Townhall.com, Where Your Opinion Counts
Talk Radio:   Bill Bennett   Mike Gallagher   Dennis Prager   Michael Medved   Hugh Hewitt   
BREAKING NEWS  LeftArrow - Townhall.com : Conservative, Political, Republican   RightArrow - Townhall.com : Conservative, Political, Republican  
Columns, funnies & more in your inbox!
  • Check the boxes and send us your email address to receveive your free newsletter
  • Your daily must-read of conservative columns, cartoons and news. Coulter, Sowell, Krauthammer and more.
  • Townhall.com’s weekly inside scoop on what’s happening behind the scenes in the world of politics. When news breaks, we report.
  • Signup to receive the latest daily Townhall cartoons
Thursday, October 02, 2008
Matt Towery :: Townhall.com Columnist
Everything You Might Not Know About The "Bailout" But Were Afraid To Ask
by Matt Towery
Vote on It:
Average Vote:
[+] Text [-]
 
Poll
Was the Copenhagen Global Warming Summit Walk-Out a Win for the U.S.?


Everybody seems to have a boatload of questions about the past week's dizzying series of events surrounding the proposed "bailout" of American financial institutions. To cut through the muddle, let's check off on a short list of vital questions I asked myself, and the answers I discovered, about the Big Mess.

Question: Was there really a "crisis?"

Who knows? There's evidence that even some large corporations have shifted gears down to a "slow pay" method of paying vendors. And some have tried to get new funds, only to find that the private borrowing cupboard is bare.

All this is starting to "trickle down" to small businesses that use modest lines of credit to meet operating expenses; or that make daily do on a cash-in, cash-out basis.

Whether or not large companies pay their bills on time, the phone and electric companies -- not to mention the landlord and the government -- still expect what's coming to them, and on time. So in a sense, a crisis has been developing on Main Street.

What no one is sure of is whether a temporary uptick or a looming near-collapse of the nation's money supply is on the way.

Opinion is divided. President Bush and Treasury Secretary Henry Paulson told members of Congress that money markets had all but ground to a stop. That tenuous new ground looked near enough to Main Street that Bush felt an impulse to edge over to the panic button.

But when the House of Representatives rejected the so-called partisan bailout plan, the stock markets, after first plunging, then started behaving as if the failure to pass the rescue bill did nothing to seriously undermine confidence in our monetary system.

Question: What started the defection of Republican members in the House for the initial bailout bill?

I can hardly believe I'm saying it, but for second time in this presidential general election campaign, former House Speaker Newt Gingrich has essentially framed an entire policy debate.

First, he used his platform on Fox News to force the issue of domestic drilling for oil and natural gas, by pushing his "capital drill, capital here, capital drill, capital now" effort that he initiated last spring. All the time, John McCain was mum on the issue. Now it's at the top of the GOP's talking points list.

Next, Gingrich became one of the first and loudest critics of the proposed first financial rescue plan. He declared early on that if McCain voted for the bill as initially proposed, Obama would win the election. Gingrich communicated his sentiments to the House Republican leadership, many of whom are his closest allies from the days when he was their leader. He made it clear that he saw huge problems with the bill.

Knowing Gingrich as I do, I read his footprints from the start in the shifting mood of his former colleagues. Republican House Leader John Boehner of Ohio's internal statement to his colleagues said that while he would vote for the bill, it was nevertheless a "crap sandwich." That was hallmark Gingrich -- give permission for the rank and file to vote their consciences, instead of in lockstep with their own leadership.

So was Gingrich right? When at first it looked like the monetary system would seize up in a matter of days, I thought we were back to the Newt of the old "government shutdown" days. But in fairness, he did point out many flaws in the bill.

One day we may know if he was spot on with his position -- that being the day we might all be standing in a soup line, talking about Great Depression II.

Question: Was Secretary of the Treasury Paulson too arrogant in his approach to the legislation?

Bluntly put, yes.

Question: Did most members of Congress understand the nature of the alleged crisis?

