Townhall.com, Where Your Opinion Counts
Talk Radio:   Bill Bennett   Mike Gallagher   Dennis Prager   Michael Medved   Hugh Hewitt   
BREAKING NEWS  LeftArrow - Townhall.com : Conservative, Political, Republican   RightArrow - Townhall.com : Conservative, Political, Republican  
Columns, funnies & more in your inbox!
  • Check the boxes and send us your email address to receveive your free newsletter
  • Your daily must-read of conservative columns, cartoons and news. Coulter, Sowell, Krauthammer and more.
  • Townhall.com’s weekly inside scoop on what’s happening behind the scenes in the world of politics. When news breaks, we report.
  • Signup to receive the latest daily Townhall cartoons
Tuesday, October 09, 2007
Pat Buchanan :: Townhall.com Columnist
The Scramble for America
by Pat Buchanan
Vote on It:
Average Vote:
[+] Text [-]
 
Poll
Was the Copenhagen Global Warming Summit Walk-Out a Win for the U.S.?


What is it that distinguishes Bush Republicanism from the Coolidge, Taft, Eisenhower and Reagan varieties? Four major issues come to mind.

Bush is a "Big Government conservative" who repudiated the "government-is-the-problem" philosophy of Reagan. His No Child Left Behind program, doubling the size of the Department of Education, and his vast expansion of Medicare to cover prescription drugs so testify.

Second, Bush believes in Wilsonian interventionism, including the use of military force, to advance a "global democratic revolution" and "end tyranny on earth."

Third, Bush believes in open borders, amnesty and "a path to citizenship" for 12 million to 20 million illegal aliens, and smoothing the way for untold millions more to come and "do the work Americans will not do."

Fourth, Bush is a NAFTA-CAFTA man who believes in throwing America's doors open to goods from all over the world, regardless of the protectionist practices of our trade partners. To Bush, free trade is an article of faith and faithful observance its own reward.

For seven years now, consistent with these beliefs, Bush has crafted national policy to conform to his convictions. Thus, any verdict on the Bush presidency must also render judgment upon his philosophy.

With his own and his party's approval at the lowest levels since Watergate, one may conclude then that America is not only rejecting Bush the man and his record, but the philosophy behind both.

This should be a matter of grave concern to a Republican Party that has lately embraced all four pillars of the Bush-Republican philosophy.

For consider the fruits.

Interventionism gave us Iraq, the worst strategic blunder in U.S. history. Big Government conservatism wiped out the surplus, fattened the federal bureaucracy and enlarged its share of GDP, and destroyed the Republican reputation as America's bastion of fiscal prudence.

The Bush immigration philosophy was repudiated by Middle America, which rose in righteous wrath against his amnesty plan and demanded he enforce the law and secure the border. Americans are unreconciled to the idea that the America they grew up in will be morphed into some mammoth multicultural Mall of Mankind.

Now, the returns have come in from the Bush policy of free-trade globalism. According to a lead story in The Wall Street Journal -- whose editorial page still champions Iraq, the Bush Doctrine, open borders, NAFTA-CAFTA and the WTO --- Republicans, by two to one, believe free trade has done more harm than good to America. "With voters provoked for years by such figures as Pat Buchanan and Ross Perot," writes the Journal's John Harwood, citing Romney adviser and former Rep. Vin Weber, "there's been a steady erosion in Republican support for free trade." While one appreciates Harwood's compliment, it is undeserved. What killed the free-trade consensus in the GOP was not provocateurs, but proven failure.

Since 2002, America has run five consecutive world record trade deficits. Three million manufacturing jobs have disappeared. The euro has almost doubled in value against the dollar. The Canadian dollar has reached parity. Plants have been shutting down across this country for years. The wages of Middle Americans have stagnated. The trade deficit with China last year reached $233 billion, a world record between any two nations.

Where Alexander Hamilton's economic patriotism, pursued by Washington, Madison, Clay, Jackson, Lincoln, McKinley, T.R. and Coolidge, created the greatest manufacturing power the world had ever seen, producing 42 percent of all of the world's goods when Silent Cal went home, America's industrial plant has been ravaged by free trade.

And we are only beginning to see the damage done by the "trade-deficits-don't-matter!" Republicans.

The trade deficits America has run up in recent decades have helped give rival nations $5 trillion in cash reserves. They have now begun to transfer this enormous cash hoard into sovereign wealth funds -- to buy up America.

China, with currency reserves estimated at $1.3 trillion, used petty cash -- one-fourth of 1 percent of its cash pile in May -- to buy a 10 percent interest in Blackstone, America's second largest private equity firm.

