Townhall.com, Where Your Opinion Counts
Talk Radio:   Bill Bennett   Mike Gallagher   Dennis Prager   Michael Medved   Hugh Hewitt   
BREAKING NEWS  LeftArrow - Townhall.com : Conservative, Political, Republican   RightArrow - Townhall.com : Conservative, Political, Republican  
Columns, funnies & more in your inbox!
  • Check the boxes and send us your email address to receveive your free newsletter
  • Your daily must-read of conservative columns, cartoons and news. Coulter, Sowell, Krauthammer and more.
  • Townhall.com’s weekly inside scoop on what’s happening behind the scenes in the world of politics. When news breaks, we report.
  • Signup to receive the latest daily Townhall cartoons
Tuesday, October 07, 2008
Larry Kudlow :: Townhall.com Columnist
McCain Must Talk Growth and Recovery
by Larry Kudlow
Vote on It:
Average Vote:
[+] Text [-]
 
Poll
Will the Dems' health care Christmas Present to America be an improvement or detriment to our health care system?


John McCain needs a knockout performance at Tuesday night's presidential debate if he is to keep his hopes alive.

Right now polls paint a dismal picture for Sen. McCain. Rasmussen shows Obama leading 52 to 44, Obama's highest level ever. (Moving above 50 percent is a key indicator.) The RealClearPolitics average has Obama up 6 points. InTrade shows Obama up by 34 points. It also could be that key states like Ohio and Florida are now up for grabs, while Obama could win in swing states like Virginia and North Carolina. McCain, of course, is moving out of Michigan.

The financial crisis and economic downturn clearly have buried Sen. McCain in recent weeks. Some of McCain's supporters think he can turn the page on the economy Tuesday night and instead attack Obama on character and qualifications. That doesn't seem realistic.

The recession economy and the financial crunch are front and center. Folks are asking: Can I get a loan? Will I have a job? Can I keep my house? Unfortunately, Sen. McCain's message overemphasizes government spending cuts, almost to the exclusion of stimulative and expansive tax cuts. This just doesn't seem like the right time for a government spending freeze, at least to the exclusion of other pro-growth policy levers. Sounds like too much root canal. More like Bob Dole than Ronald Reagan.

That's why McCain needs to stress that tax hikes of any kind would be a total disaster during this economic emergency and that letting folks keep more of what they earn is a recovery prescription. He needs to emphasize the need for across-the-board tax cuts for individuals and businesses. Lower marginal tax rates will reward work, investment and risk-taking. They also will put money in people's pockets as they keep more of what they earn.

McCain can point to Paul Ryan's modified flat tax with two brackets of 15 percent and 25 percent. That would be a great message. This is an economic emergency, and it calls for strong medicine. This is not the time to take away tax cuts. It's a time to add them. And reducing marginal tax rates would add substantially to taxpayer benefits on a permanent basis with new incentive rewards.

McCain should next talk about a corporate tax cut from 35 percent to 25 percent as a means of boosting jobs and wages. He should note that study after study shows that roughly two-thirds of the benefit of a corporate tax cut goes to the workforce. A corporate tax cut also is pro-investment and will make this country more competitive. But the key point is that a lower corporate tax rate is a job-creator. McCain must explain that you can't have jobs without healthy businesses that are funded by investment.

McCain also should state that the Federal Reserve needs to keep expanding the money supply. Milton Friedman taught us many years ago that the monetary contraction of 1929-32 was a key cause of the Great Depression. So Big Mac should tell Ben Bernanke to stop targeting the federal funds rate and pump up the money supply even more. Right now credit deflation and recession are the problems -- not inflation.

From the beginning of 2007 to the middle of 2008, the monetary base controlled by the Fed has grown only 1.6 percent at an annual rate. The basic M1 money supply has been flat. This amounts to a long-run liquidity squeeze. The credit-crunched economy desperately needs cash. But the Fed is not providing it.

Over the past three months, the central bank has stepped up a bit to a 4 percent to 5 percent growth rate. But that is still way too little in today's confidence-lacking banking environment. Everyone is hoarding cash rather than putting it to work. McCain should highlight this point.