Bluntly put, no. Most of them have either never run a business, or haven't in way too long, so that their understanding of economics is sophomoric. Even a less high-handed messenger than Henry Paulson would have had trouble penetrating these hard noggins.

Question: Why did House Speaker Nancy Pelosi start attacking President Bush in her speech on the floor of the House prior to the vote?

Possibly to kill it. Pelosi had already told some powerful Democrats who wanted to vote for bill that that might be OK because enough Republicans were defecting from "yes" votes that the legislation wasn't going to survive.

Question: Should John McCain have become so involved in the legislation and so closely identified with advocating its passage?

For a man who seems to do what he believes is right, the answer is yes. But as a candidate for president, absolutely not. We have since polled the presidential race in many states, and McCain has lost ground. That near-inevitability likely was not lost on Speaker Pelosi when she made her pre-vote speech blasting President Bush.

Share:
Vote on It:
Average Vote:
 
About The Author
Matt Towery is a former National Republican legislator of the year and author of Powerchicks: How Women Will Dominate America.
 
TOWNHALL DAILY: Be the first to read Matt Towery's column. Sign up today and receive Townhall.com daily lineup delivered each morning to your inbox.
 
©Creators Syndicate
Now for my question
Why is this damn thing so loaded up with pork that it went from being a 3-page bill to one of nearly 500 pages?


Crisis my eye. Thank God my Republican senator Allard voted against it.

Go Newt!
I like to see that Gingrich is spreading the word. Facts are facts and he is blunt and to the point about stating them. It is amazing to me that in the midst of this "crisis" there was still an attempt to attach "extras" like the contributions to ACORN to the bailout!

Excellent Summary
I'm still asking my congressman to vote "NO".

Just talked with my local bank VP. No problems. Still loaning money. No sub-prime mortgages on the books.

Could we go into recession? You bet. Could this get Obama elected? You bet. Maybe both of these and the debacle that will follow could possibly wake up some folks.

I'm still voting the straight "R" ticket. After all, what's the alternative? When the Ds are lead by folks like Pelosi, Reed, Shummer, Dodd, B. Clinton, etc. how can one not vote "R"?

Maggot and Rat infestation
No coat of paint is going to fix this rat and termite and maggot infested house of cards. BURN IT NOW, BURN IT TO THE GROUND.

The REAL culprits
The real culprits in this, the proximate cause of this, is the Federal Reserve and its loose money policies and artificially low interest rates over the last twelve years. This policy gave businessmen the false idea that we as a nation were prospering when in fact, we weren't. Many inadvisable and outright bad investment choices were made. It was a typical bubble market. And it was the second one in Greenspan's tenure (the first being the "tech bubble"). Now, the bubble is deflating, and the markets are correcting themselves to where they should be. But Hank and Benny and their ignorant worshippers on Capitol Hill want to inject MORE credit into the markets to keep the bubble inflated. It won't work. This is more of the same toxin that poisoned the market in the first place! At best, the correction will be put off a few years by this "bailout", but the correction will come, and by putting it off and adding even more debt, Congress is making things a whole lot worse. If Congress is intent on nationalizing something, it should immediately nationalize the Federal Reserve, and restore the perogative to coin money to its rightful place: The Congress. But that means we can no longer inflate the currency, and that means we will have to give up both the welfare state and the empire.'(We can't conquer Iran?? BOO HOO!) This will never happen. Half the Congress wnats to rule the planet and the other half wants to save it from anything "bad" that could ever happen. We don't need the banks to be rescued; we need to be rescued ourseves--from the 535 members of the World Improvement Committee on Capitol Hill.

What if this bill doesn't solve
the crisis? Then what? Does anyone in Congress or White House have the temerity to suggest that this bill will DEFINITELY guarantee the resolution of this crisis? If not, why are we gambling so much money? Does the bill address the root cause (or causes) of the problem? If not, why not? What does subsidizing wooden arrows for children, or bear DNA, or racetrack pavement have to do with getting us out of the financial mess? I swear, we are living in Wonderland. Up is down. Right is wrong.