Huawei Technologies, a firm linked to the Chinese military, now seeks a merger with 3Com, a company that provides the Pentagon and U.S. Army with intrusion detection equipment to keep hackers out. In July, Chinese military hackers were discovered trying to break into a computer system close to Defense Secretary Robert Gates.

Treasury should veto Huawei's bid, even if Goldman Sachs, which claims one alumnus as treasury secretary and another as White House chief of staff, has been greasing the deal. Yet this is not the end -- this is only the first of the foreign raids on vital U.S. assets.

At the 1884 Congress of Berlin that carved up the continent, "The Scramble for Africa" began. The Scramble for America, thanks to our trillions in borrowing to finance consumption of foreign goods, is about to begin. Because of the free-trade folly of this generation, foreigners, not all of them friendly, are about to buy up our inheritance. They are about to buy up America.

Share:
Vote on It:
Average Vote:
 
About The Author
Pat Buchanan is a founding editor of The American Conservative magazine, and the author of many books including State of Emergency: The Third World Invasion and Conquest of America .
 
TOWNHALL DAILY: Be the first to read Pat Buchanan's column. Sign up today and receive Townhall.com daily lineup delivered each morning to your inbox.
 
©Creators Syndicate
Thank God!!
For Pat Buchanan!

He tells it like it is with no "spin"!

Are we real conservatives supporting this NitWit president? I know I'm done with him and his NeoCon pals! How much longer are we going to be America?

Soon China will own us.

We need to WAKE UP!

You are Right, Mavtek
mavtek,

Thank God for Pat's Doomsday articles! This one might be gloomy enough to con my wife into letting me buy an AR-10 or maybe an EOtech 557 for the Mini-14. The poor woman. Woo Hoo!

BTW, what can we do after we wake up?
Alea jacta est

In a link from Drudge
Californians for Population Stabilization released a study saying there are between 20 million and 38 million illegal immigrants in America. Big surprise. Why should we believe the census bureau? Does anybody think that illegal immigrants would answer a census honestly. What is their incentive? If anything, it is to their advantage to vastly understate their numbers. Vastly.

http://www.chron.com/disp/story.mpl/m
etropolitan/mason/5189638.html

Amnesty is the issue of our time. The drain on resources, food, gas, the gas to produce the food, and on and on will bankrupt America. Not to mention the crime and social service nightmares we will be facing.

This is an 80% issue and the Republicans can sweep into Washington if they play this card. THirty million immigrants! Hillary won't stand a chance, but here we have Rudy sitting on the sidelines on this issue. I've heard that his law firm is tied to this highway they are building down here - the one that the press claims doesn't exist.


Unfortunately
I remember a time not long ago when Milk wasn't $4 a gallon, the Dollar was equal to the Euro, and it didn't cost an arm and a leg for a 12 pack of beer or a pack of Cigarettes, gas was about 100% Less too. The only doomsday I'm staring right in the face is that it's very likely that Millions will foreclose this year alone. This is bad news for the middle class, their credit will be ruined, and they will be forced back into rental properties. While the Rich will scoop up homes for rental properties or summer homes at an extreme discount.

I'm lucky I already have a fixed rate loan on my home, a stable job, and I rarely drink and I don't smoke. Unfortunately these circumstances in which I have personally witnessed have awoken me from my previously entrenched denial.

Reply to mavtek
Unfortunately, you must do more than just stir from slumber to survive. It's probably time to learn some 19th Century homestead skills to cope after the inevitable downturn. Les bon temps ne rouler pas pour toujours. When millions of folks have to take a step back in their lifestyle, the fabric of society will be stressed.

Something will happen. The crisis may be economic, environmental, lack of key resources, demographic, a major war or a combination of two or more issues. Prepare for the worst, hope for the best. Acquire a taste for squirrel meat. LOL.

Free Trade
I'm all for free trade, and do believe that it promotes growth. I'm also for immigration, as it is a sign of a countries prosperity, and does again promote economic growth. I also realize that a World Power will be forced at times to intervene in the sovereignty of other states and nations due to critical interests in that region.

HOWEVER

What we have going on now IS NOT free trade, it is unfair, unfree trade that seems designed to drain away the wealth and industry of the United States.

Importing huge swaths of homogeneous third worlders without trying to or even expecting them to assimilate to the American culture is begging for the Balkanization of the United States and is essentially cultural suicide.

If a major power is going to intervene, it better have a good reason, it better be able to maintain at least the appearance of the moral high-ground and it had darn well better have a realistic, attainable end-state envisioned prior to getting involved. (Besides, I know that the USA has the best military in the World, but the nation no longer has the moral fiber or stomach for what it takes to wage war).