He also should address all the Americans who might be worried about their bank accounts. He should propose that all deposits be guaranteed by the FDIC, at least temporarily. He might also suggest that G-7 central banks guarantee all inter-bank loans for regulated banks. (Hat tip to Wall Street economist John Ryding.)

He also should put Obama's tax hikes and trade protectionism in historical context. Under Herbert Hoover, taxes were raised, trade protectionism increased, and the money supply contracted. Sound familiar? Obama's tax hikes and trade protectionism are Hooveresque.

Right now, McCain sounds austere when he addresses the economy. Tomorrow night he must sound expansionary for economic recovery. Tax cuts, free trade and money growth -- those are the pillars of recovery. An across-the-board tax cut for individuals and businesses will boost jobs at home and our competitiveness worldwide. Free trade benefits both consumers and businesses. The Fed's money supply must keep expanding.

That message gives McCain a fighting chance.

Share:
Vote on It:
Average Vote:
 
About The Author

Lawrence Kudlow is host of CNBC's Kudlow & Company

Be the first to read Lawrence Kudlow's column. Sign up today and receive Townhall.com delivered each morning to your inbox.

McCain Blew it on Bailout
This is where he loses the election. He should have fought the bailout until he got exactly what he wanted - like a zero cap gains tax. Instead they put in those absurd extenders - geez that looks bad.
This Well Fargo/Citigroup fight over Wachovia shows how the Feds screw up the free market.

It's NOT over!
That's just an Obama campaign talking point. We still don't know who Obama is and we still don't even know if he is qualified enough to be President!

I'm just saying..........Is the fat lady singing? :-)

It's not over
Why doesn't McCain beat energy to death? The liberals say it is all drill, drill, drill -- it isn't, he can go after nuclear and ask -- does Obama and the democrats think that the French are smarter than we are? Well, the French use nuclear for 80% of their power and I am sure we can figure it out too!!

On top of that, we do want to drill now so that the NEXT TIME the world has an energy crisis, we can benefit and not be at the mercy of the Russians and our other buddies in Venezuela and the middle east!

And why doesn't McCain promise to get Detroit back on top with capital investment to develop the best hybrids? I know this is part of his plan, but in this environment, he needs to beat energy and the jobs and the hybrids to death.

I wish he would.

McCain knocked himself out
SO Kraer the Wall street crook thinks McCain needs KO punch?Well I got news for youu, Kramer, you wall street criminal, McCaib already knocked himslef out.


YeahWith his big government 800 billion dollar bail out of wall street criminals like YOU Mr. Kramer
.

Senor "amnesty" McCain ought to be sent to Singapore for flogging-NOT the white house to turn the GOP back into the big government party of Nelson Rockefeller.

Had McCain chosen Mitt Romney a financial genius, he would be ahead on the economy. But he let the anti-mormon redneck, Mike Hickabee intimidate out of selecting Mitt.

But, he still had Pawlenty. So what did McAmnesty do? Instead, he chose a bimbo under investigation for ethics violations,who is now going to court to ask supreme court justices to stop elected legislators from doing their job. Judicial activism, anyone?

Then McAmnesty lobbies and votes for a 800 billion big government pork package for Wall Street, and tells us he hates earmarks.

What a liar!

this rino is done-stick a fork in him!

Bob Barr is the only principled, trustworthy, and consistent conservative on the ballot.

You get a 1
Kudlow, you are stupid aren’t you. If he talks about the economy and this fiasco at all it should ber to attack the Vomit and the Dems in general for causing it. Thanks to your network and the rest of the MSM, the economy is poison for McCain.

And PS, your ideas are stupid too.

He's right
D... nice comment. Hopefully you'll be as chipper when we're all out of work under the dems.

The chickens have finally come home to roost. We are falling because we have not developed our own resources. Period.

With the economy finally front and center, we nominate a green, in the worst sense of the word, who does not like to engage in economics, and who as "maverick" compromised on every important issue despite the fact that many times we had the votes, if not the guts, to prevail.

McCain will loose. He will loose because he will not get down and dirty over the economy. He will not put it bluntly. The dems get in, they always raise taxes on everyone. This will cause you to loose your job, house, and put you on the street. Period. McCain won't say these things.

