Townhall.com, Where Your Opinion Counts
Talk Radio:   Bill Bennett   Mike Gallagher   Dennis Prager   Michael Medved   Hugh Hewitt   
BREAKING NEWS  LeftArrow - Townhall.com : Conservative, Political, Republican   RightArrow - Townhall.com : Conservative, Political, Republican  
Columns, funnies & more in your inbox!
  • Check the boxes and send us your email address to receveive your free newsletter
  • Your daily must-read of conservative columns, cartoons and news. Coulter, Sowell, Krauthammer and more.
  • Townhall.com’s weekly inside scoop on what’s happening behind the scenes in the world of politics. When news breaks, we report.
  • Signup to receive the latest daily Townhall cartoons
Friday, September 05, 2008
Oliver North :: Townhall.com Columnist
Report From a Forgotten War (5th and Last in a Series)
by Oliver North
Vote on It:
Average Vote:
[+] Text [-]
 
Poll
Will the Dems' health care Christmas Present to America be an improvement or detriment to our health care system?


KABUL, Afghanistan -- It is good to be heading home, where there are paved roads, no Russian landmines, and the man standing at the next intersection isn't going to blow himself to pieces trying to kill me, my family and my friends. At home, drinkable water comes out of a faucet, not just from a plastic bottle. Home is where meals come on plates -- not in brown plastic bags -- and we have air conditioning and fresh green vegetables and showers last as long as we want. At home, we go to work in coats and ties instead of body armor and helmets. At home, our vehicles don't have turrets, and if we drive after dark, we use headlights instead of night-vision goggles. At home, "overhead cover" is protection from the elements, not a defense from enemy rocket or mortar fire.

In America, we take all these things for granted. Here in the shadows of the Hindu Kush, however, ignoring any of them could get a soldier, sailor, airman, guardsman or Marine killed. Unfortunately, the so-called mainstream media has ignored this fight for so long that few in the U.S. are even aware of the challenges confronting our 33,000 troops in this always difficult and often dangerous place. For the benefit of those who care, here are some particulars that the potentates of the press generally have overlooked. First, the bad news:

--Islamic radicals know that their cause is lost in Iraq, so remnants of the Taliban, al-Qaida and foreign fighters intent on joining a jihad against the West are flooding into Afghanistan from Pakistan and Iran. Factions in both neighboring countries are providing safe haven and training and material support to those who want to overthrow the democratically elected government in Kabul.

--Despite seven years of United Nations and NATO "assistance" to Afghanistan, the Afghan army still has fewer than 85,000 troops, and the country still has only one paved highway (Route 1, the "Ring Road"). As we were reminded firsthand on this trip, the dirt tracks that pass for roads here are laced with landmines and improvised explosive devices, causing numerous U.S. and Afghan casualties and isolating the population.

--Illicit drug production -- heroin/opium/hashish/marijuana, the only real cash crops in the country -- is an enormous criminal enterprise, generating more than $5 billion in cash to benefit the Taliban and corrupt officials in the Afghan government.

--The U.N.-led "economic reconstruction" of Afghanistan is a miserable failure. The number of displaced refugees, life expectancy, live birth rate, illiteracy, childhood disease, malnutrition and unemployment all are getting worse instead of better because of incompetence, corruption and lack of coordination among "international donors." The Taliban insurgency thrives on ignorance and misery. As one U.S. officer put it, "We're feeding the beast."

--There is no coherent command-and-control structure or common set of operating procedures among U.S. forces, the Afghan National Army, the Afghan National Police or the 25 other nations in NATO's International Security Assistance Force, nearly all of which have different rules of engagement or national caveats on how they will be employed. Though some U.S. units, such as the 24th Marine Expeditionary Unit and the 101st Airborne Division, have integral air support, others have to rely on the ISAF. As a result, wounded Americans have waited hours for casualty evacuation, and sometimes it never comes.

Now the good news. Though there are significant cultural and tribal differences between Afghanistan and Iraq -- the military/security situation in Afghanistan is similar to what it was in Mesopotamia 2 1/2 years ago -- they are equally "winnable" if we do the right things. Some repairs will take time, but these are needed urgently:

--Inform both the Pakistani and Iranian governments that insurgent cross-border operations will not be tolerated and that if Taliban/terror bases on their territories are not closed, they will be attacked.

--Commence building paved roads throughout all of Afghanistan's 34 provinces, not just in urban areas. Such projects will generate tens of thousands of jobs, create lasting infrastructure, reduce casualties from IEDs and mines, and show the Afghan people that their government cares about them.

--Stop illicit drug production from the top down, not the bottom up. Arrest and prosecute the kingpins, and then go for eradication and crop replacement. It worked in Colombia, and it can work in Afghanistan.

