Townhall.com, Where Your Opinion Counts
Talk Radio:   Bill Bennett   Mike Gallagher   Dennis Prager   Michael Medved   Hugh Hewitt   
BREAKING NEWS  LeftArrow - Townhall.com : Conservative, Political, Republican   RightArrow - Townhall.com : Conservative, Political, Republican  
Columns, funnies & more in your inbox!
  • Check the boxes and send us your email address to receveive your free newsletter
  • Your daily must-read of conservative columns, cartoons and news. Coulter, Sowell, Krauthammer and more.
  • Townhall.com’s weekly inside scoop on what’s happening behind the scenes in the world of politics. When news breaks, we report.
  • Signup to receive the latest daily Townhall cartoons
Monday, November 12, 2007
Lee  Culpepper :: Townhall.com Columnist
The Comprehensive-Universal-Body-Parts Solution
by Lee Culpepper
Vote on It:
Average Vote:
[+] Text [-]
 
Poll
Will the Dems' health care Christmas Present to America be an improvement or detriment to our health care system?


Americans have grown cynical of the political quagmire inside Washington’s Beltway. Non-stop bickering over illegal immigration, healthcare, unemployment, abortion, public education, stem-cell research, prison capacity, and more has left every conscientious American yearning for better results. However, our quibbling politicians seem to succeed only at letting us down. They brazenly promote self-centered agendas versus honoring their oaths to serve regular Americans like you and me.

Meanwhile, you and I encounter governmental failures every day. Poor citizens and non-documented aliens live in deplorable conditions that can stir sorrow in the most pitiless and greedy among us. Ill-fated gang bangers and drug addicts commit senseless crimes that can rouse a modicum of aggression even from model pacifists like Cindy Sheehan. Worse, the outrageous costs and abuses of the world’s finest healthcare system have finally been exposed (thanks to Michael Moore and his spellbinding documentary Sicko). But that’s not all; our advancements in medical science and laws protecting abortion suggest that impeding the progress of stem-cell research may no longer make sense.

Then there is our job market. Sure, America’s unemployment rate remains incredibly low, but no one can argue that idle Americans do not exist. Those Americans averse to working (in jobs illegal workers gladly accept) simply need more opportunities with better incentives. Our law-abiding-illegal workforce would likely welcome additional opportunities, as well.

On top of these problems, public education remains a disaster, despite our flushing more money down its system than ever before. Leading politicians, teacher-union spokesmen, and education gurus forever insist on wasting more of our money without producing positive results.

The problems in Washington’s often lie in the convoluted thinking behind legislative good intensions. However, all hope is not lost. Sunday night the National Geographic Channel may have unveiled a real answer to these problems in Lisa Ling’s documentary about the world’s thriving black market for human body parts. Just imagine how American competition could perfect this industry while curing many of our society’s afflictions. We simply need to make it legal.

Our politicians should remove the tolls and barriers that encumber what we could entitle The Comprehensive-Universal-Body-Parts Solution. It’s a bipartisan plan that would offer something to everyone. First, we would begin by recruiting illegal immigrants willing to harvest some of their body parts for medical research and organ transplants. Unlike a communist approach, our program would be strictly voluntary -- except for extreme criminal offenses, of course.

Sure, this proposal might seem eccentric or even extreme. However, if we could just recover from the politically correct pistol-whipping we’ve suffered over the last several decades, it would make perfect sense. Yet, even PC extremists would likely find this solution enticing.

Why? Well, legalizing this thriving, black-market would definitely strike a surge in America’s Gross Domestic Product. The distribution channel would create a plethora of new jobs. Our leading healthcare system would advance, but more importantly, healthcare costs would drop as participation increased.

It’s basic economics really: supply and demand. Currently demand exceeds supply, but legalizing the market would open tremendous opportunities for new suppliers.

One significantly positive outcome would be that our struggling hospitals along our southern border (which currently provide much of the free healthcare to illegal immigrants) would probably benefit the most financially. They would likely become the industry’s wholesale suppliers -- exactly the shot in the arm those hospitals need.

Imagine the possibilities. How much would a wealthy, blind American spend for a perfectly good eyeball?

Diabetes? No problem -- here’s a pancreas, but it’ll cost you.

Need a liver? Let’s haggle.

No red-blooded American would imagine deporting an illegal immigrant willing to donate a healthy kidney to an American in need. Talk about a patriotic contribution.

But this plan would not be limited to illegal immigrants by any means. As the industry grew, the economic incentive to market newborn organs might convince American women of all classes to stop considering abortions. Of course an operation would be a lot for a little tike to undergo, but the hardship of a surgery would be far less traumatic than any abortion would be. Plus, at $250,000 for a kidney, that’s a tantalizing reward for anyone to save more than one human life. In fact, with the right financial incentives, the phrase “unwanted pregnancy” would become an oxymoron.

