Townhall.com, Where Your Opinion Counts
Talk Radio:   Bill Bennett   Mike Gallagher   Dennis Prager   Michael Medved   Hugh Hewitt   
BREAKING NEWS  LeftArrow - Townhall.com : Conservative, Political, Republican   RightArrow - Townhall.com : Conservative, Political, Republican  
Columns, funnies & more in your inbox!
  • Check the boxes and send us your email address to receveive your free newsletter
  • Your daily must-read of conservative columns, cartoons and news. Coulter, Sowell, Krauthammer and more.
  • Townhall.com’s weekly inside scoop on what’s happening behind the scenes in the world of politics. When news breaks, we report.
  • Signup to receive the latest daily Townhall cartoons
Sunday, October 28, 2007
Jackie Gingrich Cushman :: Townhall.com Columnist
Learning from Dogs
by Jackie Gingrich Cushman
Vote on It:
Average Vote:
[+] Text [-]
 
Poll
Will the Dems' health care Christmas Present to America be an improvement or detriment to our health care system?


A few weeks ago, while visiting my husband’s grandmother, I noticed a book about dogs called “Cesar’s Way” on a side table in her living room. I thought this was a bit strange as she has no dog, but, since my husband and I were planning to get a puppy for our family, I borrowed it.

I began reading that night and was instantly engrossed. While not a specific how-to book, it offers valuable insight into how to be a good dog owner and how to create an environment that will increase the probability that your dog will be happy, healthy and well-behaved.

Cesar Millan’s approach is to focus not on changing the dog, but on changing the owner’s thoughts, approach and habits in interacting with the dog. He recommends that, rather than treating the dog as we would a human, we should treat the dog as a dog. Instead of wondering why the dog sometimes does not behave, we should bear in mind that a dog is an animal first, then a dog, next a member of a particular breed and, finally, a dog with a name.

In other words, it is not the dog’s approach to us that needs to change, but our approach to the dog. By taking a different approach, we can evoke a different response from the dog. Isn’t this true in other parts of life? While we might want to control others around us, it is helpful to remember that one has control only of oneself. This is most apparent when one works hard, creates habits and rituals and is disciplined. By controlling one’s own thoughts and actions, one can affect others’ and, in turn, their interaction with us.

Cesar continually repeats that exercise is the base of all other dog activity; that an unexercised dog is an unhappy dog. The minimal recommendation is for an owner to ensure their dog exercises for a half a hour twice daily. This is to ensure that the dog is expending enough energy so that it will be able to relax and behave during the rest of the day.

I find this concept of exercising to provide an outlet for energy that would otherwise be turned into uncontrolled behavior to be true for my children as well. A bit of time to run around and expend energy allows for focus and concentration for children as well as dogs. I am reminded of this on days when errands and commitments get in the way of activity, and we all get restless.

According to Cesar, after exercise and discipline, owners must take into account the dog’s natural pack mentality and the impact it has on the owner-dog relationship, especially when it comes to discipline.

Cesar writes that dogs view all interactions from the point of view of a member of a pack. A pack leader sets rules and boundaries, which is the job of a dog owner in a good relationship. Without clear rules, boundaries and leadership, a dog becomes stressed and unsure of how to act, often acting inappropriately.

I find element to be helpful when communicating with other people. That it is important to look at events and activities from the other person’s perspective rather than one’s own perspective. I also know that I often get so consumed with my perspective that I forget that there are others.

Cesar mentions the importance of the owner projecting a calm, assertive energy to convey to the dog that the owner is in charge, is in control, and is the leader. This aura of confidence radiates between people as well as from people to dogs. People are drawn to follow others who are able to project this calm assertive energy. It is simply quite a challenge for me to maintain this perspective at all times.

Finally, Cesar talks about affection – but only as the third element of an owner-dog relationship, after exercise and discipline. Cesar contends that humans often project their desires onto their dogs, in the belief that if one needs a lot of affection and attention from one’s dog, then the dog must need and desire the same level of affection as well. While certainly affection is good and appropriate, it makes for a happy dog only in the context of exercise and discipline.

