Townhall.com, Where Your Opinion Counts
Talk Radio:   Bill Bennett   Mike Gallagher   Dennis Prager   Michael Medved   Hugh Hewitt   
BREAKING NEWS  LeftArrow - Townhall.com : Conservative, Political, Republican   RightArrow - Townhall.com : Conservative, Political, Republican  
Columns, funnies & more in your inbox!
  • Check the boxes and send us your email address to receveive your free newsletter
  • Your daily must-read of conservative columns, cartoons and news. Coulter, Sowell, Krauthammer and more.
  • Townhall.com’s weekly inside scoop on what’s happening behind the scenes in the world of politics. When news breaks, we report.
  • Signup to receive the latest daily Townhall cartoons
Wednesday, May 20, 2009
Michael Medved :: Townhall.com Columnist
After Death Decadence
by Michael Medved
Vote on It:
Average Vote:
[+] Text [-]
 
Poll
Will the Dems' health care Christmas Present to America be an improvement or detriment to our health care system?


It’s a sure sign of decadence when a society treats dead bodies with callousness, mocking cruelty, levity and disrespect.

A recent headline in the New York Times gave evidence of such degradation while suggesting the sort of outrageous parody best suited for “The Onion.”

“CADAVER SEX EXHIBITION IN GERMANY IS CRITICIZED,” noted America’s Journal of Record and then reported on the latest ground-breaking show by the acclaimed artist, Gunther von Haugen. Herr von Haugen previously inspired controversy with his display “Bodies: The Exhibition,” which toured the United States and featured skinned and preserved human remains. His new triumph, “The Cycle of Life,” features actual corpses posed and frozen forever in a variety of simulated sex acts. While some critics in Berlin complained of the exhibit’s “tastelessness,” von Haugen and his supporters insisted that they used only bodies (and body parts) that came from “voluntary donors.”

The notion that any human being would view his own earthly remains so casually that he (or she) would welcome their deployment before gawking strangers as skinned sex toys in an avant garde art exhibit represents an appalling affront to human dignity.

Meanwhile, another (though far less ghastly) fad in the display of corpses illustrates a similarly unhealthy attitude in our own civilization.

A Michigan businessman recently launched a company called “Eternal Image” which encourages customers to journey to the next world adorned with the logo of their favorite baseball team. “Our goal is to take everyday household-brand names and integrate the design into funeral products,” says Clint Mytych. “We want to celebrate a person’s life.”

To facilitate that celebration, Mr. Mytych offers licensed Major League funeral urns, resembling large ceramic jars of baked beans, in which the ashes of the deceased are sealed with a replica of a regulation baseball. The urn rests on its own home plate, complete with the authorized MLB logo, suggesting that the departed has successfully rounded the bases and finally scored in the great beyond, now resting, appropriately, safe at home.

“We have sold so many baseball urns because people just want it around the house – they feel nothing will better honor their loved ones,” declared Mr. Mytych, a life-long Detroit Tigers fan. He reports that the New York Yankees, Boston Red Sox and Chicago Cubs provide the decoration for the most popular urns (suggested price $799). This fall, Eternal Image will begin offering Major League Baseball caskets (starting at $4,500) for fans choosing to avoid cremation. “It’s really a beautiful thing,” Dan Biggins, co-director of a funeral home in Rockland, Massachusetts, told the Boston Globe.

It’s easy to understand how the invocation of the innocence, purity and timelessness of baseball (without disturbing reminders of A-Rod and Barry Bonds, one hopes) could lighten mournful occasions with gentle smiles, but even the most committed fan ought to question the eternal significance of his team loyalty. Sure, I love my Seattle Mariners (and I grew up as a generally heart-broken devotee of the Philadelphia Phillies), but I’d hardly want my life’s deepest significance defined in terms of these recreational enthusiasms. When the promoters of Major League Funeral Urns suggest that the bereaved feel “nothing will better honor their loved ones” than the corporate logo of a favorite commercial franchise, it seems to trivialize the earthly journey of the departed.

