Townhall.com, Where Your Opinion Counts
Talk Radio:   Bill Bennett   Mike Gallagher   Dennis Prager   Michael Medved   Hugh Hewitt   
BREAKING NEWS  LeftArrow - Townhall.com : Conservative, Political, Republican   RightArrow - Townhall.com : Conservative, Political, Republican  
Columns, funnies & more in your inbox!
  • Check the boxes and send us your email address to receveive your free newsletter
  • Your daily must-read of conservative columns, cartoons and news. Coulter, Sowell, Krauthammer and more.
  • Townhall.com’s weekly inside scoop on what’s happening behind the scenes in the world of politics. When news breaks, we report.
  • Signup to receive the latest daily Townhall cartoons
Tuesday, May 27, 2008
Frank Gaffney :: Townhall.com Columnist
Israel's Staticide?
by Frank Gaffney
Vote on It:
Average Vote:
[+] Text [-]
 
Poll
Will the Dems' health care Christmas Present to America be an improvement or detriment to our health care system?


There is a Greek tragedy unfolding today in the Middle East. In response to past mistakes and as a result of hubristic political calculation, Israeli Prime Minister Ehud Olmert is setting in motion forces that promise to lead inexorably to grief for his nation. The result could be staticide, the destruction of the Jewish State, with incalculably serious repercussions for the Free World in general and the United States in particular.

In the pursuit of peace with its neighbors, Israel has made one strategic concession after another. In 1979, it surrendered the Sinai to Egypt when Anwar Sadat promised peace and then was murdered for doing so. In 1993, Israel adopted the Oslo accords, legitimating one of its most virulent enemies, the PLO terrorist chief Yasser Arafat, and setting the stage for Palestinian control of the West Bank and Gaza Strip.

Eight years ago this month, Israel unilaterally withdrew from South Lebanon, creating a vacuum promptly filled by Iran’s proxy army there, Hezbollah. Then, in 2005, Israel forcibly removed its citizens living in Gaza and turned the Strip over – temporarily – to Arafat’s right-hand man and successor, Fatah leader Mahmoud Abbas.

Space constraints will not permit a full rendering of the costs associated with these serial mistakes. The “peace” with Egypt proved to be a very cold one. In Sadat’s stead, the government of Hosni Mubarak has promoted virulent hatred for Israel among its people and assiduously armed for renewed conflict with the Jewish State. It has also used the Sinai to funnel ever-longer-range missiles and other advanced weapons from Iran to the Gaza Strip – now under the control of another Palestinian terrorist faction, Hamas.

The latter and its friends, including the Palestinian Islamic Jihad, al Qaeda and the Iranian Revolutionary Guards, are now using Gaza as a safe-haven for planning and executing terrorism against Israel. It is a safe bet that Israel’s most important ally, the United States, is being targeted from there, as well.

Meanwhile, Hezbollah has not just taken over South Lebanon – its dominance of which was greatly strengthened when Olmert’s government proved incapable of decisively defeating the forces of this so-called “Army of God” in 2006. In recent days, Hezbollah launched attacks in Beirut that effectively produced a coup d’etat. The hopes for a democratic Lebanon, free of Syrian and Iranian interference, have given way to a dark future for the Lebanese people and their neighbors in Israel, alike.

Tragically, despite this sorry record of retreat followed by intensified danger, Ehud Olmert is making further and even more strategic territorial and political concessions to Israel’s enemies. By so doing, the Israeli prime minister evidently hopes to stave off accountability for these past mistakes. He also appears to be calculating that “peace-making” will spare him prosecution on myriad corruption charges.

Unfortunately, there is now no basis for depicting such a policy as one in which Israel trades “land for peace.” Today, Israel is giving up land for war.

In the illusion that that there is any appreciable difference between Fatah and Hamas, Olmert’s government is trying to turn over nearly all the West Bank and even parts of Jerusalem to Abbas and his faction’s Palestinian police force. A similar illusion is causing the United States to give Fatah’s troops training, intelligence collection equipment and arms. The latter have already used their American-supplied know-how and weapons to kill Israelis.

Olmert is also allowing the Egyptians to broker a cease-fire with Hamas. The result is predictable: Hamas will be legitimated, effectively ending international efforts to relegate it to pariah status and probably producing a unity government whereby the two Palestinian factions join forces once again. The stage will then be set for the ultimate defeat of Fatah by Hamas in the West Bank as well, putting all of Israel within range of its weapons.