--Fix the unity of command problem immediately. The NATO-ISAF command structure should be shut down. "Allied" forces that can't or won't fight should be thanked and sent home. More U.S. troops are needed desperately in Afghanistan, but unless Gen. Petraeus is given clear lines of authority to do what has to be done, the Afghan army and police never will get the equipment and training they need. He did it in Iraq. Now he needs to do it in Afghanistan.

The Afghan people don't want to be ruled by Islamic radicals. Afghan soldiers -- properly trained, equipped, led and supported -- are brave and fight well, but they can't win unless these problems are fixed. Neither they nor the young Americans serving here should have to wait for a new administration in Washington to make the necessary repairs.

Share:
Vote on It:
Average Vote:
 
About The Author

Oliver North is the founder and honorary chairman of Freedom Alliance and author of The Assassins .

Be the first to read Oliver North's column. Sign up today and receive Townhall.com delivered each morning to your inbox.

©Creators Syndicate
Blow-back from US attack
Oh my Lord...

News out of G.B. indicates that U.S. and Afghan troops were fooled into attacking a village in Nawabad based on false info from a rival clan: (Times of London: http://www.timesonline.co.uk/tol/news/world/asia/article47 10062.ece).

And contrary to initial U.S. Mil reports of only seven civilian casualties (based on info from an embedded U.S. Journo now identified as Oliver North - http://www.timesonline.co.uk/tol/news/world/asia/article46 99077.ece), evidence supports claims the attack killed 92 - including 60 children. The U.S. is re-investigating.

This is no way to "win the hearts & minds" of the Afghan people.

Times have changed
I suppose the bulk of US power is standing ready for the bigger threats that are out there, but it seems that times have changed ...

In 1941-45 we had at any given moment up to 8 million in uniform, who successfully fought in many campaigns an enemy in many different forms, all over the world.

Nowadays, a deployment of 140 thousand or so against some flea-bitten insurgents in Iraq can make the US blind to its other war in
Afghanistan, and so the US now only has the capacity to wage one little war at a time.

Seems like the terrorists just aren't scaring us enough yet. But looking at all of our demographics changing before our eyes, we should be scared.


I know I've said it before...
Keep the faith Col. North.

The mainstream media may not be covering this very important battle, but you and the other brave men and women "over there" are in the thoughts and prayers of millions of Americans each and every day.

WE are out here, and WE care!

May God bless each and every one of you and guide you safely to swift victory.

THANK YOU for all you do to preserve our freedom and expand our allies to those new fledgling democracies smack dab in the Mid-East.

We will NEVER be able to thank you enough.

But many of us will TRY!

To taft on Army Suicide Rate
Every loss of life in the Army is tragic. Multiple programs are in place to help Soldiers deal with stress to include screening and counseling.

However according to the article you cited the rate of military suicides, with all the deployments and stress we face is lower then the civilian population when adjusted for age and sex.

From the source taft cited:
The rate per 100,000 Soldiers was 18.1 per 100,000 last year -

For civilians the demographically adjusted rate is 19.5 per 100,00 for the civilian population.

So what exactly is the point of your post? That Soldiers have a lower rate of suicide then the same age group in civilian life? And other then a fine testamony to our military what does this show?
Again every loss of life is tragic and we are constantly seeking ways to improve the care our Soldiers recieve.

North
Why isn't his appalling lack of care about Iraq and Afghanistan getting more coverage.

This will shock people.

Of the three cable news stations, FOX NEWS came in last on Iraq War coverage.

North must have some pull at Fox and should push for news like this.

Army Suicide Rate May Set Record Again

http://www.military.com/news/article/army-suicide-rate-may- set-record-again-.html?col=1186032310810


Thanks LTC North!
Excellent piece pointing out some of the needs for our forces in Afghanistan. Wish more people paid attention to this theatre of the war as it is the one most frought with danger to the US. The British never tamed this area in over 100 years during their colonial period. Islam itself is what creates the worst problem. It is a religion that refuses to acknowledge any other belief system, and it is unfortunately firmly established in the region. NGOs that are Christian in nature cannot enter the region due to local restrictions, and if allowed, simply become targets. Iran actively agitates and supports the Taliban, as does Pakistan, and the unruly tribal warlords in the Waziristan region. This makes our mission there extremely difficult without a State Department that actively supports the mission. Such unfortunately hasn't been true since WW2.
Keep up the good work though.

North wrote
in "bad news", "the UN led 'economic reconstruction' of Afghanistan is a miserable failure".

No surprise there--when has the UN ever had a success in any program?

to teehall Current Goal in Afghanistan
In addition to fighting the Al-queda remnants in Afghan and battling the resurgent elements of the Taliban Gov that enabled them, the current mission of the military is to provide the peace and security so that the state department can achieve the diplomatic objectives of:
A Stable and Democratic Afghanistan: Helping Afghanistan to achieve peace and stability will require a continued commitment by the Department, USAID, and international donors to four interlocking objectives: (1) Afghanistan must establish internal and external security to ensure economic reconstruction, political stability, and stem the rise in opium production; (2) we must work to establish a stable, effective, and broadly representative central government; (3) economic development must bolster this new government and reduce dependence on donors; and (4) we must help the people of Afghanistan meet their critical humanitarian needs while reconstruction proceeds.
tinsldr2@yahoo.com

Home
I think that LTC North can understand "going home" in a sense that few who have not served overseas can truly feel.

