Townhall.com, Where Your Opinion Counts
Talk Radio:   Bill Bennett   Mike Gallagher   Dennis Prager   Michael Medved   Hugh Hewitt   
BREAKING NEWS  LeftArrow - Townhall.com : Conservative, Political, Republican   RightArrow - Townhall.com : Conservative, Political, Republican  
Columns, funnies & more in your inbox!
  • Check the boxes and send us your email address to receveive your free newsletter
  • Your daily must-read of conservative columns, cartoons and news. Coulter, Sowell, Krauthammer and more.
  • Townhall.com’s weekly inside scoop on what’s happening behind the scenes in the world of politics. When news breaks, we report.
  • Signup to receive the latest daily Townhall cartoons
Friday, May 09, 2008
John Hawkins :: Townhall.com Columnist
The Republican Party's Real Problem In A Nutshell
by John Hawkins
Vote on It:
Average Vote:
[+] Text [-]
 
Poll
Will the Dems' health care Christmas Present to America be an improvement or detriment to our health care system?


It goes without saying that the GOP is taking a dreadful thrashing right now. Conservatives are unmotivated, Democrats are obliterating Republicans in the fundraising arena, and the GOP's poll numbers have dropped off a cliff.

George Bush, the face of the Republican Party, has an approval rating of 30% and according to Rasmussen Reports, one of the best polling agencies in the business, 41.4% of Americans consider themselves to be Democrats while only 31.4% say they are Republicans. Worse yet, voters trust the Democrats more than Republicans on the economy, government ethics, the war in Iraq, health care, Social Security, education, immigration, and abortion. Yes, the GOP still has an edge on taxes and national security, but how are Republicans going to compete in 2008 if they cede all those other issues to the Dems?

That's something Republicans in Congress are just going to have to figure out. How do you win elections when your supporters are unenthusiastic, people are sick of your political party, and money is in short supply? Unfortunately, in 2006, the answer was, "You don't."

In 2006, Republicans lost 6 seats in the Senate and 30 seats in the House. Although it's far too early to say for sure, judging by the direction the political winds are blowing, it wouldn't be the least bit surprising if the GOP loses another 4-6 seats in the Senate and an additional 10-15 House seats this time around.

So, why does the GOP seem to be trapped in this recurring political nightmare?

There are a plethora of different reasons for it: the war in Iraq, gas prices, a soft economy, George Bush's lack of communication skills, corruption scandals, the illegal immigration brouhaha, nominee John McCain, out-of-control spending -- you can go on and on.

However, there is one overriding problem that dwarfs all the others, a problem that few people in the leadership of the Republican Party seem to have come to grips with. That problem is that conservatives, who are the heart and soul of the Republican Party, no longer believe that the GOP has their best interests at heart.

That's not to say that there's no difference between the two parties -- because there is. That's not to say that the country would be better off if John McCain loses; it most certainly wouldn't be. That's not to say that the Republican Party isn't more conservative than the Democratic Party; without question, it is.

That being said, does the Republican Party adequately represent conservative interests? No. Do George Bush and John McCain's values and beliefs match up well with those of the average conservative in the Party? No, they do not. Does the machinery of the Republican Party -- the RNC, the NRCC, NSCC -- treat conservatives fairly and do a good job of representing conservative interests? Not at all.

In other words, to many conservatives, the Republican Party has ceased to be an organization that serves their interests and has become merely an allied organization that shares many, but not all, of the same critical goals.

That may seem like a small distinction, but it's an important one. Conservatives will stay up late volunteering for a campaign, give until it hurts, and crawl over broken glass to put candidates in Washington who're "on their side."

However, it's a totally different ball game when we're talking about mere allies. Why give money and spend precious time volunteering on the campaigns of people who are going to turn right around and cut you off at the knees on spending and illegal immigration once they get to DC?

In other words, the attitude towards the GOP has become, "He may be a son-of-a-b*tch, but he's my son-of-a-b*tch." That's what today's Republican Party is to most conservatives: our sons-of-b*tches.