JD's Handsome Son writes:
Surely you jest...

"Hillary Clinton is a loyal, patriotic American who wants to see this country strong and respected around the world. She'll make a superb Commander in Chief. She's the most qualified person on the planet to manage our economy and charter the best path for a bright future for America."

Echo In An Empty Attic
Pat has been right for years--no one cares. Americans like being massaged with fantasy--listen to liars as long as they say what you want to hear. The President seekers run polls to determine what you want to hear and craft their speeches and utterances to give you the "warm and fuzzy feeling" of you own myth. They lie, they mislead, and they plot to expand their power--using your money and lessening your freedoms while convincing you; it is all your idea and your dream of America, fulfilled.

Pat Buchanan
When he's wrong, he's abysmally wrong. But when he's right, he's prophetic.

This is only the beginning.

Jorge Bush
I regret my votes cast for el presidente, but, my God, look at the alternatives the Democrats presented the nation with!
Our nominating system as it stands now simply does not produce the best choices for President. The "primary" system did nothing but allow political "fat cats" to have a greater influence; we need to return to the state convention system of nominating Presidential candidates...party decisions from the grassroots up.

Multicultural Mall of Mankind
Love it Pat -- A Phrase worth repeating that captures what is happening to our great land with astonishing speed. As Nick in Austin says, the 12 million illegal estimate is sheer farce. It's a lot closer to the 38 million high estimate than the "official" 12 million our wonderful census bureau medicates the populace with for the purposes of non-action.

Over the past 57 years...
...since I had turned 15 and became aware of the world outside my door,America has been going to He-- in a hand basket.But every morning I wake up and see we are still here.Do you actually think no one else has predicted the downfall of our country before?Read the history of this country and laugh at the predictions made at the time.

Maybe I have just become more mellow in my old age,but I have seen "unsolvable" problems solved in pretty short order,and for you who are despondent about our country:Hang in there.The only certainty is change.

P.S.
Watch the CNBC/Wall Street Journal Presidential debate tonight, live at 4pm, but re-aired at 9pm Eastern Time on MSNBC. Let's figure out who of the Republicans really understands the financial issues.

They are about to buy up America...

I don't know if that's as bad as Pat suggests. The Chicoms have not done too bad managing their own economy. They don't tolerate drugs and corruptiion - a bullet at the back of the head is not such a bad idea considering the circumstances "over there".

Meanwhile our "leaders" are falling all over each other to see which one of them can ruin this country faster and surrender it to any enemy that wants it. The Chicoms will seal the borders, win the war on terror in a day by delivering ultimatums to islamofascists and neo communists of Russia, proceed with the amerikin version of their '60's cultural revolution - empty all schools of "higher" learning and send all the spoiled America haters lurking there to the lettuce and strawberry fields of the nation there to perform "voluntary" picking service for some 20 years of their lives.

And this just for starters.

Not too different from what Ann Coulter would do if she was elected president and dissolved the congress and named her own supreme court.

I would think twice before I tremble for fear that "They are coming to buy up America".
That is just hogwash. History will again do what it does so well, repeat itself...and the foreign buyers of America will go the way of the Japanese in the '80's...they'll buy high and a few years on they'll sell low to the exact very same people who sold them the goods in the first place. The Masters of the Universe are making a few heavy moves in the old game, Bush and his buddies are merely silly little pawns on the chess board. As for us ordinary folk, well, we get to watch, and from time to time scratch our heads.

Piano girl...
...Why do you watch the debate? I'm sure you have already made up your mind.You are voting for what's-his-name,you know,the guy with two first names?

I have long said
that it will take a major set back to get folks interested in how our elected officials have sold us out. How they have squandered away all that prior generations have fought for.

The philosphy of the GOP has been usurped by PC correctness and the only thing remaining of the majestic elephant is it's dung.

I do not look forward to the coming times.

Welcome back Pat, great article.

The Struggle for America
As usual, Pat Buchanan gets it right on everything but Iraq, where Bush did lie bigtime, but not when he claimed there WERE WMDs (to justify the invasion), but when he COVERED UP huge such discoveries (to vindicate the UN and elect this Democratic - communist - congress, both of whom he secretly serves). Now LOST, the NAU, and the mandatory screening and drugging of our children for mental illness (read "conservative Christian parents") is all doable.

Go to my blog at http://elusivetruth.townhall.com and click on "The True Nature of the Lies" on the right side (or simply paste in http://elusivetruth.townhall.com/g/06a63265-e0ae-4ef5-b836 -b7363ac1a854), and tell me if I'm wrong.

