Townhall.com, Where Your Opinion Counts
Talk Radio:   Bill Bennett   Mike Gallagher   Dennis Prager   Michael Medved   Hugh Hewitt   
BREAKING NEWS  LeftArrow - Townhall.com : Conservative, Political, Republican   RightArrow - Townhall.com : Conservative, Political, Republican  
Columns, funnies & more in your inbox!
  • Check the boxes and send us your email address to receveive your free newsletter
  • Your daily must-read of conservative columns, cartoons and news. Coulter, Sowell, Krauthammer and more.
  • Townhall.com’s weekly inside scoop on what’s happening behind the scenes in the world of politics. When news breaks, we report.
  • Signup to receive the latest daily Townhall cartoons
Wednesday, May 30, 2007
Jack Kemp :: Townhall.com Columnist
Fighting a new war on poverty
by Jack Kemp
Vote on It:
Average Vote:
[+] Text [-]
 
Poll
Was the Copenhagen Global Warming Summit Walk-Out a Win for the U.S.?


To ignore the potential contribution of private enterprise is to fight the war on poverty with a single platoon, while great armies are left to stand aside. - Sen. Robert F. Kennedy

Mario Cuomo of New York electrified the 1984 Democratic Convention with his tale of America as two cities, one rich and one poor, almost permanently divided into two classes. Today John Edwards is running for president on this same platform and using the same metaphor.

But America is not divided into two cities; instead, America is divided into two separate and unequal economies, one that works well and one that is fatally flawed and must be fixed so as to combat poverty.

Our mainstream economy is entrepreneurially capitalistic: It is market-oriented and based on private property, ownership, the rule of law and with widespread access to capital and seed corn for new business ventures. It rewards work, savings, investment and productivity. This economy dominates the American market and serves as an example to the world of democratic capitalism.The second economy functions in almost direct opposition to our mainstream capitalist economy. Similar to a Third World socialist economy, it denies people an entry into the mainstream due to the barriers to economic activities along with a virtual absence of any link between human effort and reward. It perpetuates poverty, dependency and welfare while discouraging employment, and it prevents access to capital, ownership of assets and quality education. The irony is that this second economy was created out of a desire to help the poor, alleviate suffering and provide a social safety net. However, instead of independence, this welfare-based economy has led to near perpetual dependency, and the social and economic costs to our nation are enormous in terms of unfulfilled potential and dashed dreams.

As secretary of Housing and Urban Development from 1988 to 1993, I visited pockets of poverty in ghettos and barrios throughout America. I spoke personally with people living in the depths of poverty and hopelessness. I vowed then to take part in a bipartisan effort to help create an urban American Renaissance. I applaud Edwards' attempts to raise the issue of poverty and challenge the Republican candidates to join in the debate.The problem is that self-improvement and ownership of assets are discouraged by regulatory and tax policies that trap people in impoverished areas. In too many cases, the poverty that exists today is due in part to government welfare coupled with regulatory and tax policies that punish work, savings and investment and discourage ownership of assets. The system redlines certain areas of our country, limiting people's access to capital, credit, mortgage loans and well-paying jobs.

To wage a real war on poverty, we should launch a 21st century Marshall Aid Plan in the cities of America to reform education; create job opportunities; and provide access to capital, credit and ownership opportunities for low-income Americans. This plan must be based on equal opportunities to get jobs, own homes and launch businesses.

The first step is to create Enterprise or Empowerment Zones that would eliminate the capital gains tax in the newly "green-lined" zones, allow for expensing of all investment in plant machinery and technology, and eliminate payroll taxes for men and women who are first-time job holders up to 200 percent of the poverty line.

Next we need to cut the bureaucratic red tape that makes development in urban areas. We need to look at the legal barriers to production and commerce. Local impact (development) fees, application processing costs, building codes, zoning and land use restrictions, and nongrowth policies greatly increase construction costs. Instead of creating regulations that make it more difficult to build in urban areas, entrepreneurs need to be offered incentives for investing in cities.

We must develop a tax reform system that rewards labor, savings and capital formation. A sure way to harm the economy and slow growth is through a capital gains tax, which is not a tax on the rich but rather on the poor who hope to improve their situations. You can't get rich on wages. The only way to create wealth is to work, save, invest, make a profit and reinvest.Finally, we need to provide homeownership opportunities and affordable housing to the most impoverished in society who often become trapped in public housing. Through public-private partnerships with organizations such as the Federal Housing Administration, Fannie Mae and the Federal Home Loan Bank, we need to dedicate a percentage of profits to help develop work-force and affordable housing while encouraging homeownership policies to get people on the path out of poverty.