........Which brings us, as conversations of this sort usually do, back to Reagan. Why did conservatives love Reagan? Certainly, he was a great President, but he departed from the conservative orthodoxy on more than a few occasions. Reagan signed an abortion bill when he was governor of California, the debt exploded under his watch, he raised taxes, he signed an amnesty bill, and Iran-Contra was certainly a big scandal. Yet conservatives, who were just as serious about their principles back then as they are today, supported him ferociously when he was in office and revere the man's memory.

Why?

Simple: because there was never the slightest doubt in the minds of conservatives that Ronald Reagan shared their values and was doing everything within his power to use conservative principles to make our country a better place. So, when Reagan did something that conservatives disagreed with, they figured he was just doing what he had to do for the sake of politics and didn't hold it against him.

Republicans today don't have that luxury because the assumptions that conservatives made about Reagan have been reversed. If a Republican does something that pleases conservatives, they often assume that it is being done for political purposes while deviations from the conservative norm represent what Republicans really want to do.

Until the Republicans can repair that breach of faith and convince conservatives that the GOP has the same goals as conservatives do on issues like spending, the size of government, and illegal immigration, the Party may win some battles, but it's going to slowly, but surely lose the war for the future of our country.

Share:
Vote on It:
Average Vote:
 
About The Author
John Hawkins is a professional blogger who runs Right Wing News, Linkiest, and Viral Footage.
 
TOWNHALL DAILY: Sign up today and receive Townhall.com daily lineup delivered each morning to your inbox.
You Hit The Nail On The Head
I'm a former Republican turned Independent; now I don't send $ to the RNC or any other R organization. When they call looking for donations, they don't listen when I tell them I won't support them financially until they support conservative candidates.

That main message doesn't seem to have gotten through to them.

Well! Color me shocked!
Finally!

Someone who writes a column for TH actually gets it!

Five stars, without reservation.

Bravo
Great article. You sum up my feelings very well. Republicans are just as treacherous as the Democrats these days and they seem to have forgotten about the average schmoe who is working hard to make ends meet. They fall all over themselves to give big business whatever they want -- even at the expense of the man-on-the-street.

I used to consider myself a Republican. No more. Now I'm an independent. And now, I'm even starting to wonder if I'm a conservative. If these turncoat Republicans in Washington represent the new brand of conservatism, then I want no part of it.

Just as an FYI, the illegal immigration fiasco was the straw that broke the camel's back for me. It's beyond me how the party of so-called "fiscal conservatism" and "law and order" and could push for amnesty of 12-20 million (or more) unskilled, uneducated lawbreakers when anyone with half a brain knows that the illegal aliens we have now cost the country much more in benefits than they will EVER contribute in taxes. That's a suicidal position that can only be explained away as a big wet kiss to their wealthy corporate contributors. Well, screw them. I've had it. I'd rather vote for a Dem over McCain. At least a Dem would stab me in the FRONT.

Departments
I'll know we have something when a party truly stands fo the elmination of the Depts. of Energy, Education, Health and Human Services and a myriad of other extra-Constitutional fiscal sinkholes. These agencies produce NOTHING positive. This party will, of course, DO something to secure our borders and maintain the Anglo culture which made this nation a success.

In short, we are in desperate need of patriots in all levels of government. Instead, we have ego-driven lawyers interested only in their own agendas who will prostitute themselves to maintain positions of wealth and power in both major parties.

A curse on both their houses!

...
"If ever time should come, when vain and aspiring men shall possess the highest seats in Government, our country will stand in need of its experienced patriots to prevent its ruin"

Samuel Adams


Mr. Hawkins, terrific
column! Thank you for stating the truth and accurately capturing what so many conservatives are thinking right now. There are not enough TH columnists who are willing to say what you have said...and for that I am thankful.

