Townhall.com, Where Your Opinion Counts
Talk Radio:   Bill Bennett   Mike Gallagher   Dennis Prager   Michael Medved   Hugh Hewitt   
BREAKING NEWS  LeftArrow - Townhall.com : Conservative, Political, Republican   RightArrow - Townhall.com : Conservative, Political, Republican  
Columns, funnies & more in your inbox!
  • Check the boxes and send us your email address to receveive your free newsletter
  • Your daily must-read of conservative columns, cartoons and news. Coulter, Sowell, Krauthammer and more.
  • Townhall.com’s weekly inside scoop on what’s happening behind the scenes in the world of politics. When news breaks, we report.
  • Signup to receive the latest daily Townhall cartoons
Tuesday, March 17, 2009
Lorie Byrd :: Townhall.com Columnist
The Big Scamulus Con
by Lorie Byrd
Vote on It:
Average Vote:
[+] Text [-]
 
Poll
Was the Copenhagen Global Warming Summit Walk-Out a Win for the U.S.?


“Spendulus,” “Porkulus,” and “the Generational Theft Act of 2009” are all nicknames some have given to the “American Recovery and Reinvestment Act of 2009” signed into law by President Obama last month.   In light of Obama’s most recent statements about the economy an even more accurate moniker might be “Scamulus” considering how obvious it now is that everything leading up to passage of the bill was a master con perpetrated on American taxpayers.  The con is not over either.  We have simply entered the next phase.

“Scamulus” had to be passed in a big hurry.  The rush was such that not only did Democrats and Obama break their pledge to allow for a 48 hour review period prior to the vote, but not even 24 hours were provided to read the 1400-plus page bill.  The urgency of the bill, according to President Obama, was because America was facing an "economic crisis as deep and as dire as the Great Depression” and we could not afford to wait even 48 hours because it might turn into a “crisis that at some point we may be unable to reverse.”

After the big rush through Congress the “emergency bill” sat for four days until President Obama signed it.  If it were not obvious then that the big rush had been a con, additional evidence would continue to mount over the next few weeks.  The strategy was calculated. It was deceitful. It was manipulative. It was opportunistic. It was un-presidential. And unless tax-paying American citizens speak up it will continue to be effective, with some tweaks.

One real reason the "stimulus" bill had to be passed in such a rush was because it had to happen before the economy had a chance to rebound on its own.  Not only were retail sales up in January,

advancing for the first time in seven months, showing strong increases in sales of automobiles and in general merchandise, but gas prices dropped significantly over the past several months.  Even those who did not lose their jobs during the recession suffered from $4 a gallon gas.  When gas prices dropped so significantly over the past few months, it put extra cash in peoples' pockets, making a measurable difference in many household budgets.  This all happened before the passage of the scam stimulus bill.

Declaring a catastrophe from which we might never be able to recover, scared the public into swallowing what otherwise would have been impossible to sell.  Obama had successfully created a dire emergency atmosphere that allowed passage of the bill.  As Vice President Cheney put it, Obama used ”the current set of economic difficulties to try to justify a massive expansion in the government, and much more authority for the government over the private sector.”

Obama has also talked the economy down to the point that just about any future improvement will look like significant recovery by comparison and be hailed as the product of the miraculous Obamessiah’s policies.  The media that downplayed, and sometimes just completely ignored, good economic news during the Bush years, will highlight each and every example of it over the next few years.  It has already begun.

Over the weekend I heard the following statement from Lawrence Summers reported as an indication that the President’s policies are working and that his new found optimism is valid:  “It is surely too early to gauge the broader economic impact of the President's program. But it is modestly encouraging that since it began to take shape, consumer spending in the US, which was collapsing during the holiday season, appears, according to a number of indicators, to have stabilized.”  As I cited earlier, at least one economic indicator, retail sales, was up in January for the first time in seven months indicating the collapse of consumer spending during the holiday season was already recovering in January, not only before passage of the major component of “the President’s program” in mid February, but for the most part before Obama was even sworn into office.  The news report on the Summers statement I heard made no mention of the January retail sales numbers.  Expect each and every positive bit of economic news to be attributed to the President’s plan, regardless of whether or not it is even possible for it to be related.

