Townhall.com, Where Your Opinion Counts
Talk Radio:   Bill Bennett   Mike Gallagher   Dennis Prager   Michael Medved   Hugh Hewitt   
BREAKING NEWS  LeftArrow - Townhall.com : Conservative, Political, Republican   RightArrow - Townhall.com : Conservative, Political, Republican  
Columns, funnies & more in your inbox!
  • Check the boxes and send us your email address to receveive your free newsletter
  • Your daily must-read of conservative columns, cartoons and news. Coulter, Sowell, Krauthammer and more.
  • Townhall.com’s weekly inside scoop on what’s happening behind the scenes in the world of politics. When news breaks, we report.
  • Signup to receive the latest daily Townhall cartoons
Sunday, July 06, 2008
George Will :: Townhall.com Columnist
In Honor of Our Fallen
by George Will
Vote on It:
Average Vote:
[+] Text [-]
 
Poll
Was the Copenhagen Global Warming Summit Walk-Out a Win for the U.S.?


"The curtains pull away. They come to the door. And they know. They always know."
-- Maj. Steve Beck, U.S. Marine Corps

WASHINGTON -- Sometimes Beck would linger in his vehicle in front of an American home, like that of the parents of Lance Cpl. Kyle Burns in Laramie, Wyo. Beck knew that, as Jim Sheeler writes, every second he waited "was one more tick of his wristwatch that, for the family inside the house, everything remained the same."

Beck -- now Lt. Col. Beck -- was a CACO, a casualty assistance calls officer whose duty was to inform a spouse or parents that their Marine had been killed. He is the scarlet thread -- like the stripes on Marines' dress-blue trousers, symbolizing shed blood -- that connects the heart-rending stories in Sheeler's "Final Salute: A Story of Unfinished Lives." The book, which proves that the phrase "literary journalism" is not an oxymoron, expands the meticulous and marvelously modulated reporting he did for the Rocky Mountain News, and for which he received a Pulitzer Prize. His subject is how America honors fallen warriors.

More precisely, it is about how the military honors them. The nation, as Marine Sgt. Damon Cecil says, "has changed the channel." Still, Sheeler sees civilians getting glimpses of those who have sacrificed everything. The glimpses come as the fallen are escorted home. When an airline passenger, noting an escort's uniform, asked if the sergeant was going to or coming from the war, he repeated words the military had told him to say: "I'm escorting a fallen Marine home to his family from the situation in Iraq."

The situation. Sheeler:

"When the plane landed in Nevada, the sergeant was allowed to disembark alone. Outside, a procession walked toward the cargo hold. The airline passengers pressed their faces against the windows.

"From their seats in the plane they saw a hearse and a Marine extending a white-gloved hand into a limousine. In the plane's cargo hold, Marines readied the flag-draped casket and placed it on the luggage conveyor belt.

"Inside the plane, the passengers couldn't hear the screams."

The knock on the survivors' door is, Beck says, "not a period at the end of their lives. It's a semicolon." Deployed military personnel often leave behind, or write in the war zone, "just in case" letters. Army Pfc. Jesse Givens of Fountain, Colo.: "My angel, my wife, my love, my friend. If you're reading this, I won't be coming home. ... Please find it in your heart to forgive me for leaving you alone." To his son Dakota: "I will always be there in our park when you dream so we can still play together. ... I'll be in the sun, shadows, dreams, and joys of your life." To his unborn son: "You were conceived of love and I came to this terrible place for love."

The manual for CACOs says, "It is helpful if the NOK (next of kin) is seated prior to delivering the news. ... Speak naturally and at a normal pace." Sometimes, however, things do not go by the book.

Doyla Lundstrom, a Lakota Sioux, was away from her house when she learned that men in uniform had been to her door. She called the father of her two sons -- each serving in Iraq; one as a Marine, one as a soldier -- and screamed into her cell phone, "Which one was it?" It was the Marine.

Sheeler says that troops in war zones often have e-mail and satellite telephones, so when someone is killed, communication from the area is stopped lest rumors reach loved ones before notification officers do. "As soon as we receive the call," Beck says, "we are racing the electron."

