Townhall.com, Where Your Opinion Counts
Talk Radio:   Bill Bennett   Mike Gallagher   Dennis Prager   Michael Medved   Hugh Hewitt   
BREAKING NEWS  LeftArrow - Townhall.com : Conservative, Political, Republican   RightArrow - Townhall.com : Conservative, Political, Republican  
Columns, funnies & more in your inbox!
  • Check the boxes and send us your email address to receveive your free newsletter
  • Your daily must-read of conservative columns, cartoons and news. Coulter, Sowell, Krauthammer and more.
  • Townhall.com’s weekly inside scoop on what’s happening behind the scenes in the world of politics. When news breaks, we report.
  • Signup to receive the latest daily Townhall cartoons
Wednesday, November 19, 2008
Larry Kudlow :: Townhall.com Columnist
Tarp the TARP
by Larry Kudlow
Vote on It:
Average Vote:
[+] Text [-]
 
Poll
Was the Copenhagen Global Warming Summit Walk-Out a Win for the U.S.?


Treasury Secretary Henry Paulson has called for a pause in the financing request for the Troubled Assets Relief Program (TARP), halting it at $350 billion. (The original request was for $700 billion.) I think that’s an excellent idea. But in a recent hearing of Barney Frank’s Financial Services Committee, Democrats went ballistic at the thought of no more TARP money. They want to keep spending. They want to throw money at GM, the other Detroit car makers, plumbers, auto-parts suppliers, homeowners, mortgage problems, and foreclosures. Candy stores all over America now want TARP money. 

Meanwhile, Senior Obama advisors are talking about another $600 billion to pull us out of recession. Some reports even suggest the development of a new industrial policy for big-government interference in housing, banking, energy, autos, and more.

But all this brings up a whole new problem in American finance: How are we going to transport and deliver trillions of dollars of new government money? It’s not an easy task. We’ve moved beyond show me the money. This is throw me the money. And shovels alone won’t do.

We’ll need to convert Caterpillar earth movers into money movers. We’ll need new streamlined helicopter fleets to drop money from the sky. We’ll need a trucking armada and full use of the railroads. And we’ll need an army of smaller trucks and SUVs to reach folks in the off-road areas. And let’s not forget FedEx and UPS -- we’ll need them to make sure the money arrives on time.

We may even need high-level planners at the Department of Transportation to help coordinate this vexing money-delivery problem. Sending out trillions of dollars may sound great to your average liberal Congress member. But this will not be easy. Perhaps the transitioning Obama administration can designate a Transportation Monetary Tsar. These logistical realities must be dealt with.

Or maybe there’s a better idea: Maybe we take Mr. Paulson at his word but go one step further. Let’s stop any new TARP money -- period. Enough is enough. The TARP has already done some good. Banks have more capital. Credit spreads in the money markets are narrowing. And there even are signs that business and consumer loans are flowing once again. So let’s cap the TARP -- or tarp the TARP.

The new congressional Keynesians believe government can spend us into prosperity. They’re wrong. Everything we have learned in the last four decades tells us that governments don’t create permanent new jobs or capital investment. In fact, the more we spend, the more we’ll have to raise tax rates. And that depresses growth. Europe went down this road and failed. So did Latin America and parts of Asia before they wised up.

And for some reason no one in Washington is talking about cutting tax rates, which would strengthen incentives to work, invest, and take new business risks. We should be making it pay more after tax for entrepreneurial activity of all kinds. How about this: Let’s get back on the path of free-market capitalism.

Even at the G-20 meeting in Washington this past weekend, all one heard was “global fiscal stimulus” -- or more spending on a worldwide scale to fight recession. It won’t work. It never has. Hundreds of academic studies over the past 25 years show clearly that countries that spend more, grow less; but that nations that tax less, grow more.

Why these lessons have been forgotten is beyond me. We have to restore market discipline and personal accountability. We should reward the economic good, but punish the bad. Instead we have launched a demoralizing government-spending nymphomania.  

