Townhall.com, Where Your Opinion Counts
Talk Radio:   Bill Bennett   Mike Gallagher   Dennis Prager   Michael Medved   Hugh Hewitt   
BREAKING NEWS  LeftArrow - Townhall.com : Conservative, Political, Republican   RightArrow - Townhall.com : Conservative, Political, Republican  
Columns, funnies & more in your inbox!
  • Check the boxes and send us your email address to receveive your free newsletter
  • Your daily must-read of conservative columns, cartoons and news. Coulter, Sowell, Krauthammer and more.
  • Townhall.com’s weekly inside scoop on what’s happening behind the scenes in the world of politics. When news breaks, we report.
  • Signup to receive the latest daily Townhall cartoons
Thursday, November 01, 2007
Larry Elder :: Townhall.com Columnist
A Lesson in Personal Responsibility
by Larry Elder
Vote on It:
Average Vote:
[+] Text [-]
 
 
Poll
Will the Dems' health care Christmas Present to America be an improvement or detriment to our health care system?


Two weeks ago I arrived at San Francisco airport. The young, attractive, personable black woman at the rental car desk wore a badge that said "Trainee." I smiled and said, "That's an odd name." She laughed. I asked whether she was from San Francisco. She replied, "No, I'm not from here. I'm from Atlanta."

"Why are you here?" I asked.

"Well, I moved back with my parents here in town."

"I thought you said you were not from here."

"Well," she said, "I'm from here, but I went to school in Atlanta, and I prefer it there. So I consider it my home."

"What were you doing in Atlanta?" I asked.

"I attended Clark University, but after a couple of years I got pregnant, so I came home."

"Are you in school now?"

"No, because the money's too good."

"Too good to remain in school?"

"For now," she answered.

"What is it you don't like about San Francisco?"

"It's just so racist," she said.

"Racist? Isn't this one of the most liberal cities in the country?" I asked. She rolled her eyes.

"Sign here," she said. "You know, I should have finished my training program some time ago, but because I'm black, they're making me stay longer."

"How do you know it's because you're black?" Another roll of the eyes.

As I was leaving, I said, "You know, given your people skills and your drive, whatever obstacles others place in your way, you'll be able to overcome them."

"Wait, what do you mean?"

I turned around. "I mean that given your charm and your apparent drive, I'm sure you'll be able to deal with -- and maybe even turn around -- anybody who gets in your way."

"You think so?" she asked.

"I know so."

Which brings us to Stanley O'Neal, the recently ousted black CEO of Merrill Lynch.

Who is Stanley O'Neal? Born in segregated Alabama in 1951, O'Neal spent his early childhood delivering newspapers, picking corn and cotton on the family farm, and being educated in a one-room school built by his grandfather. He landed a job on General Motors' assembly line, and won a place studying engineering and industrial administration at the General Motors Institute. O'Neal later secured a Harvard scholarship, where he earned an MBA. "I really didn't have an understanding of the world or any role models, but I had a strong desire to learn, and I think that is what pulled me through," said O'Neal.

He left General Motors for Merrill Lynch in 1986, beginning a meteoric rise to CFO in 1998, president in 2000 and CEO in 2002. In July 2002, when Fortune magazine named O'Neal the most powerful black executive in the country, O'Neal refused to comment for the story. Most interviewers found ONeal disinclined to talk about his race and background, as Fortune later wrote: "[O'Neal] is even reluctant to discuss what it's like to be the first African American to run a major Wall Street firm."

Last year business pundits praised O'Neal, and his firm rewarded him for their record $7.5 billion net income by paying O'Neal $48 million, one of Wall Street's richest packages.

Back in 2002, when O'Neal was picked for ascension to CEO, Fortune published a fairly glowing, lengthy story on O'Neal titled, "Can Stan O'Neal Save Merrill?" mentioning his race only once. And a BusinessWeek story, "Merrill: Is Stan the Man?" never mentioned his race. Aside from noting that O'Neal was the first black CEO of a big investment firm, most stories at the time focused on O'Neal's accomplishments, his leadership style and the obstacles facing Merrill Lynch -- but did not focus on his race.