In his new memoir “Losing Mum and Pup,” Christopher Buckley describes the death of his famous parents and recalls that his father, William F. Buckley, wanted his ashes planted in the midst of a huge metal cross in the garden of his long-time Connecticut home. One might question the tastefulness of such an arrangement or (as Christopher Buckley suggests) the reaction of future owners of the place, but it’s impossible to challenge the essential seriousness of WFB’s desire to associate himself, for eternity, with his Lord and Savior.

The yen for immortal connection with the Red Sox or Yankees, on the other hand (not to mention the Milwaukee Brewers or Minnesota Twins) seems to undermine rather than celebrate the idea of a life of purpose and meaning.

Touring historic grave yards (like the richly atmospheric Grove Street Cemetery in New Haven) evokes a time when even the most humble citizens hoped for a sense of family, community and continuity in their final resting places. A ceramic jar with a sports logo offers an artificial connection that constitutes a poor substitute for the after-death proximity of relatives and neighbors.

No, neither baseball-themed funerals, nor the wish of football enthusiasts to see their ashes scattered at the 50 yard line of favorite stadiums, amount to the hideous affront to decency demonstrated by Gunther von Haugen’s pornographic manipulation of shellacked cadavers in coitus.

But the common element involves a dismissive, materialist attitude that views the body as insignificant—unworthy of solemnity and respect. If our corpses amount to nothing more than dead flesh—a cheap collection of chemicals, ripe for decay – then there’s no reason to object to using those remains for after-death displays of sports mania or public exhibitions of aggressive eroticism. If we make light of our opportunities and obligations in life, then it stands to reason that we’ll shrug off our fate after death.

While our ancestors may wait through eternity for the arrival (or the return) of The Messiah, some of the honored dead of the present day anticipate with similarly fervent faith and altogether irrational certainty the long-promised re-appearance of the Chicago Cubs in the World Series.

Share:
Vote on It:
Average Vote:
 
About The Author
Michael Medved's daily syndicated radio talk show reaches one of the largest national audiences every weekday between 3 and 6 PM, Eastern Time. Michael Medved is the author of eleven books, including the bestsellers What Really Happened to the Class of '65?, Hollywood vs. America, Right Turns and, most recently, The Ten Big Lies About America.
 
TOWNHALL DAILY: Be the first to read Michael Medved's column. Sign up today and receive Townhall.com daily lineup delivered each morning to your inbox.
Well, perhaps the people requesting
sports themed urns are simply being realistic.

No doubt Christopher Buckley spent a large percentage of his time thinking about God and how his religion shaped his life. But what if you spend most of your life watching your favorite sport, reading sports statistics and discussing sports with your friends? Doesn't it make sense to wish to be associated in eternity with what is really important to you? Not what is supposed to be important to you, but what you spent your time, energy and money on.

Sense of Worth
I would hope that even those that have the faith to believe they evolved from lower life forms would see such an "art" exhibit of cadavers as an affront to being human. As one that believes i have been fearfully and wonderfully made and was known before i even came to be, such an exhibit shows how far mankind has fallen

Unfortunately
Mankind has not fallen that far. We have always had the twisted and bizarre but what has happened are better ways to promote those ideas. I am a liberal, but even in my very left leanings I find this exhibit most appalling. While I understood the first exhibit and didn't have a problem with it because studying the human body's intricacies is extremely interesting, but there is no reason at all to bring sex into the equation. That just moves it into the perverse.

Obviously
You are not a Cleveland fan. We live and die (mostly die) by our Tribe, Browns and Cavs.


New forms of "harsh interrogation"?
I suppose we could lock up Gitmo detainees in an enclosed area along with Gunther van Haugen's exhibit. How long before some of them start to break down and confess?

Just the thought
makes me want to barf..can anyone get any sicker than this so called artist?? There's no limits to depravity and deviancy for some people.

I laughed, I cried
Lovely essay, Michael.

May I place my order......
Are those human skin lamp shades going to be back in stock soon?

Remember History.

Hmmmm?
Medved "While our ancestors may wait through eternity for the arrival (or the return) of The Messiah, some of the honored dead of the present day anticipate with similarly fervent faith and altogether irrational certainty the long-promised re-appearance of the Chicago Cubs in the World Series."
-------------
Chicago Cubs?????Do these caskets come with heated sides and insulated blankets because the only way the Cubs will ever re-appear in a world series is when H3LL freezes over.

