Townhall.com, Where Your Opinion Counts
Talk Radio:   Bill Bennett   Mike Gallagher   Dennis Prager   Michael Medved   Hugh Hewitt   
BREAKING NEWS  LeftArrow - Townhall.com : Conservative, Political, Republican   RightArrow - Townhall.com : Conservative, Political, Republican  
Columns, funnies & more in your inbox!
  • Check the boxes and send us your email address to receveive your free newsletter
  • Your daily must-read of conservative columns, cartoons and news. Coulter, Sowell, Krauthammer and more.
  • Townhall.com’s weekly inside scoop on what’s happening behind the scenes in the world of politics. When news breaks, we report.
  • Signup to receive the latest daily Townhall cartoons
Wednesday, June 17, 2009
Gary Aldrich :: Townhall.com Columnist
Air, Water, and Liberty
by Gary Aldrich
Vote on It:
Average Vote:
[+] Text [-]
 
 
Poll
Will the Dems' health care Christmas Present to America be an improvement or detriment to our health care system?


Everybody knows that clean water and air are important. That's because the special environmental interests have bullied the population in believing that we are in mortal danger if we don't bend ourselves to their demands. They brainwash our children so that the message is never lost, and the power created is never diminished.

There was evidence that we were not good stewards of our cities and country settings, but that was a long time ago. Not only are there many laws in place today, but the planet is much cleaner. There also exists a strong consensus about what each of us should do to maintain a clean planet.

But what about liberty? If you took a poll today you would have a hard time finding a citizen raised in this country who can articulate how vital liberty is to our happiness and prosperity, and why we should protect it above all else. Liberty is an essential element for the creation of happiness and prosperity, even if most people have no idea why.

If one chose to live a most modest lifestyle, one can still enjoy liberty as a natural right. Yet this country is not set on a course to live a modest life. We are lectured, maybe hectored daily, that our children should attend college – as many as possible. But what is the point of a higher education, if not to compete in the world as it is today? Our world is about commerce, productivity, and taxes.

This twist on the old work ethic is not of our creation but rather as a result of a national consensus. More people don't want to work, but they want their color TV, their microwave, their cell phones. Who will deny them these “basic constitutional rights?” Certainly not the politicians who buy votes in exchange for toaster ovens.

Since liberty and socialism cannot coexist, why are we, the productive, driving our children to become slaves of the state? Shouldn't we be teaching them to fight for clean air, clean water, and liberty?

Will they be happy to work all of their lives so that others may lounge? Are you creating, raising, and educating your kids to become cogs and drones, to be ill-used for the benefit of the masses?

You have spent your lives guiding them to get a higher GPA, but have you told them about liberty?

Will it give your children happiness and contentment to see government bureaucrats jetting here and there, driven in black limousines from one social event to another, living the high life with money robbed from their pockets? Will they wonder why you set them up to be compliant beasts of burden, trained to pull somebody else's cart?

As your children receive their pink slips and are unable to get a job, will they turn with admiration and pleasure to see others in favored classes, enjoying job security? Will they smile as they see the average government slug shuffling off to their job to accomplish nothing much in a redundant slot created when money was plentiful, but not eliminated now that it is in short supply? The government lives as if there is no tomorrow.

As Patrick Henry once asked his countrymen, “Why stand you idle?”

Folks, the rules have changed. What drove you and me to succeed in school was the potential wealth from good grades, hard work, and best behavior. We outdid ourselves and began to brag about it. The have-nots who live among us, the unproductive, heard us bragging. They envied us, became jealous, and accused us of unfair success as a result of simple luck. But it was not good luck! It was hard work.

And lazy, dishonest politicians saw an opportunity.

Together they formed a movement. They plotted ways to steal chunks of our kill, even though not a single one of these do-nothings offered a moment of their time to help us catch our dinner. Their only agenda was, and always seems to be, how to take from you what they cannot figure out how to earn for themselves.

This is not a movement for social justice. It more closely resembles a cabal of bank robbers. It is basic human greed masquerading as victimization caused by bad luck, or inaccessibility to opportunity, or victims of mean spirited intentions. They impugn our hard work and our character by alleging negative motivations, while at the same time they piously grant themselves immunity from responsibility.

