Townhall.com, Where Your Opinion Counts
Talk Radio:   Bill Bennett   Mike Gallagher   Dennis Prager   Michael Medved   Hugh Hewitt   
BREAKING NEWS  LeftArrow - Townhall.com : Conservative, Political, Republican   RightArrow - Townhall.com : Conservative, Political, Republican  
Columns, funnies & more in your inbox!
  • Check the boxes and send us your email address to receveive your free newsletter
  • Your daily must-read of conservative columns, cartoons and news. Coulter, Sowell, Krauthammer and more.
  • Townhall.com’s weekly inside scoop on what’s happening behind the scenes in the world of politics. When news breaks, we report.
  • Signup to receive the latest daily Townhall cartoons
Friday, March 20, 2009
Michael Gerson :: Townhall.com Columnist
Government Versus Confidence
by Michael Gerson
Vote on It:
Average Vote:
[+] Text [-]
 
Poll
Will the Dems' health care Christmas Present to America be an improvement or detriment to our health care system?


WASHINGTON -- The most famous piece of legislation passed by the 111th Congress may have nothing to do with health care or energy. It could be the Dodd amendment, also known as the Geithner amendment, or perhaps the low-level-anonymous-staffer-everyone-can-safely-blame amendment, reading in part:

"The prohibition required under clause (i) shall not be construed to prohibit any bonus payment required to be paid pursuant to a written employment contract executed on or before February 11, 2009 ... "

AIG executives were foolish to use this loophole to "retain" employees, some of whom nearly destroyed the American financial system. But the company did not act with deception or secrecy.

AIG's November SEC filing set out its intention to provide more than $469 million in "retention payments" to employees, eliciting a smattering of congressional protest. Concerns on the broader compensation issue were serious enough to ensure unanimous Senate passage of an amendment to the stimulus bill sponsored by Sens. Olympia Snowe and Ron Wyden that penalized bailout bonuses in excess of $100,000.

But the Snowe-Wyden amendment disappeared into the misty bog of a House-Senate conference committee, only to be trumped by language that grandfathered AIG's retention bonuses. At first, this seemed to be an example of immaculate legislation -- miraculously fatherless. After explicitly denying responsibility, Senate Banking Committee Chairman Christopher Dodd eventually admitted including the exception under pressure from the administration. But it doesn't sound like there was much of a fight. Administration input came from unnamed staffers at the Treasury Department, not high-level officials. Dodd said he viewed these as "innocent modifications."

The lack of focus, judgment and competence on the part of Congress and the administration has explanations -- for those dealing in trillions, millions must seem like dirty pennies on the street. But the hollow outrage and blame-shifting from Congress and the administration are inexcusable.

President Obama vowed to "pursue every legal avenue to block these bonuses," when the proper "legal" avenue was to write a responsible law -- a process his own administration apparently undermined. "I'll take responsibility," says the president -- before, in the next few breaths, explaining, "We didn't grant these contracts." And, "We've got a lot on our plate." And, "It's my job to make sure that we fix these messes, even if I don't make them." So Obama seems to be saying: I'll take credit for taking the blame for something that is entirely the fault of others. Positively Clintonian.

"This is an example," thunders Rep. Barney Frank, "of people at the commanding heights of the economy misbehaving, abusing the system" -- which is completely true ... of the conference committee that reshaped the stimulus bill in secret. Sen. Charles Grassley urged AIG executives to contemplate suicide.

This combination of viciousness, shamelessness and cluelessness has consequences. It drains what little political will remains to confront the credit crisis -- an effort that may eventually require spending a trillion dollars or more to help purchase toxic debt. Thanks to AIG, Congress and the administration, Treasury Secretary Timothy Geithner may find his next round of necessary bailouts greeted by a revolt of left and right.

And congressional demagoguery is compromising Geithner's own approach to resolving the credit crisis. Since the direct government purchase of toxic debt would be massively expensive, Geithner has floated the idea of enticing private investors to help buy that debt. The government would give loans or subsidies to mutual funds and hedge funds if they will buy toxic securities. But few would make such a risky investment without the hope of large returns.

If those returns are realized, it is easy to imagine how hedge fund managers would be treated when hauled before Congress. "Perhaps the witness can explain to us how he justifies such windfall profits with the people's money? Have you no shame? Give us the names, addresses and phone numbers of every millionaire you enriched at public expense so we can leak them to the press."

What sane money manager would want to partner with a government that blames others for its mistakes, urges the violation of inconvenient contracts and threatens to tax benefits retroactively? One Wall Street expert told me, "Even if people trust the president, they don't trust Congress." This kind of trust and confidence is essential to the next stage of our economic recovery. It is also being actively undermined by the incompetence and hypocrisy of the government itself.

