Townhall.com, Where Your Opinion Counts
Talk Radio:   Bill Bennett   Mike Gallagher   Dennis Prager   Michael Medved   Hugh Hewitt   
BREAKING NEWS  LeftArrow - Townhall.com : Conservative, Political, Republican   RightArrow - Townhall.com : Conservative, Political, Republican  
Columns, funnies & more in your inbox!
  • Check the boxes and send us your email address to receveive your free newsletter
  • Your daily must-read of conservative columns, cartoons and news. Coulter, Sowell, Krauthammer and more.
  • Townhall.com’s weekly inside scoop on what’s happening behind the scenes in the world of politics. When news breaks, we report.
  • Signup to receive the latest daily Townhall cartoons
Friday, September 14, 2007
Joel Mowbray :: Townhall.com Columnist
How Fatah Primed Palestinians for Hamas
by Joel Mowbray
Vote on It:
Average Vote:
[+] Text [-]
 
Poll
Will the Dems' health care Christmas Present to America be an improvement or detriment to our health care system?


The tidy Western view of Palestinian politics coming down to Islamists versus secularists faces yet another reality check.  Both Hamas and the supposedly secular Fatah are engaging in a new propaganda war, each portraying itself as the defender of the faith, while accusing the other party of defiling Islam, according to a recent report from the Palestinian Media Watch.

While the competing videos represent just a recent snapshot of the bitter struggle between Hamas and Fatah for Palestinian hearts and minds, it is indicative of the increasingly Islamic tenor of the culture that each group is attempting to stake out the Islamic high ground.

Though some are quick to blame Hamas for this state of affairs, it is Fatah, at the original direction of famed secularist Yasser Arafat, who is most responsible for Islamicizing Palestinian society.

After showing the destruction of a Gaza mosque caused by Hamas gunmen, the Fatah video has a close-up of a desecrated Qur’an with a grenade and bullet shells on top, and asks the question, “Whose grenades are these?”

Fatah’s video even goes so far as to say that the Islamic Jihad terrorists killed in the attack were “martyred” by Hamas—terminology typically used to describe a Muslim who is killed by an enemy of Islam.

The video was released around the same time as an Hamas production that portrayed Fatah as rats removing women’s head coverings and literally burning Qur’ans.  Rather than using actual footage, though, the Hamas video is entirely animated.  The surprisingly professional cartoon features a hero, representing Hamas, that bears striking resemblance to Simba, the title character in Disney’s The Lion King.

After the Fatah rats dance in their money and fire rockets at mosques, the Hamas lion defeats the rats, then stands on a hilltop looking off into the distance, with a Palestinian flag flying nearby.

This latest tussle demonstrates that Hamas has improved impressively upon the tactics long utilized by Fatah. 

Upon taking the reins of Palestinian society following the 1993 Oslo Accords, Arafat implemented an aggressive platform of Islamic indoctrination, beefing up Islamic education in the schools and giving new prominence on television and elsewhere to fire-breathing imams, including many who called for Islam to topple the West. 

Tapping into the ascending worldwide Islamist political movement, Arafat used his newfound power to create a new generation of terrorists superior to the old-school PLO thugs in one key respect: These post-Oslo brainwashed Palestinian kids were not only not afraid of death, but they actually wanted to die.

But Arafat couldn’t merely indoctrinate the children.  Sane parents would never allow their children to blow themselves up, so Arafat carefully cultivated a cult of martyrdom that permeated Palestinian society.  Much attention in the West has been paid to the hero worship of successful suicide bombers, but almost as important was the glorification of their parents. 

Of particular symbolic significance has been Mariam Farahat, better known as Umm Nidal, or Mother of the Struggle, who bursts with pride that three of her six children died as Islamic terrorists. Though embraced and praised over the years by Fatah, she is now a Hamas member of the Palestinian legislature.

The Islamization spawned by Fatah has now taken on a life of its own.

