Townhall.com, Where Your Opinion Counts
Talk Radio:   Bill Bennett   Mike Gallagher   Dennis Prager   Michael Medved   Hugh Hewitt   
BREAKING NEWS  LeftArrow - Townhall.com : Conservative, Political, Republican   RightArrow - Townhall.com : Conservative, Political, Republican  
Columns, funnies & more in your inbox!
  • Check the boxes and send us your email address to receveive your free newsletter
  • Your daily must-read of conservative columns, cartoons and news. Coulter, Sowell, Krauthammer and more.
  • Townhall.com’s weekly inside scoop on what’s happening behind the scenes in the world of politics. When news breaks, we report.
  • Signup to receive the latest daily Townhall cartoons
Thursday, December 25, 2008
George Will :: Townhall.com Columnist
A Small, Successful Government Program
by George Will
Vote on It:
Average Vote:
[+] Text [-]
 
Poll
Will the Dems' health care Christmas Present to America be an improvement or detriment to our health care system?


WASHINGTON -- In Winslow Homer's 1865 painting "The Veteran in a New Field," a farmer, bathed in sunshine, his back to the viewer, his Union uniform jacket cast on the ground, harvests wheat with a single-bladed scythe. That tool was out of date, and Homer first depicted the farmer wielding a more modern implement. Homer then painted over it, replacing it with what evokes a timeless symbol of death -- the grim reaper's scythe. The painting reminds viewers how much Civil War blood was shed, as at Gettysburg, in wheat fields.

Homer's painting is one of 40 works of art that the National Endowment for Humanities is distributing, in 24-by-36-inch reproductions, with teaching guides, to all primary and secondary schools and libraries that ask for them. About one-third of them already have done so, according to Bruce Cole, the NEH's chairman.

So as Washington's dreariest year in decades sags to an end -- a year in which trillion-dollar improvisations that will debase the dollar have been bracketed by a stimulus that did not stimulate and a rescue that will prolong automakers' drownings -- at the end of this feast of folly, consider something rarer than rubies. It is a 2008 government program that costs next to nothing -- $2.6 million this year; a rounding error in the smallest of the bailouts. And "Picturing America" adds to the public stock of something scarce -- understanding of the nation's past and present.

The 40 works of art include some almost universally familiar ones -- John Singleton Copley's 1768 portrait of a silversmith named Paul Revere; Emanuel Leutze's 1851 "Washington Crossing the Delaware"; Augustus Saint-Gaudens' bronze relief sculpture "Robert Gould Shaw and the Fifty-fourth Regiment Memorial" on Boston Common. But "Picturing America" is not, Cole takes pains to insist, "the government's 'top 40.'" Forty times 40 other selections of art and architecture could just as effectively illustrate how visual works are revealing records of the nation's history and culture, and how visual stimulation can spark the synthesizing of information by students.

The colorful impressionism of Childe Hassam's flag-filled painting "Allies Day, May 1917" captures America's waxing nationalism a month after entry into World War I. And it makes all the more moving the waning of hope captured in Dorothea Lange's 1936 photograph "Migrant Mother." This haunting image of a destitute 32-year old pea picker, a mother of seven, is a springboard into John Steinbeck's novel "The Grapes of Wrath."

One of the 40 images in "Picturing America" is more timely than Cole could have suspected when the project was launched in February. It is a photograph of Manhattan's Chrysler Building.

Built between 1926 and 1930 -- between the giddy ascent of the '20s stock market and the Crash -- this art deco monument to the might of America's automobile industry is decorated with motifs of machines and streamlining. There are winged forms of a Chrysler radiator cap; an ornamental frieze replicates a band of hubcaps. The stainless steel of the famous spire suggests the signature of the automobile industry in its salad days -- chrome.

To understand the animal spirits that drove New York's skyscraper competition -- the Chrysler Building was the world's tallest for less than a year, until the Empire State Building was completed 202 feet higher -- is to understand an era. Two eras, actually -- the one that built the building, and ours, which has reasons to be reminded of the evanescence of seemingly solid supremacies.

