Townhall.com, Where Your Opinion Counts
Talk Radio:   Bill Bennett   Mike Gallagher   Dennis Prager   Michael Medved   Hugh Hewitt   
BREAKING NEWS  LeftArrow - Townhall.com : Conservative, Political, Republican   RightArrow - Townhall.com : Conservative, Political, Republican  
Columns, funnies & more in your inbox!
  • Check the boxes and send us your email address to receveive your free newsletter
  • Your daily must-read of conservative columns, cartoons and news. Coulter, Sowell, Krauthammer and more.
  • Townhall.com’s weekly inside scoop on what’s happening behind the scenes in the world of politics. When news breaks, we report.
  • Signup to receive the latest daily Townhall cartoons
Wednesday, July 11, 2007
Janice Shaw Crouse :: Townhall.com Columnist
Sex Trafficking Victims: Disposable or Human
by Janice Shaw Crouse
Vote on It:
Average Vote:
[+] Text [-]
 
Poll
Will the Dems' health care Christmas Present to America be an improvement or detriment to our health care system?


During his swearing-in ceremony at the United States State Department this week, Ambassador Mark Lagon, the new head of the Office to Combat Trafficking in Persons (TIP), declared, “It is never negotiable to treat people as less than human, as property.” Secretary of State Condoleeza Rice expressed her commitment to anti-trafficking efforts and pledged support for Ambassador Lagon as he seeks to end the practice of treating people as less-than-human.

The TIP office and hundreds of United States non-governmental organizations (NGOs), including Concerned Women for America (CWA), are working to end modern day slavery –– the world-wide practice of treating people as disposable commercial commodities. Thanks to the vision of President George W. Bush, the United States is leading the way in ending this scourge on humanity. In fact, as the ambassador noted, “A movement of faith-based groups, feminists, government officials, legislators, international agencies and brave individual advocates have closed ranks” to end trafficking. Ambassador Lagon’s remarks provided a passionate summary: “Around the world, as a function of U.S. Government leadership, there has been a real paradigm shift in awareness about human trafficking, and a sensitivity that victims are just that –– victims, not criminals or illegal aliens.”

Ambassador Lagon enumerated the variety of situations where human beings are bought and sold as commercial commodities:

“Brick kiln slave laborers in India or China are not disposable; they are people. Central American girls sexually consumed by predatory tourists are not disposable; they are people. South Asian domestic servants abused in the Persian Gulf are not disposable; they are people. Child soldiers in Burma and Uganda are not disposable; they are people. American citizens exploited in prostitution in Las Vegas are not disposable; they are people.”

We have all heard the catchy song lyrics about “what happens in Mexico” staying in Mexico or the advertisements about “what happens in Vegas” staying in Vegas. Ambassador Lagon addressed that fallacy. “What ‘happens’ in these places does not ‘stay’ in these places. It is a stain on humanity. Every time a woman, a girl, a foreign migrant is treated as less than human, the loss of dignity for one is a loss of dignity for us all.”

It was gratifying to hear the ambassador directly address the problems of American popular culture in glamorizing the “ho” and “pimp.” He said, “It’s high time we treat pimps as exploiters rather than hip urban rebels. When a pimp insists his name or symbol be tattooed on his ‘girls’ he is branding them like cattle –– dehumanizing them, treating them like property.”

There are those who would argue that human trafficking is the inevitable outcome of poverty and that some poverty-stricken people choose willingly to be involved. But, as Ambassador Lagon pointed out, “There is a growing refusal to accept enslavement as an inevitable product of poverty or human viciousness. Corruption is typically poverty’s handmaiden in cases of human trafficking.”

CWA is pleased to be among those that Ambassador Lagon called an “indomitable force.” We and other evangelical Christians are at the forefront of this battle as modern-day abolitionists who work for the human rights of women and for the dignity of all of God’s people. We agree with Ambassador Lagon that trafficking in persons “shouldn’t be regulated or merely mitigated; it must be abolished.” The victims of this crime are among the “most degraded, most exploited, and most dehumanized people in the world.” We join the ambassador in declaring, “Exploiters must be stigmatized, prosecuted, and squeezed out of existence.”

Those who treat people as commercial commodities –– pimps, madams and johns –– are slavers who buy and sell human beings as disposable goods for their brothels, factories or fields. We must work for good laws and good law enforcement that will treat human trafficking as a criminal offense that will be investigated and the perpetrators prosecuted, convicted and punished to the fullest extent of the law. Otherwise, such crimes undermine everyone’s liberty and freedom; only corruption-free democratic processes create a society where peace and prosperity are possible for all citizens.

Share:
Vote on It:
Average Vote:
 
About The Author
Janice Shaw Crouse is a former speechwriter for George H. W. Bush and now political commentator for the Concerned Women for America Legislative Action Committee.
 