But O'Neal, as did many CEOs in financial services, placed bad bets in the mortgage market. The sub-prime meltdown resulted in a $7.9 billion write-off in mortgage-related assets for Merrill Lynch's third quarter. His rivals -- Citigroup Inc. and others -- also lost huge sums of money. After his five-year tenure -- average for an American CEO -- the board fired him.

As for the termination, only a handful of papers bothered to mention that O'Neal is black -- and usually deep into the story. A front-page Wall Street Journal article said, "Mr. O'Neal . . . is widely credited with boosting Merrill's profitability and transforming it . . . . " Then halfway through the story, it says, "No one on Wall Street embodied the Horatio Alger story better than Mr. O'Neal, who became the highest-ranking African-American on Wall Street." The New York Times story, "At Merrill, a Risk-Taker's Rise Ends With a Messy Undoing," makes no mention of race.

O'Neal's race played no role in either his hiring or firing. So Jesse Jackson and Al Sharpton will likely remain silent -- for a change.

As to the trainee at the rental car agency, I doubt whether she ever heard of O'Neal. But she certainly could benefit from something the former Merrill Lynch CEO once told Newsweek: "It's maybe the only country in the world that could have somebody like me start out where I did and wind up doing what I'm doing."

Share:
Vote on It:
Average Vote:
 
About The Author
Larry Elder is a syndicated radio talk show host and best-selling author. His latest book, "What's Race Got to Do with It?" is available now.
 
TOWNHALL DAILY: Be the first to read Larry Elder's column. Sign up today and receive Townhall.com daily lineup delivered each morning to your inbox.
 
©Creators Syndicate
Oh boy, jim, Look Out!
Better not tell any of those stories around Gloria Allred! >:)

I must choose my target well
Unca Alby writes: Thursday, November, 01, 2007 5:34 PM
Cookie -- jim --
That joke will get you slapped in most quarters, and deservedly so!
----
jim writes: Thursday, November, 01, 2007 1:12 PM

It's an old joke, but a good one
Oh, I used it a dozen times, and always got a laugh, not a slap. Of course I must be careful who I say it to, and I guess I just have a knack at first impressions.
------
Just a couple more:

One time a very well endowed lady, who I had played tennis with many times, arrived for our tennis match with a shirt with a message of some kind. She said, “Do you like my message?” I said, “No, but I love the message board!”
-------
The other day the cashier in the bank bent down to her counter, and I could almost see her belly button. I laughed and said, “That’s beautiful, but did you know that when you got dressed this morning.”

She laughed and admitted she had no reason at all to complain when a man got the nice view and commented about it.
---------
There is nothing more beautiful than a beautiful lady, and the more of the lady that can be seen, the more the beauty!!!!

BHL
"The myth of affirmative action is that an unqualified black will be given preference over a qualified white."

Uh... That's not a myth: that's the definition.

Cookie -- jim --
That joke will get you slapped in most quarters, and deservedly so!

Good for you, Larry
Mr. Elder, good for you for saying the positive things you did to that young lady. Hopefully, you planted a seed by making her think about it.

jim
I still laughed out loud.

N/A WRITES:
I only hear that from racists and/or conservatives.

Get a grip Mary. The article was about the individual, not color. What is it about libs and their blinders? They are the ones that like affirmative action, employee quotas, raced based programs, hate crimes, just to name a few. Conservatives overlook color and go straight to character content.

You liberals define everybody on color and then point your finger at conservatives. Truly pathetic.

That clerk.
How old was that "personable and attractive" trainee: 14, 15?

It's glaringly apparent that she's been programmed by political correctness, and will never honestly look at life as a fully rational and mature woman. The "victim" belief, as expressed by this apparent kid, is precisely why so many blacks blame others instead of looking in the mirror. Self-deception and responsibility-displacement has been legitimized by the left.

If I were an employer, she would be the last person I'd hire if I knew of her adolescent excuses for the poor choices she has made in her life. She has effectively brushed aside her personal history in favor of blaming others. If she owned up to them, I'd put her on the payroll.


It's an old joke, but a good one
Well it's off the subject, but the comment

"rental car desk wore a badge that said "Trainee."

and before I got to the next phrase

"I smiled and said, "That's an odd name."

I remembered the old joke,

"That's a nice name, what do you call the other one?"