After the first part of the big con was completed, the gloom and doom talk was less necessary. After Scamulus passed, and the stock market continued to plummet, even Obama supporters began criticizing him for the damage his negative language had done.  Last week, Obama officially cancelled the catastrophe. He said at a Business Roundtable meeting, “I don't think things are ever as good as they say, or ever as bad as they say. Things two years ago were not as good as we thought because there were a lot of underlying weaknesses in the economy. They're not as bad as we think they are now.”  He also had administration officials carrying the message.

Back during the presidential campaign candidate Obama made quite a big deal, and scored some major political points by criticizing John McCain for saying “the fundamentals of our economy are strong.”  The AP reported, “Obama's team painted the veteran senator as out of touch and failing to grasp the challenges facing the country. But on Sunday, that optimistic message came from economic adviser Christina Romer during an appearance on NBC's "Meet the Press."

GREGORY: So back then during the campaign when Senator McCain talked about the strong fundamentals of the economy, it was then-candidate Obama and his team that roundly criticized McCain, saying he was out of touch, he didn’t get it, he didn’t understand how bad the economy was. And yet now the president’s talking about the strong fundamentals of the economy.

So what’s different between then, the campaign, and now, except for the fact that the economy’s gotten dramatically worse?

ROMER: I think when the president says he’s focusing on fundamentals, what he means is — is we’re focusing on fixing the fundamentals; that we’ve always said we’re not looking at the ups and downs of the stock market, we’re looking for those crucial indicators: when are jobs turning around; when are sales turning around; when do we see consumers coming to life?

That’s the kind of thing that — certainly that I’m looking at in terms of when’s the economy going to be doing better and when can we see some hope.

GREGORY: Are the fundamentals of this economy sound?

ROMER: Well, of course the fundamentals are sound in the sense that the American workers are sound, we have a good capital stock, we have good technology. We know that, that temporarily we’re in a mess, right?

We’ve seen huge job loss. We’ve seen very large falls in GDP. So certainly in the short run we’re in a — in a bad situation.

GREGORY: All right, but then what’s different between now and then, when the economy was in even better shape than it is now, when McCain was saying the fundamentals were strong and then-candidate Obama criticized him?

ROMER: I think — again, I think what we’re saying is that the, you know, where we are today is obviously not good. We have a plan in place to get to a good place. I think that’s the crucial — a fundamentally crucial difference, is to make sure that you have put in place all of the comprehensive programs that’ll get us back to those fundamentals.

David Gregory made a good effort to get an answer, but all he got from Romer was that embarrassing fumble.  Major Garrett at Fox News had better luck from a source in the Obama administration.  When asked how what McCain said was different he was told, “Well he lost that spin war.  That’s why we’re here.”  Got that?  Translation:  we won the spin war and fooled the voters into putting us into office so now we can say anything we want.  That explanation would certainly explain why they thought they would get away with hyping the economic situation to scare people into accepting the huge “stimulus” bill. 

Mike Allen reports at the Politico, “The White House on Sunday began harnessing every part of the Democratic Party’s machinery to defend President Obama’s budget and portray Republicans as reflexively political, according to party strategists.”

It appears they are not going to argue the merits of the President’s policies so much as they are going to vilify Republicans.  I don’t blame them.  It has worked for them over and over again.  This time might just be different though.

As one blogger put it, “The Democrats have the White House and have huge majorities in both houses of Congress. They can pass anything they want with the vote of one RINO Senator, and there are at least three to choose from. If their legislation is meritorious, why not make the argument for it directly? The reason is that Obama's budget cannot win on the merits after transparent public debate, but if the Donks can make life difficult for Republican Senators from Maine and Pennsylvania by portraying them as inflexible partisans they might get their 60 votes in the Senate.”

In the Politico report about the campaign by a labor-funded ally of the White House accusing Republicans of playing politics and having no plan of their own, Boehner Communications Director Kevin Smith said, “If I had to defend the president’s budget—which is being eviscerated by both parties because it spends too much, taxes too much, and borrows too much—I’d probably waste time on fictitious claims like this, too.”