We win. We will drill and develope resources, which will ensure your job, give you a raise not seen since the 1960's, aka 25 dollar an hour jobs, and ensure that you can save for college or trade, buy a better house, new car, etc. McCain will not do this.

McCain will loose. And it will be up to us to rebuild the party under the image of the beliefs of Reagan, Palin, Jindal, et al. Until we do, we will continue to loose.

Be a REAL Maverick
Mack has early on compromised his economic cred in another way. He pandered to phantom "moderates" by promising to enact an energy rationing (aka "Cap & Trade") scheme because it was "the right thing to do" regardless of the science or lack thereof behind the 'climate change' dogma.

This present crisis, or even the Great D (also government-caused) would be a picnic compared to an energy starved society laboring under the delusion a naturally occurring gas essential to life must be rigidly controlled. The financial crisis is estimated now to cost a bit less than $2trillion. Reducing CO2 levels was estimated at $45trillion. Even a quarter of that isn't a "cost," it's an asteroid strike.

Mack needs to backtrack & stipulate that he is only in favor of measures science can objectively definitively PROVE will prevent unacceptable impact. Something that happens naturally, & has happened before, doesn't qualify as an unacceptable impact. That's a reasonable conservative position.

If you really want "green" jobs & "sustainable" energy, just define exactly what does constitute acceptable "sustainable" or "renewable" (no such thing per the laws of thermodynamics) energy, then provide that companies achieving it, & their employees, pay NO INCOME TAX. That probably would 'cost' less than all these stupid subsidies & grants, & would be much more motivating.

Be a REAL maverick. Reject this zeitgeist energyphobic dogma that leads directly & by design to totalitarianism. Conservatives are the real mavericks.

Herein is a great Adam Smith quote.
I don't see this alleged association of Ayers and Obama resonating with the American people at a time when their life savings are disappearing before their eyes.

THAT is what is on the minds of Americans.

And when McCain dwells on Ayers, Americans will just conclude how out of touch he and his campaign is.

McCain is holding few high cards.

One such card is on energy.

Esoteric arguments on whether regulation, or lack of regulation, caused our financial crisis reminds me of an obsession with rearranging the chairs on the deck of the Titanic..except to the extent the Obama camp can portray the culture of deregulation as benefiting Wall Street schemers.

But our nation should be careful here.

Too much regulation does stifle innovation.

Adam Smith said: "Virtue is to be feared more than Vice, because its excesses are not subject to the regulation of conscience".

THAT is an excellent quote.

Notice the operative word here is "regulation".

Some regulation or control, whether self-imposed, or due to an external force, is crucial...and in the context of this present financial meltdown, if it is not sufficiently forthcoming by the private sector, it WILL be instituted by government.

American people have a gut feeling scammers and schemers looted and exploited the financial system in a free-for-all world of "anything goes".

And they are mad as hell..enraged over perception government money is bailing these crooks out.

The Republicans have been in power for eight years(Whitehouse for all that time...House of Representatives for 6 of 8 years).

That's the problemm for McCain.

Growth vs. Taxes
Sen. John McCain needs to explain and reexplain
that his opponent not only wants to raise taxes, which will hurt growth and therefore jobs, but will use the taxes he takes from us to grow government and redistribute wealth.

McCain/Palin will support job growth, tax payers and homeowners.

The other side will raise taxes, increase regulations, grow government and groups like Acorn, and take a dollar from the average taxpayer and give them a quarter or so back, give a quarter or so to those not paying the tax to redistribute wealth and gain votes from those dependent on them, and give the rest of the dollar to the bureaucracy so that they can put their friends in power and reap more political contributions, votes and control.

Sen. McCain needs to explain Sen. Obama's responsibility for Acorn and Freddie/Fannie and therefore his responsibility for the current financial crisis and how race baiting prevented other Republicans and moderate Dems from joining Sen. McCain's effort to correct this financial situation years ago.