Personal Responsibility
If that attractive, personable trainee continues to believe that every negative thing that ever happens to her is because of racism she isn't going to get very far. Time to stop the pity party and rely on yourself to secure your happiness. I'd be very disconcerted if a stranger told me all about how mistreated she is in the first 2 minutes of our aquainance. Unfair stuff sometimes happens - to everyone - welcome to the real world. Maybe the company doesn't have a spot ready for her yet, maybe they think she needs a little more training simply because she does, or maybe her boss thinks she's cute and wants to keep her around a little longer. Throwing up the race excuse denys her the self reflection that may make her a better employee.

Stanley O'Neal
Made it on his own. He was fired because of losses he could not have foreseen. He will be back on top at some company SOON! Notice, Mr. O'Neal didn't whine and cry about racism. He just moved on. That action ALONE speaks VOLUMES about his character. Something Liberals like Mary C. KNOW NOTHING ABOUT!

Bleeding Heart Liberal -- Black CEO's
A large number of blacks already owned their own businesses before the Civil Rights Movement, and were doing quite well for themselves, thank you very much.

Liberals often make the mistake that, were it not for their oh-so-benevolent government using coercion to make people do right, then nobody would do right. It's simply not the case.

E.g.:
"In 1954, George Johnson borrowed $250 from a bank and another $250 from a friend and launched his own company, Johnson Products – the first hair care brand developed specifically for African American hair."

(of course, back then it was called "Negro hair"!)

Indeed, many black businesses suffered when the laws were changed to prevent discrimination. The history was that blacks could not go to certain white establishments, but there was nothing to stop whites from going to black establishments. When businesses were forced to integrate, many blacks stopped going to black establishments and went to white ones.

E.g.:
"I took my lover on over 'cross the tracks,
So she can hear my man awail a sax.
I must admit they have a rockin' band,
Man, they were blowin' like a hurricane."
Chuck Berry, 1957

Guess what "across the tracks" meant?

So, yes, there *were* black CEO's prior to the civil rights movement. They might not have been on the Forbes list of the 500 wealthiest, but they were certainly out there. They were grabbing a big chunk of the American Dream using the kind of drive and entrepreneurial spirit that makes this country so great.

Genius will out
If you are head and shoulders above the competition, nothing will stop you. Oneal is the perfect example.

The myth of affirmative action is that an unqualified black will be given preference over a qualified white.

The truth is that prior to affirmative action qualified blacks were more often than not ignored in favor of less qualified whites.

If you wish to treat this as typical liberal hyperbole, where were all the black CEO's prior to the the civil rights movement?

Some Examples....
of coming from meager beginnings and going up the ladder:

Condeleeza Rice
Colin Powell
Clarence Thomas
Star Parker
Walter Williams
Thomas Sowell

But these people aren't 'authentic blacks' right, Mary C.? They don't shuffle to the liberal plantation.

I hate it when liberals equate being a conservative automatically means you are racist.

There should be no discrimination because of rade and THAT includes racial set asides, failing to enforce immigration laws, searching Muslims in airports or any other politically correct nonsense.


sheesh
"I only hear that from racists and/or conservatives.

Mary C."
Never heard of Clarence Thomas, eh

AudiR10 - - limits
"Personally I would attach the future earnings of that 10 year old until every dime is repaid."

I wish we could, and there's a whole 'nother topic about victim redress.

But that kid could grow up to be Bill Gates II and still not make enough to pay back the damages from this fire. And he's only 10, clearly not a responsible adult. And how much oversight are parents *supposed* to have? You can't watch the kids 24/7, even when you're doing your best.

How many fires did *you* start when *you* were a kid? I know I started a few myself. What kid hasn't? What kid hasn't played around with a magnifying glass in the sun scorching ants? That's just what kids do.

I think we'd be better off with a better policy for the occasional controlled burn that would prevent such a catastrophic conflagration, than to worry about how to punish 10 year olds for doing what 10 year olds are always going to do.

N/A aka Mary C. - -
"I only hear that from racists and/or conservatives."

Try taking the earplugs out. Liberals are screaming this every day.

And speaking of personal responsibity
How about that 10 year old that decided to light the brush on fire behind his house and ended up burning 38,000 acres and 21 houses belonging to other people -- and cannot be named or punished?

How about the fact that his parents are now civilly liable for behaviour they did not teach him to avoid?

