Townhall.com, Where Your Opinion Counts
Talk Radio:   Bill Bennett   Mike Gallagher   Dennis Prager   Michael Medved   Hugh Hewitt   
BREAKING NEWS  LeftArrow - Townhall.com : Conservative, Political, Republican   RightArrow - Townhall.com : Conservative, Political, Republican  
Columns, funnies & more in your inbox!
  • Check the boxes and send us your email address to receveive your free newsletter
  • Your daily must-read of conservative columns, cartoons and news. Coulter, Sowell, Krauthammer and more.
  • Townhall.com’s weekly inside scoop on what’s happening behind the scenes in the world of politics. When news breaks, we report.
  • Signup to receive the latest daily Townhall cartoons
Thursday, June 19, 2008
Lisa De Pasquale :: Townhall.com Columnist
Goodnight Moonbat
by Lisa De Pasquale
Vote on It:
Average Vote:
[+] Text [-]
 
Poll
Will the Dems' health care Christmas Present to America be an improvement or detriment to our health care system?


There are thousands of authors that would sell their souls for a positive 500-word New York Times review of their book.  No doubt that many of these authors have groundbreaking books on important issues.  Putting those aside, last Sunday the Times featured a children’s book that blatantly copies the classic Goodnight Moon.  Its purpose is bashing the Bush Administration, natch.  The Times’ Joanne Kaufman writes:

The cover of Goodnight Bush looks almost exactly like Goodnight Moon — green and orange, with an image of a window and fireplace — and uses a similar rhyme scheme. But there the thematic similarities end.

The authors, Erich Origen and Gan Golan, set their story in “a situation room.” There is no bunny snuggling into bed, but rather George W. Bush grinning and wearing a “Mission Accomplished” flight suit. Instead of three little bears sitting on chairs, there are “war profiteers giving three cheers.”

Goodnight Bush’s publisher told the Times, “[T]his had so many brilliant gags. You could spend so much time looking page by page.”

It’s amazing what passes for “brilliant” in leftists’ circles.  These authors must have honed their skills in college by making “Bush is Hitler!” placards.  The authors’ gags include a clock permanently set on 9:11, a copy of the Constitution that’s been written over in crayon, “a tiny scurrying Osama bin Laden” in place of the mouse that runs around throughout Goodnight Moon, and an “Ohio 2004” ballot box burning in the fireplace. 

The text is just as subtle:

Goodnight Constitution. And goodnight evolution.

Goodnight old growth trees. Goodnight detainees.

Obviously, Goodnight Bush is meant for childish liberals rather than children.  Accolades from the media are numerous and nauseating.  The San Francisco Chronicle purrs, “Goodnight Bush stands to become a popular American political parody.” 

Salon.com coos, “Seldom have an administration's failings been set to such a lulling cadence.”  Of course, one would expect Goodnight Clinton to be wrapped in plastic and sold in the back of the store with a “Sexually Explicit Material” warning label (or widely available in America’s public schools).

A blogger for The Village Voice writes, “Cute illustrations abound: a refinery plume, piggy war profiteers, a spilt glass of water with Katrina victims floating in it.  The text is warm and fuzzy — not as fuzzy as Bush's brain but warmer than Cheney's heart.”

In the month between the San Francisco Chronicle and New York Times articles, Goodnight Bush jumped from #507 to #57 as of this week.  Apparently, liberals have an easier time reading a 48-page children’s book because there are dozens and dozens of unsuccessful Bush-bashing books collecting dust. 

There are several “children’s books” parodying the genre and bashing the Bush administration.  Young Dick Cheney (150 pages) boasts that it is “a wickedly funny faux-children’s biography recounts Young Dick Cheney’s youthful lust for guns, oil, and the girl of his dreams.”  Intellectual giant Phil Donahue says it’s “a big hoot.”  Arianna Huffington says the book “pries back the door on our secretive Vice President.”  The only thing more secret is Arianna’s electric bill.

