Townhall.com, Where Your Opinion Counts
Talk Radio:   Bill Bennett   Mike Gallagher   Dennis Prager   Michael Medved   Hugh Hewitt   
BREAKING NEWS  LeftArrow - Townhall.com : Conservative, Political, Republican   RightArrow - Townhall.com : Conservative, Political, Republican  
Columns, funnies & more in your inbox!
  • Check the boxes and send us your email address to receveive your free newsletter
  • Your daily must-read of conservative columns, cartoons and news. Coulter, Sowell, Krauthammer and more.
  • Townhall.com’s weekly inside scoop on what’s happening behind the scenes in the world of politics. When news breaks, we report.
  • Signup to receive the latest daily Townhall cartoons
Tuesday, January 22, 2008
Frank Gaffney :: Townhall.com Columnist
Front-Gate
by Frank Gaffney
Vote on It:
Average Vote:
[+] Text [-]
 
Poll
Will the Dems' health care Christmas Present to America be an improvement or detriment to our health care system?


It is now a well-established tradition in Washington that any scandal, no matter how seemingly innocuous, soon is given the suffix “-gate,” establishing a lineal connection to the mother of all scandals, Watergate.

Well, let me be the first to suggest that a recent scandal in the Pentagon be known hereafter as “Front-gate” in recognition of the central role played in the drama by the Islamic Society of North America (ISNA), an organization designated by the Justice Department as a front for the Muslim Brotherhood (Ikhwan). With the House and Senate both back in business this week, Front-gate should be subjected to close congressional scrutiny since it may involve the most strategically ominous case of official misconduct since the Clinton Administration’s China-gate.

The Front-gate saga began with the firing last month of Stephen Coughlin, a Major in the Army Reserves who was working as a civilian contractor for the Joint Chiefs of Staff when he ran afoul of one Hashem Islam. Islam is Deputy Secretary of Defense Gordon England’s point-man for the Pentagon outreach to the Muslim community.

Hashem Islam is also evidently an admirer of ISNA. He arranged for Secretary England to address one of the group’s meetings last year – a huge help to an organization reeling from its designation by the Bush Department of Justice not only as a Brotherhood front but as an unindicted co-conspirator in a terrorism-financing conspiracy.

According to reporting by the Washington Times’ National Security Correspondent, Bill Gertz, the sacking of Major Coughlin was precipitated by a sharp disagreement with Mr. Islam over ISNA. The former had made a serious study of this and other Islamist organizations as part of a 333-page thesis entitled To Our Great Detriment: Ignoring What Extremists Say About Jihad (http://www.strategycenter.net/include/docFormat_list.asp?docRecNo=725&docType=0)prepared for, and recently accepted by, the National Defense Intelligence College.

Based on his analysis of the Islamofascist roots and agenda of the Muslim Brotherhood, Stephen Coughlin was given to warning his military audiences that it was no “moderate” organization. For example, he notes that one of the Ikhwan’s most prominent leaders, Sheikh Yousef Al-Qaradhawi, has declared: “The abduction and killing of Americans in Iraq is an obligation so as to cause them to leave Iraq immediately.”

Coughlin has also studied the evidence submitted by the government in the Holy Land Foundation trial, including this chilling passage from a 1991 Muslim Brotherhood memorandum about its mission: “The Ikwan[’s]…work in America is a kind of grand Jihad in eliminating and destroying the Western civilization from within and ‘sabotaging’ its miserable house by their hands and the hands of the believers so that it is eliminated and Allah’s religion is made victorious over all other religions.”

Mr. Islam reportedly told the Joint Staff’s Coughlin to soften his criticism of the Brotherhood’s ISNA and, when the latter refused, defamed him as “a Christian zealot with a pen.” Some accounts add that it was a “poison” pen. Since Mr. Coughlin is not giving his side of the story to the press, it may require a congressional subpoena to get it properly told.

What is known, however, is that shortly after this exchange, the Joint Chiefs of Staff did not renew Mr. Coughlin’s contract, which will expire at the end of March. Mr. Gertz reports that the Chiefs deemed it “too hot” to retain the services of a man widely believed to be the military’s most knowledgeable expert on the Islamist ideology of our enemies.

Unfortunately, the sacking of Stephen Coughlin is not only a scandal in its own right. It is a window into a variety of actions that cry out for congressional investigations. These include:

* The true nature, agenda and sources of funding of Muslim Brotherhood front organizations like the Islamic Society of North America and the Council on American Islamic Relations (CAIR). Senator Jon Kyl convened a most informative Judiciary Committee hearing on the latter several years ago; it is time for an updated and more comprehensive review of the subject.