A Real Mouth Full, Kudlow
Kudlow:"Tax cuts, free trade...money growth..those are...pillars of recovery. ...across-the-board tax cut...will boost jobs at home and..competitiveness worldwide. Free trade benefits both consumers and businesses. The Fed's money supply must keep expanding." You have summarized it with a couple of sentences -- mostly wrong. Money growth and expanded Fed money supply -- that helped to get us here. Free trade -- we are in our 32nd year of deficit trade. Tax cuts -- no. That helped get us where we are today by cutting taxes and increasing money supply, government expenditures, and more free stuff to those who did not earn it. Others have said that lack of funding for SEC, FDIC and other gov'mint do-nothings helped cloud the problems. No, it was do-nothing gov'mint which knew about the problems and did nothing. Kudlow is a member of the CFR.

It's over; Obama's won
McCain has admitted that economics is not his basic strength. He ran his entire campaign on foreign policy, because that's what he knows.

And McCain never developed a positive economic message beyond drilling for oil. Drilling for oil will not do anything to fix the current financial crisis.

He obsesses over earmarks (something that is of absolutely no concern to anyone except conservatives), and bipartisanship (which is a means to an end, not an end in itself).

Barring some unforeseen event, unless McCain can offer a brand-new economic message tonight that directly addresses the financial mess we're in, this race is over. And Obama will be our next President.

Welcome to new US ...SR:

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=WtGrp5MbzAI

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wy09UpI60F8

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4q9nTfXh1eQ

... CHANGE WE WERE WAITING FOR !!!

What Should McCain Do?
Very good advice. All too true. I worry, however that John McCain is no aligned with these Milton Friedman.

A WINNING STRATEGY
A WINNING STRATEGY

Senator McCain is widely accepted as the candidate most able to be Commander in Chief. Unfortunately this is most often tied to military actions only.

The mission would be to change the ground rules being employed by the Obama campaign and drive the understanding that this role is critically important in virtually all challenges that will be faced by the next President: the war on terror, achieving energy independence, controlling the runaway spending by Congress, the economy, the rapidly increasing cost of healthcare and availability, the underperforming educational system, and infrastructure improvement. Each is a war unto itself requiring a proven Commander in Chief.

The key requirements of a Commander in Chief is to lead a team in identifying and defining major highly impactful challenges, developing strategies to address, building tactical plans to execute the strategies, identifying and securing the resources necessary to implement the plans and leading the team in the execution.

These are skills that Senator McCain learned at the Naval Academy and has used consistently in both his military and public service careers.

By emphasizing the need for a strong Commander in Chief in dealing with the current economic challenge it would focus on what is most important and not let the Obama campaign steal it as an issue that Senator Obama is best able to address.

Senator Obama has never shown any of the skills necessary to be Commander in Chief and this repositioning of the requirements would make this highly evident.

Let Governor Palin focus on the relationships, flip-flops, questions about donations, voting record etc.

Jerebaub
Two out of three Americans blame the GOP more than the Democrats of our current economic conditions. Bloggers may angerly try to dispute this fact, but the party in power always gets much of the blame, and the GOP's control of the Presidency for 8 years and the Congress for 6 of 8 has left them largely responsible, as far as the public is concerned.

I don't know, as such, that the arguments Kudlow promotes will resonate with most American's. From the outset, the economy was at the top of the list of voters concerns, yet McCain spent most of his time talking about Foreign Policy, where he is comfortable, not the economy.

Kudlow, further, and those like him, are desperate to try to turn this around - yet many of his old tried and true solutions simply put off another form of reckoning on debt that is at the core of the issues we face. We have far too much of it. The deficits for the coming years are soaring far above the $482 billion currently projected given all the bailouts.

At the same time, economists on realclearpolitics have pointed out that China, in the last six months, has added $500 billion to her dollar foreign exchange reserves, bringing their total to $2 trillion. This is 1/4 of the world's total The question is why? Further, to finance the deficits, we simply must persuade the Chinese to buy their fair share. This simply increases the economic bear hug they have put us in. So, we're trapped. The Chinese dictated the takeover of Fannie and Freddie because of the $375 billion in securities they held. They are now actively organizing a scenerio with OPEC that will replace the dollar for energy purchases, and they are systematically increasing their control of our economy.

They have become the strongest economic participant worldwide in our economy - and no one talks about it.