Through eliminating America's second economy and tapping into the economic forces of a more democratic system of capitalism, we can develop a formula for ending chronic poverty in America. Everyone should have the opportunity to go as high as their merit, ability, determination and quality of their performance can carry them.

Share:
Vote on It:
Average Vote:
 
About The Author
Jack Kemp is Founder and Chairman of Kemp Partners and a contributing columnist to Townhall.com.
 
TOWNHALL DAILY: Be the first to read Jack Kemp's column. Sign up today and receive Townhall.com daily lineup delivered each morning to your inbox.
Let me be the first, but not the last...
to LOUDLY proclaim one part of the solution:

THE FAIRTAX!!!!!

Let's see...who else is on board??

Let's reclaim America:

Step One: Stop the immigration fiasco. Kill Bill Vol 1.

Step Two: Get border locked down!!!

Step Three: Give illegals a two year grace period to deport themselves. Replace the illegals with AMERICAN labor and LEGAL immigrants.

Step Four: Enact the FAIRTAX!!!

Step Five: Dismantle No Child Left Behind. Leave education to the states. Encourage school choice and COMPETITION to public education.


That's my platform. Who's with me??

Kemp played too many times
without a helmet.

His proposals all sound like nothing more than sophisticated welfare, payed for by guess who?

I wonder if he's started hanging around with Edwards, or something, with the old "Two Americas" BS and all.


Hmmm...
FairTax + 7.65% Solution.

Both pieces of legislation would, of course, have to be modified to complement each other, but that wouldn't be difficult at all. If both of these were passed by Congress, it'd not only accelerate the growth of the economy, but it would produce real retirement and health funds, but it would also dramatically encourage upward mobility!

Just get out of the way
When someone from the government asked John Galt what the government could do to help him restore the world, his answer was 'GET THE HE** OUT OF MY WAY.'

That's it in a nut shell. Hurricane Katrina's aftermath presented a really good laboratory for those who want to see how to get people "trapped" in self-imposed ghettos to look after themselves. Flood their ghetto and force them out of it, and move them into communities of people who do not live like feral cats. Alabama has welcomed a large number of former slum dwellers who have been accepted into the Hyundai Express and have moved their families into good housing and good schools because now they not only can afford it, but they can see how to do it.

The kindest thing to do to people 'trapped' in fetid slums is to move them out, raze the slums to the ground, place the slum dwellers in decent middle class neighbourhoods where they and their children can see how middle class people live, and get the heck out of their way. Yes, some of them are going to remain slum dwellers in spirit and in truth. Private charity and the police can handle them. The real problem for most of them is that they have never been shown that there's any other way to live.

Representation Without Taxation
Kemp supports DC statehood because essentially he views the current situation as taxation without representation. Yet he essentially espouses representation without taxation (or at least at reduced levels of taxation) through his empowerment zones which only dole out these benefits to select areas rather than the country as a whole.

Mr. Kemp, why should any area or selected race or class of citizen be given any kind of special treatment? At the expense of other taxpayers no less. Some of your ideas have merit, but why not fight to incorporate these market based ideas into broad economic policy rather than selectively targeting them for the "poor" or "less fortunate" in specialized zones that give preferences the rest of society doesn't similarly enjoy.

the new poverty source
We would have a lot less poverty to worry about were it not for people like Kemp advocating the unbridled flow of "cheap" ILLEGAL alien labor. These largely wretched people have little hope of attaining the American dream, BUT they have every hope of bettering themselves at the expense of American taxpayers, culture, heritage and society!

They say that Presidente Jorge and many in the Senate are dumbfounded that Middle America is so irate about the pending Scamnesty. Then again, it does not take much to perplex Dubya! The truth is that the remote "elites" see the ILLEGAL invasion in theoretical terms. The massive, monied organized lobbies they hear most from make them imagine that it is a sure thing that we should naturalize 15-20 million (who would turn into 60-100 million just like them soon enough) undereducated, indigent, ethnocentric, "cheap" laborers... that America "must have them to do all of those jobs Americans won't do." THEIR children do not go to schools enervated by the ILLEGAL invaders... the rich LIKE their cheap ILLEGAL help nodding deferentially as they tend their lawns and mow the fairways at their private clubs as the "elites" walk by to climb into their Mercedes SUV's.