These tragic steps are now being compounded by one further, potentially staticidal act: Olmert has just launched negotiations to surrender all of the Golan Heights to Syria.

This concession would place Syrian – and quite possibly Iranian – forces on high ground which, in Israeli hands, has kept the peace for 35 years. If once again at the disposal of Israel’s enemies, these heights will put northern Israel at risk of, at best, harassing fire and, at worst, a new invasion in force.

Moreover, as my esteemed colleague, Caroline Glick, observed in her Jerusalem Post column last week, if Israel can no longer use the Golan to threaten Syria, Damascus and Tehran may feel free to redouble their subversion in Iraq. Iran may even conclude the Golan can allow it to checkmate any lingering Israeli willingness to interfere with the mullahs’ pursuit of nuclear weapons.

Importantly, the Israeli people finally seem to have had enough of false peace processes. Recent polls indicate that two-thirds of Israelis oppose their country’s surrender of the Golan; a majority believe it is motivated by Olmert’s efforts to stave off prosecution. Even the Bush Administration is said to be unhappy about his Golan initiative.

This weekend, the American Israel Public Affairs Committee (AIPAC) – universally known as “the Israel lobby” – holds its annual Policy Conference in Washington. The organization exists to support the Israeli government. At this juncture, however, attendees have an opportunity and an obligation to object to that government’s increasingly reckless, and predictably tragic, conduct. After all, friends don’t let friends commit staticide.

Share:
Vote on It:
Average Vote:
 
About The Author

Frank Gaffney Jr. is the founder and president of the Center for Security Policy and author of War Footing: 10 Steps America Must Take to Prevail in the War for the Free World .
 
TOWNHALL DAILY: Be the first to read Frank Gaffney's column. Sign up today and receive Townhall.com daily lineup delivered each morning to your inbox.

the endless con job...
re:
"He (Gaffney) is such a Zionist whacko that from safety over here he takes it upon himself to lecture the majority of Israeli Jews who wish to negotiate with democratically elected representatives of Palestinians and Lebanese, as well as Syrians, for being insufficiently patriotic!"

**********************************************
Boutte is spot on correct as usual... I am surprised the Zionist crowd has not "booted" him off of TH. The usual suspects will drown out Scott McClellan, but he is telling the truth-- as far as he can understand it.

Gaffney is simply in the militant Zionist/ neoCON camp... his confreres (Wolfowitz, Perle, Libby, Feith, Ari Fleisher on the inside, and Kristol, Kagan, Krauthammer, Barone, Cliff May, et al in the media) got us into this war against the wrong bad guys per their PNAC agenda. Their REAL goal has ALWAYS been the establishment of a permanent American presence in Iraq to protect Israel's flank. Certainly they favor McAmnesty over Obama because he is Presidente Jorge redux-- an easy dupe for their agenda. You can read a good account of it in "Hubris: The Inside Story of Spin, Scandal, and the Selling of the Iraq War"
It is AMAZING what america has been made to do for a tiny country with the population of Houston. Such a deal!

http://www.csmonitor.com/specials/neocon/spheresInfluence.h tml
http://www.boston.com/news/globe/editorial_opinion/editoria ls/articles/2007/11/04/a_lazy_simplistic_analogy/
http://tvnewslies.org/html/pnac_neo-con_artists.html

Israel
Israeli's want McCain to win, NOT Obama. Check the Ha'Aretz polls. They're accurate.

Liberal Jews, like liberals everywhere, want Obama to win. Israeli's political/social problems have been caused by the left, just as in Europe and the U.S.

America has been the driving force behind Israel's negotiating away her land. We're doing essentially the same thing by allowing illegal invaders to squat on our soil. America needs to respect borders internationally as well as nationally.

To the Palastinian sympathizing poster: The Arabs (palastinians) who were living in the land of Israel were TOLD TO LEAVE by their Arab brethren, so they could slaughter all Jews and gave a promise that they could take possession of Jewish homes and businesses. These were Arabs living peacefully with Jews, often sharing meals in their homes and greatly profitting from the labors of Jews. These Arabs left WILLINGLY in the joyous anticipation of annihilation of their Jewish neighbors, who were suppose to be their friends. The Arabs presently living in Israel enjoy prosperty and freedoms not available anywhere else in the ME. Israel is very generous in provisions to its neighbors who try to kill them daily.

