Townhall.com, Where Your Opinion Counts
Talk Radio:   Bill Bennett   Mike Gallagher   Dennis Prager   Michael Medved   Hugh Hewitt   
BREAKING NEWS  LeftArrow - Townhall.com : Conservative, Political, Republican   RightArrow - Townhall.com : Conservative, Political, Republican  
Columns, funnies & more in your inbox!
  • Check the boxes and send us your email address to receveive your free newsletter
  • Your daily must-read of conservative columns, cartoons and news. Coulter, Sowell, Krauthammer and more.
  • Townhall.com’s weekly inside scoop on what’s happening behind the scenes in the world of politics. When news breaks, we report.
  • Signup to receive the latest daily Townhall cartoons
Wednesday, March 25, 2009
Michael Medved :: Townhall.com Columnist
Death & Context
by Michael Medved
Vote on It:
Average Vote:
[+] Text [-]
 
 
Poll
Will the Dems' health care Christmas Present to America be an improvement or detriment to our health care system?


In the days following my father’s death on March 11th, I’ve missed more consecutive days of live radio broadcasting than any other time since my show began nearly thirteen years ago. Since I don’t take extended vacations and even manage to broadcast frequently from the road (in Israel, Hawaii, New York, wherever) most of the time, missing five days in a row stands out as a break in tradition and deserves some explanation.

That explanation might also serve to answer the well-meaning questions I’ve received from listeners and friends who’ve generously sent their condolences over the loss of my father.

Since Jews are a tiny minority in the United States, and religious Jews constitute a minority within that minority, it’s worth trying to explain the fundamentals of the seven-day mourning process I’m just concluding.

First, it’s worth noting that Jewish tradition requires prompt burial as a matter of respect. In contrast to the Egyptian civilization that developed next door to ancient Israel, Jews don’t do anything to embalm or preserve or decorate the body. The idea of mummification and elaborate, carved sarcophagi – or the public display of a preserved body, as with Lenin in Red Square – would be anathema to Jews of yesterday or today. We believe that God’s will mandates the natural process of decay, after the soul has left the body. In the Book of Genesis, as part of the banishment of human beings from the Garden of Eden, God declares: ”In the sweat of thy face shalt thou eat bread, till thou return unto the ground; for out of it wast thou taken: for dust thou art, and unto dust shalt thou return.” (3:19).

This means that our laws demand that the departed be returned to the ground (from which he came) as quickly as possible, with delays only for extraordinary circumstances. I heard about my dad’s passing around midnight on last Tuesday night, then managed to get on the plane to Israel at 6.30 the next morning, arriving (with my brother Harry) just before sunset at the Jerusalem hilltop cemetery just as the memorial service began. My father lay before us in a plain, tightly wrapped white shroud, covered with the prayer shawl he had used in synagogue for several decades. There is no coffin – not even the unadorned pine box used by religious Jews elsewhere – in Jerusalem funerals. The ceremony emphasizes bringing the departed directly and quickly into contact with the holy soil of this special place where, in my father’s case, he chose to live the last 19 of his 83 years.

When we arrived at the funeral a large crowd (more than 200 people) had already assembled and begun listening to the beautiful words, in Hebrew, of one of my dad’s best friends, Dr. Jospeh Bodenheimer, President of the Jersualem College of Technology (one of the leading high tech training institutions in the world). After that, my brother Jonathan spoke, then my brother Harry, then me recalling the features of my father’s life and personality that made him so important to so many people he touched and inspired.

I actually cut my remarks short because we were racing the sun. In Jewish tradition, the day ends and a new day begins with sunset (based on the Genesis description, “It was evening, and it was morning, the first day”). Having already delayed the burial for a full day to allow the arrival of his sons from abroad, the Chevra Kadisha (“Holy Brotherhood,” supervising religious authorities on matters of death and bereavement) wanted to make sure we brought my dad to his place of rest before the sun went down.

Six friends lifted my father’s body onto a simple stretcher, and helped to carry him to a wooded hillside with sweeping views of the city. As the other mourners arrived they lowered him into a deep grave cut into the rocky soil, then covered him over with fitted marble slabs. Burials in Jerusalem have followed precisely the same procedures for literally thousands of years, and in the gathering dusk I stood with my brothers and recited the ancient memorial prayer (in Aramaic), the Kaddish (“Holiness”). Though often misidentified as a “prayer for the dead,” this formulation never mentions death, grief or afterlife. The real theme is proclaimed in the opening line: “Magnified and sanctified be His great Name in the world He created according to His will.”

