Townhall.com, Where Your Opinion Counts
Talk Radio:   Bill Bennett   Mike Gallagher   Dennis Prager   Michael Medved   Hugh Hewitt   
BREAKING NEWS  LeftArrow - Townhall.com : Conservative, Political, Republican   RightArrow - Townhall.com : Conservative, Political, Republican  
Columns, funnies & more in your inbox!
  • Check the boxes and send us your email address to receveive your free newsletter
  • Your daily must-read of conservative columns, cartoons and news. Coulter, Sowell, Krauthammer and more.
  • Townhall.com’s weekly inside scoop on what’s happening behind the scenes in the world of politics. When news breaks, we report.
  • Signup to receive the latest daily Townhall cartoons
Wednesday, January 14, 2009
Mary Fallin :: Townhall.com Columnist
A Stimulus That Works
by Mary Fallin
Vote on It:
Average Vote:
[+] Text [-]
 
Poll
Was the Copenhagen Global Warming Summit Walk-Out a Win for the U.S.?


With the economy stalled and a prolonged recession seeming all but inevitable, almost everyone agrees the federal government needs to act quickly and seriously to turn things around. President-elect Obama has put economic recovery on the top of his list, for good reason, and it is heartening to see that tax cuts make up a significant part of his stimulus plan.

Unfortunately, these tax cuts appear to be mostly temporary and coupled with massive, and in many cases permanent, new spending. We in the Republican Study Committee, a group of over 100 House conservatives, think we have a better plan. We presented our alternative, the Economic Recovery and Middle Class Relief Act, today.

Our plan includes permanent and far reaching tax cuts for families and businesses as well as a renewed commitment to fiscal discipline. It is based on principles recognized by Republican and Democratic presidents alike: tax cuts work, growth begins with the middle class, and recovery comes fastest when we allow Americans to keep more of their own money.

One need look no further than history for proof; the Kennedy tax cuts of 1964, the Reagan cuts of 1981 and the Bush reductions of 2001 through 2003 all helped revitalize lagging economies.

Conversely, huge non-military spending outlays under the New Deal did little to dent the Great Depression. An economy thrives from the bottom up, not from the top down, a truth the RSC stimulus plan recognizes.

Our plan includes three major ingredients – tax cuts for families, tax relief and growth incentives for businesses, and restraint of federal spending.

The RSC proposal reduces individual income taxes by 5 percent, repeals the alternative minimum tax for individuals, raises the child tax credit from $1,000 to $5,000 and boosts tax deductions for college expenses from $4,000 to $6,000, while increasing income limits for those deductions.

It permanently repeals the requirement that seniors begin withdrawing IRA funds at age 70 1/2 and suspends taxes and penalties for all of 2009 for any IRA withdrawals. This last measure will allow hard-pressed families immediate access to savings, helping prevent foreclosures or bankruptcy.

Our proposal will prohibit tax rates on capital gains or dividends from increasing in 2010, as they are currently set to, leaving more dollars in the hands of investors.

As unemployment rises, businesses need incentives to expand and hire. The RSC stimulus plan will reduce America’s corporate income tax rate (currently the second highest in the world) from 35 percent to 25 percent, cut the capital gains rate for corporations from 35 percent to 15 percent and index capital gains taxes to offset inflation. These three provisions will allow businesses to forestall layoffs and increase hiring.

We will also encourage growth and entrepreneurship by repealing limits on expensing allowances for depreciable business assets, making the research and development tax credit permanent (they are currently set to expire with the Bush tax cuts) and extending the current two-year carryback period for net operating losses to seven years.

Finally, our plan will impose a one percent across the board reduction in non-defense discretionary federal spending. The RSC sees that as a down payment on future efforts to curb the ravenous spending that plagues the federal government. Unrestrained spending helped create our current economic crisis. We cannot cure it, or avoid future meltdowns, by following the same flawed path.

The Republican Study Committee will continue to press for tax relief and spending restraint as core elements of any economic recovery plan. President-elect Obama has pledged to listen to our ideas. Moving forward, we will hold him to that promise.

