Townhall.com, Where Your Opinion Counts
Talk Radio:   Bill Bennett   Mike Gallagher   Dennis Prager   Michael Medved   Hugh Hewitt   
BREAKING NEWS  LeftArrow - Townhall.com : Conservative, Political, Republican   RightArrow - Townhall.com : Conservative, Political, Republican  
Columns, funnies & more in your inbox!
  • Check the boxes and send us your email address to receveive your free newsletter
  • Your daily must-read of conservative columns, cartoons and news. Coulter, Sowell, Krauthammer and more.
  • Townhall.com’s weekly inside scoop on what’s happening behind the scenes in the world of politics. When news breaks, we report.
  • Signup to receive the latest daily Townhall cartoons
Friday, August 24, 2007
Linda Chavez :: Townhall.com Columnist
All the Pretty Horses
by Linda Chavez
Vote on It:
Average Vote:
[+] Text [-]
 
Poll
Was the Copenhagen Global Warming Summit Walk-Out a Win for the U.S.?


I had put off reading Cormac McCarthy's "All the Pretty Horses" for years, having picked it up when it first came out in paperback in 1993. But a Colorado vacation seemed a perfect time to take it up again. There's something satisfying about reading a book in sync with the locale where I happen to be.

Part of the book's appeal is simply that it is an adventure story, the tale of three young men -- boys, really -- who set off on horseback from west Texas in the late 1940s, seeking to recapture in Mexico a way of life fast disappearing north of the border. Instead they encounter a world so full of contradictions it destroys one of them, and nearly so the other two.

The Mexico McCarthy describes is a place of unspeakable cruelty, rigid convention and misplaced honor. It is a place where men can land in jail simply for being in the wrong place at the wrong time, and where obtaining justice depends on whom you know, not what you've done.

But it is also a country where the young men find incredible generosity and kindness -- poor Mexicans who are willing to share their meager food and abodes with strangers, even to give them, literally, the shirts off their backs. McCarthy's Mexicans are both villains and heroes, intellectuals and peasants.

But in the end, it isn't the adventure or the characters that makes this book so mesmerizing. It is McCarthy's ability to capture a sense of place.

The Southwest has for generations sparked the imagination of Americans. Even today, when skyscraper cities have sprung up on the plains where people make their living sitting at keyboards rather than on saddleback, the land itself remains wide-open, wild and vast.

The beauty of the land is stark, often harsh. There are few green, rolling hills, but jagged cliffs that jut out from the sage-covered brush, remnants of long-dead volcanoes, and earth the color of dried blood.

It does not look hospitable, which may be why it is so quintessentially American. Certainly in the early years, eking out a living in a land so arid made for an unimaginable challenge.

I think back on my own ancestors and wonder how they managed -- my father's family arriving more than 400 years ago in northern New Mexico from a similarly unforgiving landscape in Estremadura, Spain; my mother's family coming to Wyoming by wagon train from Missouri not long after the Civil War. Yet, like thousands of others, they tamed the land and recreated themselves.

Today, it is still possible to see in the land itself something of its past. Driving west along Route 40 high in the Colorado Rockies last week, I saw a herd of horses, some 40 or 50 head, that looked as if they had just descended, wild and free, from Byers Canyon above. There were overos, palominos, chestnuts and pure blacks, running against a classic Southwestern cerulean sky with cumulus clouds that dwarfed even the mountain ranges in the background.

There are few more enduring archetypes than the American cowboy. Certainly McCarthy's ability to conjure up a world in which men still ride on the backs of magnificent beasts trying to master a natural world that is both alluring and hostile has made him one of America's most popular literary figures.

But as the Southwestern landscape retreats, as suburbs encroach on the range, as fewer and fewer people know what it is to tackle nature head-on, what will happen to the cowboy tale? Perhaps this generation will be the last to come across boys like Jimmy Blevins or John Grady Cole or to see all the pretty horses running free, and all that will remain is a collective memory evoked by writers like Cormac McCarthy.