When the Army CACOs came to the Arlington, Va., door of Sarah Walton, my assistant, she was not there. She rarely forgot the rule that a spouse of a soldier in a combat zone is supposed to inform the Army when he or she will be away from home. This time Sarah forgot, so it took the Army awhile to locate her at her in parents' home in Richmond.

Her husband, Lt. Col Jim Walton, West Point class of 1989, was killed in Afghanistan on June 21. This week he will be back in Arlington, among the remains of the more than 300,000 men and women who rest in the more than 600 acres where it is always Memorial Day. This is written in homage to him, and to Sarah, full sharer of his sacrifices.

Share:
Vote on It:
Average Vote:
 
About The Author
George F. Will is a 1976 Pulitzer Prize winner whose columns are syndicated in more than 400 magazines and newspapers worldwide.
 
TOWNHALL DAILY: Be the first to read George Will's column. Sign up today and receive Townhall.com daily lineup delivered each morning to your inbox.
Thank you, George Will
for a touching and revealing article.

Semicolon
A fine homage, Mr Will. Like most grateful Americans, my experience with this is limited to Hollywood images. Those in "Saving Private Ryan" and "The Fighting Sullivans" stopped my heart.
God bless the mothers, the family, the fallen.

In Honor of Our Fallen
Mr. Will does a great job in showing the great respect each of our fallen deserve. And I still find it disgusting how the main media does not want to report all the good things that are happening in Irag; the amazing success of our troops. Leave it to the iatrogenic press.

Kudos, Mr. Will
This is a fine article...please pass along my thanks and the thanks of my family to your assistant for her husband's service to our country, as well as our deepest sympathies for her loss. My son-in-law was one of the lucky ones to come home...but he is very proud of the work he did in Iraq. Our troops are a continuing source of pride and a shining symbol of what our country stands for and is made of...honor, courage and faith.

Thankfulness
My son just returned home from his third and final deployment to the Middle East. He is retiring. Thank God for his safe return. Now I can retire my Blue Star banner.

Words are cheap
Mr. Will however comes as close as words ever can to the meaning of sacrifice and what that word really means.

Never better said. Thank you all. I hope I can pass on the meaning of your sacrifice to those who follow you, and do what I can to preserve your memory and sacrifice.

We must remember
In the movie "We Were Soldiers" the main character played by Mel Gibson tells his little girl that war is where some people try to take the lives of other people and it is the job of people like her daddy to go and stop them.

Our military does not go to conquer and build empire.

This is why every loss is so dear.


Tough read!
Geoege Will is a patriot!

How he sits next to that woman, who I believe to be a devout Maxist, from The Nation (Kristina Vander Hoople) on "This Week..." as she tears at our very fiber astounds me.

About 18 months ago she was laying down some pablum about how we need to start apologizing to the world and George interupted her and said, "You do know that they struck us first, don't you?"

Casualty Officers
We(my family and I) have first hand experience of the devotion and absolute compassion these volunteer Army CACO's. Following the death of my grandson in a helicopter crash in Aviano Italy, his wife and parents were assigned a representative. When we arrived in Arlington for the funeral we were met by "Justin" who
made sure all our needs were taken care of and helped us through the Military formalities of an Arlington funeral. He was instrumental in awarding the presidential lapel gold star pin to his wife, parents, siblings and me, grandmother. I cannot express enough the gratitude we feel to know that the young man who loved his country was honored and respected by his own. How seldom we hear about the CACO's and their difficult duty. They volunteer and rotate assignments. Their term is usually 2 years - it's not the easiest - but these men and women know that for every fallen soldier, sailor, marine, airman, there is also a family who needs questions answered.
I bless them and all our brave men and women who serve to protect, defend and honor this nation.

For those we have loved
As etched into London's Cenotaph

"The Glorious Dead".

practice makes perect
and marines have had too much practice in this particular skill.

Thank You!
Mr. Will

From a family of combat vets…thank you! And God bless the CACO. No tougher job!

Fine Column. Excellent Comments With

the fine George Will column.

Fine Column. Excellent Comments With

the fine George Will column.

