Townhall.com, Where Your Opinion Counts
Talk Radio:   Bill Bennett   Mike Gallagher   Dennis Prager   Michael Medved   Hugh Hewitt   
BREAKING NEWS  LeftArrow - Townhall.com : Conservative, Political, Republican   RightArrow - Townhall.com : Conservative, Political, Republican  
Columns, funnies & more in your inbox!
  • Check the boxes and send us your email address to receveive your free newsletter
  • Your daily must-read of conservative columns, cartoons and news. Coulter, Sowell, Krauthammer and more.
  • Townhall.com’s weekly inside scoop on what’s happening behind the scenes in the world of politics. When news breaks, we report.
  • Signup to receive the latest daily Townhall cartoons
Tuesday, December 30, 2008
Janice Shaw Crouse :: Townhall.com Columnist
Getting Away With Murder?
by Janice Shaw Crouse
Vote on It:
Average Vote:
[+] Text [-]
 
Poll
Was the Copenhagen Global Warming Summit Walk-Out a Win for the U.S.?


Nearly 800 deaths in Maryland remain classified as “undetermined” — meaning that the medical examiner cannot identify a cause of death for the victim.  In other words, based on the available evidence, the state’s medical examiner cannot rule out any of the four manners of death (accident, suicide, homicide or natural causes).  The families of the victims are left with ambiguity about the cause of death and are unable to experience closure regarding the loss of their loved one. 

Those victims’ cries for help were never heard, and their silence in the grave condemns us all.

Over the past decade in Baltimore, according to Baltimore Examiner reporter Stephen Janis, an average of 300 deaths per year were classified as “undetermined.”  This is something of a national record and certainly not one that Baltimore can brag about.  [In comparison, Janis reports that only 76 deaths in Washington, D.C., were classified “undetermined” in 2004.]  Medical examiners explain that it is impossible to determine if the death of a drug addict is caused by an intentional or accidental overdose or from the work of another person.

The families and friends of victims think that the lack of an investigation into the cause of death shows disrespect for the victims and a total disregard for those caught in the awful webs of criminal activity in the nation’s cities and back country areas.

As part of its investigation into the deaths of prostituted women, the Examiner filed a Maryland Public Information Act request for the names of women whose deaths remain “undetermined.”  They found that 26 women with histories of prostitution were victims of homicide in the last 10 years and that 19 of the cases remain unsolved.  Relatives believe that another two deaths of the prostituted women are homicides of their loved one.

The families of the victims, along with community activists, plan a candlelight vigil at 6 p.m. on Wednesday outside the office of the Chief Medical Examiner in Baltimore.  These families are hoping that the vigil will highlight their “open wounds” and the pain that they are suffering because of the ambiguity surrounding their relative’s death.

If she had not died just before Christmas after a brief, intense battle with pancreatic cancer, Norma Hotaling would be right there on Wednesday evening standing vigil in Baltimore. 

After overcoming her own childhood sexual abuse and drug addictions and escaping her life as a prostituted woman and slave to a brutal pimp, Norma Hotaling resolved to transform her own horrible experiences into realistic help for others who were exploited in prostitution and rendered invisible to authorities and polite society.  Her efforts provided dignity and services for those caught in the “multitraumatic” evil that is prostitution.

By founding the SAGE Project [Standing Against Global Exploitation], a service agency for all survivors of sexual exploitation, Miss Hotaling rescued and restored hundreds of people who previously had no hope.  As an innovative and passionate leader committed to ending the commercial sex trade, she rescued girls who had lost their personhood while serving as a sex slave to some evil pimp or criminal network.  Her social programs have been replicated nationwide.  She was especially concerned about those, like the victims in Baltimore, who were headed for an “undetermined” death.

Norma established services led by peers — those who had “been there, done that” as she explained — who could help those who felt that they had no hope.  Norma became the voice of survivors of commercial sexual exploitation.  She worked to dissolved myths about prostitution. She sought to prove that prostitution was the world’s oldest oppression rather than a so-called sex worker’s profession.  She worked to end the claim that prostitution is a victimless crime.  She established “john” schools that taught first offenders about how prostitution harms women and communities.  She was a beacon of courage and an extraordinarily effective champion of victimized and marginalized children and women.

She also worked to teach public officials how to help victims — not by providing condoms and emotional support, but opportunities to get out of the bondage to pimps and criminal networks and the opportunity to heal and be restored to the same quality of life that freedom offers to all. She received numerous awards for her work, including recognition for Oprah Winfrey as an “Angel” who works to better the lives of others.  Norma Hotaling used her public speaking platform to describe experiences from her own prostitution that moved her audience to tears while educating them about the cruelty of prostitution.  She made it clear that almost everyone in prostitution had a burning desire to get out. 

Norma could have ended up a tragic statistic, but she turned her tragedy into heroism.  She urged people to stop treating human beings as commercial commodities.  She advocated for those who had no voice — just like those who stand in vigil in Baltimore in recognition of the humanity of those hundreds of anonymous women whose deaths seemingly warrant no investigation.

