Townhall.com, Where Your Opinion Counts
Talk Radio:   Bill Bennett   Mike Gallagher   Dennis Prager   Michael Medved   Hugh Hewitt   
BREAKING NEWS  LeftArrow - Townhall.com : Conservative, Political, Republican   RightArrow - Townhall.com : Conservative, Political, Republican  
Columns, funnies & more in your inbox!
  • Check the boxes and send us your email address to receveive your free newsletter
  • Your daily must-read of conservative columns, cartoons and news. Coulter, Sowell, Krauthammer and more.
  • Townhall.com’s weekly inside scoop on what’s happening behind the scenes in the world of politics. When news breaks, we report.
  • Signup to receive the latest daily Townhall cartoons
Thursday, July 02, 2009
Matt Towery :: Townhall.com Columnist
We Love New York -- Just Less Than We Used To
by Matt Towery
Vote on It:
Average Vote:
[+] Text [-]
 
Poll
Was the Copenhagen Global Warming Summit Walk-Out a Win for the U.S.?


Who are the richest people in town? Here's a hint: Every dime they have is disposable income.

The answer is tourists. And they increasingly are the victims of the soak-the-rich mentality that has resurfaced with a vengeance in a time in which politicians are looking for ways to accomplish the paradoxical tasks of raising revenues, expanding government services and keeping voters from taking to the streets in rage. Taxing tourists looks like the fabled silver bullet to elected officials.

The latest episode is in New York City, where Mayor Michael Bloomberg has just signed into law a new measure that deals with booking hotel rooms over the Internet. It seems some online travel services have been buying hotel rentals wholesale, and then charging tourists the bed tax at the retail rate, with the bookers pocketing the difference. City officials see the new law as a way to put an end to the practice.

It's unclear what the effect of the new law will be. Some booking agents will now be paying more taxes, but will they keep their booking rates the same or raise prices on travelers to cover their "losses?"

Regardless, the city's new policy brings into daylight a practice that New York and heaven knows how many other cites have copied from despotic governments from way back -- taxing people who have no electoral voice to fight back. Taxation without representation, I believe it's called.

Although there is a dearth of survey data on the effects of bed tax hikes on tourism, New York City officials say the new law will bring in a bunch of new revenue.

They're probably right, at least in the short term. So how, you might ask, does this square with the notion that economic growth runs in inverse proportion to tax rates? Put another way, why wouldn't more and more tourists stay home if bed taxes keep rising?

The reasons this cornerstone belief of conservative fiscal policy may not be entirely true is twofold. First, as I've already mentioned, it's hard for taxpayers to protest a tax when it's imposed on them by government officials they don't elect.

But the second reason may be the key -- awareness, or lack of it. Mosey on down to your city hall or state capitol, and try to collar a lobbyist who represents tourists and business travelers. You're unlikely to find one. There's spot evidence here and there that this may slowly be changing. The first activist front is likely to be car rental taxes, but bed taxes may not be far behind.

And yet no amount of lobbyist arm-twisting is likely to scare politicians who are far more afraid of the twin-headed monster of dwindling government revenues and tea-partying voters than they are of resentful tourists in the car next to them.

The strike-back against confiscatory cities like New York is likely going to have to come the old-fashioned way -- by John and Jane Q. citizens refusing to open their wallets by staying home in the first place. Most travelers may not look at their hotel bill with the microscope (and the thesaurus) needed to see just how much tax they are paying. What they will notice more and more as the economy slowly slogs on, however, is the rising total bill they're footing to put them in the same city as the Statue of Liberty and Carnegie Hall.

Let's face it: People vote with their wallets, too. What an irony if the travelers' revenge came in the form of a lack of additional money for a major city to pay for that spanking new baseball stadium or that sprawling new convention center. Cities in effect are trying to build new tourist attractions by sticking it to tourists. Justice might be if the tourists stuck it to cities by taking next year's vacation at home, or if businessmen and women held that meeting by teleconference instead of in person.

The numbers are few on whether that's happening yet in significant numbers. But the U.S. recession shows few signs of relenting anytime soon. And the longer Americans have to go without, the more skilled they're likely to get at cutting corners. Common sense -- and economic law -- says that sooner or later, more and more of them are going to pinch pennies by sleeping in their own beds at night. Sooner or later, the silver bullet of bed and other tourist taxes may boomerang and hit tax-and-spend politicians right between the eyes.