Thank You, George Will
I too have personal experience with CAOC - not a war death, but a child who never left the hospital. In a situation frought with pain, heartache and sadly, incompetance - the CAOC were efficient, professional and most importantly compassionate. My husband, Army Retired Veteran, served on burial duties and he always instructed his guys - do this with one thought in mind - one day it will be you and your wife or mother - it drove the point home, how important it is to be honoring and honorable at such a time as this.

And MRCMRC - 977 Marines have been killed in OEF/OIF in 7 years total of fighting - in WWII on Iwo Jima (one battle of that war)in 37 days - 6821 Marines were killed. So I guess in reality the practice makes perfect you 'claim' is really for the Marines ability to do warfare well - so that their CACOs don't have to notify so many parents as in yesteryear.

These honorable Men and Women have volunteered - they know more than you, exactly why they are sacrificing their lives. You do them no honor at all to belittle their Corps or their mission.

A personal note...
...during the Vietnam war,between tours,I was teaching in the ROTC department in a small private military school in Illinois.The nearest Army post was at least 50 miles away,so there wasn't too many active duty Army officers in our area.The few officers in this school had to take our turns as Notifying Officers and Surviver Assistance Officers.That is the system the Army used.The Notifying Officer did the actual notifying and The Suvival Assistance Officer would take care of the family and help them as much as possible by arranging the body to be delivered to the funeral home.

The Notifying Officer was the hardest job,but the shortest in duration.You could not notify in the middle of the night.You had to get to the home before the Next of Kin left for work,but not too early where you have to wake them up.The initial shock is very emotional,but we treated them like we would want our own families treated if we became a casuality.We stayed there until we were sure they had family or friends present or came over.We never left them alone.

As Surviving Assistance Officer we got involved in the minutia of benefits for the NOK.Transporting the widow and children to the nearest Army post to get new ID cards,if asked,advising on military funeral arrangements and co-ordinating with the civilian funeral director to brief him on a military funeral and advise him that the body would be accompanied by a soldier of equal rank or higher and requesting he see that the soldier accompaning the body be put up in a local motel.

It was the hardest job I ever had in the Army because of the emotional involvment,but the families were one of ours just like that soldier was,and there but for the grace of God etc.

Fine Column. Excellent Comments With....
one exception (so far).

Our fighting men and women and their comrades who gave the "The Last Full Measure" are the reason we live in freedom this July 4th weekend.

Men like Lt. Col. Jim Walton who have died on our behalf, deserve the graditude of every American. It's the least we owe them.

My deepest sympathy to Sarah.



The American Soldier
History will record that the American Soldier and those American Soldiers who have fallen, rank in the greatest humans who have ever lived on this planet.

The American Soldier have freed millions in bondage and defended the freedom of America with willingness of the ultimate sacrifice.

The Fallen American Soldier is someone who walked the hero's path. Someone who walked into the heart of darkness for Duty, Honor and Country.

The American Soldier waits for the day that they have lived for and trained for their entire life - to defend until death, their families and America, its citizens and freedom.

The American soldier is the fiercest Warrior ever in history, because their mission is the defense of family, neighbors, America and freedom.

The families of the American Soldier, while their faces beamed with pride, their hearts were filled with anxiety and tears as they watched their American Soldier leave to defend them and this Great Country.

Families and neighbors look with horror as the military vehicle stops in front of the home of the American Soldier, to inform them of the ultimate sacrifice of their hero.

No honor can be to great, every tribute is to small for the Fallen American Soldier and their families.

God Bless the American Soldier and their families!

Nam65-66 et al
Thank you for your meritorious service!

All families of a Fallen American Soldier thank you for your sacrifice!

American Soldiers who are veterans - thank you and Welcome home Soldier!

American Soldiers who are serving this great Country - thank you for defending us!

God Bless the American Soldier!

Those who do NOT Honor
I am hesitant to post this but I must.

Those who do NOT Honor the American Soldier and especially the Fallen American Soldier.

I hold you in the greatest disdain and contempt that one human can hold for another - shame upon you!!

Excellent Commentary
"The curtains pull away. They come to the door. And they know. They always know."