The only disagreement I have with your column is that conservatives are not the only ones concerned about illegal immigration. +70% of Americans oppose it, and many of these are Democrats (including a few Democrat legislators like Heath Shuler.)


natbr to expand on your last
point, about illegal immigration. I think the current Republican leadership would find no shortage of votes if they stuck to conservative principles and had the courage to educate the general public on how conservative policy enhances and promotes the ideals most Americans hold dear.

Agree with all above
Especially with regard to illegal immigration and spending. I have never, ever felt so betrayed by my party, and my president, as I did last year when they were pushing amnesty down our throats. And to have the gall of insinuating that those who opposed them were racists was going way way way too far. That's liberal territory.
My financial support of the RNC stopped at that point for the foreseeable future. I'm not going to spend my hard-earned money to provide the belt with which I get whipped.
Also, I did vote Repub (so chill out, all of you "if you don't vote, you are just as guilty as the libs" scolds).

But hey, I have yet to see any change in attitude. "Throw all the bums out" is a cliche, to be sure, but that is an understatement. What we need is a high-pressure, high volume national enema!!

Over 90 per cent
That's right. Over 90 per cent of the incumbents were re-elected over the last couple elections. This is a message the pols can't ignore, the bottom line. It says "If you want to be re-elected, keep doing what you are doing". So they do. The only way we will see change is if voters throw out incumbents. Obama may become our next POTUS merely because he is a symbol of change. If similar symbols were available for every race, we would see at least a lot of new faces. But even new faces might well not be enough. It wasn't in 94. Several things have to happen to return the country to prosperity and leadership. The socialist lotus eaters have to be educated in a scenario where conservative principles can't be blamed. Bush has made this dificult over the next few years. McCain in the WH would make this impossible for at least a decade.

just for the sake of change?
Savage99,

change just for the sake of change is dangerous. I think many of these conservatives are just whining and baby-crying. The economy is not so bad given the trend that we are likely be at the down cycle of business cycle (well, the housing crisis is inevitable regardless who is in power because the price correction has to happen). The war on terror is confusing because the conservatives themselves don't have a solid idea as what to with that. Spending, ok...but is it what you really care about in this life? Spending is something that will be corrected in the future as well. And taxes, don't we have lower taxes with the conservatives in power? Illegal immigrants. Ok, what is the solution anyway? First, secure the border, then solve the legal status of the illegals.

Whining is not the solution.


Wake up!
George Bush, the face of the Republican Party, has an approval rating of 30% and according to Rasmussen Reports, one of the best polling agencies in the business,>>

Harry Truman left office with his approval ratings even lower than Bush's, and today is seen as a great president. Running away from BUsh is stupid, as we have no place to go, but home. Lest we forget, Bush also had the highest sustained presidential approval rating in our history, and history is remarkedly kind to wartime presidents.


41.4% of Americans consider themselves to be Democrats while only 31.4% say they are Republicans. Worse>>

Reality check. For most of the last fifty years republican identification has run about 10 points less than democrats. Nothing new here.

yet, voters trust the Democrats more than Republicans on the economy, government ethics, the war in Iraq, health care, Social Security, education, immigration, and abortion.>>

WE all know that republican positions on every one of these issues is the majority position. When the unwashed masses realize that Obama will raise taxes in an economy he says is in recession ... McCain wins on the economy. The war in Iraq is the most important issue of all, and one has to wonder about a man running on judgement, because he was against the war when 70% of americans supported the war. Ask yourself: Does Obama have superior judegment, or would he be the last guy in the country to pull the trigger on a serious threat to the nation? On the war ... McCAin had better win.

If republicans can't get motivated enough to stop Obama and a Lefist takeover of the country ... then the good ol' USA is gonna look a lot like France, and it a very short time. Wake up, get movtivated, or get out of my country!

No Solutions
This isn't going to get fixed. We have a populace that sees government as the answer. No matter what problem government meddling has created a majority believe that more government meddling is the cure.

A really bad thing will have to happen before people come to their senses.