But Middle America in its straightforward wisdom sees through the shell game... it realizes that the teeming masses of uneducated, indigent ILLEGAL alien laborers are really only benefiting a few business owners (who do NOT pass on the "savings") at the unbridled expense of ALL... that the downside of letting them all naturalize here will be CATASTROPHIC... that Americans would be MUCH BETTER OFF if employers simply paid a bit more to hire Americans-- like they always have before. Indeed, the jobs at Armour, etc., are quickly filled by Americans after rare raids clear out infestations of ILLEGALS.

Amazingly, even the new liberal-commissioned CBC/TIMES poll just said that Americans oppose key goals of apologists for ILLEGAL aliens:

http://www.nytimes.com/2007/05/25/us/25poll.html?pagewanted=print

poll excerpts:
"Most of those polled agreed that illegal immigrants should eventually be allowed to apply to become American citizens. BUT 59 percent said illegal immigrants should be CONSIDERED for citizenship ONLY AFTER legal immigrants who have played by the rules." [Ergo, no path to amnesty!]

"In the poll, 75 PERCENT of those who responded favored TOUGHER PENALTIES FOR EMPLOYERS of illegal workers, and 82 PERCENT said the federal government should DO MORE TO REINFORCE THE BORDER."

"Among those polled, a majority of 51 percent favored overhauling the American immigration system to make it more attuned to economic demands, GIVING PRIORITY TO JOB SKILLS AND EDUCATIONAL ACCOMPLISHMENT. Only 34 percent said that immigrants with family ties in the United States should take precedence."
_______________________________________________

Middle America reads the dire warnings of Heritage about the TRUE all-in costs and gets righteously indignant against the weird Conspiracy Of Evil which attempts lamely to brand us "racist" and "zenophobic" for common sense reckonings that america CANNOT absorb masses of the undereducated poor without morphing into what those poor people are trying to flea from. SEE HERITAGE SUMMARY HERE:

http://www.heritage.org/Research/Immigration/wm1076.cfm

Comprende espanol, amigos?

Keep booing Miss America, "amigos"-- it speaks volumes!
_______________________________________________

CONTACT YOUR PEOPLE IN CONGRESS ASAP FOLKS.... TELL THEM YOU WANT TO STOP SCAMNESTY... AMERICA IS TOO IMPORTANT AND SPECIAL TO ALLOW IT TO DEVOLVE INTO A THIRD WORLD WELFARE STATE... IT IS EASY TO REACH MEMBERS OF CONGRESS RIGHT HERE:

http://www.congressmerge.com/onlinedb/index.htm

Bookmark it and contact them often! If you want subject specific messages already prepared that you can fax/e-mail, go here (a GREAT site):

http://www.numbersusa.com/actionbuffet

Jack...
who is we? You and every hardworking stiff in this coutry who have been feeding , clothing and sheltering the laggards since the Great Society fiasco by Democrat LBJ.

Guess what, Jack? Poverty, crime, dropouts, children having children, one parent families and drug addiction has quadrupled. Trillions of dollars have been wasted. It's the U.S. Government's fault the poor are trapped. Is there any use? I believe the Bible reads..."the poor will always be with us...". Mighta been true back when but, there are jobs available for anyone who wants to work! Just tell an illegal allien to take a hike all the way to the Rio Grande from whence they came...and go to work!

You might like the feeling.

pointguard
I'm with you. Sign me up.

Jack is a has-been
And for a good reason. He's still making the same emotionally-charged, factually selective stump speech he was making 15 years ago when he ran HUD. His evangelical style of conveying an idea can't hide the fact that his ideas are little more than poorly thought-out impulses.

Jack, you had your day. It's time to retire -- from politics today as from football nearly 40 years ago.

Capital Gains Robbery
Because we're handy people whose improvements to our own home have made a substantial increase in its value and thus the equity that can be tapped we thought we might buy a run-down, neighboorhood eyesore to improve and sell as an alternative to shuffling the little ones off to daycare to put me, the mom, to work and getting the teens summer jobs at the burger joint.

We discovered that captial gains taxes could eat half our profit. We might still do so, but it makes such an investment a lot riskier and makes those burger-flipping jobs more attractive.

Stop taxing money twice -- eliminate capital gains taxes for EVERYONE.