I'm not hoarding
I'm buying a little at a time at these levels, but not much right now. I agree that McCain needs to focus not only on growth and tax cuts, but MAKE IT CLEAR who caused this problem in Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac. The media just operates under the assumption that if they repeat things enough times, like Obama The Inexperienced Tax Raiser is better for the economy, naive people will believe it without checking the facts. So far, that seems to be true.

Here's who blocked oversight and covered up the Fannie Mae, Freddie Mac scam that caused our economic crisis *in their own words* and McCain needs to pound this home, Obama has been lying and so has Nancy Pelosi, Harry Reid and Barney Frank. See for yourselves. Nobody who complains about a corrupt govt would go along with that, period.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=JNAapMpetvw

And here's proof that McCain tried to stop this, along with Elizabeth Dole, John Sununu and the Senate Banking Committee. Check the facts yourselves.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3EyKiOE78yU

We need tax policies that contribute to growth, regulations that give us transparency, an SEC who enforces the laws, the credit rating agencies have too much power and only a real reformer with experience can handle it. Give 'em hell, McCain! We need a hero!!

If that freaks anyone out, go put a blanket over your heads, these are tough times and corruption caused this collapse. Either lead, follow or get out of the way. CHARGE!!!










Redlac
Agreed.

Economy doesn't favor Democrats
McCain might also point to California as an example of where Democrat policies lead. The state has a projected $16B deficit and plans to ask the feds for $7B. He should also hammer away at cutting spending and reform.

I've compiled a few points about Obama's economic plans. Here's a link to my blog.

http://inyourrightmind.blogtownhall.com/2008/10/04/obamas_f inancial_follies.thtml

McCain debate
Do you have McCain's ear on the economy and what he needs to do? If so, does he listen? If not, how do we get him on the right track, now, soonest, quickest, immediately?
bobmcghee@pacificgolfcars.com
Small business owner.

Attitude is everything.
Bush and Bernanke must have gone to Debbie Downer's slumber party last night, don't these guys know their attitudes affect SENTIMENT and that affects EVERYTHING??? Doesn't anyone in Washington have any common sense anymore??? That's why I like Sarah Palin. I hope McCain and Obama do better tonight, I'm an American first.

Thoughts.
A reality of business is that those who think only short term fail, whereas those that protect against the future succeed. I think about that often as in politics, people think only short term, and ignore the future, which leads inevitably to the very problems that we see.
Electing McCain may be the better short term fix, but for conservatives, it solves nothing. McCain, by definition, is a maverick with some conservative tendencies and some liberal, so that his position in the white house will only prolong democratic control in the Congress, as issues of health care, immigration and the economy will carry the stamp of both parties. And as the GOP is learning, you cannot run effectively against yourself, let alone a sitting president. Further, it virtually guarantees that in 4 years, barring his death or disability, he will be at the top of the ticket.

We see the same thing on this economic debate. Kudlow desperately wants to solve it now. But none of this will prevent the fact that the meltdown of the big investment houses guarantees that Wall Street will now be only one of a number of world markets, not the principal one. Further, we are being wrapped in a calculated and purposeful economic embrace by the Chinese, who are firm believers that the US should not be as powerful as it is - and who we cannot now do without. This will have a far greater impact on our foreign policy than any war in Iraq, because it is more pervasive and comprehensive, yet we say nothing. An era is ending, and another is beginning. Huge and rising deficits, rising entitlement costs, and increasing foreign control of our economy is ending one era, and we will now have to reformulate our future.

Intrade manipulation?
Are the contracts for Obama and Mccain for president on Intrade being manipulated? It seems the market for each contract is not that large. Moveon.org and affiliated 527's have tons of money to throw around if they want to....

obama not a winner


We keep hearing it's now McCain's race to lose.

But IMHO, Obama was a loser at the start. His success to date is all media-pundit-argument, no voters will back him en masse when it's crunch-time.

When a candidate is UNABLE to shake the image of ultra-left socialist, his GOOSE is a goner! Americans will never sustain interest in that kind of person; especially if he's known as a party hack.

Pro-Life is furious today at the specter of new Justices being foisted on us by ultra-leftist abortion enablers. They DEMAND an end to abortion. Obama is a minion of the abortion lobby, everyone knows it. So is Biden!