Israel America's Evil Parasite
Israel has been exploiting America and Americans for a very long time. Again we see America's leaders lining up to save the vision of some religious extremist. Only a religious extremist thinks God hands out land deeds.

This author is deluded into thinking a GET TUFF policy will change the fundamentals. If you are surrounded by people who dont like you invading there countries DOES NOT HELP. You can invade them, bomb them , talk tuff until your dry in the mouth they will only hate you more. I guess some people will only be satisfied with genocide. I think the author wants to kill all the Arabs in the middle east to make the world fit for his holy whiteness. Perhaps then the Chosen People will be satisfied. Until then America will keep paying and Arabs will keep planning to rule their own region.

Reply to AuroraWatcher
"Israel and the US have given the Palestinians lots of acknowledgments and many opportunities to agree to peace and keep the peace;"

I don't dispute any of the above. Yet, I've also read too many surveys and articles to ignore which show that the majority of both Israeli's and Palestinians want peace through a two-state solution. Polls even show majority agreement for details like like some kind of territorial exchange in the west bank.

"unfortunately, that usually ends with a Palestinian or a dozen blowing themselves up in an Israeli market, killing innocent civilians or a Palestinian rocket or a half-dozen being launched into an Israeli neighborhood in the middle of the night."

But the above is unfair. It is true that these events occur but to call them 'endings' is to put your own spin and prejudice on the reality. These suicide bombings and rocket attacks, barbaric, stupid, and counterproductive as they certainly are, do not occur in a vacuum. Israeli attacks (using US-supplied missiles) on alleged militants and the resulting deaths of surrounding civilians and children, ongoing expansion of settlements in the west bank with the condemnation and razing of Palestinian houses and farmlands, invasion and arrests (even in Gaza) of huge numbers of people and their mistreatment in Israeli jails, as well as day-to-day life in what amounts to a country-sized penal colony, are all part of the mix of cause-and-effect.

HD
The reason the Israelis are still having to fight is they don't finish the job, I.E. kill as many of their enemies as they can. The warring will stop when Hezbollah et.al. get hurt so bad they don't want to fight anymore.
Then Israel will have peace.

AirGuard
"...I was referring to the US, Vietnam, LBJ, and his administration. In WWII, the US and UK achieved an objective, demanded and received an unconditional surrender, then greatly assisted in the reclaimation process."

My point is all with Congressional oversight and "aggravation". In the UK The House of Commons did no less. That is why free nations defeat dictatorships. Nixon's political use of the War also required Congressional intervention. In reality Korea and Vietnam were battles in the overall Cold War which by the way the US and free world won

"For Israel to concede land that was paid for at the cost of human lives in the hopes of maintaining an uneasy peace is akin to blackmail. Would you pay a thief a yearly, monthly, or weekly stipend if he would agree not to break into your home and take it by force?"

The blood argument works both ways and time shows it bears little weight. At the end of the day what and soldier wants and what they fought for was the best interest of the country.

"The fact is Olmert has purchased an uneasy peace in his lifetime by conceding land at the cost of the lives of not only his ancestors but his children and granchildren. "

No the facts are that the Israeli tactics of selective assassination, war and violence have produced nothing but the same. It is time to try a different path

Hal Donahue, et al,
I was referring to the US, Vietnam, LBJ, and his administration. In WWII, the US and UK achieved an objective, demanded and received an unconditional surrender, then greatly assisted in the reclaimation process.
For Israel to concede land that was paid for at the cost of human lives in the hopes of maintaining an uneasy peace is akin to blackmail. Would you pay a thief a yearly, monthly, or weekly stipend if he would agree not to break into your home and take it by force?
The fact is Olmert has purchased an uneasy peace in his lifetime by conceding land at the cost of the lives of not only his ancestors but his children and granchildren.

none/Aurorawatcher
"You didn't mention from where the 'palestinians' get most of their aid money.
From us, through the UN."

Really? I thought we gave it outright and can Israel survive without the massive US funding we give them?

"...I just don't understand that, or why the majority of Israelis want to talk with the Palestinians. It can only turn outbad for them."

Really? The endless war they have been involved in for the last generation has produced neither safety nor peace only violence and defeat

AirGuard
"I seem to remember a country that allowed its Democratically run government to dictate military strategy and policy...."