Share:
Vote on It:
Average Vote:
 
About The Author

Linda Chavez is chairman of the Center for Equal Opportunity and author of Betrayal: How Union Bosses Shake Down Their Members and Corrupt American Politics .

Be the first to read Linda Chavez's column. Sign up today and receive Townhall.com delivered each morning to your inbox.

©Creators Syndicate
Well, I'm always grateful...
--
...for a review (no matter how holographic) of a "mainstream" novel I wouldn't touch with tongs suitable for handling radioactive waste.

In reciprocity, I recommend to Ms. Chavez a novel centering on yet another charcter drawn from the American Southwest, written by staunch constitutionalists Aaron Zelman and L. Neil Smith.

The title of the novel is *Hope* (published in 2001, and still in print).

"*Hope* is the story of Alexander Hope, a young American who comes back from Vietnam, falls in love with a bright, beautiful girl, and with her starts a pioneering computer business. Thirty years later he's a billionaire, and alone in life. He decides to leave everything he created behind to write books and teach history at a private college.

"Almost as a joke, Alex allows a handful of admiring students to enlist him as a candidate for a third party Presidential nomination. His brief campaign rests on a single promise: to enforce the first ten amendments to the U.S. Constitution -- commonly known as the Bill of Rights -- exactly like the highest law of the land they happen to be. And in a series of astonishing but perfectly plausible political events, he's amazed to discover that he's headed for 1600 Pennsylvania Avenue."

A wonderful bit of speculation predicated upon an upbeat message that any true conservative will read with delight.
--



Novel
I read the novel as well years ago but parts were unreadable due to McCarthy's foolish decision to write Spanish-speakers conversations in Spanish without translation. Like most Americans, I refuse to learn Spanish. Therefore, I can't really say that there weren't any decent Mexicans in the novel. However, from what I could discern about the novel was that Mexico is a violent, anarchic and lawless place filled with rotten people.

Thanks, SJ
I was looking for a good read.

Ed Abbey
The westerns of Edward Abbey are great reads, especially Brave Cowboy (source of the Kirk Douglas movie Lonely Are the Brave) and The Monkey-Wrench Gang.

Another imbecile bigot on Townhall
Dereck Leaberry proves yet again that he is part of the Townhall Bigot's Club, claiming that Mexico is "filled with Rotten people."

What an absolute moron this guy must be. I feel sorry for his parents.

Thanks...
... I needed this reminder of what's important and how I need to continue forward with my dream of creating a place in the Southwest where the cowboy life is honoured and perpetuated. Thank you for the boost I needed. Odd place to find it, but God works in mysterious ways.

Did you
ever read the book? The protagonists of All the Pretty Horses went through a nightmare.

The Southwest
Ms. Chavez is right to commend the the American southwest's beauty. I have seen many wondrous parts of the world from Alaska to Antarctica. The southwest, especially Arizona, remains my favorite region.

Those who have yet to visit Arizona should do so as soon as their schedule and finances allow. See as much of the state as possible. The experience will prove life-changing as Arizona is arguably the most beautiful place on Earth.

Napoleanic Law....
...or Continental Law is Mexico's curse. It has some of its roots in the harsh justice of Moorish Spain. It's why Mexico is so poor and, by English Common Law, America is so rich.

"The Mexico McCarthy describes is a place of unspeakable cruelty, rigid convention and misplaced honor. It is a place where men can land in jail simply for being in the wrong place at the wrong time, and where obtaining justice depends on whom you know, not what you've done."

Mexico needs to rid itself of its system of Napoleonic Law, that is: "If you are arrested then you must be guilty", with the English Common Law concept of "innocent until proven (by the state) guilty".

The English and Spanish language are not the greatest barrier to Mexico-American relations, it is the traditional legal system of Mexico. Reform is not likely however, because it keeps the powerful of Mexico in their positions as does oil keep the sheiks of the Middle East in theirs.