Share:
Vote on It:
Average Vote:
 
About The Author
Michael Gerson writes a twice-weekly column for The Post on issues that include politics, global health, development, religion and foreign policy. Michael Gerson is the author of the book "Heroic Conservatism" and a contributor to Newsweek magazine.
 
TOWNHALL DAILY: Be the first to read Michael Gerson's column. Sign up today and receive Townhall.com daily lineup delivered each morning to your inbox.
Phone Calls
As the Senate voted Aye/nay on the bill I was attempting to call all the Democrats on the floor. Started too late. I asked the ones I got through to to vote Nay if they had not finished reading the bill.

My son walked up to me and asked me how I could embarrass myself by asking stupid questions?

It was clear to me the majority couldn't have read/re-read that document. One either scanned it or trusted someone else read the details.

Post-enrollment I pulled it off Thomas' immediately, deleted the trash, and read the horror novel.

Who are these guys in Congress? They're robbing us blind. OR they're indifferent. OR they're cowards, clueless, OR good men and women BUT outnumbered.

We have to dump them all then put the good guys back. HOW?



Obama’s Culpability
I don’t understand why BO is not taking more heat for the AIG bonuses. The provision allowing for them was in the $787BILLION “stimulus” bill wasn’t it? He signed that bill into law in Denver Co. So either he knew the bonus clause was in the bill and signed it or he signed the bill without knowing what was in it (i.e. reading it). Either way he screwed up!
Or maybe actually knowing what is in a bill he signs (i.e. actually reading it) is below his "Pay Grade".

Eric Blair
And the DVDs weren't even the kind that could be played in Great Britain! Could this administration be any more amateurish? I doubt it.

To Windy City Gardener
Ironically, the sky the Dems are crying about is falling largely because of their own mess-ups. And the solutions they propose to fix it are the same things that are making it totter in the first place.


Dumb Americans
This is happening all over the country. Democrats are screaming the sky is falling and we need to act today.
It's happening in Illinois. Everything Blagojevich did in the last six years has devastated the Illinois economy. I think not. He was not the only one there.
One month ago Illinois was 1.5 billion in debt. Now the democrats are telling us it's 11.5 billion and they have to raise taxes and fees immediately. The state is in critical condition. No one even questions how we got from 1.5 to 13.5. Lies, lies and more lies. Well ok just raise my taxes. Meanwhile I'm paying for social services for every illegal in this state. Of course they can't cut those programs.
It is unbelievable how gullible the voters are.

Publius4254
I recently seen better leadership from a Den of Cub Scouts than what this administration is showing to the world! DVD's to a head of state, a mislabeled button to another one! Forrest Gump could teach Hussein and crew a few lessons!

More targeted tax rates a'comming
A targeted tax, specifiic to a type of wage earner...interesting. Perhaps now that congress (both Rs and Ds) have figured out they can legilsative targeted tax levels, they will not levy 99.9 tax rates say on Radio Talk Show Hosts who lean right, or a 90% rate on professors who teach original intent, or 80% on bank tellers just because they take people's money and put it in personal savings accounts.

Disgusting
I propose that every Congressman who voted for the porkulus package without reading (that would be all) be taxed at 90% of THEIR incomes first.

By the way, when Geithner went before Congress at the first of the month, he was asked about the pending bonuses for AIG. In other words, the Congressmen on that committee as well as every reporter and anyone else who watched or covered that hearing KNEW that those bonuses were in the works then and did NOTHING. Now they howl with righteous indignation and demand punitive taxation for unprofitable and profitable firms alike.

Hope and change indeed.

Every person that signed that bill...
...without reading it should be impeached; including the self-made deity at the top. We did not need any 'bailouts' to begin with. The bankers that made the assets they owned toxic could have fixed them the old fashioned way; the hard way, one at a time. We already HAVE laws on the books to progress through bankruptcy courts and have firms emerge viable. This AIG bogus bonus outrage is a smoke screen for other socialist madness that is far more important. We will be finding more crap in this contrived crisis legislation for decades!

Tim the Tool Man
What's next now that the Benford 5000 TARP has blown up in Tim's face?

Eric Blair
"Because of all the freaks, cheats, liars, and known reprobates that make up the legislative branch of our form of government."

Can't say I disagree with your analysis. You could say the same about the current administration, as well.

Gerson is wrong ..
I think the most significant piece of legislation will be the result of the House passage of HR 1586, should a variant get through Congress. In case you're not paying attention, this is the bill that zipped through the House yesterday that proposes to tax a particular group of people at 90%, because they were paid a bonus for services rendered at some time in the past.

This is a painfully obvious and egregious violation of Article I, Section 9, Clause 3 of the U.S. Constitution: "No Bill of Attainder or ex post facto Law shall be passed." HR 1586 is on its face defective on both counts.