Those old cemeteries
Once while on a camping trip in the Blue Ridge Mountains, my family and I came upon an old cemetery. We walked around and read many of the headstones some dating back centuries.

It was sobering and poignant to see families that had as many as eight or ten children with over half of them dying before age five. This was common before the advent of modern medicine.

This sort of history lesson reminds one of the high price paid to settle this country, and also keeps us humble and thankful as to how good we have it today. My daughter was eleven at the time of this trip and she remembers to this day the impression that this cemetery had on her.

Memorial Day is fast approaching
and my guess is far more citizens will attend their local services then will ever view the artsy fartsy dead people sex show.

Our country is not entirely living in the soup of decadence.

I have to differ with Medved on this one
1. When I die, I don't care what happens to my body. I don't need it any more. My eternal spirit has moved on. The only important issue is that no one catches a disease from my remains.

2. I'm much more horrified with the way our society treats the living.

chris ... Yes, and Yes!

I too am horrified at this society. We have become a rude and disgusting lot. God will most certainly show his displeasure.


My Death
Frankly, when I die, I recognize that I'm not using the body anymore. It's just a thing, like how most people don't get terribly upset when they get rid of an old car and buy a new one. My body, like that car, is just a way for me to get from point A to point B.

That said, I want to be frozen and shot into space. That way I can set the record for the human who travelled the furthest distance from Earth. Maybe even do this when I'm alive but have a terminal illness.

MICHAEL MEDVED
on his radio show, just allowed a black man that called himself donald, smear rush, sean and mark levin. the man went on and on about how educated he, his wife, his kids and all his friends were so educated and donald just couldn't understand why conservatives didn't give obama a break, why conservatives don't just bend over and grab their ankles. michael says we should try to reach out to donald. my question to michael is WHY??????

Death, taxes, and Medved's judgment
... all seem to be things you can never escape.

Medved's insistence on a reverence towards death is strange. Surely expressing an irreverent or casual view of one's body after death is a valid view too. Indeed, one could criticize Buckley's final wish -- to be placed at the center of a metal cross -- as well. You could certainly say there is something arrogant about wanting to build a prominent reminder of yourself in your yard, as a constant reminder of your importance to family members and subsequent owners.

Ultimately, I wouldn't criticize Buckley any more than the people who want to be enshrined in a cubs urn. It's these people's final wish, and whether self-aggrandizing, tasteless, or trivial, it seems better simply to follow it without judgment.

Ms Kelly
What a great way to drive home the wonders of modern medicine, while appreciating the spirit, toughness and determination of those who came first. I still find it amazing that anyone could ever believe the lifespans then weren't usually as long as they are now; we are still seeing the first descendants of pioneers dying at 90+ here where I live; my MIL remembers shipping bakery products to Meeker via horse-drawn wagons in the 30's and even the 40's!

I have my granddad's old family Bible; there are some faded photos and even a daguerrotype or two. None are labeled so I have no idea who they were, but the thing that sobered me was a listing of one of the Wallis family's antecedents. Five children out of a family of six children were carried away by scarlet fever. It is mind-boggling to realize that if that one child had not lived, my grandmother would not have been able to marry the man who was my granddad, and so on.

Makes you grateful for life, doesn't it?

the origins of the "artist"
I saw von Hagens's exhibit when it came to Houston's Museum of Natural Science. At one point we passed a panel with some information on the... um... artist. My friend's mother pointed out that he was born in 1945, and I responded that he wasn't actually born in 1945, but that 1945 was the earliest record they had of him.

She later postulated that the male cadavers were all circumcised, which suggested that they were, like she is, Jewish. I pointed out that most of the displays were missing much more than just their foreskins.


+++

Townhall's Pop-up Ads Suck!
Every time I move my mouse I have to close another window what a pain in the butt. It makes this sight totally user un-friendly.

This and his previous exhibit
are what passes for "art" nowadays?

Guenther must be European; most likely Dutch.

They will probably be the first subsumed into Eurabia.

Insinuations from Charles Martel
I assume from your "earliest record" comment that you are implying that the artist was a Nazi, a suggestion you certainly shouldn't make lightly. Hurrying to label controversial art as degenerate has historical implications of its own.

