Townhall.com, Where Your Opinion Counts
Talk Radio:   Bill Bennett   Mike Gallagher   Dennis Prager   Michael Medved   Hugh Hewitt   
BREAKING NEWS  LeftArrow - Townhall.com : Conservative, Political, Republican   RightArrow - Townhall.com : Conservative, Political, Republican  
Columns, funnies & more in your inbox!
  • Check the boxes and send us your email address to receveive your free newsletter
  • Your daily must-read of conservative columns, cartoons and news. Coulter, Sowell, Krauthammer and more.
  • Townhall.com’s weekly inside scoop on what’s happening behind the scenes in the world of politics. When news breaks, we report.
  • Signup to receive the latest daily Townhall cartoons
Tuesday, November 04, 2008
Ira Mehlman :: Townhall.com Columnist
700 Billion (and Counting) Good Reasons to Reform Immigration Policy
by Ira Mehlman
Vote on It:
Average Vote:
[+] Text [-]
 
Poll
Will the Dems' health care Christmas Present to America be an improvement or detriment to our health care system?


Earlier this month Congress and President Bush committed $700 billion of our children’s and grandchildren’s money in a desperate effort to stave off a financial meltdown. Judging from the reaction of the markets, that sum may only be a small down payment on the real cost of decades of criminally irresponsible policies promulgated in Washington and on Wall Street.

Even from our vantage point in the midst of an unfolding catastrophe, its causes are easily identifiable: Greed and reckless expediency on Wall Street and greed and reckless irresponsibility in Washington. On Wall Street, the masters of this nation’s financial system enriched themselves by dreaming up ever more complex schemes to buy and sell debt, knowing all the while that the sustainability of these schemes depended on perpetually rising real estate values. In Washington, the people who were supposed to be the public’s watchdogs were greedily feeding at corporate troughs and, in many cases, pressuring financial markets to act even more irresponsibly to satisfy certain constituencies.

At the intersection of Greed and Recklessness & Greed and Recklessness stands U.S. immigration policy. Immigrants are not to blame for the nation’s economic crisis, but immigration policy as it has been implemented (or ignored) over the past several decades is both emblematic of and a major contributing factor to the circumstances that landed our nation in the current mess.

Immigration policies have flooded the American labor market with tens of millions of workers we neither need, nor could really afford. The net effect of decades of mass immigration was a heavily subsidized labor force that was sustainable only as long as the industries that employed them could pass the costs off to the public sector, and government could get away with borrowing vast sums of money.

As the number of immigrants grew, they, and self-anointed ethnic advocacy networks, became a political force to be reckoned with. Under extreme pressure from groups like the National Council of La Raza to increase minority home “ownership,” politicians from both parties leaned on the financial industry to make irresponsible mortgage loans, even if it meant waiving sound lending practices.

Given the mess we’re in, continued mass immigration and a massive amnesty for current illegal aliens (which both Barack Obama and John McCain support) are special interest perks that this nation can no longer afford.

An illegal alien amnesty must be taken off the table.

The bad economy coupled with a belated enforcement effort by the Bush Administration have resulted in modest declines in the number of illegal aliens, but there are still in excess of 11 million living here. The economic and social costs of implementing any sort of legalization program – staggering under the best of circumstances – would be unsustainable in light of current realities.

Amnesty would further devastate workers.

While it’s true that millions of people who would be eligible for amnesty are already in the labor market, the impact is concentrated in a few sectors. Amnesty would instantly affect the entire labor market, as millions of newly legalized workers would be able to compete for jobs even in sectors that had previously refrained from hiring them because of their immigration status.

The federal bureaucracy could not manage an amnesty.

A massive bureaucracy would be required to administer an amnesty program. The cost and manpower necessary to process millions of applications, screen out fraud, and carry out meaningful background checks, would likely costs tens of billions of dollars. In fact, symptomatic of the culture of irresponsibility that has gripped Washington, no amnesty proponent has ever bothered to even estimate the costs.

State and local governments are even less able to manage the costs of amnesty.

Most of the costs for an illegal alien amnesty would be borne by cash-strapped state and local governments. At a time when revenues are way down as a result of declining real estate values and rising unemployment, and social costs are rising because more people are using benefits and services, amnesty could bankrupt many states and localities. Nobody knows how many (because nobody has bothered to ask), but amnesty would inevitably result in millions of new kids crowding into public schools and millions of new medically uninsured relying on public health care. Because of the educational level and job skills of most illegal aliens, they would remain heavily subsidized even after they are brought “out of the shadows.”