Incidentally, all this talk of big-government bailouts and a never-ending flow of government spending has disheartened the stock market, which is now down five of the past seven days. Since the November 4 election, the Dow is off 15 percent, or more than 1,400 points.

All this shows why, like the grounds crew at a baseball stadium on a rainy evening, we need to roll out the tarpaulin in order to preserve the field. To safeguard today’s economic field, it’s time to tarp the TARP. Let’s stop right here at $350 billion before everyone in the country demands a piece of the new TARP action. At the same time, let’s cut taxes to grow the economy. Slash the corporate tax rate. Reduce personal rates across-the-board. Promote investment with a lower capital-gains tax and a lower estate tax. Let’s restore the incentive model of economic growth.

Current political trends in Washington are gonna push us off some left-wing economic cliff. Instead, let’s have some sanity. It’s time for a reality check about what works and what doesn’t in fighting recession and promoting long-term economic growth.

I say tarp the TARP.

Share:
Vote on It:
Average Vote:
 
About The Author

Lawrence Kudlow is host of CNBC's Kudlow & Company

Be the first to read Lawrence Kudlow's column. Sign up today and receive Townhall.com delivered each morning to your inbox.

Barney Frank

Has Barney Frank or Chris Dodd, both Liberals, proposed any regulations that would prevent this from happening again?

The anwser is no. Why because they caused the problem by demanding, Yes demanding, banks issue mortagages to people with no down payment and no ability to pay off the loan.

Tax and Borrow and Spend
Great - Reagan killed Democratic Tax and Spend and George Bush has now killed Republican Borrow and Spend. Get ready for Oabama's Tax AND Borrow and Spend.

Everyone is a Keynesian when it comes to the part about spending to stimulate the economy in bad times. Problem is no one ever does the other part which is to slow growth, raise taxes and reduce govt spending in good times.

Good luck to us all when we come out of this. Looks like there will be some serious inflation to reign in.

Cyclops Kudlow
If downward market forces similar to the ones that are affecting real estate prices were affecting the stock market, Kudlow would be screaming for a floor. It is somehow fine to haul money by the truck load to the biggest banks, but to let forclosures continue to push home values relentlessly downward.

Was all the apreciation in real estate over the last ten years a mirage? If so then the entire economic system has to be a monopoly game. Just fold up the board and take your game home, it's all fake anyway.

Some of those banks at the top that got those billions, didn't even want them. Fine, let them sit on extra billions, nothing fake about that part of the economy. But down where the average Americans biggest investment is being decimated by more and more forclosures, oh well.

Incredibly myopic!


Realism
The illusion that a small ranch in California was worth $500 thousand or a condo in NYC a million $$$ is what doomed our economy. Now we are being scammed into giving banks and unions billions. Yeah, that's the ticket!

You should have seen it coming
Larry,
You should have seen this coming when you strongly supported Paulson's bank bailout in the first place on your TV show. Before that, you were an effective advocate of free-market capitalism. So what happened?

Man, am I surprised
I just can't believe the "plan" that was supposed to keep the sky from falling is now falling apart itself. What a shock! So all our Chicken Little save-the-world illuminati were just living in a children's story? Darn. Can I go back to sleep now and dream of better days ahead?

Interesting
how many financial types like Kudlow want the bailout to stop now that their buddies on Wall St. have gotten theirs.
For the past two years this flack was busy telling us how good the economy was. His credibility is all used up as far as I'm concerned.

Tarp the TARP is obvious, but.....
These ill-conceived bailouts will continue to expand as long as those in charge are more concerned about maintaining their own power base than really fixing the country.

It worked for the USSR for about 70 years. Why not try it here? Right, Barney? Right, Chris?

Kudlow is a Paulson's Bootlick
He admitted on the John Batchelor Radio Show that he writes pro-Paulson articles at the direct behest of the Treasury Department.

I personally heard him state this live on the air some 6 weeks ago.

Kudlow is a hack who should be terminally ostracized.

Good money after bad
I haven't even bothered contacting my senators or representative this time around, they made it clear last time who they were looking out for and it wasn't me!