* The judgment, if not the loyalties, of those in government who promote such organizations – especially those officials who insist that Brotherhood fronts be the “go-to” groups for Muslim outreach, to the exclusion of anti-Islamist Muslims.

* The extent of Islamist penetration of the U.S. government. Such an evaluation should examine, among other things: Muslim military chaplains recruited and credentialed by Abdurahman Alamoudi, a convicted felon now serving 23 years in federal prison for terrorism-associated crimes; Saudi-sponsored travel and indoctrination of armed forces personnel; any Islamist ties to mosques on military bases like the Marine Corps’ Quantico facility; and “sensitivity” training for FBI agents by CAIR.

* The larger, seditious political-religious-legal agenda the Islamists call Shariah and its newest, alarming manifestation: “Shariah Finance” (also doing business around the world as “Islamic banking,” “ethical finance” or “structured finance”). To his credit, a freshman representative from Georgia, Republican Paul Broun, last week convened the first Capitol Hill briefing for House members and staff concerning this deeply worrisome Trojan horse in Western capital markets, drawing on research developed by and for the Center for Security Policy.

The needed congressional investigations into Front-gate and related matters should result not only in a full airing of the Coughlin-Islam affair. They should ensure that the military is not denied in time of war the services of so able a student of our enemy, its motivations and doctrine as Major Coughlin. If anything, as part of a comprehensive effort to counter the influence operations and penetration activities of Muslim Brotherhood front organizations, patriots like Steve Coughlin should be entrusted with even greater responsibilities – by Congress, if not the executive branch.

Share:
Vote on It:
Average Vote:
 
About The Author

Frank Gaffney Jr. is the founder and president of the Center for Security Policy and author of War Footing: 10 Steps America Must Take to Prevail in the War for the Free World .
 
TOWNHALL DAILY: Be the first to read Frank Gaffney's column. Sign up today and receive Townhall.com daily lineup delivered each morning to your inbox.

Where's the MSM spotlight ?

Oh great...dhimmitude & back-stabbing in the Nation's protective force,can it be any more obvious the victim is under attack internally.

First we need a real Congress.
All you have to do is watch one of the Democratic Pres. debates to know that 50% of the Congress is not going to lift a hand to defend freedom and justice.
Lead by a traitor like John F. Kerry and with Obomba and Hitlerie at the front we have one foot in a bear trap, and the other on the bad footing of McCain and or Huckabilly.

First things first.

50% turn over in the Senate and the House.
What we have now is going to get us all killed.

Washington D. C. is the center of an evil money cult of the two party reason for it all.

Bush: Islam Is A Religion Of Peace
Thank you, Jorge Bush. You really are an idiot, just like the Dems say.

taxfreekiller - how about a complete
Turn over of this lame and BOUGHT AND PAID FOR congress?

I think we the people should mount a six to ten million member march on DC, surround the capital and DEMAND that these "elected" nincompoops either DO THEIR JOBS in accordance with the very constitution they all swore to defend and uphold or GET OUT OF WASHINGTION....

The elections cycles as they are today literally guarantee these people longevity and protection.

They shoud be subject to national recall and being fired for incompetence just like the rest of us would be fired if we performed so poorly on our jobs.

FIRE THEM. And add one final note...they don't get to keep their perks, lifetime pensions and over paid benefits. THATS OUR MONEY and we have a right to demand a decent rate of return on our investment as well as competent performance.

In the Kingdom of the blind
H.G. Wells wrote about a man who stumbled onto a valley in which eveyone was blind. Hoping to rule the place he was instead looked upon as crazy.

The question is not does Mr. Coughlin speak any middle eastern languages. I don't but haveing been there I can make assessments. Nor is it whether or not he is credentialed from Harvard. The question is are his facts correct. I submit that if you read credible translations of brotherhood works and are familiar with Bernard Lewis's work and a few other things that you can make the assessment of his correctness.

Boutte's story is the P.C. story, NOT
the real story. Boutte's comments spell out everything that is wrong in America today. First, "he was only a reservist"????????????? Do you know ABoutte, how many reservists have been killed in our war????
Yes, you are the P.C. expert fool. I am sick and tired of idiots like you telling everyone else how to think and act.

Ulsterscott calls it like it is. Simple truth. We have some real wimps who are afraid of their own shadow in DC right now, and they are not just in the white house. God help us.

