Townhall.com, Where Your Opinion Counts
Talk Radio:   Bill Bennett   Mike Gallagher   Dennis Prager   Michael Medved   Hugh Hewitt   
BREAKING NEWS  LeftArrow - Townhall.com : Conservative, Political, Republican   RightArrow - Townhall.com : Conservative, Political, Republican  
Columns, funnies & more in your inbox!
  • Check the boxes and send us your email address to receveive your free newsletter
  • Your daily must-read of conservative columns, cartoons and news. Coulter, Sowell, Krauthammer and more.
  • Townhall.com’s weekly inside scoop on what’s happening behind the scenes in the world of politics. When news breaks, we report.
  • Signup to receive the latest daily Townhall cartoons
Wednesday, April 11, 2007
John Stossel :: Townhall.com Columnist
The Edifice Complex
by John Stossel
Vote on It:
Average Vote:
[+] Text [-]
 
 
Poll
Will the Dems' health care Christmas Present to America be an improvement or detriment to our health care system?


Why do we let politicians name buildings after each other? I understand building monuments to honor leaders like Washington and Jefferson. But monuments to current members of Congress? Haven't we lowered the bar too far?

Today all a congressman has to do to get his name slapped on a building is bring home enough pork.

Mississippi Sen. Trent Lott has lots of facilities named after him: a middle school, an airport, the Trent Lott Center at Jackson State, the Trent Lott Leadership Institute, and more.

West Virginia Sen. Robert Byrd has even more named after him. My show, "20/20," discovered more than 30 buildings, a bridge, even a telescope.

This practice of naming buildings after living public figures is relatively new. The Lincoln Memorial didn't appear until more than 50 years after Lincoln's death. The Washington Monument came 89 years after Washington died.

One politician wants to stop such self-glorification. Dan Greenberg, an Arkansas state legislator, introduced the "Edifice Complex Prevention Bill." It would ban his state's politicians from naming buildings after themselves. "For me it just comes too close to using taxpayer money to build temples to living people," he told me.

Arkansas politicians are as guilty as others in memorializing one another. The most recent former governor, Republican Mike Huckabee, who's now running for president, has plenty named after him, and even his wife, Janet, has things named for her, like the Mike and Janet Huckabee Lake and the Janet Huckabee Nature Center.

What made Greenberg try to stop this nonsense was discovering that a park was named after him and some other legislators. One complained that the sign with her name didn't use her campaign colors. "That was so distasteful, I just said to myself, 'Enough!'" Greenberg recalls.

Other politicians sneered at his idea, and the Edifice Complex Prevention Bill was killed in committee 11 to 3.

In Jackson, Miss., such political egotism is controversial. Some people want a new federal courthouse named after one of Mississippi's pioneering black lawyers, the late R. Jess Brown, who defended James Meredith in his effort to attend the University of Mississippi and defended Medgar Evers, the civil-rights activist who later was murdered.

But Sen. Lott has other ideas. He thinks the courthouse should be called the Cochran Federal Courthouse because his colleague Sen. Thad Cochran got Congress to spend $100 million of your tax money to build it. That upsets Brown's children, as well as others in Jackson who want to see the civil-rights fighter honored.

Sen. Cochran's office says he's too modest to comment about this matter. But Sen. Lott defended his effort, saying:

"Thad Cochran moved to the Jackson area at age 9 and adopted it as his home-making partner in less than three years in the state's most respected law firm. Jackson voters first sent Thad to Washington where he rose to chair powerful Senate committees that advanced projects that have improved the quality of life of all Mississippians. He's responsible for Congress' approval of the new Mississippi Courthouse, and that's why Jackson residents and the Mississippi judicial community want it to bear his name."

Give me a break! Jackson residents want this? Which ones? Most Jackson residents "20/20" asked were opposed to it, saying things like, "Don't put a politician's name on it. A politician's already received enough from the American public!"

I agree. I understand why politicians like having their names on buildings. It's an ego boost. And the free advertising doesn't hurt their perpetual reelection campaigns.

But you shouldn't have to pay for their monuments to themselves.

This week another politician said "enough" to politicians' self-glorification. Probable presidential candidate Fred Thompson asked a legislator to withdraw his plan to name a stretch of U.S. Highway 43 "Fred Thompson Boulevard."

Maybe it will start a trend.