Norma used to say that caring for prostituted persons was like caring for orchids.  She said, “They die so easily.  But you take the dead-looking stem to someone who knows orchids and that person can look at the root and say, ‘Look!  There's still a little bit of life here.’”

On Wednesday in Baltimore, family and friends will ask public officials to recognize the humanity of those who died before they could be restored.  In memory of Norma Hotaling, I pray that Wednesday evening’s vigil will be successful in getting that message through to the Maryland bureaucracy that the cries of those victims of cruelty and inhumanity will finally be heard.

Share:
Vote on It:
Average Vote:
 
About The Author
Janice Shaw Crouse is a former speechwriter for George H. W. Bush and now political commentator for the Concerned Women for America Legislative Action Committee.
 
TOWNHALL DAILY: Be the first to read Janice Shaw Crouse's column. Sign up today and receive Townhall.com daily lineup delivered each morning to your inbox.
Some not so correct points
Undetermined, as to the cause of death of many people is a GOOD call.

Undetermined leaves open the door to charging someone later on if evidence is developed a crime was committed.

And overdose deaths are always a hard call. Many can be suicides, accidents, or deliberate.

Not calling a death that is probably a suicide, undetermined on occasion, is a tool used to give the decedent the maximum amount of latitude possible in the description of the death.

I saw 30 plus years of this stuff. The author could have made a far better case for herself about this issue in many more effective ways.

Agree with anderson
I definitely think the exploitation of women and girls as prositutes is a serious matter. We should these women get out of this lifestyle if at all possible. But I don't see how a sloppy cause of death determination achieves that. If a person dies of a drug overdose, and there is no witness willing to come forward, it is virtually impossible to determine whether it was suicide, accident, or homicide. A determination not based on all the facts simply leaves the medical examiner open to a very effective cross examination by any good defense attorney.

oops
sorry that last post was so sloppy. trying to do three things at once...

19 out of 3000
So Ms. Crouse decides to focus on the deaths of 19 female prostitutes out of 3000 undetermined homicides (i.e., an average of 300 over 10 years in the Baltimore area). Apparently the deaths of the other 2981 or so persons, obviously MEN, don’t merit Ms. Crouse’s ire.

That being said, a recent NPR-televised news program talked at length about the international “human trafficking” epidemic & pointed out that the clear majority (around 80%) of said trafficked chattel were enslaved boys and young men meant for harsh agricultural work. Unfortunately, this fact is lost on Ms. Crouse and the rest of her ilk who subscribe to the knee jerk “men=oppressor/female=victim” like her left-wing counterparts. The fact that the majority of the exploited are boys doesn’t concern individuals like Ms. Crouse when there are a handful of women to save in a sea of expendable boys.

"Death by Open Borders"
Should be printed on the thousands of death certificates of those who die at the hands of illegal aliens, whether on purpose or by DUI, copies sent to the president and leaders of both chambers of congress.

Thomas Andres
Sierra foothills

Drugs
Since the uncontroled advent of drugs in the late 50s, life and death will never be the same. Most criminal deaths today are caused by the use of drugs or the uncontrolled distributiion of drugs. When you become controlled by drugs you loose your identity in life and become simply a statistic in death. I don't know the answer to the problem. We've lost so many good people to drugs, brilliant minds, beautiful people and wonderful friends...Sad.....

good for her
A couple of comments make valid points about Crouse oversimplifying the issue of undetermined verdicts. But I am still glad to see her standing up for the least among us in society. I see that so rarely on this site that it should be applauded where it happens.

To Lon GOOD FOR U!!
As I've stated to myself many times and to u on a post "U say a lot of words, but not much substance and mostly negative at that."
But this time I totally agree >>Have a good day!!

FAIL SAFE SOLUTIONS TO THE PROBLEM
Because there are no real life "Monks" available, it is, therefore, virtually impossible to solve the crime of murder in many instances, so the way to deal with murder is to emphasize prevention rather than spending all our time ineffectively trying to solve it.

The way you prevent it is to deal with the crime, drug and alcohol problems with which it is nearly always associated. There is one and only one effective way to do that...execute all those involved in serious crime, illegal drugs and the manufacture/sale of alcohol at every level, and that without appeal.

Sink their drug boats, shoot down their drug airplanes, destroy their marijuana crops and slaughter their mafia financiers. Then blow up all alcohol production plants and shut down places where alcohol is sold and consumed. Finally, we would need to prevent its importation entirely using whatever means necessary.

Serious criminals should be executed rather than imprisoned. When they are released, they simply go back to their previous life of crime and induce others to join with them.

Eventually we will run out of drug dealers, mafia drug lords, alcohol manufacturers and retailers, alcoholics, drug addicts and serious criminals. No more drugs, no more alcohol (which is actually a drug), very few prostitutes, extremely low crime rate and an annual murder rate in the teens if that many...problem solved permanently.

If we are not willing to take these admittedly extreme measures, then there is absolutely no other solution short of praying down a massive spiritual awakening that will shut down the drug and alcohol businesses and eliminate crime, prostitution and murder.

ColinCody
I'm going to have a smoke with my vodka, please don't chase me down. You'll make my wife really sad, not to mention my kids and grand-kids.