Bad Taste at the Cemetery
I do genealogy, which sometimes involves visiting cemeteries. At one I picked up a brochure from a table in the office. It advertised a series of, I don't know what to call this, bird releases, in which live doves would be let loose as part of the burial ceremony. The worst was a special deal if the dear departed had been in the military---it was called The 21-Dove Salute and involved releasing, you guessed it, 21 doves. There seems to be something about death that brings out the worse in bad taste. I have also seen graves marked not only with a headstone and flowers but with flashing lights, whirligigs, and a photograph of the dead.

Lilly
Sorry, but I can't imagine why someone would get
upset with a 21-dove salute or with a photograph
of the dead. I first noticed photographs on
tombstones in many places in Europe, especially
in mid-European countries and I loved it.

When I had to make a decision about such a
practice myself, I added the photograph without
a 2nd thought. No regrets, ever. I think
that flashing lights and whirligigs are a bit
much, but leave the photograph. It is a
wonderful idea. I wish more people would
use it.

soulsamurai
"
Townhall's Pop-up Ads Suck!
Every time I move my mouse I have to close another window what a pain in the butt. It makes this sight totally user un-friendly."

***
Couldn't agree with you more. But you stopped
too soon. How smart is it to give each post
a # that moves every time someone writes a new
post. That number becomes absolutely useless
as a reference point.

And on the forums on Amazon.com you can post
directly below the person you are answering.
You can spell their name without having to
move. You can reread their post as you
respond. And best of all, if you notice a
mistake in your post you can edit it later.

Amazon knows how to have a forum that isn't
annoying, no pop up ads, no annoying streams,
etc.

Medved:
Just out of curiosity - what is the purpose of
this column?

Isn't this type of behavior............
protected under the Federal "You Hurt My Fellings Because I'm an Emotionally Immature Adult" Crimes legislation? Is it really necromania when two corpses are having sex? Oh, those twisted LGBT Germans......any gay sex cannibalism in the exhibit? It wouldn't be Germany without gay cannibalism. Is cannibalism a protected paraphilia?

Who Decides?
Michael:
Who gave you the authority to decide that a person's dedication to the Philadelphia Phillies is less dignified than the dedication to some superstition that tells him he can live forever? At least the Phillies never hurt anyone.

Tammy, you can reverse the
order of the posts by clicking the "View in ascending order" just above the posts.

But it's better to refer to them by time anyway, in case an early post gets deleted for offensiveness causes all the post numbers to move up.

To AliveInHim
When you count up how many children died in childhood (my ggg-grandmother had 16 of whom 9 died), or how many women died in childbirth, or adults of diseases that no longer plague us (my gg-grandfather's brother died at 31 of diphtheria and another grandfather died at 24 of typhoid) it is surprising that anyone then lived into old age. I have a gggg-grandmother born in NC in 1765 who journeyed to the Midwest by oxcart when she was 70 and lived another 20 years; her gravestone confirms that she died at 90. And I wonder too what old age, assuming that people survived at all, would have been like without our glasses, cataract surgery, heart pills, and dentists. Our ancestors were truly awe-inspiring.

My body hurts.
It's getting slow and ugly. I'm looking forward to the promised new body. I don't see any reason to believe a plain pine box or a copper plated box with a velvet interior or a baseball themed coffin to put my old dead body in make a hill of beans difference. Why should dying cost so much $$$$. I think the funeral service should be carefully planned though. Favorite music, poetry, scriptures etc. Memories of who you were, what you believed and who you loved that is what you leave behind.

As to the sick mind in Germany. The man belongs in prison before he kills somebody. Who would even guess that someone would do such a disgusting thing.

The whole man...


“While our ancestors may wait through eternity for the arrival (or the return) of The Messiah…” –Michael Medved


Mr. Medved, it is a given that when men suppress the knowledge of God and hold the Law of God in contempt then lawlessness will become more and more prevalent. There is no limit to the depths of human depravity.