The facts are, as in the case of clean air and clean water, we also cleaned up our act in our institutions and places of employment long ago. Apparently it's not enough. It will never be enough.

There is no perfect, yet imperfection is held over our heads as “evidence” while our liberties hang in the balance. The productive ones support the ever increasing numbers of the willfully unproductive who have ever increasing exotic “needs.” Too many politicians and government bureaucrats live high on the hog – expensive human collateral damage from an out of control political agenda. And the damage is on us.

Our liberty is under assault as an endless number of self-righteous scolds guilt trip us into higher taxes and fewer freedoms. They say it is for the good of others, while our children’s and grandchildren's futures fade. They say majority mob-ism is perfectly legitimate. After all, it’s not illegal, is it?

I say the Founders did not intend for future citizens to be able to unravel a country as easily as a mischievous child pulls the loose yarn hanging from a sweater, but apparently, it is that easy.

Share:
Vote on It:
Average Vote:
 
About The Author
pollution as removal of liberty
Saying polluting air or water removes liberty is too simplistic. I am not forced to breathe bad air or drink bad water. In fact, if I took responsibility for myself, I would have to protect myself without relying on others good will or the long arm of the law. If such protection were more than walking away, I would be able to ask the polluter to pay for the protection or cleanup. No gov't rule or regulation works as well as making the polluter pay.

Not unraveled yet
But the mischievous child was trained well in his community of organizers and malcontents. The people take time rise up and bring the concepts of the Founding Fathers back into the nation's governance.

None, you don't understand that
liberty ends when you infringe on others liberty. Therefore, polluting air and water is not liberty, but the removal of liberty from others. Liberty does not mean complete free reign.

None...
You are absolutely wrong. All that is required is to develop property rights around air and water. Obviously, something like air is difficult for creating tangible property rights like for land. But there are mechanisms where courts are used to arbitrate nuisances. And pollutig the air is a nuisance. When you foul the air so that it affects your neighbor, he can sue for redress. At that point, it becomes possible to negotiate a settlement whereby the party "harmed" is paid by the party "harming" for the privilege of continuing. Courts can take into account facts like if the harmed party moved into a location where the harm had been occuring previously or when offending party has increased the magnitude of the harm beyond what was previously negotiated or even willingly accepted.

It creates a market with corresponding prices to tell people how much they should spend to abate their pollution or what they should expect if they intend to live near a polluter.

Mutually Exclusive
To put claen air and waater, with the concept called liberty is mutually exclusive. In order to have clean air and water, you have to sacrfice some liberties.

Gunnycee
You ask, "Very high and noble ideals and ones we can all live by, however, once the Jinnie is out of the bottle, how do we stuff it back in?"

Did you read Jillian Bandes's column yesterday about Sen DeMint endorsing Rubio over Crist in Florida? Now there is the kind of thing we can and need to do. I'm sure Crist would be better than anybody the Dems will put up and I'm sure he's a nice guy. But he is more in the mold of McCain and the other moderate to liberal Republican Senators who do not represent their states interests as much as they seek personal power and glory. They are going to go along to get along and we are never going to get the Genie back in the bottle if we keep electing them. I don't know Rubio, but we need to elect more senators (and representatives) who live and breathe states rights, individual rights, and the constitution as the law of the land. Since everybody who goes to DC seems to get corrupted eventually, we need to keep close eyes on our elected representation in Congress and make sure they are continuing to follow the constitution and when they show signs of corruption or malfeasance, replace them. I can't worry about what Floridians or Californians or other people around the country do, but I can dang sure work for strict constitutionalists trying to get elected here in Texas! And that is what I am and will continue to do. Maybe one day you guys in NC can replace your joke of a senator with a real constitutionalist. I hope so!

Freedom, Liberty, & Justice
Freedom exists on many levels. Liberty can only exist at the highest level of freedom. Justice cannot exist without Liberty.

It stops at invading mine
Liberty is your ability to do whatever you want until it infringes on my liberty to do whatever I want. Once an individual impedes in some way, the ability of another individual to do as they want, it is the end of liberty. Government by exceeding their constitutional authority has interfered in the individual's liberty.

Government, leave us the hell alone!