I paused when I read these words, knowing the feeling of hoping that they never applied to me. My son has served two deployments in Iraq. As we go about our day to day routines here at home, it is always in the back of our minds that that car may pull up in front of our house. We were lucky to receive weekly phone calls. He was safe. But during the in between times that unwanted visit was in the back of our minds. He is currently deployed in the South Pacific,enjoying a respite of sorts,but in a few weeks will once again be sent into harm's way. This time there will be no weekly phone calls. He considers this his job and is proud of what he does. God watch over him and all of his brothers and sisters in our armed forces.

In honor of the fallen...
Beginning June 11, 2008, a cross-country relay run began a run to honor service people killed in Iraq and Afghanistan. "Run for the Fallen" - as it is titled (www.runforthefallen.org) is being run from California to Virginia, ending their run on August 24, 2008 at Arlington National Cemetary, each mile corresponding to one soldier/sailor/marine killed in the line of duty.

They are encouraging running communities throughout the United States to organize runs on the final day - August 24 - in honor of those who have served and died. Many communities - such as ours (Omaha, NE) - are planning memorial runs on that date in honor of those who have died in service to our country in Iraq or Afghanistan.

It's one thing we can do to raise awareness and pay respect to those who have given for us. In the greater Omaha metro area, it's 13 service men and women. It's the least we can do.


In Honour of our Fallen.................
George Will gets a Veterans kudzo for one great column.

I find it appalling, that our Democratic opposites, feel it is only appropriate to remember those that have died and suffered for them. Only twice a year, because it is a paid holiday for them.

When you see a service person, say hello, ask them how they are and thank them for what they do.

I could not help but shed a tear --
These men (and sometimes women) have demonstrated a courage and devotion that our so-called"heroes" on the athletic field can only imagine while they shoot up another round of steroids or take their next snort of cocaine. Yet our press worships the latter and denigrates the former, so often. Imagine walking into a hail of bullets, or running through exploding mortar shells. I like to think that I could do it, but honestly do not know.Thank you, families of our soldiers. God be with you.

A special breed
Although I have been required to deliver bad tidings in private life, I can barely imagine what it must be like to do so day after day in an official capacity. All who serve their country in uniform face manifold challenges. CACOs, however, have an unusually tough assignment, which they must carry out in the absence of armor, weapons, or even the satisfaction of facing an enemy.

By the way, the eloquence in the quotations above is striking. They give the lie once again to sneering suggestions by Sen. Kerry, et al., that the armed forces are a refuge (or a trap) for the stupid and ignorant.

My profound gratitude to LTC Walton, my deepest sympathies to his widow, and my thanks to you, Mr. Will, for a moving essay.

"One Man's America"
George Will, I am almost finished reading your book "One Man's America." "In Honor of Our Fallen" would have been worthy of inclusion in your final chapter, "Mathers of Life and Death." My youngest son, now a retired colonel in the United States Marine Corps, served his country for 30 years, including Desert Storm. I am grateful that God protected him as he piloted those CH-53 helicopters, and that he was able to retire before the invasion of Iraq.

heartbreakingly beautiful article
I am in tears as I write this...the sacrifice of these service men and women and those they leave behind is humbling and awesome. Thank God for people like them.

A thought
I salute Lt. Col Jim Walton and will be thinking of his family. Well said George; thank you Col Walton

To all who have fallen and...
to all who are serving I give my deepest and most heart felt "Thank You"!

No words exist to express the gratitude of a nation of free people when even one is lost in battle.

They are all in my prayers daily, including their loved ones who wait for their safe return, as we await the safe return of a nephew serving in Afghanistan.

In 1989 I was a Gold Star Wife
From that time to present I have at various times through the base Family Support Center, briefed deploying troops and their families about those things we don't want to talk about.
I served on active duty for 22 years myself, and frankly, there are many ways to die, not just "hostile fire."

Most heart breaking was a female USAF NCO that was in Korea on an exercise support. It was a "table top" paperwork thing. But she died, far from home in uniform, a brain aneurysm. It was fast, as fast as a bullet and so unexpected, she left a husband and young children.
You can prepare the papers, but you cannot prepare for the news.

To all the families that have gone through, or will go through what I have, you have my prayers for strength.

While we are here, be good to each other and NEVER forget to tell the ones you love that you do love them. You never know when.