Government mandated immigration must also be reduced.

Insanely, even as our economy has been shedding jobs at an alarming rate (some 750,000 so far this year), not only isn’t Washington adjusting legally mandated immigration downward, they are pushing for increases. Even as the economy was collapsing around them, the House Immigration Subcommittee approved a measure to “recapture” some 570,000 unissued green cards going back to 1992, while in the Senate Robert Menendez (D-N.J.) single-handedly prevented reauthorization of the E-Verify system in order to force the issuance of these new green cards. Instead of adding 570,000 new immigrants – on top of the million or so we are already admitting legally – at a time when our economy and labor market are contracting, the numbers should be reduced to reflect the harsh new economic realities.

The common denominator among all the factors that have led to this national (and probably global) crisis is the complete abandonment by financial institutions and the government of any sense that they have any responsibility beyond the next quarter’s profit sheet or the next election. Immigration is a prime example to the sort of self-interested policies that helped create the current situation, and which must be changed if we are ever to find our way out of this morass.

Share:
Vote on It:
Average Vote:
 
About The Author

Ira Mehlman is the Media Director of the Federation for American Immigration Reform.

What about the Children?
Great article, Ira. As a member of the construction industry in Phoenix, I cannot agree more. It is about time some one stated this as a FACT like you have. It is the elephant in the living room that no one sees.

There is a second part of this problem that is probably even more destructive to our economy. The children of the illegals. This is going to sound harsh, but it is true. Most of the illegals coming for work here are having thousands and thousands of children out of wedlock whom are being supported by the taxpayers. 93% of all of the child births in Arizona in 2007 were paid for by the state. 41% of the children in the Phoenix School System [which is bankrupt even though property taxes have doubled last year].

We cannot continue to provide schooling, health care, in school meals, translators, welfare, and food stamps for all of these kids. We are broke and our children are suffering. Somebody in Washington has to admit we can't afford it. We must deny birth certificates for children of illegals. I beleive that the actual number if illegals and their children in the U.S. right now is well over 36 Million. I am so sick of the 12 million number that they have been using for the last decade when a milliln more come each year.

This is why most of the people in Arizona who work and pay taxes can't stand John McCain. He can't see this problem from any of his mansions.

Can't anyone admit that the hundreds of billions of taxpayer dollars each year is too much? That we can't afford it? All the income tax that is lost to cash jobs? All the money that is sent out of the country and not spent here ? All the high school kids that can't get jobs ?

We have problems and this is a big one yet not a word about it in either campaign. Sickening.

We haven't been attacked since 9/11 but we sure have been invaded.

I the Majority had Brains
the election would have been different tonight. If dims have pushed shamnesty, hidden Fannie/Freddie, stopped energy production and pushed carbon taxing and will tax as low as numerically possible and still be elected then obviously someone's stupid. I think the red states have college kids and blacks but apparently didn't have the ACORN interest as swing states. Another thing. If we don't have military votes counting by 2010 I am calling for civil war.

odd
What an oddly contorted argument. Illegal aliens do not represent a significant part of the foreclosure mess. Even minorities in general are not the main recipient of the subprime loans, despite the republican wish that that were true.

And the account above ignores the degree to which those immigrants are paying into our social security system without pulling money out. Most accounts show that immigration is a net loss at the state level and a net gain at the federal level. But one does not get much of an accurate picture by ignoring half of it. Similarly there is no consideration of the costs of the alternatives to amnesty, as if not granting amnesty is freer than granting it.

I am not convinced that amnesty is the way to go. It was predictable with the Reagan amnesty that it would just encourage future illegal immigration, and that is equally true of another amnesty. But a less tortured argument against amnesty would be more convincing.

Two points for Lon of PA
1. The sub-prime mortgage fiasco is very much a product of the nation's diversity obsession and accompanying bleatings about racism. And the obsession, in turn, is largely driven by immigration -- now that we're stuck with all these immigrants and illegal aliens from the Third World, we're stuck with diversity, so we celebrate it and cater to it (and are called "racists" if we don't). So this was a spark in destroying mortgage standards. Then lots of whites who wouldn't have met traditional mortgage standards could get mortgages, too. (So even if the preponderance of the mortgages went to unqualified whites, these mortgages wouldn't have happened at all except for the immigration-driven mania about diversity and racism.)