As for cowboys in the USA? Like George Bush, they drive pickups with automatic transmissions (what's a clutch? Carl?), air conditioning, and a cup holder with a bottle of Evion in the console. I doubt if "W" knows what a cinch, a Cheyenne Roll or founder is. #43 is a "Pace Picante Sauce, MADE-IN-NEW-YORK-CITY", kinda cowboy. All hat, no cattle.

Cowboy Georgie
Bush is as much a cowboy as John Travolta or Jon Voight.

As for Mexican justice, it was once called in Diaz's time Justice of the Graveyard. With some modifications, that is still how Mexico handles its justice. Mexican police are some of the most corrupt in the world.

I do speak and read Spanish
Not well, but well enough that I got through the Spanish parts of the novel (with a lot of help from the Spanish-English dictionary). I do remember some of the descriptive scenes as extremely well-written (as a writer, I notice these things). Throughout reading it, I kept shaking my head at the naivete of the main characters and the manipulativeness of the author. He writes his poor people as saints. We all know that not every poor person is a saint. He writes all his government officials as corrupt. Most probably are, but all of them? Doubtful.

It's been several years now since I read the novel, but my feeling was it was a travelogue by someone who had an agenda -- or really was so naive as to think all savages are noble. I ended up feeling as if I had wasted my time, which I consider to be a true crime when I'm in the mood to read a good book.

The Road
Far better than Pretty Horses and well deserved of the Pulitzer it won for fiction. Read it in a weekend, recommend it to all.
If you have a young son (6-9 years old) and ANY even slight interest in post apocalyptic fiction (A Canticle For Liebowitz etc.) buy it today!

Off-Putting in the Extreme
"But as the Southwestern landscape retreats, as suburbs encroach on the range, as fewer and fewer people know what it is to tackle nature head-on, what will happen to the cowboy tale?"

I live in Texas cowboy country, and the only reason the range is disappearing is because of the immigration policies advocated by you, Ms Chavez. Most of my neighbors aren't farmers or ranchers, but people trying to flee from cities they no longer recognize as being part of America.

aurorawatcher
Sounds like you took it a little personally.
McCarthy often "manipulates" his audience during the immediate reading of his work and upon reflection. That's the mark of a good writer,(I notice these things as a reader).
I'm sure that I read the same story but, I didn't sense any "agenda". Your assessments read like a panoptic criticism of Cormac McCarthy's work. You sound jealous.

Odd, a member of the cheap labor lobby
As a consistent member of the cheap labor lobby which wants to flood the country with unlimited poverty stricken uneducated migrants, it is odd that Chavez waxes poetic and bitter-sweet about a lifestyle and a landscape that were only possible before people like her decided to wreck it against the overwhelming wishes of the vast majority of the American people who she thinks are motivated by bigotry.

Another one check mark.

JackBenimble is a doooooche bag
Seriously, this guy must be the BIGGEST loser on the face of the earth.

Do the words "get a life" mean anything to you?


On my list
I saw the movie when it first came out, but have never read the book. But I'll put it on my list of books to read. I would defintly have to get a spanish english dictionary though, considering I took french in high school.
Sign Up to Post Your CommentsSign Up to Post Your Comments
If you are already registered, click here to login. Otherwise, please take a few seconds to register with Townhall.com. Once you sign up, you’ll be able to post your comments immediately, use the action center, get podcasts, and more!
Note: Fields marked with a red asterisk (*) are required.
Salutation:
First Name:
*
Last Name:
*
Email:
*
Nickname:
*
Note: Nick name will be shown when you post comments.
Address 1:
*
Address 2:
City:
*
State:
*
Zip:
*
Phone:
      
Your daily must-read of conservative columns, cartoons and news. Coulter, Sowell, Krauthammer and more.
(Bi-Weekly) We highlight the best opportunities from our partners for surveys, action items and more.