Personally I would attach the future earnings of that 10 year old until every dime is repaid.

uwcharlie
uhhhh, read the article again. It was mostly about not using "racism" as a crutch when you are underachieving or afraid of success. I believe Mr. Elder mentioned Atlanta so prevalently because of the blatant racism against whites perpetrated there. It seems that this young lady got caught up in the hype of "blame the whites" for all of your problems during school.

Mary C.,
your 4:46 was not a very good post. Might want to check out AudiR10 above. If you're feeling eager this morning to call more names, have at it.

we are all Horatio Alger
Those of us early feminists who fought our way into male-dominated businesses despite the overwhelming belief by the Management that it was no use training Girls to be anything because they would get pregnant and quit, are also Horatio Alger. It takes determination and ability to succeed, and the hide of a dragon to boot, but anybody can do it if he or she tries.

I am very tired of hearing about so called Affirmative Action -- that is for lazy people. The only affirmative action you need is the kind you provide for yourself.

The truth
The truth about Stan O'Neal and Merrill Lynch has so little to do with his race that it is nearly an insult to mention it. Sure, the financial shouters praised him when he made early decisions that boosted Merrill Lynch's profits. However, because he was a minority, he should have been among those who realized early on that staking his company's profits on what was clearly the chancy subprime mortgage money was wrong and stupid. His race has nothing to do with his separation from Merrill Lynch and everything to do with his decision to take the wrong financial road. That Elder brings race into the subject insults all minorities who make it in the business world - that if you fail, it's because of your race. I happen to have investments through a Merrill Lynch brokerage house and my broker must be bitterly disappointed in O'Neal for making such bone-headed financial decisions. O'Neal knew exactly what he was doing and now he has to pay for his stupidity. This clearly was a problem with O'Neal's decision making, not his racial makeup.

Unca Alby
We're probably going to see two variants -- possibly from the same people -- possibly in the same paragraph --"They only hired him because of Affirmative Action"

I only hear that from racists and/or conservatives.

Mary C.


More Horatio Alger...
less whining, please, liberals.

America is chocked full of Horatio Alger stories of all stripes. Given the fact that blacks were blatantly, systematically oppressed by their own government for centuries, there are more than a fair share of underdog triumph stories among black Americans. Why don't we hear more of them? I find them awfully inspiring - I love underdogs.

A cynic might argue that stories about people who start poor or disadvantaged yet -- through hard work and self-discipline -- rise to multi-millionaire status, or to the top of any number of noble professions, works against the liberals socialist agenda, and are therefore less likely to receive press and publicity from the liberal-dominated media.

I feel a little like Horatio Alger myself, sometimes. I started life out on the low end of the economic scale, the product of a dysfunctional home dominated by alcoholism.

Until age 30, I also followed the family tradition of drunkenness and irresponsibility, and remained relatively poor. Then I wised up, sobered up, and less than twenty years later have more -- both personally and economically -- than I ever imagined possible.

As Larry advises, people should never allow themselves to be limited by the low expectations of others. I truly believe we are all capable of great accomplishments. If we're willing to grind out the hard work, day in and day out, anything is possible.

Ok, wait for it, here it comes ---
We're probably going to see two variants -- possibly from the same people -- possibly in the same paragraph --

1. "They only hired him because of Affirmative Action"

2. "They only fired him because he's black"

Of course, both of these variants demean the man's accomplishments. But what else can you expect from the "It Takes a Village" crowd? Clearly individual hard work and perseverance are meaningless when we already know in advance that "The Man" is out to GET you. Racism in America won't end until we have 64 black congressmen (or rather, 32 black congressmen, and 32 black congress-women.)
Sign Up to Post Your CommentsSign Up to Post Your Comments
If you are already registered, click here to login. Otherwise, please take a few seconds to register with Townhall.com. Once you sign up, you’ll be able to post your comments immediately, use the action center, get podcasts, and more!
Note: Fields marked with a red asterisk (*) are required.
Salutation:
First Name:
*
Last Name:
*
Email:
*
Nickname:
*
Note: Nick name will be shown when you post comments.
Address 1:
*
Address 2:
City:
*
State:
*
Zip:
*
Phone:
      
Your daily must-read of conservative columns, cartoons and news. Coulter, Sowell, Krauthammer and more.
(Bi-Weekly) We highlight the best opportunities from our partners for surveys, action items and more.