That would be the UK and the US circa WWII. Do you have a problem with that? Also that would be the Cold War free world who won without firing a shot. Do you have a problem with that? Go read history please

Aurorawatcher
You didn't mention from where the 'palestinians' get most of their aid money.
From us, through the UN.

Israel should have never given up the Sinai. That showed weakness, and started them on the slippery slope they're still on. Land for peace? Has it worked? No, but they keep trying. Why? Don't they know the admonition about doing the same thing over and over but expecting different results?
I just don't understand that, or why the majority of Israelis want to talk with the Palestinians. It can only turn outbad for them.

Sounds All Too Familiar!
I seem to remember a country that allowed its Democratically run government to dictate military strategy and policy. In the name of diplomacy, high ground that had been won at great cost of human life was negotiated away at the bargaining table. This high ground would have to be retaken by force when the other party at the negotiating table failed to live up to the agreement. This back and forth went on for years and the loss of sons, husbands, and fathers was great.
"Those who fail to learn from history are doomed to repeat it." - Winston Churchill

Frank
Two points only:

First; Israel has been as unreasonable and as violent as the palistinians - a pox on both their houses

Second, Israel, which consumes the lion's share of our foreign aid and expenditures last I checked, is an ally like Britian but we remained relatively silent and even sheltered IRA people. Let them sort it out.

israel

maybe if he hadnt been so damn greedy in his thievery he would be able to spend more time worrying abou tthe problems of his country not about his upcoming indictment. When a thief loves a theif does that increase the possiblity that both will become thieves. perhaps this explais why there is so much support fo r israel in our government.

demise of israel already set
According to the Book of Revelation, Israel will do whatever she will, even giving in totally to her enemies in time, to appease peace; how true this event now unfolding in America marching in same cadence to appease the terrorist. i'm very sure the next president, Democrat or Republican will give up on Israel. American growing tire of defending others. When Israel fall America will follow. God is in control; Israel will not be totally destroyed according to God covenant with Abraham. Yes, Israel can give up her land but God always has the pre-eminence. I love Israel and America but the writing has already itched on the wall.

FLM
Israel and the US have given the Palestinians lots of acknowledgments and many opportunities to agree to peace and keep the peace; unfortunately, that usually ends with a Palestinian or a dozen blowing themselves up in an Israeli market, killing innocent civilians or a Palestinian rocket or a half-dozen being launched into an Israeli neighborhood in the middle of the night. The international press often ignores that and the US press almost always does, but then when Israel gets tired of the non-peace and retaliates, the press suddenly begins to notice and berate Israel for their "unilateral" attacks. I have a friend who is an archeologist living in Israel and often working on the West Bank and he says we in America haven't got a clue about how Israel is bending over backwards to stop the death of their citizens while (some) Palestinians continue to plot the destruction of Israel. Peace is not the absence of armed conflict, but a sense that you can actually be safe in your own home at night. The Israelis will never have this until the Palestinians commit to stopping their attacks. Does anyone want to lay money on the odds of that? If Israel were to stop all retaliatory strikes and withdraw back into their original UN-sanctioned territory, do any of us think the Palestinians would stop attacking them? I've been watching this for about 35 years and I think the Palestinians would just mount an all-out offensive to get the rest of Israel because they hate Jews that much and think they should have the land their ancestors sold to the Jewish settlers because, well, I don't know, Hitler told them they could have it back and, darn, you know, losing a war or three that you started is no reason you should lose your land to the nation you attacked.

Too bad Frank Gaffney...
... can't hold down a real job anymore.

Incompetence or $Corruption
One fact that is left out of virtually all discussions of Politics is Oil Money. Huge amounts of money in cash that can be funneled to any politicians, his family members, or Swiss bank accounts. The politicians include Israeli politicians.

The people that funnel this money are pros. They have been doing this for decades. They know how to do this quietly without a trace.

There is so little awareness of the possibilities of huge amounts of money being funneled to politicians that there has not been one single story on the $millions funneled to the Bush family through George Bush Sr (Consultant to the King of Saudi Arabia). The Dems in congress who supposedly hate Bush should be screaming to the roof tops. But nary a whisper. Could they be on the take as well? Saudi Arabia could not have imagined the Green movement in their wildest dreams. Can anyone imagine that it hasn't occurred to them to fund it? Look at how big that investment has paid off.