Share:
Vote on It:
Average Vote:
 
About The Author
Congresswoman Mary Fallin represents the Fifth District of Oklahoma.
 
TOWNHALL DAILY: Be the first to read Mary Fallin's column. Sign up today and receive Townhall.com daily lineup delivered each morning to your inbox.
A step
in the right direction, but a lot more spending cuts are needed.

the next step
The next step is finding some economists who think this would actually work in the current climate of heavy personal debt and weak demand for goods. That should keep republicans in the congress busy for a while.

all under the guy I voted twice for
A private sector solution is the only answer. The Govt managed to screw up their own plan by handing out all this money and not tracking where it was going - and under a Republican with an MBA.


Not tax cuts
spending cuts.

Cutting taxes without cutting spending is what Reagan, Bush and Bush did.

It is ridiculous to cut taxes without cutting spending.

The word "idiots" comes to mind.

No wonder Republicans are the minority.



Spending?
Unrealistic spending not only by government, but by individuals is what got us into this mess. The answer to the economic troubles is not more spending or government sponsored gimmicks to get people to SPEND MORE. The answer is to 1) Only buy what you can afford. This goes for individuals and government. George Washington gave us the advice of avoiding debt as much as possible and in times of peace, to pay off the debt that unforeseen wars may cause. Thomas Jefferson said that it is cowardly for a generation to burden those that follow with debt. 2) Saving, not spending will turn the economy around. When people save money, they are not vulnerable to economic hardships and can continue to pay for necessities. Borrowing 3 times what one can afford to buy a house is screaming for problems and bankruptcy. Saving also gives banks the assets needed to lend to companies. This is real money too. It is not money created out of thin air by the government. 3) Eliminate the Federal Reserve. The first national bank was eliminated by President Jackson in the early 1800s. We did not have a central bank until the 1910s when the Federal Reserve was created because bankers used their own assets to prevent a bank failure. The Federal Reserve then created the greatest economic disaster in the 1920s, eliminated the gold-standard and destroyed approximately 90% of the value of the US dollar. The US dollar is no longer "sound as a dollar."
When an economy is run only on debt, it can not be sustained and we are seeing the consequences now. Many people warned of the economic crisis for years. It was not a surprise.

STIMULATE THE ECONOMY
Disolve all civil servant unions, it was Reagan biggest mistake no going far enough after the Air Traffic Controllers Union, all in the name of national security. An immediate stimulation of the economy would occur because the blackmail
backdoor deals by the democrats and unions would be immediate over.Incompotent civil servants would not be hired because of who they knew or as a favor to anyone and could be immediately terminated.

loss of revenue
first, there has been a paradigm shift in this country that makes cutting taxes on corporations fruitless.

when we were a manufacturing country, if corporations got tax cuts they would re-invest in new plants and equipment and expand their workforce.

we have shifted to a service economy, and now re-investment is minimal, instead they take the tax cuts and build some new mccmansions and than build plants over seas.


second, according to republicans, tax cuts are always in order.

if the economy is good, cut taxes.
if the economy is bad, cut taxes.

it makes no sense particularly when revenues fall below historical levels.

you can cut taxes all you want but if there is no consumer demand, businesses wont re-invest or hire because they are simply trying to get smaller and stay in business.

seriously, we could have zero taxes on business and it would not help right now.

this is an extreme case and cutting taxes and cutting spending still won't generate the revenue needed.

THANK YOU
Thank you, House Republicans, for putting forth free market, Conservative solutions.

While you may not have much power under Pelosi rule, we Conservatives expect Republicans to aggressively and loudly fight for and teach Reagan Conservatism (which is based entirely on our founding principles.)

Christianlib
It has been proven time and again that taxes are regressive. They stifle investment. And what you don't realize is the tax cuts conservative call for are raised over and over again by dims. Business cycles should not be a reason for adjusting.

They need to be permanently adjusted with incentives to guard against what you surmised. Any money that goes directly to management and perks or foreign investment it will get taxed at a higher rate. If it goes to capital or employment it won't. Revenue has been proven to rise with tax cut stimulus. Why not set the rates be done with it. Once businesses can plan then they can get on with marketing and selling and hiring.