And how did the "experts" arrive at the $700B number? From their own mouths, not from any derived data point, just that they needed to come up with a really big number!

A trillion seconds ago was 50,000 YEARS ago. A trillion dollars is what Congress is in a hurry to flush down the Wall Street toilet.

Despicable.

We Should Listen A Lot More
To those like Gingrich who have been absolutely right on the most important and critical issues of our time, far more often than not.

Dick Morris' astute analysis on TV, and in his published opinions online as well as his excellent book Fleeced also illustrate a high level of foresight and strategic brilliance.

Gov Huckabee is another person who has had his finger on the pulse of America and who's often criticized positions have been vindicated by recent events.

McCain would do well to listen a little more. He absolutely needs to start sticking up for the American taxpayer, and go on offense and lead the charge to REFORM America now. It's time for an election surge, an all out effort to put a stop to this horrific movement to reinvent of America by socialists like the Democratic leaders and their proclaimed messiah Obama. Time to turn Palin loose as well, let her be herself and do what she does best.

If we want McCain & Palin to put our Country First, then we're going to have do everything we can to help them win. They've got to listen up, but then we've got make ourselves be heard, not only in Washington, but in every one of our neighborhoods, all across this nation. In uncertain times we need leadership, and we need leadership at every level that listens and actually earns trust.


No Justice
Bill Clinton’s Community Redevelopment Act. was a good idea to help low income people attain credit who, prior to the CRA, could not qualify for the kind of home they wanted. The Real Estate people and the money people saw their opportunity and took advantgage. We are now watching the colossal, robber baron recovery unfold with $700 billion dollars of freshly printed by the Bureau of Engraving and Printing to pay for it.
They forced the banks, financiers on Wall Street and mortgage companies to make predatory loans to people who were not financially prepared to pay the mortgages on the homes. They were threatened with fines and other measures if they did not comply. Now everyone is suffering because of greedy people and power hungry, political parasites created the high risk market – housing bubble – with the Fannies.
Penny Pritzer, James Johnson, Franklin Raines and some of their staff who are involved in Obama’s campaign at the highest level as his advisors. They were in charge and instrumental in the demise of Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac with the blessings of Barney Frank.
http://uk.youtube.com/watch?v=NU6fuFrdCJY
John McCain said, “Quarterly reports of profit growth over the past few years were “illusions deliberately and systematically created” by the company’s [Fannie Mae] senior management, which resulted in a $10.6 billion accounting scandal and a $3.8 million fine.” That did not stop them from further fraud. As a matter of fact things got worse.
On the Senate floor John McCain said, “I join as a cosponsor of the Federal Housing Enterprise Regulatory Reform Act of 2005, S. 190. To underscore my support for quick passage of GSE regulatory reform legislation. If Congress does not act, American taxpayers will continue to be exposed to the enormous risk that Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac pose to the housing market, the overall financial system, and the economy as a whole.”
http://uk.youtube.com/watch?v=NU6fuFrdCJY

There needs to be repayment!
The first version of this bill was incredibly objectionable because as far as I could tell, there was no requirement for repayment. When Newt was speaking on this last weekend, he was clear that this needed to be included and this was why he objected to the first version of the bill as well.

This shouldn't be a bailout -- it should be a rescue loan that these multi-billion dollar businesses are REQUIRED to pay back starting by a certain date and completed by a certain date and there should be an increasing amount of interest if they fail to meet their obligations in a timely manner. Why should an institution like Bank of America get better treatment from the American people than it gave to us? And, if they don't meet the requirements, then the company should be sold off and the money immediately repaid to the US Treasury.

If we don't do this, we'll be paying incredible and neverending amounts of probably increasing taxes to bail out companies that should have known better than to get into this mess.