Our education system would also flourish. Getting Grandma to part with a lung would certainly provide ample profit to send Junior to private school. Eventually, significantly less money would be wasted on public schools because the campuses would be deserted – that is until private schools and other businesses bought or leased the properties.

The benefits seem endless really. With all the spare parts that would eventually be lying around, embryonic-stem-cell research would become yesterday’s science.

To resolve prison overcrowding, we could easily create more space by harvesting the vital organs from death-row inmates. Talk about a common sense approach. Those murderers would truly do something to pay for their crimes. And they would no longer siphon money from innocent taxpayers forced to keep them alive. For those killers who join the program with high cholesterol or weight issues, well, we would simply put them on a rigorous workout and diet schedule until they were healthy again, and then it would be off to see the surgeon.

To finance deporting terrorists and other criminal aliens, we could allow them to choose the body part they want to donate to a needy American. It would be a win-win situation.

Finally, just consider all the tax revenue this would create. Name a politician who wouldn’t love that.

I’m sure Republicans and Democrats will clearly see the significant amount of common ground this solution offers both parties. It’s literally time to come together, America, so contact your representatives today!

Share:
Vote on It:
Average Vote:
 
About The Author

Lee Culpepper is a former Marine and high school English teacher. He is currently working to complete his first book, Alone and Unafraid: One Marine’s Counterattack Inside the Walls of Public Education. Visit Lee’s website at www.leeculpepper.com.

Be the first to read Lee Culpepper’s column.
Sign up today and receive Townhall.com delivered each morning to your inbox.
Sign up today
Infant organs in lieu of abortions!
Sick, sick, sick!

Wonder
who would want Hillary's thighs....ugh?

Pending
I suppose this is subject to el-Heiress Hillary's approval.

Thank you, Mr. Lee
I think you're on to something. The unfairly maligned Dr. Frankenstein has finally been rehabilitated.

What's not to like: Hillarycare, and a Dr. Mengela clone in charge of every hospital. Don't worry about authorizations - those will be handled by our excellent staff headed by the ever efficient Igor. BTW, he handles the organ bank - one of the best supplied for miles.

As the good doctor has stated, 'there is no death until I declare it so'.

You may check in but don't make any premature arrangements for checking out. And don't worry about a thing - there will be no charge for any services.

Exactly-kinda
Perhaps we all just be able to sell our organs to anyone we want at anytime? It's supply and demand. Alexander Tabarrok, professor at George Mason, has done much work on this subject.

Here come the religious who are opposed to it for "moral" reasons . . .

Hillary and thigh transplants...
No wonder so many dems are for amnesty! This really is a bipartisan plan.

Ah, back to the Roman Empire...
...When the value of life was whatever entertainment value could be derived from it.

Given the current political/economic climate and the direction We The People are heading in our quest to find out collectively how deep in debt we can go, who is to say that it won't be Americans that provide parts for the Saudis, Chinese, Europeans and any other people we so deeply owe.

Also, consistent with history, the Party Members will be the brokers/receivers while those deemed "expendable" politically speaking (that would be Christians and Producers) would be the ones served up for the sacrifice.

If it were put to the vote, and the UN and International courts decided who needs what from whom, I think we all know where Americans would fit in.

Grandma's lung for private school
I think it could work!

Would a Saudi pay $250K for a newborn
American kidney? This is a great proposal.

Like Swift's A Modest Proposal
Well done.

Socialized Healthcare
From each according to their abilities (parts available) to each according their budget.

Market vs Ethics
We are now in territory where it's impossible to discern satire from reality. There IS a free-market argument for selling-organs to the highest bidder---I've read three articles about it in the past week. Why stop there? Wait to turn off Grandma's life support until an auction sale to the highest bidder can be held for Grandma-Parts. And, hey, the poor could conceive and bear infants for an eager adoption market .

If market is never wrong, and the only social responsibility of market is to bring profit, then, at some point, ethics are just bothersome.

Lilly, public sector does not ensure
adherence to ethical standards. Like thousands of others I have chronic Lyme, which the CDC refuses to recognize and treat. Despite the staggering amount of research information and countless personal testimonies (ruined lives), proper treatment is only available through private Lyme literate physicians. Canadian Lyme patients often come here for treatment, and we are all terrified of socialized medicine because our docs WILL lose their licenses and long term antibiotics (which kept me off of permanent disability) will no longer be available. How ethical is that?

See the work of Dr.Scott Taylor, "A Plague of Ignorance and Ignorance of a Plague" if you want to look into this further. Once health care becomes a closed system, ignorance and mediocrity abound without alternatives for patients.

Satire???
OK, I admit it, I'm a moron...is this for real or is it satire? I'm reading it as satire and I sure hope I'm correct. Anybody?

gkriadis
Fear not, its satire.