After seven years of service, Cole, the longest-serving chairman in the 43-year history of the NEH, is leaving to head the American Revolution Center at Valley Forge. America has thousands of museums, including the Studebaker National Museum (South Bend, Ind.), the Packard Museum (Dayton, Ohio) -- yes, Virginia, there was a time when automobile companies were allowed to perish -- the Hammer Museum (Haines, Alaska), the Mustard Museum (Mount Horeb, Wis.), and the Spam Museum (Austin, Minn.) featuring the sort-of-meat, not the Internet annoyance. There is, however, no museum devoted to the most important political event that ever happened, here or anywhere else -- the American Revolution.

Cole says there will be one, at Valley Forge. It will be built mostly by private money, for an infinitesimally tiny fraction of the sum of public money currently being lavished on corporations. Perhaps a subsequent iteration of "Picturing America" will feature a thought-provoking photograph of the gleaming towers that currently house, among other things, General Motors' headquarters. Looming over Detroit's moonscape desolation, the building is called the Renaissance Center. Really.

Share:
Vote on It:
Average Vote:
 
About The Author
George F. Will is a 1976 Pulitzer Prize winner whose columns are syndicated in more than 400 magazines and newspapers worldwide.
 
TOWNHALL DAILY: Be the first to read George Will's column. Sign up today and receive Townhall.com daily lineup delivered each morning to your inbox.
JUST PICTURES
A 'picture is worth a thousand words', but if Americans (especially young Americans) are not taught to read, learn and understand the history of our Great Nation, then this extrodinary art, these paintings, are 'just pictures'.

When Art was ART
How wonderful for our schoolchildren to see "real" art and hear the history behind the art as well. It's a wonderful opening to American History for these kids who live in a visual world. Perhaps they should receive a text message to go see the art and then they would be more likely to view it.

my 2 cents worth.
I guess I am old school.

Pictures are fine, as far as they go.

And visual art, as well as music(including both melody and lyric), can sometimes invoke and inspire emotions and sentiments that the printed word in a textbook cannot match.

Even so, I think a solid knowledge of our history is essential if our Republic is to survive.

And I don't think that can be done absent the spoken or written word.

Certainly visual depictions of events can embellish..but they are no substitute for knowledge of history gleaned via the written or spoken word.

I'll be the Grinch here
While I'm pleased that there is a least some small effort to draw children to our history, this program, like so many others, is a problem. The problem is that it is a Federal program paid for with Federal taxes. I can't find any article in the Constitution that empowers the Federal government to do this sort of thing.

This program is an excellent example of how "nice" small programs can lead to a Federal intrusion into larger things. Here we have a small $2.8B (?) expenditure for a perceived good in the educational process. Elsewhere we have the umpteen $Billion Dept. of Education enforcing the No Child Left Behind nonsense.

This good program could have been funded by any number of processes without involving the Federal government. For instance, some foundation could have come up with a similar idea and pitched it to a number of state governments, thereby splitting the costs among several entities that are legally empowered to operate such programs.

Still wrong
Even if this is a very "cheap" government program, it is still an improper function of government. I love art, but the government has no business using my tax money to fund the arts. 100% of these types of endeavors should be funded by private sources. Protecting us from foreign invasion (on the federal level) and running the criminal justice system (on the local level) should be the limits of the state.

Christmas
Merry Christmas Mr. Will.

a small successfull gov. program
andrea,wi.and upland william are both correct,they should join the society of secrets.com a group that will put an end to this b,s. George Will should also belong to this org.as he also sees through the illusions,yes they have a new pol. party to change this,really"
bill ny

NEH Program

The address for the program George Will mentions is:
http://picturingamerica.neh.gov/educators.php?subPage=edu_g uide

Thanks George for a wonderful column.

and this is successful how?
George just says it is successful because it has done some things he calls good. Bypassing the obvious constitutional issue that others have raised, can George just pronounce it successful because it has done some good things?