This is the hardest element for me, remembering that my own need for affection should not get in the way of what might be best at a particular moment in time. Not to smother my child with affection if they run into any difficulty, but to allow them to learn and gain strength on their own.

Last weekend, armed with a new perspective, new information and a new approach, we acquired a new puppy. Midnight is a 7-week-old black Labrador. To say she is cute is an understatement. For the last few days, we have focused on leading so she will follow and providing her with enough exercise to expend her pent-up energy and grow stronger. She is receiving plenty of affection.

Currently, Midnight is quietly sleeping in her crate. She ran after the children before school this morning. I am hopeful that, after expending a bit of energy themselves, my children will focus on learning and the dog will continue to sleep, at least for today – and then we can begin again all over tomorrow, trying to incorporate what we learned and where we made mistakes the day before, continually learning from a dog.

Share:
Vote on It:
Average Vote:
 
About The Author
Jackie Cushman is a freelance writer who lives in Atlanta, Georgia. Her column also runs later in the week in the Northside Neighbor.
 
TOWNHALL DAILY: Sign up today and receive Townhall.com daily lineup delivered each morning to your inbox.
Another wonderful book is,
"Horse Sense for People" by Monty Roberts (the horse whisperer).

I do think we as a society have fallen into rewarding the very behaviors people need to change.

reality check part two
Now, if only people would treat Muslims as Muslims and not act they their desire for world wide domination by force is the same as the Christian "great commision". Then we might get somewhere.

Training of social animals
Cesar's show interests me due to the phenomenal overlap between dog and horse training. From my background with horses, yes, there is a lot in animal training that can be applied to people. It's all about conditioned behaviour. ;)

One thing I don't think Cesar emphasizes enough is reward of good behaviour. He's more dominance oriented than positive reinforcement oriented. It's natural to notice the misbehaviours that annoy us and to want to correct them. But then we silly humans often take for granted the good behaviours. Dogs and horses (and kids and employees) learn very quickly how to use bad behaviour to manipulate attention. Therefore, it's important to remember to pick the battles wisely, ignore the trivial misbehaviours, and reward the heck out of the behaviours you want repeated. Consistently. No form of training (or influence) works well without patience, clarity, and consistency. And inoring or taking for granted good behaviour and good efforts will kill a willing attitude.

Uncle Max
I am not only chief of staff for Eloise but maitre d' and chief cook! But she is very intelligent for a cat. Mama was rushed to the hospital Saturday night with what we thought was a stroke and now don't know what the heck it was (she has almost completely recovered from it, for which God be praised.) Eloise sleeps in my loft bed with me, and usually when I get up she is right there to assume it is time the day was beginning; but through several telephone calls and ups and downs she stayed put. When I finally lay down to compose myself (at about 3:30 a.m. Sunday morning) she gave my nose one pat (multiple pats aer her usual signal that she knows I am awake and I might just as well get up) and I gave hers one pat and then we both went back to sleep.

Eloise likes to sit next to the Hot Wheels race track and when the Ferrari comes by, give it a good swat and send it flying. She never touches the McLaren. She knows we like to see Schumacher in the gravel trap!

Very nice article!
I have not heard of Cesar Millan, but many years ago when I got my dog (he picked me) I got a book on training written by a man named Kohler and he based the training on sound psychological methods.

Basically, training a dog and raising a child are very similar, except the dog can't tell on you later.

Animal Whisperers
I believe I'll write a book called Chevy Whisperer and let everybody learn how to relate to their car.
Dogs vary. Some are stupid and others less so. They like to eat good food and they like to not be killed today. Anything they can do at any given time to advance these goals they will do.
If they do something that you don't want them to continue to do, you can easily convey your point to them. Simply do what their mother, or pack leader would do. Grab them by the throat in such a way as to let them know that their life is in your hands...they won't do it again.
So much for whispering.