But I must comment on the world view you display in your statement about Messiah. First, the deference to your Christian readers is noted and appreciated. Thank you for reminding me of the testimony of Job…

For I know that my Redeemer lives,
And He shall stand at last on the earth;
And after my skin is destroyed, this I know,
That in my flesh I shall see God [Job 19:25-26]

Job introduces the Biblical doctrine of the bodily resurrection in beautiful Old Covenant language. The whole man both body and soul is fallen, and the whole man is redeemed.

a--YIKES!
YOU might be just an animated piece of meat, but I'm not. My body is the temple which houses my spirit, and God expects me to treat it with respect. As nurses, we were taught to show just as much respect for the dead as for the living--not to uncover them needlessly, etc.--to protect their dignity. We were created in God's image, and we are required to show respect for ourselves as such. Yeah, yeah, your ancestors were monkeys, blah, blah, blah. This German crap--and you--show just how debased humanity has become, and is still becoming. God help us.

Lilly
Right you are. For once, I agree with you! :)

Truly it is amazing what folks can survive, even surmount, simply because there was or is no other choice. As I said before, it does make you grateful for life, doesn't it?

Just a quick hijack: A couple, three months ago the History Channel did a documentary on Galen, the famous Roman physician. We watched, entranced; I'd never even heard of him. There WAS cataract surgery then; medical implements discovered from that time period (about 100 AD if memory serves) were nearly identical to implements used in modern times until the development of laser technology. Scalpels, whatever the implement that would remove cataracts, etc. were all found there, even unto a speculum. Pain control during surgery was well in place too. The end of the Empire brought the end of the knowledge acquired, unfortunately; but Galen's surviving papers read like nothing less than a modern medical text. I keep *saying* I'm going to order the DVD, it's such an interesting story, but... :P

I'd heard once that the Levitical laws were used as a basis in nursing education, as cleanliness in all things was very important to the Hebrews.

Who *says* those ancients didn't know very much? I will argue that much of what we know now is simply the recovery of lost arts! And yes, they lived long lives too. Thankfully, new discoveries are making it clear that our ancestors were by no means the primitive, short-lived brutes conventional wisdom likes to make of them. Even our pioneer forebears brought 'civilization' with them; we have ghost towns in our mountains that attest to high living, what with ruined mansions and all!


01265487515
Michael Medved, an anti-Capitalist who seeks to meddle in people's life... even after they are long gone. Get a life Michael... or die trying.

Life is more than an RBI

The MLB urns are just tawdry and superficial. A life, any life, even the most wretched life, is more than a pastime.

The art of the corpse is grotesque.
Not that the human form or coil in death is not appropriate for viewing, (such as at M.D. Anderson Medical School), but because in such an exhibition, a mere impersonation of life is concocted to reduce life to prurient spectacle. This is not representation, it is easy staging with litle creative input beyond preservation.

If an artist seeks to move the dead around and recreate life with some 'depouille mortuaire', then that artist is nothing more than a realist version of The Bates Motel.

As to whether it is Art, does it have significant form? ... The Aestheticians may now approach with all their baggage.

I'll wager however Duchamp is puzzled.


When You're Dead Your Dead!
I certainly agree that ones body should be treated with dignity but the traditional $10,000 [+] commercial funeral is the most odious form of "decadence". I've known widows who for decades paid monthly installments on their husbands elaborate funeral...and who thereby deprived their children of proper education, food and shelter. I've obtained a court order which directs that I be cremated immediately and that no funeral be performed. If my children wish at some later point to "honor" my life that's just fine...but spare me the meaningless and mournful hymns and prayers.

Jim-Too

Oh Michael..
Ok, Michael, I see your logic in bringing to light the shallowness of commemorating one's life with and clogging one's place of rest with sports memorabilia. Though I should you should not be surprised that advertising lines such as the one you cited are being used by those who market these funeral products. As a capitalist, you have to accept the byproducts of the system. There's no possible justification for regulation of an advertising slogan like this.

"The notion that any human being would view his own earthly remains so casually that he (or she) would welcome their deployment before gawking strangers as skinned sex toys in an avant garde art exhibit represents an appalling affront to human dignity."