ColinCody
Happy New Year! :)

Usually agree with your posts but I'm with Vita on this one; I'd hate to think it would be wrong of me as a believer to send my brother a bottle of good Scotch for Christmas, when he as a fellow believer enjoys that as his adult beverage of choice.

Wine gladdens the hearts of men, saith the Psalmist! :)

Victims of government meddling 1
Victims of drug use and prostitutes are all victims of government refusal to recognize the most fundamental of all private property rights; a person's ownership of his or her self. This property right is synonymous with liberty, and is therefore the foundation of all other property rights. The government has no moral or constitutional authority to dictate to me what I may or may not ingest. Neither do they have moral or constitutional authority to govern my personal sexual conduct. Consenting adults are inherently free to engage in whatever activity they desire, as long as they don't interfere directly with the liberty of their neighbors to do the same.

Victims of government meddling 2
Bring back liberty and most of these indisputably tragic consequences disappear. Our current policy of depriving consenting adults of their liberty in order to "save them from themselves" does absolutely nothing to save them from themselves, but does succeed in making the very brutes responsible for their murders and overdoses fabulously wealthy, while providing lucrative employment for the most violent and despicable members of our society. While restoring liberty will not prevent folks from making stupid decisions regarding their own bodies and souls, it will certainly reduce the destructive results of those personal decisions to their lowest possible profile.

Victims of government meddling 3
Stop persecuting people for being stupid or resign yourself to building more and more prisons. Respect liberty (the right to be wrong) and the societal and moral costs of this immoral behavior will be decimated. Our police will be able to focus on violent crimes against persons and property, rather than the morally indefensible practice of chasing down and incarcerating people for the legitimate exercise of their own ownership of themselves. Our idiotic and ultimately ineffective policies regarding drugs have resulted in the corruption of entire nations, enriched the most despicable of our own citizens, to say nothing or our enemies like the FARC or the Taliban, and may even have exacerbated drug use and prostitution, by making them far more profitable in the black market than they ever could be in a free market.

They love to brag
Everyone who does something their proud of loves to brag about it to anyone who will listen. Even if it's about killing some one. Investigated cold cases some times aren't solved with new technology, but going back and interviewing some one who says I knew but I kept quiet because I feared for my life. It doesn't matter if it's been ten or twenty years, that person will still fear for their life, or say they say. I just hope backlogs aren't being put aside hoping that just lab work will solve crimes. There's nothing like pounding the pavement and personal experience in solving crimes. Technology can get good result, but they can't ask the right questions.

value each individual’s humanity
What a cold city we live in here in Baltimore. As a director of a program that works with homeless drug addicted women, I am extremely concerned that the exact number of drug addicts who die from heroin or cocaine intoxication may be underreported because the manner of death is listed as undetermined. We should be alarmed by the lack of clarity on such a volume of deaths of our most vulnerable citizens. I am also concerned that the number of women murdered in Baltimore is far more than last year, going from 24 in 2007, to 31 in 2008, according to the City Paper. At Power Inside, we work to assist drug addicted women who have little access to shelter, drug treatment, or health services at the very moment they need it most - when they want to get off the street and ask us for help. Despite our attempt to assist them, we must send them back out into the cold to sleep in abandoned houses until we can find them a precious drug treatment or shelter slot that can take weeks to find. All the while, they are routinely raped and assaulted by both strangers and intimate partners with no realistic way to report life threatening crimes against them. While the social behavior of our clients may be troubling or even illegal due to their drug use or prostitution, they do not deserve the death sentence consistently metered by our collective neglect. When you are homeless and addicted in Baltimore there are multiple bullets in the chamber (hypothermia, overdose, murder, medical neglect) when you play our hometown brand of Russian Rulet. Our selective attention on yearend statistics and official excuses is the finger on the trigger. My hope for 2009 is that Baltimore will not wait until the bodies roll into the Medical Examiner creating a new stack of question marks before we create real death and violence prevention initiatives informed by the realities of the streets and work harder to value each individual’s humanity while they’re still alive.

ThXs
For such a sensitive article on a sensitive and usually ignored subject. Blessings.

Undetermined!!
They aren't coming back to this case unless knocked down with evidence. Literally.
Too many say, "Why bother, he/she is just a junkie, prostitute, or alcoholic and there is no way to run down hundreds of leads when we have all these cases waiting for us"!
So, no police investigation, no determination. I am including the M.E. here, who probably knows little about forensic medicine to start with.
Sign Up to Post Your CommentsSign Up to Post Your Comments
If you are already registered, click here to login. Otherwise, please take a few seconds to register with Townhall.com. Once you sign up, you’ll be able to post your comments immediately, use the action center, get podcasts, and more!
Note: Fields marked with a red asterisk (*) are required.
Salutation:
First Name:
*
Last Name:
*
Email:
*
Nickname:
*
Note: Nick name will be shown when you post comments.
Address 1:
*
Address 2:
City:
*
State:
*
Zip:
*
Phone:
      
Your daily must-read of conservative columns, cartoons and news. Coulter, Sowell, Krauthammer and more.
(Bi-Weekly) We highlight the best opportunities from our partners for surveys, action items and more.