Is there a single gov't program that hasn't done some good somewhere? Does that mean the program is good, or is there a way to define success here that is less subjective?

I submit that George's subjective measuring stick (his opinion) is not good enough. Better to judge government programs by seeing if they are fixing the problem they are addressing. In this case, the gov't program is helping in a small way, but not in any permanent manner, and not in any way that will ever lessen the pressure on the government to continue giving money to this cause.

In my view, a government program should have as a major component the goal of eliminating itself. In fact, if a program doesn't have its end in mind, then it is not a good program, and shouldn't be continued except in emergency situations. It is hardly an emergency to think that some kid won't learn about the artists and works that George Will thinks are important.

On top of this subjectiveness, in no way can anyone argue that a state couldn't do this program at the state level and do it better. That has been the traditional reasoning to limit a program to the state level, irrespective of the bozos who see no limitation to federal power.

George Will continues to hold his spot as a national "compassionate conservative". Yuck.

"Successful"?
I refuse to call any government program "successful" when it shouldn't exist to begin with.

Successful Program
And the Constitutional authorization for this program us just what?

jerabaub
"Date: Dec 25, 2008 - 8:24 AM EST Subject: my 2 cents worth.
I guess I am old school.

....Certainly visual depictions of events can embellish..but they are no substitute for knowledge of history gleaned via the written or spoken word. "

I guess I am even older school I don't think the tale can be told by words, picture or music alone; all three are necessary.

You know I look at the "no government" parasites above and marvel at their incomprehension that we are all a stream of people and we are never alone but part of a whole.

We Can Do It Again
Millions of unemployed youths across the nation are anxiously waiting to get to work repairing highways and building new schools when the trillion dollar stimulus package goes into effect. There will be no eligible youngster left behind as armies with picks and axes in hand go to work rebuilding the nations infrastructure. The final result will be unclogged new highways and school buildings ready to educate all those that are willing to learn. Never before has such a expensive attempt made to jump start a lagging economy and bring our country into the 21 century.

A word worth a thousand pictures
Fishy writes, "If Americans (especially young Americans) are not taught to read, learn and understand the history of our Great Nation, then this extrodinary art, these paintings, are 'just pictures'."

Jerebaub concurs, "I think a solid knowledge of our history is essential if our Republic is to survive. And I don't think that can be done absent the spoken or written word."

Then, several posters address the Constitutional issue:

Upland William: "I can't find any article in the Constitution that empowers the Federal government to do this sort of thing."

Andrea: " I love art, but the government has no business using my tax money to fund the arts"

Cruise Missle: "... the obvious constitutional issue that others have raised..."

Semper Libertas: "I refuse to call any government program "successful" when it shouldn't exist to begin with."

Bob: "And the Constitutional authorization for this program us just what?"

Finally, Hal Donohue reads FIVE references to the proper role of government as defined by the Constitution, and comes up with this gem: "You know I look at the "no government" parasites above and marvel at their incomprehension...."

Jerebaub and Fishy, be sure to say thank you to Hal for proving your point. And Hal, the only incomprehension here is yours.

Glaring Omission
Any attempt to tell the story of America by "Picture America" in forty or so images is bound to omit a significant chapter or two.
However, selecting Puryear's 1995 sculpture "Ladder for Booker T. Washington" does this country's "other great American named Washington" a disservice.
A far better and more telling sculpture would have been "Lifting the Veil of Ignorance" by Charles Keck in 1922.
http://www.btwsociety.org/library/honors/09.php
The opportunity to engage students in discussion over differing viewpoints on hisw role in the civil rights movements of the day would still be there, while not reducing Dr. Washington or his legacy to an abstraction that some might interpret as a ladder leading to nowhere.
Historians have accorded only one man in American history the honor of naming an era after him. 1895-1915 is commonly known as the Booker T. Washington Era. Surely he deserves better treatment in this otherwise commendable and ambitious effort to link art with America's history.