Government spending is the main problem and dims give that a free pass. In fact they plan their campaigns on increasing everything about it. BO and company plan on making sure they give out all the goodies they can for 2010. I hope we can convince enough of the majority that doesn't pay attention that we need a '94 revolt all over again. I've already got the smokers.

Minority
As a member of the minority party, you get to watch the Dems pass all kinds of great laws! Their majority makes you marginal, but i encourage you to continue to believe that you have a say. Obama, under pressure from dems, already said he is repealing the business tax cuts from his stimulus plan. Oh how nice its going to be to watch Republicans capitulate to Dems the way Dems did for Bush! If his term goes well after the mess republicans left the country in: Permanent Majority.

sdf
Please elaborate on your history lesson. The dims capitualated? On what? Shamnesty? Declaring defeat?

What have the dims been doing for two years that we need more of? All I could see was that they were ducking and dodging behind their empty suit snake-oil schmoozer until the election and now will continue their march into the bankruptcy drink. Its been proven time and again that Reid, Pelosi, Dodd and Frank have no intention of helping the country. They just want to set their agenda. Ahh you sound like your all giddy down there in such a good ol American state like Alabama. Are the refugees from the Peoples Republic of CA, MI, MA, NJ, WA, NY, PA, IL moving in down there?

Stimulus Plan That Works?
Somehow, I don't believe that "almost everyone agrees the federal government needs to act quickly and seriously to turn things around"! For most of us, the federal government is one of the primary causes of our current economic problems and we shudder whenever we hear that the government is going to act "quickly and seriously". We have seen too many times what that actually means.

Actually receiving such things as accountability, responsibility, and integrity from our "representatives" in public office - on both sides of the aisle - would "stimulate" the majority of the American people far more than coninuing to throw our hard-earned money down the drain.

indyconantidim

thank you for a civil response but....



you say this

" Revenue has been proven to rise with tax cut stimulus."


this has not historically been proven to be true, in fact, in many cases the opposite has happened.

in fact, clinton raised taxes and revenues increased.

here are some links to prove my point.


In 1981, Congress approved very large supply-side tax cuts, dramatically lowering marginal income-tax rates. In 1990 and 1993, by contrast, Congress raised marginal income-tax rates on the well off. Despite the very different tax policies followed during these two decades, there was virtually no difference in real per-person economic growth in the 1980s and 1990s. Real per-person revenues, however, grew about twice as quickly in the 1990s, when taxes were increased, as in the 1980s, when taxes were cut. (See Figure 1.)

http://www.cbpp.org/3-8-06tax.htm

democrats are almost always better for the economy than republicans..


http://www.slate.com/id/2199810/


finally, this link proves revenues do not increase with tax cuts in most instances.

http://www.taxfoundation.org/taxdata/show/2089.html

Tax cuts are better than stimulating the
housing market again.

Here in Los Angeles, there has been a terrible inflation in the housing market, which is starting to correct, but in its wake is the advent of outrageous apartment rental prices.

All the idiots who lost their jobs in the new millinium, and tried to make a living by flipping houses, drove the market higher and higher.

Fools who read Rich Dad Poor Dad, and went to the Trump seminars, thought they could buy apartment buildings and live off the rent! As it turned out, they couldn't collect enough rent to pay for the mortgage and the maintance, so they jacked up the rents.

Meanwhile, the fools who took on bigger mortgages than they could afford started losing their homes, and had to move into apartments, pushing up the demand and therefore the rents.

I am currently working 7 days a week to pay for a one bedroom apartment. Now the economy is tanking, and the freelance jobs are getting scarcer.

Meanwhile, my neighbor, who hasn't held down a job for the last 30 years, and is getting government assistance to pay for an identical apartment to mine, is getting excited, because she expects the government to give her even more money.

This is outrageous to me, since I am self-employed, and considered too rich to deserve a tax break, much less government assistance.