PointGuard
DAMN THE TORPEDOES! FULL SPEED AHEAD!

Mother of 4
DAMN THE TORPEDOES! FULL SPEED AHEAD!

Explanation
PointGuard - Excellent Ideas!
Mother of 4 - You'll never know unless you TRY!

War on Poverty - Kemp's Folly - AGAIN???
It is a complete mystery why this moronic article (first published on May 25 on TH) has been republished today. Perhaps it is advanced dementia on Kemp's part.

Since Kemp is not embarrasssed for this garbage to run again, I am going to repeat my criticism of it, which appeared in the comments five days ago.

Jack-

Read my lips - There is no chronic, pervasive poverty in America. While some people have more than others, it has always been so. The magic (and the curse) of America is that we have it so good that we don't appreciate it.

Our so-called poor have cars, computers, homes, televisions, air conditioning, etc. , etc., ad nauseum.

Unless you are now a Communist, it is hard to figure out what gave you the idea that in a free society everyone will have an equal amount of money, goods, brains, or anything else.

Wake up and smell the coffee. You didn't get elected President or Vice President. You don't have to create a legacy out of whole cloth.

Your "Marshall Kemp Plan" is nothing more than big government - no HUGE government. I'm not surprised that you are quoting all of the insincere, hypocritic tax and spend liberals in your piece. You obviously have become one of them!

Maybe you can become John Edwards VP choice, then when the two of you win election, you can invite all of America's chronic poverty-stricken to your mansions for gruel on Thanksgiving.

Any poverty in this country is self-imposed. I suggest that you go to one of our free libraries and pick up "Basic Economics" by Thomas Sowell. You have obviously forgotten all of the economics that you learned in college.


Small steps towards justice
I like the approach, here's why: the conservative movement believes that fair tax policies are the best approach for economic growth and government health. The best place to promote and experiment is in low income areas. We may not be able to get a Democratically controlled congress to repeal the marriage penalty for everyone, but we might be able to get them to repeal it for low-income earners. The same is true for a variety of different tax policies that hinder economic growth. The perfect place to start these policies is in low-income areas. When they work there, we can convince the nation to apply them elsewhere.

Kemp = poverty
Kemp is the typical liberal Republican, like Bush, who truly believes government can resolve problems like poverty and health care. After six years of Bush, the poor are in fact poorer. The standard of living for those not as fortunate as Bush has effectively been lowered - all to pay for Bush's compassion of expanding the welfare state. We are left with a significant increase in inflation as a result. We could expect no less from a President Kemp.

The biggest obstacle for America's poor.
...is illegal immigration, which Kemp fails to mention. The wages for those bottom-of-the-ladder jobs the poor might seek are continually depressed by illegals who can and will work for slave-level wages.

Owners of certain small businesses, agribusiness, and even some of the big corporations are happy to use the cheap labor to boost their net margins. But those who would have to start off in low-skill jobs--especially urban blacks--suddenly find that they would have to work alongside people who don't even speak English, and work for less than they could get sitting on their sofas collecting welfare.

If you want to help the AMERICAN poor, secure the border and enforce serious sanctions against those who hire illegals.

Jack Kemp
Jack really needs to understand that Democrat Welfare and Republican Welfare is WELFARE!

There will always be poor people. Not everyone will or can take the opportunity to get rich. Some are substance abusers or low I.Q. who will never get above the worker bee level.

Yet Kemp believes that somehow government handouts will magically raise all the "poor" up out of poverty.

Al least, that's what happens in the magical kingdom. Hey, Kemp, time to feed the unicorns.

Another Government Program
Kemp has been a politician too long. He is calling for yet another government program -- to fix the problems caused by all the other government programs.

When will these people learn that government IS the problem?
Sign Up to Post Your CommentsSign Up to Post Your Comments
If you are already registered, click here to login. Otherwise, please take a few seconds to register with Townhall.com. Once you sign up, you’ll be able to post your comments immediately, use the action center, get podcasts, and more!
Note: Fields marked with a red asterisk (*) are required.
Salutation:
First Name:
*
Last Name:
*
Email:
*
Nickname:
*
Note: Nick name will be shown when you post comments.
Address 1:
*
Address 2:
City:
*
State:
*
Zip:
*
Phone:
      
Your daily must-read of conservative columns, cartoons and news. Coulter, Sowell, Krauthammer and more.
(Bi-Weekly) We highlight the best opportunities from our partners for surveys, action items and more.