Townhall.com, Where Your Opinion Counts
Talk Radio:   Bill Bennett   Mike Gallagher   Dennis Prager   Michael Medved   Hugh Hewitt   
BREAKING NEWS  LeftArrow - Townhall.com : Conservative, Political, Republican   RightArrow - Townhall.com : Conservative, Political, Republican  
Columns, funnies & more in your inbox!
  • Check the boxes and send us your email address to receveive your free newsletter
  • Your daily must-read of conservative columns, cartoons and news. Coulter, Sowell, Krauthammer and more.
  • Townhall.com’s weekly inside scoop on what’s happening behind the scenes in the world of politics. When news breaks, we report.
  • Signup to receive the latest daily Townhall cartoons
Wednesday, February 11, 2009
Larry Kudlow :: Townhall.com Columnist
Is Tim Geithner Ready for Prime Time?
by Larry Kudlow
Vote on It:
Average Vote:
[+] Text [-]
 
Poll
Was the Copenhagen Global Warming Summit Walk-Out a Win for the U.S.?


The day after President Obama’s big news conference, and on the day Treasury-man Tim Geithner unveiled his Bank Bailout Nation TARP III Plan, stock markets plunged in a vote of no-confidence, with the Dow dropping nearly 400 points.

Obama got the ball rolling by painting a dismal picture of the U.S. economy, saying recovery won’t arrive until 2010 at the earliest. He then said only big-government spending can jolt our economy back to life. He also bitterly attacked supply-siders and the Bush tax cuts, especially “tax cuts that are targeted to the wealthiest few Americans.” He added that these strategies have “only helped lead us to the crisis we face right now.”

You can say a lot of things about President George W. Bush’s big-government mistakes. But blaming the Bush tax cuts for the credit-crunched downturn is utter nonsense. It’s ideological politics at its worst. (It’s worth noting that while Obama was trashing supply-siders on Monday night, Scott Rasmussen’s latest poll showed 62 percent of U.S. voters wanting the stimulus plan to include more tax cuts and less government spending.)

Later in the news conference, Obama acknowledged how businesses that suddenly couldn’t get credit pulled back on their investment and laid off workers -- workers who then cut back on their spending. That -- along with the Fed’s stop-and-go monetary policy and a huge oil shock -- is much closer to the true cause of this recession.

This is all most strange. Obama’s attack on supply-side economics would rule out the successful Kennedy-Johnson tax cuts that spurred growth in the 1960s and the Reagan tax cuts that ignited growth in the 1980s. Even Bill Clinton cut the capital-gains tax. And George W. Bush’s tax cuts helped generate a six-year economic expansion before the oil shock and credit crunch took hold.

On Tuesday morning, stocks opened down about 75 points in the wake of Obama’s pessimism. But stocks really started to tumble when Tim Geithner stepped to the microphone. He totally bombed in his debut.

Geithner had no real plan to deal with the problem of unmarketable toxic assets on bank balance sheets. He offered no new architectural structure, no good way to remove the toxic assets, no clear pricing or funding proposals, and no meat on the bones.

According to Merriam-Webster, a “plan” is “a detailed formulation of a program of action; a method for achieving an end.” But Mr. Geithner had none of this. As a result, stocks plunged about 250 points. Prominent investment strategist Ed Yardeni described Geithner as an empty suit with an empty plan.

A week earlier, ace CNBC reporter Charlie Gasparino scooped the speech by chronicling how Wall Streeters advising the Obama administration talked Geithner out of a government-backed “bad bank” that would somehow buy toxic assets to be either worked out profitably or resold to private investors. These were the same “greedy” executives that Obama and Geithner had been trashing. So now Geithner talks vaguely about some sort of public/private investment fund that will use government capital and provide financing for private investors, who are then supposed to buy toxic assets.

Nobody on Wall Street is buying it right now. Geithner said the fund might cost $1 trillion, but there’s no “there” there. No wonder bank stocks dropped 12 percent on Tuesday.

By the way, Geithner did not offer any regulatory accounting relief, such as putting an end to the disastrous mark-to-market rule that has wrecked bank capital and is one of the root causes of the whole financial problem.

Geithner did talk about an expansion of the Fed’s Term Asset-Backed Lending Facility, or TALF, to help finance consumer-loan securitization packages that provide upwards of 40 percent of all consumer and small-business lending. This might work, but again there were no details. And the Fed has yet to start its TALF operation.