Aside to JD's Handsome Son: Hellary's gonna reduce the size of government, close our borders, kick out the invaders, and strengthen our military? What've you been smokin'? Just goes to show you the extent of insanity to which W's deliberate nosedive will drive sheeple prone to grasp at straws.

Hillary is a communist
1) "We're going to take things away from you on behalf of the common good."

A. Karl Marx
B. Adolph Hitler
C. Joseph Stalin
D. None of the above

2) "It's time for a new beginning, for an end to government of the few, by the few, and for the few...and to replace it with shared responsibility for shared prosperity."

A. Lenin
B. Mussolini
C. Idi Amin
D. None of the Above

3) "(We)...can't just let business as usual go on, and that means something has to be taken away from some people."

A. Nikita Khrushev
B. Jose f Goebbels
C. Boris Yeltsin
D. None of the above

4) "We have to build a political consensus and that requires people to give up a little bit of their own...in order to create this common ground."

A. Mao Tse Dung
B. Hugo Chavez
C. Kim Jong Il
D. None of the above

5) "I certainly think the free-market has failed."

A. Karl Marx
B. Lenin
C. Molotov
D. None of the above

6) "I think it's time to send a clear message to what has become the most profitable sector in (the) entire economy that they are being watched."

A. Pinochet
B. Milosevic
C. Saddam Hussein
D. None of the above

Answers:

(1) D. None of the above. Statement was made by Hillary Clinton 6/29/2004
(2) D. None of the above. Statement was made by Hillary Clinton 5/29/2007
(3) D. None of the above. Statement was made by Hillary Clinton 6/4/2007
(4) D. None of the above. Statement was made by Hillary Clinton 6/4/2007
(5) D. None of the above. Statement was made by Hillary Clinton 6/4/2007
(6) D. None of the above. Statement was made by Hillary Clinton 9/2/2005

Her solution is for government confiscation of your hard earned money and give it to those who are incapable or unwilling to work. She has never advocated closing the borders so anyone who thinks she will is delusional. Wake up America!! Get off your a@@ and take care of yourself. The government is not your mama.

Outstanding article!
Pat Buchanan hit the nail on the head...again!

I have no idea why we let our party become the party of Bush, but it's time we real conservatives take it back. We'd better hurry -- if we don't, there soon won't be a party to take back.

JD's Handsome
Handsome son wrote, "Hillary Clinton is a loyal, patriotic American who wants to see this country strong and respected around the world."


I work for a Danish company that has bases located world-wide. There are many employees here in the Houston base that are from other countries such as Sweden, Canada, Africa, Russia, Brazil, etc. Americans here are actually in the minority.

The myth is that the USA isn't respected anywhere. Actually, the USA is still quite well-respected; it's merely the Socialist-Democrats who really hate America.

Gone with the Wind (Bushes)
Fools and their money are soon parted.
Tens of millions of us remember when this nation was a powerhouse of jobs and production. That was before G.W. Bush of Arabia started the US on it's path of destruction that his son the heir has pushed us on down. Bush is a dullard and he never admits he's wrong much less will he stop when he "knows" he right. Bush and this administration have seized power and the runaway train has already jumped the track.

Conservatives must repudiate the GOP
The neocons and profiteers will try to scare us with "Hillary! Hillary!" but they are not the only alternative.

True conservatives must recognize the sad fact. Bush has infected the party irreversibly. Seven years of Rove-ist power focus has put all of the worst people into power and repudiated the best.

Watch their lips as they sell out prolife principles: "Rudy can WIN !!" Watch as they bankrupt you: "Euro hits $1.60, oil $100, gold $1000. Illegals 50 million."

Meanwhile, the fixers are fat, Richer Perle luxuriates in Provence, and good men continue to die in the desert sand.

We must repudiate this squalid, self-congratulatory generation, and recover our principles and our self-respect. Not to mention our morality.

One More Pat!
Pat, would you be able to remain employed if you did a hit piece on the Bilderberg and Council on Foreign Relations. That mentality is the driving force for most of the Bushes' actions (both father and son). Or don't you believe in real conspiracies? Those people/groups are ready and willing to shift to the Demos sides so long as the Demos perpetuate the acts of Willie Klinton. And one more thank you goes to the great strategist Newt who thankfully decided not to get into the whirlpool with the others nuts. I don't like to hear him speak the fork-tongue drivel.

pat's article
Prior to Bush's last election Pat wrote in his magazine "its time to come home and vote Republican." I didn't, Bush was such an unmitigated disaster I voted Libertarian. How about it Pat, time to admit you were wrong?

