Journalism professors failed to instill in Greenberg the sense that if one is going to make claims like "The kind of professor Alan Kors so fondly remembers from his days at Princeton, and I remember so gratefully from Missouri, is now an endangered if not extinct species on American campuses" require things like evidence.

Some of today's faculty could be compared to some at the time of the founding if one used things like scholarship, advancement of knowledge, etc as the measure. But as I noted above, it will take a few decades before they can match them in nostaligic attachment. It takes a while for nostalgia to set in.

Lon
As someone who has recently gone back to finish a degree I can tell you the ideology over critical thinking is in full swing. I am a much better student now than when I first attended college, but you wouldn't know it from the grades assigned to me in some classes. I have had papers handed back to me that instead of having anything corrected for format the professor was arguing with me in the margins over the points I was making. The people who got the best grades talked frequently with the professors of listening to NPR while showing no real knowledge of the subjects during class discussion. After correcting a professor for the umpteenth time on a math question that he was going through incorrectly the professor stopped assigning them. I received a C+ and never got a paper or test back from the man.

Since I work full time and am married with a child I don't bother fighting it. It isn't worth my time, but going back to school ended up being a huge disappointment from something I was greatly looking forward to. I love to learn and discuss things, but you must conform and praise while never questioning to do well in most college courses that I have seen.

Duke 25 years ago
I graduated from Duke in the early 80s and I used to have a sense of pride in my alma mater. Now, every time I read something about it, I cringe!

It seems to me that I, too, managed to experience the echoes of a bygone era of learning. I actually had some conservative-leaning professors (gasp!). They were mostly older, though, and retired a few years after I graduated. I remember that although some of my liberal professors knew that I was an evangelical Christian, they were generally respectful of that fact. I even had a drama professor sincerely ask me if a scene he had assigned me was offensive to me as a Christian and he offered to let me choose something else. (The scene was actually not offensive at all, so I performed it in good conscience.) I hope there are still some professors out there like that, but from the things I read and hear, many of them just really enjoy mocking and shaming conservatives, especially Christians. It is in fact a mockery of real education, and truly so terribly sad!
Sign Up to Post Your CommentsSign Up to Post Your Comments
If you are already registered, click here to login. Otherwise, please take a few seconds to register with Townhall.com. Once you sign up, you’ll be able to post your comments immediately, use the action center, get podcasts, and more!
Note: Fields marked with a red asterisk (*) are required.
Salutation:
First Name:
*
Last Name:
*
Email:
*
Nickname:
*
Note: Nick name will be shown when you post comments.
Address 1:
*
Address 2:
City:
*
State:
*
Zip:
*
Phone:
      
Your daily must-read of conservative columns, cartoons and news. Coulter, Sowell, Krauthammer and more.
(Bi-Weekly) We highlight the best opportunities from our partners for surveys, action items and more.