TOWNHALL DAILY: Be the first to read Janice Shaw Crouse's column. Sign up today and receive Townhall.com daily lineup delivered each morning to your inbox.
dehumanizing
We human beings are so capable of dehumanizing others when we want to exploit or do away with them. I think of how African Americans were thought of as less than human so they could be enslaved; how Jews were thought of as less than human so they could be killed, how the unborn are thought of as less than human so they could be aborted, and now these who are treated as a commodity in such a cruel fashion. It is scary to think how the human conscience can be twisted to convenience.

Sounds like more feminist hysteria
This whole “human trafficking” thing leaves me with a sinking feeling. I have seem some of the numbers thrown around by the NGOs and feminist groups, and looked into how they make their make their calculations and come to the conclusions they publish. In short, I seriously think that much of this is exaggerated hype (especially when it comes to women and sex slavery).

One of the things I find disturbing is how feminist groups and NGOs insist on counting voluntary sex workers as “victims of trafficking” and “sex slaves”. When adult females choose to take a job that pays better than other jobs available, we should mind our own business… not start new government agencies and commission task forces to interfere in private voluntary transactions.

If we actually believe in sexual equality, we need to stop being so paternalistic and interfering in the free decisions of adult women. Furthermore, we need to stop treating women’s vaginas mystical temples for all of society to worship and protect. They are not angels, and it is only a body part.

I find it laughable how frequently feminists flip-flop between claiming that women are strong and roaring like lionesses, and in the next breath demanding women to receive paternalistic protection.

The vast majority of women around the world live very safe and healthy lifes as compared to their male peers. The death rates for their male peers is usually 10 times higher, yet you never hear about NGOs or government programs designed to protect men.

Grow up and stop acting like adolescents!

Johnnyp
You've not seen the vagina of a 6 year old torn and bleeding, the anus of a 13 year old fraught with infection and canker, or the teeth of an 11 year old pulled so that they won't intefere with the slamming of some guy's member into her mouth. What do you suppose these kids grow up to "choose" to earn a living?

You missed the point of the article, but I think you wanted to miss it.

oldsocialworker
As you know… those kinds of atrocities are terrible and inexcusable, and perpetrators should be punished severely.

And your misdirection referring to a rare and horrible example is a classic feminist/NGO tactic for drumming up support and donations. Y’all need to find a less transparent deception.

My irritated post above is driven by the fact that feminists and NGOs can look at a population of 5,000 sex workers and search out the 3 women who have likely been duped into that line of work, and who have particularly sad stories. Then they go to work and extrapolate out numbers using deceitful techniques, and publish a report that claims 300,000 women in “x” county are sex slaves. This report is then published and repeated by politicians and news media resulting in unneeded government programs and laws.

I agree more with johnny than janice
Equating all prostitutes as coerced sex slaves is bunk. Women in Nevada, Scandinavia and Germany along with many other places are NOT FORCED into that line of work (Usually, tho there is the RARE case.)
I expected better from you Ms Shaw.

But what bothers me is the end of the 2nd paragraph: "...and a sensitivity that victims are just that –– victims, not criminals or illegal aliens.”

EXCUSE ME??? If a woman (girl or boy) is kidnapped from BFE and brought to America illegally - that person IS an illegal alien. I would do all in my power to get that person back home, but that does NOT change his/her status. I may even be MORE INCLINED to grant that person asylum because of the conditions - BUT, again, until such action is taken, the person is an ILLEGAL ALIEN.

Another point to be made for tightening the border. If drug/human traffickers are kept out, maybe we can get a grip on our own people who exploit those poor migrant and factory workers.

Nice useless photo
The photograph, which is barely enlargable, and almost completely illegible, appears to show a TABLE OF CONTENTS. Beneath this photograph is a long description about how the aforementioned table of contents mentions that brothels were provided under the heading of "amusements", and that the Japanese showed Americans how to enslave women for sex. All these accusations might be true, but I'm not particularly impressed by this piece of "evidence".

Indeed, after close examination I seem to be able to recognize that the words "Amusements" and "Brothels" (or at least words of similar length and composition (Amazements? Brothers?)) exist in the document.

Couldn't we have a nice picture of a scholar who has researched this claim and puts his/her name (and professional reputation) on the premise?

You are right that feminists
often try to make exceptional situations the rule. The reality of child sex slave industry is more wide spread than you think. I find self-proclaimed feminists busy themselves with nonissues such as meddling with school budgets around Title IV, women in the military, and club memberships.

There are women who choose protitution and a differentiation ought to be made. However, that is a mutually exclusive situation from the breeding and selling of girls (and boys) for the purpose of sex slavery, which has gained enormous ground over the past decade.

oldsocialworker
Thanks for your comments...