A Republican Senate leadership aide responded: ‘It really is a silly campaign. What are we saying ‘no’ to? Trillions in new spending? An unpopular, earmark-laden bill that the President himself was embarrassed to sign? A new national energy tax? Releasing Gitmo terrorists into the U.S.? We’d like to thank them for reminding the American people that we are saying ‘no’ to those things.’

What Democrats will most likely say Republicans are saying “no” to is the miraculous recovery we are already seeing begin to take shape.  It began last week with the President declaring things are better than he said they were three weeks ago.  It will continue with every positive bit of economic news being attributed to the “stimulus” bill.

The Republicans who stood in unity and opposition to the “stimulus” con are to be applauded.  If the media were doing their jobs they would be chasing down the three Republicans and all the Democrats who voted for the bill to ask them how they feel now that it is evident they were duped.

Although the media is under reporting them, when they report them at all, Americans are realizing they have been conned and are fighting back  in “tea party” protests across the country.  So far the protests have taken place in dozens of cities with thousands participating and many more are planned to take place over the coming weeks and months.  Now this is not so much about the scam “stimulus” bill that was passed in February as it is about all the legislation and spending the Obama administration and Democrats in Congress are proposing be passed over the coming year.  The con worked in the first round, but there are many more to go and it appears America is finally awakening from their hope ‘n change daze. 

Share:
Vote on It:
Average Vote:
 
About The Author

Lorie Byrd is a Townhall.com columnist and blogs at Wizbang and at LorieByrd.com.

Be the first to read Lorie Byrd's column. Sign up today and receive Townhall.com delivered each morning to your inbox.

POLITICAL MALICE
The Democrats have proceeded with political malice without an accurate definition of the problem. Without such definition, there cannot be consensus on a solution. The Stimulus is a big, messy, chaotic piece of legislation. The Congressional Budget Office says only 25 percent of the money would even go out in the first year. Only 12 cents of every dollar could be called stimulus. The Stimulus is a cynical display of pork, payoffs, political base-pleasing, group-greasing dollar outlays.

The political implication for Obama is devastating. In 2008, the public rejected business as usual. That rejection partly explains why he was elected. At this point we have a Humpy Dumpty example of “all the king’s horses and all the king’s men” bent on throwing huge sums at the problem in an expression of hope against hope. It is as though the Democrats believe that throwing money at the Titanic would have stopped it from sinking.

DAVID from MA: said it best!!!

"HE [Obama] KNOWS EXACTLY WHAT HE IS DOING.

"SOCIALIZING AMERICA VIA BANKRUPTCY!"




Oh and BTW, Chris Dodd was the one

who inserted the language into the Scamulus Con that allowed AIG to spend OUR MONEY on bonuses for the very people who drove AIG into the ground.


Get that? CHRIS DODD!


Caterpillar
And now caterpillar has laid off even tho the obamanation lied and stated that if we passed the stimucrap bill it would be good for catepillar...lets all TEA PARTY!

Obama's "Chicken Little" impression
No one has explained the "dire emergency" strategy of Obama better than Ms. Byrd.
If we, the true conservatives, don't get better organized to fight this scam—we will all find ourselves stuck in a "Ponzi" scam of unimaginable proportions.
Obama will keep screaming that "the sky is falling" until we all embrace socialism. That's his plan!

Paul: We knew this was coming HOURS

after Bozo made that stupid statement.

CEO Owens was on TV that same afternoon saying Caterpillar will probably have to lay off more staff before it starts THINKING about rehiring any of the more than 22,000 employees it already planned to cut.

CEO Jim Owens said, "Even if a stimulus plan passes, it likely will not have an effect on the economy until late this year or early 2010,"


And then there was Bozo speech in Elkhart, Indiana, promising money to the RV manufacturers...

Was I the only one questioning the logic in THAT? Who is going to have the money to buy an RV? And who would buy one anyway with the price of gas...?