Anecdotal evidence coming out of Gaza—where Western journalists are no longer stationed—is that the area is in many ways starting to resemble fundamentalist Islamic police states Saudi Arabia and Iran.  More and more men reportedly are sporting religious beards, and few women are venturing outside without a veil.  Hamas thugs are also out roaming the streets scouring for un-Islamic activities, even recently breaking up weddings of Fatah members and accusing the celebrants of being “Jews,” according to PA-TV reports translated by Palestinian Media Watch.

This increasing radicalization could have implications beyond Gaza’s borders.  Last March, Palestinian Authority President Mahmoud Abbas warned that al Qaeda had infiltrated Gaza, and at least one prominent Arab newspaper echoed that claim.

The Egyptian government maintains that the attack on the Red Sea resort of Dahab in April 2006 was perpetrated by operatives who received weapons and explosives training in Gaza.  The terrorists who struck Dahab belonged to Musab al-Zarqawi’s al-Tawhid wal-Jihad, which was later renamed al Qaeda in Mesopotamia.

While there is not strong evidence of ongoing coordinated operations between Hamas and al Qaeda, the two groups share similar theologies, worldviews, and burning hatred for the United States.  Dore Gold’s latest book, The Fight for Jerusalem, explores this budding alliance.  The photo appendix also provides evidence, including a poster distributed by Hamas operatives with the images of both Hamas founder Sheikh Ahmed Yassin and Osama bin Laden.  Then there’s bin Laden loyalist Sheikh Abd al-Majid al-Zindani speaking at a March 2006 Hamas fundraiser in Yemen.

The billions of dollars in U.S. aid lavished on the Palestinians should have built support for the United States, but in fact, the reverse has happened.  Why?  Because Arafat and his Fatah party enjoyed full U.S. support as they radicalized the Palestinians.

Many argue that while severely flawed, Fatah is the only viable option.  But every day Fatah is in power—in the West Bank, at least—Islamic indoctrination of Palestinians continues.  This means that every day, the “secular” Fatah is leading Palestinians further and further away from acceptance of living side-by-side with a Jewish state of Israel.

Consider the following excerpt, taken from a textbook used at Fatah-run schools (translation provided by Palestinian Media Watch):

“The Ribat for Allah is one of the actions related to Jihad …The persistence of Palestine’s people on their land in these days, and their persistence against the damage and the aggression they endure – is one of the greatest of the Ribat [defending the border areas of Islam], and they are worthy of a great reward from Allah.… 

“The reason for this preference is that the momentous battles in Islamic history took place on its land [Al-Shaam – includes Israel] and, its residents are found in a constant struggle with their enemies, and they are found in Ribat until Resurrection. The history testifies that: The battle of Al-Yarmuk decided the struggle with the Byzantines, and the battle of Hattin decided the struggle with the Crusaders, and the battle of Ein Jalut decided the struggle with the Mongols.” [Islamic Education, grade 12, p. 86-87]

Thus the madness continues, as U.S.-backed Fatah leaders frantically attempt to keep pace with the deeply Islamic society they helped create.

Share:
Vote on It:
Average Vote:
 
About The Author

Joel Mowbray, who got his start with Townhall.com, is an award-winning investigative journalist, nationally-syndicated columnist and author of Dangerous Diplomacy: How the State Department Threatens America's Security.

Be the first to read Joel Mowbray's column. Sign up today and receive Townhall.com delivered each morning to your inbox.

Warren, Warren, Warren
"Hamas announced it was giving up suicide attacks and offered a 10 year truce,"

Let's stop right there.

Do you actually believe that Hamas has ANY intention of being true to its word?

The day Israel left the Gaza strip a few years ago - on the very DAY - Hamas IMMEDIATELY set up in the territory in civilian areas and started firing missiles into nearby Israeli civilian areas.

This whole thing is not always has been and always will be about whether or not the state of Israel has the right to exist.

Warren Small
Wow! that must be a new world record for you. You very quickly slipped into a grand conspiracy theory and anti-semitic rant. Not our business? Really? Ridiculous! Let me guess, you see someone getting mugged you turn a blind eye because it not your business. Well it's the left of this country that wants to go into Darfur, yet that's not our business either, or is it?