Art
The number one place a child learns best in a museum. They need to both see and hear the story. This is a good use of money. Jean/Atlanta

re: Hal Donahue
There is a big difference between being a "no government" person and believing that the purpose of government is to protect our life, liberty, and pursuit of happiness.

"It is to protect our rights that we submit to government at all." ~ Thomas Jefferson

I see neither a need nor a Constitutional justification for federal government support of arts, music, TV, radio, etc. Personally, I support the arts in my hometown; I go to shows, I attend fundraisers, and I make direct donations. However, it would be the height of arrogance for me to FORCE you to do the same.

Government certainly has legitimate functions. Protecting our liberty and property, protect against fraud and coercion, enforcing contracts, etc. are all justified. If I were to hold a gun to your head and force you to donate to a particular arts program, it would be wrong. How is having the government do it for me any better?

NO!! NO!! NO!!

NO!! I don't care how beautiful the paintings are.. NO!! If schools were truely competative and education was free only on an income qualified scale and followed the child to ANY accredited school...

..This great art would have made it to the printer of any achool who wanted it for $X through the museaum website..(discount for schools and students because they want to cultivate appreciation and make money doing it.)


Story Art
In January of 2009, The Obamessiah became the President of the United States. HIS first action in office was to destroy all nuclear weapons; the second to eliminate all fossil fuel sources. Behold, nuclear weapons and fossil fuels no longer existed on Earth.
Behold, the planet was covered with solar-panel fields, and windmill forests, which don’t produce electricity when the sun doesn’t shine and the wind doesn’t blow.

After ten years, there was only peace and harmony on the planet, because, for five years, the noises and vibrations from the windmills drove all the people living near them to suicide, and the solar panels killed most food plants. The Ice Age that started in 2014 froze the people who hadn’t starved, because there wasn’t any heat for their homes. Everybody died except for The Obamessiah, Algore, and the 12 other liberals living in the hydroponic garden in the bunker below Mount Rushmore.

One day, the Mount Palomar Observatory warned that “The Asteroid” was coming. “The Asteroid”, an outer space rock the size of The Alps, was on a collision course with Earth, as a 2008 NOVA documentary warned.

One liberal got out the file on “The Asteroid” to find out what to do. The instructions were to launch six, 20-megaton nuclear missiles and land them on “The Asteroid”, and then detonate them one-by-one, three seconds apart. The phased explosions should divert “The Asteroid” from hitting Earth.

Then one liberal said, “We can’t do this! HE beholded the missiles and fuel out of existence! We don’t have missiles to launch and fuel to launch them.”

Then they said, “HE can behold “The Asteroid” not to hit the earth.”

After telling The Obamessiah about “The Asteroid”, the liberals realized that HE was actually the Twelfth Imam, THE ONE that, back in 2007, Muslim terrorists said would destroy the world in two years. Two years after 2007, was when The Obamessiah “beholded” the Missiles and fuel out of existence.

about those jobs
Obama said that he intends to shut down the coal industry. He presented it as just stopping new coal-fired power plants from being built. There is a lot more to coal than that. This move will shut down the coal, iron, and steel industries and every industry that uses coal, iron, and steel.
Coal is used to power some trains, heat some homes, and to make iron ore into iron the metal.
Coal is used to heat pig iron to form it.
Coal is roasted to make it into coke.
Coke is used to convert iron the metal into steel the metal.
Coal is used to form steel ingots into shapes like I-beams.
Steel is made into parts like nuts and bolts, angles, rebars, pipes, etc.
Reinforcing bars are needed for reinforced concrete.
Steel parts are made into machines such as lathes, harvesters, reactors, pumps, etc.
Steel is needed for drilling and transporting oil, natural gas, coal, and nuclear fuel.

When all these industries go out of business, they will no longer pay the many taxes they now pay, nor pay the employees’ income taxes, nor pay the new taxes that put them out of business.