A Republic, If We Can Keep It

Securing the border and enforcing the law is the only way we get to keep our rule of law, our representative Republic, and our Constitution. We must elect a President who WILL secure the border and enforce the laws. If citizenship becomes meaningless, this will no longer be the United States of America.

If the GOP thinks they can continue to import cheap labor for their donors at the expense of the citizens, they will. I will not vote for that again. If we continue to play the game of "the other guy is worse", we will lose our country. Sorry, but I will not participate in that game any longer. The GOP power brokers think we will vote for "anybody but a Democrat" so they can continue to ignore securing the borders and enforcing the laws. I'm hoping GOP primary voters give the party elites some surprises in the primaries. The levers of power and the money in the GOP are all in the hands of the cheap labor express. They do not want Duncan Hunter as the candidate. He WOULD enforce the laws and secure the border. WE have to make him the nominee by voting in the primaries. We have to talk to our friends and neighbors about him. He is not going to get media coverage. It's going to have to be a grass roots effort. I WANT to vote for a GOP candidate in Nov.'08, I WILL NOT vote for any of the amnesty supporters. If it takes crushing the GOP so a new party representing American citizens can arise, so be it.

http://www.gohunter08.com

skywalker 81
You are 100% correct and anyone who actually believes she is anything but, probably also believed that Hitler was just as passing phase and of no real consequence. Her own words, her hatred for this country, her deep-rooted anti-Semitism, her contempt for our Founding Fathers and the principals this nation was founded upon should prove to even the most casual of observers that she truly is the “anti-Christ”.

As far as Pat goes, in this essay he is also 100% correct. It is rare I agree with Pat since whatever the problem is he usually manages somehow to blame the Jews, however; in this case he is spot-on. Next to Lyndon Johnson, Richard Nixon, and Jimmy Carter, I have to say that George Bush is the worst president in my lifetime. Johnson gave us Medicare and the socialist “great society”, Nixon is as mush a socialist as Johnson with OSHA, the EPA and his feeble attempt to control wages and prices, and Jimmy Carter is just disgusting, bigoted, mean old Stalinist.

A listing the top 5 worst presidents of the 20th century must include (from the very worst):

(1) Woodrow Wilson
(2) Jimmy Carter
(3) Lyndon Johnson
(4) Richard Nixon
(5) George W. Bush

Yes, as bad as Bill Clinton was, in terms of expanding federal power, George Bush is far worse.


Hillary is an amerikin politikin
Skywalker 81:

She's a commie when she talks to THAT crowd. A health expert when she talks to nurses. A farmer's daughter in the south. A free marketeer on Wall street. A comedienne on MTV. A Union maiden in detroit. A slave chile in Atlanta. A catholic in Boston. A jew in NY. A bible thumper in Lexington.

We hear her spewing commie slogans more because that happens to be her faithful mob and she gopes to them for funds and succor often. But she's no commie. She's no anything, she's really a formless life form, an amoeba. A whiff of air. A politikin. And considering she lived with THAT man for so long, ask yourself: WHAT ELSE could she have become?

Not that I wouldn't love seeing them both building homes for the poor in Patagonia or even the moon...

skywalker81
You are 100% correct and anyone who actually believes she is anything but, probably also believed that Hitler was just as passing phase and of no real consequence. Her own words, her hatred for this country, her deep-rooted anti-Semitism, her contempt for our Founding Fathers and the principals this nation was founded upon should prove to even the most casual of observers that she truly is the “anti-Christ”.

As far as Pat goes, in this essay he is also 100% correct. It is rare I agree with Pat since whatever the problem is he usually manages somehow to blame the Jews, however; in this case he is spot-on. Next to Lyndon Johnson, Richard Nixon, and Jimmy Carter, I have to say that George Bush is the worst president in my lifetime. Johnson gave us Medicare and the socialist “great society”, Nixon is as mush a socialist as Johnson with OSHA, the EPA and his feeble attempt to control wages and prices, and Jimmy Carter is just disgusting, bigoted, mean old Stalinist.

A listing the top 5 worst presidents of the 20th century must include (from the very worst):

(1) Woodrow Wilson
(2) Jimmy Carter
(3) Lyndon Johnson
(4) Richard Nixon
(5) George W. Bush

Yes, as bad as Bill Clinton was, in terms of expanding federal power, George Bush is far worse.


Bush the Apostate!
He now says Allah is God. He believes America is an 'idea' not a nation(thus open borders). He puts foreign countries such as Mexico and Iraq ahead of
America...thus, he is an apostate American.
As bipsey quee said, when pat is right he is right and when he is wrong he is real wrong. On this he is so right. On Bush's last day I believe as he boards Choppper 1 he will give America the finger!