Share:
Vote on It:
Average Vote:
 
About The Author
John Stossel blogs at http://blogs.abcnews.com/johnstossel/ is an award-winning news correspondent and author of Myths, Lies, and Downright Stupidity: Get Out the Shovel--Why Everything You Know is Wrong.
 
TOWNHALL DAILY: Be the first to read John Stossel's column. Sign up today and receive Townhall.com daily lineup delivered each morning to your inbox.
 
©Creators Syndicate
Fred Dalton Thompson
This man is talking the talk and walking the walk.

Telling a politician to take his name off a highway is a start. If you pass the test of approval after 100 years, you get it, anything short of that is patrionage.
I have high hopes Fred Thompson is going to be a serious candidate.

Because there aren't any other serious candidates. Serious for America anyway.

Fred Thompson

is way ahead of the others.

Politicians build monuments to themselves?

Just more self-agrandizing chimps throwing poo at the "commoners".

Fred Dalton Thompson ....
.... demonstrates about the normal amount of Human fallibility and for all of that seems pretty darned comfortable in his skin and in his being -- and projects an intact American Man!

And notwithstanding his having a couple of times, as a United States Senator, given his support to the promotion and passage of anti-Constitutional legislation, he would, if he ran, stand head and shoulders above the current field.

THOMPSON/GINGRICH2008, anyone? (Or visa versa)

Pappy Michael employs .....
.... an analogy that even I understand about those who every single day of their lives prove to us all the truth about the power lust being a noxious weed that flourishes only in the vacant lots of (the pooflingers') empty minds.

IMHO it
should be illegal to name buildings, roads, and anything else public at all. In today's thin-skinned society I am sure you can find someone to be offended by anything. Roads should have numbers not names. City streets may have names but I would restrict them to dead people.

Constitutional amendment time...
..."All federal and state projects paid for by the taxpayers will be named after the taxpayers."

"The Taxpayers US Courthouse."

"The Taxpayers Interstate Highway,#95".

"The Taxpayers Bridge To Nowhere".

In ancient Rome,whenever the Romans wanted to honor a conguering hero of theirs,they would have a slave stand in the back of Caeser's chariot,holding a laurel wreath over his head and whispering in his ear"Remember,thou art only a man".

Maybe,just maybe,we can have a servant standing in the back of the presidents' limo when he returns from his inauguration,and the crowds are cheering,and the servant is saying "Remember,thou are only a man".

Ozymandias
Ozymandias

I met a traveller from an antique land
Who said: "Two vast and trunkless legs of stone
Stand in the desert. Near them on the sand,
Half sunk, a shattered visage lies, whose frown
And wrinkled lip and sneer of cold command
Tell that its sculptor well those passions read
Which yet survive, stamped on these lifeless things,
The hand that mocked them and the heart that fed.
And on the pedestal these words appear:
`My name is Ozymandias, King of Kings:
Look on my works, ye mighty, and despair!'
Nothing beside remains. Round the decay
Of that colossal wreck, boundless and bare,
The lone and level sands stretch far away.

Thanks Mr. Stossel
Thank you for commenting on this disgusting trend. It has been a pet peeve of mine for some time. I find so little to admire about most politicians that it galls the hell out of me to see their names go up on public building, bridges, highways, parks, etc. While I oppose, on principle, legislation to forbid the practice, I am in favor of vociferous public ridicule of those whose names appear on edifices built with money stolen from taxpayers'.

Rush lies?
And this is accordoing to whom? To you, a self= confessed liberal? And we're supposed to take you seriously? So tell us some of the lies Rush has told. You should be able to come up with 40 or 50 in the nexr 15 minutes. For your information, the information on Rush's show has been documented to be accurate pretty much all the time. And, if he does make a mistake, he leads the next show with a correction and an apology. Up yours.

Stossel is certainly right about Sen. Byrd. I love to travel West Virginis, surely one of our most beautiful states. But you can't swing a dead cat without hitting something named for Sen. Byrd. The telescope, the Green Bank Radio Telescope, by the way, is the largest moving object on the face of the earth. But they love the king of Pork because he enables them to live off the work of others.

I thought...
That they had formally renamed West Virginia "Robert Byrd Mountainous State Between Pennsylvania and Kentucky" thus giving it a longer name than even Rhode Island.

We keep electing these morons and they keep acting indignant when their pork projects are lambasted in the public. Remember how offended Ted Stevens was when the nation laughed at his bridge to nowhere.

The problem is, these guys believe their own press! They actually think they're better than the rest of us!