Mr. Will thank-you, and please pass on our condolences to your assistant at this tragic time.

MOM SPEAKS
My son is in the middle of another 15 month deployment to Operation Iraqi Freedom. Every time the doorbell rings or my dog growls, my heart skips a few beats. This tribute by Mr. Will brought me to tears. I can't imagine having to do that job, although honorable, it must be so hard. When my son was assigned to the rear detatchment during a rotation he didn't have to participate in, he was one of the soldiers who went and escorted the fallen soldier to his home town. Some were his friends. I don't know how this affected him, he doesn't talk much about it. I am so proud of all of them.

Please consider donating some time and money to any of the many organizations like the USO,Wounded Warrior, Adopt-a-Soldier, or operation care package. These brave men and women need our help. Some come back and face forclosure and loss of jobs.

And to MRCMRC, I think you need to get a life. Your lack of sleep (or use of booze/drugs) shows on all of your posts. Your stupid comments are on each and every post here at Townhall. Don't you have anything else to do? Most are unreadable and I just skip over them. You are an idiot.

Lincoln
"The solemn pride that must be yours for have laid such a costly sacrifice upon the alter of freedom"
Abraham Lincoln

God bless them all....Semper Fi

Steve In NC
Iraq did NOT strike us first. Or ever.

Saudi Arabia did, and for their trouble, we remained their allies and sold them some weapons. Awesome.

THANK YOU , IN MY HEART AND SOUL.
FOR THE FREEDOMS YOU ALL HAVE GIVEN ME. GIVEN TO OUR NATION ..GIVEN IN ALL THE WARS..GIVEN - TAKEN FROM YOUR FAMILYS, FRIENDS , ..TAKEN FROM YOU AND YOU GIVE MORE..THANK YOU ..THANK YOU TO THE FAMILYS THAT GAVE YOUR SONS-DAUGHTERS TO US ALL..THE BEST OF THE BEST , ..ALWAYS THE BEST..THANK YOU ..

fotini901
vote for obammmmma'..he is more to your kind !

Six Stars
would not be enough for this article. Will's writing is normally thoughtful and srticulate, but this time he really outdid himself. Of course, with the kind of inspiration he had, it's easy to see why.

Final Salute
Mr. Will:

Thank you for this piece.
May God bless all of those who make the ultimate sacrifice and watch over their families as well.

Tim Anderson
Menlo Park, CA

Thank you, Lieutenant Colonel Walton ...
... and Mrs Walton, for your service and for your lives. May Almighty God bless and keep you both for all of eternity.

And thank you, Mr Will, intact American Man -- at work. (And how is your special and beautiful son? Doin' OK, I pray and trust!)

It's Black and White.


.......
Good stuff. God bless all the fallen and all those that fight on against the heathens of humanity.

how to deal with mrcmrc
ignore him

Lt. Col Jim Walton
Thank you for fighting for me, protecting me, and standing up for my freedoms. You are to be commended. God be with your family, and God bless America!! Thank you to all veterans, and to soldiers currently serving to protect our country.

Thank you
George Will. In the army I knew a few notifing officers. Then they didn't talk about that duty to much. Now I understand better.

Thank you Mr. Will
for bringing the sacrifices the Walton family has made for our great country to us. Please give Sarah our heartfelt condolences on her loss and she and her family will be in our prayers and the good Lt. Colonel Walton will take his place in all our collective memories as one of our country's great heroes, those who gave their all for us. He joins an elite group of men and women who we should all remember forever.


MRCMRC
I don't care where you go, just go. You are beneath contempt. May God have mercy on your soul.

Thank you Mr Will
It is with great humility that I join "squarpeg and MOM". Can't stop the tears, and don't want to.
Our men in uniform need to know we appreciate them. The CACOs in all services have a tough job that they do well.
It would also seem that we are committed to the continued sacrifice of our best and brightest on Lincloln's altar of freedom, and that is most appropriate in keeping our Christian heritage alive.
God Bless.