I am trembling in my tatty old shoes that the IRS is going to come around sniffing in my pockets for more money to give to my neighbor, or the people down the street who get food stamps because they have ankle biters, even though they can afford to live in a house and drive a late model car.

Christianlib
The economy has as many stimulants as there are politicians including state and local which means thousands. Trying to judge prosperity by presidents (which is what that rep/dem thing you mentioned refers to) is like judging elections by the score of Redskin games. Besides we had 40 years of dim rule of Congress from the 50's to the 90's and that didn't work either.

The one thing that is certain is that the government is broken and making it larger will not work. It needs to be pared. Just like the article says. Get by with less and get out of the private sector. There's plenty of transparency that most businesses will adhere to if they just cust the cost of doing business. Regulations are just like immigration laws. There's more than enough if they just follow them.

This is simple. Start the budget from $0, cut corp taxes and offer temp visas to illegals if they come out and register. Then you dry up a lot of fat and cheats and this will turn around. Markets will adjust. Did you read the other article about the $350 B your government doesn't know what happened to? Now realistically who do you believe is responsible? Lame duck Bush or the fat cat dims getting ready to storm the vault.

indyconantidim

Yes, please cut corporate taxes. I need a job!

A column
from our former Lewwwtenant Gov. Nice to see you are part of the RSC. I am down to one 16 yr old tax credit. Time to get the wife's tubes untied, I guess. $5,000 child tax credit. That will show those overfornicating Muslims. It could also provide a nice means of support to them in this country. Five kids equals $25,000 cash money from the Feds on your tax return. Hmm.

HAVE WE CONCEDED?
I agree that we need to act quickly, as quickly as possible beat Congress to it's Constitutional limits as set forth in Article 1, Section 8. Need I say more? No Medicaid, no Medicare, no Department of Education, NO CORPORATE BAILOUT, which even prior to TARP has been ridiculous. Every Republican, and every Conservative should read over Thomas Jefferson's words concerning Article 1, Section 8 of the Constitution. Please go to following link,

http://avalon.law.yale.edu/18th_century/bank-tj.asp

This is what needs to be applied today, and to further this position is the fact that the power to create canals was put forth and voted down. Clearly the Debate attendees did not see "General Welfare" as what it is construed as today. Let's push the Enumerated Powers Act forward.

tax cuts
i thought tax cuts were supposed to create jobs-jobs created under clinton-21 million-jobs created under bush-3 million-whats the deal?-oh thats right bush is not the worst president ever-just the unluckiest.

FairTax is the answer.
The Government is trying to dig us out of a hole thereby creating a bigger hole.

The way out of this mess is the FairTax. Income taxes penalize the Producers and Workers in this country and force businesses to go overseas. More than thirteen trillion dollars in off-shore accounts could be stimulating the US economy but are not because of our tax code. Businesses have left the country in order to survive.

Call Congress and tell them to support FairTax H.R. 25 and let's get the jobs back into this country before it is too late. How refreshing it would be to call a business and actually speak to an American.

Roy, get the dunce cap out of your eyes
The Bush tax cuts worked wonderfully until we elected a bunch of tax & spend Democrats to Congress. Since they have taken power and refused to renew the Bush tax cuts the economy and middle class has suffered.... I know, I know, they just meant to get all those nasty rich people...

I Love It
Tax cuts and "renewed commitment to fiscal discipline"

A renewed commitment. They've been making commitments to fiscal discipline since the 80s. They've never done it. Not the dems. Not the repubs.

If the issue weren't so series, I'd be laughing my head off right now.

RSC proposes....
'Finally, our plan will impose a one percent across the board reduction in non-defense discretionary federal spending.'

Wow! This is fabulous! A whole one percent reduction!

They really don't understand do they? A one percent reduction is like using a shot glass to bail out the Titanic.

How about simply freezing the spending for 5 years. No increases. Reallocation of spending can be done but no new spending. And after 5 years spending cannot increase by more than the phony bologna inflation rate the government reports.