Reject neo-cons
I voted for Pat Buchanan in the GOP primary in 1992 and 1996. This year I am voting for Ron Paul. The top tier of Republican candidates are neo-cons. I despise neo-cons.

Pat deserves a nice cigar.
Another great column by Buchanan.

Of the four examples cited by Buchanan that distinguishes real conservatism from Bush's faux-conservatism, I might quibble slightly with the immigration amnesty scheme. I thought Reagan, deemed to be a true conservative, had granted amnesty while president.

But the numbers were dramatically smaller then, and perhaps it was not the political issue it has become today.

Even so, this is a great column by Buchanan.

It should be required reading by all Americans, even neocons and dittoheads.


Reagan and free trade
Pat Buchanan would like us to forget that Ronald Reagan was a staunch free-trader.

It was his Adminstration that created the World Trade Organization (WTO) that Pat now denounces so bitterly.

Bush is the best -
Pres. Bush is the best person the CFR. Bilderbergs, central bankers, one worlder's ever had.

The creation of a nation where the elite are waited on by immigrants. No factories, just daily investing in global companies that sell overseas and bring the money home to themselves. Our citizens have few children and are becoming the minority and those without the education and investing and international connections will die out and be replaced by the immigrants coming in to serve the elite.

The creation of a middle-class in other nations to do the work of making the things the elite want may be part of the global plan those in the "ivory towers" have had for decades. We have been in decline in real wages until the 90's tech boom, since the late 70's. Now real wages are struggling again after that minor rebound in the 90's. Check out this chart on real wages.

http://www.americaneconomicalert.org/charting_economy.asp?P rod_ID=2229


Naw! I guess it isn't that bad, but, there are days it seems to be.

We have found the enemy...
...and they are us. Why did folks vote for Bush? I think it was that he was the best of two bad choices in the Presidential elections. The problem then is in the Republican primaries. How did the country club Republicans manage to take over? The problem seems to be the party apparatus.

The Deciders

The corporate owners of The Unified Establishment Party* are already shifting funding from Rudy to Hillary. They don't care which one wins. They win either way. The RNC and the DNC are two divisions under the same ownership. The cheap labor express will be kept running, regardless of the will of the people.

That is, unless we nominate and elect someone who actually WILL secure the border and enforce the laws. It's up to us to save the GOP from itself and bring it back to its principles. The "handlers" have to be shown the door by voting your conscience in the primaries. Stop listening to the spin and hype, decide for yourself who best represents your values. If a cross-dressing, former mayor of a sanctuary city who marches in gay pride parades reflects your values, vote for Rudy. If that does not reflect your values, figure out who does and vote accordingly. We can nominate someone other than the MSM's choice. It's our country, we are the deciders.

*(h/t Pasadena Phil)

Winning the hearts and minds
of a majority of voters to support the four positions Buchanan has so articulately defined will not be easy. If Ron Paul or Duncan Hunter or Mike Huckabee supports such a comprehensive position, he has not been successful in selling it. Each has emphasized some part, but it will take more than a Johnny One Note.

I agree with Pat except for one issue
Why has there never been peace in the Middle East? Because it is stuck in history. So how do we defeat a people who think it is better to sacrifice one's own miserable life here on earth for a better one in heaven by blowing oneself up and taking as many innocents with them as they can?

Bring prosperity to the region. It may not work,but here is one place that I agree with Bush. I didn't in the beginning, however, I see the wisdom creating a culture where a person creates his own destiny rather than being resigned to what "Allah wills" and "it will be better in the next life". It's called hope.

We didn't have to do it in World War II because Germany and Japan already have that mindset, yet they prosper under the new democratic governments and self-determination brought to them by the US. So how could it hurt to try this in a country where they have been stuck in the stone age for all of time and where they might at last experience the light of freedom?

Yesterday is gone....
Today is all we have. We better not continue just taking care of our own business and trusting that the government is watching out for us!

The wisdom of our founders gave us the right formula, but we have let our "smarter than thou" elected servants tweek it to where every thing comes out to zero for "the people". It has been so gradual that too many of us just kept our nose to the grind stone thinking we were being good citizens, while we were being sold out to the lowest bidders.

People of similar (not like) minds better find a common bond and come together if we are to continue having the ability to control our personal lives, enjoy a measure of liberty, and pursue happiness.

A wise fish is a wet fish.