They say they will end paying $700 billion per year to buy oil from foreigners. They won't start us drilling our own oil to become energy independent. They will just make oil inaccessible to us. This means no more gasoline, diesel oil, home heating oil, and lubrication. Presently, when it comes to gouging on the price of oil and gas, government is the only gouger (45% of the price).

Obama cannot endear himself to the American People by taxing us to death and spouting the global warming hoax while forcing the oil, natural gas, coal, and electricity energy suppliers out of existence when we’re entering an ice age that will hit full force when we’re halfway through what might be his second term.

Just a little bit!
When you add all the little bits together, you get a whole lot. Look at the bail outs. Whooee as they say in the back woods of Ar. Smile
That is what ear marks are, just a little bit. A bill goes from a million to five million due to all the little bits. Ain't it the truth?

No!
Mr. Will, would you condemn it to being built on a foundation of theft? Of having a reputation of being so important in solidifying and epitomizing the American spirit, but not supported on private money through the virtue of the people?

Would you have it be a living monument to the general failure of Americans in the moral and aesthetic realms?

It is precisely because it is so important that it should be left up to private hands.

Manning of the American Revolution was.

Social conservativism is ever a creeping threat. It is a danger to the Republic and I hope that you come to see it.

Americans Need the FMJC
What I find truly disgusting and irresponsible is the method by those in congress who conjure and force-pass legislation for their self-serving benefits, which has proven to have caused the current devastating financial results.

Case in point - many, possibly millions of individuals and families, have had the value of their retirement accounts lose up to 70%. Federal legislation and wide-spread government intervention and meddling are the causes. People such as Dodd, Schumer, former President Carter, Barney Frank, Harry Reid, Pelosi, former President Clinton, et al have caused this disaster - the legislation: Community Reinvestment Act – CRA.

What is even more insulting and certainly will cause more financial distress to many Americans is that these idiots are actually attempting to fix the problems. Here’s a clue – leave things alone get out of town and more importantly repeal all laws which do not pass a U.S. Constitutional test.

I proposed that a Free Market Judicial Court (FMJC) be formed and comprised of 5 free market economists. The FMJC shall have all legal authority to subpoena any legislator or member of Congress who is suspected of passing or thinking about passing any law which would have any artificial impact on the economy.

Finally, those who have had anything to do with passing anti-free market economic legislation and cronyism should be thoroughly investigated and forever barred from any form of interaction with the Federal Government in any capacity.

re: richard
You mention only Democrats as culprits in "wide-spread government intervention and meddling" with the economy. Unfortunately, both parties are culprits. Republicans like to talk the talk when it comes to free market capitalism, but they don't practice what they preach.

Remington
Amon Carter Museum, Ft.Worth, TX.

The really real and the really beautiful will never die. But the "idea" of the Cowboy, rendered beautifully by Remington, needs to be put on the back burner of American Foreign Policy. Owen Wister's "The Virginian," all about a tough and noble and "stickin" type of guy--stickin with friends (no matter what) and stickin it to enemies (no matter what)--this whole cowboy mystique in American needs to be rethought.

The appropriate visuals in the schools would be most helpful in this effort.

Richard

If only... What a brilliant idea.
Sign Up to Post Your CommentsSign Up to Post Your Comments
If you are already registered, click here to login. Otherwise, please take a few seconds to register with Townhall.com. Once you sign up, you’ll be able to post your comments immediately, use the action center, get podcasts, and more!
Note: Fields marked with a red asterisk (*) are required.
Salutation:
First Name:
*
Last Name:
*
Email:
*
Nickname:
*
Note: Nick name will be shown when you post comments.
Address 1:
*
Address 2:
City:
*
State:
*
Zip:
*
Phone:
      
Your daily must-read of conservative columns, cartoons and news. Coulter, Sowell, Krauthammer and more.
(Bi-Weekly) We highlight the best opportunities from our partners for surveys, action items and more.