We need global warming!!!
The reason that so much of this planet has had drought for so long is that we’ve been in an ice age, and water needed for normal condensation has been frozen into glaciers. Glaciers are frozen water needed as condensation for barren and frozen lands of this planet, causing drought and flooding. When glaciers melt, some water runs into the oceans. Some water thaws the ground below where the glacier was, and soaks into the ground. Some water evaporates into the upper atmosphere to become normal rainfall for the whole world.

The heat of the sun, clean air, and the absence of cold from glaciers and sea ice would cause more water to evaporate from the oceans, lakes, and rivers into the upper atmosphere than there presently is; the winds would blow it evenly around the world, providing normal rainfall world-wide, even where there presently is drought and barren and frozen land, preventing flooding. Ice contracts when it melts, and would lower sea level.

The worldwide rainfall would cause long-dormant seeds in barren lands to sprout and grow into new plants: The best way to go green. The new plants would inhale carbon dioxide and exhale oxygen, which we breathe. There would be so many new plants, that we might have to increase the amount of carbon dioxide we generate, to provide enough for all of them

If the glacier in Greenland would melt, the codfish, which fled the severe cold temperature, would return, and the land could be farmed, as it was when originally colonized by Vikings.

Many parts of the world have record amounts of snow and ice. Arctic ice is as thick as it was in the 1970’s when an ice age was predicted. Polar bears, which had thrived during the previous decade, are heading south to escape the severe cold. We’re entering another ice age in 2014. We must drill and pump our own oil, natural gas, and mine our coal as soon as possible, so they are available for use.

Steve and Gunnycee
You guys are prototypcial players in the economic models of guys like Adam Smith, Ludwig von Mises,
Hayek and others; even Ayn Rand. People who pursue what are essentially selfish ends, pursuing work that is personally satisfying, wind up helping others incidentally.
Good on ya.
Though this is not to say that another's selfish end is a pure ambition to gather money by any legal means. Just that your example fits the neo-classical liberal economic models pretty nicely.

To Joel Reply #7
Very high and noble ideals and ones we can all live by, however, once the Jinnie is out of the bottle, how do we stuff it back in? The federal government has its tenacles firmly entrenched in our lives right down to the very neighborhoods we live in. Every day the feds seek more and more power over our lives and we sit on our hands while our liberties and freedoms are taken away in little increments.

We conservatives are the actual victims, though I doubt we are going to start whining about it. I fully expect that 2010 will be a jubilee year for conservatives. I believe there will be a groundswell of Republicans and Democrats who have been shocked out of their complacency, who have had enough of seeing their beloved country dying before their very eyes, who will get out the vote and start the process of sweeping the Marxist communists out of their local governments right on up to the White House and Congress.

Steve, Reply #4
I was raised in the 50's and joined the Marines in 1959. I agree with you, that I could done anything and made more money at the time. But, accululation of wealth has never been my thing. That doesn't preclude others from seeking as much wealth as they can accumulate through sacrifice, honest labor, and ingenuity. It does not mean that one has the right to steal another person's wealth by dishonest means which is what socialism is all about. That's a crime in anyone's book. To expect the government to provide me with my wants and needs is to give up my freedom and liberty. I cherish those more than free transportation, free ghetto housing, and free grocieries. Mass transit IS but one means to an end; that of stripping of us of the freedom to use our automobiles to go wherever we want whenever we want. If you can't see that the liberal's end game is to change (insert your favorite government program) by any means necessary, then get a clue yourself. To liberals, it means we all eventually take government jobs, run around in little electric carts, riding bicycles, or an even better alternative, using mass transit and walking. If you can't see that then it is you who has no clue.

Feel free to Mock Steve, but when someone mocks you back, don't have a hissy fit.

slowly.....
"You are not smart enough to be an engineer"

don't tell my boss

"have known the difference between socialism and subways"

good god, I was mocking the conservatives who equate mass transit with un-american euro values. get a freakin clue!

Steve from CA
You are not smart enough to be an engineer. My father was an engineer. He was brilliant and would have known the difference between socialism and subways and bridges. I suppose you think the military is a socialist idea. Duh!