These things are written about by Steve Sailer. See here http://www.vdare.com/sailer/081010_meltdown.htm
and here http://www.vdare.com/sailer/080928_rove.htm

2. A large fraction of illegal aliens pay no taxes, including Social Security, since they work "off the books" (i.e. for cash). And those who get paychecks and, therefore, have deductions are relatively poorly paid, on average. So what they put in to Social Security is quite modest in the grand scheme of things. And if these people ever gain legal status or, somehow, wind up being able to collect retirement benefits from Social Security, they'll be a financial DISASTER for the system, because low-income contributors get way more back from the system, proportionately, than the average American worker.

Immigration?
A complete E-verify system and a large fine for by-passing it will take care of the problem.
Nothing to it-except ALL babies of illegal aliens shall NOT be afforded citizenship and no relatives shall be afforded citizenship.
Problem solved.
Do you believe Obama is about to follow anything like that??
You can kiss our national sovereignty goodbye.

Affordable Housing
The mission of Fannie and Freddie has not changed, despite the financial meltdown and the multi-billion dollar bailout that mission precipitated.

Welfare Housing, aka Affordable Housing, remains a required goal of Fannie and Freddie as set by HUD regulations. These entities are instructed . . . "to implement ambitious plans to support the borrowers and markets targeted by the goals." Sept. 25, 2008, James B. Lockhart III, speaking before the House Financial Services Committee.

The American taxpayer assumes the risk, in this scheme, while the reward accrues to members of Congress whose poorer constituencies respond with their votes.

We have been made co-signers without our consent; not one of us would take on such risk on the micro-level, one-on-one. Not one of us would co-sign for high loan-to-value home-purchase loans of borrowers without credit histories, without Social Security Numbers, without income verification. Yet that is what our government has assumed on our behalf.

Moreover, Wall Street is already endorsing increased immigration to people the countless empty homes across our landscape.


If the government does not do something
and SOON,

THE PEOPLE WILL.

And, it will not be pretty or nice.

That's just the way it is.

Another problem caused by Liberals

Liberals complain about low wages then support illegal immigration that drives down wages.

Wages follow the supply and demand rule. Increase the supply of low wage workers and wages will go down.

So if your underpaid working at a minimum wage job, thank liberals.

For Scottsdale Brian @ 10:09
A note that SHOULD HAVE BEEN (but wasn't) taken by the administration on the anchor-baby issue occured in August in Canada, where two US-Army deserters had gone in 2006 claiming asylum.

First one (single), it was found out US Army had discharged him after non-return, so he faced NOTHING in terms of charges (totally erasing his claim of "persecution")--deported June 2008 to US.

The second one (married, with 8-month-old Canada-born son): Canada's government found his claim too as fallacy--and ruled him deported with the following, "if you wish to immigrate to Canada, ask your son to sponsor you after his 18th birthday" (due to his American parents, the child is a dual-citizen).

I guess that is too simple an approach for US officious to take.

LET THE IMMIGRANTS WORK! SOMEBODY MUST!
Obama plans to send $500 each to 46,000,000 non-workers and/or people who do NOT PAY taxes!

I do not know about you. As for me and my family, we will stop earning a living and paying taxes to the government. Let the immigrants pay for it!

I received my instructions booklet on how and where to apply for welfare, medicare, medicaid, social security benefits, food stamps and free food where the children attend school.

I hope to receive my very first $500.00 check from Obama real soon. In the interim I am enjoying my first day at home with my wife! Turns out I hardly knew her! It is like our very first honeymoon!

I think I will sign for the children to attend all after school programs where they can also get free food and enjoy the comraderie while the bride and I are enjoying each other.

I understand now why there are 46,000,000 people taking advantage of this deal from Obama. Problem is, the 46,000,000 people will increase to who knows what, then we will have to stand in line damn it.