Share:
Vote on It:
Average Vote:
 
About The Author
Matt Towery is a former National Republican legislator of the year and author of Powerchicks: How Women Will Dominate America.
 
TOWNHALL DAILY: Be the first to read Matt Towery's column. Sign up today and receive Townhall.com daily lineup delivered each morning to your inbox.
 
©Creators Syndicate
New York
New York has made all of its money off forcing the world to do all its financing through it. The New York way: all money and transactions have to go through us and we will take 10% (or more) of it. Any merger, any company going public, mutual fund activity, bond trading, angel funding, insurance, etc.

Since the advent of the internet New York was doomed. Now nobody needs New York. There isn't a need to find a middle man with the internet. Need Angel funding. Don't go to New York, google it. Everyone sees how the internet has globalized, but few see how it has localized financing.

But I digress. There's nothing that is going to save this city because it doesn't do anything else, but skim money for little or no service. The bailout (all the trillions) tried to save it, but it won't. Cap and trade will try to save it, but it won't, Obama trying to attempt to control the financial market through megabanks and kill small banks might save it, but it won't.

This is a city that has no future unless it changes its function (its service), but it won't. It can't. So we will continue to see a decline. Hopefully, America won't follow it.

Is there any major industry in New York that isn't an unnecessary or overpriced middleman?

No more opera?
We have , for decades, had series tickets to the Metropolitan Opera. A few years ago we decided to no longer drive home for two hours but rather to stay overnight in a hotel. Last winter we reverted to driving home again. The hotel prices had gotten out of hand relative, at least, to our "fixed income" situation. This also caused some long thought before I finally decided to get tickets for next season.

There will, sometime soon, come a season and all thereafter when we are no longer subscribers. We've seen all the operas they perform regularly several times, so maybe we'll just buy the DVDs and schedule our own series on our beautiful big HDTV. NYC will be missing out on several thousand dollars a year.

My California trip
Huey Long once said "Don't tax me, Don't tax thee, Tax the fella behind the tree.

If your a tourist or a out of state business man traveling to any of the Blue states, rest assured you are the fellow behind the tree.

My recent weeklong business trip to California netted the Golden State over $200 dollars in revenue from Hotel & rental car surcharges alone, over 20% of the total bill!

Mission accomplished Sacramento. I will however, choose not to travel to your state again in the future. I don't believe in rewarding bad behavior with my small children or leftist politicians

NYC Already Drains State
Upstate NY wishes NJ would take over NYC. It is a huge anchor weighing down the rest of the state.

CNY
If you go to my native Syracuse and westward,you'd see what Albany's pandering to NYC has done. Oh, I shouldn't forget that coupled w/12 years of Mario Cuomo.

Then there are the residents

St. Mark’s Square, Venice, Italy

We were enjoying a Coke, the music, and the view. Suddenly a well dressed man flopped in a chair, and let out a long sigh.

He relaxed a moment, said he is a college professor from Ireland, who acts as a tour guide for groups of traveling Americans.

“I told them I would never again lead a New York City group, they bribed me with extra money, so here I am — but never again.”

“It is impossible to lead people from New York City, they are selfish, care only about themselves, pay no attention to the needs of the tour group.”



Lugano, Switzerland

We heard some noise and saw a tour leader angrily waving his colored umbrella.

He was hollering, in English, for people to get
in the tour bus, right now.

We asked what the problem was, he said never again would he lead a group from New York City.

They are impossible, and would not cooperate, as members of a tour group must.

SS Odysseus, Athens, Greece to Black Sea

This ship had recently been sailing in the Caribbean.

The tour director said those passengers were Americans, so much friendlier, and so much easier to get along with, than the Europeans.

Passengers on the cruise tended to congregate with others from their own country.

It’s obvious the English are different from the Germans, who are different from the French, who are different from the Italians, who are different from the Greeks, who are different from — Viva La Difference!


Yugoslavia

She had recently been to New York City and attended a meeting at Hunter College, and everyone there hated Reagan. Jim told her, “Going to a college in New York City to learn about the political health of the US, is like going to a Doctor for a physical exam, and he only looks at your armpits!” I was being polite at the time!

(Also printed as a Letter in the Los Angeles Times.)

During our 1,000 days in Europe, we heard no other complaint about members of tour groups from the USA.