Simplemindeness
The link between the evidence here and the conclusions tends to be a bit weak. Fatah formed and has drawn its support in terms of Arab nationalism. Unfortunately for them Arab nationalism has taken a few blows in the middle east of late. One is the failure of the Oslo process. For 7 years the Palestinian Authority cut violence in Israel, while Israel expanded settlements in the West Bank. Not surprisingly this did not endear the peace process to the Palestinians.

The other blow was the decision to respond to an attack on the US by Islamic fundamentalists by removing an Arab nationalist ruler in Iraq. It is not surprising that people who hate America have come away with the view that Islamic fundamentalism is a stronger force than Arab nationalism.

Hamas developed as a religious counterweight to Fatah's arab nationalism, and has generally been helped to grow (whether purposely or not) by Israeli policies designed to weaken Fatah. Israel has long suffered under the delusion that if Fatah is weakened the Palestinians will come crawling to them to accept some kind of permanent second class status. In reality they turn to Hamas which looks stronger in comparison every time Fatah looks weak.

But is it surprising that Fatah would try to undercut Hamas on religious grounds? That is what our new allies in Anbar are doing with al qaeda in Mesopotamia. It is hard to imagine anything less revealing.

Similarly, Hamas, which is religious fundamentalist was recently attacked by al qaeda leadership for putting Palestinian interests above muslim interests in general. To equate these groups is to over simplify things in the way that leads to idiotic wars that involve American deaths while making us no safer.

Warren Small
"If your people had been robbed of their historic territory, expelled, forced to live in squalid refugee camps for 60 years and given no hope of any return...."

The Palestinians' plight is not much different from that of other groups around the world, except that because the U.S. is involved, leftists have insured that it is made into a huge deal.

Robbed of their territory? How about Greeks who were robbed of Constantinople by the Turks?

People expelled from their homes? How about those Chinese who were forced to go to Taiwan after the commies took over China?

Forced to live in squalid refugee camps for 60 years? That's just rhetoric. Those aren't camps. They're cities in Arab countries that refused to integrate the refugees. OK, I don't know of any parallels elsewhere, but it isn't to Israel's discredit that Arab countries treated Arab refugees that way.

Can't return to their old homes? Nor can the Chinese who fled to Taiwan. Lots of people in Europe have suffered this fate, but we never hear about it because the U.S. isn't to blame.

warren small
You keep getting smaller. Your idiotic opinions border on the "just plain stupid".

Check your history hotshot, the palestians have no more claim to that area of the ME than do the Knights Templar.

Hamas is an Iranian
surrogate like its brother Hezbollah in Lebanon.

By the way, Arab nationalism took its last breath with the collapse of the USSR. That is why terrorist Arafat embraced Islamism as an alternative focus.

The mythical 10-year truce, acc/to two Islamic schools - another only two years, is the maximum time frame allowed by Sharia Law to honor a deal with an infidel. All schools concur, however, that the truce is only granted to provide the time necessary to strengthen Islam and that it is temporary in nature. All schools hold that it may be unilaterally revoked when expedient.

You may think these notions are silly, but Muslims take them dead seriously. They are serious and you are dead.

Uncle Max
In defense of the claim that Hamas wouldn't keep its word you write,

"The day Israel left the Gaza strip a few years ago - on the very DAY - Hamas IMMEDIATELY set up in the territory in civilian areas and started firing missiles into nearby Israeli civilian areas."

I don't expect Hamas would keep its word anymore than it felt it was in its interest to do so, but why do you think your quote provides evidence that Hamas is less likely to keep its word than others.

Israel rather pointedly did not pull out as part of a deal with anyone and certainly not Hamas. Hamas naturally believes that it was its actions that drove the Israelis out of Gaza for security reasons. What then is supposed to be dishonest about their trying to build on that success?

I'm baack
Lon - I used that fact as one which showed that Hamas' word is worthless. Not to mention that they are continually

Warren - Israel is outnumbered by about 100-1 in the whole ME yet they have survived. They have had democratic elections since the beginning. They are our friends - they can be trusted. If forced to pick between them and the Palestinians I would pick them every time.

JFP - Thanks for that fact - 'They're cites in Arab countries that refused to integrate the refugees.'

