Townhall.com, Where Your Opinion Counts
Talk Radio:   Bill Bennett   Mike Gallagher   Dennis Prager   Michael Medved   Hugh Hewitt   
BREAKING NEWS  LeftArrow - Townhall.com : Conservative, Political, Republican   RightArrow - Townhall.com : Conservative, Political, Republican  
Columns, funnies & more in your inbox!
  • Check the boxes and send us your email address to receveive your free newsletter
  • Your daily must-read of conservative columns, cartoons and news. Coulter, Sowell, Krauthammer and more.
  • Townhall.com’s weekly inside scoop on what’s happening behind the scenes in the world of politics. When news breaks, we report.
  • Signup to receive the latest daily Townhall cartoons
Wednesday, March 05, 2008
Paul Greenberg :: Townhall.com Columnist
The Word from Huey Long
by Paul Greenberg
Vote on It:
Average Vote:
[+] Text [-]
 
Poll
Will the Dems' health care Christmas Present to America be an improvement or detriment to our health care system?


What's the essential difference between the two remaining candidates battling it out for the Democratic presidential nomination?

It's the difference between high popalorum and low popahirum.

Never heard of those two commodities?

Let the late great Huey Pierce Long Jr. of Louisiana, a state whose principal crops long have included cotton, rice and buncombe, explain. Back in his heyday, namely the 1930s, he would tell the story about a traveling salesman who offered two varieties of patent medicine:

One bottle was labeled High Popalorum, which the salesman would explain was taken from the bark of a tree from the top down.

The other was called Low Popahirum, which came from the bark of a tree from the bottom up.

Huey's conclusion:

"The only difference I've found in Congress between the Republican and Democratic leadership is that one of them is skinning us from the toes up and the other from the ears down."

His was a common enough thought but nary so well expressed. It would apply just as well now to the supposedly crucial policy differences between Hillary Clinton and Barack Obama on everything from taxes to health insurance to NAFTA. (That's the North American Free Trade Agreement and scapegoat, which both were for before both were against.)

Conclusion: The more things change, the more they remain the dadblamed same - even if our present day politicians lack Huey Long's ability to sum things up in a single colorful phrase.

More high popalorum and low popahirum is sure to come.

Why then are so many of my fellow opinionators, like so many American voters in general, taken with Barack Obama? I must confess I myself am not immune to his charm. It's his rhetorical prowess that mesmerizes, and the rarity of it in contemporary politics.

Every four years, as is customary, we the punditry lament the decline and imminent fall of political eloquence in this country. It's always good for at least one mournful column, in which an elegiac reference to the Lincoln-Douglas debates is almost mandatory.

But this year, just as we were performing the last rites over American political eloquence, the funeral was interrupted by the meteoric rise of Mister Cool, who continues to hold us - and a good part of the nation - in his rhetorical thrall.

The question now is how long this intoxicating spell will last, and will the hangover set in before or after the general election. In the meantime, the Cult of Obama rocks and rolls on.

The set pieces that Barack Obama delivers before his fan base are impressive enough; their likes may not have been seen on this continent since the Beatles came, saw and conquered.

And yet Senator Obama is even more impressive in informal settings - like a town hall meeting or impromptu debate. His conversational approach on those occasions bears no resemblance to the spread-eagle style that used to so excite American audiences before it became something to parody.

This is no William Jennings Bryan reciting his Cross of Gold speech with dramatic gestures. It's more like a reincarnation of John F. Kennedy's restrained elegance. Barack Obama doesn't bombard his listeners with flamboyant oratory. Instead, he wins us over with a practiced ease that doesn't seem practiced at all.

To borrow another metaphor from Huey Long, aka The Kingfish, this new political star is not a hoot owl but a scrootch owl. What's the difference? Here's how he explained it: "A hoot owl bangs into the nest and knocks the hen clean off and catches her while she's falling. But a scrootch owl slips into the roost and talks softly to her. And the hen just falls in love with him, and the first thing you know, there ain't no hen!"