And we know the govt. is looking for ways to tax petrol up to the $5-$6/gal. level, not only for revenue, but also to control our "carbon foot print."



The real scam being perpetrated upon
"we the people" is the same one that the elites have been using for years. It is the old tactic of telling a lie over and over until it is accepted as true.

The lie is: Only the elites from the two major parties have the necessary wisdom, knowledge, and experience to govern! Sure, that's why we are in this mess that THEY MADE!

This false, lesser of two evils choice, spewed out by the DEM/GOP/MSM propaganda machines has given us rule by elites whose only goals are more power and getting re-elected.

As the rightful owners of this nation, we need to change how we think and re-assert our authority to govern ourselves. The elites will never restore Constitutional self government, and there is no future for freedom in either party.

Now is the time to plan to reclaim the inheritance that the elites have stolen from us. The best way to do that is to follow the Obama administration's cue and recognize that we should not waste the opportunity presented by this crisis.

With so many out of work, now is the time to get together with family and friends, choose someone with common sense and respect for the Constitution, and RUN FOR OFFICE! Organize a campaign committee, register as a candidate, and challenge these corrupt elites. Let's elect true citizen legislators and govern ourselves. There is no other way we can ever expect to remain free unless we take charge. Now is the time to start planning, so let's do it!

Anyone have a better idea? If so, spit it out, but please, don't tell me we must trust the GOP elites over the DEM elites. That is what we have been doing for years! Thanks, Joe

IMPEACHMENT


LET THE HEARINGS BEGIN!

Timing
It takes time for any input on the economy to work its way through. Of all the bucks appropriated in this payoff program, few have actually been paid out by the Treasury, making a link between Jan/Feb numbers & the program nonexistent. The spending binge won't have any statistically significant effect on the economy for at least 9-12 months. The economy is and will continue to recover on its own. The best we can hope for is that it won't produce too much inflation.
Two further points. A)Virtually all of the money is to be paid to gubmint entities, meaning if historical percentages hold true that about 20-25% of what's appropriated will actually be spent for the intended purpose with the rest vanishing into the bureaucratic swamp.
B)This is a political package, not an economic one whose true intent is to keep politicians in office and the rest of us beholden to them.

Work it.

Republicans, Independants and Democrats with thier eyes newly opened. The air is RICH with information to use. The time is right. Obama in his absurdity has handed real thinking people of America a grand opportunity to show the hipocrocy
of the Left. Use it or Lose it..

Obama's thinly veiled attempts to grandstand about horrible bailout atrocities is laughable and downright embarrassing. There is no backing out now, no backtracking. He didnt look at the bill, stated a catastrophe was happening without it, then signed it. Put his name on it.
OBAMA OWNS IT AND EVERY BAILOUT CRIME IN IT.

Loire
47% of us were'nt fooled "one" bit. I never believed the "one", he is a chicago politician. That is a liar, and a thief.
2010 vote, run for office, it's the only way to stop him.
Kirk

Won that spin war
What a brazenly cynical statement. This follows a couple of other situations where Obama, when confronted with his inconsistencies, basically shrugged his shoulders in a "so what" fashion. The others had to do with his criticism of Hillary Clinton's foreign policy experience versus appointing her Secretary of State and his "I won" statement when asked to fulfill his promise for bipartisanship. Apparently, "transparency" means he will lie openly to us.

What Must Be Done
One good thing about Obama wanting to make veterans reimburse the VA for their medical care is that there is absolutely no possibility of our military turning on us when the revolution comes.

Let's hope that he continues to abuse them as he abuses the other productive and important segments of our society so as to be able to reward the parasitic criminal class in our country with greater transfer payments.

The quicker this country galvanizes against the subversive communist elements that have infected all branches of our government, and at all levels, the quicker we have the civil war that we desperately need.

Voting, petitions, letters to congressmen, tea parties and the like are useless. They are not listening. It does not matter that 80% of the voters disagree with this or that. The scum leeches sucking the life out of the nation seem to always be reelected.

Only when their beaten and bloody corpses are hangng upside down from lamp posts along the streets of D.C., surrounded by smiling and jovial partisans, can we feel safe from these cockroaches.