Immigration is the problem...
The United States of America - the new welfare state. Let's face it - we are screwed. Our elected officials are doing everything they can to bring the U.S. down and it's working. On both sides they're not willing to address the issue of immigration. Obama has promised to secure the borders and allow for easier entry into citizenship with a small fee and a "go to the end of the line" promise. But, these are people who are unskilled. They have babies here on our dime. They get a free education. They meld into the fabric of the country until they are citizens by default. Obama says there are 37 million Americans in the poverty group out of 300 million, or 12.3%. That's way too much. That's unacceptable. And, that's caused by a broken gov't and a broken social system that encourages unmarried women, unemployed men, and children destined to repeat their parents. This isn't going to get better, especially by supporting this behavior. But, the next four years will continue to dig the hole that will end this great nation built on doing it on your own.

There is a fix for both parties(sort of)
Democrats want the minorities for the free votes. Republicans want to end the decline of America into a complete welfare state. The fix is a compromise. Abolishment of all taxes, except for the fair-tax. Democrats could keep huge numbers of cinch voters, and republicans would have an ecomonmy that would boom and an electorate that would no longer seek to plunder from one another. This would completely nullify the "racial" argument for deportation. If they can pay, they can stay. This is the republican's only chance. If the current system continues; tax paying citizens are being out-breeded by non tax paying citizens. This can only continue into more and more socialism.

Low Ball number for illegals in US
I'm a retired cop, I worked the immigration rally in dallas three years ago. There were an estimated 700,000 aliens there, some carried an enormous mexican flags. The official white house is 11 million aliens. If that is true than Dallas is over stocked. Our share of 11 mil is 200,000. A more accurate number would be 20 million aliens, yes they contributed to the mortgage meltdown, and they burden local hospitals. Big Business is addicted to cheap labor and taxpayers pick up the healthcare costs at local hospitals, for the uninsured aliens. Business shifted its employee costs to taxpayers. The problem will constanly grow in the future.

Double standards
We were not considered, by immigration and the various agencies involved, as candidates to internationally adopt a child until we had a signed statement from our medical insurance company saying our daughter would be completely covered by our policy the moment she landed in L.A.

We also had to submit financial records proving we could afford to support her to domestic and international agencies and immigration. We paid every penny of the costs of background checks with immigration and put our fingerprints into their computer among a thousand other things.

We paid our fees, dotted our i's and played by the rules. Everyone else can too.

"Business shifted its employee costs
. . . to taxpayers."

And we're going to sit back and let business take our money??? For what? To pad their POCKETS?? at our expense? at the expense of the purchase of necessities for our families?

I DON'T THINK SO!!!

I said it last year and I'll say it again -- that head of lettuce is costing more, far more, than the check-out price. There needs to be a movement -- Heritage Foundation, American Enterprise, or some such spearhead -- to blazen on the consciousness of EVERY SINGLE SHOPPER just exactly how much that produce is costing them.

But America is too busy (aided and abetted by the leftest-socialist media) drinking kool-aid to see REALITY. We must make them see.

If we don't act we are doomed. We'll have no one to blame but ourselves.

Cloward-Pivens Strategy
http://www.americanthinker.com/2008/09/barack_obama_and_the _strategy.html

Immigration both legal and illegal has been a means to accomplish an end. The end of capitalism and Republican Rule. It has been hugely successful this election cycle, and hey when something has worked so well, why change a thing. I expect immigration from African and Arab countries to explode under an Obama presidency in an effort to drive a stake through the heart of the white power structure. Time will tell.

WELL NOW...YOU SAID
A MOUTHFUL! IT IS NOT GOING TO BE PRETTY!
BUT THE CONSERVATIVES HAD JUAN MC MEXICO
ON OUR SIDE! YEEEE HAWWWW!
ELVIS

Reform Immigration Policy?
ABOUT ENFORCING CURRENT LAWS!!! Current law is just fine to correct the problems of illegal immigration. There has to be effective enforcement.

We the people are supposed to guide our own destiny with interest and active participation in the politics of the country. Prudence and a conservative stance are required. We vote for politicians who do our bidding not the other way around and a sense of entitlement at the expense of others is not a consideration. “Keeping our powder dry” for future emergencies is essential; another words a healthy reserve in economic and military might is necessary. We the people are doing none of these things and we make ourselves very vulnerable to our enemies and we are mortgaging our futures on borrowed moneys that we don’t control. It’s time to get our internal house in order. Get back to basics like balanced budgets and fiscal responsibility in our own homes and in government. Secure our borders, return illegal immigrants to their place of origin at their expense, bring back the manufacturing base, bring our military home, and restrain our diplomatic efforts to a minimum…we are not the world’s policeman and it just invites more animosity from all the deranged but envious mobs outside our borders. We have to stop the hemorrhaging of all that is dear to this nation starting with ourselves and demanding accountability and restraint from the political office holders. That is a nation of strength; the one we have now is an obese Baby Huey waiting to be knocked over with a feather (one of its own at that).