Our Fallen
My deepest sympathy for Sarah Walton and I thank her for her sacrifce. Thank you Mr. Will for this tribute to Lt Col Walton and the others in our military and their families who have given so much. Our family was stationed on Camp Lejeune during the Viet Nam War. When one of the marine green official vehicles would drive into the family quarters our hearts would be in our throats and we had to sit down because our legs wouldn't hold us any longer. If the car would stop at a home other than ours we all felt a mixture of relief and anguish. Although my Marine grandson is serving in the Middle East now, it has been easier to push those memories aside, after all I don't hear the heartbroken cries any longer. My gratitude, Mr Will, for reminding all of us the huge price that has been and is continuing to be paid for our freedom.

Mr Will
A Marine in my PTSD group served as a Marine infantryman in Vietnam and returned. He then served as a recruiter then went back to Vietnam for his second tour. After returning from his second tour he served as a notification Sgt to families of Marines kia'd in Vietnam. He then went back to Vietnam for a third tour. Talk about baggage. What a hero. I'm proud to know him as a friend and comrade.

Final Salute
I personally know Jim Sheeler. He's not a veteran but he makes every effort to honor our military and our veterans in a very special way. He's written many fine articles about vets first in the Denver Post and now the Rocky Mountain News.
Check out this link if you are interested:

http://www.nytimes.com/2008/06/05/books/05maslin.html

MY SON, MY HERO
My son has done two tours in Iraq. Each time he would call to tell me of another friend killed or a stranger whose guts he held in his hands, he didn't know how much it scared me. All I could think was "you were right next to him, that could have been you." I know he thought the same thing, but he never let it stop him from doing his duty.
He came home to a fiancee who is battling ovarian cancer and continues to stand by her in her fight for life.
I am so proud by my miracle, my son. What a man he has turned into.

Links to the original photo and books
http://www.rockymountainnews.com/special-reports/final-salu te/

http://www.nytimes.com/2008/06/05/books/05maslin.html?ref=r eview

Some of my students have gone to Iraq. This is a hard time for all of us. We accept what happened. We expect nothing but the most from this country's leadership. Our own country has many issues of its own. God bless America.

The cost and the sacrifice
It's axiomatic that heroism and sacrifice have become traduced through abuse by those who inflate the former and delfate the latter. Now we hear tales of 'heros' in grade school and 'sacrifices' made by those merely doing the job they're being paid for.

This editorial clarifies that real sacrifice has consequences and that heroism isn't a cliche to be lightly tossed about. That's a message America must hear if it has any hope of prevailing against the unflinching foes it faces.

See my post about the cost of independence, at:

http://www.clearcommentary.com

Best,

Phil Mella

Thank You ,Mr Will
George has a way with words. Baseball is one of his loves. He has captured the hearts of almost all who has read this article.

It is always so touching to picture the person who must deliver a message that will change the lives of a family. He makes us feel their pain.

As a parent who got a 4:00AM call to go to the hospital where my youngest son had been taken,as the result of an industrial accident,I feel their pain.My son had not survived the accident.

The next day,going to the funeral home to make arrangements,I remember seeing people coming and going as if nothing had happened.

It was almost surreal,as I felt like my world had ended,and thought the whole world should be mourning with me.

I give thanks to all who have fought for our country and those who have kept the peace. But expecially,those who lost loved ones. For them and their families,I pray they will have peace,also.





I know the feeling
I was a Sgt. in the Marine Corps. I then went into law enforcement. I retired as a Lt. During my service I drew the duty of informing the NOK of several deaths. It was one of the most difficult things I ever had to do. I have been shot at several times. I will take that any time over having to tell another family that their husband/dad/brother/son/wife/mom/sister/daughter will not be coming home. When Mr. Will says "They Know", he is so very right. They always know. When they look out the window and see the state trooper car in the drive way, they know.
I currently have two sons serving in the military and another who is a fire fighter, as well as several other family members in the military. I know the feeling of dread that comes with the ringing of the door bell. I know the feeling of dread when you can reach them by email for a few days. I can only "think" about the feelings my dad must have had when I was in the Corps all those years ago. He was lucky to get a letter, no, a short note from me once a month.
Thank God for all those men and women who make the choice everyday to protect our nation from those who seek to do us harm. And thank God for all those family members who let them go, support them, and wait for their return. You are true heros too.
God Bless you all.

The most moving article
I think this is one of the most moving articles I have read on townhall.