Recommended reading - Weekly Standard, 9/17 'Jew-Hatred and Jihad - The Nazi Roots of the 9/11 Attack'

muslims
their are no palestinians just more blood thirsty arabs who want to kill jews and christians.there is no peace process with muslims not now not ever the only way to stop the muslim from killing you is to kill them first.

Uncle Max
I am still missing the connection. If you used the quote to show they are murderers, it would make sense. But Hamas never said it would not use an Israeli pullout of Gaza to launch rocket attacks against Israel. So it does not seem that their doing so shows that thier word is worthless.

Hamas did make numerous cease-fire claims at previous points during the second intifada and as far as I can tell they generally kept them until members of their leadership were assassinated by the Israelis or killed in operations against them. And to my mind that is a legitmate cause for ending a cease fire.

The terrorism and the desire for a religiously defined state seem to be good reasons to hate Hamas. But your evidence that they don't keep their word is not actually evidence of them not keeping their word.

Warren Small wrote:
“The "right to exist" of a foreign country doesn't keep me awake either. Countries keep changing their names, borders, constitutions and populations. Fact of history and Nature. Israel (born 1948) is not one I would bet on for a long life, given its current form, but so what?”

It’s getting late in the day, but Warren’s comment above corresponds to my attitude so precisely I can not resist commenting on it.

Why indeed does the “right to exist” of some rinky-dink foreign country be of any possible concern for true American citizen?

Somewhere down this thread a poster remarked: “If you saw someone being mugged, would you ignore it, blah, blah …

Personally, it would depend on who is being mugged. If it was the town scoundrel, I would not only ignore it, I might saunter by and give the “victim” a couple of licks with my VA issued cane.

I purposely mentioned the VA, because I’m sick of fighting other people’s wars!


For Lon
Hamas' claims of "ceasefire", they were oft firing rockets from Gaza towards Sderot--and experimenting on them to improve range and accuracy; they never waited for Israel to bump off their membership/leaders.

And you miss the fact that Muslims are quite inculcated about "Qubaitiya" (a place where Mohammed signed a 10-year agreement with the Quresh tribe; he attacked the Quresh one year later, extirpated them, and claimed THEY had violated the pact); this same type of deception was also used by that Egypt-born demonic thugocrat Arafat--as revealed by English-Canadian journalist Peter Worthington shortly after Oslo.

Also, has anyone seen a non-Muslim country that:
(1) PREVENTS one of its citizens from entering his own country (more than one example of Muslim countries doing that)?
(2) DEPORTS (or re-deports) its own citizens?
(3) REMOVES citizenship from one of its citizens who simply changed religion, and didn't even leave the country? (done specifically by Kuwait in 1995 to "Robert Hussein", a then-recent convert from Islam to Christianity).

(1) and (2) both done by Pakistan--in 1979, Abdus Salam was denied entry at Lahore on returning from Stockholm after receiving Physics Nobel Prize; and you've also heard of the recent attempt of Nawaz Sharif to return to Pakistan!

For Uncle Max--I've more than once mentioned that the ONLY covenant Hamas or Fatah consider sacred is the blood-covenant Haj-amin Husseini made with Adolf Hitler!

Bush
Bush is such a moron to support these people. He has assisted in the founding of two Palestinian terror statelets: a Hamas one in Gaza and a Fatah one in the West Bank.

No doubt he's been persuaded in this by his Saudi friends.
Sign Up to Post Your CommentsSign Up to Post Your Comments
If you are already registered, click here to login. Otherwise, please take a few seconds to register with Townhall.com. Once you sign up, you’ll be able to post your comments immediately, use the action center, get podcasts, and more!
Note: Fields marked with a red asterisk (*) are required.
Salutation:
First Name:
*
Last Name:
*
Email:
*
Nickname:
*
Note: Nick name will be shown when you post comments.
Address 1:
*
Address 2:
City:
*
State:
*
Zip:
*
Phone:
      
Your daily must-read of conservative columns, cartoons and news. Coulter, Sowell, Krauthammer and more.
(Bi-Weekly) We highlight the best opportunities from our partners for surveys, action items and more.