If the income tax is to be kept all the tax payers must pay taxes. First repeal EIC. Second, make FICA be collected through the FITW side and make it law that the business contribution of FICA for its employees be added to the employees wage and then deducted for payment to the government. In this way everyone will see that they pay at least 14+%. In addition the tax brackets need to be adjusted so that even the poorest citizen must pay a little more than the FICA. This is the only way to ensure all citizens will loath the tax man.

More, much more than what RSC has proposed needs to be done. They are far too timid and still too enamored with big government to really propose fixes that will work. Maybe after BHO has destroyed another huge chunk of our country they will find the courage to be true conservatives.

A Stimulus That Works
What about repealing the AMT tax? A very unfair tax.

Bob is correct.
My husband worked 2 jobs one year for extra income and we got hit with the super secret AMT tax. The government stole practically the whole extra amount he earned. Since we didn't know about the super secret tax we were not prepared and had to borrow to pay it. HOW STUPID IS THAT TAX. How are middle-class Americans supposed to get ahead?

Repeal ALL corporate and business taxes
Corporations DO NOT pay taxes, they just collect them and forward them to the politicians. Consider where corporations get the money they pay to the bureaucrats. They can take it out of dividends and benefits to their stockholders (mostly your 401K). They can pay their workers less in wages and salaries (your paycheck), or they can charge higher prices for the goods and services they produce (your cost of living). In other words, YOU pay corporate taxes indirectly!

FICA
Bush stole enough FICA during the Iraq War by refusing to fix Social Security, to fight the war and have pork to spare. This ongoing theft should be exposed and stopped. How about it?

Real tax relief is needed
The proposal in the article is a very good first step but I doubt that Obama and the Dems will accept it. They want government control over every aspect of our lives, so they would not favor anything that reinforces our original freedoms. Right now more people who don't pay taxes are in the majority and they want to suck the taxpayers dry. The government is their enforcer.

The government
needs to NOT act. It needs to get the hell out of our lives, wallets, bedrooms, and schools. PERIOD!

A rising tide lifts all boats!
You are Dead on target, Mary Fallin! You have the absolute support of this taxaphobic conservitive.To Christianlib and all other taxaholics who disagree with the facts, follow this link to understand the benefits of cutting taxes to promote REAL growth.
https://www.cato.org/pubs/pas/pa-261.html

With all due respect Ms. Fallin ...
"a one percent across the board reduction in non-defense discretionary federal spending" ??

Please. Your 'steps in the right direction' as some have called them, don't even begin to undo the fiscal damage done by Republicans and Democrats alike in the last 15 years, nor stave off the disaster that's ahead. Trying to appear relevant in front of a Democrat majority will only encourage them to spit in your face and laugh as they steer us toward the nearest cliff and hit the gas.

What our country needs is representatives bold enough to stand up without fear of failure and bring wholesale major change to the table: flat tax or fair tax, not puny reductions here or there; mandatory balanced budget; 10% reduction in federal spending until the deficit is $0 and then growth limited to a percent tied to GDP; SS reform with options for personal investment. And maybe legislative term limits just to sweeten the pot.

If you had the cajones, you'd have such a ground swell of grass roots support you'd have to learn how to drive the bus yourself.

Forget the bailouts
Giving my money to banks, auto companies, insurance companies, etc. won't do anything but create inflation. Hello the return of Jimmy Carter. Throwing money at the wall not expecting any results because there is no plan is liberal fantasy stuff I couldn't have made up. Stop wasting money, then I'll listen to you.
Sign Up to Post Your CommentsSign Up to Post Your Comments
If you are already registered, click here to login. Otherwise, please take a few seconds to register with Townhall.com. Once you sign up, you’ll be able to post your comments immediately, use the action center, get podcasts, and more!
Note: Fields marked with a red asterisk (*) are required.
Salutation:
First Name:
*
Last Name:
*
Email:
*
Nickname:
*
Note: Nick name will be shown when you post comments.
Address 1:
*
Address 2:
City:
*
State:
*
Zip:
*
Phone:
      
Your daily must-read of conservative columns, cartoons and news. Coulter, Sowell, Krauthammer and more.
(Bi-Weekly) We highlight the best opportunities from our partners for surveys, action items and more.