Yiddish with George and Laura (112 pages) “invades the ultimate bastion of American WASP culture: Kennebunkport, home of the Bush clan.”  For the supposed purpose of teaching Yiddish terms, the authors write about Laura Bush finding a baby in the woods and George Bush telling her to throw it back.  In another scene, brother Neil Bush asks, “But what if a child does get left behind?”  “‘Then he can join the Army,’ says George.” 

Other “progressive” children’s books include:

George W. Bush Coloring Book (24 pages)

Pat Robertson and Friends Coloring Book (28 pages) – “fundamentalists, politicians, journalists and criminals… meet them all in this easy-to-understand guide to the world of Pat Robertson”

My First Presidency: A Scrapbook by George W. Bush (68 pages)

Punch Out the President (and Pals!): A Paper Doll Book Starring W. and Friends (32 pages)

At an average of 71 pages, it’s no surprise that so many pathetic liberal authors gravitate to the children’s genre.  No footnotes are needed because they make the same statements found in the DailyKos comments section.  Bush is dumb!  Halliburton!  Impeach Cheney!  Diebold!  9-11 was an inside job!

As the end of the George W. Bush presidency nears, one wonders what will become of all the leftists who have made a living bashing the President and the Vice President with colorful pictures and words.  I suppose they’ll just go back to their cushy jobs at America’s colleges and universities.  Or perhaps they’ll butcher another classic and pen Paddington Bares It All for PETA or The Little Engine That Could – Thanks to Affirmative Action.

Share:
Vote on It:
Average Vote:
 
About The Author

Lisa De Pasquale is CPAC Director at the American Conservative Union. The Conservative Political Action Conference (CPAC) is the nation’s largest annual gathering of conservatives. For more information, visit www.cpac.org. To read Lisa's blog, visit www.thelotusblog.com

Be the first to read Lisa De Pasquale's column. Sign up today and receive Townhall.com delivered each morning to your inbox.

Two Words
Animal. Farm.

Conservatives don't need faux-children's lit, because the classic was written once and for all.

What is This Woman Whining About?
Seriously? For someone who thinks Anne the Man Coulter is the height of sophisticated satire, DiPasquale sure has a hard time taking as much as she dishes out.

DO you need a tissue to dry those tears?

Animal Farm
The words were too big.

Huh?
A libs book that says "Goodbye Constitution," referring to Republicans? There's a good joke.

Liberals said goodbye to the Constitution a long time ago. It wasn't good enough for them--they like Marx's writings better (and I don't mean Groucho).

I Wonder
I wonder if someone wrote one criticizing the left if it would get the same glowing reviews?

Actually, no need to wonder. PJ O'Rourke is funny, Al Franken is not. Which gets good reviews in the press? I wonder why.

Liberals
just can't get over the facts that Bill Clinton was impeached and Al Gore lost the 2000 election.

By the way
Al's politics have nothing to do with not finding him funny.

Way back ion the late 70's when "Franken and Davis" did short films that showed in the middle of Saturday Night Live, the beginning of a Franken and Davis film was always the time to go get a drink or use the bathroom.

Long before I knew anything about his political positions, I found Al Franken a dreadful bore.

conservatives write this stuff too.
This isn't that different than the conservative "Help! Mom!" series of books so I don't get what the problem is.

Rules For Radicals
What this libs are doing here is classic Saul Alinsky. If you read Alinsky's Rules for Radicals, a lot of what has been happening became clear. Alinsky's rule #13 is -- "Pick the target, freeze it, personalize it and polarize it".

George Bush has been chosen as the target. The radicals have enlisted the liberal press to freeze on the Bush target, personalize the attacks (chimpy, Bush Hitler, Bush lied/people died) and to go on and on. The strategy has been quite successful over the last eight years.

Oh, by the way, Obama was trained by the Industrial Areas Foundation, which was founded by Mr. Alinsky. If you want to understand Obama's campaign strategy and a lot of what is going on in the liberal world that does not seem to make sense -- read Rules for Radicals. If you want to develop an effective counter to Mr. Obama, read "Rules".