Huge amounts of oil money is available to be funneled to electronic and newsprint journalist.

Huge amounts of oil money is available to research the history and backgrounds of any politician and his close family members and to use any weakness as leverage.

History is replete with corruption of this kind. But for our modern day journalism there isn't a whisper. Is there any other explanation for this deadly quiet than huge amounts of oil mone?


Why?
", the Israeli people finally seem to have had enough of false peace processes. Recent polls indicate that two-thirds of Israelis oppose their country’s surrender of the Golan; a majority believe it is motivated by Olmert’s efforts to stave off prosecution.

Some facts to chew on.

"MOST ISRAELIS SAY THEIR GOV'T SHOULD ENGAGE IN DIRECT TALKS WITH HAMAS

64% of Israelis say the government must hold direct talks with the Hamas government in Gaza

An increasing number of public figures, including senior officers in the Israel Defense Forces' reserves, have expressed similar positions on talks with Hamas.

It now appears that this opinion is gaining traction in the wider public."

http://www.haaretz.com/hasen/spa...ges/ 958473.html


Jerusalem Post:

MOST JEWISH VOTERS WANT BARACK OBAMA TO WIN

61% of Jewish voters prefer Obama 32% prefer McCain

http://www.jpost.com/servlet/ Sat...d=1209627043154

The Israeli Press keeps Olmert in power
Just like their assistance to the hardcore left in this country. Hopefully the average Israeli will figure it out and take the actions which need to be taken. Including the arrest and execution of their media for treason and murder. Again, similar circumstances here but the remedies aren't and they're running out of time faster.
My advice would be to launch now before it's too late. As soon as Olmert is gone.

Olmert
Hopefully his days are numbered.


Israel isn't going anywhere.


Read EZ 38/39

The Inevitable In The Worst Possible Way

Any student of unbiased history cannot deny the legitimate claim to existence and the moral need for an Independent Palestinian State. They are precisely the same grounds, precisely the same treaties and documents, that give Israel it's legitimate claim to existence and independence.

It seems to me that, contrary to Mr. Gaffney's claims that Ohlmerts attempts to do what is morally right amount to "staticide", the real staticide occurs when Israel, America, and the West refuse to even engage with, and give any real help, assistance, and recognition to, any part of the Palestinian people. This gives us zero leverage in determining the shape of any future Palestinian entity. Iran, Syria, and other enemies of Israel aren't so stupid; they engage with the most extreme hateful elements within the Palestinian political spectrum, and they push their agenda for the destruction of Israel.

Gaffney doesn't even mention that Fatah and Hamas are in a state of civil war.

American Foreign Policy
The obsession for our govenment to sucessfully negotiate a peace treaty had only succeeded in weakening and shrinking Isreal. I was praying Bush would not allow this to happen but he has not stopped Olmert and seems more interested in his legacy as peace maker between Isreal and Palestinians no matter the consessions to Isreal. This action and the fact he did not stop illegal immigration is what has brought down his popularity in census votes\in America.

The Palestinians cheered the Scuds
during the first Gulf War, and I expected that, after the hostilities, the pressure on Israel to give up territory would abate somewhat. But, silly me... about twelve minutes after the Iraqis were expelled from Kuwait, the Bush 41 administration was out there putting more pressure on the Israelis than on Saddam. Today, Road Map and all, things have not changed. I have to believe that most of the internal pressure from Israelis on their government is based on two factors: demographics [Arab birth rate] and external [U.S. , Europe, U.N. etc] pressure. Unlike any other nation,Israel does not have an actual right to exist. It is forced to take action that is basically suicidal
Sign Up to Post Your CommentsSign Up to Post Your Comments
If you are already registered, click here to login. Otherwise, please take a few seconds to register with Townhall.com. Once you sign up, you’ll be able to post your comments immediately, use the action center, get podcasts, and more!
Note: Fields marked with a red asterisk (*) are required.
Salutation:
First Name:
*
Last Name:
*
Email:
*
Nickname:
*
Note: Nick name will be shown when you post comments.
Address 1:
*
Address 2:
City:
*
State:
*
Zip:
*
Phone:
      
Your daily must-read of conservative columns, cartoons and news. Coulter, Sowell, Krauthammer and more.
(Bi-Weekly) We highlight the best opportunities from our partners for surveys, action items and more.