One of the reasons our ancestors fought for independence from England was that individuals could be singled out for abuse by the Crown without benefit of formal charges, trial, or legal protections. This is the stuff of Stalinist dictatorships, and has no place in a constitutional republic.

The fact that a large majority of the House voted for this monstrosity should make it clear that Government is not your friend, nor is it to be trusted. Bluntly, I vote "No Confidence."

v/r,

--- Bud

Gerson shows his neo side
"It drains what little political will remains to confront the credit crisis -- an effort that may eventually require spending a trillion dollars or more to help purchase toxic debt. Thanks to AIG, Congress and the administration, Treasury Secretary Timothy Geithner may find his next round of necessary bailouts greeted by a revolt"
There are no necessary bailouts. We don't need to spend another trillion. We shouldn't have spent the nine trillion we have already spent. Statements like this from a "conservative" are breathtaking. We need to let the market do it's job, live through the consequences, and get the Gov't out of the market.
When I realize that I've gained weight and want to lose it, I don't eat 500 Big Macs. I jump on the treadmill, pick up the weights, and cut back my calorie intake. It is uncomfortable and at times even painful. This is what I have to do to become lean and strong again, however.
This is as it is with our economy. It has gotten seriously bloated and mismanagement has created many "fat" companies that need to be slimmed or cut out. The more we prop up these monoliths, the longer we prolong the pain.

Circus Congress
Because of all the freaks, cheats, liars, and known reprobates that make up the legislative branch of our form of government.

What a dog and pony show!
To call this Congress a circus is being insulting to circuses. This is incompetence and imbecility on grand display. Liberals on other threads in the past have been thankful that the "adults are now in charge". If this is what happens when "adults" are in charge then we are in bigger trouble than we thought.


Frolic away, Obama team ....
The unseriousness of our government is breathtaking.

They ....

*Pass a 1000 page "emergency" bill they haven't read.

*The Prez frolics with Jay Leno while the country goes down the tubes.

*The Sect. of the Treasury has no assistant Secretaries to help him, and there is no concerted effort to get a team in place (I can only conclude that Geithner is being set up as a fall guy).

*Senators say things about AIG executives that would get a high school kid arrested and suspended.

Liddy
was the subject of a kangaroo court in Congress. He came out of retirement and took over at AIG as a matter of public service, working for $1 per year. He was insulted and maligned during his testimony. I think he should have said, "You guys are grandstanding to cover your butts. I didn't sign up for this abuse. Here's your $1 back - scr** yourselves. I quit. You figure out what to do with AIG." Wouldn't that have been fun?

CARD CHECK
Yes, the card check is a potential disaster. We can all be living in Detroitl

Rastas
I agree completely. If Congress was so obsessed with not paying bonuses, then they should have left the language in the bill. Obviously, they were not until the public started crying out. Now this farce of pretend concern is so disgusting, pandering at it's worse. I hope the CT voters use this as an opportunity to seat a new Senator as Dodd obviously does not have what it takes to see farther than his nose. On another note, I am also totally disgusted with this talk about 'returning' the taxpayers money from the bonus recipients. It will be a cold day in He!! before the taxpayers ever see that money even if Congress gets it back. And on a third note, this talk and action in sponsoring a new bill to target these folks who actually did nothing legally wrong here should send a cold shiver down everyones spine. If Congress thinks it should do this, there are no boundaries to what they feel they can do and who knows what their next target might be. We need some serious changes come 2010.

Regards

Not the most important
The most impactful legislation in this Congress is the Card Check bill that has the required 60 Senate votes for passage once Frankenfish is seated. Every Democrat must vote for it as a matter of party discipline, and Specter will also vote for it as he is from a Union state. This bill, and not some temporary, fake, outrage over AIG will have the longest lasting impact.

The fact is that the banking system as we knew it is dead and will not recover. What replaces the old banking system is still undetermined.

Gerson



If the bonuses were contractual, then they must either be renegotiated, or paid.

We were a Nation based on law, not fiat nor decree from LeRoi.


Sign Up to Post Your CommentsSign Up to Post Your Comments
If you are already registered, click here to login. Otherwise, please take a few seconds to register with Townhall.com. Once you sign up, you’ll be able to post your comments immediately, use the action center, get podcasts, and more!
Note: Fields marked with a red asterisk (*) are required.
Salutation:
First Name:
*
Last Name:
*
Email:
*
Nickname:
*
Note: Nick name will be shown when you post comments.
Address 1:
*
Address 2:
City:
*
State:
*
Zip:
*
Phone:
      
Your daily must-read of conservative columns, cartoons and news. Coulter, Sowell, Krauthammer and more.
(Bi-Weekly) We highlight the best opportunities from our partners for surveys, action items and more.