Boutte's story is the P.C. story, NOT
the real story. Boutte's comments spell out everything that is wrong in America today. First, "he was only a reservist"????????????? Do you know ABoutte, how many reservists have been killed in our war????
Yes, you are the P.C. expert fool. I am sick and tired of idiots like you telling everyone else how to think and act.

Ulsterscott calls it like it is. Simple truth. We have some real wimps who are afraid of their own shadow in DC right now, and they are not just in the white house. God help us.

I'm curious
Supposing one wanted to know what Coughlin is contrasting ISNA with in saying that it is not a moderate islamic group, what groups has Coughlin claimed are moderate islamic group? After all, if Coughlin simply equates islamic groups with extremist islamic groups then his classification of ISNA as extremist doesn't really tell us much.

And one could certainly see why someone whose job it is to do outreach to the muslim community would object to someone who thought all muslims were extremists. So was Coughlin actually distinguishing between moderate and extremist groups, or was he advocating shunning all muslim groups? The latter would certainly be counterproductive and justify his firing.

Islamic Law
Hard to claim to be an expert on Islamic Law if you can't read Arabic.

Akagi
You'd think so, but don't forget that knowing a foreign language is suspect and evidence of elitism (eg French) and treachery (eg Arabic). Except, of course, in cases where it's evidence of being an illegal immigrant (eg Spanish).

lilly
Is this all you know how to do, make up silly strawman arguments?

Akagi
"Islamic Law
Hard to claim to be an expert on Islamic Law if you can't read Arabic. "


How about if you only know Farsi? Talk about a silly non sequitur!

Strawman etc.
buzzcat--you are correct. Do the Filipino Muslims speak Arabic? Do the Indonesian? Is Akagai even an American?

He had me until "Shariah Finance"
I don't know much about the different Islamic groups, but I do know something about Shariah finance. It is basically a way for muslims to be able to invest while keeping to what they feel is a Koranic edict against interest. If Gaffney is ignorant enough to imply that this is all part of some Muslim plot to spread terror, then I think there is good reason to question the whole rest of the article.

Shariah finance.......
is simply a way of making strategic investments that will soften the path to imposing, by any means necessary, Shariah law on a society.

Hopefully, Coughlin did not distinguish between "moderate" Muslim groups and observant Muslims.

There is no such thing as moderate Islam. Muslims do not have the right to disregard any of the Islamic texts.

Major Coughlin's job was not to "reach out" to Muslim groups. His job was to inform our military about Islam. He did. He was fired for doing his job.

What we should be doing is to stop ALL Muslim immigration into our country. Islam is not compatible with our society and our Constitution.

Arabic
Buzzcat:

Well he seems not to know any Middle Eastern Language or any language found in a country with a Muslim majority. If you provide evidence that he knows Farsi, Tagalog, Urdu, Indonesian, Malay, Uygur, Pashtun, etc then perhaps you have a point. Does he know Bisaya then? I can find no evidence that he speaks any language other than English. Nor has anyone pointed out where he did his Islamic studies--do you know?

But to be clear the language of the Qur'an is Arabic and even experts in Islam and the Qur'an that aren't native speakers of Arabic generally know Arabic, at least Quranic Arabic. Again hard to claim to be an expert on Islamic law without having the language background. Be like someone claiming to be an expert on China and not being able to read Chinese. But we have those here don't we--such as claiming that in Chinese, the CCP is "hua gong chan" and using the simplified forms of Chinese used in the PRC the stroke counts of the three characters is 666, but that isn't how you say Chinese Communist Party in Chinese, it is Zhong Guo Gong Chan Dang, not that facts mean much around here.

And Monticup, it is Akagi--can't read can we? And what does my nationality have to do with this topic?

MUSLIM "OUTREACH"
WHAT IS THE D.O.D. THINKING? MUSLIM OUTREACH? WHAT A BUNCH OF B.S. WE DIDN'T HAVE NAZI "OUTREACH" IN WWII DID WE? I'VE NEVER SEEN A BIGGER BUNCH OF MORONS IN MY LIFE.
GOD HELP US!

Boutte writes: Part 1
Now for the real story
"Major" Stephen Coughlin (he was only a reservist) presented himself as an expert on Islamic law, yet he cannot speak any Middle Eastern language. His background was as a lawyer from a second-tier law school and national defense strategy student.

Of "Major" Stephen Coughlin "(he was only a reservist)": He is a lawyer by training and a reserve Military Intelligence Officer. His first interface with Islamic Law began in Pakistan where he was investigating and prosecuting an intellectual property rights case about 10 years ago. Reviewing Pakistani property rights law, he kept seeing footnoted references to the Quran and sharia law... Your "facts" are opinions.