If John McCain was really against this .
Why isn't he screaming "I told you so" at the top of his lungs, and naming names, and pointing fingers, instead of voting yes????? Does anyone out there really expect to see Frank Raines infront of a congressional investigative committee (chaired by Barney Frank) explaining his $90 million windfall?? Barnum and Bailey could take lessons from our politicos (including Jorge Bush) and we are nothing more than the "marks" in this incredible con game. Answer that THers, if you can.

so long usa
Our political system is corrupt to the core.
It officially no longer what the tax payers want, political hacks like Hatch and Bennett are going to do whatever they want, but not to worry though, I'm sure their families and friends will be fine though.
These people are gutless losers.

Reply #11-Sen. Allard
Is the Senator up for re-election?

Just no history
To this scam, yet I can show everyone this "crisis" was predicted and PLANNED years ago, and all the road signs as it approached this current programmed bs.

My questions
WHO put pork for ACORN in this bill?
Who put the other pork in it?
They should be made famous.

The blame game
Good Lord already, if McCain doesn't start talking to the American people about what this mess is and how it got started and by whom he is doomed.

It is time for McCain to stand up and call the leadership of the Democratic Party exactly what they are; Communists.

I have come to believe that the Democrats are purposely killing the economy so that if Obama gets elected, he will enact some "Emergency" powers to expropriate and nationalize key industries. If you think gas is expensive, wait until folks like those that run the Postal Service are running the oil and gas industry.

Free speech will be a thing of the past, they will shut down talk-radio and the result will be a US version of BBC and the CBC to the north of us. Before too long, you will be calling your boss Comrade and hoping he doesn't get you sent to a re-education camp because you didn't give him your ration card for butter.

Cheers,

Bloefeld

The Real Culprits
The real guilty parties here are YOU and I. We allowed this to happen. All of us.
Anytime a people is afraid of it's Government and that Government has no fear at all of it's citizens, you breed tyranny and corruption at the highest levels. The tendency to take such tyranny personally, and then refuse to countenence it, has been replaced with Government mandated PC complacency. That's where we are, people. A Nation with "No Cojones".
Politicians tell us one thing and do another; lie to us indiscriminately and get away with it. They steal and plunder and giggle the entire time, knowing they are safe from retribution. Why do they do it?? Because we let them. Because we are a Nation with "No Cojones". Neutered sheep.
You want this Country back? First you have put the fear of God back in the politicians that are supposed to be doing "We The Peoples" work.
Force your State Legislators to enact punitive State Laws that specifically address the U.S. House and Senate violations of the U.S. Constitution. We can find a Lawfull way to peacefully force change on the U.S. political landscape or the choices are reduced to the blood and steel options. Government in general has no fear of the American citizens wrath nor their disapproval. They are the government and you ain't. Got that??
Most folks don't want to hear that this is "Our Fault". If they come to accept that premise - why then it becomes incumbent upon all of "US" to resolve this criminal/political mess. God forbid that anyone should have to actually go out and do more that complain.
If you want the Politicians to operate according to the U.S. Constition and actually behave in an honest manner - "YOU & I" will have to force them to do so. They won't do it on their own. You know they won't.
So there you have it. Take this Country back or go back to sleep. Go figure.
I'm going to go buy some more hollow-points.

Dwain Cleveland


liveinHim, so they could have a BBQ!
There is enough pork in this monstrosity to feed everyone in NC, SC, VA and TN at least!
Sign Up to Post Your CommentsSign Up to Post Your Comments
If you are already registered, click here to login. Otherwise, please take a few seconds to register with Townhall.com. Once you sign up, you’ll be able to post your comments immediately, use the action center, get podcasts, and more!
Note: Fields marked with a red asterisk (*) are required.
Salutation:
First Name:
*
Last Name:
*
Email:
*
Nickname:
*
Note: Nick name will be shown when you post comments.
Address 1:
*
Address 2:
City:
*
State:
*
Zip:
*
Phone:
      
Your daily must-read of conservative columns, cartoons and news. Coulter, Sowell, Krauthammer and more.
(Bi-Weekly) We highlight the best opportunities from our partners for surveys, action items and more.