Finally, Geithner talked about a comprehensive $50 billion housing-and-mortgage modification plan. But once again, no details -- especially on the controversial issue of having bankruptcy judges determine home-loan interest rates and lending totals without bank recourse to contractual obligations.

One positive comes from a New York Times story claiming that Geithner beat back Obama’s political advisers who want to nationalize big banks, fire senior bank executives, and establish heavy government controls over bank operations. But at the end of the day the absence of any clarity or pragmatic details from Mr. Geithner left stock markets sadder and poorer for the effort.

Geithner would have been better off not giving a speech until he could put real meat on the bones. What he pulled Tuesday was a classic rookie move that will further erode the public’s trust in his capabilities. Following the controversy over his late payment of taxes, this bank-plan blunder could be another nail in his coffin. Apparently, Tim Geithner is not yet ready for prime time.

Share:
Vote on It:
Average Vote:
 
About The Author

Lawrence Kudlow is host of CNBC's Kudlow & Company

Be the first to read Lawrence Kudlow's column. Sign up today and receive Townhall.com delivered each morning to your inbox.

Huh?
Tim the Tax Cheat should be in jail. Of course he is not ready for prime time; he should be doing jail time.

if only i had known
instead of paying taxes for 45 years, if i had evaded taxes, i could be treasury secretary. i would harass all politicians until they abolished the income tax, accomplishing the salvation of our nation. instead, i paid, and get to watch a tax cheat help an election cheat destroy our nation. what a difference 45 years of taxpaying makes.

Whining in Kudlow's world...
Obama was asked about the stock market 380 point dive after Geithner's NON news conference...His answer was pretty good. He mentioned that the market is looking for some solution to their problem. They want something gift wrapped that will bail them out. He's right. Kudlow dislikes Geithner. Kudlow wants all of his friends bailed out without ANY restrictions. Kudlow wants "free market" with a government backstop. Kudlows part of the disconnect between main street and wall street..."La-la la-la! la-la la-la! Kudlow's world!"

Geithner
Run this piece of Osama's Cabinet out on a rail.
Maybe I can follow his lead by not paying my taxes but only if I use the same computer program he did.
Hmmm...
I wonder if it will work for me as well......?
Stupidity. Criminal Stupidity indeed.

Magic Negro Has Got To Go.....
Our new moron-in-chief, the bi-racial, mooslim boy Barry is a laughing stock and anyone who voted for this momma's boy should be stripped of their citizenship - which will be worthless soon anyway as Comrade Barry, The Dear Leader, leads us to his Marxist Utopia.

His PR show, aka "press conference" showed how woefully inadequate Hussein is. He's a professional bullcrap artist, who has the gift of gab. He talks and talks and talks and talks, preaching and scolding in a condescending way, since he has little allegiance or love of the USA.

Mooslim boy is just that. That's why his first offical foreign call was to the Palestinian leader. That's why Mooslim boy is so concerned about the "rights" of illegal combatant terrorists.

The idiots that voted for our Marxist Millionaire are the kind of fools that live off of class envy in order to make up for their failed lives. Hate the rich, hate the successful so give power to a Marxist community organizer, who rigs elections and stirs up racial and class hatred.

Good call, you limp-wristed libs.

Our Affirmative Action President!
Hmm, let's see......a man who has never held a real private sector job in his life, is now going to preach to the nation and business especially, how much money to make and how many taxes to pay (unless he nominates them to be in his cabinet that is).

Interesting. Barry-boy has never run a hot dog stand in his life, since he lived a relatively priveledged life in private schools. He grew up around socialists, communists, moooslims, academics, etc. No wonder he has an affinity for them.

His registration as a "foreign student" due to his nebulous birthplace/citizenship helped him achieve scholoarships as well as affirmative action. How impressed I am!

Thank you media, for deciding who will be our president and lead our nation to become a European style socialist state of 50% government spending. Hey, the limp-wrist liberals, teacher unions, govt. "workers" and gay-boys in the MSM love the idea of Big Bro Government planning their lives for them.

It's free up their time so they can spend it masturbating all day long!

Like being back in the Sixties
when the people who knew how to govern at university were replaced by people whose fondest memory was peeing in the University Presidents wastebasket. All they knew how to do was shout, and when they finally moved on, they trashed the place behind them.