Pat
Pat's document simply underscores the dilemma the GOP has gotten itself into. Conservatism as practiced and preached by Reagan worked. It led to control of the house, 20 out of 28 years of Republican presidents, and finally, to control of both the house, the senate, and the presidency. The message was fiscal prudence, government is the problem, personal responsibility, and caution in foreign policy pertaining to nation building activities. The most critical of these issues to re-election is fiscal responsibility, controlling the growth of government, and personal responsibility. In the 90's, there were no Drug entitlement acts, no Federalization of Education, no $22 B transportation bill, no $21 B agricultural bill, etc., yet the Republicans gained all the power. Then, they threw it away. They decided that to keep power they needed to buy it, rather than stay on message. Now, having lost much of the message that propelled them to power, the current group lacks the credibility to reclaim the high ground on these issues. They, in many ways, have reverted back to the pre-Reagan era. Democrat - lite.

Mick O asks how it can hurt to try to change Iraq. On one level it may not, but that's only true if we ignore whether or not that cost justifies whatever outcome we achieve, while equally ignoring the debt we had to run up to fund it - which has passed significant control of our economy over to foreign governments. We do not have leverage with the Chinese to change trade agreements, for example, because they own so much of our debt. Which harms our security the most?

In the end,

Does it matter?
As long as Bush dressed up in a red jersey what difference does it make what he does.

Regardless of the next socialist the red jersey puts on the ballot the sycophants will worship him also.


To ApolloSpeaks
I don't believe Providence had a hand in either the election of George W. Bush or that of Woodrow Wilson. If true, God really dislikes this country. Neither was a good president, to put it mildly.

Reagnite
Amen.

A real comic
JD's Handsome Son is a natural-born comic. I was waiting for the punch line as I read his post. He had to be doing a deadpan joke, right?

Letterman, Leno and all the other TV hosts: We have before us America's next great stand-up comic. Book him now.

He's right!!
I don't like Buchanan. In this case he's right on the money. Bush has been the second worst president of my lifetime (Carter was the worst by far). Bush (who I voted for twice) has done everything in his power to destroy the republican party and pretty much guarantee a Hillary win. He is a globalist who doesn't believe in the sovereignty of the USA. I have never been more disappointed in a president or felt more betrayed.

For the love of...
America and Pat Buchanan. Thanks Pat for another great article. I do not believe however that the majority of Americans will understand our peril until it's too late. Most blacks vote Democrap on blind faith, most hispanics vote democrap for selfish reasons, (such as having every family member still back in Mexico live here) and every gay or lesbian voting democrat in hopes of a marriage amendment. The days of ask not what your country can do for you, but what you can do for your country are OVER!

economics
I have the misfortune of having studied economics. Honduras could produce an airplane that it can buy from us for $100 million or produce one themselves for many billions of dollars. We can buy a banana grown in Honduras for a few cents or grow it ourselves in hot houses for ten dollars per banana. But not knowing as much as Pat, we build airplanes and sell them to folks in Hondoras and the folks in Hondoras grow bananas and sell them to us cheap while buying our airplanes. So if some foreigners want to sell us things at give away prices and are silly enough to refuse to buy things we produce dirt cheap but instead accept green pieces or paper that they can eventually decide to use, good luck to them. Somehow or other, Pat to the contrary notwithstanding, our standard of living and the size of our economy is outstanding and continues to improve.

Whether or not you appreciate Pat
Whether or not you appreciate Pat, he is right that the chickens have come home to roost for both the Republicans and the Country as a whole. This all out sprint to sell off America in the name of Globalism will haunt us in the near future.

Actually Bandu
Chinese banks using western standards are bankrupt, the SOEs suck billions of Yuan out of the economy every year, the country is headed for an environmental meltdown, and the peasants (which lead the last revolution)are revloting on almost a daily basis.

Taiwanese, Hong Kong and the western money is keeping China afloat. China is headed for an iceberg and the leadership of the CCP is unwilling to take the hard steps required to keep the entire thing from blowing up. If you think the US has problems, they are nothing compared to what China is facing.

GOD BLESS AMERICA
nuff said

Well done, Pat
Loved the beginning of the article: Bush is THIS kind of a conservative, and THAT kind of a conservative and THIS kind of a conservative. When in fact, what Bush is is a liberal. He sold out conservatism a loooooong time ago. I'm no fan of Hillary, Barack, Chris and Johnny Boy -- but to be honest, George is not any better. He can cry Republican all he wants -- but he's a Democrat based on his behavior, a Democrat who likes to wage war, that's all. I have nothing against Democrats. The world is full of them. But I'm not fond of those who masquerade as conservatives when, in reality, they support every action and every policy that is slowly selling this wonderful country down the river to Mexico,Latin America and the Middle East.

Well said
JD's Handsome Son writes:
***
A Bright Future for America
It'll be good to have the democrats in office in 2009. They're going to lock our borders tight, get rid of all the illegals, build up our industrial might, strengthen the military, defeat our enemies abroad, balance the budget, reduce the size of government and protect all our rights.