The prostitution of children is a sad sad thing. Luckily many (if not all) governments take significant steps to seek it out and prosecute offenders. I cannot understand how an adult could be sexually aroused by a child… but that is another topic.

I would like to see some reliable info on child prostitution (how widespread, where, when, why...). The reports I have seen seem to be sensationalized. One of the techniques for sensationalizing these reports is to state an overall statistic, and then use an example of a nine-year old victim.

I am sure these sensationalized report grabs attention and achieves the writer’s objective. But the downside is that many well meaning people become jaded after they find out they have been duped multiple times. There is a material difference between a 9 year old and a person 17 years, and 300 days old. Another technique is to categorize all prostitutes who do not have readily available and credible ID handy, as minors. It is not uncommon in poor underdeveloped countries for large portions of the population to not have credible ID on their person. It is not like the US where nearly every person you see can produce multiple cooberating forms of ID within 3 minutes (driver’s license, SS card, credit cards, vehicle registration, employer’s ID, voter’s registration card…).

I am all for solving problems… but I am against hysteria for political purposes. NGOs need donations to grow and thrive. Feminists strive to win and maintain the highest level of victim hood status for political advantage (anything that demonizes men works to that goal). And the current administration does not like prostitution. This is a perfect storm for disinformation and distortion.

"Thanks to the vision of President
George W. Bush, the United States is leading the way in ending this scourge on humanity."

Funny, I thought that the whole point of the immigration bill he pushed was to essentially enshrine this practice in American jurisprudence.

Johnnyp,
your comments may be more accurate in the North American context, but not world-wide. Having lived for a year in Asia, believe me it is very prevalent. What doesn't get talked of anywhere near enough is how so many young people and children get into the industry. They are sold into it by their parents.

They are either sold directly to work as a sex worker, or sold off as 'wives', not really much difference except the number of 'customers'. I knew some American expats in Thailand, and they would tell me of mothers frequently coming up to them with their 14 year-old daughters and telling them what great second wives they'd be.

I remember reading about the actions of a couple of BBC journalists who were doing a story about child trafficking in the sex trade. They found a couple of 13 year old girls and were so moved that they purchased their freedom from the madam and wanted to bring them home. They were quite surprised to learn that their parents had been the ones to sell them. They had quite the problem there, what do you do with the girls then?

But really, how could they be surprised? This has been going on forever in these countries. It was even a MASH episode for cryin' out loud. Wonder if Burt wrote that one?

re: thoughtadventure
My life has viewed much more examples that you put forth than any feminist agenda, as others have mentioned. Even today, we have a variety of the world's downtrodden being shipped into the southern California area as sex slaves.

Pointedly, I wonder at the people that continue to justify this activity because of any plausible reason. In my opinion, if any reason for capital punishment was displayed outside of murder, this is the crime.

Exploitation
Why dwell on the contemporary sex trade or slave labor? This world's history has been inextricably tied to slavery and dominion of the few over the many, as in feudal times when the Lords literally owned their vassals. Do away with absolute rule everywhere and you will still have the hoi poilloi kowtowing to the rich and famous. It's a part of life in this world. People are getting bought and sold right under our very noses every minute of every day, especially in Washington. Stop picking on foreigners. That's just a way of turning your backs on your own problems.


JohnieP
Where do you think a good number of the teen runaways end up Both male and female? Cold and hungry on the streets. A nice guy called a p!mp comes up and offers them a hot meal and a warm place to sleep. We all know the moral of that story.

"choosing" a line of work
"Where do you think a good number of the teen runaways end up"

Thank you for posting this! No little girl dreams of the day she'll get paid for anonymous sex or take her clothes off in some other setting for strangers in exchange for money. Those "choices" are overwhelmingly a result of violence, usually sexual violence, done to a girl at a young age. Besides that, even if someone "chooses" to put him- or herself in a degrading or unhealthy situation, a decent person STILL wouldn't defend it or contribute to it. You don't help people have violence done to themselves, even if for some pathological reason, they have put themselves in the situation.
Sign Up to Post Your CommentsSign Up to Post Your Comments
If you are already registered, click here to login. Otherwise, please take a few seconds to register with Townhall.com. Once you sign up, you’ll be able to post your comments immediately, use the action center, get podcasts, and more!
Note: Fields marked with a red asterisk (*) are required.
Salutation:
First Name:
*
Last Name:
*
Email:
*
Nickname:
*
Note: Nick name will be shown when you post comments.
Address 1:
*
Address 2:
City:
*
State:
*
Zip:
*
Phone:
      
Your daily must-read of conservative columns, cartoons and news. Coulter, Sowell, Krauthammer and more.
(Bi-Weekly) We highlight the best opportunities from our partners for surveys, action items and more.