What do you expect...
New York City like New Jersey and thousands of other jurisdictions are each saddled with literally hundreds of thousands of over pampered, overpaid, over perked, over pensioned cops, teachers and other forms of public parasites sucking the life blood from the public. Every year the corrupt, cowardly politicians cave to the Communist thug infested public “workers” unions and pile on the outrageous raises and other goodies. $crew you Mr. Taxpayers, we deserve, and are entitled, to rip you off.

Love New York
I could love New York no less than i do now.

The Other Side of the Story
Here is what it's like to live in a tourist mecca. During tourist season, you are rushing down a city sidewalk trying to get to a doctor's appointment on time but you are stuck behind a group of eight big-butt women from Ohio who splay themselves across the sidewalk as they goggle upwards surveying the tops of tall buildings. The sidewalks are impassable.

Do you want to go out to lunch? Not downtown you won't, because everything is full of tourists and there's an hour's wait for a table. Plan to do a little shopping? Long lines to at every checkout. Get on a bus to go home? Forget sitting down, because a school group of 35 visiting teenagers got there before you.

Are you driving? I lived many years in the Washington DC area, where no living tourist has ever figured out how to get around the many traffic circles. Confusion reigned.

Those of you who despise cities: feel free not to visit us. Somehow we will survive without you. The streets and crowds and traffic and noise that you hate are OUR streets and crowds and traffic and noise. Our property taxes support this place. This is our home, and we love it. We choose to be here. If you can't be nice, please don't come.

Welcome to New York
NOW GO HOME.
You do not have to come to New York. You can always go for vacation to Cleveland. Or Spokane. A nice city, Spokane.Of course, there is no Satue of Liberty in Cleveland. No Empire State Building In Spokane. How about the Metropolitan Museum? Nope, sorry. Only in New York.
How about the forty theaters on Broadway? And the 200 off Broadway? You can always wait for a tour company. Fifth Avenue fashion? Madison avenue sophistication? Going to lunch, and Chevy Chase is on the next table. Or seeing each one of the four stars from Sex in the city walking in the street ahead of you, all within ten days? (it happened to me). I guess it wouldn't interest you.
As a young waiter on Times square, I once had Gene Hackman, Duke Ellington, Jack Lemmon and Woody Allen sit on one of my tables, within the same month. Duke Ellington was the best tipper.

You don't really have to come visit the center of the world. On any given day, we have about 500,000 tourists in Manhattan (you can look it up). More during Christmas, when the tree is up in Rockefeller Center. We won't miss you.

Alice are you kidding?
Since you appear to be a missnamed waiter, I will call attention to the fact that the main reason waiters exist is to provide service to the public. And yet you deride the tourists who provide so much in revenue not only to your profession but to the city you claim to love?
I suggest you are in the wrong profession.

Alice and Lilly
Girls, that city you claim to love is going straight into the crapper. Push the tourism dollars out the door along with the banking dollars Obama is making sure never get to NYC.

Jack up taxes for "the rich," and watch how many of them discover the delights of Raleigh-Durham, or Charleston, or Savannah, or Atlanta or heaven forbid, Houston.

Living in Houston, for a rich family, is worth millions per year versus living in NYC. Do you really think your city is that great?

Hogwash.

You wouldn't pay millions per year to live in New York, yet you expect your richies to do it.

Keep jacking up the taxes. Quality of life is going down there now, and it's going to get worse, worse, worse, until those with the money to buy any lifestyle will just opt out.

Where will you be without their taxes? Your whole system is built on massive government spending, financed by raping the rich and the tourists.

By all means, drive both groups out of your state.

What do I think of the result?

Couldn't happen to a nicer bunch of people!
Sign Up to Post Your CommentsSign Up to Post Your Comments
If you are already registered, click here to login. Otherwise, please take a few seconds to register with Townhall.com. Once you sign up, you’ll be able to post your comments immediately, use the action center, get podcasts, and more!
Note: Fields marked with a red asterisk (*) are required.
Salutation:
First Name:
*
Last Name:
*
Email:
*
Nickname:
*
Note: Nick name will be shown when you post comments.
Address 1:
*
Address 2:
City:
*
State:
*
Zip:
*
Phone:
      
Your daily must-read of conservative columns, cartoons and news. Coulter, Sowell, Krauthammer and more.
(Bi-Weekly) We highlight the best opportunities from our partners for surveys, action items and more.