Not a one of these people knows how to pour p**s out of a boot with directions on the heel. This is just the beginning of a very rough two years.

Old Tom
Old Tom writes: Maybe I can follow his lead by not paying my taxes but only if I use the same computer program he did.

I used that computer program for the same years Treasury Swindler-tary Geithner did, and somehow, it insisted I owed self-employment taxes. So far as I can tell, only the Geithner 1.0 version of the software had that glitch.

What Goes Around Comes Around
Every time the Pres speaks he reenforces his position by putting the blame on the last eight years. The hate Bush mentality. No one has yet been able to tell me why? Maybe we need to take a completely different approach. Let's nominate a football team owner for President. Let's start with the management of the Green Bay Packers which is a team owned by the people. IF YOU CAN'T PERFORM, YOU GET FIRED. In hindsight maybe the best course of action would have been for Bush to fire Paulson. Who's responsibility was it to keep eyes on this guy? Certainly after the comments Paulson made about going into the sewere Bush should have fired him on the spot. Having said that, Obama hires a guy under Paulson. The Pres (coined Healer of the Nation) is suppose to have the brain power but can't see past basic budget management 101. To change direction you need to fire DEAD WOOD. I can only say that I never figured the people of this country to be so naive that they couldn't read between the lines. Promises are made to be broken, not kept. The idea of getting handouts has never been the solution. In fact it is one of the ideas that most conservatives oppose. It boils down to an honest days pay for an honest days work. SIMPLY SAID, GET OFF YOUR LAZY BACK SIDE AND GET A JOB. It's not about hand outs. How is that possible? Business who employees everyone in this country. The individual who supports that business by being responsible as an employee. So, I am afraid that many who have voted for a smooth talking Pres are going to be disappointed. How many of us know that if we leave it to government it is only going to get worse. How many times do we say that?

Tax Cuts for the Rich
Lawrence, even the Wall Street Journal has admitted on its editorial pages as well as the CBO study that W's tax cuts for the rich have accounted for at least 30% and perhaps 40% of the current federal deficit.
Hey Larry, since you and Gov.Palin love Israel so much, shouldn't you Republicans pay for the Iraq war with taxes? After all Iran is the next target for the American treasury and soliders to solve for Israel while they use our military cover to continue to brutally treated the Palestinians.

Obama said. . .
his "man" Geithner was going to show up with details. Seems that details was the one thing he didn't show up with. Less than impressive start for such a tax cheating genius too big to not be approved. I don't think any of Obama's people are ready for prime time, but they sure are good at promoting socialism in America. Maybe that's all they ever intend to do? The stock market may not be the only measure of Obama's success or failure, but he hasn't done anything to help investors I can see.

So far as I am...
concerned, confessed tax evader Geither has no business saying anything about taxes or tax cuts. In fact, he has no business being in the position to which he has been appointed. It's an insult to the tax-paying American public.

Each time he speaks, I want to hurl...

Why should we trust Geithner?
He doesn't even understand his own department. If he does, why did he underpay his taxes? The only other possibility is that he deliberately avoided them (if such is the case, he belongs in jail).

Geithner is either crooked or incompetent, so I'm not interested in anything he has to say.

differences
between a liberal and conservative.


conservative will teach you how to fish.

liberal will give you a fish




compasionate conservative - will give you a fish today and will teach you how to fish for tomorrow and beyond.

looney lib - will give you someone else's fish, and ban the use of hooks, ban the use of boat engines, tax the bait, require licenses for fishing, judge you for eating fish, etc.....

roy

roy
Very well put! I couldn't have said it any better myself!
Sign Up to Post Your CommentsSign Up to Post Your Comments
If you are already registered, click here to login. Otherwise, please take a few seconds to register with Townhall.com. Once you sign up, you’ll be able to post your comments immediately, use the action center, get podcasts, and more!
Note: Fields marked with a red asterisk (*) are required.
Salutation:
First Name:
*
Last Name:
*
Email:
*
Nickname:
*
Note: Nick name will be shown when you post comments.
Address 1:
*
Address 2:
City:
*
State:
*
Zip:
*
Phone:
      
Your daily must-read of conservative columns, cartoons and news. Coulter, Sowell, Krauthammer and more.
(Bi-Weekly) We highlight the best opportunities from our partners for surveys, action items and more.