In other words, rather than asking specific mercy on the departed, or comfort for the bereaved, we respond to death by acknowledging God’s power, majesty and control of every aspect of our lives. To honor the memory of a loved one, mourners recite this declaration in morning, afternoon and evening prayers every day for the eleven months following burial. The challenge is that a prayer quorum (minyan) of ten adult Jewish males is required to say the kaddish, which means that in honoring a loved one who has died you must depend on, or return to, a religious community. In that way, the eleven months as a mourner has served for many disaffiliated or indifferent individuals as a path back to commitment or continuity.

The first seven days after the funeral, this observance is no problem since the prayer quorum comes to you. The word “shiva” means, simply, seven, and denotes the first week after a burial when close relatives (children, spouses, parents of the deceased) gather together in a house of mourning without undertaking their normal jobs or activities. It’s considered a religious obligation to visit such a house, to bring words of comfort and specially prepared foods, and to join in the prayers three times a day. The close relatives sit on the floor or on low benches, and receive the visitors who stream through the home in a course of a busy, demanding but oddly uplifting week.

We “sat shiva” (observing the week of mourning) in my brother Jonathan’s house in Jerusalem, not far from where my father lived and the tree-shaded plot where he rests now. The stream of visitors has been amazing –including some of the most celebrated political, cultural and religious leaders in Israel, coming to pay their respects to my father’s memory. The first prayer service began at 7.30 each morning and the last visitors finally went home about 11.00 PM each night. The conversations often centered on little recollections (often humorous) about my dad and his many endearing quirks, but also ran far afield to cover politics (both American and Israeli), mutual friends, the chances of economic recovery, family history, or even favorite foods.

The restriction on ordinary work made it impossible for me to broadcast the show this week, though my brothers did join me in a telephone conversation with my guest host (my friend and colleague, Dave Boze) about my dad and the mourning process. In many instances, the week of mourning provides the first chance for siblings to live together under the same roof (and to share every meal together) since childhood. On occasion, the close quarters and the impact of loss can produce raw feelings – like a religious version of the awful reality show, “Big Brother.” For the Medved boys, the chance of sharing all this time together proved precious and life-affirming --- helping us rediscover how much we have in common and how much, despite the vast geographic distances between us, we all remain our father’s sons. For me, the most difficult restriction of the mourning week involves shaving. With no reduction in stubble since receiving news of my dad’s death, my face feels grubby and scratchy and disgusting, and I’m sure I look like a big-time terrorist suspect -- though I don’t know because mirrors are covered in a house of mourning (in order to de-emphasize vanity). I keep rubbing the bristly growth on my cheeks as if that could make it go away and yearning for the moment (tomorrow) when I can finally trim my facial fuzz. Because I speak in public as part of my work (with two major lectures in Michigan and Chicago on Wednesday and Thursday night), most authorities accept the idea that I can shave to preserve my vaguely respectable appearance. Other mourners will wait a whole month (the thirty days, or shloshim, which represents the next stage of the grieving process) before they resort to a razor. During this week of receiving visitors and comforters, I’ve spoken with literally hundreds of people – some of them close family members and friends, other who are neighbors of my brother’s who I’ve never met before, still others who count as old friends who I hadn’t seen in twenty years or more. Some of those who’ve cycled through this house have been deeply devout, others proudly secular, still others disengaged or undecided about their relationship to God or to religious tradition. On the phone, I spoke with a Christian friend who wondered whether all the restrictions and regulations of Jewish practice didn’t seem burdensome, even obnoxious, at a time of grief and hurt and vulnerability. I explained that on the contrary, the confusion and shock and uncertainty associated with death makes the rules and traditions particularly welcome. Informed of the passing of a loved one, the normal reaction for most people would be, “What do I do now? Where do I go from here?” The traditional mourning process answers those questions directly and decisively. You’re reminded above all that you hardly count as the first person (or even the first in your family) to endure a troubling loss. The seven days following the burial serve as a solid bridge back to normal life, with each step specifically and clearly demarcated. The fellowship and focus should, ideally, bring families closer together, emphasizing precisely those values of community and continuity that my father devoted much of his life to advancing. Of course, my father’s loss impoverishes all his sons and admirers, but on another level, when I get up from the week of remembrance and return to my own precious family in the United States, I will have been undoubtedly enriched by the mourning process, for all its challenges and inconvenience.

Share:
Vote on It:
Average Vote:
 
About The Author
Michael Medved's daily syndicated radio talk show reaches one of the largest national audiences every weekday between 3 and 6 PM, Eastern Time. Michael Medved is the author of eleven books, including the bestsellers What Really Happened to the Class of '65?, Hollywood vs. America, Right Turns and, most recently, The Ten Big Lies About America.
 