I returned from Iraq two months ago and have made it a point to be less of a news junkie and spend time with the family and fishing (i caught a 65# tuna on 4 July).

I think in many ways it was sometimes harder on my family here then on me. I knew I was safe and they were the ones always wondering.

Mr. Will wrote a great article that got right to the heart of what the families back home go through. It was tough to read with bleary eyes.
Tinsldr2@yahoo.com

George Will, Thank you.

Also thank all those who went in harms way to protect us and our way of life.

I am not a particularly emotional person, but I too, had tears in my eyes while reading the article, and some of the comments.


This was a powerful column, along with most of the commentary.



Thanks to all...
who have, continue and will in the future fight and fall for our liberty!

As usual, Will is Brilliant
A point that has been driven home to me on many occasions is that a professional soldier often has a different point of view about dying in combat than those who love and treasure them.

It is that death in combat is not just the loss of their life. It is the culmination of their chosen profession. In dying in combat the solder does something that most others do not in dying; the soldier’s life is made complete as well as finished.

This is not an easy thing to communicate so please give me your forbearance. No one wants to die, but not everyone fears death in the same way. Being a soldier does not mean a foolish disregard of death, but the knowledge that all life ends, and in ending in combat the soldier’s life has been properly finished.

All life is a gift of God and He alone knows what His plan for anyone is. He puts the same value on all lives by giving us all his Grace. In making the choice of a military profession, especially one that is combat oriented we take as a matter of faith that His plan for us is fulfilled if we die by a snipers fire, or after a long and productive life of service to each other and our Country.

I believe that George Will knows this and knows that those who have family in the line of fire, know deep in their own hearts that a higher purpose has been served when their loved one fails to return safely home after their duty on the battlements. Even that knowledge however can ever replace the promises and hopes that accompanies the loss of any life that is taken too soon.

In that respect, it does no harm to keep a prayer for those who choose to serve in our military and for those too many families that are changed forever by their loss.

Cheers,

Bloefeld

God bless those who bless us...
I have the deepest respect for our troops, our veterans, and especially for the fallen men and women who have sacrificed and given their lives to secure the freedoms that I enjoy as an American.

You are what makes America great.

I have travelled to many foreign countries, but I've never found one that can compare to the U.S.A. And it is you, brave men and women, who serve and have served in our military, who have made this country great.

I owe you all a debt of gratitude which I can never repay. I am humbled by your sacrifice and most grateful for your service which honors our country and our God. May God continue to bless you and yours.

Thank you, Mr. Will, for writing this poignant article.

Uncle Max
Thank you ! I have a neighbor just like him and its hard but ignoring them is the thing to do !

Thank you George Will and all of our men and women in uniform past and present.

God Bless America !

With all due respect
Blofield, "In dying in combat the solder does something that most others do not in dying; the soldier’s life is made complete as well as finished."
God's plan is not for soldiers to complete their lives as casualties of war. If that were true, we would all want to die. We fight against evil and some lose their lives in the fight.
God's plan is for all of us to live rich and fulfilled lives. The fact that some of us choose a profession that may someday take our lives and leave our loved ones behind, is a personal choice. We do it in love. Love for our country, love for our families, and love for our neighbor. That is God's ultimate plan and commandment.
"My command is this: Love each other as I have loved you. Greater love has no one than this, that he lay down his life for his friends." John 15:12-13 NIV
Thank you and God's blessings to all the families who have sacrificed and especially to those whos loved ones have paid the ultimate price for freedom that will never be free. May God's protection be over all that continue in the fight.

I'm sitting here bawling..
Probably the saddest column I've ever read. thanks George W., I'll recommend the article to all my family and friends.

Thank you
Whenever I have the occasion to write to our servicemen and women (something I do all too seldom), I always say the same thing, because it is the truest thing I can say. Throughout history, the preservation of every decent value has depended on people like you. Those of us in civilian life owe you a debt we can never repay.

My deepest gratitude to LTC Walton and my sincerest sympathies to Sarah.