Whenever I returned from Iraq, I remember the doors of the plane opening, the smell of the GA pines and slight salt marsh smell of the low country. The sight of veterens standing in two rows with American Flags, welcoming us home as we walk between them, is the first thing we see. Then after what seems an impossibly long time of admin details and weapons turn in but really is a brief and efficient process we march to a formation where our leaders thank us for what we did and thank our assembled families for the sacrifices THEY made while we were gone. Then we are "cut loose" and that first joyous moment when we get to hugg our wives and kids. There is no feeling in the world quite like that.

Of course I can only imagine what LTC John McCain felt after what he had gone through when he got home. And while it is great to be home, people that have been there like McCain and North can never forget the costs paid and being paid by those we leave behind.

However there are some things worth fighting for, and those things and the trials we go through to earn them, make comming home with HONOR that much sweeter.

Mr. North
Thank you for your hard work and information. We are in your debt. I don't understand. How many times does it need to be said that we are in a war against Terrorism.
Stable countries can fight terror. Unstable countries cannot.
Terrorism because it is evil if left to itself grows worse.
It cannot be ignored.
It will not go away on it's own.
It cannot be pacified.
It must be squashed.
Can the American people through fundraising in the private sector at least help to get rid of the Atheist Communist's landmines. Despicable.
Are you saying that George W has given up. He must keep up the fight until his last moment in office.

What Is Expected In Afghanistan?
Wasn't the purpose for invading Afgahn. to get back at the people which did the thing on 9/11. If that is the answer, what is our goal there now? Describe the end result that some expect. Democratic government? Kill all the terrorists? The first seems to have been done. The second is impossible since most of we people in the US are not muslim. How about eliminating tribal wars? Do it in a few years? Never, it has been going on since people set foot on that land. Wouldn't it have been better to assist Russia conquer Afghanistan?

Excellent column Col.!
This is the kind of information we need to put pressure on our Congressmen and Senators to correct and expand the mission in Afghanistan.

I know you are on your way back to the world Col., but please continue with these types of article with the information from your contacts who are still over there.

Thank you Col. North.

B.O. is offensive!

TBC ~:>{)

Why can't we learn?
Why can't we follow through with Afghanistan? We didn't do it after we helped them defeat the Russians, and look at what happened. What do we think is going to happen if we don't follow through this time? We need to spend the money and time now so we don't have to spend even more later.

Also, no wonder many of them and the world hate America. We come in with a battle cry of promises of making things better, but it isn’t quite quick enough for the short attention span of the America politicians or people. So by the time we get past the initial excitement of the invasion, we’ve moved onto another problem and the people of that country are left out in the cold. We need to stay focused and finish the job we started THE RIGHT WAY!


Shame on us....
The absence of comments on this article speaks to the complacency, disinterest and willful ignorance of what our troops and the Afghans are experiencing. In the case of the MSM, this rises to the level of criminal negligence. A snippet on page 10E in some paper when a soldier or Marine is killed is not what I call informing the public.

Ollie's observations also speak to the impotence of the UN and the command and control problems inherent in coalitions. It is criminal that our wounded are not adequately supported by US medical evacuation assets. Ollie is entirely correct is stating, "... the young Americans serving here should have to wait for a new administration in Washington to make the necessary repairs."

Has GWB lst his cojones? Has the MSM so poisoned the atmosphere in America that we are incapable of positive concerted action? Have the self serving fools in congress so tied the hands of the CinC that he can no longer protect our troops on the ground or give Gen Patreus, who already knows HOW to do it, the authority and tools to do the job?

My God, people. Wake up before we have to buy burkas and prayer rugs!

McCain/Palin will give our guys and gals the leadership and tools to do the job. But why should they have to wait?

Ollie, please keep up the good work!

Retired Green Beret O5
Sign Up to Post Your CommentsSign Up to Post Your Comments
If you are already registered, click here to login. Otherwise, please take a few seconds to register with Townhall.com. Once you sign up, you’ll be able to post your comments immediately, use the action center, get podcasts, and more!
Note: Fields marked with a red asterisk (*) are required.
Salutation:
First Name:
*
Last Name:
*
Email:
*
Nickname:
*
Note: Nick name will be shown when you post comments.
Address 1:
*
Address 2:
City:
*
State:
*
Zip:
*
Phone:
      
Your daily must-read of conservative columns, cartoons and news. Coulter, Sowell, Krauthammer and more.
(Bi-Weekly) We highlight the best opportunities from our partners for surveys, action items and more.