TOWNHALL DAILY: Be the first to read Michael Medved's column. Sign up today and receive Townhall.com daily lineup delivered each morning to your inbox.
Mr. Medved:
My condolences on the passing of your father. The loss of a parent is the most difficult thing a child can deal with. I will not say that the sense of loss gets easier with the passage of time. My Dad passed on two years ago on March 20, and even today I still miss him and mourn his passing.

Mr. Medved:
I don't know how you are able to write this piece. It brings back all the pain and loss I feel from my father's passing. I know I could not have written anything like this about my father, and it's been over 21 years since his death.

Thank you for writing this article, and bringing us closer to you.

God be with you and your family.

Mr. Medved
My condolences on your loss.

Your tribute to your father emphasizes those verities which bring us all closer together.

Passing of Father
Mr. Medved, my concolences to you at losing your Father.
I've only been an online subscriber to Townhall Magazine for a few months, but I thorougly enjoy your columns. I wish I could hear your radio program.
May God be with you and your family especially duringt this year of mourning.

Mr. Medved:
Thank you for this very fine tribute to the continuity tradition and family give to us at the time of death. I lost my beloved Daddy in October 2008 and like you and your brothers, my sisters and I found to our secret relief and to Mamas, that despite our varied lifestyles, locations and beliefs, we still stand together when the hard times come. My Daddy grew up in what they call these days a dysfunctional family, and his sole bedrock desire was to leave us with the one thing he could never have: happy memories of family and particularly of our father. We all agree that he has done this in wonderful fashion.

Your traditions also save you from the nanosecond culture of today that thinks when you leave home to come back to your daily work, you are *over it* and should now go back to worrying about that Bachelor who dumped his bimbette-du-jour for one of the others, or who is winning some basketball game or other. Your traditions give you what ours do not: time and structure.

May He bless you at this difficult time and send you peace.

Prayers with you and your family
Thank you for sharing these beautiful thoughts with your readers, Michael. I'm so sorry you've lost your father, and so glad that you have your faith to help pull you through. Having read and thoroughly enjoyed "Right Turns," I feel as if I know you're entire wonderful family. My prayers are with you all.

Margaret Evans
Beaufort, SC
http://www.lcweekly.com

My condolences
I do not believe in god or any supernatural force for that matter. But I still understand and empathize with the loss of a loved one. It is a difficult and conflicting time for anybody and I wish you and your family the very best.

Evangelical Christian funerals
typically make a point of praising the Lord for the life of the late departed. But remembering to keep that up non stop for even a year (or, as would be truly fitting, a life time) can be a challenge. A good Christian community will by no means turn and leave the bereaved out in the cold the moment the funeral is over. When the pastor of my church lost his wife at a young age to a horrible cancer some years ago, the people turned out to help him for months and months.

Condolences now too
lest I forget. My condolences to the Medved family for the passing of their father.

Mr. Medved
My Deepest Sympathy on your loss.

I've been there too:
http://georgetwin.blogtownhall.com/2008/01/08/he_made_me_wh at_i_am.thtml


Condolences
Mr. Medved may God bless and be with you and your family during this difficult time.

Learning about my own Jewish roots
My condolences, Mr. Medved. I have long enjoyed your radio show and Right Turns when it was first published. Thank you for providing much good insight into politics, spirituality and conservatism. And I wish you and your family a deep and meaningful period of mourning.

Raised culturally Jewish but now a Messianic Jew, I have learned much from you about my own Jewish roots and traditions. I was raised without any sense of God, even though was sent to Sunday school and went to grandma's for seders. But now as a Messianic Jew, I appreciate your orthodox Jewish worldview and beliefs much more than I would have 10 years ago. I actually feel we have more in common with each other than I do with my own family, in terms of theological interest level. But I thank you for sharing all you do about your faith and of the value of the God of the Bible.

marc

condolences
May God comfort you in this difficult time. Thank you for the explanation of the shiva days of mourning. It helps explain the verse in Proverbs where it says, "It is better to be in a house of mourning than in a house of feasting".
Susan

an admirer of medved
Good man, Michael Medved.

I said something rhetorically--in jest; some weeks back,

Asking, What have I got against Jews? OK;

Why do they always have to be the best pianists? If they can't play piano, why do they always turn out the best violinists??? Or song-writers? Richard Rodgers, Gershwin! Jewish. It ain't FAIR, I tell you! How terrific are Jews?

JESUS is a Jew; and Mary, the mother of Our Lord; Holy Jewish virgin; Blessed among women! Saint Peter (OK. A Galilean, but I love him.)

Then I love ordinary guys like Jackie Mason, a GREAT Jew. The best trainer of thoroughbreds at Santa Anita today? A Jew, Bobby Frankel. When we lose a fine man who is also a good Jew; Christians weep just as bitterly as Jews do.