However, if it is truthful that the donors to the body exhibitions and others were voluntary, then I'm sorry, in speaking for them and saying what's quoted above you're insulting their dignity and impugning on their free will. Who are you to say what their decision means for human dignity? The "Bodies: The Exhibition" exhibit is fascinating and very educational, actually. It seems quite obvious your objection to these displays is rooted in religion. This is silly. As an atheist, I believe this objection carries no weight. Even as a theist, however, can you really say God will care if we're devoting some of our dead remains to educational displays? Puh-leeease. You continue to disappoint me, Medved.

Thanks, Lily
It's a little off-subject, but thanks for sharing a little of your personal family history. Looking at old cemeteries helps us appreciate just how far we've come. As a pediatrician, it saddens me when people refuse to vaccinate their children from diseases that once killed children and young adults.

All medical students have the honor of dissecting a human cadaver. And as well as being a learning experience that could not really be achieved any other way, it truly is an honor. I had such appreciation for the person who gave this precious gift. When we were finished with the dissection, the medical students and our professors along with families and loved ones of those who donated their bodies met at a cemetery for a nondenominational burial service. I am forever in the debt of the man who donated his body for my education.

Will, you are simply nuts
Necrophiliac displays, grave robbing, corpse desecration, and dishonoring the dead have been abhorrent to civilized peoples for millennia.

Even the *primitive* Egyptians,long before the pyramids, buried their dead with ceremony on the left bank of the Nile with their goods and symbols.

But there should be nothing libs. do that surprises anyone.

Leave it to the left to find the last remaining corner of social interaction--treatment of the deceased--to be invaded and debased by lunatics hiding behind *art* as an excuse.

As to free will, the Const. of the US guarantees more freedoms than any other nation save Great Britain, and yet your King Elect O thinks he can fire private employees, take over private businesses, cheat private investors of their hard-earned money and desire to increase their lives' savings and pensions, and allow thousands of businesses to collapse (car dealerships, and all their attendant associates like bookkeepers, accountants, bank liaisons, bank officers themselves, car washers, et. al. without a blink of the eye.

The common man, my foot. You people do not care one whit for anyone except your own inexcusable behavior and illegalities.

Lilly, life was *solitary, poor
nasty, brutish, and short.* Thomas Hobbes, The Leviathan.

And for all our weeping and wailing about costs of medicine and health care in old age, when Soc. Sec. started, only 1 in 10 reached 65. That's just 70 years ago.

Prior to the vaccines for childhood disease, infants had c. 50% mortality rate before two years. Then tuberculosis killed young people to such numbers that for centuries our general mortality was 35-40.

My mother's father died at 36 and her mother died at 41, leaving a family of four orphaned, and they raised themselves.

My father's mother died in childbirth, and my father was given to two great aunts to raise, as men then weren't *sensitive* and baby-raising was for women.

But my mother's grandfather lived to 98 (1835-1933), served in the Civil War (four years) with famous the NJ Second Cavalry and died in his sleep. He died ten years before I was born, and now in my own old age, I wished I had had the opportunity to talk with him.

Their Bodies Their Rights
I normally am very impressed with how you present your arguments, Mr. Medved. But I'm disappointed with this. You've been preaching conservative values so eloquently for so long, yet here you are ridiculing people for making a choice on their own bodies. If you truly value the conservative notion of freedom, you understand that people have a right to their life, liberty, and property and part of that property and liberity involves what to do with their bodies.

And using sports memorabilia and donating their bodies to art is hardly the worst thing a culure has done. Cultures of the past, some of them Christian, had such rituals as letting dead bodies hang from trees, lining them up in catacombs, and severing the heads and keeping them in rooms as centerpieces. How is that better than mixing one's ashes with that of a sports team.

Now I've met Red Sox fans and I've met Eagles fans. Their devotion is hard to understand, but nobody has a right to tell them they can't express it after their death. It doesn't speak ill of a culture that allows people to die in a way they see fit. It speaks ill of a culture when people impose their values on others even after they have moved on.

Money grubbing disguised as art
I'm an ardant free market capitalist, but even I must admit it's disgusting how far some people will go to make a buck.

This issues described in this article are about nothing more than an attempt by scumbags to line their pockets with gelt. And once again, the worst part for me, is they hide behind a fig leaf of "culture" by calling themselves artistes. What unmitigated BS.