Steve Francis

Nam65-66
Until today, I don't think I've ever read a post of yours I disagreed with. What a shame that you've had bad experiences with our canine friends. Some twenty-five years ago when I was an idealistic lib canvassing door to door for a Public Interest Research Group (MassPIRG) I encountered a huge silver and black German Shepherd keeping watch over his yard. We sized each other up for about thirty seconds and then chased each other back and forth through his yard for about five minutes before I knocked on his master's door. That is the memory that I, as a stranger meeting a strange dog, will always carry with me. The noxious memories fade away. I wish you could have delivered his mail; that dog is long dead, but that moment in time will always be a cherished memory. Give a dog a chance, they will bring you a lifetime of joy.

Learning from dogs
I watch Cesar Millan's show, and we don't even have a dog! I highly recommend the Dog Whisperer for anyone thinking about getting a dog or puppy. What a great article.

Nam 65-66, etc.
1) Have you ever heard of mace? I saw a mailman mace my dog once and I laughed like he++. He got what was coming to him. Your post suggests that you and I wouldn't be buddies.

2) To spoil a dog, which I do, does NOT mean to ruin him. What fun is there in having a silly dog if you can't spoil him? Who wants a serious dog? Sometimes all I have to do to laugh is to think of something Spike has done or will do.

Montanalady - Who is Mickey? Why did he nip people? They might have asked for it.

Katy
What a sweetheart you must be and we know if we lived near you we would come and play. We are smaller than Bubba but we would try and behave.
Mickey and Shawn

P.S. We just moved to Montana from Texas and Mickey is getting a reputation, he has nipped a couple of people, We're starting to call him "Jaws".
I think it is just this great Mountain air around Bozeman He's always hungry.
Shawn

View from the top
Let me tell you something about that wiseass Katy.
Do you think that she consulted me before bringing in that annoying blond thing into my home?
He's OK, but that's not the point.
I've hung with this old bat for 17 rs.

Katy is such a phony!I used to kill baby rabbits and put them on her pillow.Dumb broad would scream like a freight train.

The Cat

katy
you made my day.

Thanks

Uncle Max

If we ever meet you can give me tummy pats

Spike

Had a wonderful time
reading and remembering all my fine friends, furry and not so furry. Nice way to spend a Sunday.
One thing I pray for every day is that - come the 08 election we keep our fearlessness - like our dogs have. And IF those up for election haven't been as loyal as our cats, we give them the bird.

Thanks Polly!
Enjoy him/her. They are great dogs!
The adopted kids are so happy to get out of jail!

I spent many happy years on the "sucker list" for shelters. Never had a bad one, and everyone of them blended in and got along.
My cool old mule Winston (Churchill) would always have dawgs and cats sleeping next to his fine old body.
If I had the time,the money, and the room, I'd do it all over again!

Spike and Uncle Max
Katy keeps muttering about a "road trip" to Newfoundland so I can discover my roots.
She better snap to. I'm not getting any younger, and she's no spring chicken.
We hooked up a few years ago when the boss died.
Hey, I was TOP DAWG in a breeding kennel!
All these strange people came and took my women, but kept saying that I was too old. Huh?
Katy is great, but she did whisper to Doc about taking some private parts off.AAHHCCKK!
Doc said no, too old. Whew!
I don't get the urge that often, but the poodle down the street is FINE!

Keep the faith,
Bubba

Labs rule,cats drool

Nam65-66
Two months ago we adopted a rescued 84-lb. Bouvier des Flandres. We have not yet found ANYTHING that this dog dislikes, in or out of uniform, very young or very old.

May he live, please, Sir?

Yep, I found this column quite pleasant and noticed that my blood pressure did not rise at any time during its reading. Not even reading the comments! Nice change.

(Okay, a tiny blip reading yours, Nam, or at least a slight wrinkling of my forehead.)

I pity Teehall
What a sad human being. The column was about relationships, not only dog/human but human/human. That you have so much hate you could not enjoy a thoughtful article and then end your comments with childish name calling. Please read the article again and try to open your mind. There is always hope....