I say if you receive gov't monies
You loose your right to vote.

nice value system....
"What drove you and me to succeed in school was the potential wealth from good grades"

Maybe for you, but it wasn't even a consideration for me. I wanted a job that I enjoyed; if I wanted money I would have studied 'business' not engineering. I studied to learn what I needed so that I would have a job I enjoyed going to every day and one that would actually do good for society. (building evil socialist creations like subways, rail stations, airports and all sorts of other public works.) I also wanted a job that would take me all over the world, allow me to work and live in different, exciting places. I can honestly say that I accepted one mid-career position without even inquiring about the salary. It wsn't until the afternoon of my first day on the job that I tracked down an HR person and found out my salary. Different strokes...

Loving liberty
Great subject matter. It need to be visited often and forcefully.
It is unfortunate that historic analysis of our nation's situation leads us to the conclusion that we need either a peaceful revolution, i.e. a constitutional convention or a non-peaceful one. The potential dangers of the former are preferable to the certain dangers of the latter.
Cowards and doubters step back. It will take the courage, patience and wisdom of the founders to pull it off.

Clean air and water.

I like clean air.

I like Clean water.

I don't like Liberals.

I am a conservative.

Major Hypocrite
Aldrich trumpets the cause of "liberty" yet staunchly supports and rationalizes the war on drugs. I guess it doesn't bother him that tens of millions of his fellow citizens have become criminals, oppressed by their own government for nothing more than a preference in the means of achieving inebriation that differs moderately from one of the politically favored substances (alcohol, prescription drugs, etc.).

Aldrich has no credibility with me when it comes to defending the fundamental rights of liberty espoused by our nation's founders. Walter Williams, John Stossel, Thomas Sowell, Jacob Sullum, and others at Townhall are much more powerful and intellectually consistent voices for the cause of liberty.

Nio
What an amazing quote. I was not familiar with this one. Thank you for sharing.

Lincoln, no doubt, was talking about the South demanding the “liberty” to own slaves, but how appropriately this can be used to describe socialism. And how chillingly relevant it is to what is going on in our country today. Just goes to prove that the heart of man never changes. Or to put it another way, the more things change, the more they stay the same.

I have never been able to understand how liberals can denounce slavery with such passion, and yet have no problem with making slaves of us all in servitude to government.

Will we ever hear the truth?
Over and again, we have been led astray. We have been told that television would give us unfettered truth. We believed the media. We believed politicians. We believed companies. We believed institutions.

"Let your yes be yes and your no be no" seem to be lost in modern politcs, journalism and society at large

Heres a blog post that talks about that:

http://redletterbelievers.blogspot.com/2009/06/will-we-ever -trust-again.html

It is only that easy....
when we forget the definitions of our founding principles - one of which, of course, is liberty.

"We all declare for liberty; but in using the same word we do not all mean the same thing. With some the word liberty may mean for each man to do as he pleases with himself, and the product of his labor; while with others, the same word may mean for some men to do as they please with other men, and the product of other men's labor. Here are two, not only different, but incompatible things, called by the same name - liberty. And it follows that each of the things is, by the respective parties, called by two different and incompatible names -- liberty and tyranny."
- Abraham Lincoln

Mr. Aldrich, you have just published an entire article devoted to liberty, yet you yourself have not even come close to including an absolute definition of this word, this thing that you say must be "protected above all else." If liberty does not have an absolute definition, then of course it is easy to ignore, discount or abolish. You cannot build a nation upon principles that are not defined. To do so is the same as passing a law that contains no wording.

If you want to know the absolute definition of this word, then you will have to do some reading. 233 years of ignorance and misinformation cannot be remedied in an instant.
Sign Up to Post Your CommentsSign Up to Post Your Comments
If you are already registered, click here to login. Otherwise, please take a few seconds to register with Townhall.com. Once you sign up, you’ll be able to post your comments immediately, use the action center, get podcasts, and more!
Note: Fields marked with a red asterisk (*) are required.
Salutation:
First Name:
*
Last Name:
*
Email:
*
Nickname:
*
Note: Nick name will be shown when you post comments.
Address 1:
*
Address 2:
City:
*
State:
*
Zip:
*
Phone:
      
Your daily must-read of conservative columns, cartoons and news. Coulter, Sowell, Krauthammer and more.
(Bi-Weekly) We highlight the best opportunities from our partners for surveys, action items and more.