Hillary Clinton is definitely a hoot owl. Charm has never been her strong suit. She's been a brass-knuckles fighter for as long as I've watched her in hard-hitting action.

In contrast, Barack Obama is a scrootch owl, sidling up to his audience in the most agreeable fashion before co-opting it.

Miss Hillary bashes us into acquiescence, or at least tries to. Naturally we resist. Nobody likes being argued into submission.

In contrast, Mister Cool makes agreeing with him seem only reasonable.

Ever notice how he begins so many responses to challenging questions? First he agrees with his questioner's position, perhaps restating it better. Then he gradually moves on in that soft-spoken way of his to supply his own, quite different conclusion so subtly he's won you over.

Barack Obama charms his prey before delivering the coup de grace. And the first thing you know, there ain't no opposition left.

In his own concise, memorable way, Huey Long explained the theory behind the scrootch owl's modus operandi long ago. Barack Obama has just put it into practice.

Share:
Vote on It:
Average Vote:
 
About The Author

 
TOWNHALL DAILY: Sign up today and receive Townhall.com daily lineup delivered each morning to your inbox.
Barack "Two Smooth" Obama
As the words "Hope" and "Change" flow from his preacher cadenced tongue we observe the enamored masses swoon with deer in headlights abandon, and as the faintings occur and another super tuesday bites the dust we're left to contemplate next november and the real issues like the war, the economy- to include high gas prices, Nafta, the sub-prime debacle, education, immigration-to include the fence and subsequent round-up, and foreign policy.
We're going to need an experienced hand here, is Obama it?

Lobama
If Texas is any indication, Obama's heyday is over. Hillary overcame his 70,000 vote lead in early voting, and went on to a 100,000 vote victory. I wonder what her lead would have been had the early voters had time to hear about Michelle's disdain for this county, Tony Rezko, and the NAFTA flap. Oh, and last night in San Antonio BHO said something about making this country one we can be proud of. Heh.

Disclose the Puppeteer
Okay, the puppet puts on a good show for those whose knowledge of Hope and Change revolves mainly around the Casino. Why not start demanding that he disclose the puppeteer? Daddy thinks its the Chicago Mafia. (Daddy is partial to the Mafia). I think its someone more dangerous.

Disclose the Puppeteer.

Huey P. Long
I've always maintained that if you want to truly understand Bill Clinton, you have to understand Huey Long. One excellent way to do this is to read Robert Penn Warren's roman a' clef novel about a Long-type southern politician, "All The King's Men", or watch the 1949 film version with Broderick Crawford in the lead role (for which he won a well-deserved Best Actor Oscar). (The recent Sean Penn remake is best ignored.)

From what I've seen, I'd say that the parallel with Long is equally applicable to Senator Obama. He is a smooth talker, who is adamant that no one finds out what he really wants until after he's take the Oath of Office- and can start issuing Executive Orders.

As for Hillary, to figure her out, read "The Manchurian Candidate" by Richard Condon, and pay very close attention to Mrs. Iselin. Or just watch the 1962 film version, with Angela Lansbury in that role'. (As with "All The King's Men", the recent remake is largely irrelevant.)

cheers

eon

Come on Greenberg et. al
Give Mike Savage the credit for showing this comparison last week on his radio broadcast. It is uncanny how Long and Obama sound alike.

LzVandy is right...
Michael Savage should get 'props' for the Huey Long comparison. Greenberg reminds me of all the Johnny-come-lately diet book writers who never give a line of credit to Dr. Atkins even though they knock off the old boy's research.

Secular Televangelist
It's the same principle used by many preachers to get people to send in their money. Obama is basically a preacher. Probably would have made a good one in these modern times where preaching seems to be a very lucrative racket for many.

I think you mentioned on another thread AudiR10 who you think the puppeteer is. It is certainly possible but, I am starting to discount that possibility. He is on that team, of course, but a typical player. Deluded and deceived but, not an outright true supporter and follower. He is just a typical democratic politician who saw an opportunity and seized it. I detect signs recently that the ether is already starting to wear off. It will be interesting to see him defend the platform and try to keep the campaign emotional and devoid of substance till November. The media will help him but, it may not be enough.