KIA (Killed In Action)
The "Corpsman" (Navy enlisted) for the Marines, who call them "DOC", and the "Medic" Army and Air Force enlisted) for the Soldiers and Airmen, are the first words out of the mouths of wounded warriors when they are "hit" or when one of their buddies is hit on the field of battle.

The "Doc" and the "Medic" go immediately to the aid of the wounded warrior while disregarding their own safety during the battle to administer first aid to the WIA (Wounded In Action).

Many "Docs" and "Medics" have given their lives on the fields of battle while trying to save the lives of their wounded warrior buddies.

I mention this to let you know these are the first of many to shed tears when they are called to tag the KIA (Killed In Action). From them there is a long process of many military personnel involved in preparing the fallen warrior for their final destination.

The "Escort" is the military personnel who escort the fallen warrior to their hometown mortuary; The Burial Detail consists of six Pallbearers who remove and fold our American Flag; The Honor Guard consists of seven Riflemen who fire the salute; The Bugler who plays 'taps' and the OIC (Officer In Charge) who presents our American Flag to the NOK (Next Of Kin).

All of this occurs before, during and after LtCol. Steve Beck, the CACO (Casualty Assistant Calls Offier), has informed the fallen warrior's parents or NOK of their loss.

Those of us who have been involved in these duties are proud to have the honor of serving our fallen warriors during their last call to duty. We call it "Double Drill Duty."
1stSgt.,USMC(Ret)

Thank you
To the Walton's (and all of the military families) for their sacrifice. You are all in our prayers. God bless you in your loss and for your sacrifices.

Beautiful column Mr. Will, absolutely beautiful!

best of the best
This is George Will's finest work.

Outstanding Column
It is a credit to the author of a column when the reader is taken to another place and time without realizing it; when the author's mark and style is invisible and all that remains is the effects the words have on the reader's emotions.

George has written a column in which the written word has disappeared and in its place is an emotion so strong and deeply felt, that the memory of the story is seared into my psyche forever.

As a Marine Vietnam Veteran, I stand and salute you George Will. You have done a service to these brave men and women and their families and it is appreciated.


Amen MSGT, Low through the valley.......
RetMSgt
Location: AR

Reply # 60
Date: Jul 6, 2008 - 10:58 PM EST Subject: With all due respect
Blofield, "In dying in combat the solder does something that most others do not in dying; the soldier’s life is made complete as well as finished."
God's plan is not for soldiers to complete their lives as casualties of war. If that were true, we would all want to die. We fight against evil and some lose their lives in the fight.
Heros lie still upon the red stained carpet of the battlefield, whilest us onlookers trudge of to fight again. Oh the silence doth scream at us all.

RetMSgt, Butcher
God indeed has a plan for all of us, and it is His and only His to know.

I take your point that of Butcher even more so.

Please take no offense at my inept try to explain something that I feel and I know a lot of others feel.

God Bless all, but especially those who die in keeping even the most unworthy of us free.

Cheers,

Bloefeld

In Honor of Our Fallen
The phrase at the end of George Will's Sunday morning article, "Sarah, full sharer of his sacrifices", made me think about my mother, it touched my heart and brought tears to my eyes. In my case the woman left behind, Hazel
Ratliff, although inconsolably grief-stricken after my father's WW II death, had to pick up the pieces of the broken family and carry on, so in some ways her sacrifices may have been
greater. When mother was 85 she said this to me, "I carried out all of his requests, all that he ever made of me. I did all the things your heart tells you to do."
Always In Their Memory by AWON Author,
Thomas G. Ratliff
Google me and AWON for more information.
Sign Up to Post Your CommentsSign Up to Post Your Comments
If you are already registered, click here to login. Otherwise, please take a few seconds to register with Townhall.com. Once you sign up, you’ll be able to post your comments immediately, use the action center, get podcasts, and more!
Note: Fields marked with a red asterisk (*) are required.
Salutation:
First Name:
*
Last Name:
*
Email:
*
Nickname:
*
Note: Nick name will be shown when you post comments.
Address 1:
*
Address 2:
City:
*
State:
*
Zip:
*
Phone:
      
Your daily must-read of conservative columns, cartoons and news. Coulter, Sowell, Krauthammer and more.
(Bi-Weekly) We highlight the best opportunities from our partners for surveys, action items and more.