Thereafter registered democrats should be put behind barbed wired labor camps so their cases can be evaluated and proper disposition of them made.




moaning in their graves
Our founding fathers could never have imagined this fiasco!
Doom & gloom statements from the Pres'..
And all we law abiding, hard working tax payers have to do is trust the same people who started this mess w/ sub prrime loans..to fix everything? My GAWD..when did 'stupid' become fashionable in Washington?
I just saw that there is an appointed 'Climate Czar? who was, until recently a Socialist!
Climate Czar? What on Earth is that?
More big Gov't controlling your very thermostat..wonderful.
I feel warmer already.

And the point is...?
What is NEW in this piece? Obama said, Larry Summer said, Romer said, the dems said, the repubs said, porkulus, scamulus, spendulus.

Maybe that the obama-ites are going to take credit for the good news and blame Bush, the Republicans, the Economy, the Chinese, the French, for the bad? What should they do, take the reverse stance?

Or is the point here that they should tell the truth? Was Bush telling the truth last year when the first spend-, pork-, scamulus passed?

What a waste of space.


JDs Handsome son -oh
Always 2% that don't "get the word", right.. What's the deal on Ob "making the veterans reimburse the VA"??I'm Retired Military and I always paid (Or my Insurance, more specificaly)
when I was working before retiring totally at 65.. I'm not certain I paid for Routine Out-patient visits, but for Shoulder Surgery, A radical procedure, shortly before final retirement was paid by my Insurance to the tune of 14-15K bucks.

NOT EVEN 100 days and POOF !!

Obama has destroyed this country in less than 100 days ! OVER 150 years of blood, sweat and tears: GONE ! plus it will take another 100 plus years to put this country back together:

deliberately:
OBAMA is the enemy within: HE lies about his calculated lies:

ALL SMOKE AND MIRRORS:::

He gives you the finger and he flashes that EVIL smirk:



and the GOP just sits on its face and says NOTHING;
NO spine
NO Action


GOP: Independents to blame too:

All of those who sat at home and pouted, did not fight the fight and refused to vote against Obama are to blame too:

Obama has destroyed this country in less than 100 days: it will take 100 YEARS to put it back together:

OBAMA is the enemy within:

Tragedy: 33% of those who voted for OBAMA are illiterate! and the productive people have to pay the price:

As Germany went under HITLER
SO GOES the USA under OBAMA

ROME is BURNING !

SOROS
PUTIN
HUGO
Bin Laden
etc. are laughing their heads ofF::: celebrating: at Obama's 100 bucks a lb. all night Razzle Dazzle parties:

THEIR MAIN MAN Obama the enemy within destroyed the USA in less than 100 days without firing one shot!

The Big Scamulus Con
Excellent article Ms Byrd.

More deceit and smoke and mirrors. A "charismatic" delivery does not a good president make! That is practically the only talent the pretender has to "dazzle" the Obamabots with.

Nothing short of a massive socialistic manifesto for BIG government at the expense of that precious and rare (but already dwindling) commodity: Freedom. The pretender’s agenda will mandate government control of the lives AND minds of our children and the elderly; bookends that will trap the once productive adults in the middle to do government’s bidding while being taxed to oblivion. Nice one America!

socialism rising?
Mabe its time to vote with our rifles?
Sign Up to Post Your CommentsSign Up to Post Your Comments
If you are already registered, click here to login. Otherwise, please take a few seconds to register with Townhall.com. Once you sign up, you’ll be able to post your comments immediately, use the action center, get podcasts, and more!
Note: Fields marked with a red asterisk (*) are required.
Salutation:
First Name:
*
Last Name:
*
Email:
*
Nickname:
*
Note: Nick name will be shown when you post comments.
Address 1:
*
Address 2:
City:
*
State:
*
Zip:
*
Phone:
      
Your daily must-read of conservative columns, cartoons and news. Coulter, Sowell, Krauthammer and more.
(Bi-Weekly) We highlight the best opportunities from our partners for surveys, action items and more.