I have no doubts that they will end up forking over more and more money to their special interest buddies in the UAW. By all means lets pay them to make cars that no one wants to or can afford to buy.

The question needs to be is this company viable NOT how many votes will I lose? If there is sufficient demand for the product the market will step in, if there isn't it won't matter how much of MY money the government throws at it and you can't get paid back if the company ends up going out of business. Force them into bankruptcy or seize the assets and sell them off to recoup the 25 billion they already gave them.

Look where we have come from
We spent, printing money, added debt, to get housing for everyone, increased benefits for retirees with credit, expanded government salaries and benefits and the house comes down.

Now Obama and team say, just need a little bit more. They talk on the hill of confiscating 401 k's to put in treasury notes. Broke and want a little more.

The thiefs see a dollar on the floor and they sramble to see who gets to spend it. What does one do, short of anarchy to save this country.

Hypocrite
When the Wall Street bailout was being debated - well, not debated, but hysterically rammed down our throats - people like Kudlow were all for helping out their corrupt, greedy, sometimes criminal Wall Street cronies and their firms.

Now that they got their $700 billion bait-and-switch plan through Congress and shored up the big players' balance sheets, the rest of country can go to hell. The Treasury Czar is pushing TARP money on banks that haven't even requested it, but God forbid that anyone outside the financial sector should get their unmanicured flyover country fingers on any of THEIR funds.

Kudlow is a lousy economist who flips and flops as much as your average politician. He evidently fell in love with his "tarp the Tarp" expression, since he used it ad nauseum on CNBC yesterday. Hope it didn't take him too long to come up with it. It's not that cute, Larry.

Ken/Kudlow
You have a wonderfully one track mind. In your world, the Fed's cheap money policy had no affect, the treasury's new rule that permitted the Wall Street Investment Banks to increase their debt per $1 of assets from 12.5 to 30 to $1 had no impact, Credit Default Swaps that allowed them to increase their debt even further had no impact, banks had no responsibility even though the majority did not engage in sub-prime lending - meaning the government wasn't "forcing" them to do anything, and the fact that when McCain tried to reform F&F in 2005 when the GOP had 55 senators and the majority, but could only get 19 to support reform while the other 36 GOP senators refused, is not relevant either.

Your type will never win the press war because everyone had a hand in the meltdown, and you sit there and try to twist it to claim that only one hand was really in it. The banks, the GOP, the treasury, the Fed and the Insurance companies with their Credit Defaul swaps are pure as the driven snow.

And Kudlow. Give me a break. A month ago you were screaming for $700 billion. Now you support capping it at $350 billion without knowing whether or not Paulson will have to ask for the next $350 billion. Paulson "hopes" he can put it off until Obama is sworn in. But that's 60 days away. And let's not forget, you were madly promoting the idea of buying up the banks "toxic" debt - meaning bad loans, now you're trying to support just buying a big piece of all of them (ignoring what you supported 1 month ago), and then casually looking away. And what about AIG? They've borrowed $140 billion to date. How's that for a stock now trading at $1.75.

You are clueless.

BARNY FRANK IS A BIG PROBLEM!
BARNEY FRANK,AND NANCY POLISI AND HARRY REID AND HARRY POTTER ALL SING FOR A NEW BUICK!THEY WILL FIND A WHOLE NEW WAREHOUSE OF TARPS!15 BILLION A YEAR JUST TO FIGHT FOR AL GORES GREEN HOUSE GAS!

Bailout
I respect Mr. Kudlow deeply but you were one of the one's screaming for this bail out. Having second thoughts are we?

life in the hereafter
For those of you who have wondered what living in a democratic dictatorship would be like, I think you're about to find out.

NO TO ANY MORE BAILOUTS
NO TO STIMULUS CHECKS OBAMA NEED TO GIVE OUT PINKSLIPS STARTING IN THE DEPARTMENT OF EDUCATION, RECALL ALL QUASI-GOVERNMENT AGENCIES PROHIBIT ALL TAX-DEDUCTIONS, ELIMINATE FEDERAL WELFARE SYSTEM AND CORPORATE WELFARE.