We feel badly for you Michael. Cheer up, though-- we're all close behind your Dad. We shall meet again in heaven sooner than we realize; those who love God.


Shalom
Michael,

You and your writing are amongst the most healing in our present culture wars. The heart of cult-ure is cult, religion. That is really the only reason for being a conservative, to conserve the teaching of God through Abraham, Moses, David, the prophets and Jesus. Your column was tear-provoking on the human, subjective level, and educational on the objective level. May your wonderful father live on in you and your grandchildren, and may he rest in the bosom of Abraham.

Mr. Medved
If you're any indication, your father was a good man; and his loss, consequently, is our loss. Thank you for remembering your readers at this challenging time. My condolences to you and your family.

Mr. Melved
Thank you for sharing your story and enlightening me about these absolutely beautiful Jewish traditions. My deepest sympathy on the loss of your beloved father.

Thank you
Michael,

I have been an admirer since reading your autobiography. I especially liked your stories about your dad and your obvious and heartfelt respect and love for him. I have also always enjoyed your thoughts on Judaism. As a Christian, I view my religion as the fulfillment of your religion. I feel very close to Jews and very much enjoy participating in Jewish traditions with my Jewish friends as it brings me closer to Jesus in a very tangible way. Today's column is a wonderful testament to your dad's memory. Thank you again for your insight and wisdom. God Bless you, your family and your father.

Thank you, Mr. Medved.
Michael, what a gift your father has left for us. Your father passes leaving a legacy most of us can't imagine. Thank you Michael, for sharing and articulating, as only you can do. You and your family are in our prayers...

Thank you
As a practicing Catholic who loves the Jewish faith, thank you for sharing the details of your father's service, and how it exemplifies what you believe. It is a privilege to know it.

A few weeks ago, a dear friend who is Hindu lost her father. She lives here, and her family is still in India, and so she returned for his funeral. When she got back to the States, she told me all about the Hindu traditions, including the 13-day (I believe) mourning period, when the immediate family cannot really leave the house, and friends and other mourners come by the whole time with food, etc. It seemed long to me until another friend's father died (native-born American this time) three weeks ago. I watched the family go through the typical whirlwind 72 hours - getting everyone into town, planning the service and burial, picking the casket, writing the obituary and other notices, and then attending the service and interment. There is hardly time to cry.

And then suddenly - POOF! - it's over, and everyone is supposed to go back to their lives,

Your experience, Mr. Medved, like my Hindu friend's, confirms for me that we do not allow enough time for ritualized mourning here in the U.S.

My condolences for your loss.

Thank you
I was deeply touched by the generosity you have shown your audience in explaining the process of mourning in Judaism. As a member of your audience, you have helped me understand many things.

I am sorry for your loss.

May your father's memory be a blessing
and may we know no more sorrow.



Poignant description of Shiva...
Thank you Mr. Medved for sharing your thoughts and feelings during this sad time. I lost my father at 86 in 1999 and have since read many fine books on death and mourning (such as R. Lamm's and Wieseltier's) but I can't recall ever hearing or seeing in print your observation of how the mourning home is the first time since childhood/adolescence that siblings are again sharing meals and living under the same roof. This truism brought back emotions I had not felt in ten years... heartfelt condolences to you and your family. (a regular listener).

Sincere condolences
Michael,
My sincere condolences on the passing of your father. My views on politics, and life, and almost everything else, are very different from yours. But we share a common humanity. And I'm very sorry to hear of your father's passing.

My thoughts and best wishes and hopes are with you and your family at this time.

a very islamic funeral!!
wow! That was a perfectly Islamic burial. Take the word jew out of essay and replace with muslim and you are done. I knew many muslims growing up in Mumbai. There are lot more similarities between Jews and Muslims than between Jews and Christians.

Really Michael, you praise christians solely because of our support for israel. But given a choice between converting to Islam or christianity, you and every other Jew will chose Islam.

Maya,
New York
Sign Up to Post Your CommentsSign Up to Post Your Comments
If you are already registered, click here to login. Otherwise, please take a few seconds to register with Townhall.com. Once you sign up, you’ll be able to post your comments immediately, use the action center, get podcasts, and more!
Note: Fields marked with a red asterisk (*) are required.
Salutation:
First Name:
*
Last Name:
*
Email:
*
Nickname:
*
Note: Nick name will be shown when you post comments.
Address 1:
*
Address 2:
City:
*
State:
*
Zip:
*
Phone:
      
Your daily must-read of conservative columns, cartoons and news. Coulter, Sowell, Krauthammer and more.
(Bi-Weekly) We highlight the best opportunities from our partners for surveys, action items and more.