Teehall, Was this about Dogs?
Great column,

To answer Teehall, the column wasnt about dogs. It was about getting along in society. Notice the book was at the writers Husbands GrandMom's house who did not own a Dog.

My opinion.

Nice comments by Peppermint too, its nice to read an uplifting piece once in awhile.

TREAT A DOG LIKE A DOG

.....What a novel idea ...as long as I don't have to drop to all fours whenever I encounter a strange dog and sniff its behind ...that's where I draw the line .....COLOSSUS

Reminds me of that movie....
"If a man answers". The mother was teaching her newlywed daughter how to train her new hubby to behave as well as her farther, who had been trained by the mother, using a manual for training a puppy.
I am terrible at remembering who was in what movie.

We have a 7 year old yellow lab, whose name is Jake which now needs to be changed to Job because of his patience and tolerance of the newest members of the mob, twin rat terriers we call Rowdy and Bubba. We also have a greyhound/blueheeler mix we call Nibbles.

We got the two new "boys" to help us over the loss our first rat terrier named Shorty was killed by a coyote. Shorty and Jake were best friends and when Shorty was killed Jake led my husband to his body. We buried him alongside Lucy the springer spaniel and Ammo the black cat who could catch and kill jack rabbits bigger than he was and drag them back to house to show to us.

Thanks Jackie for bringing back a lot of good memories and good times with the pets we love.

5 stars
Lura Helms
in the Texas Panhandle, the stepchild of the Great State Texas

Best column of the day

There certainly wasn't any competition.

And yes, treat dogs like dogs, but kindly.

And children like children, but kindly.

And all the other critters we call humans, make allowances.



Teehall
Try going back to bed. Sounds like you got up on the wrong side of it. Have a cup of coffee.

Dog lovers always like to hear other dog lovers stories. That's because we love dogs.

Nam65-66
LOL! My brother is a mailman too and has gotten his share of bites. I can commiserate with you on that one.
But, don't be too hard on the dogs. It's the owner who is at fault.

As an ex mailman...
...I can tell you without hesitation.THE ONLY GOOD DOG IS A DEAD DOG!!!!!

AudiR10
Would I be correct in saying that you are Chief of Staff for the cat Eloise?

son of 2 more cents
Ms. Cushman sounds a bit yuppie-like about her dogs. Labs don't respond well to that. They need to be DOGS. I was lucky to get Spike (at the shelter) because I was told that his original owners gave him up saying they couldn't handle him. Labs need to run and play and be goofy.

2 more cents
Doggie day care is a good thing - the dogs get to run and play and socialize and act like dogs in concert with other dogs and since dogs are for the most part herd animals they get to do their dog thing and the people who watch them make money and if you have a good daycare person, which I do, you don't have to worry about them while they're there.

Another benefit is that sometimes when you tell other people about it they get a huge laugh out of it, and that's nice too.

teehall
go to your room

without your supper

NOW!!!

Jackie
I like your article and it is nice to take a break from all the political garbage once in awhile.

After Mr. P and I got together, we have a blended family of two German Shepherds and one Corgi.

Cesar Milan also has a TV show about how to control and break your dog of bad habits. But, the whole trick is breaking the bad habits of the humans who forget that a dog is a dog and needs an alpha dog since dogs have pack mentality.

Mr. Pepperhawk's two shepherds are guard/attack dogs (trained police dogs)so when I met them my ultimate goal was that neither one of them would ever see me fearful of them.

Prior to me, those two dogs have never let anyone else near them other than Mr. P. Shadow and Foxy would rather have bitten off someone's arm than allow anyone near them, not even to pet them. No one came near Mr. P without him giving the dogs commands to stay. Mr. P has complete control over the both of them. They are extremely well trained dogs.

But, through my determination and stand of showing them I am also an alpha, they are now completely adapted to me, allow me to feed them, play with them, brush them, and pay heed to my commands.

These two shepherds are two very dangerous dogs with strangers. And, Shadow, the older male is now completely protective of me. So I know no stranger will ever get near me if Mr. P leaves the property.