Brian in Scottsdale
Amen my brother amen. Too sad!

I know that Barry Dunham is our President elect. I know that it bodes no good for anything being done about illegal immigration.

There is a group that will become even more important when Barry becomes our President. It's http://www.numbersusa.com. Please check it out. It is more important than ever that we as Americans become activists.

I know I am posting from Md., but I spent 3 wonderful months in Sierra Vista Arizona.What a wonderful,beautiful state!Bisbee, Douglas, Tempe,et al,unbelievable! I was appalled at what was going on. Illegals crossing without fear. The garbage they left on the beautiful Arizona landscape was inexcusable.It is ruining Arizona.

Please check out the website. Please become an activist for this country. It's not hard. Call the White House...,leave a comment. Call your senators. Call your congressman.Remember the words of flight 93? Let's roll! Just do it! Barry may be our next President..., but if we all stand together he will have to listen and so will the Queen of Hearts(NANCY PELOSI)and the Mad Hatter(HARRY REID). Call them! They thrive in the darkness of an ignorant electorate.They cannot survive the sunlight of an informed electorate!

Lon in Pa
Lon: Over 5 million illegal aliens have Fannie/Freddie mortgages that are in default. Michelle Maklin wrote about this last month.

According to FamilySecurityMatters, their research forms that illegal aliens take 4 dollars for every one they put in. That costs the taxpayers slightly more than $20,000.00 per family per year.

Judicial Watch.org is another great anti-illegal immigration organization. They are spearheadibg the charge on sanctuary cities.

GOP: crack down on immigration

Aside from Ira Mehlmann being 100% right on the merits, the GOP should adopt such a view in its politics. John McCain took the La Raza view, and look where it got him and us-- Hispanics voted for Obama in droves.


no pay no stay
Mike are you insane? If you can pay you can stay,

Yea! thats just what we need. ALL of them need to vacate. Why should we have to compete with the invaders for work. I have to and I don't like it, and I don't want to support foreigners on welfare/medicad while my family has to struggle and we have NO medical insurance.

I could give a rats hind end about their needs...

It is cheeper to deport them than it is to support them.

Just that simple...

AAA Rating For Subprime Securities
High demand for these high-risk subprime mortgage-backed securities would not have been there if the security rating agencies had not been corrupt and given them unwarranted AAA ratings. Oversight of these rating agencies might have prevented this whole fiasco.

It is clear that corrupt Democrats (including Obama, Frank, Dodd, Schumer and others) pandered to minorities (including ACORN and NCLR and others) in return for campaign contributions, votes and other perks, by mandating subprime mortgages that led to this economic collapse.

It is also clear that the Bush Administration and Republicans tried to impose oversight that might have prevented this depression, and they were blocked by Democrats. I have not heard, until this article, that members of both parties were involved in promoting subprime mortgages. Please name those Republicans involved.

There's no question that with the economic downturn and loss of jobs, we will not be able to absorb the same number of immigrant workers; these numbers will have to be dramatically scaled down.

Arizona thanks you
Arizona and all of the other states on the borders with Mexico thank you. The illegal immigration problem is so out of control that it's scary!

The illegal crossing is bad enough, but the trash they leave behing them, plastic jugs that held water, clothes they were wearing, even dirty diapters (can you imagine crossing the burning desert with a baby?) is terrible as others have posted.
Sign Up to Post Your CommentsSign Up to Post Your Comments
If you are already registered, click here to login. Otherwise, please take a few seconds to register with Townhall.com. Once you sign up, you’ll be able to post your comments immediately, use the action center, get podcasts, and more!
Note: Fields marked with a red asterisk (*) are required.
Salutation:
First Name:
*
Last Name:
*
Email:
*
Nickname:
*
Note: Nick name will be shown when you post comments.
Address 1:
*
Address 2:
City:
*
State:
*
Zip:
*
Phone:
      
Your daily must-read of conservative columns, cartoons and news. Coulter, Sowell, Krauthammer and more.
(Bi-Weekly) We highlight the best opportunities from our partners for surveys, action items and more.