Hillary Clinton is a loyal, patriotic American who wants to see this country strong and respected around the world. She'll make a superb Commander in Chief. She's the most qualified person on the planet to manage our economy and charter the best path for a bright future for America.
***

Well said. Hilary will save this nation from the Bush Republicans, who don't give a rat's sass about America, or her citizens, unless they're multi-millionaires.

peace

Buchanon is right again!
George Bush is more of a democrat than most democrats! Hey Jack...so you think our standard of living is rising??? Oh Really?? Is that why the symptoms of ECOLI are known to everyone now? or why LEAD is considered integral to a childs nutritional supplement...via their toys?? hey maybe that explains the rise is AUTISM , as the number of Chinese Toys have increased porportionately to the rise of this illness.Maybe that's why math scores have dropped and stupidity reigns!!
By the way, most salaries are lower than they were 15 years ago...while food and other products prices rise ever higher.Jobs leave the country by the day and a larger number of illegals arrive to take the few that remain.Sick of moronic politicians and citizens who are oblivious to the erosion of the countrys culture, economy and standard of living. I'm sure Pat is as frustrated as most Americans are about the race to the bottom Bush has taken the country.

Emperor Buchanan
Once fascist critiquing another.

It's not free trade. It's federal taxes.
Pat Buchanan correctly exposes 3 pillars of belief that have failed Republicans and Bush, but he is mistaken about free trade. Free trade is not the reason we are hemorrhaging jobs, running record trade deficits, and the dollar is falling: our federal taxes our. Every major US trading partner has adopted a business friendly VAT tax that rebates taxes on foreign exports and taxes imports, our tax structure embeds a 22% price hike, on average, on every product and service made in America. Therefore, whenever an American product competes with a foreign product, at home or abroad, the US product is penalized by that embedded tax. The solution is to adopt the FairTax. Our exports will have no embedded taxes. All products sold in America, foreign and domestic, will have a 23% embedded tax, putting American made goods and services on a level playing field with our trading partners. And Americans, who are still the most productive workers in the world, will win. Did I mention that everybody gets to keep 100% of their paychecks too?

Dan Bartlett won't criticize Giuliani
Who is Dan Bartlett? Former counselor to President Bush. Some called him Bush's alter ego.

Well, the alter ego, Mr. Bartlett spoke for the first time publically since resigning from his White House Position. He spoke about the Republican race for President. He had plenty of criticism for the candidates.

But none for Giuliani.

The article in The Washington Post suggested Bartlett may think along the lines of the President since he served 14 years with Bush.

If Mr. Buchanan is right about Bush's four principles: Big government conservatism, Wilsonian interventionism, amnesty, and so-called free trade that has taken the U.S. to a $800 billion trade deficit in '06.

Bartlett's failure to criticize Giuliani could be because Bush wants to hand off the baton to a like minded new President.

Question: Are these four principles, something Republicans want to carry on?

Because likely a Giuliani Administration would carry on all of these principles.

Pat has provided a strong analysis as to why these principles are destructive to America.

Are they destructive to America? If so, why would Republicans want to support Rudy Giuliani?

To lostinwilderness:
You are right about the tax structure, but that's what has been called "free trade" for years.

It is not free trade. That is just a label and a mask for "managed" trade. It is called free trade so people don't examine the actual terms of the trade.

If Americans in sizable numbers knew the actual terms of the trade, they would think it's neither free nor fair.

The Congress has tried to change this structure several times, but our trading partners would not agree.

It's too good of a deal for them.

Would Giuliani renegotiate these terms?

There is no indication he would.

That's the problem.

Jack writes: 09, 2007 3:55 PM

economics
I have the misfortune of having studied economics.

DESKJOCKEY WRITES

Well Jack I had the same misfortune and I like Pat and he is a great historian but unlike us, Pat skipped his eco classes and took populism 101.
Sign Up to Post Your CommentsSign Up to Post Your Comments
If you are already registered, click here to login. Otherwise, please take a few seconds to register with Townhall.com. Once you sign up, you’ll be able to post your comments immediately, use the action center, get podcasts, and more!
Note: Fields marked with a red asterisk (*) are required.
Salutation:
First Name:
*
Last Name:
*
Email:
*
Nickname:
*
Note: Nick name will be shown when you post comments.
Address 1:
*
Address 2:
City:
*
State:
*
Zip:
*
Phone:
      
Your daily must-read of conservative columns, cartoons and news. Coulter, Sowell, Krauthammer and more.
(Bi-Weekly) We highlight the best opportunities from our partners for surveys, action items and more.