Cesar Milan's way of dealing with dogs really works. And, his methods can also work on children. LOL As long as one doesn't forget that children are not dogs. Sometimes it's hard to see the difference especially in those primitive early years of a child's life.

Treat kids as kids too
I have mentioned my foster grandson before, and the difficulty his mother (who had never had responsibility for any child, much less an active little boy) had in realizing that a child cannot come home from sitting all day in school and sit passively all day in an apartment without creating a disturbance of some kind. Neither can adults, when it comes to that. I used to take my kids out in the back yard and volunteer to be the goalie while they played shinny with my old Spaldeen and a couple of beat up hockey sticks. The exercise was good for all of us.

I remember Mama evacuating us from Hurricane Hazel, which had caused the river to rise well above flood stage, when she was 25 and all of us were under age 6; she had taught us to obey the Mom Voice and when she told us to sit still in the motorboat and hold hands, we sat and held hands. She admitted long years later that she was scared out of her wits, but to us she was Mama who was in command, and if we did what she said, we would be all right. I took that lesson to heart and learned that kids will be much easier to handle in an emergency when they know adults they trust are in command.

I am not a dog person; I am a cat person. My cat thinks she IS a person. We get along fine because I respect her belief about herself and still treat her pretty much like a cat. It worked fine with the kids, and it works fine with the cat, whose name is Eloise for a very good reason.

TeeHall
I guess it really aggravates some people to have to take a break from the doom and gloom that is the political landscape right now. How dare this essayist take time to show her human side!?!?! What'st he matter? Are you a "cat person"?

What?
Does this personal story have a point to it? Want to hear my dog stories? No, I didn't think so because they are equally personal dog experiences without thrilling anyone else. Why are you writing for TH? You getting paid? Would you be there is your name wasn't Gingrich, the loser?

my 2 cents
My dad is pretty good. We live out in the sticks in Maine, on a dirt road OFF a dirt road and I pretty much have the freedom to go where and when as long as I don't abuse the privilege. It's hunting season now so he's being pretty careful, but today is Sunday so a friend of my dad's is bringing over his two idiots, aka Rhodesian Ridgebacks. Dad says they are "saps" but I don't know what that means. I think it's good. We'll all take a walk down the road to the river and dad and I will play fetch, and that's always fun too.

And dad says that I should say a thing or two about Doggie Day Care, which I love. I'm pretty friendly and at least once a week dad takes me to day care for what he calls "all day goofy" and my pals are there.

Some folks call them the silliest dogs in Maine, I call them my colleagues.

Obviously my dad can speak fluent dog, wo that too is a plus. One thing I CAN'T do is type, so I'm dictating this to him.

I'm a 4 year old Black Lab and my name is

Spike

Good points, Jackie.
I was once told that the way to train a dog was to find out what the dog was going to do, then tell the dog to do it.

Works with people, too.

One piece of advise about the
Black Labs: IF you release them into the yard to run at night - get them a reflective collar. There is NOTHING like having that dog come up and lick you when you don't even know she is there!
Crates are wonderful for dogs. Mine was kind of large and easily scared people. IF I wanted to put the people (like grandma) at their ease - sending Shadow to her crate, and watching her go quickly calmed ANY fears.
Sign Up to Post Your CommentsSign Up to Post Your Comments
If you are already registered, click here to login. Otherwise, please take a few seconds to register with Townhall.com. Once you sign up, you’ll be able to post your comments immediately, use the action center, get podcasts, and more!
Note: Fields marked with a red asterisk (*) are required.
Salutation:
First Name:
*
Last Name:
*
Email:
*
Nickname:
*
Note: Nick name will be shown when you post comments.
Address 1:
*
Address 2:
City:
*
State:
*
Zip:
*
Phone:
      
Your daily must-read of conservative columns, cartoons and news. Coulter, Sowell, Krauthammer and more.
(Bi-Weekly) We highlight the best opportunities from our partners for surveys, action items and more.