A good dose of ridicule and contempt will drive these lizards back under their rock. Won't happen though; the cultural elites will LOVE this stuff....they're afraid not to...they might be ridiculed themselves for appearing "square".

Odds Against Tomorrow
What do you want to bet that the Messiah will return before the Cubs go to the World Series?

Sorry, I forgot the Messiah is already in D.C.

I need help...
...can anyone tell me where I can get an urn in the shape of a Heineken beer can?

Thank you.

Jim...Oklahoma...
...You are making a mistake.Funerals are not for the dead,they are for the living.It is to help them get over their grief at that time.Let them decide how they will bury you.At that time,you won't give a dam.

How ironic
I refused to enter the exhibit that my friends went to when the Body Tour came to Los Angeles. It just seemed very disrespectful, despite its claims to be so scientific. In one apparent display, posing a dead human body on a dead horse cadaver was their way to convince us it was all about science and wonder!

It was just another way, in my opinion (4 years ago) of denigrating the human person by making it less sacred and treating it like a carnival attraction. How we treat and view the dead will affect how we view and treat the living over time.

Funeral customs
My wife and I want the least expensive funeral possible.
Many years ago, when I was visiting a monastery, I was told of their monks' custom. When a brother died, his body was laid on a bier, and was carried to the cemetary after the funeral. the body alone was laid in the grave and then covered. Would that that were possible in all cases now. It is true that the grave would have to be tended, and more earth added as the earth subsided, but even that would be less expensive than the custom of requiring an expensive casket and a vault. Also, the monastic custom acknowledges the reality of death--from dust you come, and to dust you shall return.
I have been to a burial in which family and friends filled the grave after the casket had been lowered into it. Now, it is almost impossible to have the funeral director even lower the casket into the grave until after family and friends have left, as though the reality of death is to be denied.

Wow, I thought...
... this was going to be an article about CSI or some of the other forensic shows that have gotten so graphic and gruesome over the years, not to mention the movies or video games. I think our society really has become desensitized about death to our detriment.

I do accept, however, the explanation about memorializing of a person's life in funeral services, however banal or secular they might be. I do hope, regardless, that mankind somehow becomes more spiritually minded and dwell on the future and our relationship with Deity and not strictly what was done and lived. As for me, whatever happens to my body when I pass over won't matter; it will be just a shell.

incomplete
this article is incomplete without illustrations. we should see what the author is complaining about.

What is sown in dishonor
shall be raised in glory. Hallelujah!

We were never meant to be covered over with earth, but thanks to the fallen condition, so it must be for every one of us.

I plan to donate whatever is usable, and cremate the rest. Ashes to be scattered over our mountain property, and a memorial service only, with Thy Strong Word as my hymn of choice. Funerals to me are smarmy at best, barbaric at worst. What is so doggone special about seeing your loved one's shell in a box, all made up as if s/he were sleeping? Who are we kidding? Eww!

Toad Island @ 12:46 pm
Toad Island, are you a voyeur? His description is sufficient for me.

Final Rest
My wife and I have already made the preparations to leave this life with the exception of a few minor details. We are in our 70's. We are Christians and do believe that sometime Christ will come in the clouds to receive Christians both dead and alive. (I hope we get to go up with the live ones) but in case we don't, our children will not be left with any expense.
The reason I want my body displayed (and if it doesn't happen naturally the morticican has my persmission to do so)I want everyone to see a smile on my face. You see I haven't slept a full night through in 10 years and I want evrybody to know that I am now going to get a good rest. God bless you all!

seeing is believing?
I'm fine without the visuals! Sounds like this artist is trying to immortalize himself and his art with shock and awe.His Body display could pass for educational, but this is going way too far!
I'm not following the author in his criticism of urn choices/coffins though. If my dad loved the Red Sox and I want to memorialize him with that logo, that's my choice. ($700 is a bit high though!) America is a free country so far.....

Road Accidents As Art
Respect for the human body is part of respect for human beings. In my police days, I was always disgusted at the neck craning and eagerness to see the dead in road accidents. The lowest type of human behavior was on display, and watching it from the accident side of the barrier made this all the clearer.
I'm not surprised that our society declares that obscene displays of human death are called 'art'. It's in accord with much of what passes for modern values.