We could also use this approach to ...
Feed the poor by producing soylent green from the homeless. Also from all those on Death Row after the useful organs have been harvested, we trun em into burger meat.

Once the UN gets involved all those loons who believe in Christ will also get fed into the grinder, after harvesting the useful parts, of course.

No more hungry or uninsured. If you are one or the other you get to solve one or both. The only trick is all those who do not wish to participate. Such selfishness needs to be weeded out ruthlessly of course.

Burger anyone?

I would rather die...
...than receive a kidney from Charles Manson.

I have this vision...
...of the government collecting the names of drivers with licenses that display the orange sticker *organ donor*. These are kept in a file. When a certain organ is needed the new 'organ procurement department' at the DMV will spring into action causing car crashes and making them look like accidents.

Just the thought of anyone at the DMV 'springing into action' makes me LOL.

oldsocialworker is right though, if healthcare becomes a closed system there is no limit to how unethical it will become.

Excellent satire
Can you please run for public office?

Charles Manson's organs...
I don't think Chuck is on death row. You should be good to go. JK

oldsocialworker
So sorry to hear about the Lyme's.

We were put on high alert 10 years ago in central New Jersey.

I'll put you in my prayers.

My body parts?
Giggle,snort,tee-hee.

Hey anybody that wants to cough up the bucks to harvest my parts on the way out, feel free.

My heirs would be thrilled!

The lungs have had a lifetime exposure to Lucky Strike non-filter.

The liver has had some really top-shelf winerum and single malt scotch.

Aside from that, make me an offer.

Not much difference
is it really, from stem cell research -- save that you can recognize the bodies whose organs you *harvest* and you really do not have to see the bodies of the stem cell *donors* ...

It will come to that some day. People are becoming increasingly resistant to charity, and increasingly uninterested in their neighbours (name any of your neighbours, bet you cannot) and concerned only with themselves and their own children. It will be sooner than you think when *for the Good of All* includes the *equitable* sharing of body parts by government fiat. In fact, think of the continuing drumbeat that property is wrong and parents have no right to their children ... isnt that really the prelude to making everything and everyone fungible?

think about it.

Quick edit!
You wrote, "They brazenly promote self-centered agendas versus honoring their oaths to serve regular Americans like you and me."

My edit would have read, "They brazenly promote self-centered agendas versus honoring their oaths to serve regular Americans like you and I [are]."

Fire your editor who has nothing more than a third-grade education.

Body parts....
How many fell into the honeytrap?

Good satire, but a good idea also
Good satire, but actually the idea of a free market is valid no funny.

If we could sell body parts, such would become an asset that could be used as collateral at the bank or gifted in a will.

People don't donate parts because there is no incentive. If you could go to the bank today and borrow $100K on body parts and have an insurance company guarantee the loan, people would all have wills regarding their body parts. There would be plenty of supply, and none harmed. Our problem is giver-ment is trying to circumvent the market place and

Deskjockey...
Might also result in a lot of mercy killing.

Rick's grammar lesson
would ruin the "folksy effect" the writer has established. It would also interfere with the sentence's rhythm.

An A for regurgitating grammar rules, but an F for literary analysis.

Another English Teacher

This satire is no Swift or Bastiat
Kadima writes:

"I would rather die than receive a kidney from Charles Manson."

That is your choice, spoken as a hypothetical. If you were dying, on dialysis, in a seven-year queue with two years max to live, you might think differently.

Unfortunately, however, it is not my choice to act on a different opinion from yours. I would gladly take Manson's kidney so that I could watch my children blossom and their progeny enter this world.

Let's hear it for a well-regulated market for body parts, whether those parts originate (a) from the estates of dead folks who when living indicated their approval, (b) from live people who want to do good by making a buck, or (c) from live people who simply want to make a buck.


Say, Lilly
Did you notice how you made a reasonable post, and you got a reasonable response? Just sayin'...

turtle writes: 13, 2007 8:56 AM

Deskjockey...
Might also result in a lot of mercy killing.

I have nothing against mercy, however one should have that issue covered in their will so they are comfortable on how that issue is handled.
Sign Up to Post Your CommentsSign Up to Post Your Comments
If you are already registered, click here to login. Otherwise, please take a few seconds to register with Townhall.com. Once you sign up, you’ll be able to post your comments immediately, use the action center, get podcasts, and more!
Note: Fields marked with a red asterisk (*) are required.
Salutation:
First Name:
*
Last Name:
*
Email:
*
Nickname:
*
Note: Nick name will be shown when you post comments.
Address 1:
*
Address 2:
City:
*
State:
*
Zip:
*
Phone:
      
Your daily must-read of conservative columns, cartoons and news. Coulter, Sowell, Krauthammer and more.
(Bi-Weekly) We highlight the best opportunities from our partners for surveys, action items and more.