We are stupid and we deserve what is happening to us.

RNC
and its affiliates have been chasing my few SSD funds for over six months by phone and mail. I finally let my answering machine answer the phone and NRC mail goes in the circlar snail and e files.

Think it through.
I have this irresitible urge to slap some sense into my conservative brothers.

Wake up! Sitting out the election because McCain doesn't measure up to your conservative ideals ... is pompous and excedingly foolish. Are you really going to sit on your hands while Obama and a democrat congress gives us universal healthcare? Clue: Once you give people a government handout (social program) you can never take it back. Is your statement really worth the price?

Will my conservative brothers really sit back and watch Obama grasp defeat from the jaws of victory in Iraq? Clue: The reason we have not been attacked in the US is it's easier to go play Jihad in Iraq. Iraq is where we win or lose the war on terror.

Not working for McCain, is not the way to change the party ... but it is the best way I can think of to ruin a court conservatives have been building for forty years. I can see the young, make it up as you go, judges Obama will appoint, and I'll blame Rush and his idiots. For Christ sake think! Use that bump between your shoulders for something more than an ideological blow hole!

Buddy can you spare
a swift kick in the arse, to all RNC that want my dime!
Great article. Read my mind. Incumbents that stay that way really do so with impunity. Well, it's often the devil or the deep blue sea. What other viable choices other than "D" or "R" in the booth. Well, maybe we'll fiddle while Rome burns.

mega dittos
I am also a former Republican now Independant, searching for a more acceptable party. The Republican Party started when people abandoned the Whig's. What are we going to call our new one?

Agree With Thomas J Gassett
I was going to write some posts telling conservatives to stop being politically stupid, but Thomas J Gassett has already made what would have been my points.

There are plenty of very good things about John McCain that should cause conservatives to stop whining, as Hawkins does in his article, and work hard for John McCain.

what caused loss of faith in brandname?
I can't believe some are counseling to not run away from G.W. Bush.

His approval rating has been in the mid-20s to 30% for a prolonged period now.

Americans identify Bush with the Iraq war.

By a by a 2:1 ratio Americans think the war was not worth the cost. They've concluded the war was a mistake.

They resent expenditures for Iraq at a time when they are having more and more difficulty in providing for their own families.

Meantime, 70 billion or more of Iraqi oil funds sit idly in banks, while Americans poney up more and more for Iraqi reconstruction.

Spiraling, out of control gasoline and energy costs occurred while Bush was in office.

The evisceration in the value of the U.S. dollar, resulting in a loss of Aamericans' purchasing power, occurred while Bush was in office.

Radical spikes in the cost of food(partially due to the idiotic decisions by congress and this administration to subsidize corn-based ethanol), also occurred while Bush was in office.

By huge margins, Americans think our nation is on the wrong track(right track-wrong track polling).

Only because the Democrats are likely to field a candidate whom many small town Americans believe to be scornful of their values, and saddled by a 20 year association with a racist demagogue who despises America and the white race, is the GOP heir-apparent even competitive, given the last 7 1/2 years.

But I would caution against aligning with Bush.

Americans will reject a third G.W. Bush term.

They don't want anymore of that.

G.W. Bush and GOP congress have destroyed the Republican brandname.

That's the cold hard truth.


Iraq war and domestic....
issues are not really joined at the hip. We should not sacrifice national security because of problems at home. If we leave Iraq now Iraq will be used as a platform to export terror all over the globe and that would include this country. I have talked to soldiers that have come back from Iraq and they cannot believe the lies the mainstream media tell. They question why their victories have not been documented and essentially only the deaths of the American military. They tell me that the enemy casualties and defeats are tremendous but not put in the news. It appears that the left believes it is more important that the military is unsuccessful because that makes Bush look bad. We now have a political party that functions on hatred of the other party.

Boutte
You really should lay off the bald faced lies.