When Phil Gramm popped an amendment on Hillary Clinton's healthcare bill requiring that Congress live by the same system they imposed on the rest of the nation, Arlen Specter said, "We can't do that, I would have died of my brain tumor if we did that!" Gramm said that was the point.

I wonder if we will ever be able to reign in the ego of public officials. I tend to doubt it. In a nation obsessed with celebrity, even politicians get the star treatment.

Finally, something we can all agree on.
Congratulations, Mr. Stossel, you've found the first truly bi-partisan issue on Townhall.

If only we could end this kind of quid pro quo for pork, we could finally see a potential end to wasteful government spending. But we'd have to do it as a referendum...if we leave it up to our elected representatives to do in committee, they will continue to sell us out for their own egos.

(Although I suppose if you're stroking your own ego, that would be called id stroking.)

I love how liberals
I love how liberals from Massachushits, who never listen to The Rush Limbaugh Show for fear of having their preconceptions challenged, throw around phrases like "...lies all the time..." when referring to the MahaRushie. Being someone raised in a Northeastern Irish Democrat household, I've seen this too many times among my own family (though thankfully not from Mass.)and friends. But, when pressed for examples, they can never come up with them--and they usually just start in with the "drug addict", & "fat" name calling thing.
I just started listening to his show about 5 years ago, and I have found it to be grounded in logic, truth, and conservatism.
And I've also found that his grandfather is respected in MO as a serious jurist who served his state well. If they want to name a building for a judge who did a good job, I say that's their business.
It's just funny to me how libs take any chance they can to bite at Rush's ankles.

Rush Hudson Limbaugh, sr. . . .
. . . was not a political figure at all. He was an attorney and judge, known troughout Missouri as one of its finest legal minds. The courthouse is being named for him actually despite, rather than because of, his grandson's work. Rush, sr. practiced law until the day he died. At 103.

Bob Byrdbrain
I am a native of West Virginia and a graduate of the WVU School of Medicine. The state has not been renamed for the senile old coot that is its (extremely) senior senator. I am not sure of the states proper full name, but it is either "The People's Republic of West Virginia" or "West Virginia Soviet Socialist Republic." I cannot describe how glad I am not to live there anymore.

They did, however, rename the WVU Medical Center as "The Robert C. Byrd Health Sciences Center." And I immediately stopped writing checks.

To add insult to injury, WVUSM then opened "The Rockefeller Neurosciences Institute." Ironic that it is named for the junior senator, who appears not to have a brain.

Hello pot? This is kettle....
I love it when, in the course of "debate", some folks love to throw out ad hominem insults while simultaneously deploring the other side's use of them. Above, Shempy Larue criticizes Massachussets Liberal for ad hominem attacks on Rush, and liberals in general that "they usually just start in with the "drug addict", & "fat" name calling thing." But he starts the post by calling the state "Massachushits", itself a name calling thing.

Rush is pretty easy to criticize. While "lies" is a bit harsh, he does love to paint with a broad brush, does tend to use ad hominem attacks, does tend to create strawmen, and does tend to ascribe nefarious motives to the holder of many ideas with which he disagrees. I would say that Hannity has taken the Rush formula and brought it to new extremes.

Want examples? In the case of Hannity, he mischaracterized the whole Dubai Ports deal. In the case of Rush, I've heard him say that those that agree with gay marriage are liberals who are REALLY trying to undermine traditional marriage. I know for a fact that's not true because I'm in favor of gay marriage, and I'm no liberal (unless you consider it in the classical sense) -- I'm a free market capitalist who believes that the purpose of government is to protect individual liberty, not to protect "values" (whether they be "traditional", "family", "Judeo-Christian", "progressive", or other). I certainly don't want to undermine traditional marriage, and I don't know of anyone who does; the people I know who agree with me (and I know we're a minority) are mostly straight people who see it as a problem with the government picks and chooses groups on which to confer special rights and priveleges.

Anyway, sorry to get off on the tangent there. Ultimately, I would hope we could keep the debate on facts and philosophy, and stay away from the ad hominem attacks.

Stossel and I Agree On Something!
This has long been one of my pet peeves - ever since I first laid eyes on the "Brendan Byrne Arena" in New Jersey. And from the various Robert Byrd named pork barrels across West Virginia, to the Ronald Reagan fetish through the 90's, we've gone way overboard with this.

I think the rule should be - no Federallly Funded project gets named after a living person. If after he/she dies, we decide we want something to remember them by, then by all means memorialize them.