On Iraq, all of us know what he's was branded since he began: Cut and Run; not interested in fighting global terrorism.

As a legislator, however undistinguished; simply tax and spend as his inevitable "plan."

Add the fact no man of color has yet been elected a president; plus the way he cut Hillary Clinton; his prospects of garnering the woman's voting bloc are NIL. On energy, Obama is on Nancy Floozie's leash, another lost voting bloc; and he fails also for NRA members.

Is he popular with Hispanics?

Probably; yet McCain is counting on a large segment of that one too.

Add to it all the Palin factor-- a tremendous boost, McCain is going to peak at the best possible time: ON ELECTION DAY!

The only poll to think about in America is November 4th, 2008! McCain & Palin in a landslide!

Tax Cuts?????
That's the last thing we need with this deficit. I hope this crisis puts a stake though the heart of supply side economics and we regain fiscal sanity. It's hard to believe that it was only 14 years ago that our Party was calling for a balanced budget amendment.
The inmates are running the asylum now.

Keep Dreamin', CINO's
Yeah, that one will go over like another lead balloon. Do you guys really believe Conservatives are drinking your Kool-Aid after MCShamnesty just shafted us with the 700 billion dollar bailout. What are you people smokin'? It's over with the Conservative base. We're voting 3rd Party; the permanent defection is on. We know a "Titanic" catastrophe when we see one. The difference between CINO's and Conservatives is you guys talk and wax nostalgic about Reagan, but we still LIVE and honor Reagan in our lives and principles. We seek to give him a legacy instead of remove every last vestigial trace of Conservatism from the face of the Earth!

To Gregdn in CA


You're lost between worlds, Pal. First: Never has any nation taxed itself into prosperity. Not once.

Then, Tax cutting and control over spending is precisely what we haven't had for all these years. Now McCain, the Maverick, can bring the new era. He'll veto porkbarrel lists in every bill. He'll cut spending to essentials and give us back our tax dollars; which are NOT the government's to begin with!

Your idiots in the Congress hate him JUST for those reasons. He won't allow them to spend the whole economy into ruin the way California was ruined by Democrats. It's a stinking disgrace our governor's asking the Feds for a "loan," now! You must be so proud!

Take Back Your Brain
Take Back Gov't has to recover his brain first.

If he/she is banking on a 3rd party to get him back on track, I pity the fool. The GOP is good enough for us. A 3rd party will never get you Bubble Gum money, nor win the way to the dog pound for you. National elections are won or lost by the 2 major parties; so you mot start by deciding which one you'll be loyal to. If you don't like the current candidate, try running for the office yourself. You haven't a chance backing those nobodies in the Feeble Party or the Grab Bag Party.

Dreadnaught
Economics is not a subject that you can understand. In this economic environment taxes have a rare purpose. If you understood economics you would know that, as well as the purpose. I could explain it to you but you probably wouldn't understand. "Dumb As"... Why do you think the FED is willing to reduce interest rates below 2%? You may answer when ready...

do your best, killer
"Economics is not a subject that you can understand."

I understand raising taxes and what's lowering taxes.


"In this economic environment taxes have a rare purpose."

Good. Keep taxes RARE.

"If you understood economics you would know that, as well as the purpose. I could explain it to you,"

Well-- I see you're all eagerness for taxes. I don't understand that. We're talking here about COST. Not theory. ME; I worry about BIG mistakes made by our leaders. You're worried about me. I can't lower taxes. I only VOTE to lower them.
Something you probably wouldn't understand.
Sign Up to Post Your CommentsSign Up to Post Your Comments
If you are already registered, click here to login. Otherwise, please take a few seconds to register with Townhall.com. Once you sign up, you’ll be able to post your comments immediately, use the action center, get podcasts, and more!
Note: Fields marked with a red asterisk (*) are required.
Salutation:
First Name:
*
Last Name:
*
Email:
*
Nickname:
*
Note: Nick name will be shown when you post comments.
Address 1:
*
Address 2:
City:
*
State:
*
Zip:
*
Phone:
      
Your daily must-read of conservative columns, cartoons and news. Coulter, Sowell, Krauthammer and more.
(Bi-Weekly) We highlight the best opportunities from our partners for surveys, action items and more.