In other words, he was a device for back-channelling hysterical Islamophobic scaremongering of the kind Gaffney, Danny Pipes, Robert Spencer, Norman "Pope Poddy" Podhoretz and the rest of the Israel Firsters and Military Industrial Complex mouthpieces put up to ensnare America in the biggest diplomatic and military blunder in its history, the Iraq Attaq.

Anti-semetic are we?....... All of the individuals you mention have impecable records for being fair and for being loyal Americans.
You should try it.

Military blunder? The only blunder was to undersize the occupational forces, not secure the borders and to isolate the local chiefs.






Israel
How is claiming someone is an Israel-firster anti-Semitic? If at any time someone is critical of Israel they are automatically anti-Semitic as well? So if I complain that Israel sells weapons to the PRC that the US helped it develop--weapons that violated the US-weapons embargo put in place after Tiananmen, does that make me an anti-Semitic as well? Is one anti-Semitic for pointing out that some people seem to favor actions that are in Israeli's interest, but not in the US best interest?

Just like to see you define the term so we can be clear on what is and what is not anti-Semitic in your view.




Boutte writes: Part 2
Robert Spencer holds a Master's degree in the department of Religious Studies from the University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill 1986. Spencer began studying Islam in 1980 during his first year as an undergraduate at the University of North Carolina. I'll take his word over yours.


"Gradually as the realists retake control of the USA's foreign policy in our true national interest-- and the Scooter Libbys, Wolfowitzes, Feiths, Rumsfelds etc are let go by Secretaries Gates and Rice-- the weeding-out process works its way down the intel food chain and reaches the likes of Coughlin."

Realists? You need a plastic belly button to be able to see out. Your “facts” are rubbish.
Scooter Libby fired by Gates or Rice? Not so. Feith resigned for family reasons…..Wolfowitz resigned to accept the position of president of the World Bank….Rumsfeld was let go by President Bush

"The NIE on Iran has helped discredit our "experts" on the Muslim world too. Gaffney and his war-whooping, paranoid soulmates are becoming not only monotonous but painfully dated."

The use of the NIE is laughable. It is so patently politically driven that no one with any brain cells takes it seriously
Typical of your type - no sources for your "facts". You are obviously stuck with your head in the sand.
Your are a perfect illustration of the quotation by Mark Twain:
“It is better to keep your mouth closed and let people think you are a fool than to open it and remove all doubt. “

Bouette...
Now for the real story

"Major" Stephen Coughlin (he was only a reservist) presented himself as an expert on Islamic law, yet he cannot speak any Middle Eastern language."

This statement is utter idiocy. This is akin to claiming that someone doesn't speak French makes they're unqualified to practice law in Louisiana.

Did you have to work, very hard, over the years to develop the depth of your stupidity or is this a genetic trait?

islamists, go home, who needs you?
The islamists should go home to their mud hut villages. Mohamedanism hasn't had a fresh idea since the VII century. They don't like it here because we eat pork, we don't want them or need them here. It was a mistake to allow such a backward people into the US.

Coughlin -Islamic Law Expert? YES!

Much like the Bible, the Koran has been translated into the native languages of those who desire to read it. Mr Coughlin doesn't necessarily need to be fluent in Arabic- the Koran is translated with great accuracy from the Arabic language into the English language.

I am sure all that other Islamic religious literature is translated into English too, making it very accessible to anyone who is smart enough and willing to take the time to understand it. Fortunately, Steve Coughlin has, and is an unsung hero.

How long will Americans sit back and continue to believe the PC notion that Islam is a peaceful religion; or that "Moderate Islam" actually exists?

Sign Up to Post Your CommentsSign Up to Post Your Comments
If you are already registered, click here to login. Otherwise, please take a few seconds to register with Townhall.com. Once you sign up, you’ll be able to post your comments immediately, use the action center, get podcasts, and more!
Note: Fields marked with a red asterisk (*) are required.
Salutation:
First Name:
*
Last Name:
*
Email:
*
Nickname:
*
Note: Nick name will be shown when you post comments.
Address 1:
*
Address 2:
City:
*
State:
*
Zip:
*
Phone:
      
Your daily must-read of conservative columns, cartoons and news. Coulter, Sowell, Krauthammer and more.
(Bi-Weekly) We highlight the best opportunities from our partners for surveys, action items and more.