I think if he debates McCain a few times and does well, he is a shoo-in. The sheep love him and turnout is likely to be high among african americans.

Snake Oil Salesmen
I like comparing Hillary to the "scrootch owl".I can think of some names for her,but not fit to print.Obama reminds me of the "snake oil salesmen" I used to see in western movies many years ago.They would come in with their wagons loaded with bottles of who knew what kind of concoctions.People would gather 'round and he would start his speil.He would charm them and they were mesmerized,putty in his hands.He would guarantee it would cure "everything that ails you".If it didn't,he would refund your money,even double the refund.The charmed would buy his speil and his medicines and discover it was probably swamp water or something worse.Of course he was already in another town,by then and never to be seen again.

Rowly
Robert Preston did it better. Can you see Obama turning out some of the slick patter songs from The Music Man? ("Ya got trouble! Right here in River City!")

AudiR10
Also,Burt Lancaster in Elmer Gantry. Who was it who said "there's a sucker born every minute"?Barnum & Bailey?

Owl Theory
Re "Barack Obama charms his prey then delivers the coup de grace and the first thing you know there ain't no opposition left". Yes, and couldn't we just use his skill in our dealings with hostile foreign nations who haven't responded too well to Hooty A**-Kicker Owl Bush's more frontal approach.

I saw Obama the doing his Scootch Owl number, on live TV, one time when Bill O'Reilly's cameraman was being blocked access to Obama by Secret Service. O'Reilly went off like Donald Duck, the way he does, and Obama heard the ruckus and strolled over to see what was going on. He spoke softly to wrath and within sixty seconds O'Terrible was eating out of Barack's hand. It was something to see. This is no empty suit. This is a talent, and we would be fools to let it slip past us.

lilly
It won't slip...it'll slither...

The current delegate math
(according to Sean Hannity this afternoon) is:

Obama: 1562

Clinton: 1461

Despite the victories yesterday, Hillary only increased her delegate count by 12. That's it. 12. The contests were close (at least in Texas) & democrats don't have a winner-take-all system like the republicans.

So this thing is going to go on for awhile.

Hillary suggested on CBS's "The Early Show", when asked if she'd consider a Clinton & Obama "dream team" ticket, that, yes, this scenario seems to be playing itself out....it just remains to be seen "who is at the top of the ticket". So she's game.

I think a ticket with a woman & african-american is doubly energizing, doubly history making, creates its own momentum. This, combined with democratic enthusiasm this year (the amazing primary turnouts, the record-breaking campaign contributions for both Clinton & Obama), is McCain's worst nightmare. This ticket would be intriguing on so many different levels.

will
Certainly intriguing in many ways except one. We know where they stand politically, both die hard communists. I wonder how many more we can take before we hit the tipping point of no return. Many think we have passed it. I agree all things remaining the same for the next fifty years as the past fifty or so. That is not likely though.

We may plunge into another abyss ala 1930's through socialist policies but pull out due to experience and expertise lacking then. My reason for abandoning McCain and trying to maintain an alternative political option. The other scenario is we plunge into the abyss and a renewed terror threat emerges thanks to appeasement policies and that pulls us out economically like WWII did the depression. It will take a dire threat of some kind to get americans off the teat and back to work.
Sign Up to Post Your CommentsSign Up to Post Your Comments
If you are already registered, click here to login. Otherwise, please take a few seconds to register with Townhall.com. Once you sign up, you’ll be able to post your comments immediately, use the action center, get podcasts, and more!
Note: Fields marked with a red asterisk (*) are required.
Salutation:
First Name:
*
Last Name:
*
Email:
*
Nickname:
*
Note: Nick name will be shown when you post comments.
Address 1:
*
Address 2:
City:
*
State:
*
Zip:
*
Phone:
      
Your daily must-read of conservative columns, cartoons and news. Coulter, Sowell, Krauthammer and more.
(Bi-Weekly) We highlight the best opportunities from our partners for surveys, action items and more.