Elizabeth
Your father is a Red Sox fan? O death, where is thy sting?

Pretty Funny, Medved
I don't agree with your political leanings, Mr. Medved, but I did get a chuckle out of this column, especially the line about the Chicago Cubs. Seriously, though, I know some diehard baseball fans who would love to have their ashes scattered at the favorite stadium. Actually, the human body is the equivalent of an old, used up garment after death. It should not be treated disrespectfully, but our souls have already departed. My late mother, who was a devout Christian, always said "bring me flowers when I'm still living, not after I'm dead." Meanwhile the commercial funeral industry continues to make a fortune off of grieving families. I'm opting for a cheap cremation (already have my cemetery spot paid for, so my kids won't have to) and absolutely no funeral. They can say a few words over me, but what's the point of making them spend a fortune on a party on me when I'm not there!

It's no body's business
The dead bodies as art thing is just creepy, no way would I ever go see it. BUT, as long as the people whose bodies are being used knowingly gave permission it's their right. If you don't like it, just don't go see it.

Ditto for ostentatious funerals. My daughter just got back from a friend's funeral. This young man died at age 17 from a fast spreading, untreatable cancer. He was a terrific Cubs fan. He asked to be able to plan his own funeral and his parents allowed this. He had a Cubs casket and vault, and was buried in a full Cubs uniform. Attendees were forbidden to wear black, he requested Chicago sports team jerseys (well, no White Sox of course). His pallbearers wore Cubs jerseys. As he was being taken from the chuch to the hearse the people sang "Take Me Out To The Ballgame" (seventh inning song) and as he was lowered into the ground "Go Cubs Go" (sung when Cubs win). His family was well able to afford this. Was this decadence or comfort?

Charles Martel
I heard that this guys "Bodies" show used Chinese (as in People's' Republic) corpses. I boycotted it because you have to wonder how "voluntary" the donation of corpses was in that country with its deplorable human rights conditions. Probably a bunch of murdered Tibetans.
_______________________________

"My friend's mother pointed out that he was born in 1945, and I responded that he wasn't actually born in 1945, but that 1945 was the earliest record they had of him.

She later postulated that the male cadavers were all circumcised, which suggested that they were, like she is, Jewish. I pointed out that most of the displays were missing much more than just their foreskins.

After Death Decadence, Corrections
The Body Worlds exhibition in Berlin that Michael Medved refers to is the fourth chapter of Dr. Gunther von Hagens' HUMAN SAGA project.The first chapter, The Three Pound Gem looked at the brain and neuroscience. The second, The Story of the Heart presents aspects of the heart and cardiology. The third, The Mirror of Time focuses on aging. The Berlin exhibition, BODY WORLDS & The Life Cycle focuses on the human life cycle, of which human reproduction is a key element. The display Mr. Medved refers to in the Berlin exhibit should be viewed in this context. The most comprehensive and latest information on BODY WORLDS and Dr. Gunther von Hagens can be found at http://www.bodyworlds.com. Mr. Medved is factually incorrect on two counts when he states: "Herr von Haugen previously inspired controversy with his display “Bodies: The Exhibition,” which toured the United States and featured skinned and preserved human remains." First in the spelling of Dr. von Hagens name, and secondly in associating "Bodies: The Exhibition" with Dr. von Hagens. That exhibition is by Atlanta based publicly traded company (PRXI), Premier Exhibitions.

Sign Up to Post Your CommentsSign Up to Post Your Comments
If you are already registered, click here to login. Otherwise, please take a few seconds to register with Townhall.com. Once you sign up, you’ll be able to post your comments immediately, use the action center, get podcasts, and more!
Note: Fields marked with a red asterisk (*) are required.
Salutation:
First Name:
*
Last Name:
*
Email:
*
Nickname:
*
Note: Nick name will be shown when you post comments.
Address 1:
*
Address 2:
City:
*
State:
*
Zip:
*
Phone:
      
Your daily must-read of conservative columns, cartoons and news. Coulter, Sowell, Krauthammer and more.
(Bi-Weekly) We highlight the best opportunities from our partners for surveys, action items and more.