How are the libs going to defeat terror?
Ask them that question as they make Bush the enemy of the world. Get ready for some child like answers from these idiots.

if you have children and you let them buy into liberal BS you are a horrible parent.

andrews
out of curiosity I looked up the New York Times review of O'Rourke's latest book. It turns out it is pretty glowing. Or was your point that Franken is the one who gets bad reviews? I am not sure that is true either.


On the column
The column leads to an interesting question that came up with the Shapiro column yesterday. Why are conservatives not capable of producing clever people the way that liberals are?

(Even O'Rourke became clever back when he was a liberal and was writing stuff for the National Lampoon that would make Al Franken blush).

This Goodnight Bush seems to get its praise from the care with details. Goodnight Moon has a particular notable style, and the authors have worked with every detail while keeping the overall image recongizable.

The conservative reaction seems to be to just flatly hurl insults back. In a country with as many conservatives as liberals, there would seem to be as good a market for conservative satire as liberal. Conservatives have no trouble selling books that simply hurl insults at liberals in the Limbaugh mode. So why are you so bad at satire? O'Rourke stands out as an exception because he stands out so much.

Right can't take it
Plainly, people on the Right can't take even the most inane send-ups without having some sort of mess in their diapers. Conservatives indulge in satire and idiotic parody, as a couple of readers have noted. Is Ms. De Pasquale's point that Bush and his presidency are beyond any sort of criticism at all? Looks like that's what she wants to say. I wonder what she thinks of Pat Buchanan and other conservatives who've been denouncing the war since day one. Probably thinks they're all leftist pinko tree-hugging gay-loving, commie-embracing drug-abusing pro PC, constitution-bashing atheistic (I could go on, but I won't)enemies of the people.

Having said all of that, I'm appalled at some leftist weenie (see? I don't like everything done by my fellow liberals) ripping off a classic I read to my kids. There are other, better ways to express a critical opinion.

What right wing whack jobs (see? I can still insult y'all) like De Pasquale really don't like is the very existence of anything that questions their love for Bush and the Bushies.

Obama-Messiah on Iraq War
We can't let the American soldiers win the war in Iraq because it would hurt our 'collective' power grab.

NEWSFLASH: Many members in the MSM are seeking relief for depression because of the reports that the American soldiers are winning the war in Iraq.

Obama-Messiah will do his best to ensure that America will lose the war against terrorism to bring 'Hope' to Democrats and the MSM.

Obama-Messiah wants the Democrats and the MSM to concentrate on leg shivers and involuntary orgasms to ease the pain and depression of the American soldiers winning the war in Iraq - SCOTUS applauds the Obama-Messiah effort.

*Free tin foil hat fitting for everyone voting for Obama-Messiah.

Scotch Indian
Please forward that post to McCain's campaign people. They might find a clue.

Retired Squeak
"*Free tin foil hat fitting for everyone voting for Obama-Messiah"

the irony...

LIBS READ MORE BOOKS
Remember that news flash? Now we know what kind of 'literature' they are reading. No wonder they read more books than we do. They're all 70 pages long.

Boom Baby Moon
I have a really funny book called "Boom Baby Moon" which is also a send-up of the stupefyingly boring Goodnight Moon -- only it is all about Product Placement. It's humour for the Sex and the City crowd.

By the way, if you are the kind of parent who actually reads this crapola to your kids instead of reading them Kipling, its no wonder your kids are lumpen.

The Truth..
Hurts, huh Ms. Lisa???

The left can't write satire
They simply try too hard. It comes across desperate and childishly obvious. Stephen Colbert mirrors some of the overdone satire I engaged in as a high school student.

Liberals are historically inept at humor. Even Jonathan Swift's prose is too exaggerated to be funny.

For satire, Mark Twain is still king, and pretty conservative too.

Audi
Thank you for mentioning Kipling. Great author and poet.

The Fountainhead
This reminds me of Ayn Rand's book, The Fountainhead.

One sub story was about medicore and untalented writers and artists giving each other praise to no end. They were made popular by the very columnist who wrote how wonderful they were, knowing very well it was tripe and a lie.

Seems not only are we becoming Atlas Shrugged, but we've become The Fountainhead as well.