Re: Hypocritical comments
As a MO native, I would like Mass. Liberal to show me the hypocrisy he thinks he is pointing out. The article is about politicians naming buildings after themselves and/or their colleagues. The supposedly hypocritical thing he points out is that a building in MO is named after one of its favorite sons, a person who meets the standard criteria for being honored with a landmark namesake. He is 1) deceased and 2) well-known and liked in the area in which he is being honored.
This is exactly the type of person that buildings are to be named after, regardless of his descendants. Just as you cannot hold the child accountable for the sins of his father, you cannot hold the ancestor accountable for the actions of his descendants. Whether you like Rush Limbaugh or not, this does not change the facts about his grandfather.
So please, show exactly wherein the hypocrisy lies with this situation.

How about we compromise
And at least, like the Baseball Hall of Fame, wait until they've been retired at least 5 years. Then, if anybody still thinks their great, we can name something after them.

Stop it!
If this goes through, how am I ever going to get that Redhead Bridge built to the Redhead Memorial Library over the Redhead River along side the Redhead Highway??

The Comedy of It
It's especially funny when politicians name things after themselves (or their buddies) and then go bad. Ask a Las Vegan. Tule Springs Park got its name changed to Floyd Lamb State Park. Floyd was from a powerful Nevada family and had been a state senator. Then Floyd got himself convicted of attempted extortion, but the park still carries his name. Provides a little comic relief.

Subtle Graft...

...and insidious bribery. Local union or business "leaders" have been known donate $5K-$10K-$25K, to the local hospital, in the name of a council person, mayor or county supervisor. This buys a bronze plaque that perpetually greets you as you enter the lobby of the hospital. The local politician gets "humanitarian" campaign advertising for free, the union or business a tax write-off and and the politicians vote. No one is the wiser in Torrance, California, USA.

No ships named for the living, either
We shouldn't name naval ships after the living, either. Until the USS Ronald Reagan was launched, we didn't. But the time-honored custom was to name vessels after the deceased, as a way of honoring them. And similarly, custom is not to put the living on coins, at least in a republic. It is a whiff of tyranny to put a living person on a coin--even if it's Elizabeth II--it's not consistent with republican (small R, folks) principles.

And how about renaming the airport for Reagan, when he was still alive.

Please don't misunderstand--I think Reagan was a great President, perhaps the greatest of all of our Presidents, excepting maybe Washington, but I'm old-school, and I didn't think it was right. But our vanity and our hubris are part of our humanity, I guess.

Rush lies
I'm laughing so hard I can't comment on anything else.....You wish. Even the liberal left can't catch him......Hell they use his material and reference him all the time.....

Edifice Complex Prevention Bill
I agree this Bill should be passed, but with one exception and that would be to allow the Congressional Men's Rooms to all be named the Senator Ted Kenney Memorial Out Houses.

Throw into a hat
The names of every serviceman, police officer, and firefighter killed in the line of duty.

When you have something that needs naming, pick one.




karoden, I hear Kennedy..
...will be the voice of the talking urinal cakes in all the bars....

Byrdland
It will be a cold day before either Senator from WV would support this legislation, no matter how desperately it is needed. As a resident of WV, my husband and I did have some disagreement during the lead up to the November election. He thought that Massey Coal executive Don Blankenship was trying to buy votes by donating to primarily republican candidates. I asked him if he thought that Sen Byrd was doing anything less? At least Blankenship wasn't buying votes with taxpayer monies. There is a difference.

Memorials to the Living
If the mother's milk of politics is money, than the mother's keester caress of politics is memorials. Where I live it is hard to drive a public road, or visit a public building that has not been named for some free spending politician, with a passel of relatives on the "Road and Building Naming Commission".

Ski

Norman Y. Mineta International Airport
.
Sign Up to Post Your CommentsSign Up to Post Your Comments
If you are already registered, click here to login. Otherwise, please take a few seconds to register with Townhall.com. Once you sign up, you’ll be able to post your comments immediately, use the action center, get podcasts, and more!
Note: Fields marked with a red asterisk (*) are required.
Salutation:
First Name:
*
Last Name:
*
Email:
*
Nickname:
*
Note: Nick name will be shown when you post comments.
Address 1:
*
Address 2:
City:
*
State:
*
Zip:
*
Phone:
      
Your daily must-read of conservative columns, cartoons and news. Coulter, Sowell, Krauthammer and more.
(Bi-Weekly) We highlight the best opportunities from our partners for surveys, action items and more.