Alan Keyes injury case against Obama
Alan Keyes has filed in Ca Supreme Court proving injury as a Presidential Candidate from Obama failing to prove he is a natural born citizen of US...is Petitioning a Stay of California's electoral votes.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=c9qQv9UXc

Alan Keyes injury case against Obama
Alan Keyes has filed in Ca Supreme Court proving injury as a Presidential Candidate from Obama failing to prove he is a natural born citizen of US...is Petitioning a Stay of California's electoral votes.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=c9qQv9UXc

Demand Obama PROVE US born citizenship
Act NOW: Demand Obama PROVE He's A US Natural Born Citizen!

Isn't arguing about "Obama's horrendous policies and cabinet picks" a little PREMATURE & PRESUMPTUOUS? He's simply NOT QUALIFIED to be president because he is not a natural US born citizen; and if the GOP were SMART they'd focus on this and ONLY THIS NOW UNTIL RESOLVED!

worldnetdaily.com — Subject: the time for CONGRESSIONAL HEARINGS is NOW This may be the most important thing we can do in the next four years. Fight for freedom while we still have it. Please spread this message far and wide. Paste links below on TownHall.com and anywhere else you visit while blogging. Contact radio & TV stations... And remember, Goliath lost.

Get the latest updates on the Obama fake birth certificate cases:
http://moniquemonicat.wordpress.com/2008/11/10/%E2%80%A2-la test-update-on-obama-birth-certificate-case/

View Obama’s fake birth certificate:
http://moniquemonicat.wordpress.com/obama-proof-he-was-born -in-kenya-fake-birth-certificate/

Good luck America on your ride to hell
Yes, you dug yourself into the deepest hole ever called Socialism/Communism plus now full speed ahead as the most abusive and far-reaching Empire the world has ever known.

Yes, while you blame just about every other nation on earth, for all your own problems plus that of the whole wide world, while at the same time you have forgotten that there are laws of immigrations plus borders!

Yes you, yourself praised as American patriots, you have broken your onw laws so that now millions of illegals have America look more and more like a banana republic! Even while messing oround all over the world, only God knows who and what has entered America in the meantime.

Yes, as a legal immigrant of 52+ years, and a staunch conservative Christian Republican, I very soon realized what America is doing to itself, as I would urged born Americans to wake up, while many times get the following words: Get back home.

So, what is happening to America, is nothing but the product of absolute and complete lawlessnees/anarchy. Yes, Kruschev said well in the 60's as he pounded his shoe on his desk at the UN: America will accept communism and not even know it.

Of course this guy already saw all the Socialistic/Communistic programs in force. Yes, while most born Americans had a a good laugh.

Now to cure the evils only doing more of the same as Thomas Jefferson said so well: "The principle of spending money to be paid by posterity, in the name of funding, is but swindling futurity on a large scale".

Yes, as the National Debt growing that by itself was true swindingling, and now to cure that first swindling, this Administration calling itself conservative, only more full speed ahead swingling.

Yes, I voted for Ron Paul here in California as a write in candidate.

Give TARP a chance
Why can't the public be patient and give TARP time to work? Didn't the Surge work its magic in Iraq?

Enjoy these final days of President Bush's leadership. Hopefully his wisdom will ultimately prevail.
Sign Up to Post Your CommentsSign Up to Post Your Comments
If you are already registered, click here to login. Otherwise, please take a few seconds to register with Townhall.com. Once you sign up, you’ll be able to post your comments immediately, use the action center, get podcasts, and more!
Note: Fields marked with a red asterisk (*) are required.
Salutation:
First Name:
*
Last Name:
*
Email:
*
Nickname:
*
Note: Nick name will be shown when you post comments.
Address 1:
*
Address 2:
City:
*
State:
*
Zip:
*
Phone:
      
Your daily must-read of conservative columns, cartoons and news. Coulter, Sowell, Krauthammer and more.
(Bi-Weekly) We highlight the best opportunities from our partners for surveys, action items and more.