Ayn was pretty sharp.

Shells
That is an excellent book. Rand is wonderful.

The subplot shows the "Emporers New Clothes" methods of modern intelligenstia.

Sophie
Don't dismiss Fox News' comedians until you've watched "Red Eye with Greg Gutfield". I'm serious about this. You'll love it.

"PMSNBC" is not much worse than "General Betray Us".

Stewart is mostly funny, although his emotions show through on occasion.

Colbert is like an angry young teenager: overly obvious, obnoxious, and blatant. He lacks any subtlety in his satire. He's the equivalent of a bar bully wildly swinging his fists only to get knocked out cold by the first foe who can fight back.

Please watch an episode of "Red Eye". The humor transcends petty politics. If you disagree you can nail me when we next cross paths.

Childish behaviour
Whenever a debater gets stuck for reason and truth, out come the personnel insults. Do Conservatives do it, sure, but not with such immaturity as the "Bush is respondsible for (fill in disaster of your choice)" crowd. As a Conservative, I have become displeased with the GOP and its leftward direction. That said, I am thoroughly repulsed by the vindictive and childish obsession of the Far Left Democrat party with the villification of all things conservative. What are you afraid of Mr. Obama? Mrs. Clinton? Mr.& Ms. Kennedy? et.al.? A nation of people who think for themselves, and reject the theory that big intrusive government is the answer to All? I pity you, for you have forgotten how power corrupts anyone who has it .... even the Democrat party.

JimP
Yeah, and half of those 70 pages are pictures. These authors know their audience very well.

Maximilian
Are you saying we should eat Stephen Colbert?

Satire
What makes satire is the element of truth that runs through it. The problem with liberal/leftist satire about the current administration or the right wing is that it's all based on lies and false preconceptions.

That's what we're distressed about.

God knows, there's enough true stuff about us to make fun of. The libs aren't smart enough to see what that is.

Yawn - another boring left-wing diatribe
The most wretched shortcoming of this book is that it violates the first rule of satire – that it must be based in truth. There appears to be none of that here. There is only the same fact-free hate speech that anyone can get by tuning in to Stewart, Uberdork, Colbert, or most of the commentators on DNC-NN.

Oh yes, and the humor seems to be about as sharp as a rubber ball. Any Paul Shanklin song/sketch that is heard on Rush would send this crybaby piece of tripe running to its mama from embarrassment.

Satire needs Truth
Why didn't Jenna Bush have a dove release at her wedding? She knew Dick Cheney would be attending and didn't want to take any chances.

Even Dick Cheney would think that was funny. Certainly my conservative friends do. Conservatives are secure enough in their own identity they can laugh at themselves.

Lon
"Why are conservatives not capable of producing clever people the way that liberals are?"

Lon,
I don't think clever describes liberal humour. Most liberal humour comes off (to me, anyway) as sophmoric. Satire such as Goodnight Bush is just one example. If the liberal intelligentsia are such sophisticates that wouldn't have gotten so irritated by the lampooning of liberals by the likes of Beavis and Butthead or South Park (again sophmoric humour directed both ways, but the MSM now has declared the creators of B&B and South Park "right-wingers").

Most of the humour from our liberal humorists are profaine, jeuvinille, and shallow.( It's all so "epater les bourgeiosie")Conservatives normally just ignore these people as they would ignore a 13 year old throwing a temper tantrum.
Sign Up to Post Your CommentsSign Up to Post Your Comments
If you are already registered, click here to login. Otherwise, please take a few seconds to register with Townhall.com. Once you sign up, you’ll be able to post your comments immediately, use the action center, get podcasts, and more!
Note: Fields marked with a red asterisk (*) are required.
Salutation:
First Name:
*
Last Name:
*
Email:
*
Nickname:
*
Note: Nick name will be shown when you post comments.
Address 1:
*
Address 2:
City:
*
State:
*
Zip:
*
Phone:
      
Your daily must-read of conservative columns, cartoons and news. Coulter, Sowell, Krauthammer and more.
(Bi-Weekly) We highlight the best opportunities from our partners for surveys, action items and more.