Ron Paul supports were and are allowed to post at RWN. The problem is that so many Paul supporter tried to highjack the threads. The subject could have been underwater basket weaving for fun and profit and some Paulnut would show up with some long winded, off topic, idiotic rant. Then get all huffy when their post got removed. John allows people of any political persuasion comment, but there are some rules. And Paulites have proven to be the worst rule breakerS. Even worse then the far left moonbats.

And by the way, Paul doesn’t, nor has he ever stood a snowballs chance in hell of becoming POTUS.



Republican Problems
hmmm. Should I vote for a thief, a liar or the flim-flam man? I, too, once proudly labeled myself as Republican. Abraham Lincoln remains one of my heroes, fomative to my understanding of Liberty. However, no longer do I donate time or money to the RNC. It is evident that my fidelity was not reciprocal. God forbid that the RNC would firmly state its unwavering support for the Bill of Rights ("Strict Scrutiny"). Rather, "reasonable" (by who's judgements?) restraints upon these rights are acceptable.

Come November, I think I will vote for my ex-wife or the Libertarian nominee. How else remain honest and get the attention of the thieves, liars and charlatans?

Hawkins
"That may seem like a small distinction, but it's an important one. Conservatives will stay up late volunteering for a campaign, give until it hurts, and crawl over broken glass to put candidates in Washington who're "on their side." "

You mean like those "cult-like, wingbat, Paulnut, Paulbot, Paulpots, Paultards, kooks, truthers, and *liberals*" supporters of Ron Paul that you and the RNC were *ever so kind* to?

THAT'S where your grassroots die-hard conservative soldiers went. YOUR party told them to take a hike. Now you can hit the pavement and empty your OWN pocketbooks for John MCAN'T yourselves.

And guess what, Don_KOS? John McCain doesn't stand a snowball's chance in hell of becoming president either, so wipe that smug liberal smirk off your face, whydontcha?

8-}
Boutte writes ~ don_cox and Vindex writes ~ Don_Kos.


Thanks for proving my point.

By the way. I happen to agree with much (not all of) what Dr. Paul expounds. Unfortunately his views that I don’t share are way to far out there.

Ron Paul’s biggest problem is the rabid Paul supports (like yourselves) who drove away those who might otherwise have taken the time to look at and listen to Dr. Paul


How nice
of the party to *allow* those "paultards" to *pretend* to participate in their party. Look at how charitable the republican party is! They even set up the childrens table for them to play games, while the *serious adults* made plans without and against them. How very nice of them.

Good luck winning without us.

Missing a few members and a few dollars, lately?

Are you really too stupid to know why?


Grassroots Party Takeover
We need to de-fund the Republican party at the national level. We should identify true conservative candidates who are running for the House and Senate---and send them our money instead. If we can at least stop the bleeding in Congress, we can minimize the power of whomever is elected in November. Frankly, that may be as good as it gets.

We don't have to send money to the national party to get McCain elected. Somehow, some way, there will be donations to the party on that level. But if enough conservatives withhold their financial support, they will get the message---especially if there are enough conservative votes in Congress to stop the silliness McCain is likely to support with regard to immigration "reform." IF NOTHING ELSE, THE PLAN SHOULD BE TO INSTITUTE COMPLETE AND TOTAL GRIDLOCK. WE WOULD ALL BE MUCH BETTER OFF IF NOTHING EVER "GETS DONE" IN D.C.

We need to vote for John McCain because he will be the lesser of two evils. We have to realize that sometimes, we get just half the loaf---and in this case, it would be better than having the Democrat (Socialist) Party in the White House. Remember, McCain is getting up there in age. Who knows what his health will be in four years? Far be it from me to hope that little knot on his jaw gets bigger or anything like that. :~)

Don_KOS writes:
"... and profit and some Paulnut... "

And THANK YOU for proving our point.

John, I have one problem
with your analysis.

You state: “…the Republican Party has ceased to be an organization that serves their interests and has become merely an allied organization that shares MANY, but not